SMT M J SEETHA vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD
TH
DATED THIS THE 29 DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE HEMA KULKARNI
WRIT APPEAL NO.100564 OF 2025 (LB-RES)
BETWEEN:
1. SMT. M.J SEETHA
AGE: 66 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. AKSHAYA, PLOT NO.547/A/1,
RD
3 CROSS, BHAGYA NAGAR, BELAGAVI,
TQ: AND DIST: BELAGAVI-590 002.
2. SHRI. M.G.JNANADEVA
AGE: 76 YEARS, OCC: RETIRED,
R/O. AKSHAYA, PLOT NO.547/A/1,
RD
3 CROSS, BHAGYA NAGAR, BELAGAVI,
TQ: AND DIST: BELAGAVI - 590 022.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SMT.SURABHI KULKARNI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
DEPARTMENT OF URBAN DEVELOPMENT,
VIKAS SOUDHA, DR. B.R.AMBEDKAR VEEDHI,
BENGALURU-560 001,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY.
2. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
BELAGAVI, D.C.COMPOUND,
BELAGAVI - 590 001.
Digitally signed
by PRATIBHA
M PATIL
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
DHARWAD
BENCH
Date:
2026.11.20
12:18:36 +0530
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
3. THE COMMISSIONER
CITY CORPORATION OF BELAGAVI,
CTS NO.4821/27A, RS NO.1005,
NEAR SP OFFICE, SUBHASH NAGAR,
DIST: BELAGAVI - 590 016.
4. THE COMMISSIONER
BELAGAVI URBAN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY,
DIST: BELAGAVI.
5. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER (REVENUE)
CITY CORPORATION OF BELAGAVI,
CTS NO.4821/27A, RS NO.1005,
NEAR SP OFFICE, SUBHASH NAGAR,
DIST: BELAGAVI - 590 016.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT.GIRIJA S.HIREMATH, HCGP FOR R1;
SRI.ARAVIND KULKARNI, ADVOCATE FOR R3 AND R5;
SRI.G.I.GACHCHINAMATH, ADVOCATE FOR R4)
THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 4 OF
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961, PRAYING TO PLEASED TO SET
ASIDE THE IMPUGNED ORDER DATED 17.03.2025 PASSED IN WP
NO.100079/2022 (LB-RES) BY THE LEARNED SINGLE JUDGE, AND
ALLOW THE WRIT PETITION AS PRAYED FOR IN THE INTEREST OF
JUSTICE AND EQUITY; AND ETC.
THIS WRIT APPEAL COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING
THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
AND
HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE HEMA KULKARNI
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE HEMA KULKARNI )
The present intra-court appeal is filed by the appellants
assailing the order dated 17.03.2025 passed by the learned
Single Judge in W.P.No.100079/2022, whereby the learned
Single Judge dismissed the petition by imposing cost of
Rs.50,000/-, which shall be payable to the Karnataka State
Legal Services Authority.
2. Heard the learned counsel Smt. Surabhi Kulkarni
appearing for the appellants, learned High Court Government
Pleader Smt. Girija S. Hiremath appearing for respondents No.1
and 2, learned counsel Sri. Aravind Kulkarni appearing for
respondents No.3 and 5 and the learned counsel
Sri. G.I. Gachchinamath appearing for respondent No.4.
3. For the sake of convenience and easy reference the
parties are referred to as per their respective rankings before
the writ Court.
4. Facts in brief germane are as follows:
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
4.1. The petitioners claim that the properties in survey
Nos.275, 276-A, 276-B, 276-C and 277, totally measuring 02
acres 01 gunta, were converted for non-agricultural purposes
on 21.05.1960 under the then Section 66 of the Bombay
Revenue Act, 1879. The land in Survey No.277 was allotted
1
CTS No.5384 and measured 599 5/9 square yards . The
petition property was originally belonging to Mr. Anand
Gundappa Hulabatte and Mr. Ramchandra Hulabatte. The
original owners leased the petition property bearing CTS
No.5384 in favour of petitioner No.1 in the year 1986 and
subsequently, a lease deed was executed on 10.03.1996
(Annexure-C). That the original owners executed a registered
Sale Deed dated 08.09.2000 in respect of the petition property
in favour of petitioner No.1 for a sale consideration of
Rs.2,95,000/- (Annexure-D). Although the entire petition
property measuring 599 5/9 square yards was sold to the
petitioner No.1, through oversight only an area measuring
233.78 square yards was mentioned in the Sale Deed.
