Som Dutt Sharma vs Presiding Officer Labour Court Gurgaon And Anr.
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CWP No.9883 of 2010 (O&M)-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
219
CWP No.9883 of 2010 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 16.11.2026
SOM DUTT SHARMA (SINCE DECEASED) THROUGH HIS LEGAL
REPRESENTATIVES; i) KAUSHALYA DEVI, (ii) LOKESH SHARMA, (iii)
KUSUMLATA AND (iv) VIVEK KUMAR.
....PETITIONERS
Versus
PRESIDING OFFICER, INDUSTRIAL TRIBUNAL-CUM-LABOUR COURT-
I, GURGAON AND ANOTHER
....RESPONDENTS
CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE KIRTI SINGH
Present: Mr. R.K. Malik, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Sandeep Dhull, Advocate and
Mr. Samrat Malik, Advocate for the petitioners (LRs).
Mr. D.S. Patwalia, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Rishu Bajaj, Advocate for respondent No.2.
*
KIRTI SINGH, J. (ORAL)
1. The present writ petition, as amended, has been filed under Articles
226/227 of the Constitution of India seeking quashing of the order dated
12.03.2010 (Annexure P-10) passed by the learned Industrial Tribunal-cum-
Labour Court-I, Gurgaon (hereinafter referred to as 'the learned Labour Court')
in Reference No.484 of 2001, whereby the preliminary issue regarding the
fairness and propriety of the domestic enquiry was decided against the workman,
as also the award dated 16.08.2012 (Annexure P-11), whereby the reference was
answered against the workman. A further direction is sought for reinstatement of
the workman with all consequential benefits.
2. The writ petition was originally instituted in the year 2010
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
challenging the order dated 12.03.2010 passed on the preliminary issue. During
CWP No.9883 of 2010 (O&M)-2-
its pendency, the learned Labour Court answered the reference vide award dated
16.08.2012. The application seeking amendment of the writ petition was allowed
on 13.05.2013 and the amended writ petition was taken on record. The
workman, Som Dutt Sharma, died on 16.12.2020 during the pendency of the
present petition. His legal representatives, namely Smt. Kaushalya Devi, Lokesh
Sharma, Smt. Kusumlata and Vivek Kumar, were brought on record vide order
dated 09.08.2022 passed in CM-11974-CWP-2022 and are now prosecuting the
present petition.
3. Briefly stated, as per the pleaded case of the petitioners, the
workman joined respondent No.2-Management on 23.11.1987 as an Attendant
and was promoted as Technician (Level-III) with effect from 02.02.1991. It is
the case of the petitioners that his service record remained unblemished and that
the controversy arose in the year 1994 with the induction of an officer, namely
Sh. Anil Sehgal, at whose instance the workman was transferred from the
vigilance department to the general department, despite his complaints to the
Managing Director (Annexures P-1 and P-2). It is further pleaded that on
06.03.1996, the workman received a letter (Annexure P-3) initiating domestic
enquiry proceedings in respect of a charge-sheet dated 02.02.1995, to which he
submitted a reply dated 07.03.1996 (Annexure P-4), stating that he had never
received the said charge-sheet. Sh. K.H. Jani, an officer of the Management, was
appointed as the Enquiry Officer. The petitioners allege that the Enquiry Officer
was biased; that the request of the workman for assistance of a person acquainted
with law or a co-worker of his choice was declined; that copies of the Certified
Standing Orders and the documents demanded by him were not supplied; that no
order was passed on his application seeking production of documents; and that
the cross-examination of the witnesses was recorded as dictated by the
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Management. During the pendency of the first enquiry, the workman was served
CWP No.9883 of 2010 (O&M)-3-
with another charge-sheet-cum-suspension order dated 21.09.1996. He objected
to the appointment of the same Enquiry Officer and also instituted a civil suit
seeking to restrain the Management from conducting the enquiry through him
(Annexure P-8). However, the Enquiry Officer was not changed. On the basis of
the enquiry reports, the services of the workman were terminated vide order
dated 11.11.1999 (Annexure P-9). Aggrieved thereby, he raised an industrial
dispute, which was referred for adjudication under Section 10(1)(c) of the
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (for short, 'the Act'), vide Reference No.484 of
2001.
4. The Management contested the reference, pleading that the
workman had been dismissed from service after holding a fair and proper
domestic enquiry. On the pleadings of the parties, the learned Labour Court
framed issues on 13.08.2003, including whether a fair and proper enquiry had
been conducted by the Management and whether the termination of services of
the workman was justified and in order. The issue regarding the fairness and
propriety of the enquiry was treated as a preliminary issue. The workman
examined himself and proved documents, whereas the Management did not lead
oral evidence at that stage and relied upon documents Ex.R1/1 to Ex.R1/18.
5. Vide order dated 12.03.2010 (Annexure P-10), the learned Labour
Court decided the preliminary issue against the workman. It noticed that the
enquiry proceedings (Ex.R1/4 and Ex.R1/5) bore the signatures of the workman
in token of his participation and that, in the first enquiry, the Management had
examined seven witnesses, whom the workman was afforded an opportunity to
cross-examine. It further noticed that, except one, the charges in the charge-sheet
dated 02.02.1995 relating to the incidents dated 24.12.1994, 11.01.1995 and
12.01.1995 stood proved, as reflected in Ex.R1/13. The learned Labour Court
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
concluded that the workman had been afforded an opportunity to cross-examine
CWP No.9883 of 2010 (O&M)-4-
the Management witnesses and to lead evidence; that no prejudice had been
established on account of the alleged non-supply of the list of witnesses or
documents; that the Enquiry Officer was justified in declining the assistance of
Mathew Abraham; and that neither any material contradiction in the statements
of the witnesses nor any bias on the part of the Enquiry Officer had been
established. The learned Labour Court further found that the order of dismissal
had been passed by the competent authority in terms of the delegation of powers
by the Board of Directors (Ex.MW1/1 to Ex.MW1/3). It also noticed that the
appeal preferred by the workman against the order of dismissal had been
considered and dismissed by the Managing Director on 28.12.1999, which was
communicated to him vide letter dated 07.01.2000. Relying upon Mahindra and
Mahindra Ltd. Vs. N.B. Narawade, (2005) 3 SCC 134 and Tata Engineering
and Locomotive Co. Ltd. Vs. N.K. Singh, (2006) 12 SCC 554, the learned
Labour Court declined to interfere with the quantum of punishment.
6. Learned senior counsel for the petitioners submits that the domestic
enquiry was conducted in violation of the principles of natural justice. It is
contended that the documents relied upon by the Management were not supplied
to the workman and that neither the list of witnesses nor the list of documents
was furnished to him. It is further argued that the assistance of a co-employee of
his choice was declined, thereby depriving him of an effective opportunity to
defend himself. It is also contended that the Enquiry Officer, being an officer of
the Management against whom the workman had instituted a civil suit, was
biased and that the request for change of the Enquiry Officer was wrongly
declined. Reliance is placed upon Daya Nand College for Women Vs. State of
Haryana, 1994(4) SCT 646, to contend that where fresh documents and
witnesses are permitted to be introduced by the Management without supplying
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.9883 of 2010 (O&M)-5-
copies and necessary information to the delinquent employee, the enquiry
proceedings stand vitiated.
7. Learned senior counsel further submits that the punishment of
dismissal is disproportionate to the alleged misconduct and that the learned
Labour Court failed to appropriately exercise its jurisdiction under Section 11-A
of the Act. It is also argued that the appeal preferred by the workman was
decided by an incompetent authority and that no personal hearing was afforded
to him despite his request.
8. Per contra, learned senior counsel appearing for respondent No.2
submits that the workman participated in the enquiry proceedings throughout
and that the documents demanded by him were made available for inspection. It
is contended that the workman inspected the list of witnesses and the documents
submitted by the Management and took notes thereof on 09.04.1996. It is further
submitted that, under the Certified Standing Orders, the workman could be
represented only by a co-worker and not by an advocate; that he was permitted
to avail the assistance of a co-worker; and that, after the Management evidence
was concluded, he declined to lead evidence in defence. It is also argued that the
plea of bias was not raised in the statement of claim and that the findings
recorded by the Enquiry Officer are based on the evidence available on record.
9. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the relevant
material on record.
10. The scope of interference by this Court under Articles 226/227 of
the Constitution of India in matters arising out of awards passed by Labour
Courts and Industrial Tribunals is well settled. This Court does not sit as an
appellate authority over the findings recorded by the Labour Court, nor is it
expected to reappreciate the evidence merely because another view may be
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
possible. Interference is warranted where the findings suffer from perversity, are
CWP No.9883 of 2010 (O&M)-6-
based on no evidence, or are vitiated by an error of law apparent on the face of
the record.
11. The question, therefore, is whether the findings recorded by the
learned Labour Court, either on the fairness and propriety of the domestic
enquiry or on the validity of the order of dismissal, suffer from any such
infirmity warranting interference.
12. At the outset, the objection regarding the maintainability of the writ
petition, as originally instituted against the order passed on the preliminary issue,
deserves consideration. Respondent No.2 had relied upon the judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Cooper Engineering Ltd. Vs. P.P. Mundhe, (1975) 2
SCC 661, in support of its objection. There is no dispute that the writ petition
was initially filed against the order dated 12.03.2010, whereby the preliminary
issue regarding the validity of the domestic enquiry was decided against the
workman. However, during the pendency of the petition, the learned Labour
Court proceeded to adjudicate the remaining issues and passed the final award
dated 16.08.2012. The said award was thereafter brought under challenge by
way of amendment, which was allowed on 13.05.2013.
13. In these circumstances, the challenge is no longer confined to an
interlocutory order passed on the preliminary issue. Both the order dated
12.03.2010 and the final award dated 16.08.2012 are now under challenge. The
objection, therefore, does not warrant dismissal of the petition on the ground of
prematurity, and the matter is accordingly examined on merits. The principal
grievance of the petitioners concerns the alleged non-supply of documents and
the list of witnesses during the domestic enquiry. In this regard, the enquiry
report pertaining to the charge-sheet dated 02.02.1995 (Annexure R-3) assumes
significance.
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.9883 of 2010 (O&M)-7-
14. A perusal of the enquiry proceedings reveals that, on the first date
of the enquiry, a copy of the charge-sheet was handed over to the workman. On
his expressing difficulty in understanding English, the Presenting Officer was
directed to furnish its Hindi translation. When the workman sought copies of the
reports of Ashok Kumar, Anil Sehgal and S.P. Sarin, along with the list of
witnesses, the Enquiry Officer directed the parties to submit the relevant
documents.
15. The proceedings further record that, on 27.03.1996, the Presenting
Officer submitted the list of witnesses along with the report of Ashok Kumar
dated 24.12.1994 and other relevant documents. The workman was permitted to
inspect the documents and take notes thereof, which he admittedly did on
09.04.1996. The Enquiry Officer also offered to explain the documents to him in
Hindi, while the Presenting Officer undertook to supply the Hindi translation of
the statement of Ashok Kumar. It is also borne out from the enquiry proceedings
that the Management witnesses were examined in the presence of the workman
and were subjected to cross-examination by him or his co-worker.
16. The learned Labour Court, after examining the enquiry record,
specifically returned a finding that no prejudice had been established on account
of the alleged non-supply of the list of witnesses or documents. Even before this
Court, learned senior counsel for the petitioners has not been able to identify any
particular document relied upon against the workman which was withheld from
him, or demonstrate how the alleged non-supply of such document materially
impaired his defence. The mere assertion that copies of all the documents were
not furnished, by itself, would not be sufficient to invalidate the enquiry in the
absence of a demonstration that the workman was denied an effective
opportunity to meet the charges. The relevant consideration is whether the
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
procedure adopted resulted in any actual prejudice to the delinquent employee
CWP No.9883 of 2010 (O&M)-8-
17. In the present case, the record reflects that the documents were
made available for inspection, the workman took notes thereof and the
Management witnesses were subjected to cross-examination. No specific
prejudice arising from the alleged procedural irregularity has been demonstrated.
The reliance placed upon Daya Nand College for Women (supra) is also
misplaced. The said judgment was relied upon by the petitioners to contend that
where fresh documents and witnesses are permitted to be introduced without
furnishing the requisite information and copies to the delinquent employee, the
enquiry would stand vitiated.
18. There is no material on record in the present case to establish that
the Management was permitted to introduce any fresh document or witness
behind the back of the workman without affording him an opportunity to meet
the same. On the contrary, the enquiry proceedings indicate that the list of
witnesses and the relevant documents were submitted before the Enquiry Officer
and made available for inspection.
19. The record further reveals that Ashok Kumar and A.K. Pal were
recalled for further cross-examination at the request of the workman's co-worker.
The workman was also permitted to submit a list of defence witnesses. However,
vide his letter dated 27.12.1996, he stated that he did not wish to produce any
witness and that he would not continue with the assistance of his co-worker. In
these circumstances, the ratio of the judgment relied upon by the petitioners does
not advance their case.
20. The next contention relates to the denial of assistance of a co-
worker of the workman's choice. The record indicates that the workman initially
sought the assistance of a lawyer and thereafter requested the assistance of
Mathew Abraham, General Secretary of the Maruti Employees Union.The
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Enquiry Officer, vide letter dated 12.03.1996, informed the workman that he
CWP No.9883 of 2010 (O&M)-9-
could avail the assistance of a co-worker. The request for assistance of Mathew
Abraham was not accepted. However, the workman was permitted to avail the
assistance of another co-worker and was, in fact, represented by Madan Lal
Sharma, who participated in the enquiry and cross-examined the Management
witnesses. The record further indicates that the workman subsequently chose not
to continue with the assistance of his co-worker. In these circumstances, it
cannot be said that the workman was completely deprived of assistance in
defending himself. The petitioners have also failed to demonstrate how the
refusal to permit Mathew Abraham, in particular, resulted in any prejudice to the
workman or materially impaired his defence.
21. The learned Labour Court has considered this aspect and found the
Enquiry Officer justified in declining the assistance sought. No perversity in the
said finding has been demonstrated.
22. The plea of bias against the Enquiry Officer also does not merit
acceptance. The petitioners primarily rely upon the fact that the Enquiry Officer
was an officer of the Management and that the workman had instituted a civil
suit seeking to restrain him from conducting the enquiry. However, the mere fact
that the Enquiry Officer was an employee of the Management would not, by
itself, establish bias. The allegation of bias must be supported by material
circumstances demonstrating that the enquiry was conducted with a
predetermined or unfair approach.
23. The learned Labour Court has specifically examined this objection
and found that no material was brought on record to establish bias against the
Enquiry Officer. Even before this Court, no specific instance demonstrating that
the Enquiry Officer acted with prejudice or conducted the proceedings unfairly
has been pointed out. The institution of a civil suit by the workman, seeking a
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
change of the Enquiry Officer, cannot by itself be treated as proof of bias. In the
CWP No.9883 of 2010 (O&M)-10-
absence of any independent material demonstrating a reasonable apprehension of
bias or actual prejudice in the conduct of the proceedings, the finding recorded
by the learned Labour Court does not call for interference.
24. The other objections concerning the non-supply of the Certified
Standing Orders and the manner in which the cross-examination was recorded
have also been considered. The petitioners have not been able to point out any
specific provision or material on record demonstrating that the alleged non-
supply of the Certified Standing Orders deprived the workman of an effective
opportunity to defend himself. Likewise, the allegation that the cross-
examination was recorded as dictated by the Management remains
unsubstantiated by any specific instance or material contradiction in the enquiry
proceedings.
25. It is also relevant that the enquiry proceedings bear the signatures of
the workman in token of his participation. The Enquiry Officer did not
mechanically accept every charge, but extended the benefit of doubt to the
workman in respect of the allegation concerning his absence from his place of
work on 24.12.1994. This circumstance also lends support to the conclusion that
the evidence was considered on its merits.
26. Viewed cumulatively, the material on record does not establish any
procedural irregularity of such nature as would render the domestic enquiry
unfair or contrary to the principles of natural justice. The finding of the learned
Labour Court upholding the fairness and propriety of the enquiry is, therefore,
based on the material available on record and does not suffer from any
perversity.
27. Coming to the challenge to the award dated 16.08.2012, the learned
Labour Court, after considering the evidence led by the parties, returned a
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
finding that the charges against the workman stood proved. These included
CWP No.9883 of 2010 (O&M)-11-
abusing and threatening a supervisor, refusing to load material and hand over the
keys of the forklift, failure to perform the allotted work and unauthorised use of
the Management's photocopy machine.
28. The learned Labour Court also considered the service record of the
workman, which had been graded in the 'C' category from 1991-92 to 1995-96.
The findings were recorded after considering the evidence led before it,
including the testimony of the workman as WW1 and that of Om Prakash as
MW1 on behalf of the Management. The petitioners have not been able to
demonstrate that the findings regarding the misconduct were based on no
evidence or that any material piece of evidence was ignored. This Court, while
exercising supervisory jurisdiction, would not substitute its own assessment of
the evidence for that of the learned Labour Court merely because another view
may be possible.
29. The contention regarding the proportionality of punishment and
non-exercise of jurisdiction under Section 11-A of the Act also deserves
consideration.
30. The power conferred upon the Labour Court under Section 11-A of
the Act enables it to examine the justification of the order of discharge or
dismissal and, where appropriate, to grant suitable relief. However, the existence
of such power does not mean that the punishment of dismissal must necessarily
be substituted by a lesser punishment in every case.
31. In the present case, the learned Labour Court considered the nature
of the misconduct found established against the workman, his past service record
and the material relating to the disciplinary proceedings. It thereafter declined to
interfere with the punishment of dismissal, placing reliance upon Mahindra and
Mahindra Ltd. (supra) and Tata Engineering and Locomotive Co. Ltd. (supra).
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.9883 of 2010 (O&M)-12-
32. Having regard to the nature of the misconduct established, which
included insubordination, refusal to perform assigned duties and unauthorised
use of the Management's property, the petitioners have not been able to
demonstrate that the punishment imposed was so disproportionate as to warrant
interference by this Court in exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction.
33. No material has been brought to the notice of this Court to establish
that the learned Labour Court ignored any relevant circumstance while
considering the challenge to the punishment. Consequently, no ground for
interference is made out on this count.
34. The final contention relates to the competence of the authority
which passed the order of dismissal and the manner in which the departmental
appeal was decided. The learned Labour Court examined the delegation of
powers by the Board of Directors and the relevant documents produced by the
Management, namely Ex.MW1/1 to Ex.MW1/3. It recorded a finding that the
order of dismissal dated 11.11.1999 had been passed by the competent authority.
The award further records that the order of dismissal was signed by Sh. P.
Chakrabartty, Department Manager (PAP), and that the appeal preferred by the
workman was considered and dismissed by Sh. Khattar, Managing Director, on
28.12.1999. The decision was thereafter communicated to the workman vide
letter dated 07.01.2000 issued by Sh. P. Sudhakar, Department Manager
(EMR).Thus, the contention that the appeal was decided by an authority other
than the Managing Director is not borne out from the findings recorded by the
learned Labour Court. The fact that the decision was communicated by another
officer does not establish that the appeal itself was decided by that officer.
35. The further grievance that no personal hearing was afforded to the
workman in the departmental appeal also does not warrant interference. The
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
petitioners have not been able to point out any specific provision of the
CWP No.9883 of 2010 (O&M)-13-
applicable Certified Standing Orders requiring a personal hearing in the
departmental appeal. Nor has any prejudice resulting from the alleged denial of
such hearing been demonstrated.
36. In the absence of any material establishing that the appeal was
decided by an incompetent authority or that the procedure adopted resulted in
any prejudice to the workman, the finding recorded by the learned Labour Court
does not warrant interference.
37. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds that the learned
Labour Court has considered the objections raised by the workman with regard
to the fairness and propriety of the domestic enquiry, the evidence concerning
the alleged misconduct, the quantum of punishment and the competence of the
authorities concerned. The petitioners have not been able to establish that the
findings recorded in the order dated 12.03.2010 or the award dated 16.08.2012
suffer from perversity, illegality or any error of law apparent on the face of the
record warranting interference under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of
India.
38. Accordingly, finding no merit in the present writ petition, the same
is dismissed.
39. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
(KIRTI SINGH)
JUDGE
November 16, 2026
SwarnjitS
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes
Whether reportable: No
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document