PRADEEP KUMAR SHARMA vs HOME AFFAIRS

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

1
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024



Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi

O.A. No.3682/2024

Order reserved on : 23.07.2026
Order pronounced on: 26.10.2026


Hon’ble Dr. Chhabilendra Roul, Member (A)
Hon’ble Mr. Rajveer Singh Verma, Member (J)

1. PRADEEP KUMAR SHARMA,
HINDI PRADHYAPAK,
AGE 65 YEARS, GROUP 'B'
S/O SHRI KRISHAN SHARMA
R/O: 1701, TOWER 1, BPTP PARK GENERATION,
SECTOR 37 D, GURUGRAM, HARYANA-122006.

2. MURLI RAM
HINDI PRADHYAPAK,
AGE 37 YEARS, GROUP 'B'
S/O SHRI SULTAN RAM
R/O: WARD NO. 09, NEAR BISHNOI MANDIR,
15 LGW-A, LIKHMISAR, HANUMANGARH,
RAJASTHAN-335803

3. RAM PRAKASH YADAV
HINDI PRADHYAPAK,
AGE 41 YEARS, GROUP 'B'
S/O SHRI RAM KARAN YADAV
R/O: VILLAGE- AAYAR,
NEAR ADHANPUR CANAL BRIDGE,
POST- SONHITA, DIST- JAUNPUR,
UTTAR PRADESH-222144.

4. KIRAN LATA YADAV,
HINDI PRADHYAPAK,
AGE 40 YEARS, GROUP 'B'
W/O SHRI RAM SINGH YADAV
R/O: A-9 MAYUR VIHAR, FARlDI NAGAR,
INDIRA NAGAR, LUCKNOW,
UTTAR PRADESH - 226016



Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR

2
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

5. BAHUBALI BHOSGE
HINDI PRADYHAPAK,
AGE 61, YEARS, GROUP 'B'
S/O: SHRIMANDHAR
R/O: LIG-343, KHB COLONY, UDAYAGIRI,
SATTUR, DHARWAD, KARNATAKA-580009

6. KUMAR SAMBHAV,
HINDI PRADHYAPAK,
AGE 40, YEARS, GROUP 'B',
S/O: JIYALAL YADAV
R/O: VILLAGE & POST JAGDISHPUR,
PHOOLPUR, DISTRICT- AZAMGARH,
UTTAR PRADESH- 276304

7. DEEPAK SHAW
HINDI PRADHYAPAK
AGE 37 YEARS, GROUP 'B'
S/O: SHANKAR SHAW
R/O: H/NO 13/3, BLOCK NO- 9, POST OFFICE
KANKINARA, P.S-BHATPARA, DISTRICT - NORTH 24
PARGANA, WEST BENGAL -743126

8. ABDUL SALAM
HINDI PRADHYAPAK,
AGE 41 YEARS, GROUP 'B'
S/O: LATE BASHEER AHMAD,
R/O: VILL-AMRAUNA, POST-KOILARI,
DIST. JAUNPUR, UTTAR PRADESH - 222148

9. HARISH CHANDRA SHARMA
HINDI PRADHYAPAK,
AGE 66 YEARS, GROUP 'B'
S/O: GANAPATLAL SHARMA
R/O: PORDAR COLONY, KHETRAJPUR,
SAMBALPUR -768003

10. POONAM
HINDI PRADHYAPAK
AGE 47 YEARS, GROUP 'A'
W/O: AMAR SINGH
R/O: B2 CIVIL LINE, PALWAL, HARYANA.

11. TEK CHAND
HINDI PRADHYAPAK
AGE 64 YEARS, GROUP 'A'
S/O: ISHWAR SINGH
RD
R/O: 585 'C' BLOCK, 3 STAGE,
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR

3
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

VIJAY NAGAR,
MYSORE-570017

12. SANGITA BOTHRA
HINDI PRADHYAPAK
AGE 58 YEARS, GROUP 'A'
S/O OR W/O: LATE BIJOY CHAND BOTHRA
R/O: 2A SAGAR DUTTA LANE, BOWBAZA.

13. RAGINI TIWARI
HINDI PRADHYAPAK
AGE 37 YEARS, GROUP 'B'
W/O: SANDIP KUMAR
R/O: 209/B/l NAKARl MONDAL ROAD,
KANCHRAPARA

14. PUNAM SHAW,
HINDI PRADHYAPAK
AGE 37 YEARS, GROUP 'B'
W/O: RANJIT KUMAR SHAW
R/O: C/O GANESH SHAW, 27/1 S P MUKHERJEE
ROAD, TITAGARH, NORTH 24 ,PARGANAS,
KOLKATA 700119, WEST BENGAL,
P.O & P.S-TITAGARH

15. S SUBHALAXMI
HINDI PRADHYAPAK
AGE 62 YEARS, GROUP 'B'
W/O: M SHANKAR
RD
R/O: PLOT NO 45, 3 CROSS STREET, AGS
COLONY, CHROMPET, CHENNAI 600044

16. DR. BINOY KUMAR PANDEY
HINDI PRADHYAPAK
AGE 70 YEARS, GROUP 'B'
S/O OR W/O: YUGAL KISHOR PANDEY
R/O: ANANDAPURI, RAJA HIGH SCHOOL, PAKUR,
DIST- PAKUR, JHARKHAND, PIN 816107

Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
…Applicants

(By Advocate : Shri Ashish Nischal)

VERSUS

1. UNION OF INDIA,
THROUGH ITS SECRETARY,
MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS,

4
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

NORTH BLOCK, NEW DELHI-ll0001.

2. UNION OF INDIA,
THROUGH ITS SECRETARY (OL),
DEPARTMENT OF OFFICIAL LANGUAGE,
MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS,
RD
NDCC-Il BHAWAN, B WING, 3 FLOOR,
JAI SINGH ROAD, NEW DELHI-l10001.

3. THE DIRECTOR,
DEPARTMENT OF OFFICIAL LANGUAGE,
MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS,
CENTRAL HINDI TRAINING INSTITUTE,
TH
7 FLOOR, Pt. D ANTYODAYA BHAWAN,
C G O COMPLEX, LODHI ROAD,
NEW DELHI-110003.

…Respondents

(By Advocate : Shri Bijendra Singh Sharma)
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR

5
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024


ORDER
By Hon’ble Mr. Rajveer Singh Verma, Member (J) :-

The applicants, sixteen in number, are currently
working or have retired as Hindi Pradhyapaks (Group
B) under the Central Hindi Training Institute,
Department of Official Language, Ministry of Home
Affairs. The core issue pertains to equating the post of
Hindi Pradhyapak with Assistant Director (Hindi
Typing and Shorthand) as well as Assistant Director
(Hindi Language) within the same Department, along
with the grant of higher pay scale attached to the post
of Assistant Director w.e.f. 09.04.2009.
2. The initial round of litigation was instituted by
similarly situated Hindi Pradhyapaks before the
Madras Bench of the Tribunal in OA No. 610/2003
seeking equation and higher pay scale. The Tribunal
dismissed the OA on 09.03.2004, holding that pay
fixation is an executive function and feeder posts
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
cannot carry a higher pay scale than promotional
posts. Assailing the said order, the aggrieved
employees preferred Writ Petition (Civil) No.
14005/2004 before the Hon‟ble High Court of Madras

6
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

and vide its judgment dated 09.04.2009, the Hon‟ble
High Court set aside the order of the Tribunal and
allowed the writ petition, observing that the
educational qualifications and duties of Hindi
Pradhyapaks are much higher than Assistant Directors
(Hindi Typing and Shorthand), and continuing such an
anomaly shocked judicial conscience. The Hon‟ble High
Court directed that the post of Hindi Pradhyapak
should be equated with Assistant Director (Hindi
Typing and Shorthand) as well as Assistant Director
(Hindi Language), with Deputy Director being the next
promotional post for both, to be implemented from the
date of the order i.e. 09.04.2009.
3. The respondents challenged the judgment dated
09.04.2009 before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in SLP
(Civil) Nos. 36981-36982/2009 (converted to Civil
Appeal Nos. 7540-7541/2012). The Hon‟ble Supreme
Court dismissed the Civil Appeals vide order dated
06.04.2022, thereby confirming the judgment of the
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
Hon‟ble High Court of Madras.
4. Subsequent to the dismissal of the Civil Appeals,
the Department of Official Language consulted the
Department of Expenditure and the Department of

7
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

Legal Affairs, Ministry of Law and Justice, in April and
May 2023. Both departments rendered opinions
advising that the benefit of the judgment dated
09.04.2009 will be restricted solely to the original
petitioners in Writ Petition No. 14005/2004. In
Contempt Petition No. 1236/2023 filed before the
Hon‟ble High Court of Madras seeking implementation,
the High Court disposed of the matter on 12.07.2023,
recording compliance for the petitioners before it while
leaving it open for any other aggrieved persons to
agitate their rights in accordance with law. Thereafter,
the respondents issued the impugned order dated
12.02.2024, explicitly restricting the equation and pay
benefits to the petitioners of the writ petition only.
Being aggrieved, the applicants have filed the present
OA seeking the following relief(s) :-
“i. Quash and set aside the Impugned Order
dated 12.02.2024;

ii. Directions be issued to the respondents, to
treat the applicants as deemed Assistant
Director (Hindi typing and Shorthand) /
Assistant Director (Hindi Language) with all
consequential benefits, such as grant of pay
scale, arrears of pay etc., w.e.f. 09.04.2009 i.e.
the date of the Judgement of the Hon'ble High
Court of Madras, in Writ Petition 14005/2004;

iii. pass any other relief that this Hon‟ble
Tribunal may consider fit in the interest of
justice.”
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR

8
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024


5. The learned counsel for the applicants contended
that the judgment dated 09.04.2009, which has
attained finality, is a judgment in rem and not in
personam , as it resolved a general cadre-wide anomaly.
Reliance is placed on the Division Bench order dated
09.03.2023 of the Tribunal at Mumbai in OA No.
261/2013 ( Shashikant Govind Kulkarni and Ors.
vs. UOI & Ors. ), which applied Hon‟ble Supreme Court
precedent in State of U.P. vs. Arvind Kumar
Srivastava (2015) 1 SCC 347; to hold that judgments
touching upon policy matters and cadre anomalies are
in rem , casting a legal obligation on the executive to
extend the benefits to all identically situated employees
without forcing them into litigation.
6. Pursuant to notice, the respondents filed their
counter reply opposing the OA. Learned counsel for
the respondents submitted that the determination of
pay scales, equation of posts, and cadre structuring
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
are exclusive executive domain matters governed by
expert bodies like Pay Commissions. The post of Hindi
Pradhyapak carries a pay scale of Rs. 6500-10500
(Level 8), whereas the promotional post of Assistant

9
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

Director carries a pay scale of Rs. 7500-12000 (Level
10).
7. Following the dismissal of Civil Appeal Nos. 7540-
7541/2012 by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court on
06.04.2022, the matter was thoroughly examined in
consultation with the Department of Expenditure and
the Department of Legal Affairs. The Department of
Expenditure vide note dated 13.04.2023, and the
Department of Legal Affairs vide note dated
17.05.2023, recommended that the implementation of
the Hon‟ble High Court order dated 09.04.2009 be
limited specifically to the original
applicants/petitioners. Extending such an equation
across the entire cadre would have wider financial and
administrative ramifications.
8. Furthermore, the Department of Official Language
had already executed a comprehensive Cadre Review
via Gazette Notification dated 29.09.2020,
restructuring the cadres under which eligible Hindi
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
Pradhyapaks are systematically promoted to Assistant
Director (Language), following which the remaining
posts of Hindi Pradhyapak will gradually be deemed

10
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

abolished upon reaching qualifying service and
mandatory training.
9. In Contempt Petition No. 1236/2023, the Hon‟ble
High Court of Madras specifically observed on
12.07.2023, that the judgment dated 09.04.2009 stood
fully complied with regarding the petitioners before it.
Consequently, the administrative decision conveyed
through the order dated 12.02.2024, restricting the
relief to the litigating parties, is in complete harmony
with legal advice, judicial observations, and financial
guidelines.
10. In response to the counter contentions, the
applicants submitted that the defense raised by the
respondents relying upon the internal opinions of the
Department of Expenditure and Department of Legal
Affairs dated 13.04.2023 and 17.05.2023 is legally
unsustainable. Administrative opinions cannot override
the authoritative judicial mandate of the Hon‟ble High
Court of Madras dated 09.04.2009, which explicitly
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
ruled that continuing the pay anomaly between Hindi
Pradhyapaks and Assistant Directors shocked judicial
conscience and mandated the post-level equation. The
Gazette Notification dated 29.09.2020 does not cure

11
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

the past pay discrimination that crystallized on
09.04.2009. As established in Shashikant Govind
Kulkarni (supra), when a judicial decision resolves a
cadre-wide structural anomaly, the judgment operates
in rem . Denying the same relief to identically placed
employees within the same Ministry violates Article 14
of the Constitution of India.
11. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties
and gone through the material placed on record.


12. Having considered the rival submissions, the
following questions arise for determination:

(i) Whether the judgment dated 09.04.2009 of the
Hon'ble High Court of Madras in W.P. No. 14005/2004,
as affirmed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court on
06.04.2022, operates in rem so as to oblige the
respondents to extend its benefit to all incumbents of
the post of Hindi Pradhyapak, or only in
in personam
favour of the writ petitioners;
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR

(ii) Whether the applicants are disentitled to relief on
the ground of delay, laches or acquiescence;

12
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

(iii) Whether the opinions of the Department of
Expenditure and the Department of Legal Affairs, the
order dated 12.07.2023 in Contempt Petition No.
1236/2023, or the Cadre Review notified on
29.09.2020 justify the impugned order dated
12.02.2024; and

(iv) The relief, if any, to which the applicants are
entitled.

13. The principles governing the extension of the
benefit of a judgment to persons who were not parties
to it are settled. In State of U.P. vs. Arvind Kumar
Srivastava , (2015) 1 SCC 347, the Hon'ble Supreme
Court summed them up as follows:
"22.1. The normal rule is that when a particular set of
employees is given relief by the court, all other identically
situated persons need to be treated alike by extending that
benefit. Not doing so would amount to discrimination and
would be violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
This principle needs to be applied in service matters more
emphatically as the service jurisprudence evolved by this
Court from time to time postulates that all similarly
situated persons should be treated similarly. Therefore,
the normal rule would be that merely because other
similarly situated persons did not approach the Court
earlier, they are not to be treated differently.

22.2. However, this principle is subject to well-recognised
exceptions in the form of laches and delays as well as
acquiescence. Those persons who did not challenge the
wrongful action in their cases and acquiesced into the
same and woke up after long delay only because of the
reason that their counterparts who had approached the
court earlier in time succeeded in their efforts, then such
employees cannot claim that the benefit of the judgment
rendered in the case of similarly situated persons be
extended to them. They would be treated as fence-sitters
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR

13
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

and laches and delays, and/or the acquiescence, would
be a valid ground to dismiss their claim.

22.3. However, this exception may not apply in those
cases where the judgment pronounced by the court was
judgment in rem with intention to give benefit to all
similarly situated persons, whether they approached the
court or not. With such a pronouncement the obligation is
cast upon the authorities to itself extend the benefit thereof
to all similarly situated persons. Such a situation can occur
when the subject-matter of the decision touches upon the
policy matters, like scheme of regularisation and the like
(see K.C. Sharma v UOI). On the other hand, if the
judgment of the court was in personam holding that benefit
of the said judgment shall accrue to the parties before the
court and such an intention is stated expressly in the
judgment or it can be impliedly found out from the tenor
and language of the judgment, those who want to get the
benefit of the said judgment extended to them shall have
to satisfy that their petition does not suffer from either
laches and delays or acquiescence."


14. The Hon'ble High Court of Delhi, in Manjeet
Kumar vs. Food Corporation of India , LPA
979/2024, decided on 07.02.2025, after extracting the
above passage, explained the interplay of these
principles thus:

"7. The position is, therefore, one of an exception to an
exception. To the general principle that the benefit of a
judgment must extend to all persons similarly situated, is
the exception that fence sitters who are guilty of delay and
laches would not be entitled to invoke this benevolent
principle, which principle, in turn, stands excepted where
the judgment is in rem. The Supreme Court has, however,
clarified that an judgment in rem must disclose a manifest
intendment of having been rendered in rem, such as a
case in which the Court directs regularization of
employees."


The question, therefore, is whether the judgment dated
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
09.04.2009 discloses, from its terms and tenor, an
intendment to operate for the post and the cadre rather

14
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

than only for the individuals who had approached the
Court.

15. We have carefully perused the judgment dated
09.04.2009. The Hon'ble High Court found that the
Hindi Pradhyapak, who is required to hold a Master's
degree in Hindi and a Bachelor's degree in Education
and teaches Hindi to employees from the clerical level
to senior officers, was placed in a lower scale than the
Assistant Director (Hindi Typing and Shorthand) in the
same organisation, a post carrying a lower prescribed
qualification. The respondents' plea that fixation of pay
scales is a matter for experts was specifically
considered and rejected. In paragraph 7, the Hon'ble
High Court held:
"7. …..We are conscious of the position of law. Normally,
pay scales are left to the experts. However, in spite of clear
directions and observations in the earlier occasions, the
departmental authorities have reiterated the earlier
position and sought to justify higher pay scales to lesser
qualified Assistant Directors (Hindi Typing and Shorthand)
and lower pay scale to higher qualified Hindi
Pradhyapaks. This is too shocking to our judicial
conscience and therefore, we are restrained to interfere
though in the normal course, such a matter is left to the
appropriate Government to decide. ... Therefore, in these
peculiar circumstances, we deem it proper to quash the
order of the Tribunal and direct that the Hindi
Pradhyapaks should be given the pay scales at least on
par with the Assistant Directors (Hindi Typing and
Shorthand) in the pay scale of Rs.7500-12000."

Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR

15
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

and in paragraph 9:
"...On deeper scrutiny, continuing such an anomalous
position, shocks to our judicial conscience. Therefore, the
post of Hindi Pradhyapak should be equated with the
Assistant Director (Hindi Typing and Shorthand) as well as
the Assistant Director (Hindi Language) and the next
promotional post can be considered as Deputy Director for
both. This would be implemented from the date of this
order."

16. Three features of the judgment are decisive. First,
the direction is not couched in terms of the writ
petitioners. It is addressed to "the Hindi Pradhyapaks"
as a class, and the equation is made of "the post of
Hindi Pradhyapak" with the two posts of Assistant
Director. Second, the Hon'ble High Court did not stop
at pay. It re-ordered the hierarchy of the cadre by
declaring that Deputy Director would be the next
promotional post for Hindi Pradhyapaks as well as for
Assistant Directors. A declaration about the pay and
promotional placement of a post is, by its very nature,
a declaration about every incumbent of that post. It
cannot sensibly be confined to some of them. Third,
the anomaly the Hon'ble High Court corrected was
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
structural and cadre-wide, arising from the placement
of the post itself, and not from any circumstance
personal to the petitioners. The subject matter of the
decision thus touches upon the structure of the cadre,
which is precisely the class of case identified in

16
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

paragraph 22.3 of Arvind Kumar Srivastava (supra)
as one in which a judgment operates in rem .

17. The consequence of the impugned order makes
the point clear. After 12.02.2024, the respondents have
in the same post, in the same organisation, governed
by the same recruitment rules and discharging the
same duties, two sets of incumbents drawing two
different scales of pay, the only difference between
them being that some were petitioners in W.P. No.
14005/2004. A classification founded solely on the fact
of having been a party to an earlier litigation, in respect
of a declaration made about the post itself, bears no
rational nexus to any object connected with the post
and is plainly violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India.

18. The fact that the Hon'ble High Court made the
equation effective prospectively from 09.04.2009 does
not detract from this conclusion. Fixing a date from
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
which a cadre-wide correction takes effect is a common
feature of judgments in rem and says nothing about
who is to benefit. Nor did the Hon'ble High Court state,
expressly or by necessary implication, that the benefit
was to accrue only to the parties before it. On the

17
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

contrary, the language employed manifests an
intention to correct the position of the post. We are,
therefore, satisfied that the judgment dated 09.04.2009
discloses the manifest intendment contemplated in
Manjeet Kumar
(supra) and operates in rem .

19. The judgment dated 09.04.2009 was carried by
the Union of India to the Hon'ble Supreme Court and
the Civil Appeal Nos. 7540-7541/2012 were dismissed
on 06.04.2022. Upon such dismissal, the judgment of
the Hon'ble High Court attained finality as between the
Union of India and the Hindi Pradhyapaks. The
contention of the respondents in their counter reply
that the determination of pay scales and equation of
posts lies exclusively in the executive domain and with
expert bodies is, in substance, the very contention that
was raised, considered and rejected by the Hon'ble
High Court, and the rejection has been left
undisturbed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. It is not
open to the respondents to re-agitate it before this
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
Tribunal under the guise of resisting the extension of
the same judgment.

18
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

20. We now turn to the grounds on which the
impugned order rests. The notes dated 13.04.2023 of
the Department of Expenditure and 17.05.2023 of the
Department of Legal Affairs are internal advice to the
Government. They cannot narrow the scope of a
judicial declaration that has attained finality, and the
financial implications of compliance, which the
respondents emphasize, cannot be a ground for
treating identically placed incumbents of one post
unequally. Such considerations may at best bear upon
the period for which arrears should be paid, which we
address below.


21. The order dated 12.07.2023 of the Hon'ble High
Court of Madras in Contempt Petition No. 1236/2023
does not assist the respondents. A contempt court is
concerned only with the fact that whether the order
has been complied with in respect of the parties before
it. In recording compliance for the petitioners, the
Hon'ble High Court expressly left it open to other
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
aggrieved persons to agitate their rights in accordance
with law. That observation preserves the remedy of
persons such as the applicants; it does not construe
the judgment dated 09.04.2009 as one in personam .

19
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024


22. The Cadre Review notified on 29.09.2020 is
prospective in its operation. It provides for promotion
of eligible Hindi Pradhyapaks to the post of Assistant
Director (Language) and for the progressive abolition of
the remaining posts of Hindi Pradhyapak. It does not
address the period from 09.04.2009 until the date on
which each applicant was placed in the higher scale,
and it cannot, therefore, cure the discrimination for
that period.

23. This brings us to the objection of delay and laches.
Since we have held the judgment dated 09.04.2009 to
be one in rem , the exception in paragraph 22.2 of
Arvind Kumar Srivastava (supra) does not apply, and
the obligation was upon the respondents themselves to
extend the benefit. In any event, the applicants cannot
be described as persons who slept over their rights and
woke up long after their counterparts had succeeded.
The judgment remained under challenge at the
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
instance of the respondents themselves until
06.04.2022. The respondents thereafter took a
considered decision on the question of extension, after
inter-departmental consultation, by the impugned
order dated 12.02.2024, and the present OA has been

20
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

filed within the period prescribed in Section 21 of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 from that order.
The claim, moreover, relates to the scale of pay
attached to the post, the denial of which is a
continuing wrong. In The Chief Executive Officer &
Ors. vs. S. Lalitha & Ors ., 2025 INSC 565, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, while holding that belated
representations cannot defer the cause of action,
observed in paragraph 35:
"...Needless to observe, the cause of action cannot be
deferred by making a highly belated representation and
awaiting its outcome. We also make it clear that different
considerations would arise in a case of a continuous
wrong, which has to be decided in the light of the
decision of this Court in Union of India v. Tarsem Singh."


24. The objection of limitation and laches, therefore,
does not defeat the claim. At the same time, in keeping
with the principle laid down in Union of India vs.
Tarsem Singh , (2008) 8 SCC 648, that in cases of a
continuing wrong relief may be granted
notwithstanding delay but the arrears are ordinarily
confined to a period of three years preceding the filing
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
of the application, and having regard to the fact that
the applicants did not themselves approach any forum
between 2009 and 2024, we consider it just that the
applicants' pay be refixed notionally from 09.04.2009

21
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

while the actual payment of arrears be confined to the
period of three years preceding the date of filing of this
OA.

25. As regards the prayer that the applicants be
treated as deemed Assistant Directors, we note that the
Hon'ble High Court did not direct that Hindi
Pradhyapaks be designated or appointed as Assistant
Directors. It equated the post for the purpose of pay
scale and declared Deputy Director to be the next
promotional post. The applicants cannot be placed in a
better position than the writ petitioners. Relief (ii) is,
accordingly, moulded to the grant of the pay scale, and
the corresponding replacement pay band, grade pay
and pay level, as extended to the petitioners in W.P.
No. 14005/2004 in compliance with the judgment
dated 09.04.2009, together with the consequential
benefits flowing therefrom.

26. In view of the foregoing discussion, the OA is
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
allowed in the following terms:

(i) The impugned order dated 12.02.2024, to the
extent it restricts the benefit of the judgment dated
09.04.2009 in W.P. No. 14005/2004 to the writ
petitioners alone, is quashed and set aside.

22
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024


(ii) The respondents shall extend to each of the
applicants the benefit of the said judgment by granting
them the same pay scale, and its corresponding
th
replacement pay band and grade pay under the 6
th
CPC and pay level under the 7 CPC, as has been
granted to the writ petitioners in compliance therewith,
w.e.f. 09.04.2009, or from the date of the applicant's
regular appointment as Hindi Pradhyapak, whichever
is later, till the date of the applicant's promotion or
placement as Assistant Director (Language) or the date
of retirement, as the case may be.

(iii) The pay of the applicants shall be fixed notionally
with effect from the date mentioned in clause (ii), with
all consequential benefits including increments and
fixation on subsequent promotion. Actual arrears of
pay shall be restricted to the period of three years
preceding the date of filing of this OA.

(iv) In the case of applicants who have retired, their
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
pension and other retiral dues shall be revised on the
basis of the pay so refixed, and the arrears thereof
shall be paid subject to the limitation in clause (iii).

23
Item 53 (C-V)
OA No.3682/2024

(v) The respondents shall carry out the above
exercise and pass appropriate orders within a period of
three months from the date of receipt of a certified copy
of this order.

27. All Pending MAs, if any, shall stand disposed of.
There shall be no order as to costs.


(Rajveer Singh Verma) (Dr.Chhabilendra Roul)
Member (J) Member (A)

„rk‟

Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR