Narender And Anr vs Phooli And Ors

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court


1
RSA-5587-2018 (O&M) - -


IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH

RSA-5587-2018 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 16.11.2026

Narender and Another
....Appellants
Versus

Phooli and Others
...Respondents

CORAM:- HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE AMARJOT BHATTI

Present:- Mr. Abhinav Sood, Advocate for the appellants.

*

AMARJOT BHATTI, J.
1. The appellants/plaintiffs have filed present Regular Second Appeal
against impugned judgment and decree dated 07.08.2018 passed by learned
Additional District Judge Sonepat vide which he dismissed the appeal and
upheld the judgment and decree dated 08.02.2016 passed by learned Civil
Judge (Junior Division) Gohana vide which the suit filed by the
plaintiffs/appellants was dismissed. Feeling aggrieved of the concurrent
findings of both the courts below, present Regular Second Appeal has been
filed.
2. As per the facts of the case, Narender and Sheela being children of
late Smt. Shanti daughter of Hukam Chand filed suit for declaration challenging
the release deed dated 13.09.2001 as well as subsequent sale deed No.466 dated
05.05.2004 in favour of Bhupender Singh and Krishan and another sale deed
No.467 dated 05.05.2004 in favour of defendants No.7 to 10 and the mutations
sanctioned thereon as illegal, null and void and not binding on the rights of the
plaintiffs and the same are liable to be set aside and the plaintiffs claiming their
SUNIL DEVI
2026.11.20 13:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


2
RSA-5587-2018 (O&M) - -


th
ownership and possession to the extent of 1/4 share in the said property along
with suit for permanent injunction restraining the defendants from alienating
the suit property in any manner to defendant No.4 or any other person as
detailed in the plaint.
3. It is the case of plaintiffs that Hukam Chand was owner in
possession of agricultural land measuring 55 kanals 11 marlas situated in
Revenue Estate of Village Saragthal, Tehsil Gohana, District Sonepat. The suit
property was their ancestral property. The pedigree table is as under:-
Pokhar
↓
Hukam Chand
↓
__________________________________________________________
Phooli Shanti Angoori Kamla

The defendants No.1 to 3 got registered release deed in their
favour on 13.09.2001 and the name of mother of the plaintiffs namely Shanti
th
was ignored. She was divested from her 1/4 share in the suit property. In fact,
the defendants fraudulently and by way of misrepresentation got the release
deed dated 13.09.2001 in their favour from Hukam Chand, who was their
maternal grandfather. Said Hukam Chand was habitual of consuming liquor. He
was an old man and was not in his senses at the time of execution of disputed
release deed dated 13.09.2001. Thus said release deed and mutation No.4262
sanctioned thereon are also null and void and liable to be set aside. The
defendants No.1 to 3 sold 07 kanals 12 marlas of land to defendants No.5 & 6
vide sale deed dated 05.05.2004 and further sold 15 kanals 17 marlas of land to
defendants No.7 to 10 vide registered sale deed dated 05.05.2004. After the
aforesaid sales, the defendants No.1 to 3 are still owner in possession of 33
SUNIL DEVI
2026.11.20 13:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


3
RSA-5587-2018 (O&M) - -


kanals 12 marlas of land. Smt. Shanti, mother of the plaintiffs was also co-
sharer in the suit property. She used to take her profit of earning from
defendants No.1 to 3 every year. After the death of their mother on 23.05.1979,
the defendants No.1 to 3 did not pay any lagaan and profit. The defendants
No.1 to 3 are enjoying the fruits of entire land including the share of their
mother. The plaintiffs came to know about the aforesaid factual position at the
time of sanctioning of mutation. The release deed and the sale deeds referred
above and the mutation sanctioned thereon are illegal, null and void and the
same are liable to be set aside. Hence the present suit.
4. Notice of the suit was given to the defendants. The defendants
No.1 to 3 filed their joint written statement taking preliminary objections that
the plaintiffs have no right, title or interest in the suit property. The suit filed by
the plaintiffs is hopelessly barred by limitation. It is bad for miss-joinder of
defendant No.4. The plaintiffs have no cause of action to file the present suit.
They are estopped from filing this case by their own act and conduct. On the
merits of the case, it is admitted that Hukam Chand, father of defendants No.1
to 3 was owner in possession of 55 Kanal 11 marlas of land situated in village
Saragthal, Tehsil Gohana, District Sonepat. He was owner of another piece of
land which he had sold during his lifetime. Smt. Shanti, mother of the plaintiffs
never looked after her father Hukam Chand. She expired about 33 years ago.
After the death of Smt.Shanti, even the plaintiffs never cared and looked after
their maternal grandfather Hukam Chand during his lifetime. The defendants
No.1 to 3 served their father and out of love and affection and the services
rendered by them, Hukam Chand with his free volition and without any
pressure executed registered release deed dated 13.09.2001 in favour of his
SUNIL DEVI
2026.11.20 13:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


