Smt. Vangeti Susheelamma, vs The State of Telangana,
- Court
- High Court for the State of Telangana
*THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
+
WRIT PETITION No.30423 of 2023
%30-09-2026
# …Petitioner
Vangeti Susheelamma
vs.
$ The State of Telangana rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Revenue Department, Hyderabad and 7 others
… Respondents
!Counsel for the petitioner
: Mr. Katika Ravinder Reddy.
^Counsel for respondents
: Mr. M.Yadagiri,
learned Assistant Government Pleader for
Revenue appearing for respondent Nos.1 to 4
Mr.S.Rama Mohan Rao, learned counsel for
respondent Nos.6 to 8
<Gist :
>Head Note :
? Cases referred
1. W.P.No.3323 of 2019, dt.06.05.2022
2. (2017)4 SCC 97 = MANU/SC/0183/2017
3. 2023(3) CCC 374 = MANU/TN/5114/2023
2
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
WRIT PETITION No.30423 of 2023
(CNR No.HBHC010553082023
)
DATE: 30.09.2026
Between:
Vangeti Susheelamma
…Petitioner
AND
The State of Telangana rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Revenue Department, Hyderabad and 7 others
…Respondents
ORDER
Heard Mr.Katika Ravinder Reddy, learned counsel for the
petitioner; Mr.M.Yadagiri, learned Assistant Government Pleader
for Revenue, appearing for respondent Nos.1 to 4; Mr.S.Rama
Mohan Rao, learned counsel for respondent Nos.6 to 8 and
perused the record.
2. The present Writ Petition is filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, with the following prayer:-
“…..to issue an Order Direction or Writ more particularly a Writ of
MANDAMUS declaring the action of the Respondent No.3 in not
considering the application filed under Sec.11 of The Maintenance
And Welfare Of Parents And Senior Citizens Act, 2007 filed on
28.08.2023 inspite of the Orders Dt. 09.06.2022 in File
3
No.G/PV/382/2022 passed by the Respondent No.3 as illegal,
arbitrary, unjust and contrary to law and consequently direct the
Respondent No.3 to consider the application filed under Sec.11. of
The Maintenance And Welfare Of Parents And Senior Citizens
Act, 2007 inspite of the Orders Dt. 09.06.2022 in File
No./PV/382/2022 passed by the Respondent No.3 as illegal,
arbitrary, unjust and contrary to law and pass such other order
or orders as deemed fit and proper in the circumstances of the
case and in the interest of justice.”
Factual Matrix
3. The petitioner is the mother of late Vangeti Janaki Ram
Reddy, who was respondent No.5 in the writ petition. The
petitioner and her husband, Vangeti Ram Reddy, were stated to be
aged about 76 and 80 years respectively. In the year 2015, they
had transferred various agricultural lands, house sites and other
properties in favour of their son (respondent No.5), his wife
(respondent No.6), and their minor grandchildren (respondents
No.7 and 8), through registered gift settlement deeds.
4. The petitioner alleged that after the said transfers,
respondent No.5 failed to take proper care of the petitioner and her
husband and, inter alia , alleged that the respondent No.5 was
addicted to alcohol and was alienating properties without their
knowledge and consent. The petitioner submitted a complaint
dated 25.04.2022 before the authorities under the Maintenance
and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 (for short
4
‘2007 Act’), which was forwarded to respondent No.3 for
appropriate action.
5. Respondent No.3, after issuing notices to the parties and
hearing them, passed orders dated 09.06.2022 in File
No.G/PV/382/2022. Respondent No.5, inter alia was directed to
clear the loans obtained by mortgaging the agricultural lands and
to re-register the relevant lands in favour of his son and daughter,
i.e., respondents No.7 and 8, with the petitioner as guardian; to
transfer agricultural land admeasuring Ac.2-20 Gts. in favour of
the petitioner; and to make necessary changes in respect of the
house sites and commercial shops in favour of the minor
grandchildren with the petitioner as guardian. The order further
directed respondent No.5 and his wife, respondent No.6, to
construct two additional rooms in the old house of the petitioner
with all facilities within three months, and to provide food, daily
necessities and medical care to the petitioner and her husband.
6. Aggrieved by the said order, respondent No.5 preferred
Appeal No.C1/5307/2022 before respondent No.2, the District
Collector-cum-Chairman of the Appellate Tribunal for Maintenance
and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens at Nalgonda. By order
dated 17.01.2023, respondent No.2 dismissed the appeal and
confirmed the order dated 09.06.2022. The subsequent
5
proceedings before this Court record that respondent No.5 did not
challenge the said order further.
7. Thereafter, the petitioner submitted a representation
dated 27.01.2023 to respondent Nos.2 and 3 seeking
implementation of the order dated 09.06.2022. The petitioner then
approached this Court in W.P.No.9842 of 2023, wherein this Court
directed respondent No.3 to consider the petitioner's
representation and pass appropriate orders in terms of Section 11
of the Act, preferably within four weeks from receipt of the order.
Alleging that the aforesaid directions were not effectively
8.
acted upon, the petitioner submitted an application dated
28.08.2023 under Section 11 of the 2007 Act before respondent
No.3 seeking implementation of the order dated 09.06.2022. As no
effective action was taken on the said application, the petitioner
instituted the present writ petition.
Submissions on behalf of the petitioner
9. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has advanced
the following submissions:
i) That the order dated 09.06.2022 passed by respondent No.3,
as confirmed by respondent No.2 by order dated 17.01.2023,
has attained finality, as respondent No.5 did not challenge
the same before any higher forum. It was submitted that the
6
petitioner, being a senior citizen, is entitled to seek
enforcement of the said order under Section 11 of the 2007
Act.
ii) That respondent No.3 failed to discharge its statutory duty
under Section 11 of the 2007 Act. According to learned
counsel, the application dated 28.08.2023 filed by the
petitioner was not considered, notwithstanding the earlier
directions issued by this Court in W.P. No.9842 of 2023. The
inaction on the part of respondent No.3 was therefore
contended to be illegal, arbitrary and contrary to the object
and purpose of the Act.
iii) That though respondent No.5 has since died, the obligations
arising out of the order dated 09.06.2022 do not stand
extinguished merely on account of his death. It was
submitted that respondent Nos.6 to 8, having been brought
on record as the legal representatives of respondent No.5, are
liable to fulfil the obligations arising from the said order, to
the extent permissible in law and in view of the estate
inherited by them.
iv) That respondent No.6 was herself a party to the proceedings
before respondent No.3 and was specifically directed to
construct two additional rooms and to provide food, daily
7
necessities and medical expenses to the petitioner and her
husband, and that such obligation cannot be avoided on
account of the subsequent death of respondent No.5.
v) That under Hindu law, maintenance of aged parents
constitutes a pious obligation. It was submitted that the
properties transferred by the petitioner and her husband to
respondent No.5 and other family members were transferred
in the circumstances, in which the care and maintenance of
the petitioner and her husband were to be secured. It was
therefore submitted that respondent Nos.6 to 8 cannot retain
the benefit of the properties inherited by them while denying
the corresponding obligations arising under the order dated
09.06.2022.
Submissions on behalf of the respondent Nos.6 to 8
10. Learned counsel for the respondent Nos.6 to 8 has
advanced the following submissions:
i) That respondent No.5, during his lifetime, had complied with
part of the order dated 09.06.2022 by executing Gift Deeds
bearing Document Nos.894 and 896 of 2023 and Sale Deed
bearing Document No.898 of 2023, all dated 08.08.2023. It
was submitted that the lands which had originally been
transferred by the petitioner to respondent No.5 had been re-
8
transferred in favour of respondent Nos.7 and 8 and the
petitioner, respectively, in terms of the directions contained
in the said order.
ii) In regard to the issue of the construction of two additional
rooms or, alternatively, provision of accommodation, it is
submitted that respondent Nos.6 to 8 had offered the
petitioner and her husband accommodation in their 3BHK
house, but that the petitioner and her husband were not
willing to accept the said arrangement. It was further
submitted that respondent No.6 is a Government Doctor and
respondent Nos.7 and 8 are minor students. Learned counsel
contended that respondent No.6, being the daughter-in-law
of the petitioner, does not fall within the expression
“children” under Section 2(a) of the 2007 Act and, therefore,
cannot be fastened with a personal obligation to maintain
the petitioner under the Act.
iii) By placing reliance on the decision of the Bombay High
Court in Sheetal Devang Shah v. Presiding Officer of the
Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior
1
, it is submitted that a daughter-in-law is not liable
Citizens
to pay maintenance under the 2007 Act and that the
1
W.P. No.3323 of 2019, dated 06.05.2022
9
obligation of maintenance is personal to the children. It was
therefore submitted that the writ petition, insofar as
respondent Nos.6 to 8 are concerned, may be dismissed.
11. I have taken note of the respective submissions urged and
the material on record.
Consideration by this Court
Failure of respondent No.3 to consider the Section 11
application
Section 11 of the 2007 Act deals with enforcement of an
12.
order of maintenance. Sub-section (1) provides for enforcement of
an order of maintenance upon satisfaction as to the identity of the
parties and the non-payment of the allowance or expenses due,
while sub-section (2) provides that a maintenance order made
under the Act shall have the same force and effect as an order
passed under Chapter IX of the CrPC, 1973 and shall be executed
in the manner prescribed for execution of such order.
13. In the present case, respondent No.3 passed a detailed
order dated 09.06.2022 granting several reliefs to the petitioner.
The said order was confirmed by respondent No.2 by order dated
17.01.2023. The petitioner thereafter submitted a representation
dated 27.01.2023 and subsequently an application dated
28.08.2023 under Section 11 of the 2007 Act seeking
10
implementation of the order dated 09.06.2022. The record
discloses that effective action on the said application did not follow.
14. It is pertinent to note that the earlier order of this Court
dated 11.04.2023 in W.P.No.9842 of 2023 specifically directed
respondent No.3 to consider the petitioner's representation dated
27.01.2023 and pass appropriate orders in terms of Section 11 of
the 2007 Act, preferably within four weeks from the date of receipt
of a copy of the order. The subsequent proceedings disclose that
the petitioner continued to seek implementation of the order dated
09.06.2022. In such circumstances, the failure of respondent No.3
to take effective steps in accordance with the said directions and
the statutory mechanism under Section 11 cannot be regarded as
consistent with the object of the Act.
15. The Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior
Citizens Act, 2007 is a beneficial legislation intended to provide for
the maintenance and welfare of parents and senior citizens.
Section 3 gives the Act an overriding effect over inconsistent
provisions contained in any other enactment, instrument or
custom or usage. The provisions relating to maintenance and
enforcement are therefore required to be given meaningful effect so
that an order passed in favour of a senior citizen is not rendered
ineffective merely by reason of delay in its implementation.
11
16. It is to be noted that the order dated 09.06.2022 had been
confirmed in appeal by order dated 17.01.2023, and the petitioner
thereafter invoked the statutory mechanism for its enforcement.
The earlier direction of this Court dated 11.04.2023 also required
respondent No.3 to consider the petitioner's representation and
pass appropriate orders in terms of Section 11 of the Act. Having
regard to the subsequent course of proceedings, this Court is of the
view that respondent No.3 failed to take effective action for
implementation of the order dated 09.06.2022 in accordance with
the statutory scheme.
Enforceability of the order against the legal representatives of
deceased respondent No.5
17. The order dated 09.06.2022 passed by respondent No.3
was challenged by respondent No.5 before the Appellate Tribunal,
which was dismissed by order dated 17.01.2023 confirming the
order dated 09.06.2022. The subsequent proceedings before this
Court record that respondent No.5 did not challenge the said order
further. The said order, therefore, stood confirmed during the
lifetime of respondent No.5.
18. It is pertinent to note that respondent No.5 died on
27.10.2025. Respondent Nos.6 to 8 were thereafter brought on
record as his legal representatives. It is a settled principle of law
12
that an obligation which has crystallized into an enforceable order
does not come to an end merely because the person against whom
it was passed dies. Such obligation passes to the legal heirs and
successors-in-interest to the extent of the estate inherited by them.
19. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Prabhakara Adiga v.
2
Gowri and others has held as under:
26…It is apparent from Section 50 Code of Civil Procedure
that when a judgment-debtor dies before the decree has
been satisfied, it can be executed against legal
representatives. Section 50 is not confined to a particular
kind of decree. Decree for injunction can also be executed
against legal representatives of the deceased judgment-
debtor. The maxim "actio personalis moritur cum persona" is
limited to certain class of cases as indicated by this Court in
Girijanandini Devi v. Bijendra Narain Choudhary (supra)
and when the right litigated upon is heritable, the decree
would not normally abate and can be enforced by LRs. of
decree-holder and against the judgment-debtor or his legal
representatives. It would be against the public policy to ask
the decree-holder to litigate once over again against the
legal representatives of the judgment-debtor when the cause
and injunction survives. No doubt, it is true that a decree for
injunction normally does not run with the land. In the
absence of statutory provisions it cannot be enforced.
However, in view of the specific provisions contained in
Section 50 Code of Civil Procedure, such a decree can be
executed against legal representatives.
(Emphasis supplied)
20. It is true that Section 2(a) of the Act defines “children” to
include a son, daughter, grandson and granddaughter, but does
not include a minor. A daughter-in-law is not expressly included in
2
(2017) 4 SCC 97 = MANU/SC/0183/2017
13
the said definition. The decision of the Bombay High Court in
Sheetal Devang Shah (supra 1) does support the proposition that
a daughter-in-law is not a “child” under Section 2(a) and cannot be
made personally liable to pay maintenance merely on the strength
of that relationship. To that limited extent, the submission of
respondent No.6 is correct.
21. However, the present case does not rest solely on the
definition of “children” under Section 2(a). The liability of
respondent No.6 arises from four independent and cumulative
circumstances, which do not require her to be treated as a “child”
under the Act. Respondent No.6’s obligation is not a personal
obligation de hors the estate, but an obligation fastened upon her
as a party to a final order, as the legal representative of her
deceased husband, as the natural guardian of the minor legal
heirs, and as a beneficiary of transfers made by the petitioner.
22. It is pertinent to note that the respondent No.6 was not a
stranger to the proceedings. The order dated 09.06.2022 passed by
respondent No.3 specifically names and directs “the respondent
Vangeti Janaki Ram Reddy and his wife Mudududla Divya” to
construct two rooms and provide care. The record shows that
respondent No.6 was present before the Tribunal and placed her
14
version. The order was, therefore, passed against the respondent
No.6 after hearing her. Respondent No.6 did not challenge the said
order. The order dated 09.06.2022, therefore, attained finality qua
respondent No.6, and respondent No.6 cannot now collaterally
contend that she is not bound by it.
23. Under Section 11 of the Act, the Tribunal is empowered to
enforce its own order. A person against whom an order is passed
and who does not challenge it cannot escape enforcement by
taking recourse to a definition clause.
It is to be noted that the respondent No.6 is the legal
24.
representative of deceased respondent No.5. Under Order XXII Rule
4 of the CPC, legal representatives are brought on record to
represent the estate of the deceased. They step into the shoes of
the deceased for the purpose of the proceedings. The obligation
under the order dated 09.06.2022 was not a mere personal
obligation which died with respondent No.5. It had crystallized into
an enforceable order. Such an obligation is binding on the estate of
the deceased and can be enforced against the legal representatives
to the extent of the estate inherited by them. Respondent No.6,
along with respondent Nos.7 and 8, has inherited the estate of
15
respondent No.5. Respondent No.6 cannot take the benefit of the
estate and simultaneously disown the burden attached to it.
25. It is relevant to note that respondent No.6 is the natural
guardian of respondent Nos.7 and 8, who are minors and in whose
favour respondent No.5 executed Gift Deed Nos.894 and 896 of
2023 dated 08.08.2023. The properties in their hands are traceable
to the properties originally gifted by the petitioner. Under Section
23 of the Act, where a senior citizen has transferred property by
way of gift subject to the condition that the transferee shall provide
basic amenities and basic physical needs, and the transferee
refuses or fails to provide such amenities, the transfer is deemed to
have been made by fraud or coercion or under undue influence
and is voidable at the option of the transferor. The gift deeds in
favour of respondent Nos.7 and 8, and the gift deed earlier
executed in favour of respondent No.6, were all part of the same
family arrangement meant to secure the care and maintenance of
the petitioner and her husband. Respondent No.6 cannot retain
the benefit of those transfers and, at the same time, refuse to
discharge the obligation. As natural guardian, respondent No.6 is
bound to ensure that the estate in the hands of the minors is
applied towards the lawful obligations attaching to it.