1
Hereinafter referred to as the ‘petition property’
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
4.2. The respondent No.1-State of Karnataka issued
final notification dated 10.03.2006 under the powers conferred
under Section 13-E of the Town and Country Planning
2
(Amendment) Act, 2004 , by adding a new regulation regarding
exemption for open space and civic amenities in sub-division of
land. Pursuant to the said notification, the respondent No.5
issued an order dated 01.09.2007 giving permission to
petitioner No.1 to change the land use from open space to
commercial purpose to an extent of land measuring 05 gunta in
CTS No.5384. Since the petition property was mentioned as
open space in the CDP prepared by respondent No.4, petitioner
No.1 made an application under Section 14(1)(1) of the Act for
change of land use on 08.10.2007. The respondent No.4, by its
order dated 21.01.2008, granted permission to petitioner No.1
to use the petition property for commercial purpose as single
layout on certain conditions (Annexure-F). Pursuant to the said
order, the respondent No.4 approved the single layout plan in
respect of the petition property (Annexure-G). On payment of
necessary fees by petitioner No.1, the respondent No.4 granted
approval and the entire petition property was treated as a
2
Hereinafter referred to as the ‘Act’
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
single layout plan. Thus, the respondents have recognized the
title of the petitioner over the entire 599 5/9 square yards in
CTS No.5384.
4.3. The petitioner No.1 had purchased the entire extent
of petition property of 599 5/9 square yards. However, in the
registered Sale Deed dated 08.09.2000, only an area of 233.78
square yards was mentioned. The petitioner No.1 filed
O.S.No.438/2009 for the relief of declaration and permanent
injunction against the former owners in respect of the petition
property. The said suit was ended in compromise on
01.06.2009 and petitioner No.1 was declared as the owner of
the entire extent of the petition property (Annexure-H). The
erstwhile owners of petition property have admitted the
ownership of petitioner No.1 over the petition property and
have not challenged the compromise decree in
O.S.No.438/2009 till date and the same has attained finality. It
is in pursuance thereof that the name of the petitioners was
entered into in the property card, as regards CTS No.5384.
4.4. The petitioner No.1 executed a registered Gift Deed
on 30.09.2009 in respect of the petition property in favour of
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
her husband- petitioner No.2. At this stage, it is claimed that
respondent No.3, Commissioner, City Corporation, Belagavi,
acquired a portion of the petitioners’ property to an extent of
2820 square feet for the purpose of road widening, without
issuance of notice and without following due process of law.
4.5. In furtherance of the said acquisition, the property
was bifurcated into CTS No.5384/1, measuring 270 1/9 square
yards, and CTS No.5384/2, measuring 328 7/9 square yards.
As regards CTS No.5384/2, the name of the Corporation was
entered into, the same having been acquired for the purpose of
road widening.
4.6. The petitioner No.2 executed a Sale Deed on
24.02.2014 in respect of CTS No.5384/1 in favour of one Raju
Ganapati Raikar and Shilpa Raju Raikar. The petitioners
thereafter have been making several representations to the
respondents for grant of an alternate site measuring 328 7/9
square yards or for payment of compensation in respect of the
land acquired in CTS No.5384/2. However, no action was taken.
Hence, the petitioners filed W.P.No.106592/2015 and
W.P.No.107313/2015 for mandamus and this Court directed
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
respondent No.3 to pass appropriate orders on the
representation within three months. The respondent No.1 had
also issued a direction to respondent No.3 on 05.04.2016 to
consider the representations of the petitioners and take
necessary action (Annexure-P).
4.7. The petitioners filed contempt proceedings in CCC
No.100193/2016 and CCC No.100200/2016, during the
pendency of which, respondent No.3 passed an order on
25.08.2016 that since the petitioners had already relinquished
a portion of the property, the question of payment of
compensation of granting alternate land would not arise.
4.8. The petitioners challenged the order dated
25.08.2016 in W.P.Nos.106525-106526/2017. The said writ
petitions came to be dismissed on the ground that the
petitioners had voluntarily given up their portion of the land in
terms of a release deed dated 07.11.2007, as per sub-section
(5) of Section 32 of the Karnataka Urban Development
Authorities Act, 1987.