4
RSA-5587-2018 (O&M) - -


three daughters Phooli, Angoori and Kamla i.e. defendants No.1 to 3. Mutation
No.4262 was also sanctioned in their favour. Hukam Chand died in the year
2003. At present defendants No.1 to 3 are owners in possession of the suit land.
There was no misrepresentation or fraud committed by the answering
th
defendants. It is denied that mother of plaintiffs was owner of 1/4 share in the
suit property or the plaintiffs have got any share in the suit land. The answering
defendants categorically stated that the sale deeds both dated 05.05.2004 in
favour of defendants No.5 & 6 as well as defendants No.7 to 10 are legal and
valid documents. The plaintiffs have no right to challenge the same. It is
submitted that the suit filed by the plaintiffs may kindly be dismissed.
5. The defendants No.5 to 10 also filed their joint written statement
taking preliminary objections. They reiterated their claim on the basis of two
sale deeds dated 05.05.2004. They are bona fide purchasers for valuable
consideration. They became owners of the property, the day they purchased the
same. The mutations were also sanctioned in their favour. The suit filed by the
plaintiffs against them may kindly be dismissed with exemplary cost.
6. The defendant No.4 filed separate written statement taking
preliminary objections denying the claim of plaintiffs in the suit property. He
supported the case of defendants No.1 to 3 on the basis of registered release
deed dated 13.09.2001. He based his claim on the basis of agreement to sell and
receipt dated 19.10.2011 and took the stand that defendants No.1 to 3 had
received Rs.12 lakhs as earnest money and the date fixed for the sale deed was
31.12.2011. He took the stand that defendants No.1 to 3 did not come forward
to execute and register the sale deed in his favour. The defendant No.4 based
his claim in the suit property on the basis of one agreement and receipt dated
SUNIL DEVI
2026.11.20 13:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


5
RSA-5587-2018 (O&M) - -


19.10.2011. He submitted that suit filed by the plaintiffs may kindly be
dismissed with cost.
7. The plaintiffs filed replication to the written statements filed by the
defendants and reiterated their claim as detailed in the plaint.
8. From the pleadings of the parties, following issues were framed by
the Trial Court on 25.07.2014:-
1. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to a decree for
declaration declaring that release deed dated 13.09.2001 and sale
deeds no.466, 467 dated 05.05.2014, in favour of defendants no. 5
to 10 and subsequent mutations no.4262,4352,4353 are wrong,
illegal null, and void, and not binding upon rights their rights and
are liable to be set aside on the grounds mentioned in the plaint?
OPP
2. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to a decree of joint
possession of suit property qua ¼ share? OPP
3. Whether, the plaintiffs are entitled for a decree for
permanent injunction restraining the defendants no.1 to 10 from
alienating the suit land in any way or in any manner? OPP
4. Whether the defendants no. 5 to 10 are bonafide purchasers
for sale consideration? OPD
5. Whether the suit filed by the plaintiffs is not maintainable in
its present form? OPD
6. Whether the suit of the plaintiffs is bad for mis joinder and
non joinder of necessary parties? OPD
7. Whether the suit filed by the plaintiffs are estopped from
filing the present suit by his own act and conduct? OPD
8. Relief
9. In order to prove the case, plaintiffs examined Nirmala Devi as
PW-1, Ram Chander as PW-2, Raghbir as PW-3, plaintiff Narender examined
SUNIL DEVI
2026.11.20 13:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


6
RSA-5587-2018 (O&M) - -


himself as PW-4 and Jagdish Chander as PW-5 and after tending documents,
learned counsel for the plaintiffs closed the evidence on 19.09.2015.
10. On the other hand, defendants examined Phooli as DW-1,
Ramphal as DW-2, Naresh Kumar as DW-3, Bhupender as DW-4, Kawar Bhan
as DW-5 and after tending documents, learned counsel for defendants closed
the evidence on 24.12.2015.
11. After hearing the arguments advanced by learned counsel for both
the parties, the suit filed by the appellants/plaintiffs was dismissed vide
judgment and decree dated 08.02.2016 with cost. Feeling aggrieved of this
judgment and decree, the appellants/plaintiffs have filed the appeal before the
First Appellate Court, which was also dismissed vide impugned judgment and
decree dated 07.08.2018. Thereafter, the present Regular Second Appeal has
been filed.
12. Learned counsel for appellants/plaintiffs argued that suit property
was owned and possessed by Hukam Chand who was father of four daughters
i.e. Phooli, Shanti, Angoori and Kamla. The appellants/plaintiffs are the
children of late Smt. Shanti who expired on 23.05.1979. The
appellants/plaintiffs being children of Smt. Shanti had share in the suit property
th
to the extent of 1/4 share. During the life time of Smt. Shanti, she was
receiving her share in the earnings from the land and after her death, they were
not given anything. The release deed dated 13.09.2001 (Exhibit P-1/Exhibit
DW-3/A) is the result of fraud and misrepresentation. The share of Smt. Shanti
was wrongly ignored and the document was got executed in favour of Phooli,
Angoori and Kamla. At the time of execution of release deed, Hukam Chand
was not in his full senses. He was habitual of drinking. Therefore, the
SUNIL DEVI
2026.11.20 13:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


7
RSA-5587-2018 (O&M) - -


th
appellants/plaintiffs have got 1/4 share in the suit property. After the execution
of said registered release deed dated 13.09.2001, the defendants No.1 to 3
alienated part of the suit property i.e. 07 kanal 12 marlas and another 15 kanal
17 marlas vide two sale deeds both dated 05.05.2004 (Exhibit P-2 and Exhibit
P-3). The mutation No.4352 and 4353 were sanctioned on the basis of said sale
deeds which are Exhibit PC and PD. The copy of jamabandi for the year 1999-
2000 and copy of jamabandi for the year 2004-05 are Exhibit PA and PE
respectively. The defendants No.1 to 3 had no right to alienate the property
ignoring the share of appellants/plaintiffs through their mother Smt. Shanti.
Narender, one of the plaintiffs stepped into the witness box as PW-4 to prove
his version. His case is also supported by examining the close relatives namely
Ram Chander PW-2 and Raghbir PW-3. The release deed dated 13.09.2001
(Exhibit P-1) and subsequent sale deeds dated 05.05.2004 (Exhibit P-2 and P-3)
do not have any adverse effect on the rightful claim of the appellants/plaintiffs.
The courts below failed to appreciate the aforesaid factual position and wrongly
dismissed the suit filed by the plaintiffs and further wrongly dismissed the first
appeal preferred by the appellants/plaintiffs. With these arguments, it is
submitted that the judgments passed by the courts below may kindly be set
aside and the suit filed by the appellant/plaintiffs may be decreed as prayed for.
13. I have considered the arguments advanced by learned counsel
representing the appellants/plaintiffs and have gone through the trial Court
record with his able assistance. Certain facts narrated in the plaint are admitted.
The relationship of appellants/plaintiffs with defendants No.1 to 3 is admitted.
Hukam Chand was father of four daughters, Phooli, Shanti, Angoori and
Kamla. The appellants/plaintiffs are son and daughter of Smt. Shanti whereas
SUNIL DEVI
2026.11.20 13:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