16
26. The Madras High Court in Mohamed Dayan vs. The
3
District Collector, Tiruppur District and others has held as
under:
38. The Kerala High Court observed in the case of
Radhamani and Others (cited supra), Section 23(1) of the
Senior Citizen Act, cannot be interpreted to the
disadvantage of the senior citizen. Section 23(1) of the Act
contemplates that "Where any senior citizen who, after the
commencement of this Act, has by way of gift or otherwise,
his property, subject to the condition that the transferee
shall provide the basic amenities and basic physical needs
to the transferor and such transferee refuses or fails to
provide such amenities and physical needs, the said
transfer of property shall be deemed to have been made by
fraud or coercion or under undue influence and shall at the
option of the transferor be declared void by the Tribunal".
The phrase " subject to the condition that the transferee
shall provide the basic amenities" does not mean that the
Gift or Settlement Deed should contain any such condition
expressly. "Subject to the condition" as employed in Section
23(1), is to be holistically understood with reference to the
subsequent phrase i.e., "deemed to have been made by
fraud or coercion or undue influence". Both the phrases
would amplify that the deeming clause should be
considered so as to form an opinion that the phrase "subject
to condition" amounts to an implied condition to maintain
the senior citizen and any violation would be sufficient for
the purpose of invoking Section 23(1) of the Act, to cancel
the Gift or Settlement Deed executed by the senior citizen.
39. To elaborate, the phrase "subject to condition" employed
Section 23(1) of the Act, is to be understood with reference
to the love and affection by the senior citizen towards the
person in favour of whom such Gift or Settlement Deed has
been executed.
3
2023 (3) CCC 374 MANU/TN/5114/2023
=
17
40. "Love and Affection" is an implied condition in the
context of Section 23(1) of the Act, and therefore, there need
not be any express condition in the Settlement Deed for the
purpose of maintaining the senior citizen. Refusal of
maintenance after executing the Settlement Deed or Gift
Deed, is the ground for invoking the deemed ground of fraud
or coercion or undue influence. When the deeming clause
has been incorporated under the provisions of Section 23(1)
of the Act, 'Love and Affection' to be construed as the
consideration for executing the Gift or Settlement Deed.
Thus the condition need not be expressly made in the
document and the love and affection, which resulted in
execution of the Deed by the senior citizen is to be construed
as a condition for the purpose of invoking the deeming
clause for declaring the document as fraud or coercion or
undue influence.
41. The entire purpose and object of the Senior Citizens Act,
is to consider the human conduct towards them. When the
human conduct is indifferent towards senior citizen and
their security and dignity are not protected, then the
provisions of the Act, is to be pressed into service to
safeguard the security and dignity of senior citizen.
Therefore, the purposive interpretation of the provisions are
of paramount importance and Section 23 of the Act, cannot
be mis-utilised for the purpose of rejecting the complaint
filed by the senior citizen on the ground that there is no
express condition for maintaining the senior citizen. Even in
the absence of any express condition in the document, "Love
and Affection" being the consideration for execution of Gift or
Settlement Deed, such love and affection becomes a
deeming consideration and any violation is a ground to
invoke Section 23(1) of the Act. Thus there is no infirmity in
respect of the order passed by the second respondent in the
present case.
42. The human conduct in the context of the senior citizen
Act, is to be understood considering the relationship
between the senior citizen and the beneficiaries of the Gift
or Settlement Deed. Mostly the parents are executing the
document in favour of their children. Since they may not be
in a position to maintain the property at their old-age and
18
more-so, they are intending to visibly express their love and
affection towards their children by settling their properties.
In some cases, the parents during their old-age are settling
their property in order to avoid conflict between their
children and to ensure that all children get equal share. If at
all the parents decide to settle the property in favour of a
son or daughter, then they are doing so, only with love and
affection and with a fond hope that they will be taken care
of by the son or daughter during their old-age. Thus love
and affection, being the consideration and implied condition,
within the meaning of Section 23(1) of the Act. The
subsequent non-maintenance of senior citizen would attract
Section 23(1) of the Act and the Authorities in such
circumstances are empowered to declare the document as
null and void.
(Emphasis supplied)
27. Under Hindu law, the maintenance of aged parents is not
merely a contractual or statutory duty; it is a pious obligation. The
son's duty to maintain his parents is considered a sacred
obligation, and it attaches to his estate. On the death of the son,
the estate in the hands of his heirs remains burdened with that
obligation. The widow and children of the deceased son are,
therefore, bound to maintain the aged parents out of the estate.
This principle is consistent with the object of the 2007 Act, which
is a beneficial legislation meant to protect the life and property of
senior citizens. The Act has an overriding effect under Section 3. A
construction which allows the legal heirs to enjoy the estate while
leaving the aged parents destitute would defeat the very purpose of
the Act.
19
28. Further the reliance placed on Sheetal Devang Shah
(supra 1) by the learned counsel for respondent Nos.6 to 8 is
distinguishable. In that case, the daughter-in-law was sought to be
made personally liable for payment of maintenance solely because
of her relationship as daughter-in-law. There was no prior order
specifically directing her to provide accommodation or care. In the
present case, respondent No.6 was a party to the proceedings, was
specifically directed by the Tribunal, did not choose to challenge
the order, and is now the legal representative of the deceased son
and the natural guardian of the minor legal heirs. Respondent
No.6’s liability is, therefore, not based on the definition of
“children” under Section 2(a). It is based on the binding nature of
the final order, the doctrine of legal representation, the obligation
attached to the estate of the deceased respondent No.5.
29. In the aforesaid circumstances, while respondent No.6
cannot be described as a “child” within the meaning of Section 2(a)
of the Act, she is nevertheless bound by the obligations of her
deceased husband, respondent No.5. Respondent No.6’s liability is
not personal de hors the estate, but arises from her status as a
party to the final order, as the legal representative of the deceased,
as the natural guardian of the minor heirs, and to the extent of the
estate inherited. Respondent No.6 cannot escape the directions
20
contained in the order dated 09.06.2022, as confirmed by order
dated 17.01.2023, by taking shelter behind the definition clause.
The Tribunal is entitled to enforce the said order against her and
the estate in her hands in accordance with Section 11 of the Act.
Liability of respondent Nos. 6 to 8 to fulfil the obligations
30. It is apposite to note that the order dated 09.06.2022
contains several directions. Some of them have been partially
complied with by execution of the Gift Deeds and Sale Deed dated
08.08.2023. However, the crucial direction relating to the
construction of two additional rooms with all amenities and the
provision of food, daily needs, medical expenses and care to the
petitioner and her husband continues to remain a matter of
compliance.
31. This Court vide order dated 06.03.2024, recorded the
statement of respondent No.5 and his wife that they were residing
in a 3BHK house and had invited the petitioner and her husband
to stay with them, which offer was stated to have been declined.
This Court, referring to the direction contained in the order dated
09.06.2022, directed respondent No.5 to inform the Court
regarding the arrangements made for constructing the two
additional rooms and also to come up with an alternative proposal
by depositing a lump-sum amount in the bank accounts of the
21
petitioner and her husband towards their accommodation,
maintenance and medical expenses. The subsequent proceedings
show that the question of compliance continued to be considered
by this Court and that the legal representatives sought time to
place the relevant material regarding such compliance on record.
32. Respondent Nos.6 to 8, being the legal representatives of
respondent No.5, are required to satisfy the obligations arising
under the order dated 09.06.2022 in accordance with law and to
the extent legally enforceable against them. However, the
respondent No.6 stands on a distinct footing, as she was a party to
the original proceedings and was specifically directed to comply
with the said order. Respondent Nos.7 and 8, being minors, cannot
be treated as personally liable merely by virtue of their status as
legal representatives; any liability attributable to the estate
inherited by them would necessarily be confined to such estate and
be subject to law. The petitioner and her husband are aged senior
citizens and cannot be left to pursue the enforcement of an order
that has already attained finality through repeated proceedings.
