AMBEE ENGINEERING PRIVATE LIMITED AND ANR vs HOWRAH MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
Form No.J(2)
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present :
The Hon’ble Justice Raja Basu Chowdhury
WPA 12290 of 2026
Ambeee Engineer Private Limited& Anr.
Versus
Howrah Municipal Corporation& Ors.
For the petitioners : Mr. Sumitava Chakraborty
For the respondent no. 8 : Ms. Bratati Pramanick
For theHMC : Ms. Sonal Sinha
Mr. Sandipal Das
Heard on : 22.07.2026, 24.08.2026, 25.08.2026,
05.10.2026 and 12.11.2026.
Judgment on : 12.11.2026.
Raja Basu Chowdhury, J (Oral):
th
1. Challenging the order dated 29 May 2026 passed by the Executive
Engineer (Buildilng), Howrah Municipal Corporation, whereby, the
petitioners were directed to once again re apply for sanction proposal of
G+IV storied building at 80/2, Kshetra Mohan Banerjee Lane, under Ward
no. 33 through the Online Building Plan Approval System (OBPAS), the
instant writ petition has been filed.
2. The matter has a chequered history. Previously, the writ petitioners along
with the proforma respondent no. 8 had filed two separate writ petitions
involving a common cause. While the writ petitioner no. 1 claims to be
2 WPA 12290 of 2026
developer, the respondent no. 8 is the owner in respect of the holding nos.
78, 79/28, and 80/2, Kshetra Mohan Banerjee Lane, Post Office and
Police Station Shibpur, Ward No. 33, District Howrah, PIN–711102.
According to the case made out, the above holdings had been mutated in
the name of the respondent no. 8. Subsequently, the holdings have been
amalgamated in the records of the municipal authorities as holding no.
80/2, Kshetra Mohan Banerjee Lane, P.O. and P.S. Shibpur, Ward No. 33,
District Howrah, PIN–711102, measuring an area of 6 Cottahs, 9
Chittacks, and 17 sq. ft., more or less, including the common passage.
3. It is the petitioners‟ case that the respondent no. 8 had entered into a
development agreement with the petitioners and had also executed
necessary documents for development of the aforesaid property for
constructing a G+IV storied residential building having a proposed height
of 15.49 metres. Pursuant to the Development Agreement and the Power
th
of Attorney, the petitioner no. 1 had submitted the building plan on 27
February 2020 along with the requisite fees for sanction of the proposed
G+4 residential building. The petitioners also obtained a Fire Clearance
th
Certificate dated 16 October, 2020 from the West Bengal Fire and
Emergency Services and had also previously conducted a soil
investigation in December 2019 for construction of the proposed
structure. The petitioners claimed that the property in question is
situated within 500 meter radial distance from the State Secretariat,
Nabanna, which has been declared as a “Security Zone” by the
th
Government of West Bengal vide notification dated 4 September, 2019
issued in exercise of powers under Sections 243 and 244 of the Howrah
Municipal Corporation Act, 1980 (in short the said Act).
3 WPA 12290 of 2026
4. The petitioners claim that section 244 prohibits the sanction of any
building exceeding 15.5 metres in height within a 500 metre radius of
such „Security zones‟ from the standpoint of security. Although, the
petitioner No. 1 as Developer sought permission for a structure having a
height of 15.49 meters i.e., within the permissible sanction limit, the
Commissioner, Howrah Municipal Corporation vide letter dated 13th
October 2020 sought the views and observations of the Commissioner of
Police regarding sanction of the building plan. In response, the
Commissioner of Police, vide communication dated 29th December 2020,
raised two concerns: (i) demolition of the existing structure would
generate severe pollution around Nabanna; and (ii) a large number of
labourers required for demolition and construction could pose a security
risk to the State Secretariat.
rd
5. Consequently, by letter dated 23 August 2021, the petitioners were
called upon to explain how these concerns would be addressed. The
rd
petitioner No. 1 as Developer, vide letter dated 23 August 2021,
submitted its proposal outlining the measures intended to address and
mitigate the concerns raised by the respondents.. Despite receipt of such
response since the respondents did not take any steps in the matter, the
petitioners were compelled to file a writ petition which was registered as
WPA no. 29098 of 2024. Such writ petition was dismissed as withdrawn
due to technical defects. Later, the respondent no. 8 filed a writ petition
th
which was registered as WPA no. 12094 of 2024. By order dated 15 July
2024, the writ petition was allowed by directing demolition work of the
dilapidated structure to be carried out under the supervision of a
Chartered Engineer. Pursuant to the aforesaid direction the dilapidated
4 WPA 12290 of 2026
structure at the site was accordingly demolished. Independent of the
aforesaid, the petitioner filed yet another writ petition which was
registered as WPO no. 477 of 2024 seeking a direction upon the
respondents to sanction the building plan at the said property.By order
th
dated 24 May 2024, a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court had directed the
Commissioner, Howrah Municipal Corporation to consider the
representation of the Developer and to pass a reasoned order.
6. Pursuant to the aforesaid direction, the petitioners were heard and the
Commissioner granted conditional permission for construction of G+IV
storied building of height of 15.49 metres. The respondents, however,
imposed 17 conditions at the instance of the Commissioner of Police for
execution of the construction work. To morefully appreciate the conditions
th
imposed by the Commissioner, HMC by order dated 24 September 2024,
the relevant conditions are extracted hereinbelow:-
1. The said premises should not be used foranyactivities which may breach the security of Nabanna.
th
2. The proposed building should be constructed following ...... 1266 ISS/PL/O/21-P/20/2013 dt.4 September
2019. …. the building should not exceed 15 and ½ metres from the ground level.
3. Howrah Municipal Corporation shall strictly impose terms and conditions related to pollution and other
building norms. 4.A ten (10) feet high view cutter should have to be constructed around the roof of the
building.
5. Windows and Balconies/ open access towards the prime security zones may not be approved.
6. Mobile Tower should not be allowed to be erected on the roof of the building.
7. The builder should have to submit copy of sanctioned plan to the local Police Station
8. During construction, transportation of materials and construction hours/days etc should be done in
consultation with IC, Shibpur P.S and TI, Mandirtala.
9. During construction, building/ premises should be properly covered so that it does not cause disturbance to
neighbours.
10. Considering the Administrative requirement/ safety related issues, IC, Shibpur PS in consultation with
SupervisoryOfficers may ask the building owners/contractors to stop the work temporarily and it can be
further resumed.
11. Traffic clearance is also mandatory as this premise is situated beside a narrow lane.
5 WPA 12290 of 2026
12. Roads from all the sides should be accessible by Fire Brigade/ Disaster Management.
13. Sufficient parking space is required at the said premises so that no traffic congestion at the adjacent
roads occurs even during any familygathering or similar events.
14. There should not be any encroachment of public thoroughfare during and after construction of the
building. 15 . 24x7 hours CCTV surveillance in all common accessible area including entry and exit gate of the
said premises may be covered with Bullet/ Dome/PTZ careras with a back up of a considerable period at
least of 3 (three) months) by the Developer and the service is to be continued.
16. Character antecedents of the dwellers should be done by the authority and should be repeated in case of
any new dweller.
17. HMC and O.C, Shibpur Police Station should keep a close vigil during construction of the building to
ensure that the construction is done as per sanctioned plan and no security measure gets violated.
7. Challenging the conditions as aforesaid the petitioners moved a writ
petition which was registered as WPA no. 2445 of 2025. By an order dated
th
11 March 2026 a Coordinate Bench of this Court was pleased to hold that
the condition nos. 4 and 5 are intrusive, disproportionate, contrary to
mandatory building norms relating to light and ventilation, and amount to an
arbitrary exercise of power, offending Articles 14 and 19(1)(g) of the
Constitution of India. Similarly, condition no. 16 which contemplates
continuous character verification of every present and future dweller of the
premises was also found to be foreign to the scheme of the Act. The said
condition was also found to be disproportionate and interferes with the
privacy and liberty of residents, and lacks any rational nexus with the grant of
a building permit and the same was declared as unconstitutional and ultra
vires.
8. Following the aforesaid, the respondents were directed to process and
finalize the building-plan sanction strictly in accordance with law and without
insisting upon compliance with the quashed conditions. Incidentally,in terms
of the aforesaid direction, the Executive Engineer (Building) by a cryptic
th
orderdated 29 May 2026had held that the petitioners should apply for
6 WPA 12290 of 2026
sanction proposal of G+IV storied building at 80/2 Kshetra Mohan Banerjee
Lane afresh through the Online Building Plan Approval System (OBPAS) as
there is no scope for offline approval for sanction. Challenging the aforesaid,
the instant writ petition has been filed.
9. The HMC has been contesting the writ petition and has filed an
affidavit in opposition. In the affidavit in opposition it has contended that
st
having regard to the notification dated 31 December 2024 issued by the
Government of West Bengal, there is no scope available to the municipality to
process any sanctioned building plan in offline mode. To morefully appreciate
the aforesaid notification, the relevant portion of the notification is extracted
hereinbelow:-
7 WPA 12290 of 2026
10. Ms. Sinha, learned advocate appearing for the HMC submits that it is
but for the notification that the municipality has not been able to process the
matter any further.
11. Having heard the learned advocates appearing for the respective parties
and having considered the materials on record, I find that the Commissioner
th
of HMC pursuant to the order dated 24 May 2024 passed by a Coordinate
Bench of this Court in WPO no. 477 of 2024 was of the view that in the
instant case the height of the building was admittedly 15.4 meters and the
representative of the police and security department have not denied the same
at the time of hearing of the issue before him as it does not cross the height
th
limit mandated for Nabanna Security Zone vide gazette notice dated 12
September 2019 and as such, the HMC could not refuse the sanction plan of
the building on that ground.
12. However, the order goes on to record that the HMC will take up the
sanction process of the building with proper executions of 17 (Seventeen)
points terms and conditions laid by Kolkata Police Directorate to the Ambee
Engineering Pvt.Ltd. for compliance. After getting necessary approval, the
agency Ambee Engineering Pvt. Ltd. has to follow the guidelines strictly as
stated in the NOC issued by the Kolkata Police Directorate.
th
13. Having regard to the order dated 24 September 2024, it is clear that
the HMC in principal sanctioned the plan subject to the conditions as stated
above. The petitioners, had, however challenged the same and the Coordinate
th
Bench of this Court by order dated 11 March 2026 had held that the
condition nos. 4, 5 and 16 were ultra vires and should not be enforced insofar
as the petitioners were concerned. It may be noted that the matter was
th
reserved for judgment on 16 December 2025 and the judgment was delivered
8 WPA 12290 of 2026
th
on 11 March 2026. At no point of time before the Co-ordinate Bench, the
HMC did take the stand that the HMC cannot process the application any
further as the same was made in offline mode. Records would show that the
municipal authorities at all material times led the Court to believe that it is
but for the compliance of the conditions imposed that the sanction has been
withheld. It was not the case of the municipal authorities before this Court
that the sanction would not be granted unless the application was made
through OBPAS. Notwithstanding the aforesaid, in an attempt to disregard the
directions issued by this Court, the Executive Engineer (B) by a cryptic order
th
dated 29 May 2026 had observed that there is no scope to consider the
application for approval though the Hon‟ble Court specifically directed the
municipality to consider the same. The aforesaid act on the part of the
municipality appears to overreach the direction passed by the Court.This
Court also notes that the municipality in this case did not seek to deny the
petitioners‟ right to obtain sanction except through OBPAS, which provides
st
that any building plan approved on or after 1 January 2025 has to be done
th
through OBPAS. In fact as on 24 September, 2024 it was held by the
Commissioner, HMC that sanction could not be withheld.
th
14. Admittedly, in this case what was outstanding as on 24 September,
2024 was the petitioners‟ readiness and willingness to comply with the 17
conditions. Out of the 17 conditions three conditions were found to be
unconstitutional and have been struck down with a further direction upon the
municipality to process and finalize the petitioners‟ application strictly in
accordance with law without insisting for compliance of the quashed
conditions. Further in course of hearing before this Court in WPO 477 of 2024
no other objection was raised.
9 WPA 12290 of 2026
15. In the peculiar facts and having regard to the directions passed by the
th
Coordinate Bench of this Court by order dated 11 March 2026 , it is too late
st
in a day for the municipality to fall back on the notification dated 31
December 2024 especially when the municipality, in principle, has agreed to
sanction the building plan. The municipality had also accepted the order
th
dated 11 March, 2026 and did not call for review of the order on the ground
st
of the notification dated 31 December, 2024. As such in my view, the
respondents at this stage cannot turn the clock back by insisting that the
petitioners should apply afresh in offline mode. The aforesaid conduct of the
municipality read with its previous conduct, appears to be arbitrary.
th
16. Accordingly, while quashing the communication dated 29 May 2026, I
direct the Commissioner, HMC, to forthwith finalize the petitioners‟ building
plan subject to the petitioners submitting an undertaking to comply with the
other portions of the conditions. If such compliance is made by the petitioners
within two weeks from the date of communication of this order, the municipal
commissioner shall be obliged to process the application without insisting for
any other compliance on expeditious basis within 10 days from receipt
thereon.
17. With the above direction and observation, the writ petitionis disposed
of.
18. All parties shall act on the basis of the server copy of this order duly
downloaded from this Court‟s official website.
(Raja Basu Chowdhury, J.)
Saswata
Assistant Registrar (Court)