8
RSA-5587-2018 (O&M) - -


other three daughters are arrayed as defendants No.1 to 3. Smt. Shanti expired
on 23.05.1979. Initially, it was claimed that the property in the hands of Hukam
Chand was their ancestral property. During evidence before the trial Court,
Intkhab was got prepared from the revenue agency which is Exhibit PW-5/A. In
this record, it was revealed that as per jamabandi for the year 2004-05,
mutation was sanctioned on the basis of hibanama in favour of Thambu, Moji,
Hukam Chand sons of Pokhar. During the course of arguments, it was conceded
that the suit property in the hands of Hukam Chand was not joint Hindu family
coparcenary property. It is rightly held by the trial Court that the
daughter/female became a coparcener by way of amendment in Hindu
Succession (Amendment) Act 2005. Prior to this, a female child was not
considered as coparcener in the joint Hindu family. In the case in hand, Hukam
Chand executed release deed on 13.09.2001 (Exhibit P-1) in favour of
defendants No.1 to 3. The aforesaid amendment did not affect any disposition
or alienation or testamentary disposition of property prior to 20.12.2004.
Therefore, the courts below rightly concluded that neither the
appellants/plaintiffs could establish that the property in the hands of Hukam
Chand was joint Hindu family coparcenary property nor Smt. Shanti, mother of
the appellants/plaintiffs was having interest in the suit property by birth.
14. In the light of a foresaid factual position, the property in the hands
of Hukam Chand is to be considered as his self acquired property. Therefore, he
had a right to dispose of the property as per his wishes. The disputed release
deed dated 13.09.2001 is Exhibit P-1/DW-3/A. It was thumb marked of Hukam
Chand and attested by witnesses namely Ramphal (Nambardar) and Ram
Chander. On behalf of defendants No.1 to 3, Phooli had appeared at the time of
SUNIL DEVI
2026.11.20 13:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


9
RSA-5587-2018 (O&M) - -


execution of registration of said release deed. In order to prove this document,
Phooli stepped into the witness box as DW-1 and one of the marginal witnesses
Ramphal (Nambardar) is examined as DW-2. I have carefully gone through the
statement of Narinder PW-4 who during cross-examination also conceded that
Hukam Chand had executed release deed in favour of his three daughters on the
basis of which mutation was sanctioned and prior to filing of this suit, it was
never challenged. Cross-examination of Ram Chander PW-2, Raghbir PW-3
further confirms the aforesaid factual position. The appellants/plaintiffs failed
to lead any convincing evidence to show that Hukam Chand was drunkard or
for any reason he was not competent to execute release deed of his own
property in favour of his daughters i.e defendants No.1 to 3. The
appellants/plaintiffs claimed fraud and misrepresentation but could not lead any
evidence to prove the said stand taken in the plaint. Therefore, Hukam Chand
being absolute owner of the suit property was competent to execute release
deed in favour of his daughters i.e. defendants No.1 to 3, as per his desire.
15. The other important aspect of the present case is Hukam Chand
executed the release deed dated 13.09.2001. He expired in the year 2003.
Mutation was sanctioned in favour of defendants No.1 to 3 i.e. 4262 (Exhibit
PB). The said release deed was duly reflected in the revenue record. After the
execution of release deed, the defendants No.1 to 3 further executed two sale
deeds both dated 05.05.2004 (Exhibit P-2 and P-3) and the mutations No.4352
& 4353 (Exhibit PC and PD) were also sanctioned. Despite all this, the
plaintiffs never challenged the aforesaid transactions and they filed present civil
suit for the first time on 27.02.2012. The appellants/plaintiffs failed to explain
their long silence with regards to the aforesaid transactions. Once the
SUNIL DEVI
2026.11.20 13:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


10
RSA-5587-2018 (O&M) - -


defendants No.1 to 3 became owners of the suit property on the basis of release
deed, then they were competent to further transfer the same as per their desire.
16. In the light of aforesaid factual position, I do not find any
perversity in the concurrent findings of both the courts below. All the aspects of
the case were rightly dealt with and I do not find any valid reason to interfere in
the impugned judgment and decree dated 07.08.2018 passed by learned
Additional District Judge, Sonepat dismissing the appeal preferred by the
appellants/plaintiffs and upholding the judgment and decree dated 08.02.2016
passed by learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Gohana, consequently, the
Regular Second Appeal preferred by the appellants/plaintiffs is dismissed
17. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, stand disposed of
accordingly as well.
(AMARJOT BHATTI)
JUDGE
16.11.2026
Sunil Devi
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No

SUNIL DEVI
2026.11.20 13:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document