E M IBRAHIM vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62210
CRL.A No. 847 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010302192017





IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 11 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE G BASAVARAJA


CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 847 OF 2017 (C)

BETWEEN:

E M IBRAHIM
S/O LATE MOIDEEN
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,
COOLIE
R/O ODEYANAPURA VILLAGE
SOMWARPET TALUK
KODAGU DISTRICT-574134
…APPELLANT

(BY SRI. LETHIF B., ADVOCATE)

AND:

THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
THROUGH CPI SOMAWARPET CIRCLE
SHANIVARASANTHE P.S.
KODAGU DISTRICT
REP BY SPECIAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
HIGH COURT COMPLEX BUILDING
BANGALORE-560 001
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. K NAGESHWARAPPA, HCGP)

THIS CRL.A. IS FILED U/S.374(2) CR.P.C BY THE
ADVOCATE FOR THE APPELLANT/ACCUSED PRAYING THAT
THIS HON'BLE COURT MAY BE PLEASED TO SET ASIDE THE
JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF CONVICTION AND SENTENCE
DATED 8.12.2016 AND 9.12.2016 PASSED BY THE PRINCIPAL
SESSIONS AND SPECIAL JUDGE, KODAGU, MADIKERI IN
SPL.C.(POCSO) NO.43/2013 - CONVICTING THE











Digitally signed by
LAKSHMINARAYAN N
Location: High Court
of Karnataka

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62210
CRL.A No. 847 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010302192017



APPELLANT/ACCUSED FOR THE OFFENCE P/U/S 376(1),506 OF
IPC AND SEC.6 OF POCSO ACT, 2012.

THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE G BASAVARAJA

ORAL JUDGMENT


1. The appellant has preferred this appeal against
the judgment of conviction dated 08.12.2016 and order on
sentence dated 09.12.2016 passed in Special Case
[POCSO] No.43/2013 by the Principal District and Sessions
Judge, Kodagu, Madikeri (for short, 'the trial Court').


2. For the sake of convenience, the parties herein
are referred as per the status before the trial Court.


3. Brief facts leading to this appeal are that, the
Circle Inspector of Police, Somwarpet Circle,
Shanivarasanthe Police Station, Kodagu filed charge sheet
against the accused for the offence under Sections 376,
506 IPC and Section 6 of POCSO Act, 2012. It is alleged
by the prosecution that in the first week of February 2013

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62210
CRL.A No. 847 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010302192017



at Odeyanapura, Shanivarasanthe Hobli, Somwarpet
Taluk, when CW1-Kum. Ayisha was in her house at about
11.00 am, the accused entered the house from the back
door and closed the mouth of CW1 tightly with hands and
pulled her to a bedroom and removed the clothes worn by
the CW1 and had sexual intercourse with her.
Subsequently on 4 or 5 occasions also, he had sexual
intercourse with her by going to her house, who being a
girl under age of 18 years and committed an offence of
aggravated penetrative sexual assault. The accused also
gave life threat to her stating that if she discloses the
incident to anybody he will kill her and on 24.06.2013,
when she was examined in Lakshmi Nursing Home,
Hassan, she came to know that she was pregnant of 18-19
weeks and same had got aborted. Thus, the accused has
committed the alleged offence.


4. Accused was arrested on 26.06.2013 and was
remanded to judicial custody. The judgment was delivered

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62210
CRL.A No. 847 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010302192017



on 09.12.2016 and he was remanded to judicial custody.
The accused has preferred this appeal before this Court on
18.05.2017. This Court has passed an order on
IA.No.I/2020 on 18.11.2020 suspending the sentence and
accordingly accused was released on bail. The accused
was in judicial custody for a period of 7 years, 4 months
and 22 days.


5. On hearing, the trial Court has framed the
charges against accused for the commission of alleged
offence. Same was read over and explained to the
accused. Having understood the same, accused pleaded
not guilty and claimed to be tried.


6. To prove the guilt of the accused, the
prosecution has examined 17 witnesses as PWs.1 to 17;
15 documents were marked as Exs.P1 to P15. No material
objects marked on behalf of the prosecution. On closure of
prosecution side evidence, statement under Section 313 of
Cr.P.C. was recorded. However, the accused did not

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62210
CRL.A No. 847 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010302192017



choose to lead any defence evidence on his behalf. Having
heard the arguments on both sides, the trial Court has
convicted the accused for the offence under Sections
376(1) & 506 of IPC and Section 6 of POCSO Act, 2012
and passed a sentence to undergo rigorous imprisonment
for a term of 12 years and to pay fine of Rs.5000/- for the
offence under Section 376(1) of IPC. Further, sentenced
to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a term of 12 years
and to pay fine of Rs.5,000/- for offence under Section 6
of POCSO Act, 2012. Further, sentenced to undergo
imprisonment for a period of 7 years and to pay fine of
Rs.1,000/- for offence under Section 506 of IPC and all the
sentences shall run concurrently. Being aggrieved by the
said judgment, the appellant has preferred this appeal.


7. Learned counsel for the appellant Sri Lethif B,
would submit that, though he has urged several grounds
in the memorandum of appeal, he is not going to press the
judgment of conviction for the offence under Sections

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62210
CRL.A No. 847 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010302192017



376(1) and 506 of IPC. However, he has challenged the
conviction for the offence under Section 6 of POCSO Act
2012, as the prosecution has not placed any cogent and
convincing legal evidence before the Court to prove the
offence under Section 6 of POCSO Act. Further, he would
submit that the trial Court has passed a sentence for the
offence under Section 376(1) of IPC for a period of 12
years and to pay fine of Rs.5,000/-. The accused has
already undergone the sentence for a period of 7 years, 4
months, 22 days. Now, the age of the accused is 55 years
and the victim has already married and has a child and is
leading a settled life with her husband. The alleged
incident took place in the year 2013. Now, 13 years have
already elapsed. The appellant is married and having
children and he is the only earning member and he has to
maintain his family. Hence, it is sought for reducing the
sentence for the period already undergone by the accused,
which is more than 7 years. To substantiate his argument,
the learned counsel for the appellant relied on the decision

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62210
CRL.A No. 847 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010302192017



of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
P. YUVAPRAKASH vs. STATE REPRESENTED BY INSPECTOR
OF POLICE reported in (2024) 17 SCC 684 decided on
18.07.2023.


8. As against this, the learned High Court
Government Pleader Sri Nageshwarappa K, would submit
that the trial Court has properly appreciated the evidence
in accordance with law and facts. Absolutely, there are no
grounds to interfere with the impugned judgment of
conviction and order on sentence and sought for dismissal
of the appeal.


9. Having heard the arguments on both sides and
on perusal of materials placed before this Court, the
following points would arise for my consideration:
(1) Whether the prosecution proves beyond all
reasonable doubt that the victim was a "child" as
defined under Section 2(d) of POCSO Act, 2012, as
on the date of commission of offence?

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62210
CRL.A No. 847 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010302192017



(2) Whether the prosecution proves beyond all
reasonable doubt that the accused has committed
the offence punishable under Section 6 of POCSO
Act, 2012?

(3) Whether the trial Court is justified in convicting
the accused for the offence under Sections 376(1)
and 506 of IPC?

(4) Whether the appellant has made out grounds
for modification of sentence?

(5) What order?


10. My answers to the above points are as under:
Point No.1 in the Negative.
Point No.2 in the Negative.
Point No.3 in the Affirmative.
Point No.4 in the Affirmative.
Point No.5 as per final order.

Reasons to Point No.1

11. I have examined the materials placed before
this Court. It is the case of the prosecution that as on the
date of commission of offence, the age of the victim was,
17 years and 10 months. To prove the age of the victim,
the prosecution has produced Ex.P10-Date of Birth

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62210
CRL.A No. 847 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010302192017



Certificate issued by the Vice Principal, Pre-University
College, Shanivarasanthe, Kodagu District, in which the
date of birth of the victim is shown as 07.03.1995. To
prove this document, Vice Principal, Pre-University
College, Shanivarasanthe who is examined PW12, has
deposed in her evidence that the date of birth of the victim
was 07.03.1995. On what basis PW12 has issued Ex.P10,
has not been disclosed by the prosecution. The
Investigating Officer has not whispered anything as to
non-production of Admission Register extract maintained
by the concerned School, at the time of admission of
victim to 1st Standard. The IO has not explained anything
as to non-production of Birth Certificate or SSLC Marks
Card of the victim. Accordingly, the prosecution has failed
to place relevant documents as required under Section 94
of Juvenile Justice [Care and Protection of Children) Act,
2015.

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62210
CRL.A No. 847 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010302192017




12. In Paragraphs 22 and 23 of the judgment in the
case of P. YUVAPRAKASH vs. STATE REPRESENTED BY
INSPECTOR OF POLICE reported in (2024) 17 SCC 684, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed as under:
"22. It is clear from the above narrative that none
of the documents produced during the trial answered
the description of "the date of birth certificate from
the school" or "the matriculation or equivalent
certificate from the examination board concerned or
certificate by a corporation, municipal authority or a
Panchayat. In these circumstances, it was incumbent
for the prosecution to prove through acceptable
medical tests/examination that the victim's age was
below 18 years as per Section 94(2)(iii) of the JJ Act.
PW 9, Dr Thenmozhi, Chief Civil Doctor and
Radiologist at the General Hospital at Vellore,
produced the x-ray reports and deposed that in
terms of the examination of 'M', a certificate was
issued stating "that the age of the said girl would be
more than 18 years and less than 20 years". In the
cross-examination, she admitted that M's age could
be taken as 19 years. However, the High Court
rejected this evidence, saying that "when the precise
date of birth is available from out of the school
records, the approximate age estimated by the

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62210
CRL.A No. 847 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010302192017



medical expert cannot be the determining factor".
This finding is, in this Court's considered view,
incorrect and erroneous.

23. As held earlier, the documents produced i.e. a
transfer certificate and extracts of the admission
register, are not what Section 94(2)(1) mandates;
nor are they in accord with Section 94(2)(ii) because
DW1 clearly deposed that there were no records
relating to the birth of the victim, 'M'. In these
circumstances, the only piece of evidence, accorded
with Section 94 of the JJ Act was the medical
ossification test, based on several x-rays of the
victim, and on the basis of which PW9 made her
statement. She explained the details regarding
examination of the victim's bones, stage of their
development and opined that she was between 18-
20 years; in cross-examination she said that the age
might be 19 years. Given all these circumstances,
this Court is of the opinion that the result of the
ossification or bone test was the most authentic
evidence, corroborated by the examining doctor
PW9."


13. Keeping in mind the aforesaid decision of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, since the IO has not produced
legally acceptable evidence before the Court to

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62210
CRL.A No. 847 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010302192017



substantiate the age of victim, I am of the considered
opinion that the prosecution has failed to prove that the
age of the victim was below 18 years, as defined under
Section 2(d) of POCSO Act, 2012. Accordingly, I answer
Point No.1 in the Negative.

Reasons to Point No.2

14. Since the prosecution has failed to prove that
the victim had come under the definition of "child" as
defined under Section 2(d) of POCSO Act, 2012 the
question of commission of offence under the penal
provisions under Section 6 of POCSO Act, 2012 does not
arise. Accordingly, the prosecution has failed to prove
that the accused has committed the offence under Section
6 of POCSO Act, 2012. Hence, I answer Point No.2 in the
Negative.

Reasons to Point No.3

15. On careful examination of the entire evidence
on record, the trial Court has come to the conclusion that

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62210
CRL.A No. 847 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010302192017



the accused has committed the offence punishable under
Sections 376(1) and 506 of IPC. In this regard, the
learned counsel for the appellant fairly submits that the
appellant is not going to press as to the judgment of
conviction passed by the trial Court for the offence under
Sections 376(1) and 506 of IPC. However, I have carefully
examined the entire evidence on record. On careful
examination of the entire evidence, I do not find any legal
or factual error in the judgment passed by the trial Court
for the conviction under Sections 376(1) and 506 of IPC.
Accordingly, I answer Point No.3 in the Affirmative.

Reasons to Point No.4

16. With regard to the modification of sentence is
concerned, the trial Court has passed sentence for the
offence under Section 376(1) of IPC to undergo rigorous
imprisonment for a term of 12 years and to pay fine of
Rs.5,000/-. Further, accused shall undergo imprisonment
for a period of 7 years and shall also pay fine of

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62210
CRL.A No. 847 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010302192017



Rs.1,000/- for the offence under Section 506 of IPC.
Section 376(1) of IPC reads as under:

376(1): Whoever, except in the cases provided for in
sub-section (2), commits rape, shall be punished
with Rigorous Imprisonment of either description for
a term which shall not be less than seven years , but
which may extend to imprisonment for life , and shall
also be liable to fine."


17. The accused has already undergone in judicial
custody for a period of 7 years, 4 months and 22 days and
he has already deposited the fine amount. The learned
counsel for the appellant would submit that, the age of the
accused is 55 years now and the victim is already married
and having a child and is leading a settled life with her
husband. The alleged incident took place in the year 2013.
Now, 13 years have already elapsed. The appellant is also
married and having children and he is the only earning
member and he has to maintain his family. Hence, it is
sought for reducing the sentence for the period already
undergone by the accused, which is more than 7 years.

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62210
CRL.A No. 847 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010302192017



This Court has already held while answering point No.1
that the prosecution has failed to prove the guilt of the
accused for the offence under Section 6 of the POCSO Act,
as on the date of commission of offence, the victim had
attained majority. Considering the nature and gravity of
offence and previous antecedent of the accused/appellant
and submission of the learned counsel for the appellant, it
is just and proper to reduce the sentence to the extent of
7 years, 4 months, 22 days as already undergone by the
appellant/accused. Accordingly, I answer Point No.4 in the
Affirmative.

Reasons to Point No.5

18. For the aforestated reasons and discussions,
I proceed to pass the following:
O R D E R
(i) Appeal is partly allowed ;
(ii) The judgment of conviction dated
08.12.2016 and order on sentence dated
09.12.2016 passed in Special Case [POCSO]

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62210
CRL.A No. 847 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010302192017



No.43/2013 by the Principal District and Sessions
Judge, Kodagu, Madikeri, for the offence under
Section 6 of POCSO Act, 2012, is hereby set
aside ; Accused is acquitted of the offence under
Section 6 of POCSO Act, 2012;

(iii) The judgment of conviction dated
08.12.2016 and order on sentence dated
09.12.2016 passed in Special Case [POCSO]
No.43/2013 by the Principal District and Sessions
Judge, Kodagu, Madikeri, for the offence under
Sections 376(1) and 506 of IPC, is confirmed; and
the sentence passed by the trial Court is modified
as under:
a) The Appellant/accused shall undergo
rigorous imprisonment for a period of 7
years, 4 months, 22 days for the offence
under Section 376(1) of IPC. Further,
accused shall undergo imprisonment for a
period of 7 years for the offence under
Section 506 of IPC;

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62210
CRL.A No. 847 of 2017


CNR: KAHC010302192017




b) The above said sentences shall run
concurrently;

c) It is submitted that the fine amount is
already deposited. The same shall be
forfeited to the Government;

d) The period of sentence already
undergone by the accused shall be set-off
as contemplated under Section 428 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.

The Registry is directed to send copy of the judgment
along with Trial Court Records to the concerned Court.


Sd/-
(G BASAVARAJA)
JUDGE



DHA
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 63