33. Moreover, the contention that the petitioner and her
husband declined to stay in the 3BHK house does not, by itself,
bring the proceedings to an end or render the specific direction
22
contained in the order dated 09.06.2022 otiose. The said order
specifically directed the construction of two additional rooms with
all amenities, besides providing food, daily necessities and medical
expenses. At the same time, the order dated 06.03.2024
contemplated an alternative arrangement by way of a lump-sum
deposit towards accommodation, maintenance and medical
expenses. Therefore, if the petitioner is unwilling to stay in the
existing 3BHK accommodation, the respondents are required to
comply with the final order in the manner directed therein or place
before the competent authority an appropriate alternative
arrangement consistent with the directions already issued. The
respondents cannot treat the offer of accommodation in the
existing house, by itself, as extinguishing the obligations arising
under the order dated 09.06.2022. Therefore, the respondent Nos.6
to 8 are liable to fulfil the obligations of deceased respondent No. 5
under the order dated 09.06.2022, as confirmed by order dated
17.01.2023.
Conclusion
34. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the
considered view that the order dated 09.06.2022, as confirmed by
the appellate order dated 17.01.2023, is required to be given effect
in accordance with law. The death of respondent No.5 does not
23
render the proceedings infructuous, and the liability of
respondents 6 to 8 has to be considered having regard to the
nature of the directions issued and their respective legal status.
Respondent No.3 shall therefore take effective steps under Section
11 of the 2007 Act, after taking into account the compliance
already effected and determining the extent of enforceability
against the respondents in accordance with law, so that the
petitioner, a senior citizen, is not left without the benefit of the
order already passed in her favour.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition is disposed of, in the
35.
following terms:
i) The inaction of respondent No.3 in considering the
application dated 28.08.2023 filed by the petitioner under
Section 11 of the 2007 Act, is declared as illegal and contrary
to the statutory scheme of the Act.
ii) Respondent No.3 is directed to consider the said application
and take effective steps for enforcement of the order dated
09.06.2022 in File No.G/PV/382/2022, as confirmed by the
order dated 17.01.2023 in Appeal No.C1/5307/2022, strictly
in accordance with law, as expeditiously as possible,
preferably within a period of eight(8) weeks from the date of
receipt of a copy of this order.
24
iii) Respondent Nos.6 to 8, being the legal representatives of
deceased respondent No.5, shall comply with the obligations
arising from the order dated 09.06.2022, as confirmed by the
order dated 17.01.2023, to the extent legally enforceable
against them. In particular:
a. The direction contained in Point No.5 of the order
dated 09.06.2022 relating to construction of two
additional rooms with all amenities for the petitioner
and her husband shall be complied with.
b. Alternatively, the respondents may place before
respondent No.3 an appropriate proposal consistent
with the directions of this Court dated 06.03.2024
towards their accommodation, maintenance and
medical expenses, including by way of a lump-sum
deposit in the bank account of the petitioner and her
husband, as may be determined by respondent No.3.
c. Respondent Nos.6 to 8 shall provide food, daily
necessities, medical expenses and proper care to the
petitioner and her husband shall be enforced in
accordance with the order dated 09.06.2022.
d. Respondent No. 6 shall be personally liable to comply
with the said directions. Respondent Nos. 7 and 8
25
shall be liable to the extent of the estate inherited by
them from deceased respondent No. 5. Respondent No.
6, as the natural guardian of respondent Nos. 7 and 8,
shall ensure compliance on their behalf.
e. Respondent Nos. 6 to 8 shall not alienate or create any
third-party interest in the properties involved in the
present proceedings, without the prior permission of
respondent No. 3, till the obligations under the order
dated 09.06.2022 are fully complied with.
iv) Respondent No.3 shall enforce the order dated 09.06.2022 in
accordance with Section 11 of the Act, keeping in view the
interim directions issued by this Court on 06.03.2024, which
shall stand continued and extended to respondent Nos.6 to
8, and shall, in the event of wilful disobedience, take
appropriate action against the persons responsible in
accordance with law.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, pending if any, stand
closed. No order as to costs.
_____________________________
G.M.MOHIUDDIN, J
Date: 30.09.2026
Note: LR copy to be marked
(B/o) ssp