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
4.9. Being aggrieved by the said order, the petitioners
preferred W.A.Nos.100226-100227/2019, where the writ
appeal Court held that the release deed did not bear the
signature of the petitioners and as such, set aside the order
passed in W.P.Nos.106525-106526/2017 and directed
respondent No.3 to pay a speaking order within three months.
Thereafter, respondent No.3 issued notice to the petitioners to
appear on 18.07.2020. The petitioners appeared and filed
written arguments. The respondent No.3 passed an order on
21.01.2021 holding that the recitals in the Sale Deed dated
08.09.2000 clearly shows that petitioner No.1 had purchased
CTS No.5384 only to an extent of 233.78 square yards and not
the entire extent and dismissed the claim of the petitioners.
4.10. Being aggrieved by the same, the petitioners
preferred W.P.No.100079/2022 challenging the order dated
21.01.2021 passed by respondent No.3. On 17.03.2025, the
learned Single Judge dismissed the said petition by imposing a
cost of Rs.50,000/-. The order of the learned Single Judge
reads as follows:
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
“1. The Petitioners are before this Court seeking for the
following reliefs:
i. Issue a writ or order or direction in the nature of
certiorari quashing the order of the respondent No.3
dated 21.01.2021 in CCB/REV/MP/Misc22-2019-20,
produced as per Annexure-A;
ii. Issue a writ or order or direction in the nature of
mandamus directing the respondents to acquire the
portion of the petition property used for road widening
in accordance with law and pay compensation as
required under the law or grant an alternative
commercial land in Belagavi City.
iii. Issue any other writ or direction which this Hon'ble
Court deems fit to meet the ends of justice.
2. The facts in brief are;
2.1. The petitioners claim that the properties in survey
Nos. 275, 276-A, 276-B, 276-C and 277, totally
measuring 2 acres 1 gunta, were converted for
non-agricultural purposes on 21.05.1960 under
the then Section 66 of the Bombay Revenue Act,
1879. The land in Survey No.277 was allotted CTS
No.5384 and measured 599 5/9 square yards.
2.2. The said owners leased the properties in favor of
petitioner No.1 in the year 1986, however a lease
deed was executed only on 10.03.1996.
Subsequently, it is claimed that the owners sold
the said properties in favor of the petitioners on
08.09.2000 for a sale consideration of
Rs.2,95,000/-.
2.3. A notification came to be issued by the Urban
Development Department on 10.03.2006 under
Section 13-E of the Town and Country Planning
(Amendment) Act, 2004, by virtue of which an
exemption was provided for open space and civic
amenities on the sub-division of land.
2.4. Respondent No.5 thereafter issued an order on
01.09.2007, permitting petitioner No.1 for change
of land use to commercial purposes to an extent of
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
land measuring 5 guntas in CTS No.5384. Since
the said property was mentioned as open space in
the CDP prepared by the Belagavi Urban
Development Authority ('BUDA' for short), the
Respondent No.4-BUDA, also approved a single
layout plan in respect of the aforesaid property,
and thus, it is claimed that BUDA has recognized
the right, title, and interest of the petitioners over
the entire 599 5/9 square yards in CTS No.5384.
2.5. It is further claimed that, although the entire land
had been sold, by oversight, only an extent of
233.78 square yards was mentioned in the sale
deed as regards CTS No.5384.
2.6. Since there was a defect in the sale deed, the
petitioners had filed a suit in O.S.No.438/2009 for
declaration and permanent injunction against the
former owners as regards the entire land. The said
suit ended in a compromise where petitioner No.1
was declared as the owner of the entire extent of
599 5/9 square yards. It is in pursuance thereof
that the name of the petitioners was entered into
in the property card, as regards CTS No.5384.
2.7. Petitioner No.1 executed a registered gift deed on
30.09.2009, gifting the above property to
petitioner No.2, his wife. At this stage it is claimed
that respondent No.3, Commissioner, City
Corporation, acquired a portion of the petitioners'
property to an extent of 2820 square feet for the
purpose of road widening, without issuance of
notice and without following due process of law.
2.8. In furtherance of the said acquisition, the property
was bifurcated into CTS No.5384/1, measuring
233 7/9 square yards, and CTS No.5384/2,
measuring 365 7/9 square yards. As regards CTS
No.5384/2, the name of the Corporation was
entered into, the same having been acquired for
the purpose of road widening.
2.9. Petitioner No.2 executed a sale deed on 24.02.2014
in respect of CTS No.5384/1, measuring 270 7/9
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
square yards, in favor of one Raju Ganapati Raikar
and Shilpa Raju Raikar. The petitioners thereafter
have been making to the several representations
respondents for grant of an alternate site
measuring 328 7/9 square yards or for payment of
compensation in respect of the land acquired in
CTS No.5384/2. However, no action was taken.
2.10. Hence, the petitioners filed WP No. 106592/2015
and WP No.107313/2015 for mandamus and this
Court directed respondent No.3 Corporation to
pass appropriate orders on the representation
within 3 months. Respondent No. 1 had also
issued directions to respondent No.3 to consider
the representation, which were not so considered.
2.11. Hence, the petitioners filed contempt proceedings
in CCC No.100193/2016 and CCC
No.100200/2016, during the pendency of which
respondent No.3 passed an order on 25.08.2016
that, since the petitioners had already relinquished
a portion of the property, the question of payment
of compensation or granting alternate land would
not arise.
2.12. The petitioners challenged the order dated
25.08.2016 in WP Nos. 106525-106526/2016. The
writ petitions came to be dismissed on the ground
that the petitioners had voluntarily given up their
portion of the land in terms of a release deed
dated 07.11.2007, as per sub-section (5) of
Section 32 of the Karnataka Urban Development
Authorities Act, 1987.
2.13. This order was challenged by the petitioners in WA
Nos. 100226-100227/2019, where the writ appeal
Court held that the release deed did not bear the
signature of the petitioners, and as such, set aside
the order passed in WP Nos. 106525-106526/2017
and directed respondent No.3 to pass a speaking
order within three months.
2.14. Thereafter, respondent No.3 issued notice to the
petitioners to appear on 18.07.2020, the
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
petitioners appeared and filed written arguments,
respondent No. 3 passed an order on 21.01.2021
holding that the recitals in the sale deed dated
08.09.2000 clearly shows that petitioner No.1 had
purchased CTS No.5384 only to an extent of
233.78 square yards and not the entire extent and
dismissed the claim of the petitioners.
2.15. Thereafter, the petitioners issued a notice on
07.06.2021, under the Right to Fair Compensation
and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation, and Resettlement Act, but no action
has been taken by the respondent.
2.16. It is challenging the order dated 21.01.2021
denying the petitioners compensation, that the
petitioners are before this Court.
3. Ms. Surubhi Kulkarni, learned counsel for the
petitioners, would submit that;
3.1. The Petitioners are the owners of the entire extent
of land covered under CTS No. 5384, though the
sale deed was for 233.78 square yards, in terms of
the compromise entered into in O.S.No.438/2009,
the owners have accepted the petitioners to be the
owner of the entire extent of land.
3.2. This aspect having been accepted by the BUDA,
change of land use having been permitted for the
entire extent of 599 5/9 square yards, and a
single layout plan having been approved for the
entire extent, the question of the Corporation
claiming that the petitioners are the owners of
only 233.78 square yards is not proper and
correct.
3.3. She submits that a suit having been filed in O.S.
No.438/2009 wherein it has been declared that
the petitioner No.1 is the owner of the entire
extent of land in CTS No.5384 measuring 599-5/9
square yards, the present impugned order could
not have been passed. She reiterates that the
petitioner No.1 is the owner of the enire CTS
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
No.5384 measuring 559-5/9 square yards and, the
same is now divided into CTS No.5384/1 and CTS
No.5384/2.
3.4. On the above basis she submits that the writ
petition is to be allowed and reliefs sought for be
granted.
4. Sri.Arvind D.Kulkarni, counsel learned for respondents
No.3 and 4 would submit that,
4.1. What has been sold to the petitioner under sale
deed dated 8.09.2000 is only 233.78 square
yards. The sale deed only reflects that extent of
land having been sold, the petitioners have misled
BUDA in obtaining change of land use to the entire
extent of 599-5/9 square yards as regards which
petitioner No.1 nor petitioner No.2 said to be
owners thereof. The change of land use having
applied for on 8.10.2007, granted on 21.02.2008.
it is only when the aspects relating thereto were
poined out, that a collusive suit in O.S.
No.439/2009 and compromise is immediately
entered into on 1.06.2009.
4.2. He submits that the conduct of the petitioners is
completely malefide, the petitioners have
wantonly misled all the concerned. He further
submits that the petitioners are seeking to reserve
the land to an extent of 599-5/9 square yards
when it does not belong to them. Even as regards
this, he submits that a relinquishment deed having
been executed way back on 07.11.2007, the
question of the petitioners claiming any right or
interest would not arise. The petitioners have also
sold the extent of land belonging to them and
more, vide sale deed dated 24.02.2014 having
conveyed an extent of 270-7/9 square yards in
favour of Raju Ganapati Raikar and Shilpa Raju
Raikar, when the petitioners have title over only
233.78 square yards. He thus submits that the
petitioners are seeking to usurp the land which
does not belong to them. The order passed by
respondent No.3 is proper and correct, inasmuch
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
as the petitioner having purchased only 233.78
square yards, the same has been taken into
consideration while passing the order dated
21.01.2021 and holding that the petitioners will
not be entitled for any compensation since that
land measuring 233.78 has not been acquired or
dealt with by the respondents No.3 or 4.
4.3. On these grounds, he submits that the above
petition is required to be dismissed.
5. Sri.V.S.Kalsurmath, learned AGA submis that the
dispute is between the petitioner and respondent No.3.
Respondents No.1 and 2 have nothing to with it.
6. Sri.M.A.Huliyal, learned counsel for respondent No.4
would submit that the change of land use which has been
effected by respondent No.4 is in pursuance of the
application submitted by the petitioners and no fault can
be found therewith. He therefore submits that the present
order which is impugned herein namely the order passed
by respondent No.3, the matter is between the petitioner
and respondent No.3.
7. Heard Smt.Surabhi Ravindra, learned counsel for the
petitioners, Sri.V.S.Kalasurmath, learned AGA for
respondents No.1 and 2, Aravind D.Kulkarni, learned
counsel for respondents No.3 and 5 and Sri.M.A.Hulyal,
learned counsel for respondent No.4. Perused papers.
8. The short question that arises for consideration in the
present matter is;
"Whether the petitioners would be entitled
for compensation as regards land in CTS
No.5384 over and above 233.78 square yards?"
9. It is not in dispute that what has been purchased by
the petitioners under sale deed is only 233.78 square
yards, when in fact the total extent of land in CTS
No.5384 was 599-5/9 square yards. Thus it is clear that
what the owners of the land sold to the petitioner No.1
was only 233.78 square yards and the sale deed has been
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
executed in relation thereto. The schedule to the said sale
deed reads as under:
Schedule
All that part and parcel of the open plot (without electricity,
well and tap & drainage connection) admeasuring 233.78 Sq.
yds. Situated at C.T.S. No. 5384, situated at Mahatma Phule
Road, Shahapur, Belgaum, which is bounded as follows;
On or towards East: Road
On or towards West: Road
On or towards South: Main Road
On or towards North: Road
10. The reason why a sale was executed as regards
233.78 square yards is that the balance land was
earmarked for road widening and it is for that reason that
the petitioners probably did not purchase the land
earmarked for road widening.
11. Though the petitioners claim that the petitioner No.1
was in occupation of the entire land and the intention of
the owners was to execute a sale deed in respect of the
entire land, the fact remains that there is no sale deed
executed for the entire land. The sale deed which has
been executed is only as regards 233.78 square yards.
That being the case, the petitioner No.1 had filed an
application with respondent No.4 for change of land use of
the entire extent of 599-5/9 was square yards which
granted. A single layout plan was also sanctioned by
respondent No.4 in pursuance of which the petitioner
relinquished an extent of area which was reserved for
formation of a road. The petitioner having taken the
benefit of the single layout plan sanction had later filed a
suit in O.S. No.438/2009 which was compromised
immediately after filing on 1.06.2009 declaring that the
petitioner No.1 was the owner of entire extent of 599-5/9
square yards. It is therefore clear that the suit was filed to
achieve the purposes of the petitioners, the decree passed
is not on merits but is a compromise decree, which the
petitioners now want to make use of against the
corporation, the corporation not being a party to the said
suit needless to say would not be bound by such a
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
collusive decee obtained by the petitioners to further the
false cause of the petitioners.
12. Immediately thereafter, petitioner No.1 executed a
gift deed on 13.09.2009 in favour of her husband-
petitioner No.2 as regards to 599-5/9 square yards. and
thereafter got the property bifurcated into CTS No.5384/1
and 5384/2 on 3.10.2013. CTS No.5384/1 measuring
233-7/9 square yards and CTS No.5384/2 measuring 365-
7/9 yards. CTS No.5384/1 rightly measured 233-7/9
square yards which is purchased by petitioner No.1 under
the aforesaid sale deed dated 8.09.2000, the extent which
had not been purchased but was subject matter of O.S.
No.438/2009 was numbered as CTS No.5384/2.
13. Though the land in CTS No.5384/1 measured only
233-7/9 square yards, the petitioners executed a sale
deed in respect of CTS No.5384/1 showing the same to
measure 270-7/9 square yards. Thus, it is clear that the
property purchased by petitioner No.1 was only 233.78
square yards. The same is however not subject matter of
these proceedings, it is between the petitioners and their
purchaser.
14. The change of land use was obtained as regards 599-
5/9 square yards. Subsequently, in a collusive suit, a
compromise decree was passed declaring the petitioner to
be owner of 599-5/9 square yards. The property was
bifurcated into two and thereafter 270-7/9 square yards
sold by petitioner No.2. All these are in my considered
opinion taking into account the dates of the transaction
created to try and establish a right of the petitioner over
the property when there is no such right. It is on that
basis that the petitioner has claimed compensation for
328-7/9 square yards or for grant of alternate site which
land was never purchased by the petitioner. This is also
rejected in several litigations filed by the petitioner
initially for mandamus, subsequently, when a direction
had been issued and orders have been passed challenging
the impugned order dated 21.01.2021.
15. In view of my categorical finding above that the
petitioners do not have any right, title or interest over
328-7/9 square yards, the question of the petitioners
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
claiming any compensation in relation thereto and or
claiming for alternate site to be granted on account of the
said land having been used for widening of the road would
not at all arise.
16. In my considerable opinion, the above petition and
even the earlier petitions leading up to the present
petition are a clear and categorical abuse of the process of
law and court. The petitioners without any regard for the
rule of law have sought to create documents, and have
gone to the extent of creating a collusive compromise
decree to try and unjustly benefit themselves, the same
would have to be dealt with by this court with iron hand,
so that such kind of actions are not repeated. The
sequence of events clearly indicates the malafides on part
of the petitioners.
17. In that view of the matter, the above petition stands
dismissed
by imposing cost of Rs.50,000/- which shall be
payable to the Karnataka State Legal Services Authority
within a period of 30 days from the date of receipt of copy
of this order. If the said amount is not paid within 30 days
as indicated above, the KSLSA would be entitled to
recover the cost as arrears of land revenue.”
5. Being aggrieved by the said order, the
appellants/petitioners preferred the present writ appeal.
6. Learned counsel for the appellants contends that the
learned Single Judge erred in dismissing the writ petition on the
basis of assumptions and presumptions, without appreciating
the material available on record in its proper perspective. The
learned Single Judge erred in holding that the Sale Deed dated
08.09.2000 establishes that petitioner No.1 had purchased the
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
petition property only to an extent of 233.78 square yards and
that, therefore, the petitioners had probably not purchased the
remaining land earmarked for road widening. The learned
Single Judge failed to appreciate the compromise decree dated
01.06.2009 passed between the erstwhile owners of the
petition property and petitioner No.1.
7. Learned counsel for the appellants further contends
that the learned Single Judge failed to appreciate that the
erstwhile owners had leased out the entire petition property to
petitioner No.1 in the year 1986 and had intended to sell the
entire extent of the property to her. However, due to an
oversight, only an extent of 233.78 square yards was included
in the Sale Deed dated 08.09.2000. To rectify the said
omission, the erstwhile owners, under a compromise decree
dated 01.06.2009 passed in O.S.No.438/2009, admitted that
petitioner No.1 was the absolute owner of the entire extent of
the petition property, measuring 599 5/9 square yards. The
said compromise decree has attained finality and has not been
challenged till date.
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
8. Learned counsel further contends that the learned
Single Judge erred in holding that the compromise decree
passed in O.S.No.438/2009 was a collusive decree and was not
binding on the respondent-Corporation on the ground that the
Corporation was not impleaded as a party to the said suit. The
learned Single Judge failed to appreciate that the petition
property is admittedly private property and that the
respondent-Corporation has no concern with the determination
of title thereto. Therefore, the respondent-Corporation was
neither a necessary nor a proper party to the suit in
O.S.No.438/2009, which was instituted between petitioner No.1
and the erstwhile owners of the petition property. In such
circumstances, the compromise decree could not have been
characterised as collusive merely because the respondent-
Corporation was not a party to the said proceedings.
9. Learned counsel further contends that the learned
Single Judge failed to appreciate that mere widening of the
road by the Corporation by utilising a portion of the petition
property, without acquiring the same in accordance with law,
does not confer title over such portion of land upon the
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
Corporation. The respondents are duty-bound to acquire the
land by following the procedure prescribed by law and either
pay compensation to the rightful owner or allot an alternative
site in accordance with law.
10. In the present case, the erstwhile owners of the
petition property admitted, under the compromise decree, that
they had intended to sell the entire extent of the petition
property, i.e., 599 5/9 square yards, to petitioner No.1 at the
time of execution of the Sale Deed itself. They further admitted
that, owing to an omission, the Sale Deed dated 08.09.2000
was executed only in respect of 233.78 square yards and that,
subsequently, they had entered into a compromise with
petitioner No.1, acknowledging her ownership over the entire
extent of the petition property. When the erstwhile owners
themselves had acknowledged the title of petitioner No.1 over
the entire petition property, the respondents could not claim
any right, title or interest therein, much less utilise any portion
thereof for road widening without acquiring the same in
accordance with law. It is further contended that petitioner
No.1 had submitted an application to respondent No.4 seeking
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
change of land use in respect of the petition property from
open space to commercial use. In that regard, respondent No.4
sought the opinion of respondent No.3-Corporation, which, by
its letter dated 07.04.2006, issued a no-objection for the
proposed change of land use. Pursuant thereto, respondent
No.4, in its meeting held on 01.07.2006, resolved to consider
the change of land use, having regard to the fact that the
petition property was privately owned, though it was
designated as open space in the Master Plan. Accordingly,
respondent No.4 submitted a report dated 16.09.2006 to
respondent No.1-State Government, which, in turn, approved
the change of land use by its order dated 01.09.2007.
11. Learned counsel further contends that the order dated
01.09.2007 passed by respondent No.1-State Government was
challenged by third parties before a Co-ordinate Bench of this
Court in W.P.No.30112/2009, contending that the petition
property belonged to respondent No.3-Corporation and,
therefore, the change of land use could not have been
permitted. In the said proceedings, the learned counsel
appearing for respondent No.3-Corporation herein categorically
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
submitted that the petition property did not belong to the
Corporation but belonged to the petitioners herein. Upon
consideration of the rival submissions, the Co-ordinate Bench
dismissed the said writ petition by order dated 05.08.2011.
12. Learned counsel submits that the learned Single Judge
failed to appreciate that the utilisation of private property by
the respondent-authorities for road widening, without acquiring
the same by following due process of law, is violative of Article
300-A of the Constitution of India. Hence, learned counsel
prays that the appeal be allowed and the impugned order
passed by the learned Single Judge be set aside.
13. Per contra, learned counsels appearing for the
respondents support the impugned order passed by the learned
Single Judge and pray for dismissal of the appeal.
14. We have given our anxious consideration to the
submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties.
Perused the materials available on record.
15. It is not in dispute that what has been purchased by
the petitioners under sale deed is only 233.78 square yards,
when in fact the total extent of land in CTS No.5384 was 599-
- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
5/9 square yards. Thus it is clear that what the owners of the
land sold to the petitioner No.1 was only 233.78 square yards
and the sale deed has been executed in relation thereto. The
schedule to the sale deed reads as under:
Schedule
All that part and parcel of the open plot (without electricity, well and
tap & drainage connection) admeasuring 233.78 Sq. yds. Situated at
C.T.S. No. 5384, situated at Mahatma Phule Road, Shahapur,
Belgaum, which is bounded as follows;
On or towards East : Road
On or towards West : Road
On or towards South : Main Road
On or towards North : Road
16. The reason why a sale was executed as regards
233.78 square yards is that the balance land was earmarked
for road widening and it is for that reason that the petitioners
probably did not purchase the land earmarked for road
widening.
17. Though the petitioners claim that petitioner No.1 was
in occupation of the entire land and the intention of the owners
was to execute a sale deed in respect of the entire land, the
fact remains that there is no Sale Deed executed for the entire
land. The Sale Deed which has been executed is only as
regards 233.78 square yards. That being the case, the
- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
petitioner No.1 had filed an application with respondent No.4
for change of land use of the entire extent of 599-5/9 square
yards which was so granted. A single layout plan was also
sanctioned by respondent No.4 in pursuance of which the
petitioner relinquished an extent of area which was reserved for
formation of a road. The petitioner having taken the benefit of
the single layout plan sanction had later filed a suit in
O.S.No.438/2009, which was compromised immediately after
filing on 01.06.2009 declaring that petitioner No.1 was the
owner of entire extent of 599-5/9 square yards. It is therefore
clear that the suit was filed to achieve the purposes of the
petitioners, the decree passed is not on merits but is a
compromise decree, which the petitioners now want to make
use of against the corporation, the corporation not being a
party to the said suit needless to say would not be bound by
such a collusive decree obtained by the petitioners to further
the false cause of the petitioners.
18. The learned Single Judge observed that the change of
land use had been obtained in respect of the entire extent of
599 5/9 square yards and that, subsequently, a compromise
- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
decree was obtained in a collusive suit, declaring petitioner
No.1 to be the owner of the said extent of land. The learned
Single Judge further observed that the property was thereafter
bifurcated into two portions, out of which an extent of 270 7/9
square yards was sold by petitioner No.2. Taking into
consideration the dates and sequence of the aforesaid
transactions, the learned Single Judge opined that the
transactions appeared to have been structured to create and
establish a claim of ownership over the property,
notwithstanding the absence of any subsisting right thereto. It
was further observed that, on the basis of such transactions,
the petitioners had claimed compensation in respect of 328 7/9
square yards or, alternatively, sought allotment of an
alternative site, even though the said extent of land had never
been purchased by them. The learned Single Judge also took
note of the fact that the petitioners had earlier instituted
several rounds of litigation, initially seeking a writ of mandamus
and subsequently challenging the order dated 21.01.2021 after
directions had been issued and consequential orders had been
passed.
- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
19. The learned Single Judge, therefore, concluded that
the petitioners had no right, title or interest over the extent of
328 7/9 square yards and, consequently, were not entitled to
claim compensation or seek allotment of an alternative site on
the ground that the said land had been utilised for road
widening. The learned Single Judge further characterised the
series of proceedings initiated by the petitioners as an abuse of
the process of law and the Court, observing that the petitioners
had attempted to create documents, including a collusive
compromise decree, with the intention of securing an unjust
benefit. Taking serious note of the sequence of events and the
alleged mala fide conduct of the petitioners, the learned Single
Judge considered it necessary to impose exemplary costs of
Rs.50,000/- to deter similar conduct in future.
20. We have carefully considered the reasoning assigned
by the learned Single Judge on merits. We find no error of law
or jurisdiction warranting interference with the impugned order
in this intra-court appeal. Accordingly, the order passed by the
learned Single Judge on merits is confirmed. Insofar as the
imposition of costs is concerned, the award of costs is a matter
- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
of judicial discretion, which, however, must be exercised
judiciously. Costs are not ordinarily imposed merely because a
litigant fails to succeed in the proceedings. Imposition of
exemplary costs is warranted in cases where a litigant
approaches the Court with mala fide intentions, suppresses
material facts, or institutes frivolous or vexatious proceedings
or otherwise abuses the process of law.
21. In the present case, we find that the petitioners
approached this Court bona fide to vindicate what they
perceived to be their legitimate rights and pursue their claim.
The mere fact that their claim has not found favour with the
Court does not, by itself, render the proceedings frivolous or
vexatious. We also cannot lose sight of the fact that the
petitioners are senior citizens suffering from age-related
ailments. In the facts and circumstances of the case, we are of
the considered opinion that saddling the petitioners with costs
of Rs.50,000/- would cause further hardship and that such
imposition is not warranted.
22. Therefore, for the aforesaid reasons, we are of the
view that the impugned order passed by the learned Single
- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17724-DB
WA No. 100564 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020186502025
Judge is liable to be set aside only to the extent of imposition of
costs of Rs.50,000/- on the petitioners.
23. Hence, the following:
ORDER
a) The writ appeal is allowed in part .
b) The order dated 17.03.2025 passed by the
learned Single Judge in W.P.No.100079/2022 is
hereby confirmed on merits and in all other
respects.
c) Insofar as the imposition of costs of
Rs.50,000/- is concerned, the same is hereby set
aside and the costs are waived.
Pending interlocutory applications, if any, stand
disposed as not calling for adjudication.
Sd/-
(M.NAGAPRASANNA)
JUDGE
Sd/-
(HEMA KULKARNI)
JUDGE
PMP
CT:VH/List No.: 1 Sl No.: 36