SHRI. D. NARASIMHA RAO vs STATE BY
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
R
TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.P.SANDESH
WRIT PETITION NO.6422 OF 2022 (GM-RES)
C/W
CRIMINAL PETITION NO.9900 OF 2017
CRIMINAL PETITION NO.2351 OF 2022
WRIT PETITION NO.2785 OF 2022 (GM-RES)
IN W.P. No.6422/2022:
BETWEEN:
1. SHRI. D. NARASIMHA RAO
S/O LATE KONDAIAH
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS
PROP. M/S. CHITHRITHA ENTERPRISES
R/AT C/O SHRI. BALAPRAKASH
BEHIND RAMA TEMPLE, K.G.HALLI
BENGALURU-560 015.
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. SHANKAR M. NAIK, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. STATE BY
CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
ANTI-CORRUPTION BRANCH
NO.36, BELLARY ROAD, GANGANAGAR
BENGALURU-560032.
REP. BY SPECIAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
K.G.I.D. BUILDING
BENGALURU-560001.
2. SHRI. G.C. MOTALLI
DY. GENERAL MANAGER
SYNDICATE BANK
Digitally signed
by DEVIKA M
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
REGIONAL OFFICE-NORTH
BENGALURU-560 015.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI P. PRASANNA KUMAR, SPECIAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
FOR R1
SRI. T.P. MUTHANNA, ADVOCATE FOR R2)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO
QUASH THE ENTIRE PROCEEDINGS PENDING IN SPL. CC
NO.481/2017, ON THE FILE OF THE LEARNED XXI ADDL. CITY
CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE AND PRL. SPL. JUDGE FOR CBI
CASES, BENGALURU CITY, WHICH IS REGISTERED AGAINST
THE PETITIONER FOR THE OFFENCES PUNISHABLE UNDER
SECTIONS 120B R/W 409, 420, 467, 468 AND 471 OF IPC AND
SECTION 13(2) R/W 13(1)(C) AND (D) OF THE PC ACT 1988,
ANNEXURE-C.
IN CRL.P NO. 9900/2017:
BETWEEN:
1. S. NARAYAN SHASTRY
S/O LATE SHAMA SHASTRY
AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS
SA-5, SUNDER KUNJA APARTMENTS
TH
8 MAIN, BINNY LAYOUT
VIJAYANAGAR
BENGALURU-560 040.
...PETITIONER
(BY SRI. S.G. BHAGWAN, ADVOCTATE)
AND:
1. G.C. MATOLLI
MAJOR
DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER
SYNDICATE BANK
REGIONAL OFFICE-NORTH
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
NO.110, RADHA VITTALA MANSION
R.V. ROAD, V.V. PURAM
BENGALURU-560 004.
2. DR. SUBRAMANYESWARA RAO A.,
MAJOR,
SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE AND
OFFICER-INCHARGE OF THE POLICE STATION
AND HEAD OF THE BRANCH,
CBI, ACB, NO.36, BELLARY ROAD
GANGANAGAR
BENGALURU-56032.
3. RAKESH RANJAN
MAJOR
INSPECTOR OF POLICE, CBI/ACB/BLR
36, BELLARY ROAD, GANGANAGAR
BENGALURU-560 032.
4. CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
CBI/ACB/BLR
ANTI CORRUPTION BRANCH
REPRESENTED BY
DR. SUBRAMANYESWARA RAO A,
SUPERINTENDIENT OF POLICE
AND HEAD OF BRANCH
NO.36, BELLARY ROAD
GANGANAGAR
BENGALURU-560 032.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. T.P. MUTHANNA, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
SRI. P.PRASANNA KUMAR, SPECIAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
FOR R2 TO R4)
THIS CRIMINAL PETITION IS FILED UNDER SECTION
482 OF CR.P.C. PRAYING TO QUASH THE ENTIRE
PROCEEDINGS IN SPECIAL C.C.NO.481/2017 PENDING IN
THE COURT OF THE XXI ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND
SESSIONS JUDGE AND SPECIAL JUDGE FOR CBI CASES,
BENGALURU (CCH-4).
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
IN CRL.P NO.2351/2022:
BETWEEN:
1. SRI. GURU RAJ K
PRO. M/S. SRI GURU PRECISION
TECHNOLOGIES
S/O K.P. PANDURANGA
AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS
R/AT NO.2052
GURU KRUPA NILAYA
OPP. MOSQUE, KAMMANAHALLI
JALAHALLI WEST
BANGALORE-560015.
2. SRI. MANOHAR S
PRO. M/S. GAMAN TECHNOLOGIES
S/O SUBBAIAH M
AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS
R/AT NO.62/2,
10TH MAIN, 6TH CROSS,
RAGHAVENDRA TEMPLE
MAIN ROAD, K.G. HALLI
JALAHALLI WEST
BANGALORE-560015.
3. SMT. T.M. THULASI
W/O T.M. KONDAIAH
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
PROPRIETOR
M/S UNIVERSAL HYDRAULIC HOUSES
R/AT NO.30,. K G HALLI
JALAHALLI WEST,
BANGALORE-560015.
...PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. RAJESH A, ADVOCATE)
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
AND:
1. THE CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
BY THE STATION HOUSE OFFICER
ACB POLICE STATION, BANGALORE-560001
REP. BY SPECIAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, CBI
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
BANGALORE-560001.
2. SRI. G.C. MOTALLI
DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER
SYNDICATE BANK
REGIONAL OFFICE
BANGALORE-560015.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. T.P. MUTHANNA, ADVOCATE FOR R2
SRI. P. PRASANNA KUMAR, SPECIAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
FOR R1)
THIS CRIMINAL PETITION IS FILED UNDER SECTION
482 OF CR.P.C. PRAYING TO QUASH THE CRIMINAL
PROCEEDINGS IN SPL.C.NO.481/2017
(FIR.NO.RC.3(A)/2016) AGAINST THE PETITIONERS
HEREIN FOR AN OFFENCE PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTION
120(B) R/W 420, 468, 471 OF IPC AND SECTIONS 7, 8, 12
AND 13(2) R/W 13(1)(d) OF PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION
ACT, REGISTERED BY THE C.B.I., A.C.B., BENGALURU ON
THE FILE OF PRINCIPAL SPECIAL JUDGE FOR CBI CASES
AND XXI ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE,
BENGALURU.
IN W.P. NO.2785/2022:
BETWEEN:
1. SHRI. SRINIVASALU N.P.
S/O N. PULLAIAH
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
R/AT NO.14
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
ANAND NAGARA
VENKATESHWARA LAYOUT
MAHADEVAPURA
BANGALORE-560048.
2. SMT. PADMA K.,
W/O SRI. S. TIRUPATHI REDDY
AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS
TH
R/AT NO.30, 6 CROSS
KALA NAGAR ROAD
K.G.HALLI, JALAHALLI WEST
BANGALORE-560015.
3. SRI. M. RAGHURAM
S/O SRI. PEDHARAMULU
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS
R/AT NO.4 AND 5
ST
1 CROSS, BALAJI ENCALVE
PIPELINE ROAD, KEMPAPURA
CHIKKABANAVARA POST
BANGALORE-60090.
4. SRI. S. SRINIVASALU
S/O SRI. MALAKONDIAH
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
ND
R/AT 69/A, 2 CROSS
TH
11 MAIN ROAD,
KALA NAGAR
KAMMANAGONDNAHALLI
JALAHALLI WEST
BANGALORE-560015.
5. SRI. C. VENKATESHWARALU
S/O CHINNAIAH
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS
TH
R/AT NO.23, 5 MAIN
NEAR SDA HIGH SCHOOL
K.G. HALLI, JALAHALLI WEST
BANGALORE-560015.
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
6. SRI. MADHU BABU
S/O MALAKONDAIAH TUMATI
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
R/AT NO.62, BEL COLONY
JALAHALLI
BANGALORE 560013.
...PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. P.N. HEGDE, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. MANJUNATH R., ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
ACB, GANGENAHALLI
INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT ROAD
BANGALORE 560032.
2. SYNDICATE BANK
REGIONAL OFFICE NORTH
JALAHALLI, BANGALORE-560015
REP. BY ITS BRANCH MANAGER.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. PRASANNA KUMAR P, SPECIAL PUBLIC
PROSECUTOR FOR R1)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA R/W SECTION
482 OF THE CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE, 1973,
PRAYING TO QUASH THE IMPUGNED ORDER OF TAKING
COGNIZANCE DATED 21.9.2017 IN SPL. C.C.NO.481/2017
PASSED BY THE HON’BLE XLVII ADDL. CITY CIVIL AND
SESSIONS JUDGE, BANGALORE (CCH-48), SPL. JUDGE,
CBI CASES, PRODUCED HERETO AS ANNEXURE-A AND TO
CONSEQUENTLY QUASH THE CHARGE SHEET DATED
21.8.2017 AND ENTIRE PROCEEDINGS IN SPL.
C.C.NO.481/2017 PASSED BY THE HON’BLE XLVII ADDL.
CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE, BANGALORE (CCH-48),
SPL. JUDGE, CBI CASES, PRODUCED HERETO AS
ANNEXURE-B.
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
THESE PETITIONS COMING ON FOR FURTHER HEARING
THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.P.SANDESH
ORAL ORDER
Heard learned counsels for the petitioners, learned
counsel for the CBI and learned counsels for the complainant.
2. The factual matrix of case of the complainant and
also CBI while filing the charge sheet against these petitioners
is that petitioner in Crl.P.No.9900/2017 is the former bank
employee, who retired from service at the time of this
transaction. However, in connivance with the Manager i.e.,
accused No.1, he pursued the loan application of some of the
accused persons and collected an amount of Rs.15,000/- and
thereafter, having sanctioned the amount in favour of the
borrowers, he had collected commission amount of
Rs.1,00,000/- and to that effect, one of the accused made the
statement before the learned Magistrate under Section 164 of
Cr.P.C. and other borrowers also made the statement before
the CBI that he had collected Rs.1,00,000/- as commission.
Hence, he has been arraigned as accused No.26.
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
3. The petitioner in W.P.No.6422/2022 is accused
No.17, who had filed an application for discharge and his
application was rejected and thereafter, he had invoked the
provisions under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. The allegation against
this petitioner is that he is also a borrower and creating the
fake documents at the instance of accused No.2, borrowed the
loan from the bank.
4. The petitioners in Crl.P.No.2351/2022 are arraigned
as accused Nos.7, 19 and 21, who are also the borrowers and
based on the created bills, they also borrowed loan from the
bank in connivance with accused No.1-Bank Manager and so
also, the petitioners in W.P.Nos.2785/2022 are arraigned as
accused Nos.5, 8, 13, 16, 18 and 20, who are also the
borrowers and similar allegations are made against these
accused persons as well, except the petitioner in
Crl.P.No.9900/2017, who is an ex-employee of the Bank.
5. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner in
Crl.P.No.9900/2017 i.e., accused No.26 would vehemently
contend that no substantive piece of material is collected
against this petitioner, who was a retired employee of the Bank
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
and he retired from service in 2011 as Manager of Syndicate
Bank. The counsel would vehemently contend that when no
substantive piece of material collected against him, there
cannot be criminal prosecution against this petitioner.
6. Learned counsel appearing for the Central Bureau of
Investigation would submit that accused No.25 made statement
before the learned Magistrate under Section 164 of Cr.P.C. that
he made payment of Rs.1,00,000/- as commission to accused
No.26 and in connivance with accused No.1, he had played his
role in getting the loan in favour of the accused. The counsel
also would vehemently contend that there was conspiracy
between the accused as well as Bank Manager, who had been
arraigned as accused No.1. The counsel also would vehemently
contend that he had also indulged in introducing other
borrowers in opening the account and he had played his role in
getting the loan and commission. The statement of C.Ws.30
and 38 was also recorded before the CBI that they have also
given the amount to him. The counsel would vehemently
contend that he had not filed any discharge application before
the Trial Court, since he had approached this Court by filing a
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
petition in the year 2017 and since, there was stay, he did not
file any discharge application.
7. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner in
Crl.P.No.2351/2022 in his argument would vehemently contend
that the petitioners in this petition, who are arraigned as
accused Nos.7, 19 and 21 are also the borrowers of loan and
invoked the offence under Sections 120(B) and 420 of IPC and
the fact that accused No.1 had advanced the loan in favour of
these accused persons is not in dispute. The counsel also would
vehemently contend that before advancing the loan amount,
legal opinion was also taken by the bank and based on the legal
opinion itself, accused No.1 had advanced the loan in favour of
these accused persons. The counsel also would vehemently
contend that Bank Manager is also arraigned as accused No.1.
The counsel would vehemently contend that the account of
accused Nos.7, 19 and 21 are regular and they have not
committed any default in payment of the loan amount. The
counsel also would vehemently contend that they have cleared
entire loan amount with interest. Hence, there was no intention
to cheat the bank and under ‘One Time Settlement’, dues to the
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
bank are cleared. As a result, DRT proceedings initiated against
the petitioners was also withdrawn after the payment.
8. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners in
W.P.No.2785/2022 would contend that account of accused
Nos.5 and 13 was made as NPA, but accused Nos.8, 16, 18 and
20 were regular in payment of loan amount. The counsel also
brought to notice of this Court the document for having given
endorsement by the bank itself that they have made entire
payment and no arrears of loan amount. The settlement was
also made before framing of charge.
9. Though the petition in W.P.6422/2022 is listed for
consideration, the counsel is not regularly appearing before the
Court. Hence, taken as no argument of counsel appearing for
the petitioner, since this petition was filed in 2022 and not
pursuing the matter.
10. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the CBI in
his argument would vehemently contend that though the
petitioners made the payment subsequently and the same is
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
not made before initiation of criminal prosecution against the
petitioners. The counsel also would submit that these
petitioners along with other borrowers have indulged in taking
fake bills which was issued by accused No.2. Having availed the
loan from the bank, the said amount was paid to accused No.2,
consequent upon the loan advanced by the bank. The counsel
would vehemently contend that the borrowers, the Bank
Manager and also the accused No.2 have duped the bank. The
bank also conducted an enquiry before lodging the complaint.
The counsel also would vehemently contend that the material
supplied is not the material as mentioned in the fake bills and
on enquiry, came to know that different machineries were
supplied. The counsel also would vehemently contend that
complaint was filed in 2016 and the CBI had investigated the
matter and filed the charge sheet in 2017 itself.
11. The counsel would submit that even though
payments are made subsequently after registration of the case,
but during the course of investigation, collected 525 documents
and those documents are very clear that those documents are
fake documents. The counsel would vehemently contend that
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
during the course of investigation, the CBI unearthed the truth
that based on the fake documents itself, loan amounts are
disbursed in their favour. Hence, it is very clear that, at the
time of creation of bills i.e., at the inception itself, they had an
intention to cheat the bank. The counsel also submits that in
Crl.P.No.2351/2022, though the petitioners therein have not
filed the discharge application, but the counsel argued the
matter before framing of charge and raised all these grounds.
The counsel would vehemently contend that in
W.P.No.2785/2022 filed an application for discharge and same
is dismissed. The counsel brought to notice of this Court order
passed by the Trial Court, wherein reasons are given while
dismissing the application for discharge. Hence, it is a fit case
to go on for trial and there are prima facie material that the
borrowers had indulged in creation of documents at the
instance of accused No.2 as well as accused No.1 and availed
the loan from the bank based on the fake documents. Hence,
there cannot be quashing of proceedings under Section 482 of
Cr.P.C.
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
12. The counsel for the petitioners in
W.P.No.2785/2022, in support of his argument relied upon the
judgment of the Apex Court in SURESH C. SINGAL AND
OTHERS vs. STATE OF GUJARAT AND OTHERS reported in
2025 SCC ONLINE SC 788 and brought to notice of this Court
paragraph Nos.2, 3, 4, 5 and 7. So also, paragraph Nos.14, 15
and 20, wherein discussion was made with regard to that the
dispute involved is primarily of civil nature with regard to the
advancing of loan amount and payment is concerned. In
paragraph No.22, judgment of Narinder Singh was also taken
note of and the Apex Court held that in cases where charge is
framed but the evidence is not yet started or is at the infancy
stage, the High Court may exercise its powers by showing
benevolence after prima facie assessment of circumstances and
material mentioned and when there was already a settlement
between the parties, the aggrieved party, if any, would have
been the Bank which has no grievance against the Appellants,
Further, no loss has been caused to the Bank as is apparent
from the calculations presented by the appellants before this
Court and in One Time Settlement, entire dues are received.
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
13. The counsel also relied upon judgment of the Apex
Court in TARINA SEN vs. UNION OF INDIA AND ANOTHER
reported in 2024 SCC Online SC 2696 and brought to notice
of this Court discussion made in paragraph Nos.3.7, 3.8, 3.9
and 3.10, wherein also exercising the power under Section 482
of Cr.P.C., the High Court, vide the orders impugned in the
present appeals disposed of the applications under Section 482
of Cr.P.C. by permitting the appellants herein to urge all the
pleas raised in their application before the trial Court at the
appropriate stage. Being aggrieved thereby, the present
appeals arises and particularly, in paragraph Nos.14 and 15
exercised the powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C. and relying
upon on the earlier judgments, held that in the matters arising
out of commercial, financial, mercantile, civil, partnership or
such like transactions or the offences arising out of matrimony
relating to dowry, etc. or family disputes where the wrong is
basically private or personal in nature and the parties have
resolved their entire dispute, the High Court should exercise its
powers under Section 482 CrPC for giving an end to the
criminal proceedings. In paragraph No.11, the Apex Court
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
observed that it is not in dispute that the matter has been
compromised between the borrowers and the bank. It has also
not been in dispute that, upon payment of the amount under
the OTS, the loan account of the borrower has been closed.
14. The counsel also relied upon judgment of the Apex
Court in VIJAY KUMAR KELA AND ANOTHER vs. CERNTRAL
BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION AND ANOTHER reported in
2026 SCC ONLINE SC 1003 and brought to notice of this
Court discussion made in paragraph No.3 as well as paragraph
No.5.1 and so also, paragraph No.7, wherein also CBI
registered FIR and investigated the matter invoking offence
under Section 420 IPC and Section 13(2) read with Section
13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and also
discussion was made in paragraph No.8 that CBI filed charge
sheet and also brought to notice of this Court settlement
arrived between the parties in paragraph No.11.7 referring to
the compromise settlement dated 30.03.2015 and the same
was unconditional and was approved by the UCO Bank's highest
authority and discussion was made in paragraph No.11.8, it is
submitted that a purely civil dispute which had resulted in a
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
settlement was belatedly sought to be given a criminal colour
by the UCO Bank. The counsel also brought to notice of this
Court discussion made summarizing the facts in the said case
and also reasoning given in paragraph Nos.16 and 17, the
question is, whether, in a case of this nature, the offences
under Section 420 and 471 IPC can be said to have been made
out against the appellants when the subject transaction was a
banking one which ultimately led to a compromise settlement
approved by the competent authority of the bank and which
had the imprimatur of the DRT. However, this issue need not
detain us since we are focusing on the larger question of
permissibility of continuance of criminal prosecution which was
set in motion after settlement of the loan account on
compromise between the borrower (appellants) and the Bank
and which had the endorsement of the DRT. This judgment is
also relied upon by learned counsel appearing for the CBI
referring paragraph No.18, wherein also NIKHIL MERCHANT
VS. CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION reported in
(2008) 9 SCC 677, wherein also CBI filed the charge sheet
invoking the offence under Section 120B read with Sections
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
420, 467, 468, 471 of IPC read with Section 5(2) and 5(1)(d)
of the Prevention of Corruption Act, wherein also discussion
was made that Andhra Bank filed a suit for recovery and also
lodged a complaint before the CBI which led to registration of
FIR and filing of charge sheet in the Court of the Special Judge.
In paragraph No.18.2 discussed that this Court has observed
that the dispute between the company and Andhra Bank was
set at rest on the basis of the compromise arrived at by them
whereunder the dues of Andhra Bank were cleared and in
paragraph No.19, discussed the correctness of the view taken
in Nikhil Merchant and two other cases was doubted by a
subsequent coordinate Bench whereafter the matter was
referred to a larger bench. In GIAN SINGH vs. STATE OF
PUNJAB reported in (2012) 10 SCC 303, the appellant was
convicted under Sections 420 and 120B IPC. During pendency
of the appeal against his conviction, appellant filed an
application for compounding the offence. Thereafter, appellant
also filed a petition under Section 482 CrPC for quashing of the
FIR on the ground of compounding the offence. The petition
under Section 482 CrPC was dismissed by the High Court and
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
hence, approached the High Court. In paragraph No.19,
considered the judgment of the Apex Court in Nikhil Merchant
and other two cases was doubted by a subsequent coordinate
Bench whereafter the matter was referred to a larger Bench
and also Narinder Singh case was also discussed in paragraph
No.20. So also, the Apex Court in paragraph Nos.16.8, 23.1,
23.2 and 23.3 taken note of the judgments as well as the
settlement arrived between the parties and DRT also recorded
that the dispute was settled in full satisfaction of the dues of
the respondent-Indian Bank.
15. Learned counsel appearing for the CBI also relied
upon the very same judgment referring paragraph No.23.2. If
the charges were proved, those would be grave crimes against
the society as a whole and hence merely due to a private
settlement between the Bank and the accused, it cannot be
said that the prosecution of the accused persons would amount
to abuse of the process of the court.
16. Apart from that learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners in Crl.P.No.2351/2022 relied upon judgment of the
Apex Court in K. BHARTHI DEVI AND ANOTHER vs. STATE
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
OF TELANGANA AND ANOTHER reported in 2024 INSC 750
and brought to notice of this Court principles laid down in the
judgment, wherein also Nikhil Merchant’s case was also
discussed, particularly in paragraph Nos.34 and 39, while
exercising the power under Section 482 Cr.P.C. taken note of
after receipt of the amount under OTS, the Bank had also
decided to close the loan account. The dispute involved
predominantly had overtures of a civil dispute and allowed the
petition and quashed the same.
17. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners in
Crl.P.No.2351/2022 also relied upon details of loan released,
particularly bringing it to the notice of the Court that account
was regular in respect of M/s. Sri Guru Precision and in case of
M/s. Gaman Technologies is concerned, regular but only two
installments are due. So also, in respect of M/s. Universal
Hydraulic, account was regular, but more than 2 installments
are due. Similarly, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners
in W.P.No.2785/2022 also would submit that accounts were
regular, except accused Nos.5 and 8.
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
18. Learned counsel appearing for the CBI relied upon
judgment of the Apex Court in MURALI vs. STATE
REPRESENTED BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE reported in
(2021) 1 SCC 726, particularly brought to notice of this Court
paragraph No.11 that in later decisions including in RAM LAL
vs. STATE OF JAMMU AND KASHMIR, BANKAT vs. STATE
OF MAHARASHTRA, MOHAR SINGH vs. STATE OF
RAJASTHAN, NANDA GOPALAN vs. STATE OF KERALA,
SHANKAR vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA, the Apex Court
held that compromise between parties to reduce the sentence
of the convicts even in serious non-compoundable offences was
discussed.
19. The counsel also relied upon judgment of the Apex
Court in CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION vs. HARI
SINGH RANKA AND OTHERS reported in (2019) 16 SCC
687 and brought to notice of this Court paragraph Nos.17 and
19, wherein Apex Court has discussed the judgment in RUMI
DHAR vs. STATE OF W.B. reported in (2009) 6 SCC 364,
wherein also observed that when settlement is arrived at
between the creditors and the debtor, the offence, if
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
committed, as such does not come to an end. Even a judgment
rendered in the civil proceedings, when it is rendered on the
basis of a settlement entered into between the parties, would
not be of large relevance as per criminal offence required of
Section 43 of the Evidence Act. The judgment of the Civil Court
is admissible only for limited purposes. The counsel also
brought to notice of this Court paragraph No.19, wherein also
discussion was made when the charge-sheet reflects that the
respondent got LCs issued by the Bank in favour of fictitious
companies propped up by them and the fictitious beneficiary
companies had got letters of credits discounted by attaching
their bogus bills. It is not a simple case where an accused has
borrowed money from the bank and diverted it somewhere else
and, thereafter, paid the amount. Civil settlement of the
controversy would not suffice to wipe off the criminal liability.
20. The counsel also relied upon judgment of the Apex
Court in PARBATBHAI AAHIR ALIAS PARBATBHAI
BHIMSINHBHAI KARMUR AND OTHERS vs. STATE OF
GUJARAT AND ANOTHER reported in (2017) 9 SCC 641 and
brought to notice of this Court paragraph Nos.16 and 16.10,
- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
wherein the Apex Court discussed with regard to there is yet an
exception to the principle set out in propositions 16.8 and 16.9
above. Economic offences involving the financial and economic
well-being of the State have implications which lie beyond the
domain of a mere dispute between the private disputants. The
High Court would be justified in declining to quash where the
offender is involved in an activity akin to a financial or
economic fraud or misdemeanour. The consequences of the act
complained of upon the financial or economic system will weigh
in the balance.
21. The counsel also relied upon judgment of the Apex
Court in CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION vs.
SARVODAYA HIGHWAYS LTD. AND OTHERS reported in
2025 SCC ONLINE SC 2598 and brought to notice of this
Court discussion made by the Apex Court in paragraph No.23,
wherein it was observed that it is apparent that while quashing
the proceedings on the basis of One Time Settlement, the High
Court failed to advert to the vital facts of the case as narrated
in point Nos.(i) to (iv) and also observation is made that while
exercising the jurisdiction under Section 482 Cr.P.C., did not
- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
consider these vital facts and quashed the proceedings merely
on the basis of the alleged one-time settlement. The counsel
brought to notice of this Court that quashing of the proceedings
initiated for criminal action, that too when it is serious in
nature, there cannot be quashing. Hence, prays this Court to
continue the proceedings and mere making payment by the
borrowers cannot be a ground to quash the proceedings.
22. Having heard the respective counsels and also the
principles laid down in the judgments referred supra and also
taking note of factual aspects of the cases, the points that
would arise for consideration of this Court are:
(1) Whether the petitioner in Crl.P.No.9900/2017
has made out the ground to invoke Section
482 of Cr.P.C. to quash the charge sheet filed
against him, who has been arraigned as
accused No.26?
(2) Whether the petitioners in W.P.No.2785/2022
and Crl.P.No.2351/2022 have made out the
grounds to quash the proceedings in view of
payment made by them subsequent to filing
of charge sheet and whether this Court can
invoke Section 482 of Cr.P.C.?
- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
(3) Whether the petitioner in W.P.No.6422/2022,
who has been arraigned as accused No.17
has made out the ground to invoke Section
482 of Cr.P.C. to quash the proceedings?
(4) What order?
POINT NO.(1)- CRL.P.NO.9900/2017
23. The very contention of learned counsel appearing
for the petitioner is that he was a retired employee and no
substantive piece of evidence and material is collected against
this petitioner and he was retired from service in 2011 and at
the time of this transaction also, he was not in the bank and he
was worked as a Manager of Syndicate Bank. Hence, there
cannot be any criminal prosecution. On the other hand, it is the
contention of learned counsel appearing for the CBI that
C.Ws.30 and 38 made the statement before the CBI-police that
both of them made the payment to this petitioner and he had
collected the amount of Rs.1,00,000/- as commission. Apart
from that, counsel appearing for the petitioner would submit
that accused No.25 also made the statement before the learned
Magistrate under Section 164 of Cr.P.C. that he had collected
- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
an amount of Rs.15,000/- for paper work and thereafter,
collected an amount of Rs.1,00,000/- as commission, out of his
demand of Rs.2,00,000/- and the same is reiterated in his 164
statement and he has also not filed any discharge application.
24. No doubt, this petitioner had approached this Court
earlier in 2017 immediately after filing of the charge sheet, but
having taken note of contention of learned counsel appearing
for the petitioner that he worked as Manager and he has retired
from service in 2011, he was not working in the bank in which
the loan was advanced as on the date of transaction. But,
specific allegations are made against him that even though he
was retired from service, he had indulged in contacting accused
No.1 to pursue the loan papers and during the course of
investigation also, his handwriting was collected by the CBI.
Apart from that, when 164 statement of the accused was
recorded before the learned Magistrate, no doubt, the same is
not a substantive piece of evidence, but, in order to face the
criminal proceedings, the Court has to look into 164 statement
as well as statement made by C.Ws.30 and 38, wherein they
categorically made the statement that they made the payment
- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
in connection with this transaction. When such being the case,
it is not a case for invoking Section 482 of Cr.P.C. to quash the
proceedings when materials are collected during investigation
and whether there was substantive piece of evidence or not is a
matter of trial and the grounds which have been urged before
this Court can be urged during the course of trial.
25. The Court has to look into the material collected at
the time of investigation and if material discloses prima facie
case, particularly taking into note of 164 statement of accused
No.25, who made the statement before the learned Magistrate
that he made the payment of Rs.1,00,000/- as commission and
apart from that, C.Ws.30 and 38 also made the statement that
they made the payment, matter requires trial. Hence, no
ground is made out by the petitioner in Crl.P.No.9900/2017 to
invoke Section 482 of Cr.P.C. to quash the proceedings.
Therefore, I answer Point No.(1) accordingly.
POINT NO.(2)-W.P.NO.2785/2022 & CRL.P.NO.2351/2022
26. This point is in respect of accused Nos.5, 8, 13, 16,
18 and 20 and so also, accused Nos.7, 19 and 21. The
- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
argument of both the counsels is similar that subsequent to
filing of the charge sheet, though discharge application was
dismissed, they made the payment. In support of their
contention also, produced the document i.e., endorsement
issued by the bank. Learned counsel for the bank also not
dispute the fact that it was settled in One Time Settlement.
However, learned counsel for the CBI and learned counsel for
the bank would contend that it is a serious offence, since the
petitioners have created the documents, even though no such
bills for having supplied the material and on the basis of the
created documents, loans are availed and the same requires to
be considered during the course of investigation. Even though
payments are made in respect of the criminal act is concerned,
all the petitioners are to be penalized.
27. In support of his argument, learned counsel for the
CBI also relied upon the judgment of the Apex Court in
Murali’s case, Hari Singh’s case and also Parbatbhai
Aahir’s case, wherein the Apex Court while discussing in case
of offences of criminal nature, lenience cannot be shown and
when the criminal offences are invoked, it requires the trial.
- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
28. No doubt, learned counsel appearing for the CBI
also brought to notice of this Court Sarvodaya Highways
Ltd.’s case, wherein the Apex Court discussed regarding
payment is concerned, particularly in paragraph No.23 it is
observed that there was a specific finding in the charge sheet
that the defaulter company through its directors had submitted
fabricated documents and misrepresented to the bank for the
purpose of procuring the cash credit facility and on the basis of
the evidence collected during the investigation, found that the
offences of criminal conspiracy, fabrication of documents, and
offences under the PC Act, were clearly made out. So also, the
sanction for prosecution had been duly issued and that the
amount of settlement under the One-Time Settlement did not
cover the actual amount due to the bank and that there was a
deficit of more than 5 crores plus interest which was a direct
loss to the public exchequer. The counsel also brought to notice
of this Court paragraph No.26, wherein it is observed that the
liability was of Rs.52 crores, but it was settled for only an
amount of Rs.41 crores as One-Time Settlement are, as a rule,
effected under the circumstances where the bank under duress
- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
is compelled to accept lesser amount in order to secure the
maximum possible recovery against the defaulting account.
29. The counsel appearing for the petitioner referring
the recent judgment of the Apex Court in Vijay Kumar Kela’s
case brought to notice of this Court detailed discussion made
wherein the Apex Court taken note of the judgment in
K.Bharthi Devi’s case which was referred by learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner in W.P.No.2351/2022, wherein the
counsel relied upon paragraph No.23 and the said judgment
was also relied upon by learned counsel the CBI. No doubt, if
the charges are proved, they would be grave crimes against the
society as a whole and hence, merely due to a private
settlement between the bank and the accused, it cannot be
said that prosecution of the accused persons would amount to
abuse of process of the Court as observed in paragraph
No.23.2. However, the Apex Court having considered the said
fact into consideration, in paragraph No.23.2, taken note of
allegations made even with regard to the offence under
Sections 420, 468 and 471 of IPC i.e., creation of document
and using those documents for availing the loan and in
- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
paragraph No.27, it is made clear that the dispute between the
parties arising out of banking transaction which are commercial
transactions having overwhelmingly or predominantly civil
flavour had ended in a compromise settlement, that too, in the
manner which we have delineated above, in our view, the
possibility of conviction of appellant No.1 is remote and bleak.
Therefore, the continuation of the criminal case would cause
grave prejudice and injustice to the appellants. The Apex Court
also taken note of in paragraph No.28 that if the respondent-
bank is permitted to go ahead with the criminal prosecution
initiated after settlement of the loan amount before the DRT, it
would adversely impact the sanctity of such settlement which
has become part of the judicial proceeding and which had the
approval of a judicial forum like the DRT. If such a conduct is
overlooked and prosecution is allowed to continue, many
persons including commercial entities would be hesitate to
come forward and seek resolution of their disputes arising out
of banking transactions which are after all commercial
transactions, having predominantly elements of civil dispute(s).
This in turn would have a debilitating effect on the overall
- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
economy, more so, when the focus is on settlement of
commercial dispute. This is the larger picture we need to keep
in mind.
30. Having taken note of the principles laid down in
paragraph Nos.27 and 28, though learned counsel appearing
for CBI would vehemently contend that matter requires trial
before the Trial Court that offence is against the economy, the
Court also has to look into the reasoning given by the Apex
Court in the recent judgment after the judgment of Sarvodaya
Highways Ltd.’s case. The counsel appearing for the
respondent would submit that this case is not factually
applicable contending that the same application in a case where
settlement is arrived before initiation of criminal prosecution
not after the initiation of criminal prosecution, the said
contention cannot be accepted in view of the discussion made
by the Apex Court in paragraph No.28, wherein also clear
observation is made that, if such powers are not exercised,
there are no chances of settlement between the parties and
though it is an offence, the persons including the commercial
entities will not come forward to settle the matter, if criminal
- 34 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
prosecution is continued which is in the larger interest of
settlement between the bank as well as the person, who is due
to the bank. Hence, the very contention of learned counsel
appearing for the CBI also cannot be accepted.
31. So also, learned counsel appearing for bank would
contend that there cannot be any quashing. But, the fact is that
they have not resisted the compromise and they have given
consent with the prior approval of the higher authorities for
One Time Settlement and now, cannot blow hot and cold in
coming to the conclusion that it requires a criminal prosecution
making the submission that proceedings has to continue.
Hence, the very submission made by learned counsel appearing
for the bank also cannot be accepted. In the judgment in
Sarvodaya Highways Ltd.’s case which has been relied upon
by learned counsel appearing for the CBI, observation is made
that settlement was arrived for only Rs.41 crores as against
Rs.52 crores and there was loss to the bank, but that is not the
case of the bank in the case on hand and while settling the
case, in view of the judgment relied upon by learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner i.e., in Vijay Kumar Kela’s case,
- 35 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
though it is seriously contended by learned counsel for the CBI
that the same is not applicable, the said contention cannot be
accepted and the Court has to look into interest of both the
bank and the person, who is due to the bank while settling the
matter as observed in paragraph No.28 and larger interest of
the parties has to be taken note of while invoking the
provisions under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. When such observation
is made by the Apex Court and even taken note of judgment of
Apex Court in Narinder Singh’s case and Gian Singh ’s case
and other judgments, wherein the dispute between the private
parties is taken note of and no doubt, the bank amount is a
public money, the same will not affect the settlement between
the bank as well as the borrower.
32. It is also important to note that the respective
counsels brought to notice of this Court though several
allegations are made that documents are created and availed
the loan, but statement is very clear that loan accounts are
very regular, except one or two installments due in respect of
only two borrowers are concerned. When such being the case,
if really they intend to cheat the bank at the inception and
- 36 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
indulged in creating the document to commit the offence, they
would not have regularly made the payment and such
ingredient of offence under Section 420 is also missing in the
case on hand. Hence, W.P.No.2785/2022 and
Crl.P.No.2351/2022 could be considered invoking Section 482 of
Cr.P.C. since, settlement is arrived between the bank and the
borrower, even subsequent to filing of charge sheet and even
though discharge applications are rejected, the Court has to
look into the material available on record that there was
settlement subsequent to discharge application and those
documents are also not filed before the Trial Court at the time
of filing a discharge application, there cannot be criminal
prosecution in view of the observation made by the Apex Court
in paragraph No.28 of the judgment in Vijay Kumar Kela’s
case. Accordingly, I answer point No.(2) as ‘affirmative’.
POINT NO.(3)- W.P.No.6422/2022
33. Now coming to the relief sought by the petitioner in
W.P.No.6422/2022, prayer is sought for quashing the
proceedings on behalf of accused No.17. Having considered the
grounds, since learned counsel appearing for the petitioner is
- 37 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
not pursuing the matter, even inspite of matter was heard by
this Court on the previous occasions, the only ground urged is
that accused No.1 being the Manager, Syndicate Bank entered
into a criminal conspiracy with accused No.2, Proprietor of M/s.
Akshay Enterprises, Bangalore and other accused during the
period 2014-2015, the accused No.1 has sanctioned 21 micro
small and medium enterprises loans to the accused Nos.3 to 26
based on the fake documents without supplying the
machineries to the borrowers. But, those allegations are
omnibus and the complainant-bank has not given proper
instructions to the borrowers, who borrow the loan and utilized
the scheme amount. Loan review format, business loan model
and process note and the same was not at all informed. It is
also contented that, afterthought, the petitioner entire loan
amount is cleared and the entire loan amount was deposited to
the bank on 16.04.2021, on One Time Settlement scheme,
entire loan amount was cleared and on loan clearance
Reference No.0444/JAL/NOC/0444/791/796 dated 16.04.2021
issued by the Senior Bank Manager, Canara Bank produced for
kind perusal of the Court marked as Annexure-E and the entire
- 38 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
charge sheet allegation which is civil in nature is converted into
criminal offence which is an abuse of process.
34. Having considered the document of Annexure-E, the
Canara Bank had issued the endorsement on 16.04.2021 i.e.,
M/s. Chitritha Enterprises, Proprietor Mr. Narasimha Rao, who
is the petitioner herein have paid their MSME Loan Account
No.04447910000796 under One Time Settlement Scheme of
the bank by availing interest concession and this Certificate is
issued at the specific request of the customer. This document is
also very clear that the petitioner is also similarly placed as that
of the other petitioners in Crl.P.No.2351/2022 and also
W.P.No.2785/2022 and the discussion made by this Court with
regard to the principles laid down in the judgment referred by
learned counsel for the CBI as well as learned counsel for the
petitioner comes to the aid of this petitioner, since he has made
entire payment of the loan amount and certificate is also
issued. Hence, the petitioner in W.P.No.6422/2022 is also
entitled for the relief under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. Hence, I
answer point No.(3) as ‘affirmative’.
- 39 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62626
WP No.6422 of 2022
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010135362022
Point No.(4)
In view of the discussion made above, I pass the
following:
ORDER
i. The Crl.P.No.9900/2017 is dismissed.
ii. The Crl.P.No.2351/2022, W.P.Nos.2785/2022
and 6422/2022 are allowed and the
proceedings initiated against the petitioners in
Spl.C.C.No.481/2017 are hereby quashed.
Sd/-
(H.P.SANDESH)
JUDGE
ST
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 17