Ram Sundar Paswan vs The State of Bihar
- Court
- Patna High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.5790 of 2023
CNR No. BRHC010329492023
======================================================
1. Ram Sundar Paswan S/o Late Jugeshwar Paswan R/o Village- Laukahi,
Bihra, Ward No.- 12, P.S.- Pangachhiya, District- Saharsa.
2. Md. Hasnain, S/o Late Md. Salamat Miya R/o Village- Gamhariya, Ward
No.- 09, P.S.- Sor Bazar, District- Saharsa.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary, Urban Development
Department, Bihar, Patna.
2. The Principal Secretary, Urban Development and Housing Department,
Bihar, Patna.
3. The Assistant Director, Urban Development and Housing Department, Bihar,
Patna.
4. The Board of Nagar Parishad, Saharsa, through its Executive Officer,
Saharsa.
5. The Chairman, Nagar Parishad, Saharsa.
6. The Executive Officer, Nagar Parishad, Saharsa.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s : Mrs. Nivedita Nirvikar, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Amarshakti, Adv.
For the State : None
For the Nagar Parishad, Saharsa : Mr. Pravashankar Mishra, Adv.
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DR. ANSHUMAN
CAV JUDGMENT
Date : 20-11-2026
Heard learned Senior Counsel Mrs. Nivedita
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
2/20
Nirvikar, assisted by Mr. Amarshakti, Advocate for the
petitioners and learned counsel Mr. Pravashankar Mishra for the
Nagar Parishad, Saharsa (Respondent Nos. 4 to 6). None
appears on behalf of the State.
2. The present writ petition has been filed for
issuance of appropriate writ/writs, order/orders,
direction/directions for the following relief/s:-
“A. For quashing the Order bearing Letter
No. 6331, dated 15.09.2016 issued under
the Signature of the Respondent No.3 from
The Office of Urban Development &
Housing Department, Patna, Govt. of Bihar,
whereby and where under the Petitioners
has been Denied of being a Regular
Employee/ Permanent Employee.
B. For issuance of a writ/s, an order/s, a
direction/s in the nature of mandamus
commanding upon the respondents to
reinstate the petitioners with back wages
and with arrears of service as per
Regular/Permanent employee scale since
April 2013 and all other service benefits
which are consequential to reinstatement in
service and for other incidental and
ancillary relief.
C. For issuance of any other appropriate
writ/writs, order/orders, direction/directions
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
3/20
for which the writ petitioner would be found
entitled under the facts and circumstances of
the case.”
3. Learned Senior counsel for the petitioners
submits that here in the present case, petitioner no. 1 joined
Nagar Parishad, Saharsa in the year 1992 on the post of Night
Guard and petitioner no. 2 joined in the year 2005 as Paachak
(Orderly). Both worked on daily wage/casual employee basis.
Senior counsel submits that the petitioners were working on
daily wage/honorarium since long and thus, the Nagar Parishad,
Saharsa in it’s meeting, dated 11.02.2011 regularized both the
petitioners. The petitioner no. 1 was regularized vide Letter No.
609, dated 23.07.2011 against permanent and sanctioned post of
Night Guard in the pay scale of Rs. 2550-3200/- and petitioner
no. 2 was regularized vide Letter No. 603 dated 21.07.2011
against permanent and sanctioned post of Paachak (Orderly) in
the pay scale of Rs. 2550-3200 (annexed as Annexure-1 & 1/A).
Senior counsel further submits that both the petitioners were
doing their duties with all sincerity and were getting salaries
without any hindrance, but suddenly, their salaries were stopped
and show cause notice was issued to the petitioners vide Letter
No. 1116 dated 17.09.2013, seeking explanation regarding the
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
4/20
issue related with the regularization of their employment.
Thereafter, both the petitioners submitted their reply on
07.10.2013 before the Executive Officer, Nagar Parishad,
Saharsa. Senior counsel further submits that in a similar matter
vide Letter No. 1377, dated 10.04.2012, the Urban Development
& Housing Department, Govt. of Bihar had approved the
appointments of some Class-III and IV daily wages employees
accepting the fact that Municipal Corporation is the competent
authority to appoint the Class-III & IV employees. Senior
counsel submits that after receiving the show cause notice and
submitting the reply to the same, the petitioners moved before
this Hon’ble Court in C.W.J.C. No. 24560 of 2013 in which,
vide order dated 10.12.2013, the Executive Officer, Nagar
Parishad, Saharsa was directed to take a final decision in the
matter, considering the reply to the show cause notices filed by
the petitioners, by passing a reasoned order within a reasonable
period of three months from the date of receipt/production of a
certified copy of the order and the decision with regard to
payment of their salary should be taken expeditiously within a
period of three weeks. But, the directions were not complied
with by the Executive Officer, Nagar Parishad, Saharsa.
4. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
5/20
further submits that office of the Urban Development &
Housing Department, Govt. of Bihar issued a letter bearing
Letter No. 6331 dated 15.09.2016, declaring the petitioners
Irregular Employee/Daily Wager, which is against the law and it
shows the mala fide intention of the Respondents. Senior
counsel submits that the petitioners got their salary as per rules
applicable for Regular Employee for 19 months from the date of
their Regularization viz , 21.07.2011 & 23.07.2011. But suddenly
after that, the salaries to the petitioners were stopped from April
2013 to July 2014. It is further stated that after the petitioners
filed contempt application vide M.J.C No. 2273 of 2014 dated
14.05.2014, the respondents paid the entire remaining salaries to
the petitioners, but as per Daily Wage/Casual worker rules, not
as per regular employee scale. Petitioners further got salaries as
per Daily/Casual worker rule till January 2019, when they got
dismissed from the service. Senior counsel further submits that
Board of Nagar Parishad is a competent authority to make an
appointment of Class III & IV and in the case of the petitioners,
there is no adverse order/objection passed by the Urban
Development & Housing Department at any point of time
regarding the resolution passed by the Nagar Parishad, Saharsa
for the regularization of the petitioners. Senior counsel submits
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
6/20
that according to Section 38 of the Bihar Municipal Act, 2007
(Act No. 11 of 2007), the Board of Nagar Parishad is a
competent authority to make an appointment for Class-III & IV
Employees and the notification regarding the regularization of
the daily wage workers is to be submitted to Respondent Nos. 2
and 3. Hence as per the said Rule, Board of Nagar Parishad,
Saharsa passed the resolution in favour of the petitioners and it
was notified and sent to the office of Urban Development &
Housing Department, Bihar, Patna. The Urban Development and
Housing Department had not raised any adverse order/objection
to the resolution passed by the Board of the Nagar Parishad. It is
further submitted that in similar matter in C.W.J.C No. 791 of
2005 (Raj Kumar Vs. The State of Bihar & Ors.), this Hon’ble
Court, vide order dated 26.11.2007 has clearly stated that in
process of selection, the respondents shall consider the age
relaxation with regard to the petitioner and shall consider his
experience also as he has worked with them for 10 years. Here
in the present case, petitioner No. 1 has also worked for more
than 10 years and petitioner No. 2 has also worked for 7 years.
Both worked with sincerity and had an unblemished carrier, that
is why they were recommended for regularization vide
resolution passed by the Board of Nagar Parishad which has
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
7/20
been approved by the Executive Officer, Nagar Parishad,
Saharsa vide Letter No. 603 dated 21.07.2011 and Letter No.
609 dated 23.07.2011. Senior counsel, therefore, submits that
the petitioners cannot be denied of being a permanent employee
of Nagar Parishad, Saharsa and this writ petition be allowed.
5. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners
further submits that the Three Member Committee’s findings are
ex-facie perverse and pedantic, due to the reason that against
petitioner no. 2, the sole ground cited is ‘no proof of
honorarium/remuneration’. It is trite law that maintenance of
muster rolls, wage registers and payment vouchers are the
statutory custodian obligation of the employer (the Nagar
Parishad) and not the impoverished Group-D daily wager. An
employee who served for over a decade cannot be penalized
because the administrative authority failed to produce its own
financial ledgers. Senior counsel further submits that against
petitioner no. 1, the committee alleges that ‘the regularization
process was flawed and reservation roster was not followed’. A
roster clearance defect is a classic procedural defect which at
highest renders an appointment ‘irregular’, not a fraudulent or
void ‘backdoor entry’. Learned Senior counsel for the
petitioners relied on series of judgments viz , State of Karnataka
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
8/20
& Ors. Vs. M.L. Kesari & Ors., reported in (2010) 9 SCC 247;
Secretary, State of Karnataka & Ors. Vs. Uma Devi & Ors.,
reported in (2006) 4 SCC 1; Dharam Singh & Ors. Vs. State of
U.P. & Anr., reported in 2025 SCC Online SC 1735; Jaggo Vs.
Union of India & Ors., reported in 2024 SCC Online SC 3826
and Pawan Kumar Tiwary & Anr. Vs. Jharkhand State
Electricity Board (Now Jharkhand Urja Vikas Nigam Ltd.) in
Civil Appeal No. 10893-10896 of 2025 (2025 INSC 1000).
6. Learned counsel appearing for the Nagar
Parishad, Saharsa, on the other hand, submits that some persons
including the petitioners, were engaged on daily
wages/contractual basis in Nagar Parishad, Saharsa and
subsequently they were regularized. However, when the
Executive Officer, Nagar Parishad, Saharsa did not receive any
approval from the department with respect to the petitioners
then he issued show cause notice to the petitioners vide Letter
No. 1116 dated 17.09.2013 and subsequently retrenched the
persons who were engaged illegally and also other persons
working on contractual or daily wages were removed. As the
appointment of the petitioners was done without following the
guidelines of the government and also without following the
reservation roster, the same was held to be illegal. Further, it is
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
9/20
also stated that the alleged appointment of the petitioners was
also found to be illegal by the Three Member Departmental
Committee which has been mentioned in para 29 of the report.
(Annexure-6 of the writ petition). He submits that one Sanjay
Kumar Singh filed a writ petition bearing C.W.J.C. No. 384 of
2016 against the State authorities and others in light of which,
the department constituted a Three Member Committee for
looking into the irregularities related to appointment and pay
revision at Nagar Parishad, Saharsa. The Three Member
Committee inquired and subsequently submitted its report on
19.08.2016. Thereafter the Assistant Director, Department of
Urban Development and Housing, Bihar sent a letter bearing
Letter No. 6331 dated 15.09.2016 directing the Executive
Officer, Nagar Parishad, Saharsa to take action against the
petitioners and others.
7. Learned counsel for the Nagar Parishad, Saharsa
further submits that due to changed circumstances, the Govt. of
Bihar took a policy decision regarding taking different type of
services under municipal bodies including Nagar Parishad,
Saharsa through outsourcing only and accordingly, the Urban
Development and Housing Department, Bihar, Patna had issued
a resolution vide Memo No. 2503 dated 03.05.2018 regarding
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
10/20
restructuring and creation of posts existing under municipal
bodies including Nagar Parishad and by the same, the State
Govt. took a policy decision to abolish all the vacant existing
Group-D posts. As such, after May 2018, there is no Group-D
post existing under Nagar Parishad, Saharsa against whom
anyone could be appointed. Counsel submits that thereafter, the
Urban Development and Housing Department took a policy
decision regarding determination of core position for taking
different types of services under municipal bodies including
Nagar Parishad through outsourcing. The said decision was
issued to Municipal Commissioner of all the Municipal
Corporations, all Executive Officers of Nagar Parishad vide
Letter no. 3453 dated 29.06.2018. Counsel, therefore, submits
that the Executive Officer, Nagar Parishad, Saharsa retrenched
the persons including the petitioners in compliance of the
judgment of the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court dated
27.09.2016 passed in C.W.J.C. No. 384 of 2016 (Sanjay Kumar
Singh Vs. The State of Bihar & Ors.) and on the basis of Three
Member Departmental Committee report. Counsel submits that
the Three Member Committee has found most of the
appointments under enquiry in Nagar Parishad, Saharsa as
irregular and without following the prescribed procedure like
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
11/20
publication of advertisement, non-adherence to the reservation
rules etc. Counsel therefore submits that the appointment of the
petitioners were ab-initio illegal and accordingly, the impugned
order dated 15.09.2016 contained in Letter No. 6331 was
passed. Hence, there is no need of any interference in this matter
and this writ petition is fit to be dismissed.
8. After hearing the parties and upon perusal of the
documents, it transpires to this Court that the petitioners have
earlier moved before this Hon’ble Court in C.W.J.C. No. 24560
of 2013 in which vide order dated 10.12.2013, the Executive
Officer, Nagar Parishad, Saharsa was directed to take a final
decision in the matter. The operative part of the order dated
10.12.2013 passed in CWJC No. 24560 of 2013 is reproduced
here-in-below:-
“…..In the aforesaid facts and
circumstances, this writ application is being
disposed of, without going into the merit of
the case, with a direction to the respondent
no. 5, the Executive Officer, Nagar
Parishad, Saharsa, to take a final decision
in the matter, considering the reply to the
show cause notices filed by the petitioners,
by passing a reasoned order and
communicating the same to the petitioners
immediately, if the same has already not
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
12/20
been done. Such decision should be taken
within a reasonable period but not later
than three months from the date of
receipt/production of a certified copy of this
order by the petitioners.
However, the decision with regard to
payment of their salary should be taken
expeditiously preferably within a period of
three weeks from the date of
receipt/production of a certified copy of this
order by the petitioners on its own merit and
in accordance with law as the petitioners
are claiming that they are working but not
getting their salary.”
9. It further transpires to this Court that the learned
Senior counsel for the petitioners has relied on various
judgments viz , State of Karnataka & Ors. Vs. M.L. Kesari &
Ors., (supra), Secretary, State of Karnataka & Ors. Vs. Uma
Devi & Ors., (supra), Dharam Singh & Ors. Vs. State of U.P. &
Anr., (supra), Jaggo Vs. Union of India & Ors., (supra) and
Pawan Kumar Tiwary & Anr. Vs. Jharkhand State Electricity
Board (Now Jharkhand Urja Vikas Nigam Ltd.) (supra), and
demanded the relief that petitioners were engaged on daily
wage/casual employee in the Nagar Parishad, Saharsa and their
services were regularized, but the Executive Officer, Nagar
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
13/20
Parishad, Saharsa did not receive any approval from the
department with respect to the petitioners and then, a show
cause notice was issued to the petitioners and subsequently,
petitioners were retrenched.
10. It also transpires to this Court that in the light of
decision made by this Hon’ble Court in similarly situated case
of Sanjay Kumar Singh Vs. The State of Bihar and Ors. in
C.W.J.C. No. 384 of 2016, a Three Member Departmental
Committee has been constituted for looking into the
irregularities relating to appointment and pay revision at Nagar
Parishad, Saharsa in which the Three Member Departmental
Committee has found that those appointments in Nagar
Parishad, Saharsa was irregular and without following the
prescribed procedure like publication of advertisement, non-
adherence to the reservation rules etc. and therefore,
appointment of the petitioners were ab-initio illegal.
11. It is made clear that in the State of Bihar, a new
law namely, Bihar Municipal Act, 2007 (Act No. 11 of 2007)
(hereinafter referred to as ‘Act of 2007’) has been enacted and
published in the Bihar Gazette (Extraordinary) dated
05.04.2007. The relevant provisions relating to appointment
according to the said law has been embedded in Sections 37, 38,
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
14/20
40A, 488(1) and 488(4)(b) of the Act of 2007 and are very much
relevant for complete adjudication of the present case which are
quoted here-in-below:-
“ …..37- Establishment of Municipality
and schedule of posts:-
(1) The posts of officers and other
employees of the Municipality, other than
those referred to in sub-section (1) of
Section 36, shall constitute the municipal
establishment.
(2) The Municipality shall, by Regulation,
classify the posts of officers and other
employees constituting the establishment of
the Municipality into four categories,
namely, category 'A' post, category 'B' post,
category 'C' post, and category post, on the
basis of the scales of pay of such posts.
(3) The Municipality shall prepare, and
maintain, a schedule of posts of officers and
other employees constituting the
establishment of the Municipality, to be
called Establishment Schedule, and such
Establishment Schedule shall include the
designation, and the number of posts under
each designation, and shall be in three parts
of which Part I shall include category, A'
posts, Part II shall include category 'B1
posts, and Part III shall include category 'C'
posts and category 'D' posts.
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
15/20
(4) Every year the Chief Municipal Officer
shall place before the Empowered Standing
Committee for its consideration the
Establishment Schedule along with the
proposals for such changes therein as he
may consider necessary:
Provided that no upward revision of the size
of the establishment of the Municipality
shall be made without the prior sanction of
the State Government.
(5) The Empowered Standing Committee
shall, after consideration of the
Establishment Schedule along with the
proposals, if any, for changes therein, place
the same along with its recommendations, if
any, before the Municipality for approval
prior to the presentation of the budget
estimates to the municipality by the Chief
Councillor.
(6) The Chief Municipal Officer shall revise
the Establishment Schedule as approved by
the Municipality.
(7) The Empowered Standing Committee
may sanction any category 'C' post or
category 'D' posts for a period not
exceeding six months:
Provided that no such post shall be
sanctioned unless there is a provision in this
behalf in the budget estimates of the
Municipality.
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
16/20
(8) Subject to such norms regulating the size
of a municipal establishment as may be
fixed by the State Government from time to
time, no post of an officer or other employee
of the municipality shall be created by the
Municipality without the prior sanction of
the State Government, if the number of posts
to be so created in a year for a Municipality
is more than one per cent of the total
number of sanctioned posts of officers and
other employees in existence in the year
immediately preceding:
Provided that the number of posts as may be
admissible for creation in a year without the
prior sanction of the State Government after
the commencement of this Act, if not created
in that year, may be carried forward to the
next year, subject to a maximum of ten.
(9) The recruitment to the posts of officers
and other employees of the Municipality not
required to be made through the Public
Service Commission shall be made through
the local Employment Exchange or through
such other method as the State Government
may determine from time to time.
(10) Notwithstanding anything contained in
the foregoing provisions of this Section or
elsewhere in this Act, the Empowered
Standing Committee may decide to engage
on contract basis, officers and other
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
17/20
employees of the Municipality against such
posts of officers and other employees
referred to in sub-section (1) of Section 37.
…..38- Appointing Authorities - Subject to
the other provisions of this Act, the
appointing authority in respect of the posts
of officers and other employees constituting
the establishment of the Municipality shall
be,-
(a) in the case of category, 'A' posts, the
Chief Municipal Officer,
(b) in the case of category 'B' posts,-
(i) an Additional Municipal Commissioner
or a Joint Municipal Commissioner, in the
case of a Municipal Corporation, or
(ii) the Municipal Executive Officer, in the
case of a Municipal Council or a Nagar
Panchayat, and
(c) in the case of category 'C' posts and
category 'D' posts, such officer or officers of
the Municipality as the Chief Municipal
Officer may, with the prior approval of the
Empowered Standing Committee, designate
in this behalf.
…..40A- The State Government may make
provisions by framing Service Rules for
different categories of officers and other
employees of the Municipality for
recruitment, service conditions, posting,
transfer, promotion, disciplinary action and
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
18/20
other related aspects of municipal service
and municipal personnel management.
…...488:- Repeal and Savings:-
(1) With effect from the date of coming into
force of this Act, the Bihar Municipal Act,
1922, Patna Municipal Corporation Act,
1951, Bihar Municipal Corporation Act,
1978, Bihar Regional Development
Authority Act, 1981, Bihar Town Planning
& Improvement Trust Act, 1951, Bihar
Restrictions of Uses of Land Act, 1948,
Bihar Municipal Ordinance, 2007 shall
stand repealed.
…...488(4)(b) - Anything done or any action
taken (including any appointment, Rule,
bye-laws, Regulation made, granted or
issued under various Acts listed in sub-
section (1) and (3) of this Section shall,
continue to be in force and be deemed to
have been done or taken under the
provisions of this Act unless it is
superceeded modified/altered by any thing
done or any action taken under this Act.”
12. It transpires to the Court from the arguments
advanced and the pleadings made by all the parties that none of
them has brought to the notice of this Court the applicable
statutory provisions governing the case of the petitioners under
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
19/20
the Bihar Municipal Act, 2007 (Act No. 11 of 2007), as
amended from time to time. In view of the enactment of the
aforesaid Act in the year 2007 and its subsequent amendments,
the respondent No.2, namely, the Principal Secretary, Urban
Development and Housing Department, Government of Bihar,
Patna, is hereby directed to take an appropriate decision in
respect of the petitioners, after affording an opportunity of
hearing to the Executive Officer, Nagar Parishad, Saharsa
(Respondent No. 6), as well as to the petitioners, in the light of
the relevant provisions of the Bihar Municipal Act, 2007, within
a period of 90 days. The aforesaid period of 90 days shall
commence from the date on which all the concerned parties
appear before Respondent No. 2.
13. It is made clear that this Court has not granted
any substantive relief to the petitioners at this stage. In view of
the statutory provisions in force, the State Government is
empowered under Section 40A of the Bihar Municipal Act,
2007, to take an appropriate decision in the matter. Accordingly,
Respondent No. 2 is directed to take a decision after duly
considering the relevant legal provisions, particularly Sections
37, 38, 40A, 488(1) and 488(4)(b) of the Bihar Municipal Act,
2007, which have a bearing on the adjudication of the claims of
Patna High Court CWJC No.5790 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
20/20
the petitioners. The matter shall accordingly be considered and
decided at the level of the State Government.
14. Accordingly, this writ petition stands disposed
of with the aforesaid observations and directions.
(Dr. Anshuman, J)
Divyansh/-
AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE 29/09/2026
Uploading Date 20/11/2026
Transmission Date NA