Satendra @ Dactar vs State of U.P. and others

Court
Allahabad High Court

Reserved
A.F.R.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
CRIMINAL MISC. WRIT PETITION No. - 16953 of 2025
Satendra @ Dactar
…..Petitioner
Versus
State of U.P. and others
…..Respondents
Counsel for the Petitioner : Harbansh Prasad Pandey
Counsel for the Respondents : G.A.
Court No. - 2
HON'BLE J.J. MUNIR, J.
HON'BLE TARUN SAXENA, J.
(Delivered by Hon’ble J.J. Munir, J.)
1. Let this writ petition be de-tagged from Criminal Misc. Writ
Petition No. 20611 of 2025, as we find that there are no common
questions of facts and law involved, and both related to
completely different history-sheets.
2. This writ petition is directed against the order dated
27.02.2020 passed by the Senior Superintendent of Police,
Prayagraj, approving the opening of a B-Class history sheet
against the petitioner as well as the history sheet opened on the
basis of the said order, annexed as Annexure No.1 to the writ
petition. The petitioner prays that the order of the Senior

2
CRLP No. - 16953 of 2025
Superintendent of Police, granting approval to the opening of a B-
Class history sheet against him as well as the history sheet, be
quashed.
3. The petitioner says that the Station House Officer, Police
Station Meja, District Prayagraj, on 19.02.2020 submitted a report
to the Circle Officer, Meja, District Prayagraj, proposing the
opening of a history sheet against him. The Circle Officer, Meja,
District Prayagraj, on the same date, recommended the matter to
the Superintendent of Police, Yamunapar, District Prayagraj. The
Superintendent of Police, Yamunapar, Prayagraj also
recommended the opening of a history sheet against the
petitioner on 19.02.2020 to the Senior Superintendent of Police,
Prayagraj. The Senior Superintendent of Police, Prayagraj
approved the opening of a history sheet by means of his order
dated 27.02.2020. The petitioner has detailed his history of eight
crimes registered against him, which is as follows:
“I. Case Crime No. 464A/2009, under Sections 323, 504, 506, 427, 452 IPC,
Police Station Meja, District Prayagraj;
II. Case Crime No. 374/2012, under Sections 323, 504, 506, 427, 452 IPC, Police
Station Meja, District Prayagraj;
III. Case Crime No.276/2013, under Sections 147, 323, 504, 506, 384, 427 IPC,
Police Station Meja, District Prayagraj;
IV. Case Crime No.342/343/2013, under Sections 504, 308, 386, 503, 341 IPC,
Police Station Meja, District Prayagraj;
V. Case Crime No. 361/2013, under Sections 3/4 of the Goondas Act, Police
Station Meja, District Prayagraj;
VI. Case Crime No. 398/2013, under Sections 406, 504, 506 IPC, Police Station
Meja, District Prayagraj;
VII. Case Crime No. 418/2015, under Sections 323, 504, 506 IPC Police Station
Meja, District Prayagraj;
VIII. Case Crime No. 498/2015, under Sections 147, 148, 149, 302, 323, 504, 506
IPC and Section 7 Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, Police Station Meja, District
Prayagraj.”
4. The petitioner says that on the basis of the impugned order
passed by the Senior Superintendent of Police, Prayagraj dated
27.02.2020, a history sheet for the petitioner has been opened in

3
CRLP No. - 16953 of 2025
Class-B, bearing no. B-26, relating to Police Station Meja, District
Prayagraj. It is the petitioner's case that he had no knowledge of
the aforesaid history sheet opened by the respondents and came
to know of the fact for the first time on 10.07.2025, when a
Constable from Police Station Meja informed him about the
opening of the impugned history sheet. The petitioner contacted
the Station House Officer and requested him to provide papers
relating to opening of the history sheet. It is in this manner that he
was provided a photostat copy of the history sheet together with
the endorsements of approval etc. carried thereon. It is next
asserted by the petitioner that a perusal of the history sheet
shows that the conduct of the petitioner has been under
surveillance from 2020 to 2024. It is clearly mentioned there that
in 2020, the history sheeter was found at home and is currently
the Pradhan and active. He requires a surveillance. In the year
2021, the entry dated 28.08.2021 shows that the history sheeter
lives in Naini and runs a school. He is inactive. On 15.07.2022,
there is an entry to the effect that the history sheeter was found at
home, he runs a school and is inactive. On 15.06.2023, there is
an entry that the history sheeter was found at home, he runs a
college and is inactive. In the year 2024, there is an entry dated
30.08.2024 that the history sheeter was found at home, he runs a
college and is inactive.
5. About the eight cases, it is pointed out in paragraph nos. 10
to 17 of the writ petition that in Crime No. 464-A/2009, under
Sections 323, 504, 506, 427, 452 IPC, a final report has been
submitted after investigation on 05.09.2010. In three of the
crimes, he has been granted bail – in two by the District Court and
in one by this Court. The case registered under Section 3/4 of the
Goondas Act at P.S. Meja, Prayagraj, is a case where no
externment order has been passed. To our mind, under the
Goondas Act, no crime can be registered. About Crime
No.398/2013, under Sections 406, 504, 506 IPC, P.S. Meja,

