SIVAPERUMAL, M/52 YEARS vs STATE REP BY
- Court
- Madras High Court
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF MADRAS
Reserved on : 28.09.2026
Pronounced on : 13.11.2026
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE M.NIRMAL KUMAR
CRL.A.No.527 of 2018
Sivaperumal ... Appellant / Accused
Vs.
State rep. By
The Inspector of Police,
Eriyur Police Station,
Pennagaram Sub Division,
Dharmapuri District
(Crime No.90/2014) ... Respondent / Complainant
PRAYER: Criminal Appeal filed under Section 374(2) of Cr.P.C.,
to set aside the conviction and sentence imposed by the learned
Principal Sessions Judge, Dharmapuri, in S.C.No.31 of 2016, by
judgment dated 09.08.2018, and to acquit the appellant.
For Appellant : Mr.R.Dhanasekar
For Victim : Ms.S.Thatshinya
Legal Aid Counsel
For Respondent : Mrs.Sharada Vivek,
Additional Public Prosecutor,
1
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
JUDGMENT
This Criminal Appeal is directed against the Judgment, dated
09.08.2018, passed by the learned Principal Sessions Judge,
Dharmapuri, in S.C.No.31 of 2016.
2. By the impugned judgment, the Appellant / Accused found
not guilty of the offence punishable under Section 294(b) of the
Indian Penal Code (hereinafter referred to as “IPC”) and was
accordingly acquitted of the said charge under Section 235(1) of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as
“Cr.P.C.”). However, the trial Court found him guilty of the other
charges and convicted and sentenced him as follows:
Sl.
Provision of Law Sentence Imposed
No
Section 3(1)(r) of the Scheduled
Castes and the Scheduled Tribes
(Prevention of Atrocities) Act, as
amended by the Amendment
Ordinance, 2014 (hereinafter
referred to as “the SC/ST Act”)
To undergo Rigorous
Imprisonment for one year
and to pay a fine of Rs.500/-,
in default, to undergo
Rigorous Imprisonment for
three months.
1.
To undergo Rigorous
Imprisonment for one year
and to pay a fine of Rs.500/-,
in default, to undergo
Rigorous Imprisonment for
three months.
2. Section 3(1)(s) of the SC/ST Act
To pay a fine of Rs.500/-,
with the default sentence as
imposed by the trial Court.
3. Section 341 IPC
2
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
3. The trial Court further directed that all the substantive
sentences of imprisonment shall run concurrently. It also ordered
that the period of imprisonment, if any, already undergone by the
appellant shall be set off under Section 428 Cr.P.C. The total fine
amount imposed under all the three counts was Rs.1,500/-.
4. For the sake of convenience and clarity, the Complainant,
Govindan, who examined as PW1 before the trial Court, shall
hereinafter be referred to as “PW1” or “the complainant”, as the
context may require. The remaining witnesses shall be referred to by
their respective witness numbers assigned to them before the trial
Court.
5. The respondent in this appeal is the State, represented by
the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Pennagaram Sub-Division,
Dharmapuri District, in connection with Crime No. 90 of 2014, on the
file of the Eriyur Police Station. The alleged occurrence is stated to
have taken place at Aralgundhi Village, which shall hereinafter be
referred to as "Aralgundhi" for the sake of uniformity throughout this
judgment.
6. The case of the prosecution, in brief, are that the accused
is a resident of Aralgundhi village, Pennagaram Taluk, and belongs to
3
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
the Vanniyar community, classified as a Most Backward Class (MBC).
PW1 is a resident of Vathalpatti Village and belongs to the Adi
Dravidar community, which is a Scheduled Caste. He is an elected
Member (Councillor) of the Pennagaram Panchayat Union, and his
official duties require him to visit various villages falling within his
jurisdiction. On 09.08.2014, at about 7.00 p.m., PW1, accompanied
by PW6 Thangaraj, went to Aralgundhi Village in connection with
their work. At that time, the accused obstructed PW1, abused him by
referring to his caste name, using obscene expressions in Tamil, and
threatened to cut him to death, if he ventured to walk through the
street in which the accused resided. By making such caste-based
remarks in a place within public view, the accused intentionally
insulted and humiliated PW1 on the ground of his caste, thereby
causing him mental agony. On these allegations, the accused
prosecuted for the offences punishable under Sections 341, 294(b)
and 506(ii) IPC, read with Sections 3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s) of the SC/ST
Act.
7. According to PW1, immediately after the occurrence, he
contacted the Eriyur Police over the telephone from the place of
occurrence and informed them about the incident. The police arrived
at the spot, whereupon the accused fled on seeing them. However,
PW1 lodged a written complaint (Ex.P1) on 12.08.2014, i.e., three
days after the alleged occurrence, at Eriyur Police Station. On the
basis of the said complaint, PW10, the Special Sub-Inspector of
4
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
Police, registered a case in Crime No.90 of 2014, for the offences
punishable under Sections 341 and 506(ii) IPC, read with Sections
3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s) of the SC/ST Act. The printed First Information
Report marked as Ex.P4.
8. By proceedings dated 12.08.2014 (Ex.P5), the
Superintendent of Police, Dharmapuri, entrusted the investigation of
the case to PW11, the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Pennagaram
Sub-Division. In the course of investigation, PW11 visited the place of
occurrence, prepared observation mahazar (Ex.P2) and the rough
sketch (Ex.P6), in the presence of PW8 and one Vijayakumar. He
examined the witnesses and arrested the accused at 10.15 a.m. on
12.08.2014 at the Poochur bus stop, following which the accused
remanded to judicial custody.
9. On a requisition made by PW11 on 25.09.2014, PW9, the
Tahsildar, issued the Community Certificate relating to PW1 (Ex.P3).
The community certificate relating to the accused (Ex.P7) issued by
the then Deputy Tahsildar, Ramalingam (since deceased). The said
certificates disclosed that PW1 belonged to the Adi Dravidar
community and that the accused belonged to the Vanniyar
community.
10. Upon completion of the investigation, PW11 laid the final
report on 01.12.2014. After furnishing copies of the relevant
documents to the accused under Section 207 Cr.P.C., the learned
5
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
Judicial Magistrate, Pennagaram, committed the case to the Court of
Session under Section 209 Cr.P.C., in P.R.C.No.31 of 2015, for trial.
11. The accused pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried. To
establish its case, the prosecution examined eleven witnesses,
namely, PW1 to PW11, and marked seven documents, namely, Ex.P1
to Ex.P7. No material object was produced before the trial Court.
12. Among the witnesses, PW2 Radhakrishnan, PW3 Ammasi,
PW4 Arthanari, PW5 Deivanai and PW7 Arjunan all residents of
Aralgundhi Village. PW6 Thangaraj also a resident of the said village
who accompanied PW1 at the time of the alleged occurrence. PW8
Natarajan examined as the mahazar witness. PW9/ Tahsildar, who
issued the community certificate relating to PW1, while PW10 /
Special Sub-Inspector of Police who registered the case. PW11 /
Deputy Superintendent of Police, was the investigating officer.
13. When the accused questioned under Section 313 Cr.P.C.
with regard to the incriminating circumstances appearing against
him in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses, he denied the same
and contended that a false case had been foisted against him. The
accused neither examined any witness nor marked any document on
his side.
14. The reasoning adopted by the trial Court, insofar as it is
relevant to the present appeal, may be summarised as follows:
6
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
(a) The trial Court held that the delay of three days in lodging
the complaint satisfactorily explained and could not be attributed to
any fault on the part of the complainant. In arriving at such a
conclusion, the trial Court relied upon the evidence of PW1, PW4 and
PW6, who spoken about PW1 having gone away in connection with
the death of a relative.
(b) The trial Court held that the prosecution witnesses spoken
about the accused having wrongfully obstructed PW1. Relying upon
the decision in Madala Peraiah v. Voruganti Chendriah, AIR 1954
Mad 247, the trial Court concluded that the ingredients of the
offence punishable under Section 341 IPC established.
(c) The trial Court found that none of the witnesses, PW1 to
PW7, specifically spoken about the obscene words allegedly uttered
by the accused or established that the alleged utterances caused
annoyance to others. Consequently, the accused acquitted of the
charge under Section 294(b) IPC.
(d) Offences under Sections 3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s) of the SC/ST
Act: After discussing the expressions “public view”, “intentional
insult” and “humiliation”, the trial Court held that PW1 to PW7
consistently spoken about the occurrence, PW8 spoken about the
preparation of the mahazar, PW9 established the community
particulars of PW1 and the accused through the community
certificates, PW10 and PW11 spoken about the registration of the
7
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
case and the subsequent investigation. The trial Court further
observed that the caste of the complainant not disputed and that the
discrepancies pointed out on behalf of the accused not material
enough to discredit the prosecution case. On such reasoning, the trial
Court found the accused guilty of the offences under Sections 3(1)(r)
and 3(1)(s) of the SC/ST Act. (Paragraphs 17 to 35 and 39 to 44).
(e) The contention raised on behalf of the accused regarding
non-compliance with Rule 7 of the Scheduled Castes and the
Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Rules, 1995, was rejected
by the trial Court on the ground that the Deputy Superintendent of
Police duly nominated to investigate the case through the
proceedings marked as Ex.P5.
15. Mr.R.Dhanasekar, the learned counsel for the appellant
assailed the judgment contending that the prosecution case rests on
witnesses who contradict one another, and the benefit of doubt ought
to have been given. The occurrence is alleged on 09.08.2014 and the
complaint lodged only on 12.08.2014 and the reason now given, the
death of a relative, was stated neither in the statement under Section
161 Cr.P.C. nor in the chief examination. PW1 not named the
deceased, the village or the relationship and the Investigating Officer
admits that no explanation was given to him. PW1 himself deposed
that two policemen came to the spot within two hours, that he
narrated the occurrence to them and that they noted it down. That
earliest information suppressed. PW6 Thangaraj is the political rival
8
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
of the appellant and the leader of a local political party, under whose
support PW1 won the panchayat election, there was no quarrel
between PW1 and the appellant, and the complaint lodged at the
instigation of PW6. PW2 is a close relative of PW6. The occurrence
said to have been in front of the appellant’s house, not in a public
place and no offence under the SC/ST Act is made out. The
Investigating Officer not examined Semmalai, Kuppan, Madhu,
Karuppuchetty and others living near the place of occurrence. Except
the FIR and the complaint, the other materials were sent to the
committal Court only on 26.08.2015, and delay unexplained. Hence,
the learned counsel for the appellant prayed for setting aside the
conviction and sentence imposed by the learned Principal Sessions
Judge, Dharmapuri, and to acquit the appellant.
16. Mrs.Sharada Vivek, the learned Additional Public
Prosecutor, strongly opposed the relief sought for by the appellant
and supported the judgment of the trial Court. She submitted that the
respective caste identities of PW1 and the appellant stood
established through Ex.P3 and Ex.P7 and were not in dispute. She
further contended that PW1 to PW7 consistently deposed that the
appellant abused PW1 by referring to his caste name, threatened him
and wrongfully obstructed him in the presence of villagers, at a place
within public view. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor further
submitted that PW2 to PW5 and PW7 all residents of the appellant's
village, and not related to PW1 and no apparent reason to falsely
9
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
implicate a fellow villager. The delay of three days in lodging the
complaint satisfactorily explained due to the death of a relative of
PW1, as spoken to by PW1, PW4 and PW6. The discrepancies in the
testimonies of the prosecution witnesses were only minor and
natural, particularly considering that they were examined more than
three years after the occurrence. She also submitted that the
investigation conducted by an officer of the rank of Deputy
Superintendent of Police, appointed by the Superintendent of Police.
According to her, the trial Court properly appreciated the oral and
documentary evidence and rightly recorded the conviction. On these
grounds, she prayed for dismissal of the appeal.
17. Ms.S.Thatshinya, the learned Legal Aid Counsel appointed
by this Court to represent PW1, the victim, whose right to be heard
through an advocate is recognized under Section 15-A of the SC/ST
Act, also supported the judgment of the trial Court. She submitted
that PW1, being a Scheduled Caste Member and an elected
Councillor, was publicly abused by referring to his caste name and
threatened by the appellant in the presence of villagers. She further
contended that the testimony of PW1, being that of the victim, did not
require independent corroboration, provided it inspired the
confidence of the Court. In any event, his testimony stood
corroborated by the evidence of PW2 to PW5 and PW7, who were
residents of the appellant's village. The learned Legal Aid Counsel
further submitted that the delay in lodging the complaint
satisfactorily explained and that the discrepancies pointed out in the
10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
prosecution evidence were minor in nature and attributable to the
passage of time. She emphasised that the SC/ST Act was enacted to
protect members of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes,
from humiliation and indignity and that the provisions of the Act
ought not to be construed or applied in a hyper technical manner so
as to defeat its protective object. On these grounds, she prayed that
the appeal be dismissed.
18. I have carefully considered the rival submissions advanced
by the learned counsel appearing on either side, including the
submissions made by the learned Legal Aid Counsel representing the
victim, and have meticulously perused the oral and documentary
evidence available on record, together with the judgment of the trial
Court.
19. An appeal under Section 374 Cr.P.C. is an appeal on facts as
well as on law. This Court is entitled, and indeed bound, to re-
appreciate the evidence and to come to its own conclusion, giving
due weight to the findings of the trial Court, which saw the
witnesses, but bearing in mind that the presumption of innocence is
available to the accused throughout and that the prosecution must
prove its case beyond reasonable doubt (Chandrappa v. State of
Karnataka, (2007) 4 SCC 415) . Where two views are reasonably
possible on the evidence, the view favourable to the accused must be
preferred. The caste of PW1 (Ex.P3) and of the appellant (Ex.P7) is
not in dispute, and the appeal does not turn on it.
11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
20. The points that arise for determination are:
(1) Whether the delay in registering the FIR, and
the non-production of the information said to have
recorded by the police at the spot on 09.08.2014, have
been satisfactorily explained, and, if not, what follows;
(2) Whether the evidence of PW1 and of the other
eye-witnesses are reliable, having regard to its internal
consistency and to the background of village and party
rivalry;
(3) Whether the ingredients of Section 341 IPC
and of Sections 3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s) of the SC/ST Act
proved beyond reasonable doubt;
(4) Whether the appreciation of evidence by the
trial Court is sustainable; and
(5) What relief the appellant is entitled to.
21. Section 339 IPC defines the offence of wrongful restraint. It
provides that whoever voluntarily obstructs any person so as to
prevent that person from proceeding in any direction in which he has
a right to proceed is said to wrongfully restrain that person. Section
341 IPC prescribes the punishment for such wrongful restraint. Thus,
the essential ingredients of the offence are (i) voluntary obstruction
of a person by the accused; and (ii) such obstruction must have the
effect of preventing that person from proceeding in a direction in
which he has a right to proceed. Mere verbal prohibition or
remonstrance, without any actual obstruction resulting in the
12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
curtailment of the person's liberty of movement, would not, by itself,
constitute the offence. As the trial Court itself extracted in paragraph
12 of its judgment, the essence of the offence lies in the abridgment
of the liberty of a person against his will.
22. Sections 3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s) of the SC/ST Act, which, as
noticed by the trial Court in paragraph 30 of its judgment,
substantially correspond to the erstwhile Section 3(1)(x), prescribe
punishment for specified acts committed by a person who is not a
member of a Scheduled Caste or a Scheduled Tribe against a
member of either of those communities. While clause (r) penalises
the intentional insult or intimidation of a member of a Scheduled
Caste or a Scheduled Tribe, with intent to humiliate such person, in
any place within public view, clause (s) penalises the abuse of such a
person by his caste name in any place within public view. Thus, apart
from establishing the requisite community status of the victim and
the accused, the prosecution is required to establish the essential
ingredients of the respective offences, including the intentional
nature of the act and the specific intention to humiliate under clause
(r), as well as the commission of the act in a place within public view.
23. It is significant that the statute employs the expression “any
place within public view” and not the expression “public place”. The
distinction between these two expressions has been explained by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Swaran Singh v. State, (2008) 8 SCC
435 . As explained therein, an occurrence taking place in an open
13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
area, where the act can be seen or heard by members of the public,
may fall within the expression “within public view”, even if the place
is situated in front of a private house. Conversely, an occurrence
taking place within the four walls of a building, in the presence of
only relatives or friends, would not ordinarily satisfy that
requirement. The trial Court correctly noticed this distinction in
paragraphs 21 to 24 and 29 of its judgment. Therefore, the
contention of the appellant that the alleged occurrence took place in
front of his house and, consequently, could not be regarded as having
taken place in a public place, does not, by itself, advance his case.
The decisive question is not whether the place was a public place in
the ordinary sense, but whether the prosecution has satisfactorily
established that the alleged caste-based abuse was uttered in
circumstances where it was within the public view. In other words,
the question that falls for consideration is whether the evidence of
the witnesses, who claim to have witnessed and heard the alleged
occurrence, is worthy of acceptance. This takes us to an examination
of the reliability and credibility of the prosecution witnesses.
24. The trial Court observed and finds there is rivalry between
the parties namely, appellant and the witnesses who have allegiance
to rival political parties hence evidence must be scrutinized with
greater care, caution and that the allegation of intentional insult
must be supported by cogent and independent evidence. It further
observed that the testimony of the witnesses must be consistent and
14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
reliable. These principles furnish the necessary yardstick for
evaluating the evidence in the present case. In a criminal trial, the
burden rests entirely upon the prosecution to establish the guilt of
the accused beyond reasonable doubt. The Court must be satisfied
that the accused must have committed the offence and not merely
that he may have committed it. The distinction between these two
standards was emphatically explained by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, (1984) 4
SCC 116, wherein it was observed that there is a long distance
between the expressions “may be true” and “must be true”. It is in
the light of this settled principle that the evidence adduced by the
prosecution in the present case has to be examined.
25 . The occurrence is alleged to have taken place on
09.08.2014, at about 7:00 p.m. The written complaint (Ex.P1) lodged
on 12.08.2014 at Eriyur Police Station, situated at a distance of 18
Kilometers from the place of occurrence viz., Aralgundhi, whereupon
the First Information Report (Ex.P4) came to be registered. PW1 is a
resident of Vathalpatti, located 8 Kilometers away from Aralgundhi.
Though it is settled law that a delay of three days in lodging the FIR
is not by itself fatal to the prosecution, the Court is duty-bound to
examine whether such delay satisfactorily explained and whether the
interregnum afforded room for deliberation, consultation, and
embellishment, as held in Thulia Kali v. State of T.N., (1972) 3
SCC 393 . The learned Trial Judge, merely noted the prosecution’s
15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
submission attributing the delay to the de facto complainant, and
held that there was no delay on his part, without either evaluating
the plausibility of the explanation or appreciating the attending
circumstances on record.
26 . In my considered view, the attending circumstances strike
at the very root of the prosecution case and emerge unmistakably
from the testimony of the prosecution’s own witnesses. PW1 deposed
that he telephoned Eriyur Police Station from the scene of
occurrence and two police personnel one in uniform and the another
in plain clothes arrived at the spot, inquired as to the identity of
Govindan, heard PW1’s narration of the incident, and reduced the
same into writing, though his signature not obtained thereon. PW6
corroborated the arrival of the police, testifying that they inquired as
to who created the disturbance, conducted a search for about two
hours, left stating that they would look into the matter the next
morning, and noted down what transpired, while PW1 sent away in
their presence. PW4 likewise deposed that the police visited the spot
on the very day of the occurrence and recorded the statements of
himself, PW2, and PW3. Although PW2 stated that the two policemen
questioned PW1 without reducing anything into writing, this minor
variance does not detract from the undisputed position that the
police arrived at the scene within hours of the occurrence and were
apprised of the incident by PW1. The grievance raised in the grounds
16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
of appeal regarding the suppression of this earliest information is
thus borne out by the record.
27 . Consequently, on the very evening of 09.08.2014, the police
put on notice of the commission of alleged cognizable offences
directly by the aggrieved person in the presence of co-villagers, and
the said information is stated to have reduced into writing. Under
settled principles of criminal jurisprudence, the earliest information
disclosing the commission of a cognizable offence recorded by the
police constitutes the First Information Report under Section 154 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, and any subsequent report in
respect of the very same occurrence is hit by Section 162 Cr.P.C.,
being merely a statement recorded during the course of investigation
as held by Hon’ble Supreme Court in T.T. Antony v. State of
Kerala, (2001) 6 SCC 181 ). However, the prosecution neither
produced that earliest written record nor exhibited the General Diary
of Eriyur Police Station to reflect the receipt of the telephonic
message and the consequent police visit on 09.08.2014. Furthermore,
neither of the two police personnel who visited the spot examined,
nor any explanation offered for their non-examination, with the
Investigating Officer (PW11) maintaining complete silence on this
vital aspect.
17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
28. Where material evidence, documentary or ocular available
to the prosecution is withheld without plausible explanation, an
adverse inference necessarily arises under Illustration (g) to Section
114 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, that such evidence, if
produced, would have been unfavourable to the prosecution. A
prompt FIR serves as the strongest safeguard against embellishment
and afterthought, its suppression renders it wholly unsafe to treat
Ex.P1 and Ex.P4, brought into existence three days later, as a
spontaneous report capable of sustaining a conviction. The
explanation belatedly proffered for the delay namely, the demise of a
relative does not cure this fundamental infirmity. Pertinently, no such
explanation forthcoming in the examination-in-chief of PW1. PW10,
the Special Sub-Inspector who registered the case, candidly admitted
that he sought no explanation for the three-day delay, while PW11,
the Investigating Officer, deposed that no such reason disclosed
during the course of investigation. This explanation surfaced for the
first time during the cross-examination of PW1 and was echoed by
PW6 and PW4, bereft of elementary particulars such as the name of
the deceased, village, degree of relationship, or the date of death.
Even assuming arguendo that there was a bereavement in the family,
it would at best explain why PW1 not personally visited the police
station, it offers no justification whatsoever as to why the police
machinery, having already visited the scene of occurrence, heard
18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
PW1, and ascertained the identity of the accused, failed to register a
case that very night, remained wholly inactive on 10.08.2014 and
11.08.2014, and swung into action only on 12.08.2014. Such
unexplained inertia is all the more glaring considering that PW1 an
elected Panchayat Union Councilor with telephonic access at the spot
and accompanied throughout by PW6, the Union Secretary of his
political party.
29. Further, PW7, a prosecution witness, deposed that the
accused fled from the spot and apprehended by the police the very
next day. Per contra, the Investigating Officer (PW11) asserted that
the accused arrested on 12.08.2014 at 10:15 a.m. While the defence
suggestions put to PW1 and PW11 to the effect that the accused kept
in illegal detention at the police station for three days and falsely
implicated upon his refusal to meet an unlawful demand of
Rs.50,000/- were denied and remain unsubstantiated, and this Court
does not rest its conclusion thereon, the unchallenged testimony of
the prosecution’s own witness (PW7) stands wholly unexplained. It
runs directly counter to the prosecution’s claim of a prompt and
genuine registration of the case on 12.08.2014, and no attempt was
made by the prosecution, either by way of re-examination or
otherwise, to clarify or reconcile this material contradiction.
19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
30. PW1 is the complainant, while PW2 to PW7 are projected as
eyewitnesses to the occurrence. PW8, however, is not an eyewitness.
The versions of these witnesses, as emerging from their depositions
in chief-examination and cross-examination, disclose several
variations concerning the time and duration of the occurrence, the
intervention of the police, the flight of the accused and the other
surrounding circumstances. PW1 places the occurrence at about 7.00
p.m. on 09.08.2014 and deposed in chief-examination that he was
prevented from leaving for four hours, whereas Ex.P1 refers to a
period of about three hours. In cross-examination, he deposed that
the police arrived two hours after the accused started shouting. He
claims to have telephoned Eriyur Police, following which two
policemen, one in uniform, came to the spot and noted what he
stated, though he did not sign any statement. According to him, the
accused ran away with a billhook and a stick on seeing the police. He
names PW2, PW7, Natarajan, PW3 and PW5 as persons who
intervened and admits previous quarrels between the accused and
PW6, as well as that PW6 had secured his elected position. PW2 also
places the occurrence at about 7.00 p.m. and states that the oral
quarrel continued for three hours and that he intervened. He speaks
of two policemen, one in uniform, coming to the spot and questioning
PW1, but specifically states that they did not write down what PW1
told them. He is the maternal uncle of PW6 and belongs to the same
20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
political party. He does not refer to any weapon. PW3, on the other
hand, places the occurrence at 3.00 p.m. on Saturday and states that
it continued for three hours, during which PW1 was not allowed to
leave. He states that the police questioned him only three days later.
He refers to a knife and states that PW6 had kept Dhanapal's family
out of the village, describing PW6 as the village headman. PW4
places the occurrence at about 7.00 p.m., without specifying its
duration. He states that the police came to the spot and the accused
ran away. He further claims that the police recorded what he, PW2
and PW3 stated on that day. He refers to a billhook and speaks of
previous quarrels and enmity between PW6 and the accused.
According to him, the entire village witnessed the occurrence. PW5
states that the quarrel continued for three hours and that about fifty
persons witnessed it. Unlike PW1, PW4 and PW6, she states that the
accused ran away before the police arrived and that she did not see
the police coming to the scene. She further states that the police
questioned her only three days later. She also speaks of previous
quarrels between the accused and PW6 and identifies her husband as
the village headman. PW6 states that the occurrence lasted for two
hours. Significantly, he describes it as involving no striking dispute
and admits that he pushed the accused. According to him, the police
arrived after one to one-and-a-half hours, enquired as to who created
the trouble, and the accused thereafter ran away. He further states
that the police searched for two hours and left, PW1 was sent away
in their presence, and the police noted what had happened. He
21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
admits that he was PW1's party patron and an adversary of the
accused. He also states that his father is the village headman and
does not refer to any weapon. PW7, as recorded in his deposition,
places the occurrence at 7.00 a.m., though he states that the police
arrived at 8.00 p.m. He speaks of more than ten persons witnessing
the occurrence and states that the accused ran away and was
apprehended by the police on the following day. He names only PW4,
PW3 and PW2 as persons present and identifies one Perumal as the
village headman. He does not refer to any weapon. As regards PW8,
he is admittedly not an eyewitness. He states that he was passing
near Aralgundhi School when the police were making enquiries. He
resides about 18 to 20 kilometres away, does not know the accused
and admits that he signed the mahazar without knowing its contents.
31 . The prosecution characterises these inconsistencies as
minor discrepancies. The settled legal test, however, is whether such
contradictions are merely normal errors of memory attributable to
the passage of time, or whether they go to the very root of the matter
and strike at the credibility of the witnesses. While it may be
accepted that the witnesses broadly converge on a bare core namely,
the accused uttered a caste epithet and threatened to cut PW1 a
substantial part of the surrounding substratum of the prosecution
case stands mutually contradicted, not merely by the defence, but by
the prosecution witnesses themselves:-
22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
(a) PW1, PW2, PW4, Ex.P1 and the final report place the
occurrence at about 7.00 p.m. PW3 places it at 3.00 p.m. on a
Saturday. PW7, as recorded, gives the time as 7.00 a.m., though he
also states that the police arrived at 8.00 p.m. PW11, in his cross-
examination, gives the time of occurrence as 9.00 p.m. Some of
these discrepancies may be attributable to recording errors. I do not
rest my conclusion on any one of them. Nevertheless, considered
cumulatively with the other inconsistencies, they demonstrate that
the evidence regarding the time of occurrence is far from consistent.
(b) The alleged obstruction is stated to have lasted for four
hours (PW1 in chief-examination), about three hours (Ex.P1, Ex.P5,
PW2, PW3 and PW5), or two hours (PW6). PW1 deposed in chief-
examination that he telephoned the police after four hours, whereas,
in cross-examination, he states that the police arrived two hours after
the accused started shouting. These versions do not sit comfortably
with each other.
(c) PW1, PW4 and PW6 state that the accused ran away when
the police arrived. PW5, on the other hand, states that the accused
run away before the police arrived and she did not see the police
coming to the scene. While PW1, PW4 and PW6 state that the police
recorded the information furnished to them, PW2 states that the
police did not write it down. PW3 and PW5 state that they were
23
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
questioned by the police only three days later. These are materially
different accounts of the police intervention and the events
immediately following the occurrence.
(d) PW1 states that the accused stood on the road holding a
stick and a billhook (koduval). PW3 speaks of a knife, while PW4
refers to a billhook. PW2, PW5, PW6 and PW7 do not mention any
weapon. More significantly, PW6 states that, although the accused
talked for two hours, there was no "striking" dispute and that it was
only an oral quarrel. He further admits that he pushed the accused
away. This account is difficult to reconcile with PW1's version that
the accused was holding both a billhook and a stick in the presence
of a crowd. The absence of any reference to a weapon by several
witnesses assumes significance in this context.
32. The evidence of PW8 deserves separate consideration.
According to PW1, as reflected in the trial Court's summary of the
evidence Natarajan one of the persons who intervened at the scene
and asked the accused not to speak in that manner. PW8, however,
resides at Pannavadiyan Kadu, about 18 to 20 kilometres away, states
that he does not know the accused, and claims only to have been
passing near Aralgundhi School when the police making enquiries.
He further admits that he signed the observation mahazar without
knowing its contents. His evidence, therefore, does not establish his
presence as an eyewitness to the occurrence. More importantly, his
own testimony does not support PW1's version that he was one of
24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
those who intervened at the scene. The second mahazar witness,
Vijayakumar, has not been examined.
33. It is not the prosecution case that the accused had any prior
dispute with PW1. PW1 himself states that he had none, and that the
accused first abused him when he came to Aralgundhi along with
PW6 (“why do you bring Thangaraj, do not enter our village”). The
trial Court’s own summary of his evidence records that there was
previous enmity between the accused and PW6. In cross-examination,
PW1 admits that the accused and PW6 quarrelled orally two or three
times. PW6, a resident of Aralgundhi holding a post in a Political
Party secured the party ticket for PW1 and ensured his election from
the ward reserved for the Scheduled Castes. PW6 himself states that
he and PW1 travel together daily on the same two-wheeler for party
work, that he “got the seat” for PW1, and that PW1 serves in the
party’s union working committee a post subordinate to that of Union
Secretary, which PW6 holds.
34. The other witnesses reinforce this backdrop. PW4, a
prosecution witness, deposed that PW6 and the accused often
quarrelled and harboured previous enmity. PW5 confirms that the
accused and PW6 had prior quarrels. PW2 admits that PW6 is his
maternal uncle, that both belong to the same political party, and the
accused formerly in that party before moving to another. PW3, PW4,
and PW5 admit that the family of one Dhanapal had been ostracized
25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
from the village. PW3 deposed that this was done by PW6 over non-
payment of village tax, and as headman, some obey him while others
do not. The defence suggestion that those who defy PW6’s word are
forced out of the village and these witnesses depose out of fear
denied and remains unsubstantiated. Nevertheless, the record clearly
establishes that the village divided, PW6 was the accused’s political
and personal adversary, and PW6 wielded far greater influence than
an ordinary co-villager.
35. I do not suggest that a witness is to be rejected merely
because he is interested or belongs to a faction. Enmity is a double-
edged weapon, it may supply a motive for the accused to commit the
offence, and equally a motive to implicate him falsely as held by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Dalip Singh v. State of Punjab, AIR
1953 SC 364 . Nor can a person who abuses another by his caste
name escape liability under the Act merely because the quarrel
originated elsewhere. The point is a narrower one. On the
prosecution’s own showing, the animus was directed at PW6, whom
PW1 had accompanied, and PW1 is a person who owes his elected
office to PW6. PW1 himself, PW2 (a close relative of PW6), PW6, and
the villagers deposing alongside them fall into the category of
witnesses whose evidence must be scrutinized with care and, where
contradicted on important particulars, cannot safely be acted upon
without corroboration in material particulars. Though the trial Court
noted this contention, it failed to adjudicate upon it.
26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
36. There is no independent corroboration on record. The
Investigating Officer admits that he did not examine Semmalai,
Kuppan, Madhu, Karuppuchetty, and other residents living near the
scene of occurrence, and he did not state in the final report that they
unwilling to give evidence. If the incident indeed took place on a
public village road in the presence of fifty persons, as PW5 claims, it
is significant that no neutral or disinterested witness examined.
While the non-examination of independent witnesses is not fatal
where the evidence adduced is cogent and consistent, that is
conspicuously not the case here.
37. The sequence of events on 12.08.2014 calls for scrutiny.
According to PW10, PW1 arrived at the police station at 7.00 a.m.
(6.00 a.m. in cross-examination), a printed FIR registered, and a
report dispatched to the Superintendent of Police at Dharmapuri,
who issued proceedings in Ex.P5 on the same date. PW11 received
the authorization and, by his own account as well as Ex.P2, was
present at the scene of occurrence at Aralgundhi 18 kilometres from
Eriyur by 7.30 a.m. This compresses the registration of the FIR,
transmission of the report to district headquarters, issuance of
authorization by the Superintendent of Police, and travel to the
village into a span of thirty to ninety minutes. PW11 further claims
that he prepared the observation mahazar and rough sketch at the
27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
spot, examined nine witnesses, recorded their statements, and
arrested the accused at the Poochur bus stop at 10.15 a.m. PW1,
however, deposes that the Deputy Superintendent of Police visited his
house only at 1.30 or 2.00 p.m. that day. Moreover, the FIR reached
the Judicial Magistrate, Pennagaram, only at 3.15 p.m., even though
PW10 admits that the journey takes barely an hour, and PW10 does
not state through whom, or at what time, it transmitted to the Deputy
Superintendent of Police. While it cannot be said that these steps
impossible, their unexplained compression into a narrow window
leaves the Court unable to treat the investigation as an objective
verification of the complaint.
38. Ex.P1 is a handwritten complaint in Tamil. PW1 admits that
he studied only up to third standard and can read printed text, but
not handwritten material. PW10 does not know who scribed Ex.P1 or
whether PW1 is capable of reading and writing. PW1 himself does not
disclose the identity of the person who prepared the complaint. He
further admits that Ex.P1 does not contain any reference to his
having telephoned his brother, nephew and brother-in-law, who
allegedly came to the scene of occurrence. Thus, the authorship of
Ex.P1 remains unexplained, and there is no evidence to establish that
its contents were read over or explained to PW1 before he signed it.
These circumstances assume significance particularly because the
complaint was lodged three days after the occurrence. Ex.P1,
28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
therefore, cannot be readily treated as a spontaneous or
contemporaneous account of the occurrence, and its evidentiary
value must be assessed with due caution.
39. The sole evidence of obstruction, within the meaning of
Section 339 IPC, is that of PW1, who states that when he was about
to leave on his two-wheeler, the accused stood on the road with a
stick and a billhook and asked how he would go. PW3 states generally
that PW1 not allowed to leave for three hours. PW4 and PW5 speak
only of abuse and threats and say nothing of any obstruction, while
PW2 and PW6 describe an oral altercation lasting two or three hours
in which PW6 pushed the accused away. No other witness states that
the accused physically blocked PW1’s vehicle, or that PW1 attempted
to depart and prevented from doing so. The trial Court, having
extracted an authority holding that mere verbal remonstrance does
not constitute wrongful restraint, merely recorded that the
ingredients “are established by the prosecution witnesses” without
explaining how. For the reasons already stated, PW1’s
uncorroborated version is unsafe to act upon. The charge under
Section 341 IPC is, therefore, not proved beyond reasonable doubt.
40 . For the same reasons, the offences under the SC/ST Act
also fail. Had the evidence established that the offending words
uttered and heard by members of the public, the requirement of
29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
“public view” would not have difficult to satisfy. However, the entire
proof of the utterance, the place, the audience, and the requisite
intent rests on PW1 and the villagers PW2 to PW5 and PW7 whose
testimonies, as demonstrated above, diverge materially on the time
and duration of the incident, the arrival of the police and the flight of
the accused, the persons present, the weapon carried, and even the
identity of the village headman. This testimony emanates from a
divided village where the complainant’s political patron and the
accused were adversaries. It was reduced to writing three days after
the event, and only after the police had, on the prosecution’s own
showing, received and noted an earlier account on the night of the
occurrence which has been withheld from the Court. There is not a
single independent witness. On such infirm evidence, it is impossible
to hold that the accused must have uttered the caste name in a place
within public view with the intent to humiliate PW1. At the highest,
the prosecution case rests in the realm of “may be true”, and the
distance between “may be true” and “must be true” remains
unbridged.
41 . The trial Court’s reasoning is unsustainable. First, it suffers
from manifest internal contradiction. The trial Court acquitted the
accused of the charge under Section 294(b) IPC on the ground that
none of PW1 to PW7 spoke to the utterance of obscene or abusive
words, and Ex.P1 and Ex.P4 contained no mention of such words. Yet
PW3, PW4, and PW6, for instance, did speak of an abusive epithet,
and on the other hand, the very same Court held that almost all the
30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
prosecution witnesses supported the case that PW1 was insulted and
threatened “by using filthy abused words” and by calling his caste
name. While the acquittal under Section 294(b) IPC is not under
challenge and remains undisturbed, the same body of evidence
cannot be held to disclose no abusive words for acquitting the
accused on one charge, and simultaneously be relied upon as
establishing those very words to convict him on another.
42. Further, the trial Court brushed aside the entire defence
case with the sweeping observation that certain discrepancies were
pointed out “and such kind of defect will in no way affect the nature
of the case”, without even identifying what those discrepancies were.
It failed to address the earlier information recorded at the spot, the
absence of any explanation for the three-day delay, the admission of
enmity by the prosecution’s own witnesses, PW7’s testimony that the
accused was apprehended the very next day, the non-examination of
independent residents living near the scene, or the damaging
admissions of PW8.
43. For all these reasons, I hold that the prosecution failed to
prove, beyond reasonable doubt, that the appellant committed the
offences under Section 341 IPC and under Sections 3(1)(r) and 3(1)
(s) of the SC/ST Act. The appellant is entitled to the benefit of doubt.
The conviction and sentence recorded by the trial Court cannot be
sustained.
31
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
44. In the result:
(i) This Criminal Appeal is allowed.
(ii) The conviction and sentence imposed on the appellant by
the learned Principal Sessions Judge, Dharmapuri, by judgment dated
09.08.2018 in S.C.No.31 of 2016, for the offences under Section 341
IPC and Sections 3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s) of the SC/ST Act, are set aside,
and the appellant is acquitted of those charges. His acquittal under
Section 294(b) IPC stands undisturbed.
(iii) The fine amount, if paid by the appellant, shall be refunded
to him.
(iv) The bail bond, if any, executed by the appellant and his
sureties shall stand cancelled, and the sureties shall stand
discharged.
(v) This Court places on record its appreciation for the valuable
assistance rendered by Ms.S.Thatshinya, the learned Legal Aid
Counsel, who assisted the Court on behalf of the victim. She shall be
paid remuneration by the State Legal Services Authority, High Court,
Madras.
Consequently, connected miscellaneous petitions, if any, are
closed.
13.11.2026
Index : Yes / No
Internet : Yes / No
mpk
32
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
To
1. The Principal Sessions Judge,
Dharmapuri.
2. The Deputy Superintendent of Police,
Pennagaram Sub Division,
Dharmapuri District.
3.The Inspector of Police,
Eriyur Police Station,
Pennagaram Sub Division,
Dharmapuri District.
4.The State Legal Services Authority
High Court, Madras.
5. Ms.S.Thatshinya
Legal Aid Counsel
6. The Public Prosecutor,
High Court, Madras.
33
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL A.No.527 of 2018
M.NIRMAL KUMAR, J.
mpk
Pre-Delivery Judgment made in
CRL.A.No.527 of 2018
13.11.2026
34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )