CORROGANON INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED vs THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS

Court
Calcutta High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
ORIGINAL SIDE

Present :-
The Hon’ble Justice PARTHA SARATHI SEN

W.P.O. 2474 OF 2022

CORROGANON INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED
-Vs-
THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.



For the Petitioners: Mr. Jishnu Chowdhury, Sr. Adv.
Ms. Pratiti Das, Adv.
Ms. Ujjaini Chatterjee, Adv.

For the Union of India: Mr. Abhratosh Majumdar, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Chayan Gupra, Adv.
Mr. Sandip Dasgupta, Adv.
Mr. Aviroop Mitra, Adv.
Hearing concluded on: 01.10.2026
Judgment on: 05.10.2026


PARTHA SARATHI SEN, J. : –
1. The subject matter of the instant writ petition is the memo dated
02.12.2021 as issued by the respondent no. 3 authority whereby and
whereunder the writ petitioner Company was intimated regarding forfeiture of
the Earnest Money Deposit (‘EMD’ in short) amounting to Rs. 73,97,650/- in
terms of the provision in the Instructions to Bidders of the Notice Inviting E-
Tender (‘NIET’ in short) dated 18.08.2016.
Page 1 of 19

2. For effective adjudication of the instant writ petition some relevant facts
leading to filing of the instant writ petition are required to be dealt with in a
nutshell and those are as under:
(i) On 18.08.2016 the respondent no. 2 authority has published a NIET
for construction of two numbers of right turn flyovers across Kona
Expressway at ingress and egress points of Santragachhi bus
terminus with approach roads. Along with the said NIET, an
Instruction to Bidders was also published, a copy of which has been
annexed at page nos. 49 to 63 of the instant writ petition.
(ii) The writ petitioner company participated in the said bid and found to
be a successful bidder and thus the respondent no. 5 authority vide
memo dated 18.11.2016 issued a letter of acceptance-cum-work order
which was duly received by the writ petitioner company.
(iii) On 05.12.2016 the writ petitioner company issued a letter to the
respondent no. 2 authority to allow the writ petitioner company to
step down from the tender for the reasons stated therein.
(iv) On 07.12.2016 the respondent no. 5 authority in reference to the
aforementioned letter dated 05.12.2016 issued another letter to the
writ petitioner company noting therein that the writ petitioner
company neither deposited performance security nor executed the
agreement and on the contrary it has prayed for stepping down from
the tender and thus, the contract awarded to the said writ petitioner
Page 2 of 19

company stood terminated with immediate effect following the
provisions of the Instruction to Bidders.
(v) Thereafter on and from 15.12.2016 to 19.07.2021 the writ petitioner
company issued series of letters to the different authorities of the
Hooghly River Bridge Commissioners (“Commissioners” in short) who
are the the respondent nos. 2 to 7 herein requesting them to refund
the EMD amount which was turned down by the impugned memo
dated 02.12.2021 by the respondent no. 3 authority.
3. At the time of hearing Mr. Jishnu Chowdhury, learned Senior Advocate
appearing on behalf of the writ petitioner at the very outset took me to the copy
of the Instruction to Bidders. Drawing attention to Clause 16.6 of the said
Instruction to Bidders, it is argued by Mr. Chowdhury that the respondent
authorities most illegally invoked the provisions of Clause 15.6 which deals
with the forfeiture of EMD. It is argued by Mr. Chowdhury that by issuing the
letter of acceptance dated 18.11.2016 by the respondent no. 5 authority, a
concluded contract between the writ petitioner and the respondent
Commissioners was entered into and, therefore, the inter se relation between
the parties to the said contract are to be governed under the provisions of
Section 74 of the Contract Act. It is argued by Mr. Chowdhury that for the sake
of argument even if it is accepted that the said concluded contract has been
broken at the instance of the writ petitioner, the respondent Commissioners is
not entitled to retain the said EMD in absence of any stipulation that in case of
Page 3 of 19

breach of the contract, the party aggrieved to the contract is entitled to damage
by way of penalty.
4. Placing his reliance upon a judgment passed by a Division Bench of this
High Court in the case of Dolphin Suppliers Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of India &
Anr. reported in (2025) 1 SCC (Cal) 1 it is argued by Mr. Chowdhury that
relying upon the various judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the cases
of Security Engg. (P) Ltd. vs. Electro Medical & Allied Industries Ltd.
reported in 2024 SCC OnLine Cal 111 , MBL Infrastructure Ltd. vs. Rites
Ltd. reported in 2020 SCC OnLine Cal 478 , Shree Coal Enterprises of
India (P) Ltd. vs. Coal India Ltd. reported in 2018 SCC OnLine Cal 1652
and Kailash Nath Associates vs. DDA reported in (2015) 4 SCC 136 the said
Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court came to a logical conclusion that the
party claiming to be aggrieved by the breach of contract in absence of any
specific pleading regarding the quantum of loss and damages suffered by
reason of cancellation of the contract is not entitled to forfeit the amount as
deposited by the party to the contract who had broken the same.

5. It is further argued by Mr. Chowdhury that the respondent Commissioners
in their correspondences as well as in their affidavit-in-opposition had not
averred anything regarding the quantum of damages suffered by them on
account of alleged breach of contract and, therefore, retention of the EMD
amount as made by the writ petitioner is grossly illegal. It is thus submitted by
Mr. Chowdhury that the impugned memo dated 02.12.2021 as issued by the
respondent Commissioners may be quashed and the respondent
Page 4 of 19

Commissioners and/or their instrumentalities may be directed to refund the
EMD amount of Rs. 73,97,650/- to the writ petitioner along with accrued
interest thereon.
6. On being asked by this Court as to whether the writ petitioner approached
this High Court with a time barred claim or not, Mr. Chowdhury contended
that since the cause of action arose on account of issuance of the impugned
memo dated 02.12.2021 the writ petitioner’s claim is not barred by limitation
since under Article 113 of the Schedule of the Limitation Act, the writ petitioner
is entitled to sue within 3 years from 02.12.2021 that is from the date of
issuance of the impugned letter and on the contrary the instant writ petition
was filed on 25.08.2022.
7. Per contra, Mr. Majumdar, learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of
the respondent Commissioners and its instrumentalities also took me to the
relevant NIET dated 23.09.2016 as well as to the different clauses of the
Instruction to Bidders. He also draws attention of this Court to the letter of
acceptance dated 18.11.2016 as issued by the respondent Commissioners
wherein it has been indicated that the said letter dated 18.11.2016 is to be
treated as work order as well as a notice to commence work.


8. It is argued by Mr. Majumdar that on conjoint perusal of the said letter of
acceptance dated 10.11.2016 vis-à-vis Clauses 15.6 and 31 of the Instruction
to Bidders it would reveal that it was specifically mentioned in the Instruction
to Bidders that in the event the successful bidder fails to sign the agreement
within 7 days of the receipt of the letter of acceptance, EMD would be forfeited.
Page 5 of 19

It is argued by Mr. Majumdar that since the writ petitioner company had failed
to execute the agreement within the stipulated days the respondent
Commissioners and its instrumentalities have rightly invoked Clause 15.6 of
the Instruction to Bidders and rightly forfeited the EMD. To substantiate his
contention Mr. Majumdar places his reliance in the judgments passed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of National Highways Authority of India
vs. Ganga Enterprises & Anr. reported in (2003) 7 SCC 410, National
Thermal Power Corporation Ltd. vs. Ashok Kumar Singh & Ors. reported
in (2015) 4 SCC 252 and State of Haryana & Ors. vs. Malik Traders
reported in (2011) 13 SCC 200 .
9. It is submitted by Mr. Majumdar that it has been consistently held by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court that in the event a person made his offer on a
condition that some earnest money will be forfeited for not entering into any
contract or if some act is not performed, then even though he may have a right
to withdraw his offer, he has no right to claim that the earnest/security be
returned to him. It is further argued by Mr. Majumdar that the Hon’ble
Supreme Court further held that forfeiture of such earnest/security, in no way
affects any statutory right under the Contract Act, since such earnest/security
is given and taken to ensure that a contract comes into existence. It is thus
argued by Mr. Majumdar that Section 74 of the Contract Act has no manner of
application in the instant lis and thus, the respondent Commissioners have
rightly forfeited the EMD amount.
Page 6 of 19

10. In his next fold of submission Mr. Majumdar also took me to the
letter dated 05.12.2016 whereby and whereunder the writ petitioner company
stepped down from the tender as well as to the letter dated 07.10.2016 as
issued by the respondent Commissioners whereby the said Commissioners
have terminated the contract as awarded to the writ petitioner with immediate
effect following the provisions of the Instruction to Bidders clearly indicating
that the writ petitioners have failed to deposit the performance security and
execute the agreement in terms of the Clause 15.6 of the instructions to bidder.
It is argued by Mr. Majumdar that in the event the letter of termination dated
07.12.2016 is viewed in the perspective of the various clauses of the
Instruction to Bidders, it would reveal that while issuing the letter of
termination, the respondent Commissioners have invoked Clause 15.06 of the
Instruction to Bidders and thus, forfeited the EMD amount.
11. It is thus argued by Mr. Majumdar that cause of action for the
initiation of a proceeding being a writ before appropriate Civil Court having
territorial and pecuniary jurisdiction ought to have been filed within 3 years
from 07.12.2016 for recovery of the said forfeited amount. It is submitted
further that though there is no period of limitation for filing a writ however,
there is sufficient materials before this Court to come to a logical conclusion
that the writ petitioner has filed the instant writ petition in order to get rid of a
time barred claim before a jurisdictional Civil Court.
12. Mr. Majumdar further contended that the reported decisions in the
case of Dolphin Suppliers (Supra) as well as in the cases of Security Engg.
Page 7 of 19

(Supra), MBL Infrastructure (Supra), Shree Coal Enterprises (Supra) and
Kailash Nath Associates (Supra) as passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
are distinguishable from the facts and circumstances as involved in the instant
writ petition.
13. This Court has meticulously perused the entire materials as placed
before this Court. This Court has given its anxious consideration over the
submissions of the learned Advocates for the contending parties.

14. For effective adjudication of the instant writ petition some relevant
clauses of the Instruction to Bidders are required to be looked into and those
are as under:
“ 15.6 The Bid Security/Earnest Money may be forfeited

(a) if the bidder withdraws his bid during the period of bid
validity;
(b) in the case a successful bidder fails within the specified
time limit to
(i) sign the Agreement
(ii) furnish the required performance security
*
31 . Signing of Agreement

The following documents shall be deemed to form and be
read and construed as part of this Agreement, viz.:

(a) Agreement

(b) Letter of Acceptance

(c) The offer submitted by the Contractor in the prescribed
Form of Bid

(d) Addenda/Corrigenda to Tender Documents, if any

(e) Notice Inviting e-Tender (NIeT)

(f) Instructions to Bidders

Page 8 of 19

(g) General Conditions of Contract

(h) Technical Specifications

(i) Bill of Quantities and Preamble to B.O.Q. with Provisional
Sums

(j) Tender Drawings

(k) Technical Submission by the contractor

(1) List of Technical Personnel (Section B, Form - IV)

(m) List of Equipment (Section B, Form - V)

(n) Undertaking for Technical and Equipment Capability
(Section B, Form - VI)

(o) Self Declaration (as per format shown in Section B)

(p) Other documents as agreed uponWithin seven days of
receipt of the Letter of Acceptance, the successful bidder
shall present himself at the office of the Employer to sign
the Form of Agreement (to be typed on Non Judicial Stamp
Paper of value Rs.100/- by the bidder). The successful
bidder shall have to sign on every page of all the hard
copies of tender document comprising of the above-
mentioned documents, which will be downloaded and
printed by HRBC, by authorized signatory of the bidder in
the office of Director (Pl. & Dn.). HRBC.

32. Performance Security/Guarantee

Within seven days of receipt of the notification of award
from the Employer the successful bidder shall furnish to the
Employer a performance security in the form of Bank
Guarantee in favour of 'Hooghly River Bridge
Commissioners' from Nationalised or Scheduled Banks of
India to be acceptable to the Employer of an amount of 7.5%
of the Contract Price in accordance with the Conditions of
Contract. The form of Performance Bank Guarantee
provided in 'Section B Form-IX of the bidding documents
may be used or some other form acceptable to the Employer
which will have provision of extending the Bank Guarantee
with extension of time approved by the Employer.

33. Annulment of the Award

Page 9 of 19

Failure of the successful bidder to comply with the
requirements of Clauses 31 or 32 shall constitute sufficient
grounds for the annulment of the award and forfeiture of
the bid security.

34. Issue of Notice to Commence

After receipt of Performance Security from the contractor as
stipulated in Clause 32 of Instructions to Bidders and
Clause 6 of General Conditions of Contract or even alter
award of the contract through issue of Letter of Acceptance,
the Engineer will notify the contractor to commence work as
soon as reasonably possible with due expedition and
without delay. If the contractor fails to commence works
physically at the site within 7 (seven) days from the date of
issue of Notice to Commence Work, that will constitute a
breach of contract and in that case the Employer will have
right to annul the contract with forfeiture of Performance
Security and if the same is not deposited forfeiture of Bid
Security.”

15. Keeping in mind the aforementioned clauses of the Instruction to
Bidders, if I look to the letter dated 18.11.2016 as issued by the respondent
Commissioners, it appears that the same is not only an acceptance of the offer
of the writ petitioner company but also the same is a formal work order with a
notice to commence work upon compliance of the stipulations regarding
performance security and signing of form of agreement. Admittedly, by issuing
a letter dated 05.12.2016 the writ petitioner expressed its intention to step
down from the tender and soon thereafter that is on 07.12.2016 the
respondent Commissioners have issued the letter of termination with
immediate effect following the provisions of the Instruction to Bidders.
Page 10 of 19

16. For effective adjudication of the instant writ petition this Court further
considers that the relevant portion of the letter dated 07.12.2016 is required to
be looked into and the same is also quoted hereinbelow:
“You have yet neither deposited Performance Security
nor executed the Agreement.
You have prayed to step down from this tender on
humanitarian ground.
Under the circumstances, the contract awarded to you
is hereby terminated with immediate effect following the
provisions in the instructions to bidders.”
17. On careful perusal of the aforementioned quoted portion of the letter of
termination dated 07 . 12.0216 as issued by the respondent Commissioners, it
appears to this Court that the respondent Commissioners in such letter of
termination made specific reference in respect of the Instruction to Bidders and
categorically indicated immediate termination of the contract following the
provisions of the said Instruction to Bidders which permits the respondent
Commissioners to forfeit the EMD in case the awardee of the tender fails to
fulfill his obligation regarding signing of agreement and submission of
performance security/ guarantee.
18. At this juncture, the moot question arises for consideration before this
Court is as to whether the respondent Commissioners are at all entitled to
forfeit the EMD amount as submitted by the writ petitioner company at the
time of submission of the bid following the provisions of the Instruction to
Bidders and further as to whether Section 74 of the Contract Act shall have a
prevailing effect over the Instruction to Bidders.
Page 11 of 19

19. In order to answer the aforementioned legal question/ questions as
involved in the instant writ petition this Court at the very outset proposes to
look to the law of the land in this regard. In the reported decision of National
Highways Authority of India (Supra) the Hon’ble Supreme Court while
dealing with an identical situation expressed the following view:
“ 2. Briefly stated, the facts are as follows:
The appellant issued a tender notice calling for tenders
for collection of toll on a portion of the highway running
through Rajasthan. The last date of submission of bid was
31-7-1997. It was also provided that toll plazas would be
got completed by the authority and handed over to the
selected enterprise. There were two types of securities to be
furnished, one being a bid security in an amount of Rs 50
lakhs (Rupees fifty lakhs only); the other was a performance
security by way of a bank guarantee of Rs 2 crores (Rupees
two crores only). Clauses 7.1 to 8 deal with bid security.
They read as under:
“7. Bid security
7.1. The bidder shall furnish, as a part of his bid, a bid
security in an amount of Rs 50 lakhs (Rupees fifty lakhs
only), or an equivalent amount in a freely convertible
currency. The bid security shall, at the bidder's option, be in
the form of a bank draft, or guarantee from a bank located
in India. The bank guarantee shall be in the form of bank
guarantee for bid security included herein, valid for 150
days after the last date for submission of the bid.
………….
7.5. The bid security may be forfeited:
(a) if the bidder withdraws his bid during the period of
bid validity; or
(b) in case the successful bidder fails within the specified
period to
(i) furnish the required performance security; and
(ii) sign the agreement
Page 12 of 19

*
9. In our view, the High Court fell in error in so holding.
By invoking the bank guarantee and/or enforcing the bid
security, there is no statutory right, exercise of which was
being fettered. There is no term in the contract which is
contrary to the provisions of the Indian Contract Act. The
Indian Contract Act merely provides that a person can
withdraw his offer before its acceptance. But withdrawal of
an offer, before it is accepted, is a completely different
aspect from forfeiture of earnest/security money which has
been given for a particular purpose. A person may have a
right to withdraw his offer but if he has made his offer on a
condition that some earnest money will be forfeited for not
entering into contract or if some act is not performed, then
even though he may have a right to withdraw his offer, he
has no right to claim that the earnest/security be returned
to him. Forfeiture of such earnest/security, in no way,
affects any statutory right under the Indian Contract Act.
Such earnest/security is given and taken to ensure that a
contract comes into existence. It would be an anomalous
situation that a person who, by his own conduct, precludes
the coming into existence of the contract is then given
advantage or benefit of his own wrong by not allowing
forfeiture. It must be remembered that, particularly in
government contracts, such a term is always included in
order to ensure that only a genuine party makes a bid. If
such a term was not there even a person who does not have
the capacity or a person who has no intention of entering
into the contract will make a bid. The whole purpose of such
a clause i.e. to see that only genuine bids are received
would be lost if forfeiture was not permitted.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
20. While adopting the view taken by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case
of National Highways Authority of India (Supra), the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in a subsequent decision namely; Malik Traders (Supra) expressed the
following view:
Page 13 of 19

“ 2. .......As required by the terms and conditions of the bid,
all the bidders, including the respondent, deposited the bid
security of Rs 20 lakhs in the form of bank guarantee or
FDR in favour of the Executive Engineer. ....
3. In Para 10 of the offer/bid, the respondent also agreed
that the full value of bid security would be forfeited
without prejudice to any other right or remedy available to
the Executive Engineer or his successor in office or his
representative, should the respondent withdraw or modify
its bid/offer after the last date and time for the receipt of
bids, during the period of bid validity (90 days) or
extended validity period.
*
5. Thereafter, a letter of acceptance dated 26-11-2008 was
issued to the respondent, M/s Malik Traders who was the
second highest bidder. As per Condition 6 of the said letter
of acceptance, the respondent was required to deposit the
security amount and the first instalment within 21 days
from the receipt of the letter of acceptance. However, the
respondent failed to deposit the security amount and the
first instalment as required by the letter of acceptance.
Hence, vide Memo No. 5029 dated 17-12-2008 issued by
the Executive Engineer, Provincial Division No. III, PWD,
B&R Branch, Karnal, the letter of acceptance was
cancelled and withdrawn and the bid security of Rs 20
lakhs was forfeited.
6. It has to be mentioned that before receipt of the letter of
acceptance, the respondent had sent a letter dated 15-11-
2008 informing the Executive Engineer that the respondent
was not interested in the work and, therefore, the amount
of bid security deposited on 19-9-2008 may be
refunded.....
*
11. In Para 10 of the offer/bid, the respondent had also
agreed that the full value of the bid security would be
forfeited without prejudice to any other right or remedy
available to the Executive Engineer or his successor in
office or his representative, should the respondent
withdraw or modify its offer/bid during the period of bid
validity (90 days) or extended validity period. Since the
Page 14 of 19

respondent withdrew its offer during the period of bid
validity in violation of the abovementioned agreement in
Para 8 of the offer/bid, the full value of bid security was
liable to be forfeited in terms of the agreement contained in
Para 10 of the offer/bid. Thus, even though under Section
5 of the Act a proposal may be revoked at any time before
the communication of its acceptance is complete as against
the proposer, the respondent was bound by the agreement
contained in its offer/bid to keep the bid open for
acceptance up to 90 days after the last date of receipt of
bid and if the respondent withdrew its bid before the
expiry of the said period of 90 days the respondent was
liable to suffer the consequence (i.e. forfeiture of the full
value of bid security) as agreed to by the respondent in
Para 10 of the offer/bid. Under the cover of the provisions
contained in Section 5 of the Act, the respondent cannot
escape from the obligations and liabilities under the
agreements contained in its offer/bid.
12. The right to withdraw an offer before its acceptance
cannot nullify the agreement to suffer any penalty for the
withdrawal of the offer against the terms of agreement. A
person may have a right to withdraw his offer, but if he
has made his offer on a condition that the bid security
amount can be forfeited in case he withdraws the offer
during the period of bid validity, he has no right to claim
that the bid security should not be forfeited and it should
be returned to him. Forfeiture of such bid security amount
does not, in any way, affect any statutory right under
Section 5 of the Act. The bid security was given by the
respondent and taken by the appellants to ensure that the
offer is not withdrawn during the bid validity period of 90
days and a contract comes into existence. Such conditions
are included to ensure that only genuine parties make the
bids. In the absence of such conditions, persons who do
not have the capacity or have no intention of entering into
the contract will make bids. The very purpose of such a
condition in the offer/bid will be defeated, if forfeiture is
not permitted when the offer is withdrawn in violation of
the agreement.
*
Page 15 of 19

15. Allowing the appeal, this Court held as follows:
(National Highways Authority of India case [(2003) 7 SCC
410] , SCC p. 416, para 9)
“9. In our view, the High Court fell in error in so holding.
By invoking the bank guarantee and/or enforcing the bid
security, there is no statutory right, exercise of which was
being fettered. There is no term in the contract which is
contrary to the provisions of the Contract Act, 1872. The
Contract Act merely provides that a person can withdraw
his offer before its acceptance. But withdrawal of an offer,
before it is accepted, is a completely different aspect from
forfeiture of earnest/security money which has been given
for a particular purpose. A person may have a right to
withdraw his offer but if he has made his offer on a
condition that some earnest money will be forfeited for not
entering into contract or if some act is not performed, then
even though he may have a right to withdraw his offer, he
has no right to claim that the earnest/security be returned
to him. Forfeiture of such earnest/security, in no way,
affects any statutory right under the Contract Act. Such
earnest/security is given and taken to ensure that a
contract comes into existence. It would be an anomalous
situation that a person who, by his own conduct, precludes
the coming into existence of the contract is then given
advantage or benefit of his own wrong by not allowing
forfeiture. It must be remembered that, particularly in
government contracts, such a term is always included in
order to ensure that only a genuine party makes a bid. If
such a term was not there even a person who does not
have the capacity or a person who has no intention of
entering into the contract will make a bid. The whole
purpose of such a clause i.e. to see that only genuine bids
are received would be lost if forfeiture was not permitted.”
We respectfully agree with the above view of this Court.”
[Emphasis Supplied]

21. Similar view was taken by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
National Thermal Power Corporation Ltd.(Supra) .
Page 16 of 19

22. In the event the aforementioned three reported decisions of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court are looked into conjointly, it appears to this Court that the
Hon’ble Supreme Court had granted a stamp of approval regarding forfeiture of
earnest/security money as has been given at the time of submission of bid in
the event the successful bidder withdraws his offer subsequently and in doing
so the Hon’ble Supreme Court further held that withdraw of such
earnest/security, in no way affects any statutory right under the contract. In
view of such, this Court holds that the provision of Section 74 of the Contract
Act has got no manner of application in the facts and circumstances as
involved in the instant writ petition.
23. This Court has meticulously gone through the reported decision of
Dolphin Suppliers (Supra) as passed by a Division Bench of this Court
wherein much reliance was placed upon the judgment passed by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Security Engg. (P) Ltd. (Supra), MBL
Infrastructure Ltd.(Supra), Shree Coal Enterprises of India (P) Ltd.
(Supra) and Kailash Nath Associates . It appears to this Court that the
judgment of Dolphin Suppliers (Supra) is distinguishable from the facts and
circumstances of the instant case since the subject matter as involved in the
said appeal was setting aside of cancellation of sale of a landed property
pursuant to an e-auction initiated by SEBI upon acceptance of the remaining
consideration.
24. It further appears to this Court that the perspective of the reported
decision of Security Engg.(Supra) is also different since on account of COVID
Page 17 of 19

pandemic the successful bidder could not act in terms and conditions of the
work order as he could not complete and/or foresee the adverse effect of such
pandemic. It further appears to this Court that the facts and circumstances as
involved in MBL Infrastructure Ltd. (Supra) are equally distinguishable from
the facts and circumstances as involved in the instant writ petition inasmuch
as the legal question as involved in the said case was on account of a material
concealment and/or material non-disclosure, the forfeiture clause would
become applicable or not. The reported decision of Shree Coal Enterprises of
India (P) Ltd.(Supra) equally has no manner of application since the subject
matter of dispute was with regard to the non-refund of the EMD against alleged
non-lifting of two racks of coal purchased by the writ petitioner company. The
reported decision of Kailash Nath Associates (Supra) is also not applicable in
view of the fact that in the said judgment the Hon’ble Supreme Court laid down
the law relating to law on compensation for breach of contract under Section
74 of the Contract Act.
25. It thus appears to this Court that the writ petitioner company has
miserably failed to make out a case that the facts and circumstances of the
instant writ petition comes under the purview of Section 74 of the Contract Act
wherein the party complaining of a breach is entitled to receive reasonable
compensation only if it is a genuine pre-estimate of damages fixed by both
parties and found to be such by the Court. Rather it appears to this Court that
the stand taken by the respondent Commissioners by way of defense is in
accordance with law laid down in the case of National Highways Authority
Page 18 of 19

(Supra), National Thermal Power Corporation Ltd.(Supra) and Malik
Traders (Supra) wherein it has been consistently held by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court that in the event a bidder participates in a bid knowing fully well that in
case he becomes successful in such bid and subsequently, fails within the
stipulated period to furnish the required performance security and sign the
agreement in that event the said successful bidder may have a right to
withdraw his offer however, he has no right to claim that the earnest money/
security to be returned to him.
26. In view of the discussion made hereinabove this Court thus finds no
merit in the instant writ petition.
27. Accordingly, the instant writ petition is dismissed.
28. With the dismissal of the instant writ petition, the interim order, if there
be any, stands hereby vacated.
29. All pending interlocutory applications, if there be any, are also dismissed.
30. There shall be no order as to cost.
31. Urgent photostat certified copy of this judgement, if applied for, be given
to the parties on completion of usual formalities.


(PARTHA SARATHI SEN, J.)

Page 19 of 19