Dr Nandita Paul vs The State Of Assam And 3 Ors
- Court
- Gauhati High Court
Page No.# 1/13
GAHC010124982024
2026:GAU-AS:16874
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/3242/2024
DR NANDITA PAUL
DAUGHTER OF LATE BINANDA PAUL,
VILL. AND P.O.- KABUGANJ,
DIST.- CACHAR, ASSAM,
PIN- 788121.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 3 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY AND COMMISSIONER TO THE
GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM,
EDUCATION (HIGHER) DEPARTMENT,
DISPUR, GUWAHATI-781006.
2:THE DIRECTOR OF HIGHER EDUCATION
ASSAM
KAHILIPARA
GUWAHATI
PIN- 781019.
3:THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF HIGHER EDUCATION
ASSAM
KAHILIPARA
GUWAHATI
PIN- 781019.
4:THE PRINCIPAL
GURU CHARAN COLLEGE
SILCHAR
P.O.- SILCHAR
DIST.- CACHAR
ASSAM
PIN- 788004
Page No.# 2/13
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH MAZUMDAR
Advocate for the petitioner : MR S NATH, DR G J SHARMA
Advocate for the respondents : SC, HIGHER EDU,
: MR S DUTTA (r-4),
: MS S MOCHAHARI (r-4)
Date on which judgment was reserved: 03.11.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment : 17.11.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the : NA
operative part of the judgment?
Whether the full judgment has been : Yes
pronounced?
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. S. Nath, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard
Mr. S. Dutta, learned Senior Counsel, assisted by Mr. S. Dutta, learned counsel
for the respondent No. 4 and Mr. A.R. Tahbildar, learned Standing Counsel,
Higher Education Department. Hearing was concluded on 03.11.2026, and the
judgment was reserved.
2. The petitioner has filed this writ petition invoking the extraordinary
Page No.# 3/13
jurisdiction of the Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, being
aggrieved by the cancellation of the selection process for the post of Assistant
Professor in Bengali in the Gurucharan College, Silchar, which was held pursuant
to the advertisement dated 07.08.2016. It is the case of the petitioner that she
had participated in the selection process conducted by the respondent
authorities, and had been recommended by the selection committee for
appointment. It is her further case that the cancellation of the selection process
for the post for which she had vied is wholly irrational and illegal, as are the
consequential orders requiring the initiation of a fresh selection process for the
post in issue. The petitioner prays for directions to the respondents to bring the
selection process for the post of Assistant Professor in Bengali in the
Gurucharan College, Silchar, which was held pursuant to the advertisement
dated 07.08.2016, to its logical conclusion by appointing the petitioner on the
basis of her selection.
Facts which are not in dispute:
I. The Principal, Gurucharan College, Silchar, had published an advertisement
calling for applications for the post of Assistant Professor in the subjects of
History, English, Sanskrit, Botany and Bengali. The advertisement laid down
the general qualifications and eligibility conditions required to be fulfilled by
a candidate, and it was also stipulated that the applications had to reach the
concerned authority within 15 days of publication of the advertisement. It
Page No.# 4/13
was further clarified in the advertisement that the selection would be
conducted in accordance with the guidelines given in relevant office
memorandums. It is not the case of any of the parties that any of the
guidelines had been violated in conducting the selection process with regard
to the post of Assistant Professor, Bengali in the college concerned.
II. As per the records of the proceedings of the Selection Committee, 17
candidates had filed applications with regard to the post of Assistant
Professor in Bengali and out of them, 8 candidates, including the petitioner,
were found to be eligible for being called for document verification and to
face the interview in accordance with the guidelines laid down by the
appropriate authority. Accordingly, all eligible and qualified 08 candidates
had been called to appear in the selection proceedings. The learned Senior
Counsel appearing for the College authorities has caused production of the
records of the selection proceedings, which also contain the postal receipts
of the call letters to the candidates who were found eligible and qualified to
participate in the selection process.
III. The petitioner appeared for the document verification process and for
the interview before the Selection Committee on 17.11.2022 as directed by
the call letter. It is the assertion of the petitioner and the Selection
Committee as well that the petitioner had been found fit and qualified for
the post in issue and accordingly her name had been forwarded to the
Page No.# 5/13
Director of Higher Education, Assam, through the Governing Body of the
college, for further necessary action. The respondents in the Department of
Higher Education do not dispute the assertions.
IV. On 30.5.2023, the Director of Higher Education, Assam issued a list
containing the details of the candidates, along with reasons, whose
appointments were kept pending despite their selection. The list also
contained the name of the petitioner, where the reason for keeping her case
pending was shown to be the receipt of a complaint, which the Hon’ble
Minister had recommended to be investigated.
V. The Director of Higher Education, Assam, thereafter, on 12.12.2023,
published the list of candidates approved for appointment to various
provincialised College/PDUAM and Government Medical Colleges. The list
did not contain the name of the petitioner, and she preferred
representations. In the course of time, two other candidates who were
selected for the post of Assistant Professors in the same college and whose
approval was shown to be pending in the list published on 30.5.2023, were
appointed.
VI. By communication dated 27.12.2023, the Director of Higher Education,
Assam, permitted the Principal of the College to re-advertise the post of
Assistant Professor in Bengali, reserved for OBC/MOBC candidates at Roster
Page No.# 6/13
point 91, which was the post for which the petitioner had offered her
candidature. This information was disseminated to the petitioner by the
Principal of the College by forwarding a communication dated 30.5.2024
issued by the Deputy Director of Higher Education, Assam, requiring the
Principal of the College to inform the petitioner that such permission had
been granted since only a single candidate had appeared in the interview.
The petitioner filed the present writ petition challenging the cancellation of
the process in which she had participated and also challenging the
insistence on a fresh selection process.
Submissions on behalf of petitioners:
3. The learned counsel for the petitioner, Mr. S. Nath, has submitted that the
respondents in the Directorate of Higher Education had resorted to cancellation
of the selection process undergone by the petitioner only on the ground that the
petitioner was the lone candidate who had appeared before the interview board
and there were no other reasons assigned. He has submitted that the
documents made available by the respondents would indicate that a complaint
had been made and the Hon’ble Minister, Education had made an endorsement
for an enquiry on the complaint. The learned counsel has submitted that the
petitioner had not been supplied with the complaint, if any. Therefore, she never
had the opportunity to be heard before the decision to cancel the selection
process was taken to her detriment. The learned counsel has submitted that
Page No.# 7/13
there were no allegations levelled from any quarter whatsoever regarding any
irregularities or illegalities in the selection process, and the only reason given by
the respondents is that she was the lone candidate who had appeared in the
interview, despite call letters having been sent to all the eligible candidates. It is
not even the case of the respondents that the petitioner did not have the
eligibility or did not have the qualifications required for appointment to the post.
There is no doubt that the petitioner had qualified the interview and was fit for
appointment. The proposal of the selection committee, which had forwarded her
name for appointment, stands testimony to the said fact. The learned counsel
has submitted that the petitioner cannot be held responsible in any manner
whatsoever if the other candidates abstained from participating in the interview
process, more so since it is a matter of record that the College authorities had
sent call letters to all eligible candidates. He has submitted that when no
irregularities and illegalities had been alleged regarding the selection process,
the decision of the respondents to cancel the selection process is without rhyme
or reason. He has submitted that the decision of the respondents to venture for
a fresh selection process, when the selection committee had lawfully and legally
selected a candidate, deserves the interference of this Court. He has prayed that
the respondents be directed to bring the selection process, where the petitioner
stood selected, to its logical conclusion by appointing the petitioner to the post
of Assistant Professor in the Department of Bengali in the Gurucharan College,
Silchar.
Page No.# 8/13
4. Mr. S. Dutta, learned senior counsel appearing for the college authorities who
had conducted the selection process, has submitted that, as per available
records, the applications which had been received in response to the
advertisement dated 07.08.2016 were duly scrutinised and the eligible
candidates, being 8 in number, were issued call letters at the addresses given by
them to attend the further proceedings of document verification and interview in
continuation of the selection process undertaken. He has submitted that only
the petitioner had reported for the document verification and interview process,
and she was not only found eligible and qualified for the post, but she was also
recommended for appointment on the basis of her performance in the interview.
He has submitted that the college authorities did not receive any complaints of
irregularity, illegality, or malpractice with regard to the selection process. He has
also submitted that the selection committee had followed the due procedure
while conducting the selection.
5. Mr. A.R.Tahbildar, learned counsel appearing for the Department of Higher
Education, has submitted that he has received the records and, as per the
same, a complaint had been received regarding the presence of only one
candidate in the selection process and her subsequent selection. He has
submitted that since only one candidate had participated, the Director of Higher
Education, Assam, was of the opinion that the selection process lacked healthy
competition and a re-advertisement was therefore issued to ensure the essential
Page No.# 9/13
element of a fair recruitment process in public employment. He has submitted
that no fault can be attributed to the decision to initiate a fresh selection
process and therefore, the writ petition, being devoid of merits, merits
dismissal.
6. I have heard the learned counsel for the contesting parties, and I have
perused the records produced by the College authorities and also the records
produced by the learned counsel appearing for the Department of Higher
Education. There is no dispute of the fact that the advertisement had been duly
published by the Principal of Gurucharan College, Silchar, calling for applications
for the posts of Assistant Professor in the Department of Bengali, which post, as
per the advertisement itself, related to roster point No. 91 and was reserved for
candidates belonging to the Other Backward Classes/ More Other Backward
Classes (OBC/MOBC) categories. 17 (seventeen) applications had been received
by the college authorities from candidates for the aforesaid posts, and there is
no dispute that all the qualified and eligible candidates had been issued call
letters to appear in the document verification and interview process.
7. There is a variation in the number of applications stated to be received for
the post of Assistant Professor in the Department of Bengali in the college,
inasmuch as while the Director of Higher Education has referred to 37
applications being received, out of which 7 (seven) candidates had been called
for interview, the college authority has asserted there were 17 (seventeen)
Page No.# 10/13
applications received out of which 8 (eight) candidates had been called for
interview.
8. We would trust the statements made by the college authorities, since the
records regarding applications and call letters are retained at the college level
and the number of applications received, vis-a-vis the number of candidates
called for, as given in the affidavit of the Director of Higher Education may have
been a typographical error.
9. In any view of the matter, at least 7 (seven) candidates were issued call
letters for the interview by the selection committee and only the petitioner had
appeared on the particular date.
10. The Director of Higher Education, Assam, in the affidavit has not alleged
any illegality or irregularity in the selection process. He has referred only to the
absence of “healthy competition” since only the petitioner appeared for the
interview and none else appeared. It is not the case of the respondents in the
Higher Education Department that eligible candidates were not called for or that
any leniency was shown towards the present writ petitioner during the interview
process.
11. In my considered opinion, when candidates who have applied for a
particular post do not appear in the interview process, despite being called upon
Page No.# 11/13
to do so, the candidates who appear in the interview and are evaluated cannot
be faulted for the absence of other candidates. It would have been another
matter had there been any allegations that no other eligible candidate had been
called for the interview. The admitted position in the present case is that all
eligible candidates were called for the interview, out of whom the petitioner
faced the interview process on the designated date and the selection
committee, on the basis of her qualifications and on her fulfilling the other
conditions, found her fit to be appointed as an Assistant Professor in the
Department of Bengali, in Gurucharan College, Silchar.
12. The absence of healthy competition, as sought to be asserted by the
Director of Higher Education, would have been taken up for consideration, had
there been a complete absence of applications by candidates or the call letters
were not dispatched to eligible and qualified candidates. In the present case,
not only have eligible and qualified candidates responded to the advertisement,
but they were also intimated and required to appear in the interview process.
13. In my considered opinion, the petitioner cannot be penalized with a
cancellation of an interview process, which she diligently faced, only on the
ground that other candidates preferred not to appear on the due date of the
selection process.
14. Accordingly, the decision of the Director of Higher Education requires an
Page No.# 12/13
interference. I hasten to add that the bonafide intent of the Director of Higher
Education, Assam, to ensure a healthy competition deserves appreciation.
However, in the facts and circumstances of the present case, when the eligibility
and qualifications of the petitioner are not an issue, and the only reason is the
absence of other candidates despite being informed of the date of interview, it
would be unfair and against equity to deny the petitioner a fair chance of
consideration for the post for which she had applied and participated in the
interview. As already noted above, the selection committee has found the
petitioner fit for appointment.
15. In view of the observations made hereinabove, the proposal of the selection
committee to offer appointment to the petitioner deserves to be taken to its
logical conclusion, without reference to the absence of candidates who had
chosen not to participate in the selection process.
16. The writ petition is accordingly allowed. The directions issued by the
Director of Higher Education to the college authorities to proceed with a fresh
re-advertisement for the post are interfered with in the given facts and
circumstances of the case.
17. The Director of Higher Education, Assam, shall now process the proposal
sent by the Selection Committee through minutes of the meeting dated
17.11.2022, in accordance with law. The minutes had admittedly been
Page No.# 13/13
processed and forwarded by the Governing Body of the Gurucharan College,
Silchar, by forwarding the same to the Director of Higher Education, Assam. The
final approval by all the respondents concerned, in the absence of any
impediment in the appointment of the petitioner, shall be granted within a
period of 4 (four) weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this
order. In case there is any impediment in the appointment of the petitioner, the
same shall be brought to her notice within a period of 4 weeks from the date of
receipt of the certified copy of this order, and the petitioner shall be afforded
due opportunity to rectify the same.
18. The Writ Petition is accordingly allowed. Parties to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant