SHAN BABY vs ROSHNY SHAN

Court
Kerala High Court

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

1
2026:KER:71420
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P. KRISHNA KUMAR
ND
TUESDAY, THE 22 DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026 / 31ST BHADRA, 1948
MAT.APPEAL NO. 234 OF 2022
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 30.09.2021 IN OP NO.2450 OF 2015
OF FAMILY COURT,ERNAKULAM
APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS IN O.P.:
1 SHAN BABY
AGED 32 YEARS, S/O M.O.PHILIP,
RESIDING AT MUTTAPALLIL HOUSE,
PADICHIRA P.O, PULPALLY VILLAGE, WAYANAD- 673579,
PRESENTLY RESIDING AT FALCON TOWERS,
A1 BUILDING, FLAT NO. 1404, A1 RASHIDIYA 2,
AJMAN, UAE, REPRESENTED BY POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER
SHARJ BABY, AGED 36 YEARS,
S/O M.O. PHILIP, RESIDING AT MUTTAPALLIL HOUSE,
PADICHIRA P.O, PULPALLY VILLAGE,
WAYANAD-673579.
2 M.O.PHILIP
AGED 58 YEARS
RESIDING AT MUTTAPALLIL HOUSE,
PADICHIRA P.O, PULPALLY VILLAGE, WAYANAD -673579
BY ADVS.
SHRI.M.R.HARIRAJ (SR.)
SMT.THANUJA ROSHAN
SHRI.VISWAJITH C.K
SMT.GISHA G. RAJ
SHRI.REJIVUE K.C.
SMT.VIDYA A.K
SMT.ALINA ANNA KOSE

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

2
2026:KER:71420
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER IN O.P.:
ROSHNY SHAN
AGED 26 YEARS, D/O REMANI
REMANIKA HOUSE, CHENGANNUR TALUK, NEDUVARAMCODE
VILLAGE, ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT NOW RESIDING AT ANCHU
BHAVAN VARUR, RANNI TALUK, PATHANAMTHITTA DISTRICT.
BY ADVS.
SRI.RAJESH VIJAYAN
SMT.SIKHA S.NAIR
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON
10.09.2026, THE COURT ON 22.09.2026 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

3
2026:KER:71420
CR
SATHISH NINAN & P. KRISHNA KUMAR, JJ.
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Mat.Appeal No.234 OF 2022
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
nd
Dated this the 22 day of September, 2026
JUDGMENT
P.Krishna Kumar, J.
A petition for return of gold ornaments and money filed
by the wife against her husband was decreed by the Family Court,
Ernakulam. The husband challenges the said decree in this appeal.
2. The parties will hereinafter be referred to as they were
arrayed in the original petition. The petitioner and the first
respondent were married on 23.10.2010, in accordance with
Christian religious rites and customs. Before the marriage, the
petitioner had converted to Christianity. According to the
petitioner, she had adorned 35 sovereigns of gold ornaments at
the time of her marriage. Two days after the marriage, the first
respondent obtained all her gold ornaments and pledged them,
stating that he needed to discharge debts incurred in connection
with his business. The petitioner further alleges that, on
14.09.2010, her mother had given ₹5,00,000/- to the second

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

4
2026:KER:71420
respondent, the father of the first respondent, as the family
share of the petitioner. Thus, the petitioner seeks recovery of
the aforesaid gold ornaments and money. (Though the petitioner
also claimed that the first respondent had obtained amounts
totalling ₹11 lakhs and odd on various occasions from her mother,
the trial court did not accept the said claim, and there is no
appeal against it.)
3. The respondents stoutly resisted the petition, contending
that they had neither received 35 sovereigns of gold ornaments
nor ₹5,00,000/- as claimed in the petition. They further
contended that the petitioner had been wearing only 20 sovereigns
of gold ornaments at the time of her marriage and that her entire
ornaments were taken away by her mother and her friend, Chacko
Mathai, from the petitioner within three days of her marriage,
for safe keeping in the custody of Chacko Mathai.
4. The Family Court tried the above case together with the
petition filed by the wife for divorce. The evidence of the
petitioner consists of the oral testimony of PW1 to PW4 and
Exts.A1 to A14. RW1 to RW7 were examined and Exts.B1 to B28 were
marked on the side of the respondents. Upon evaluating the oral

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

5
2026:KER:71420
and documentary evidence, the trial court partly decreed the
petition and directed the first respondent to return 35
sovereigns of gold ornaments or their market value. The court
also allowed the petitioner to realise ₹5,00,000/- from the
second respondent.
5. We have heard Sri. M.R. Hariraj, the learned Senior
Counsel appearing for the respondents/appellants, and Sri. Rajesh
Vijayan, the learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner/respondent.
6. The points that arise for consideration in this appeal
are as follows:
1. Whether the petitioner had 35 sovereigns of gold
ornaments at the time of her marriage?
2. Whether the first respondent had obtained 35
sovereigns of gold ornaments from the petitioner
after the marriage?
3. Whether the mother of the petitioner entrusted
₹5,00,000/- to the second respondent?
4. Is the decree under challenge liable to be interfered
with?
7. As regards the quantity of gold ornaments possessed by
the petitioner at the time of her marriage, PW1, the petitioner,
and PW2, her mother, deposed that, at the time of marriage, the

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

6
2026:KER:71420
petitioner had 35 sovereigns of gold ornaments. Ext.A9 marriage
photograph was also produced in evidence by the petitioner. The
genuineness of the document is not under challenge. The
respondents also produced Ext.B1 series of photographs taken at
the time of their marriage. The ornaments adorned by the
petitioner, as seen in Ext.B1 series, tally with those depicted
in Ext.A9. The schedule to the petition specifically describes
the ornaments possessed by the petitioner at the time of her
marriage. The said description also subatantially tallies with
the photographs. The respondents have no case that the ornaments
worn by the petitioner as seen in Ext. B1 series photographs were
spurious gold. The financial capacity of the petitioner's mother
to raise so much quantity of gold ornaments, is not in dispute.
She had been working abroad. Although the respondents disputed
the petitioner's claim that she possessed 35 sovereigns of gold
ornaments, they conceded that she was in possession of 20
sovereigns. There is nothing on record to disbelieve the oral
evidence of PW1 and PW2 as to the total quantity of the gold
ornaments. In the light of all the above circumstances, it can
safely be concluded that the petitioner possessed 35 sovereigns
of gold ornaments at the time of her marriage.

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

7
2026:KER:71420
8. Coming to the question as to whether the first respondent
obtained the petitioner's gold ornaments after her marriage, the
oral evidence of the petitioner is consistent with the averment
in the petition. When examined as RW1, the first respondent
denied the said allegation. In a case where the evidence is
essentially one of ‘oath against oath’, the acceptability of the
competing versions has to be assessed in the light of the overall
circumstances of the case, having regard to all relevant factors
including various social circumstances.
9. Sri. M.R. Hariraj, the learned Senior Counsel appearing
for the respondents, contended that, as the petitioner had failed
to adduce convincing evidence, other than her own oral testimony,
to prove the alleged entrustment of the gold ornaments with the
first respondent, no decree ought to have been passed in her
favour, in view of the law laid down in Vinu K.S. and Another v.
Veena Viswan (2026 (5) KHC 19). It is further contended that the
trial Judge reached a conclusion as to the entrustment merely on
the basis of surmises and inferences, without any factual
foundation, by observing that the marriage in question was an
arranged one and, hence, gold ornaments must necessarily have
been presented to the bride by her parents at the time of

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

8
2026:KER:71420
marriage. The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the
said finding runs counter to the law laid down in Vinu K.S. ,
particularly when the marriage in question was a love marriage
and the petitioner had converted to Christianity just one week
before the marriage. Referring to Exts.B2 to B5, the learned
Senior Counsel fervently contended that the trial court had
failed to advert to the said documents while arriving at the
crucial conclusion that the entire gold ornaments were obtained
by the first respondent, whereas those photographs, admittedly
taken much later, would show that some of the ornaments were
retained by the petitioner.
10. In view of the above submissions, it is necessary to
consider the ratio of Vinu K.S. before appreciating the evidence
on record. In paragraph 7, Their Lordships, following the law
laid down in Dr. N.G. Dastane v. Mrs. S.D. Dastane (AIR 1975 SC
1534) observed that, in matrimonial matters, the proof of a
relevant fact is tested on the touchstone of ‘preponderance of
probabilities’ and not ‘beyond reasonable doubt’. It is further
observed that the court must first look into the pleadings and
the evidence adduced by the parties to see whether there is any
material therein from which the court can draw an inference as

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

9
2026:KER:71420
regards the existence of a fact. If there are no positive proved
facts— oral, documentary or circumstantial— from which such an
inference can be drawn, the process of inference would fail, and
what would remain is mere speculation and conjecture. Their
Lordships further deprecated the practice of trial courts placing
reliance on observations made by the constitutional courts in
lieu of inferences to be drawn on the basis of the evidence on
record, thereby abandoning the search for available evidence on
record. The Court also criticised the tendency to rely upon a
Judge's singular perception of a general practice or custom to
find an ‘entrustment’. It was further observed that, if the court
bases its finding on general practices or customs, there must be
evidence on record regarding the existence of such practice or
custom. Accordingly, this Court held that, while considering
claims by a wife for return of gold or money that she had taken
along with her to the matrimonial home, the court needs to look
for proved facts from which an inference as regards entrustment
of such gold or money to the husband or his relatives can be
drawn. Their Lordships further observed that past precedents
which assume the existence of a general practice that a woman, at
the time of her marriage and entry into her matrimonial home,

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

10
2026:KER:71420
would hand over her gold ornaments to her husband or in-laws for
safe keeping, may not be reflective of the present reality where
a well-educated and financially independent bride retains
decisional autonomy in respect of her material possessions, in
the light of the changed status of women in modern society.
11. We are in respectful agreement with the view expressed
in Vinu K.S. . However, even while applying the principles laid
down in Vinu K.S. , we do not find any flawed exercise by the
trial court in appreciating the evidence in the present case. The
trial court specifically considered the oral evidence of PW1 and
PW2 in the light of Ext.A9 wedding photographs and arrived at a
conclusion, though not in so many words, that the petitioner
possessed 35 sovereigns of gold ornaments at the time of her
marriage. Giving due emphasis to the oral evidence of PW1, the
trial court concluded that those ornaments were taken by the
first respondent, observing that the entire gold ornaments were
kept in the matrimonial home, but that the petitioner could
neither see nor hear about them thereafter (paragraph 22). In
paragraph 24, the trial court referred to the law laid down in
Pankajakshan Nair v. Shylaja (2017 (1) KHC 620), observing that
the primary burden of proving the entrustment of gold ornaments

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

11
2026:KER:71420
with the husband and in-laws is on the petitioner/wife and that,
once she succeeds in proving that aspect, it is for the
respondent to disprove the same. The trial court thereafter
considered the respondents' contention that the gold ornaments
had been taken away by PW2 and her friend, Chacko Mathai. The
court concluded that the respondents had failed to establish the
said plea and accordingly held that “so much so, the entrustment
of gold ornaments weighing 35 sovereign as pleaded by the
petitioner with the first respondent stands well proved and
established.” True, in the course of appreciating the rival oral
versions the court observed that in an arranged marriage, bride
would necessarily be presented with gold by the parents.
12. The trial court, as well as the appellate court, while
appreciating the evidence on record to determine whether a
disputed fact is proved or not, is guided by the principles
embodied in Section 3 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872/Section
2(1)(j) of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, where the term
“proved” is defined. A fact is said to be proved when the court
either believes it to exist or considers its existence so
probable that a prudent person ought, in the circumstances of the
particular case, to act upon the supposition that it exists, upon

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

12
2026:KER:71420
considering the matters before the court. In the course of such
appreciation of evidence, the court can draw inferences as to the
existence of any fact which it thinks likely to have happened,
having regard to the common course of natural events, human
conduct and public and private business, in their relation to the
facts of the particular case, as empowered by Section 114 of the
Indian Evidence Act (Section 119 of Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam,
2023).
13. In M. Narsinga Rao v. State of Andhra Pradesh (AIR 2001
SC 318), the Apex Court held that, in reaching a conclusion, the
Court can use the process of inferences to be drawn from the
facts produced or proved, and that such inferences are akin to
presumptions in law. It was observed that the law gives absolute
discretion to the Court to presume the existence of any fact
which it thinks likely to have happened. While inferring the
existence of one fact from another, the Court is only applying
the process of intelligent reasoning which the mind of a prudent
person would employ in similar circumstances, it was held. The
relevant part of the judgment reads thus:
“15. The word "proof" needs to be understood in the sense
in which it is defined in the Evidence Act because proof depends
upon the admissibility of evidence. A fact is said to be proved

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

13
2026:KER:71420
when, after considering the matters before it, the court either
believes it to exist, or considers its existence so probable
that a prudent man ought, under the circumstances of the
particular case, to act upon the supposition that it exists.
This is the definition given for the word "proved" in the
Evidence Act. What is required is production of such materials
on which the court can reasonably act to reach the supposition
that a fact exists. Proof of the fact depends upon the degree of
probability of its having existed. The standard required for
reaching the supposition is that of a prudent man acting in any
important matter concerning him. Fletcher Moulton L.J. in
Hawkins v. Powells Tillery Steam Coal Co. Ltd. (1911 (1) KB
988 : 1911 WN 53) observed like this:
"Proof does not mean proof to rigid mathematical
demonstration, because that is impossible; it must
mean such evidence as would induce a reasonable man
to come to a particular conclusion."
16. The said observation has stood the test of time and
can now be followed as the standard of proof. In reaching the
conclusion the court can use the process of inferences to be
drawn from facts produced or proved. Such inferences are akin to
presumptions in law. Law gives absolute discretion to the court
to presume the existence of any fact which it thinks likely to
have happened. In that process the court may have regard to
common course of natural events, human conduct, public or
private business vis a vis the facts of the particular case. The
discretion is clearly envisaged in S.114 of the Evidence Act.
17. Presumption is an inference of a certain fact drawn
from other proved facts. While inferring the existence of a fact
from another, the court is only applying a process of
intelligent reasoning which the mind of a prudent man would do
under similar circumstances. Presumption is not the final
conclusion to be drawn from other facts. But it could as well be
final if it remains undisturbed later. Presumption in law of
evidence is a rule indicating the stage of shifting the burden
of proof. From a certain fact or facts the court can draw an
inference and that would remain until such inference is either
disproved or dispelled.
18. For the purpose of reaching one conclusion the court
can rely on a factual presumption. Unless the presumption is
disproved or dispelled or rebutted, the court can treat the
presumption as tantamounting to proof.”

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

14
2026:KER:71420
14. Drawing a permissive presumption or an inference as to
the existence of a fact, depending upon the facts of a particular
case, is often indispensable to the process of appreciation of
evidence. Evidently, such inferences cannot be drawn out of thin
air, but must arise from the circumstances in which the
foundational facts are established through evidence. Trial Judges
and appellate Judges, while appreciating evidence, are guided by
such wider principles. It is only a process of intelligent
reasoning. In appropriate circumstances, this process may involve
drawing upon their general knowledge and experience. The Apex
Court, in Chaturbhuj Pande and Others v. Collector, Raigarh (AIR
1969 SC 255), observed that, while assessing the value to be
attached to oral evidence (in that case, for the purpose of
discarding unchallenged and uncontroverted oral evidence) the
trial Judges are bound to call into aid their experience of life
and, as Judges of fact, are entitled to test the evidence placed
before them on the basis of probabilities.
15. Indeed, a Judge is not permitted to rely upon specific
facts not proved by the evidence in the case, merely because they
are known to him personally or otherwise. At the same time, it is
equally clear that a Judge may, and indeed does, use his general

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

15
2026:KER:71420
knowledge and experience in assessing the credibility of the
evidence adduced before him and in applying it to the
determination of the specific facts in dispute in the case. (See
Mulpuru Lakshmayya and Others v. Sir Rajah Varadaraia Apparow ,
1912 23 MLJ 624).
16. Section 59 of the Indian Evidence Act, which corresponds
to Section 54 of Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, permits proof
of any fact by oral evidence, except the contents of documents or
electronic records. The question of entrustment of gold
ornaments, in most cases, depends upon an appreciation of the
oral evidence. The process of arriving at a conclusion, guided by
the broader principles embodied in Sections 3 and 114, as stated
above, should invariably be based on the facts and circumstances
of each case and not on any rigid rule. As held in Vinu K.S. and
Another v. Veena Viswan (supra), applying precedents in this
area, without regard to the facts and circumstances of the
particular case, would only be a puerile exercise.
17. In the cases of the above nature, most often, the
courts are called upon to consider a difficult factual situation,
namely, which of the rival versions of the oral evidence is more
probable and acceptable. In determining that question, the Judges

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

16
2026:KER:71420
of fact, as noted above, may sometimes test the evidence on the
touchstone of the principles discussed above. It is only a
process of intelligent reasoning, having regard to the factual
circumstances of the particular case.
18. As regards the question of entrustment of gold ornaments
to the first respondent, we have carefully re-appreciated the
oral evidence on record. PW1 deposed categorically, both in her
chief affidavit and during cross-examination, that the first
respondent obtained all her gold ornaments within a couple of
days of the marriage. She was subjected to a searching cross-
examination, but nothing was elicited to discredit her version.
The evidence of RW1 does not inspire confidence in this regard.
Pertinently, he falsely disputed the quantum of gold ornaments
possessed by the petitioner and even set up a case that all her
gold ornaments had been taken back by her mother and her friend,
Chacko Mathai, but did not attempt to examine the said person.
19. The trial court, having had the advantage of observing
the demeanour of the witnesses, preferred the version of PW1 over
that of RW1 in this regard. In the light of all the above, we are
of the view that the claim of the petitioner is more probable

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

17
2026:KER:71420
than that of the respondents. We therefore conclude that the
trial court was correct in holding that the first respondent had
obtained the gold ornaments of the petitioner.
20. However, we find that it is not possible to hold that
the entire quantity of gold ornaments worn by the petitioner was
taken away by the first respondent. Exts.B2 to B5 were marked in
evidence during the cross-examination of PW1. She admitted that
those photographs had been taken at a later point of time. It can
be seen from the said photographs that she was wearing certain
gold ornaments, including a small necklace, a chain and bangles.
As regards the necklace and chain, PW1 explained that they had
not been given to her at the time of her marriage. Her
explanation appears to be genuine, as far as the small necklace
and chain are concerned, when they are compared with the images
in Ext.B1. However, the same cannot be said with respect to the
bangles worn on her hands. Further, it is only probable that she
might have retained some of her gold ornaments, probably 10
sovereigns, for daily wear while entrusting the remaining
ornaments to her husband. Therefore, it can be inferred that the
first respondent had obtained 25 sovereigns of gold ornaments

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

18
2026:KER:71420
from the petitioner. The trial court did not notice this aspect.
To that extent, the decree requires modification.
21. In respect of the claim for return of ₹5,00,000/-, the
evidence of PW2, the mother of the petitioner, is convincing. She
specifically stated in her affidavit that, though the family
members of the first respondent had informed that they had no
demand for dowry, she had entrusted ₹5,00,000/- to the second
respondent in the presence of the first respondent. According to
her, the said amount was withdrawn from her bank account
maintained with the Federal Bank, Marine Drive Branch, by cheque
No.677624. Ext.A1 bank account statement was produced to
substantiate the said contention.
22. It was contended by the learned Senior Counsel appearing
for the respondents that the said claim is inherently improbable,
as PW2 deposed in her affidavit that the amount was withdrawn
from the bank on 14.09.2010, whereas, during cross-examination,
she stated that the amount was given to the second respondent on
the day following the betrothal, which could not be true since
the betrothal was held on 12.09.2010. We find no merit in the
said contention when her oral testimony is analysed together with

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

19
2026:KER:71420
Ext.A1 statement of account. It can be seen from Ext.A1 that she
had withdrawn ₹5,00,000/- on 04.09.2010 through cheque No.677624.
Therefore, the statement in the proof affidavit that she had
withdrawn ₹5,00,000/- through the said cheque on 14.09.2010 could
obviously be a mistake.
23. The learned Senior Counsel further contended that merely
because the petitioner was able to show that her mother had
withdrawn an amount on a particular day, that would not amount to
proof of entrustment of the same to the second respondent. We are
afraid we cannot agree with the said proposition. The evidence on
record has to be appreciated in its entirety. The oral testimony
of a witness has to be tested by the court in the light of
several elements, one such factor being the ability of the person
concerned to raise the requisite funds. Proof of withdrawal of
the amount from the bank and the proximity of such withdrawal to
the date on which it was allegedly given are aspects that would
lend credibility to the oral testimony, in the facts of the given
case. In view of the above materials, we accept the claim of the
petitioner that her mother had entrusted ₹5,00,000/- to the
second respondent as her family share. The second respondent is

Mat.Appeal No.234 of 2022 CNR : KLHC010214092022

20
2026:KER:71420
bound to return the said amount. Thus, we uphold the decree in
that regard.
In the result, the appeal is allowed in part. The first
appellant is directed to return 25 sovereigns of gold ornaments
to the respondent/wife within one month, failing which, the
respondent shall be entitled to recover the market value of 25
sovereigns of gold ornaments. The remaining part of the impugned
judgment is upheld.
Sd/-

SATHISH NINAN
JUDGE
Sd/-
P. KRISHNA KUMAR
JUDGE
sv