Mohammad Zakir vs State of U.P.
- Court
- Allahabad High Court
Reserved on 24.08.2026
Delivered on 17.11.2026
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. - 4855 of 2021
Mohammad Zakir
.....Appellant(s)
Versus
State of U.P.
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s) : Deepesh Kumar Ojha, Janardan Yadav,
Nand Lal Yadav, Prem Chandra, Ram
Janam Shahi, Sharad Yadav
Counsel for Respondent(s) : Dilnawaz Ahmad Khan, G.A., Yogesh
Kumar Mishra
Court No. - 43
HON'BLE SIDDHARTH, J.
HON'BLE VINAI KUMAR DWIVEDI, J.
(Delivered by Hon'ble Siddharth, J.)
1. Heard Sri Sri Deepesh Kumar Ojha, learned counsel for the appellant;
learned A.G.A. for the State and perused the judgment passed by the trial
court as well as trial court record.
2. This criminal appeal has been preferred against the judgement and order
dated 16.10.2021 passed by Sessions Judge (POCSO Act) Azamgarh in
S.S.T. No.128 of 2020 arising out in Case Crime No.167 of 2020, U/S 363,
366, 376(3) I.P.C. and U/S 3/4 POCSO Act, P.S. Kotwali, District
Azamgarh, whereby the learned trial court has convicted the appellant U/S
376(3) I.P.C. to life imprisonment, fine of Rs. 20,000/- and in default of
payment of fine to undergo 3 months additional imprisonment; U/S 363
I.P.C. to 4 years rigorous imprisonment, fine of Rs. 5,000/- and in default of
payment of fine to undergo 1 month simple imprisonment and U/S 366
I.P.C. to 7 years rigorous imprisonment, fine of Rs. 10,000/- and in default
of payment of fine to undergo 2 months simple imprisonment, and all the
sentences are run concurrently.
3. The prosecution case is that the informant, Mohd. Talib, son of Mohd.
Anas Sakin, is a resident of Mohalla Pahadpur, Police Station Kotwali,
District Azamgarh. The house of the informant's in-laws is situated at
Village Vindawal, Police Station Bilriyaganj, District Azamgarh. The
appellant is also a resident of the same village and used to work at the house
CRLA No. 4855 of 2021
2
of the informant's in-laws. Consequently, he used to visit the informant's
house in connection with household matters, due to which the informant and
his family respected him. On 23.03.2020, the informant, along with his wife,
went to visit their relatives, leaving only his daughter (the victim), aged
about 15 years, and his son, namely, Mohd. Savish, aged about 13 years, at
home. At around 03:00 P.M., the appellant came to the informant's house,
lured his daughter (the victim), and took her away with him. When the
informant returned home at night and inquired about the victim, his son
informed him that the appellant had taken her away with him. Thereafter, the
informant made inquiries about the appellant and came to know that he was
a person of bad character who used to lure and take away girls, commit
wrongful acts with them for a few days, and thereafter sell or kill them and
dispose of their bodies. It was also learnt that he had been involved in
several such incidents in the past. The informant searched for the victim at
the houses of his relatives but could not ascertain her whereabouts. The
appellant's mother, namely, Sakira, had assisted the appellant in committing
the said act and was aware of the victim's whereabouts. Despite the
informant having informed the police station and the Superintendent of
Police about the incident, no report was lodged, and no action was taken.
Therefore, the informant prayed that the S.H.O., Kotwali, Azamgarh, be
directed to register the F.I.R. and take appropriate legal action.
4. The prosecution examined PW-1, informant, Mohd. Talib (father of the
victim); PW-2, victim; PW-3, Ehrar Ahamed; PW-4, Vinjay Kumar Dubey,
Investigating Officer; PW-5, Seema Parween, Head Mistress of School and
PW-6, Dr. Roshan Ara, District Hospital, Azamgarh.
5. The statement of the accused recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C., wherein
he claimed that he had been falsely implicated in this case. He stated that the
victim had given her statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C. under the pressure
of PW-4 and PW-5, who had also not given correct statements before the
court. He further stated that he was innocent and that the victim had eloped
with him of her own free will. The FIR had been lodged on false
allegations.
6. We have gone through the statements of the witnesses and the
documentary evidence on record. We have also heard learned counsel for the
appellant and learned AGA appearing for the State at length.
7. We find that the FIR in the present case was lodged pursuant to an
application dated 24.06.2020 filed under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C., whereas the
incident in question took place on 23.03.2020. The aforesaid application was
allowed by the court on 03.07.2020, directing the registration of the FIR and
investigation of the case. There does not appears to be any justification on
record for the delay in lodging the FIR, particularly when the informant,
PW-1, claimed that he had come to know about the incident on the date of its
occurrence itself (23.03.2020). There is no explanation as to why he did not
CRLA No. 4855 of 2021
3
lodged the FIR or informed any of the concerned authorities promptly. The
victim in her first statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C. recorded on
28.8.2020 claimed that she was aged about 19 years and admitted eloping
with the appellant on her own free will and marring him. She stated that she
wanted to live with the appellant. However, in her statement under Section
164 Cr.P.C., recorded on 01.09.2020, she changed her version and alleged
that she had been forcibly compelled to enter into Nikah with the appellant.
The medical examination of the victim, conducted on 28.08.2020, was quite
belated. Nothing incriminating was found therein by the doctor. The age of
the victim was determined on the basis of her school transfer certificate.
PW-5, the Headmistress of the School, stated the dates of her admission to
school and leaving of the school; however, the basis for recording her date of
birth at the time of admission to the school was not proved in accordance
with the provisions of Section 94 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection
of Children) Act, 2015.
8. PW-1 stated before the Court in his cross-examination that he had been
married for the last about 15 years and that his eldest daughter had attained
the age of about 15 years, which is not possible.
9. PW-2 stated before the Court that she had been enticed away by the
appellant and was subjected to wrongs for two months. Thereafter, the police
rescued her from the place where she had been kept by the appellant.
10. PW-3, Ehrar Ahamed, is the maternal uncle of the victim and brother-in-
law of the informant, and his testimony further weakens the prosecution
case. In his examination-in-chief itself, he stated that he came to know about
the incident from the informant and that, about 2-3 days after the date of the
incident, the informant visited his house. Thereafter, both of them went
together to the house of the appellant. When they reached the appellant's
house, the victim was present there. PW-3 tried to convince his niece to
return home, but she told him that she had married the appellant and would
live with him only. He further stated that they were living together as
husband and wife. Thus, the statement of PW-3 itself makes it clear that the
informant came to know about the whereabouts of his daughter (the victim)
within 2-3 days of the incident, yet he did not take any immediate action.
The F.I.R. was ultimately registered only after a lapse of more than three
months.
11. PW-4, Vinay Kumar Dubey, S.I., Police Station Kotwali, District
Azamgarh, was the Investigating Officer in the present case. He conducted
the investigation and submitted the charge-sheet only against the appellant,
while Sakira, the mother of the appellant, was exonerated during the course
of the investigation. He prepared Parcha No. 4 dated 28.08.2020, containing
the details of the recovery of the victim and her statement under Section 161
Cr.P.C.; Parcha No. 6 dated 31.08.2020, containing the medical report and
the statement of the doctor; Parcha No. 7 dated 01.09.2020, containing the
CRLA No. 4855 of 2021
4
statement of the victim under Section 164 Cr.P.C.; Parcha No. 9 dated
03.09.2020, reflecting the arrest of the appellant on 03.09.2020 at about
08:30 A.M. from Junaidganj Crossing, Azamgarh; and Parcha No. 10 dated
01.09.2020, recording that the victim was handed over to her parents.
12. In his cross-examination, PW-4 admitted that the site plan prepared by
him was based on the instructions of the informant and not those of the
victim. With regard to the recovery of the victim, he stated that he, along
with a lady constable, had recovered the victim on 28.08.2020 from Hafizpur
Crossing, Azamgarh, and not from any other place. He further stated that
neither he nor any of his colleagues had visited Mumbai in connection with
the investigation of the present case.
13 . A perusal of the statement of PW-4 gives rise to several doubts regarding
the reliability of the prosecution case. One such material contradiction
relates to the recovery of the victim. The Investigating Officer stated that the
victim was recovered on 28.08.2020 from Hafizpur Crossing, Azamgarh,
whereas the victim herself stated that she had been recovered from Mumbai
and brought back by the Azamgarh Police. There is also a material
discrepancy regarding the statement of the victim under Section 164 Cr.P.C.,
which was recorded on 01.09.2020. The victim stated that her parents were
present with her when her statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C. was
recorded, thereby raising the possibility that she might have given the
statement under their influence or pressure. However, according to the
Investigating Officer, the victim was handed over to her parents only on
04.09.2020. Thus, there is a material gap as to where and in whose custody
the victim remained between 28.08.2020, when she was allegedly recovered,
and 04.09.2020, when she was handed over to her parents. This aspect has
not been satisfactorily explained by the prosecution.
4. PW-5, Seema Parween, Principal of Dr. Saleem Memorial School,
1
Pahadpur, stated in her examination-in-chief that the date of birth of the
victim was recorded as 15.07.2005 and that she had been admitted to the
school on 30.04.2012 in Class II. However, in her cross-examination, she
stated that the date of birth mentioned in the admission form had been
written by the parents of the victim. She further stated that the school had
since been closed and was no longer functioning. Thus, the testimony of
PW-5 does not establish the age of the victim through any independent or
reliable documentary evidence. The date of birth mentioned in the admission
form was admittedly furnished by the parents of the victim and is not
supported by any other document establishing the basis or correctness of
such date of birth.
15. The Apex Court in the case of
P. Yuvaprakash v. State Rep. by
Inspector of Police, Criminal Appeal No. 1898 of 2023 has held that School
Transfer Certificate is not relevant for deciding the date of birth of the victim
as follows:
CRLA No. 4855 of 2021
5
" 14. Section 94 (2)(iii) of the JJ Act clearly indicates that the date of birth
certificate from the school or matriculation or equivalent certificate by the
concerned examination board has to be firstly preferred in the absence of
which the birth certificate issued by the Corporation or Municipal Authority
or Panchayat and it is only thereafter in the absence of these such
documents the age is to be determined through "an ossification test" or "any
other latest medical age determination test" conducted on the orders of the
concerned authority, i.e. Committee or Board or Court. In the present case,
concededly, only a transfer certificate and not the date of birth certificate or
matriculation or equivalent certificate was considered. Ex. C1, i.e., the
school transfer certificate showed the date of birth of the victim as
11.07.1997. Significantly, the transfer certificate was produced not by the
prosecution but instead by the court summoned witness, i.e., CW-1. The
burden is always upon the prosecution to establish what it alleges;
therefore, the prosecution could not have been fallen back upon a document
which it had never relied upon. Furthermore, DW-3, the concerned Revenue
Official (Deputy Tahsildar) had stated on oath that the records for the year
1997 in respect to the births and deaths were missing. Since it did not
answer to the description of any class of documents mentioned in Section
94(2)(i) as it was a mere transfer certificate, Ex C-1 could not have been
relied upon to hold that M was below 18 years at the time of commission of
the offence.
19. It is clear from the above narrative that none of the documents produced
during the trial answered the description of "the date of birth certificate
from the school" or "the matriculation or equivalent certificate" from the
concerned examination board or certificate by a corporation, municipal
authority or a Panchayat. In these circumstances, it was incumbent for the
prosecution to prove through acceptable medical tests/examination that the
victim's age was below 18 years as per Section 94(2)(iii) of the JJ Act. PW-
9, Dr. Thenmozhi, Chief Civil Doctor and Radiologist at the General
Hospital at Vellore, produced the X-ray reports and deposed that in terms of
the examination of M, a certificate was issued stating "that the age of the
said girl would be more than 18 years and less than 20 years". In the cross-
examination, she admitted that M's age could be taken as 19 years.
However, the High Court rejected this evidence, saying that "when the
precise date of birth is available from out of the school records, the
approximate age estimated by the medical expert cannot be the determining
factor". This finding is, in this court's considered view, incorrect and
erroneous. As held earlier, the documents produced, i.e., a transfer
certificate and extracts of the admission register, are not what Section 94 (2)
(i) mandates; nor are they in accord with Section 94 (2) (ii) because DW-1
clearly deposed that there were no records relating to the birth of the victim,
M. In these circumstances, the only piece of evidence, accorded with Section
94 of the JJ Act was the medical ossification test, based on several X-Rays of
the victim, and on the basis of which PW-9 made her statement. She
explained the details regarding examination of the victim's bones, stage of
their development and opined that she was between 18-20 years; in cross-
CRLA No. 4855 of 2021
6
examination she said that the age might be 19 years. Given all these
circumstances, this court is of the opinion that the result of the ossification
or bone test was the most authentic evidence, corroborated by the examining
doctor, PW-9."
16. For determination of her age, the victim was referred, however, no result
regarding the same was ever received, and no C.M.O. report or ossification
test report was brought on record to conclusively establish the age of the
victim. The age of the victim was determined solely on the basis of the date
of birth recorded in the Transfer Certificate issued by the school, which has
subsequently been permanently closed. It is also relevant to mention that the
victim herself stated in her statement under Section 161 of the Cr.P.C. that
she was aged about 19 years. Thus, despite the victim having been referred
to the C.M.O. for age determination, no report regarding the ossification test
or any other medical age-assessment was produced before the learned trial
court, and the prosecution solely relied upon the Transfer Certificate. These
circumstances raise serious doubts regarding the determination of the age of
the victim.
17. PW-6, Dr. Roshan Ara, who conducted the medical examination of the
victim on 28.08.2020, stated in her examination-in-chief that, upon external
examination of the victim, no mark of injury was found. Upon internal
examination, the hymen was found to be torn, but no other mark of injury
was present. Samples for D.N.A. examination were collected, and a vaginal
smear was prepared for pathological examination, including spermatozoa
analysis. For the purpose of age determination, she referred the victim to the
C.M.O. However, in her cross-examination, PW-6 stated that she had
received no result regarding the samples sent for D.N.A. examination. She
further stated that she had referred the victim to the C.M.O. for age
determination, but she could not state whether any result had been received,
as she had no knowledge thereof, and no supplementary report had been
brought on record. She also stated that the victim had been brought before
her by a lady constable, namely Mamta, and that the mother of the victim
was accompanying her.
18. The medical examination of the victim was conducted on 28.08.2020,
i.e., on the very same day on which she was allegedly recovered. The doctor,
PW-6, stated that the victim had been brought for medical examination by a
lady constable, namely Mamta, and that her mother was also accompanying
her. This circumstance raises a serious doubt as to when and under what
circumstances the victim came into contact with her parents. According to
the Investigating Officer, the victim was handed over to her parents only on
04.09.2020. If that be so, it remains unexplained as to how and under what
circumstances her mother was accompanying her at the time of her medical
examination on 28.08.2020. Further, the victim stated that her parents were
present when her statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C. was recorded on
01.09.2020. Thus, a material and unexplained discrepancy arises regarding
CRLA No. 4855 of 2021
7
the custody and whereabouts of the victim between 28.08.2020 and
04.09.2020, which casts serious doubt upon the prosecution story and the
circumstances in which the subsequent statement of the victim was recorded.
19. In the statement of the appellant recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C., a
total of 12 questions were put to him, and he answered all of them.
According to his statement, the victim was aged about 18 years; her
statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C. had been given under the influence and
pressure of her parents; the documents relied upon for determining the age of
the victim were false and did not disclose her actual date of birth; and the
victim had left her house of her own free will. The appellant further stated
that he had not committed any offence.
20. When the evidence of PW-1, PW-2, PW-3 and PW-4 is examined
collectively, it becomes evident that their statements regarding the incident
and the subsequent events contain material contradictions and
inconsistencies. These contradictions go to the root of the prosecution case
and render the prosecution version highly doubtful.
21. The unexplained delay in lodging the F.I.R., despite the informant
allegedly having become aware of the incident on the very same day and
having come to know about the whereabouts of the victim within 2-3 days of
the incident, raises serious doubts regarding the conduct of the informant and
the genuineness of the prosecution version.
22. Despite these material weaknesses and inconsistencies in the prosecution
evidence, the learned trial court placed substantial reliance upon such
doubtful and inconsistent statements. Such reliance is contrary to the settled
principles governing the appreciation of evidence, particularly where the
testimony of material witnesses suffers from material contradictions and
does not inspire confidence.
23. In
Santosh Prasad @ Santosh Kumar v. State of Bihar, (2020) 3
Supreme Court Cases 443, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed
regarding solitary testimony of prosecution as follows:
5.2 From the impugned judgments and orders passed by both the courts
"
below, it appears that the appellant has been convicted solely relying upon
the deposition of the prosecutrix (PWS). Neither any independent witness
nor even the medical evidence supports the case of the prosecution. From
the deposition of PW1, it has come on record that there was a land dispute
going on between both the parties. Even in the cross-examination even the
PW5-prosecutrix had admitted that she had an enmity with Santosh
(accused). The prosecutrix was called for medical examination by Dr. Renu
Singh - Medical Officer and PW7 - Dr. Renu Singh submitted injury report.
CRLA No. 4855 of 2021
8
In the injury report, no sperm as well as RBC and WBC were found. Dr.
Renu Singh, PW7 - Medical Officer in her deposition has specifically opined
and stated that she did not find any violence marks on the body of the victim.
She has also categorically stated that there is no physical or pathological
evidence of rape. It is true that thereafter she has stated that possibility of
rape cannot be ruled out (so stated in the examination-in-chief). However, in
the cross-examination, she has stated that there was no physical or
pathological evidence of rape.
5.4.2 In the case of Rai Sandeep alias Deepu (supra), this Court had an
occasion to consider who can be said to be a "sterling witness". In
paragraph 22, it is observed and held as under:
"22 In our considered opinion, the "sterling witness" should be of a very
high quality and calibre whose version should, therefore, be unassailable.
The court considering the version of such witness should be in a position to
accept it for its face value without any hesitation. To test the quality of such
a witness, the status of the witness would be immaterial and what would be
relevant is the truthfulness of the statement made by such a witness. What
would be more relevant would be the consistency of the statement right from
the starting point till the end, namely, at the time when the witness makes the
initial statement and ultimately before the court. It should be natural and
consistent with the case of the prosecution qua the accused. There should
not be any prevarication in the version of such a witness. The witness should
be in a position to withstand the cross-examination of any length and
howsoever strenuous it may be and under no circumstance should give room
for any doubt as to the factum of the occurrence, the persons involved, as
well as the sequence of it. Such a version should have co- relations with
each and every one of other supporting material such as the recoveries
made, the weapons used, relation with each and every one of other the
manner of offence committed, the scientific evidence and the expert opinion.
The said version should consistently match with the version of every other
witness. It can even be stated that it should be akin to the test applied in the
case of circumstantial evidence where there should not be any missing link
in the chain of circumstances to hold the accused guilty of the offence
alleged against him. Only if the version of such a witness qualifies the above
test as well as all other such similar tests to be applied, can it be held that
such a witness can be called as a "sterling witness" whose version can be
accepted by the court without any corroboration and based on which the
guilty can be punished. To be more precise, the version of the said witness
on the core spectrum of the crime should remain intact while all other
attendant materials, namely, oral, documentary and material objects should
match the said version in material particulars in order to enable the court
trying the offence to rely on the core version to sieve the other supporting
materials for holding the offender guilty of the charge alleged."
5.4.3 In the case of Krishna Kumar Malik v. State of Haryana (2011) 7 SCC
130, it is observed and held by this Court that no doubt, it is true that to hold
CRLA No. 4855 of 2021
9
an accused guilty for commission of an offence of rape, the solitary evidence
of the prosecutrix is sufficient provided the same inspires confidence and
appears to be absolutely trustworthy, unblemished and should be of sterling
quality.
5.5 With the aforesaid decisions in mind, it is required to be considered,
whether is it safe to convict the accused solely on the solitary evidence of the
prosecutrix? Whether the evidence of the prosecutrix inspires confidence
and appears to be absolutely trustworthy, unblemished and is of sterling
quality?"
In the present case also, the testimony of the victim does not satisfy the test
of a "sterling witness," and the principles laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Santosh Prasad (supra) squarely apply to the facts and
circumstances of the present case.
24. In view of the aforesaid inconsistencies, contradictions, unexplained
circumstances and gaps in the prosecution evidence, it is evident that the
prosecution has failed to establish the guilt of the appellant beyond
reasonable doubt.
25. In view of the above considerations, it appears that the prosecution has
failed to prove its case against the appellant beyond reasonable doubt. He
deserves to be granted the benefit of doubt.
26. The judgment and order of the trial court is set aside.
27. The appellant is in jail since 03.09.2020. He is directed to be released
forthwith, if not required in connection with any other case.
28. The above noted criminal appeal is allowed.
29 Office is directed to send back trial court record and notify this judgment
to the trial court, within two weeks.
November 17, 2026
Ruchi Agrahari
(Vinai Kumar Dwivedi,J.) (Siddharth,J.)
Digitally signed by :-
RUCHI AGRAHARI
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad