KUM YOGESHWARI S D/O DIWAKAR S vs THE REGISTRAR GENERAL

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18558-DB
WA No. 100267 of 2026

CNR: KAHC020062882026


IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKAAT DHARWAD


TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

PRESENT


THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA

AND

THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE HEMA KULKARNI


WRIT APPEAL NO.100267 OF 2026 (S-RES)


BETWEEN:

KUM. YOGESHWARI S
D/O. DIWAKAR S.,
AGE: 28 YEARS,
OCC: UNEMPLOYED,
R/O: DOOR NO.55,
WARD NO. 10,
NEAR MARISWAMY MUTT,
MARATHI BIKKOJI RAO STREET,
BALLARI – 583 101.

…APPELLANT

(BY SRI. JANARDHANA G.,ADVOCATE)


AND:

1. THE REGISTRAR GENERAL,
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
DR. B.R. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI,
BENGALURU – 560001.

2. THE PRINCIPAL DISTRICT
AND SESSIONS JUDGE,








Digitally signed
by RAKESH S
HARIHAR
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18558-DB
WA No. 100267 of 2026

CNR: KAHC020062882026

BALLARI DISTRICT,
BALLARI – 583101.
…RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. MALLIKARJUNSWAMY B. HIREMATH,ADV. FOR R1;SRI.
SUJEET HIREMATH, ADV. FOR
SRI. JAGADISH PATIL, ADV. FOR R2)


THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED U/S.4 OF KARNATAKA HIGH
COURT ACT, 1961, PRAYING TO SET-ASIDE THE LEARNED
SINGLE JUDGES ORDER IN WRIT PETITION NO.105585/2024
(S-RES) DATED 26/02/2026 CONSEQUENTLY ALLOW THE WRIT
PETITION AS PRAYED FOR. TO FURTHER ISSUE WRIT OF
MANDAMUS DIRECTING THE RESPONDENT NO.2 TO COMPLETE
THE SELECTION PROCESS AS PER SECTION 4(1) (H) OF SUB-
ORDINATE COURTS (MINISTERIAL AND OTHER POSTS)
(RECRUITMENT) (AMENDMENT) RULES 2007 AND THEREBY
TAKING INTO THE MARKS OF THE ELIGIBLE CANDIDATES
FROM THE QUALIFYING EXAM AND THEREAFTER TO COMPLETE
THE PROCESS OF RECRUITMENT WITHIN TIME BOUND PERIOD
AND ETC.


THIS WRIT APPEAL, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY
HEARING THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS
UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
AND
HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE HEMA KULKARNI



- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18558-DB
WA No. 100267 of 2026

CNR: KAHC020062882026

ORAL JUDGMENT

(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA )

The appellant stands before us calling in question an
order of the learned Single Judge in Writ Petition No.105585 of
2024 dated 26.02.2026, whereby the learned Single Judge
rejected the claim of the appellant - petitioner on the score that
a participant in the select list or the name figuring in the final
select list would not get an indefeasible right to get appointed.

2. Heard the learned counsel Sri. Janardhana G,
appearing for the appellant; learned counsel Sri.
Mallikarjunswamy B. Hiremath appearing for respondent No.1
and learned counsel Sri. Sujeet Hiremath appearing for
respondent No.2.

3. Facts, in brief, germane are as follows:
Respondent No.2, the Principal District and Sessions
Judge, Ballari, issues a notification calling for applications from
eligible candidates for the purpose of appointment to the post
of Typist cum Copyist. The appellant finding herself eligible to
be considered for appointment to the post of Typist cum
Copyist applies to the said post, participates in the selection

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18558-DB
WA No. 100267 of 2026

CNR: KAHC020062882026

process and gets selected by issuance of a select list and an
intimation for viva voce is also communicated to the appellant.
It is then the entire selection is shelved. The appellant along
with others approached the learned Single Judge on the score
that the selection process cannot be abandoned midstream as
the selected candidates would have a certain right to be
considered for appointment in the teeth of their names being
found in the select list. The learned Single Judge rejects the
claim of the appellant. Therefore, the appellant is before us in
the subject appeal.

4. Learned counsel Sri. Janardhana G., appearing for
the appellant would vehemently contend that the only reason
for the cancellation of the select list or the recruitment process
not to be continued further is with regard to certain obfuscation
of the qualifying examination. Therefore, this Court must direct
continuance of the recruitment process by observing that the
said alleged discrepancy or anomaly could not have led to
cancellation of the selection process. He would submit that
certain rights get accrued to the persons who get selected and
the name of the appellant is found in the select list and the

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18558-DB
WA No. 100267 of 2026

CNR: KAHC020062882026

intimation for viva voce was also communicated to the
appellant.

5. Learned counsel Sri. Sujeet Hiremath appearing for
nd
the 2 respondent would vehemently refute the submission in
contending that the order of the learned Single Judge does not
warrant interference as it was an administrative decision taken
not to continue the recruitment process for manifold reasons.
The administrative decision was also placed before the learned
Single Judge, which was accepted by the learned Single Judge.
Therefore, there is no warrant of interference with the order of
the learned Single Judge. He would seek dismissal of the
petition.

6. We have given our anxious consideration to the
submissions made by the respective learned counsel and
perused the material on record.

7. The issue lies in a narrow compass. The
afore-narrated dates, link in the chain of events are all a matter
of record. It is an admitted fact that the appellant along with
others gets selected and the name of the appellant is found in

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18558-DB
WA No. 100267 of 2026

CNR: KAHC020062882026

the final select list. After finding the name of the final select
list, an intimation is also issued with regard to the conduct of
interview. The date for interview/ viva voce is said to have been
fixed as well and what remained was only issuance of an
appointment order to those persons who were selected in terms
of the selection process so initiated. The learned Single Judge
declines to accept the same on the score that a person who
participates in the selection process and gets selected and
name found in the select list even after the stage of interview
would not get an indefeasible right to claim appointment.

8. The contention of the learned counsel for the
appellant is that a direction should be issued to the
respondents to continue the recruitment process. The said
submission is noted only to be rejected. Merely because of the
vacancies subsisting or the issuance of a particular notification,
we in our jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, would be loath to issue such directions to continue the
selection process or fill up the vacancies. It is within the
administrative domain, which this Court would not step into.

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18558-DB
WA No. 100267 of 2026

CNR: KAHC020062882026


9. The other submission is that the name of the
appellant was found in the select list and the interview was also
conducted. Therefore, certain right is accrued to the petitioner
for selection to the post of Typist cum Copyist. This submission
is again noted only to be rejected, as the Apex Court in the
case of TEJ PRAKASH PATHAK v. HIGH COURT OF
1
RAJASTHAN considers the issue as to whether a person's
name found in the final select list would get an indefeasible
right to seek appointment, and holds as follows:
“…. …. ….

25. Candidates participating in a recruitment
process have legitimate expectation that the process of
selection will be fair and non-arbitrary. The basis of
doctrine of legitimate expectation in public law is founded
on the principles of fairness and non-arbitrariness in
government dealings with individuals. It recognises that a
public authority's promise or past conduct will give rise to
a legitimate expectation. This doctrine is premised on the
notion that public authorities, while performing their
public duties, ought to honour their promises or past
practices. The legitimacy of an expectation can be
inferred if it is rooted in law, custom, or established
procedure. [ Sivanandan C.T. case , (2024) 3 SCC 799,
para 18]

26. However, the doctrine of legitimate
expectation does not impede or hinder the power of
the public authorities to lay down a policy or
withdraw it. The public authority has the discretion
to exercise the full range of choices available within
its executive power. The public authority often has

1
(2025) 2 SCC 1

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18558-DB
WA No. 100267 of 2026

CNR: KAHC020062882026

to take into consideration diverse factors, concerns,
and interests before arriving at a particular policy
decision. The courts are generally cautious in
interfering with a bona fide decision of public
authorities which denies legitimate expectation
provided such a decision is taken in the larger
public interest. Thus, public interest serves as a
limitation on the application of the doctrine of
legitimate expectation.

27. Courts have to determine whether the
public interest is compelling and sufficient to
outweigh the legitimate expectation of the
claimant. While performing a balancing exercise,
courts have to often grapple with the issues of
burden and standard of proof required to dislodge
the claim of legitimate expectation. [ Sivanandan
C.T. case , (2024) 3 SCC 799, para 37]

…. …. ….

64.Thus, in light of the decision in Shankarsan
Dash [ Shankarsan Dash v. Union of India , (1991) 3
SCC 47 : 1991 SCC (L&S) 800] , a candidate placed
in the select list gets no indefeasible right to be
appointed even if vacancies are available. Similar
was the view taken by this Court in Subash Chander
Marwaha [ State of Haryana v. Subash Chander Marwaha ,
(1974) 3 SCC 220 : 1973 SCC (L&S) 488] where against
15 vacancies only top 7 from the select list were
appointed. But there is a caveat. The State or its
instrumentality cannot arbitrarily deny appointment to a
selected candidate. Therefore, when a challenge is laid to
State's action in respect of denying appointment to a
selected candidate, the burden is on the State to justify
its decision for not making appointment from the select
list.”

The Apex Court in the afore-quoted judgment holds that a
candidate who participates in the selection process, is found to
be selected in the final select list, does not get an indefeasible

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18558-DB
WA No. 100267 of 2026

CNR: KAHC020062882026

right unless an order of appointment springs pursuant to the
selection process.

10. The Apex Court in the case of TEJ PRAKASH
PATHAK supra was following the earlier judgment of the
Constitutional Bench of the Apex Court in the case of
2
SHANKARSAN DASH v. UNION OF INDIA , wherein it is
held as follows:
“…. …. ….
7.It is not correct to say that if a number of
vacancies are notified for appointment and
adequate number of candidates are found fit, the
successful candidates acquire an indefeasible right
to be appointed which cannot be legitimately
denied. Ordinarily the notification merely amounts to an
invitation to qualified candidates to apply for recruitment
and on their selection they do not acquire any right to the
post. Unless the relevant recruitment rules so indicate,
the State is under no legal duty to fill up all or any of the
vacancies. However, it does not mean that the State has
the licence of acting in an arbitrary manner. The decision
not to fill up the vacancies has to be taken bona fide for
appropriate reasons. And if the vacancies or any of them
are filled up, the State is bound to respect the
comparative merit of the candidates, as reflected at the
recruitment test, and no discrimination can be permitted.
This correct position has been consistently followed by
this Court, and we do not find any discordant note in the
decisions in State of Haryana v. Subash Chander
Marwaha [(1974) 3 SCC 220 : 1973 SCC (L&S) 488 :
(1974) 1 SCR 165] , Neelima Shangla v. State of Haryana
[(1986) 4 SCC 268 : 1986 SCC (L&S) 759] , or Jatinder
Kumar v. State of Punjab [(1985) 1 SCC 122 : 1985 SCC
(L&S) 174 : (1985) 1 SCR 899] .

2
(1991) 3 SCC 47

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18558-DB
WA No. 100267 of 2026

CNR: KAHC020062882026


8. In State of Haryana v. Subash Chander Marwaha
[(1974) 3 SCC 220 : 1973 SCC (L&S) 488 : (1974) 1 SCR
165] 15 vacancies of Subordinate Judges were
advertised, and out of the selection list only 7, who had
secured more than 55 per cent marks, were appointed,
although under the relevant rules the eligibility condition
required only 45 per cent marks. Since the High Court
had recommended earlier, to the Punjab Government that
only the candidates securing 55 per cent marks or more
should be appointed as Subordinate Judges, the other
candidates included in the select list were not appointed.
They filed a writ petition before the High Court claiming a
right of being appointed on the ground that vacancies
existed and they were qualified and were found suitable.
The writ application was allowed. While reversing the
decision of the High Court, it was observed by this
Court that it was open to the government to decide
how many appointments should be made and
although the High Court had appreciated the
position correctly, it had “somehow persuaded
itself to spell out a right in the candidates because
in fact there were 15 vacancies”. It was expressly
ruled that the existence of vacancies does not give
a legal right to a selected candidate. Similarly, the
claim of some of the candidates selected for
appointment, who were petitioners in Jatinder
Kumar v. State of Punjab [(1985) 1 SCC 122 : 1985
SCC (L&S) 174 : (1985) 1 SCR 899] , was turned
down holding that it was open to the government to
decide how many appointments would be made.
The plea of arbitrariness was rejected in view of the
facts of the case and it was held that the candidates
did not acquire any right merely by applying for
selection or even after selection. It is true that the
claim of the petitioner in the case of Neelima Shangla v.
State of Haryana [(1986) 4 SCC 268 : 1986 SCC (L&S)
759] , was allowed by this Court but, not on the ground
that she had acquired any right by her selection and
existence of vacancies. The fact was that the matter had
been referred to the Public Service Commission which
sent to the government only the names of 17 candidates
belonging to the general category on the assumption that
only 17 posts were to be filled up. The government
accordingly made only 17 appointments and stated before

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18558-DB
WA No. 100267 of 2026

CNR: KAHC020062882026

the court that they were unable to select and appoint
more candidates as the Commission had not
recommended any other candidate. In this background it
was observed that it is, of course, open to the
government not to fill up all the vacancies for a valid
reason, but the selection cannot be arbitrarily restricted
to a few candidates notwithstanding the number of
vacancies and the availability of qualified candidates; and,
there must be a conscious application of mind by the
government and the High Court before the number of
persons selected for appointment is restricted. The fact
that it was not for the Public Service Commission to take
a decision in this regard was emphasised in this
judgment. None of these decisions, therefore, supports
the appellant.

9. Mr Goswami appearing in support of the appeal
has contended that in view of the relevant statutory rules,
the authorities were under a duty to continue with the
process of filling up all the vacancies until none remained
vacant. Reference was made to Rule 4 of the Indian Police
Service (Cadre) Rules, 1954, Rules 3, 4, 6 and 7 of the
Indian Police Service (Recruitment) Rules, 1954 and
Regulations 2(1)( a ), 2(1)( c ), 8 and 13 of the Indian Police
Service (Appointment by Competitive Examination)
Regulations, 1965. We do not think any of these rules
comes to the aid of the appellant. Rule 3 of the Cadre
Rules directs constitution of separate cadres for States or
group of States, and Rule 4 empowers the Central
Government to determine the strength in consultation
with the State Governments. The strength has to be re-
examined at intervals of 3 years. Rule 3 of Recruitment
Rules deals with the constitution of the Service, and Rule
4 the method of recruitment. Rules 6 and 7 give further
details in this regard. The learned counsel could not point
out any provision indicating that all the notified vacancies
have to be filled up. Similar is the position with respect to
the Competitive Examination Regulations. Regulation
2(1)( a ) defines available vacancies as vacancies
determined by the Central Government to be filled on the
results of the examination, described in Regulation
2(1)( a ). Regulation 8 prescribes that the candidates
would be considered for appointment to the
available vacancies subject to provisions 9 to 12
and Regulation 13 clarifies the position that a

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18558-DB
WA No. 100267 of 2026

CNR: KAHC020062882026

candidate does not get any right to appointment by
mere inclusion of his name in the list. The final
selection is subject to satisfactory report on the
character, antecedent and suitability of the
candidates. We, therefore, reject the claim that the
appellant had acquired a right to be appointed
against the vacancy arising later on the basis of any
of the rules.

10. The main contention on behalf of the appellant
has been, however, that the authorities in keeping the
vacancies arising later unfilled, acted arbitrarily. Mr
Goswami referred to several documents annexed to the
special leave petition and affidavits filed on behalf of the
parties and contended that although appointments of
many candidates in the other services were made in the
later vacancies, the vacancy in the Indian Police Service
which subsequently became available to the appellant
was refused without any just cause, resulting in illegal
discrimination. This was emphatically denied on behalf of
the respondent. Since the matter did not appear to be
free from ambiguity on the basis of the affidavits before
us, we decided to examine the factual aspects more
thoroughly by examining the other available materials on
the records of the Union of India, and accordingly the
learned counsel for the respondent got the relevant
departmental files called. Two further affidavits were also
filed along with photostat copies of a large number of
documents, which we examined at some length with the
aid of the learned advocates for both sides. From the
materials produced before us it is fully established that
there has not been any arbitrariness whatsoever on the
part of the respondent in filling up the vacancies in
question or the other vacancies referred to by the learned
counsel for the appellant. The process of final selection
had to be closed at some stage as was actually done. A
decision in this regard was accordingly taken and the
process for further allotment to any vacancy arising later
was closed. Mr Goswami relied upon certain appointments
actually made subsequent to this stage and urged that by
those dates the further vacancies in the Indian Police
Service had arisen to which the appellant and the other
successful candidates should have been adjusted. We do
not find any merit in this contention. It is not material if
in pursuance of a decision already taken before closing

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18558-DB
WA No. 100267 of 2026

CNR: KAHC020062882026

the process of final selection, the formal appointments
were concluded later. What is relevant is to see as to
when the process of final selection was closed. Mere
completing the formalities cannot be of any help to
the appellant. We do not consider it necessary to
mention all the details in this connection available
from the large number of documents which we
closely examined during the hearing at
considerable length and do not have any hesitation
in rejecting the argument of the learned counsel in
this regard based on the factual aspect.

11. So far the decision to adopt a different policy
with respect to filling up of the reserved vacancies is
concerned the same is justified on account of the special
circumstances mentioned in the respondent's affidavits.
The decision to depart from the confirmed policy was
taken after a consideration by the authorities of the
position in regard to unavailability of qualified candidates
from year to year adversely affecting the desired strength
of the reserved candidates in the services and cannot be
condemned on the grounds of arbitrariness and illegal
discrimination.”

(Emphasis supplied at each instance)

The Constitutional Bench of the Apex Court in the afore-quoted
judgment was considering an identical issue and it is held that
a candidate whose name is found in the select list does not get
an indefeasible right to get appointed.

11. The learned Single Judge has followed these
judgments and frames an issue with regard to whether the
candidate would get an indefeasible right as is observed
hereinabove and holds that the candidate does not.

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18558-DB
WA No. 100267 of 2026

CNR: KAHC020062882026


12. Therefore, we in this intra Court appeal do not find
any perversity for us to entertain the appeal as a matter of
course.

13. Finding no merit in this appeal, the writ appeal
stands rejected .

Sd/-
(M.NAGAPRASANNA)
JUDGE



Sd/-
(HEMA KULKARNI)
JUDGE


RSH
CT: ASC
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 27