4
CRLP No. - 16953 of 2025
District Prayagraj, it is to be noticed that the matter was
compromised and the proceedings of the case have been stayed
by this Court in an application under Section 482 Cr.P.C., being
Application U/S 482 No. 44888 of 2024, vide order dated
15.01.2025.
6. So far as Crime No. 418 of 2015 is concerned, it is a case
under Sections 323, 504, 506 IPC, registered at P.S. Meja, District
Prayagraj, that mostly discloses non-cognizable offences. So far
as Crime No. 498 of 2015, under Sections 147, 148, 149, 302,
323, 504, 506 IPC and Section 7 of the Criminal Law
(Amendment) Act, P.S. Meja, District Prayagraj is concerned, a
charge-sheet has been submitted by the Investigating Officer, but
the petitioner has been exculpated. The contents of paragraph
nos. 10 to 17 of the writ petition, where these assertions are made
about the criminal cases, have not been denied in the counter
affidavit, except the remark that these are matters of record.
7. The thrust of the petitioner's case is that the offences, which
have been registered against the petitioner, are not within the
mischief of Regulation 228 of the Uttar Pradesh Police
Regulations (for short, 'UP Police Regulations') at all, so as to
entitle them to open a history sheet in Class-B or even Class-A.
The petitioner's case is that the offences disclosed against the
petitioner do not place him in the class of offenders, where either
a history sheet of Class-B or Class-A could be opened against
him within the meaning of Regulation 228 of the UP Police
Regulations. He submits that this is a case of an arbitrary exercise
of power by the Police to open a history sheet in relation to crimes
registered against the petitioner, which do not authorize
surveillance after the opening of history sheet under the U.P.
Police Regulations at all. In reply to paragraph nos. 19, 20 and 24
of the writ petition, where the case pleaded is that the offences
registered against the petitioner do not fall within the ambit of

5
CRLP No. - 16953 of 2025
relevant cases, on the basis of which a history sheet in Class-B or
Class-A might be opened under Regulation 228, all that is
asserted is that the petitioner is a hardcore and nefarious criminal.
He has several criminal cases registered against him. It is then
said that his case was recommended by the Station House
Officer, Meja for the opening of a history sheet, which went
through the police hierarchy and met with the approval of the
Senior Superintendent of Police, resulting in opening of the
impugned history sheet no. B-26 against him.
8. It is asserted in paragraph no. 19 that the petitioner is
involved in antisocial activities in the area and serious criminal
cases are registered against him. It is in order to prevent his
illegal activities and to keep an eye on him that the impugned
history sheet has been opened on 27.02.2020. It is asserted that
the Higher Authorities of the Police have given approval to the
opening of the impugned history sheet on the basis of the criminal
cases registered against the petitioner, which is just, legal and
proper, and does not suffer from any kind of infirmity.
9. Heard Mr. Harbansh Prasad Pandey, learned Counsel for
the petitioner and Mr. Deepak Mishra, learned Additional
Government Advocate appearing on behalf of the State.
10. Regulations 228, 229 and 232 of the U.P. Police Regulations
provide:
“228. History sheets, Part V of the village Crime Note Book- Part V consists of
history sheets. These are the personal records of criminals under surveillance.
History-sheets should be opened only for persons who are or likely to become
habitual criminal or abettors of such criminals. There will be two classes of
history-sheets :
(1) Class A history-sheets for dacoits, burglars, cattle-thieves, railway-goods
wagon thieves, and abettors thereof.
(2) Class B history-sheets for confirmed and professional criminals who
commit crimes other than dacoity, burglary, cattle-theft, and theft from railway
goods wagons, e.g., professional cheats and other experts for whom criminal
personal files are maintained by the Criminal Investigation Department,
prisoners, cattle poisoners, railway passenger thieves, bicycle thieves, expert
pick-pocket, forgers, coiners, cocaine and opium smugglers, hired ruffians and
goondas, telegraph wire-cutters, habitual illicit distillers and abettors thereof.

6
CRLP No. - 16953 of 2025
History-sheets of both classes will be maintained in similar form, but those for
class B will be distinguished by a red bar marked at the top of the first page. No
history-sheet of class B may be converted into a history-sheet of class A, though
should be the subject of a history-sheet of class B be found to be also addicted to
dacoity, burglary, cattle-theft or theft from railway goods wagons. A class, as well
as B class, surveillance may under paragraph 238 be applied to him. In the event of
a class A history-sheet man becoming addicted to miscellaneous crime his history-
sheet may be converted into a class B history-sheet with the sanction of the
Superintendent.
229. Classification of history sheets- This classification of history-sheets as A and
B is based on the principle that, whereas there is always hope of a dacoit, burglar,
or cattle thief or railway goods wagons thief mending his ways, the expert
miscellaneous criminal is as a general rule incapable of reform. The classification,
therefore, solely on the kind of crime to which suspects are addicted and is
designed to regulate only-
(1) the length of time for which a suspect should ordinarily remain, under
surveillance in the absence of complaints against him,
(2) the kind of surveillance which his activities require.
The degree of surveillance of the appropriate kind to be exercised over a suspect
will depend not on his classification, but on the extent to which he is believed to be
active at any particular time.
232. Continuity of B-Class history sheets- History-sheet of B class will be
continuously open records and the subjects of these sheets will except for every
special reasons remain under surveillance until death. This being so it is
unnecessary to ‘star’ suspects of this class.”
11. The impugned history sheet, that has been opened against
the petitioner, is a B-Class history sheet, which is essentially
meant for confirmed and professional criminals, who commit
crimes other than dacoity, burglary, cattle-theft, and theft from
railway goods wagons. They would include professional cheats
and expert criminals, for whom personal files are maintained by
the Criminal Investigation Department (CID). They are
enumerated to be prisoners, cattle poisoners, railway passenger
thieves, bicycle thieves, expert pick-pockets, forgers, coiners,
cocaine and opium smugglers, hired ruffians and goondas,
telegraph wire-cutters, habitual illicit distillers and abettors of
these crimes. The hallmark, therefore, of a subject against whom
a history sheet of Class-B can be opened, is a professional
criminal, who is beyond redemption. The fact that a man is
aggressive by temperament and gets involved in different kinds of
offences, assuming that these are true, would not qualify him as a
professional or expert criminal, who is contemplated as the

7
CRLP No. - 16953 of 2025
subject of a B-Class history sheet under Regulation 228 of the UP
Police Regulations.
12. The offences registered against the petitioner are all of
diverse nature. The first of the crimes is under Sections 323, 504,
506, 427, 522 IPC, where a final report was submitted on
05.10.2009. It appears to be a cross case. The other is Crime No.
374 of 2012, again under Sections 323, 504, 506, 427, 452 IPC,
where the petitioner has been admitted to bail by the Sessions
Judge. The next is an offence, being Crime No. 276 of 2013,
under Sections 147, 323, 504, 506, 387, 427 IPC, P.S. Meja,
where too the petitioner had been enlarged on bail by the
Sessions Judge. The next is an offence, giving rise to Crime No.
342 of 2013, under Sections 504, 308, 506, 386, 341 IPC, P.S.
Meja, District Prayagraj, where the petitioner has been granted
bail. In Case Crime No. 398 of 2013, under Sections 406, 504,
506 IPC, P.S. Meja, Prayagraj, a compromise has been entered
into between parties, where this Court has stayed proceedings on
an application made under Section 482 CrPC. Case Crime No.
418 of 2015 is the next offence under Sections 323, 504, 506 IPC,
P.S. Meja, Prayagraj, which is apparently a petty offence, which
the petitioner has described as non-cognizable, but later records
shows that a charge-sheet has been filed in the said case. Crime
No. 498 of 2015, under Sections 147, 148, 149, 302, 323, 504,
506 IPC and Section 7 of the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, P.S.
Meja, Prayagraj is a case where the petitioner has not been
charge-sheeted, but exculpated. The fact is not denied that this
crime does not appear to have been found proved by the Police
against the petitioner.
13. Looking to the entire profile of cases, none of the offences
are of a character which may place the petitioner in the category
of a professional or expert criminal, like a pick-pocket, railway
passenger thief, bicycle thief, cattle poisoner, professional cheat,

8
CRLP No. - 16953 of 2025
coiner, forger, a hired ruffian or goonda etc. It may show the
petitioner, as already remarked, to be a man who lands himself in
trouble, but there is nothing said in the counter affidavit too to
show that professionalism in crime against the petitioner, which
would attract the opening of a Class-B history sheet. We have to
be mindful of the fact as we read Regulation 229 of the UP Police
Regulations, that a subject, against whom a B-Class history sheet
is opened, is considered beyond redemption and the history sheet
remains alive against him until he is dead. Therefore, the nature
of the crime committed by a person to qualify for being placed in a
B-Class history sheet, is very different, and the offences that are
mentioned there are tell-tale. This is certainly not the case with
the petitioner. He is, by no means, an expert or professional
criminal, though cases might have been registered against him
time over again.
14. We also notice that the last crime recorded in the history
sheet dates back to the year 2015. The history sheet has been
opened in the year 2020 and the proposal was made in the year
2020. During those five years, the history sheet does not record
any crime against the petitioner.
15. Represent 240 of the UP Police Regulations reads:
“240. History sheets of both classes when to be opened? History-sheets of both
classes may be opened (1) on suspicion or (2) on conviction or acquittal. No
history-sheet may be opened without the orders of the Superintendent of Police.
(1) On suspicion.- Whenever as a result of investigation into a case of dacoity,
burglary, cattle theft from railway goods wagons or into a case of miscellaneous
crime of a professional type, the officer-in-charge of a police station applies for the
name of any person to be entered in the crime register as reasonably suspected, he
must at the same time report whether the suspect is under surveillance, and if not,
whether a history-sheet should in his opinion be opened for him. Should the
gazetted officer-in-charge of a sub-division on receiving such a report and after
such further inquiry as he may think necessary consider that a history-sheet is
required, he will forward the report to the Superintendent who if he accepts the
proposal will define the class of historysheet to be opened and pass orders as to
whether the suspect should be ‘starred’. Similarly whenever an officer-in-charge of
a police station finds reason to believe, otherwise than in the course of an
investigation, that any resident of his circle is addicted to crime, or whenever a
gazetted officer or circle inspector for any reason believes that a history-sheet for
any person is necessary a report must be submitted to the Superintendent, who will
pass orders on it as laid down above.

9
CRLP No. - 16953 of 2025
(2) On conviction or acquittal.- Whenever any person is sent for trial on a charge
of dacoity, burglary, cattle theft or theft from a railway goods wagons or of
miscellaneous crime of a professional type, the officer-in-charge of the police
station must state in his diary whether accused has a history-sheet and if not,
whether he recommends that a history-sheet should be opened for him. It will be
the duty of the Public Prosecutor, if the accused is acquitted to inform the
Superintendent, in his report on the acquittal or otherwise, whether in his opinion a
history-sheet is required. On this the Superintendent will pass any orders to the
station office that may be necessary. If the accused is convicted, the Public
Prosecutor must, in the remarks column of the daily report of convictions and
acquittals (Form No. 107) enter in red ink the words, ‘On H.S.’ if a history-sheet is
already open, or the letters ‘H.S.’ if he recommends that one should be prepared. In
either case he must prepare and attach to the daily report of convictions and
acquittals a P.R. slip (Form No. 313). If a history-sheet is already open or if the
Superintendent agrees that a history-sheet should be opened he will sign this P.R.
slip and initial the letters ‘H.S.’ or ‘On H.S.’ on the daily report of convictions and
acquittals. The Public Prosecutor will then communicate the Superintendent’s
orders for the opening of a history sheet to the police station concerned and will
forward the P.R. slip to the Superintendent of Jail. If no history-sheet is opened and
if the Superintendent does not agree that one should be prepared, he will not sign
the P.R.. slip, which will be cancelled.
If the accused is a resident of another district or State or has been sent for trial by
the railway police, the same will be followed except that the Superintendent of
Police will not order a history-sheet to be opened. If the accused is convicted and
the Superintendent considers a history-sheet to be desirable the P.R. slip will be
signed and sent to the Superintendent of Jail and the Superintendent of Jail shall
furnish the Superintendent of Police with a receipt for the P.R. slip. In column 10
Form No. 148 (conviction roll) the Public Prosecutor will note in red ink that this
has been done and in column 15 of the same form a note will be made
recommending that a history-sheet should be opened : Any conviction roll on
which a recommendation for the opening of history-sheet has been made must on
receipt in the district of the convict’s residence be put up before the Superintendent
of Police of that district who will decide whether a history-sheet should be opened
or not, and will address the Superintendent of Jail regarding the cancellation of the
P.R. slip if he does not agree that a history-sheet is necessary. Notwithstanding
anything in the above, the Superintendent of Police of any district in Uttar Pradesh
shall subject to the final decision of the Deputy Inspector-General of the Range, to
whom any question of disagreement must be referred, be bound to open a history-
sheet at the request of the Superintendent of Government Railway Police for any
person resident who is suspected or convicted of crime on the railway. The
Superintendent, Railway Police, should specify the kind of surveillance required in
each case.
In the case of persons, sent for trial by the Railway police, in which the
Superintendent considers a history-sheet desirable, the Public Prosecutor will send
Form No. 143 (conviction roll) endorsed, as directed above, to the Superintendent
of the man’s district, through the Superintendent, Railway Police.
The Superintendent, Railway Police, in forwarding Form No. 148 to the
Superintendent of the district concerned will state whether he considers a history-
sheet necessary. If not, he will request the Superintendent of the Jail to cancel the
P.R. Slip.”
16. It shows that history sheet is a matter of police surveillance
in order to enable them to keep an eye on certain kind of
criminals. These may be opened on suspicion or on conviction or
even acquittal, but the rider is that no history sheet can be opened
without the orders of the Superintendent of Police. This embargo

10
CRLP No. - 16953 of 2025
against the opening of history sheets, without the orders of the
Superintendent of Police, shows that the law-makers were aware
even in the pre-constitutional days, when the UP Police
Regulations were framed, that the opening of a history sheet,
howsoever described as a measure for the Police to go about
their duty, is deeply invasive of the individual's liberty and privacy.
Also, the opening of a history sheet requires a fine understanding
of the distinction between those cases where the man may have
committed or got involved in more than one instances of crime, on
one hand, and an expert or a professional criminal, on the other. It
is for this reason that in the day, the Regulations were framed, it
was thought that the Superintendent of Police is a responsible
officer, who would exercise this authority with understanding, care
and caution. Unfortunately, in this case, this has not happened at
all.
17. A look at the history sheet, and, more than that, the contents
of the counter affidavit, it is apparent that the proposal was made
by the Station House Officer Meja, Prayagraj and it went through
the desk of the Circle Officer, Meja, the Superintendent of Police,
Yamunapar, Prayagraj on the same day, that is to say,
19.02.2020. The Senior Superintendent of Police, Prayagraj, who
was exclusively vested with the authority to authorize the opening
of the impugned history sheet, granted his approval on
27.02.2020. A look at the approval granted by the Senior
Superintendent of Police, Prayagraj would show that it is nothing
more than a rubber stamped approval. We do not wish to say that
it is the obligation of the Senior Superintendent of Police to pass a
detailed order authorizing the opening of a history sheet, but at
the same time he has to record in a few words how he finds the
man to be a professional or an expert criminal, on the basis of
material available on record, so as to imperil his liberty until the
man's death.

11
CRLP No. - 16953 of 2025
18. In the post-constitutional era, the right of privacy and the
right to liberty guaranteed under Articles 19 and 21 of the
Constitution have gained profound importance. The liberty
guaranteed by Article 21 is no longer the bare freedom from
restraint, but involves all that freedom where the individual can
truly live a human life with all its myriad facets. Article 19(1)(a)
guarantees the rights to freedom of expression, and Article 19 (1)
(d) the freedom to move freely throughout the territory of India.
Once a B-Class history sheet is opened against a man, the
methods of surveillance are laid down in Regulations 236 and 238
of the UP Police Regulations, which read:
“236. Methods of surveillance of history sheeters.- Without prejudice to the right
of Superintendents of Police to put into practice any legal measures, such as
shadowing in cities, by which they find they can keep in touch with suspects in
particular local ties or special circumstances, surveillance may for most practical
purposes be defined as consisting of one or more of the following measures :
(a) secret picketing of the house or approaches to the house of suspects;
(b) through periodical inquiries by officers not below the rank of sub-inspector
into repute, habits, associations, income, expenses and occupation;
(c) the reporting by constables and chaukidars of movements and absences from
home;
(d) the verification of movements and absences by means of inquiry slip;
(e) the collection and record on a history-sheet of all information bearing on
conduct.
238. Surveillance of B-class history sheeters- History-sheet men of class B will be
subject to measures (c), (d) and (e) but not to measures (a) or (b) unless the nature
of the particular crime to which they are addicted requires that these measures
should be applied to them. Thus, while it might be necessary to have a telegraph
wire-cutter visited, or to have his house picketed at night, the application of these
methods of surveillance to a professional cheat would be futile.
Similarly, though the absences from home of all history-sheet men of class B must
be reported at the police station, and though, all such men will be liable to have
their movements verified, this verification need not be made when it would clearly
serve no useful purpose. It would almost invariably be essential, for instance to
verify the movements of prisoner or a pick-pocket, but rarely necessary to verify
those of a local bulky. In such matters station officers be expected to exercise an
intelligent discretion having regard to the circumstances of the criminal’s absence
and the nature of the crime to which he is addicted.”
19. A look at these methods of surveillance would certainly
show that while a man may not be actually under restraint, his
liberty and privacy, including his movements, would be under
constant gaze. His house would be subjected to picketing as well

12
CRLP No. - 16953 of 2025
as the approaches to his house, likewise dealt with. There would
be eyes following him wherever he went. A supervision, like this,
would certainly be severe curtailment of an individual's right to
liberty guaranteed under Articles 19 and 21 of the Constitution. It
is not that even in cases of professional and expert criminals, their
fundamental rights are to over-weigh against the countervailing
and overbearing larger public interest. But, cases where this kind
of curtailment is indeed necessary, have to be sensitively
classified and identified. A cavalier approach cannot be adopted
with a rubber stamped approval by the Superintendent of Police to
open a B-Class history sheet, that would cast a shadow of
surveillance over a man for the remainder of his life.
20. There is no material placed on record in the present case,
as already remarked, which would entitle the Senior
Superintendent of Police or the recommending Authorities lower
down to think that the petitioner is that kind of an expert or
professional criminal, whose conduct requires constant
surveillance by resort to a B-Class history sheet. In the context of
surveillance and the opening of history sheets for the purpose,
reference must be made to Gobind v. State of M.P., (1975) 2 SCC
148, where the entire measures of surveillance and for what kind
of men it would pass constitutional muster has been laid down. In
Govind (supra) it was held by the Supreme Court while
considering constitutional validity of Regulation 855 and 856 of
the Madhya Pradesh Police Regulations:
“33. When there are two interpretations, one wide and unconstitutional, the other
narrower but within constitutional bounds, this Court will read down the
overflowing expressions to make them valid. So read, the two regulations are more
restricted than counsel for the petitioner sought to impress upon us. Regulation
855, in our view, empowers surveillance only of persons against whom reasonable
materials exist to induce the opinion that they show “a determination, to lead a life
of crime” — crime in this context being confined to such as involve public peace
or security only and if they are dangerous security risks. Mere convictions in
criminal cases where nothing gravely imperilling safety of society cannot be
regarded as warranting surveillance under this regulation. Similarly, domiciliary
visits and picketing by the police should be reduced to the clearest cases of danger
to community security and not routine follow-up at the end of a conviction or
release from prison or at the whim of a police officer. In truth, legality apart, these

13
CRLP No. - 16953 of 2025
regulations ill-accord with the essence of personal freedoms and the State will do
well to revise these old police regulations verging perilously near
unconstitutionality.”
21. The remarks of their Lordships made half a century ago in
Gobind (supra) are a beacon light to show that these kind of
intrusive measures do not much accord with a constitutionally
governed society, though it is not entirely prohibited. It is to be
limited for such men, who pose dangerous security risks to the
society at large, when they virtually lead a professional life of
crime. In the day when Gobind was decided, the right to privacy
was still not established as a facet of Article 21 of the Constitution.
It is now a well established facet of that fundamental right after the
decision in K.S. Puttaswamy (Privacy-9J.) v. Union of India,
(2017) 10 SCC 1.
22. A similar question arose before a Division Bench of this
Court in Munna Lal Gupta v. State of U.P., 2016 SCC OnLine All
3023, where highlighting the importance of invasive surveillance
by the Police on account of opening of a B-Class history sheet
and the recording of reason by a police officer that the person,
against whom the measure was taken, was a desperate character
and habitual offender, it was held:
“14. The petitioner under the shadow of surveillance is certainly deprived of this
freedom. Due to presence of such history-sheet, the petitioner is deprived of his
freedom of movement as well as right of privacy under the shadow of surveillance
by police. He can move physically, but he could not do so freely for all his
activities because he is watched and noted. After knowledge of this history-sheet
he could not act as freely as he would like to do in absence of such history-sheet.
15. Where the police officer has not given any reason for his belief that the
petitioner was a desperate character, and a habitual offender, the history-sheet
opened against him is not in accordance with the mandate of the relevant rules, and
as such it would be just to order closure of such history-sheet. The exercise of the
power by the police under the cover of surveillance which invades into personal
liberty of the petitioner as regards his free movement in day to day life, when there
is no material to continue the history-sheet for him, is violative of Article 21 of the
Constitution of India.
16. For the reasons discussed above, we hold that Class-B history-sheet for the
petitioner Munna Lal Gupta was an erroneous act done with out the facts being
verified and without reasonable satisfaction being reached or mind being applied
by the then Superintendent of Police. This history-sheet was never reviewed
because rules provided that Class-B history-sheet shall continue till death.

14
CRLP No. - 16953 of 2025
17. Although right of privacy stands declared as fundamental right and a person
cannot be deprived of freedom of movement guaranteed by the Article 19(1)(d) of
the Constitution of India as well as personal liberty granted under Article 21 and it
cannot be said that rights are absolutely rights because they subjected to reasonable
restrictions, but in present matter restrictions imposed on aforesaid fundamental
rights of the petitioner are unwarranted erroneous and unreasonable. This history-
sheet is violative of constitutional guarantee and fundamental rights of the
petitioner guaranteed under the Constitution of India. We are satisfied that there
were no sufficient grounds for Superintendent of Police to entertain a reasonable
belief that a surveillance was required in the case of the petitioner and there existed
no offence to support the fact that surveillance of the petitioner was necessary.
Hence the order passed by the Superintendent of Police Chitrakoot to open Class-B
history-sheet of the petitioner at Police Station Manikpur, District Chitrakoot
deserves to be quashed.”
23. We must say in this case, as already noticed, with reference
to the specific contents of the impugned history sheet that the
Senior Superintendent of Police has not at all applied his mind to
the fact, if indeed the petitioner was that kind of an offender, who
fell in the description of an expert professional criminal, one who
would require supervision because of his actions by their sheer,
desperate and repetitive nature and the fact that these would
imperil the security and safety of the society at large. If we look at
the history sheet, except for the cases registered, which are all
disjunct and different, there is no material, which the Senior
Superintendent of Police has taken into consideration before
granting approval to the opening of the impugned history sheet by
his order dated 27.02.2020. The order too is a rubber stamped
approval, which does little justice to the solemnness of the duty,
which is cast upon the Senior Superintendent of Police while
granting approval to the opening of a history sheet under
Regulation 240 of the UP Police Regulations. There is absolutely
no justification, therefore, in our opinion, on the material that is
placed on record to infer that the petitioner ought be classed as a
professional and expert criminal, so desperate that he is to be
subjected to a life long surveillance as a B-Class history sheeter.
24. In the result, this writ petition succeeds and is allowed. The
impugned order of the Senior Superintendent of Police, Prayagraj
dated 27.02.2020 and the impugned history sheet are hereby
quashed.

15
CRLP No. - 16953 of 2025
25. Let a copy of this judgment be communicated to the
Commissioner of Police, Prayagraj, the Deputy Commissioner of
Police, Yamuna Nagar, Commissionerate Prayagraj, the Assistant
Commissioner of Police, Circle Meja, Commissionerate Prayagraj,
and the Station House Officer, P.S. Meja, District Prayagra by the
Registrar (Compliance).
(Tarun Saxena,J.) (J.J. Munir,J.)
August 14, 2026
Anoop
Digitally signed by :-
ANOOP KUMAR SINGH
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad