RAJIA ENGINEERING vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction)
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Krishna Rao
W.P.A. No. 26288 of 2026
Rajia Engineering
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Sk. Md. Galib
Mr. Monajit Chakrabarti
....For the petitioner.
Mr. Rivu Dutta
Mr. Swastik Saha
....For the State.
Mr. Sanjay Saha
Mr. Raju Mondal
Ms. Indrani Mukherjee
....For the respondent no. 6.
Hearing Concluded On : 13.10.2026
Judgment Delivered On : 16.11.2026
Judgment Uploaded On : 16.11.2026
2
Krishna Rao, J.:
1. The petitioner has filed the present writ petition praying for a
mandamus directing the respondent nos. 2 to 4, to take immediate
steps in issuing the Work Order in connection with Request For
Proposal (hereinafter referred to as “RFP”).
2. The Department of Irrigation and Waterways, Government of West
Bengal, had invited RFP for selection of contractor for the work of
Dredging/de-silting/removal of river bed materials from New Cossey
River. The tender was invited on the basis of the recommendation of the
expert body, which conducted survey and recommended for dredging
for improvement of the health of the concerned river. Subsequent to
inviting the tender, it was detected that the stretch, for which the
tender was invited for dredging, was overlapping some of the auction
sand block by WBMDTCL. Accordingly, the Department of Irrigation
and Waterways invited further RFP for selection of Contractor for
dredging/de-silting of river bed materials, keeping distance between the
dredging site and sand mining blocks.
3. The petitioner has participated in the bidding process in response to
the RFP. In the auction process, the petitioner was found to be in serial
th
no.1 with a highest bid value of Rs. 5,86,58,035/-. On 15 March,
2026, Letter of Acceptance (hereinafter referred to as “LOA”) was issued
in favour of the petitioner for the work of dredging/de-silting/removal
of riverbed materials from New Cossey River from Tituan to Shyampur.
3
The petitioner was requested to contact with the Executive Engineer,
West Midnapore Division and to execute an agreement as stipulated in
the RFP by submitting performance security of Rs. 29,33,035/- with an
additional performance security of Rs. 1,17,32,139/- in the form of
Bank Guarantee in favour of Executive Engineer, West Midnapore
Division. The petitioner has submitted Standard Covering Letter for
Letter of Guarantee for an amount of Rs. 29,33,035/- and Rs.
th
1,17,32,139/- on 17 March, 2026 in favour of the Executive Engineer.
4. Mr. Sk. Md. Galib, Learned Advocate, representing the petitioner
submits that even after issuance of RFP and depositing security
guarantees, the respondent authorities failed to issue work order to the
petitioner without any reason. The petitioner has made several requests
to the respondent authorities for issuance of work order so as to enable
the petitioner to complete the work within the time period but the
respondent authorities failed to issue work order and accordingly, the
petitioner has filed the present writ petition.
5. Mr. Galib submits that in the LOA, the time to complete the work is
only 18 months but unless and until the work order is not issued to the
petitioner, it is not possible for the petitioner to complete the work
within the time prescribed in the LOA.
6. Mr. Galib submits that the petitioner came to know that one Sek Abdul
Mahatab had filed a Public Interest Litigation being W.P.A. (P) No. 287
of 2026 challenging the alleged illegality of issuance of multiple Request
4
for Proposal for the purpose of dredging/de-silting/removal of river bed
materials from New Cossey River from Tituan to Shyampur for a length
of 15.90 Km in Block – Debra, Paschim Medinipur under “No Cost to
State Exchequer” basis. The petitioner immediately intervene in the
said writ proceeding and objected for grant of any interim order and the
Hon’ble Division Bench refused to grant any interim order in the said
Public Interest Litigation and directions were issued for exchange of
affidavits.
7. Mr. Galib submits that the respondent authorities have the knowledge
that the Hon’ble Division Bench has not passed any interim order but
inspite of the same, the respondent authorities failed to issue work
order to the petitioner though the petitioner has submitted performance
security of Rs. 29,33,035/- with an additional performance security of
Rs. 1,17,32,139/- in the form of Bank Guarantee in favour of the
th
Executive Engineer, West Midnapore Division on 17 March, 2026.
8. The petitioner has relied upon the judgment in the case of Mihan India
Limited Vs. GMR Airports Limited and Others reported in (2022) 19
SCC 69 and submits that after issuance of LOA and accepting
performance security as well as additional performance security
amounts to a concluded contract.
9. Mr. Galib further relied upon the judgment in the case of Subodh
Kumar Singh Rathour Vs. Chief Executive Officer and Others
reported in (2024) 15 SCC 461 and submits that the respondent
5
authorities have not taken any decision for cancellation and without
taking any decision, the respondent authorities inspite of receipt of
performance security and additional performance security, have
deliberately not issuing the work order to the petitioner.
10. Mr. Rivu Dutta, Learned Advocate, representing the State submits that
though the LOA is issued in favour of the petitioner but work order
could not be issued to the petitioner as the department was examining
and adopting a revised mechanism for carrying out dredging/ desilting/
removal of river bed materials. The Department, with the concurrence
of the Finance Department, subsequently decided to adopt the
“Revenue Sharing Method” in place of the of the earlier “Volume
Sharing Method”, particularly for dredging works undertaken for flood-
management purposes.
11. Mr. Dutta submits that the department communicated the decision to
th
the concern authorities by a letter dated 9 June, 2026, informing that
the appropriate level of I&W Department decided that henceforth all the
proposed dredging/de-silting/removal of river bed materials are to be
carried out under e-auction platform of “Revenue Sharing Method”
instead of “Volume Sharing Method” at No Cost to the State Exchequer
Model.
rd
12. Mr. Dutta submits that the competent authority by a letter dated 3
August, 2026, directed that issuance of work order may be withheld till
rd
further order. He submits that by a letter dated 3 September, 2026,
6
the department decided in principle to cancel the identified ongoing
works under the “Volume Sharing Method” and process the balance
works under the “Revenue Sharing Method” for which work order is not
issued to the petitioner.
13. Mr. Dutta has relied upon the judgment in the case of Subodh Kumar
(supra) and submits that if the State deems it necessary to alter or
cancel a contract on the ground of public interest or change in policy,
such consideration be treated as bona fide .
14. The issue raised in the present writ petition whether the action of the
respondent authorities by not issuing work order to the petitioner,
though LOA is issued in favour of the petitioner and the petitioner has
submitted performance security of Rs. 29,33,035/- and additional
th
performance security of Rs. 1,17,32,139/- on 17 March, 2026, is
arbitrary.
th
15. There is no dispute with regard to issuance of LOA dated 15 March,
2026 in favour of the petitioner and the petitioner has submitted
performance security of Rs. 29,33,035/- and additional performance
th
security of Rs. 1,17,32,139/- on 17 March, 2026.
16. It is the specific case of the respondent authorities for non-issuance of
Work Order to the petitioner is that after issuance of LOA in favour of
the petitioner, the department has examined mechanism for carrying
out dredging/de-silting/removal of river bed materials and with the
concurrence of the Finance Department, it is decided to adopt “Revenue
7
Sharing Method” in place of the earlier “Volume Sharing Method” with
respect to dredging works undertaken for flood-management purposes.
17. The respondent authorities have submitted report along with a copy of
rd
order dated 3 September, 2026, issued by the Secretary–in-Charge,
Irrigation and Waterways Department with the concurrence with the
Finance Department and with the approval of the Competent Authority
which reads as follows:
“With a view to retrieve carrying capacity of
rivers and drainage channels, lost due to siltation
over the years, Irrigation & Waterways Department
has been carrying out dredging for flood
management adopting the Volume Sharing Method
of WBMDTCL since early 2025, by selecting
agencies through e-auction.
2. Unlike WBMDTCL, Irrigation & Waterways
Department has no stackyard for keeping the
government share of the dredged material. A
portion of the government share of the dredged
material is used for embankment repair as per
direction of the concerned Engineer-in-Charge and
the balance portion of the same is supposed to be
taken away by the dredging contractor by paying
the government a revenue per unit volume as per
existing Rates as applicable, if not otherwise used
by other government departments/organizations
like PWD.
3. There is always a probability of the left-out,
government share of the dredged material, lying
beside the river bank/embankment to be re-
deposited on the river bed during heavy rainfall.
Also due to lack of stackyard, pilferage of the
stacked material is almost unavoidable.
4. Considering this uncertainty, Irrigation &
Waterways Department, with the concurrence of
the State Finance Department, has promulgated the
tender document of e-auction, adopting revenue
sharing method of dredging vide memo no-73(9)-
IRC-IW-16099/15/2024/Deptt. of IW[E-1097188],
8
dated 20.02.2026 with subsequent direction vide
memo no-237-IRC-IW-14011(33)/2/2025-
SECTION(IW)-Dept. of IW (Computer No-E-
1177380), dated 09.06.2026 to follow the Revenue
Sharing Method only for dredging work with a view
to Flood Management. The main advantage of this
method is that there is no requirement of any
government stackyard as the total dredged
material except a very nominal volume, is taken
away by the dredging agency by paying a revenue
per unit volume apart from statutory taxes like
Royalty, Cess etc. on entire dredged material. It
emerges from the recent e-auction process of
Revenue Sharing Method for some stretches of
rivers across the state, that potential of revenue
generation is much higher than the Volume Sharing
Method. As such the State is making a huge loss
under the volume sharing method, which, is
against the public interest.
5. Considering above, it has been decided in
principle in the department to cancel all the 59 no.
of ongoing dredging works under Volume Sharing
Method (the list is at Annexure-I which were
Auctioned and grounded prior to promulgation of
Revenue Sharing Method), in the public interest,
referencing clause-11.1.1(b)-poor performance and
11.1.1(i)-loss of public interest of the tender
document and to re-auction the balance portion of
each work following the Revenue Sharing Method.
6. This order should be carried out forthwith
and an Action Taken Report is to be sent to the
Department within 7 days from the date issue of
this order. The EMD and Performance Security of
each work are to be refunded to the respective
agency without taking any punitive action. All the
aforesaid stretches shall be processed immediately
for auction under "Revenue Sharing Method" with a
minimum reserve price as fixed by the Department.
7. This issues with the concurrence of the
Finance Department vide their U.O.No.-PPP/2026-
2027/0009, dated 21/08/2026.
8. This is issued with the approval of the
Competent Authority.”
9
18. In the case of Mihan India Limited (supra) , the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held that:
“ 35. As per the above discussion, we do not
have any hesitation to hold that letter dated 7-3-
2019 is an LoA after selecting GAL as the highest
bidder and it acquired the status of concessionaire.
It was only the concession agreement required to
be executed and there was no fault on the part of
GAL in complying with the provisions of RFP. The
conduct of the appellant MIL also indicates that
concession agreement is required to be executed by
concessionaire (GAL). Thus, after proposal of the
highest revenue share on issuing the letter of
acceptance and also as reflected by conduct, it has
become a concluded contract.
49. It appears the objection has been raised
analysing the terms of RFQ and RFP issued by the
department on the basis of which the bidding
process was completed. In our view, the said
objection/clarification is suffering from the vice of
arbitrariness and without any justification. In view
of the discussion made above regarding
objections/clarifications of MoCA in Paras 5(i) to (iii)
in the proceedings dated 30-8-2019 are arbitrary,
unreasonable and without any justification,
submitted by the authorities even before this Court.
Therefore, all these queries are violative of Article
14 of the Constitution.
51. For dealing the fourth objection of the
meeting dated 30-8-2019 of MoCA and 14-10-2019
of PMIC, the Court knows its limitation and is
reluctant to interfere because they are not expert to
analyse the financial viability, but the Court can
see the justification of the issue in a matter where
after following the procedure established by law,
LoA was issued in favour of GAL. Awaiting long,
when the concession agreement was not executed,
GAL knocked the door of the Court and thereafter
the order of annulling of the bidding process has
been passed, which is quashed by the High Court.
In such circumstances, we have to examine
whether the defence taken by the authorities is just
and reasonable or suffers from vice of arbitrariness
on the pretext of loss to public exchequer.
10
60. Now, as per the material available and
discussed hereinabove, it is clear that the
appellants were aware of the procedure which is
being adopted. After completion of the bidding
process, GAL was declared as a selected bidder on
offering highest revenue share and on issuance of
LoA, it has been declared as a concessionaire and
at the stage of execution of the concession
agreement, all these formalities are not relevant
and it amounts to arbitrary exercise of the power
by the authorities which is not permissible under
law. The said approach is fortified with the view
taken in the judgment of this Court in Union of
India v. Dinesh Engg. Corpn., wherein while
dealing with the rejection of bid of the respondent
therein by the Railways in a tender floated for
procurement of certain items of spare parts for use
in GE governors, this Court has held that power to
reject bids cannot be exercised arbitrarily merely
because the Railways has the power to do so. Any
arbitrary exercise of power to reject bids has been
held violative of Article 14.
62. Bare perusal of the abovestated case law
in light of the facts of the instant case makes it
clear that merely having the power of rejection of
bids does not entitle authorities to exercise the said
power arbitrarily. While discussing the applicability
of Clauses 2.16.1, 3.3.1 and 3.3.5, it is made clear
that in pre-bid procedure prior to acceptance, the
bidding process may be annulled otherwise after
issuance of LoA, the annulment cannot be done.
The authorities further acted arbitrarily relying
upon the GoM's letter dated 16-3-2020 in reference
to PMIC's meeting dated 14-10-2019 in which re-
tendering was directed. Re-tendering was not
possible without ignoring the bid already accepted.
Therefore, the order of annulment has been
directed applying Clause 2.16.1 arbitrarily.
63. As discussed hereinabove, while
explaining the scope of Chapters 1, 2 and 3 of RFP,
it is clear that Chapter 2 deals with the bidding
instructions which are general in nature. Clause
2.16 deals with the rejection of bid which is a
situation prior to acceptance of the bid. After
Chapter 2, in Chapter 3 evaluation of bid starts.
While evaluating those bids in Clause 3.3.1, if the
11
provision of Clause 2.16.1 has not been invoked
and the bidder whose bid has been adjudged as
responsive in terms of Clause 3.3.1 and who
offered the highest revenue share would be a
selected bidder. In the present case, the selection of
the bidder was complete. Thereafter, LoA was
issued as per Clause 3.3.5 and by issuance of
draft of concession agreement, it has been declared
as a concessionaire. At that stage, Clause 2.16.1
for annulment of the bidding process would not
apply. It appears to us that as per the objections
raised in the meeting dated 30-8-2019 held by
MoCA, clause (iv) in Para 5 persuaded the MIL and
GoM to pass the order of re-tendering.”
19. In the case of Vice-Chairman and Managing Director, City and
Industrial Development Corporation of Maharashtra Limited and
Another Vs. Shishir Realty Private Limited and Others reported in
(2022) 16 SCC 527, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that :
“ 60. Ultimately, we need to consider whether
there was any illegality or unfairness in the
aforesaid transaction. The learned Senior Counsel
representing the appellants have submitted that
allowing sub-division of plots with change in land
use, had caused substantive loss to the State
largesse, as many people would have shown a
proclivity to buy land with different land use. On
the contrary, the learned Senior Counsel
representing the respondent lessees have stated
that the allotment, change in land use and transfer
have taken place in accordance with law. There is
no substantial deviation as sought to be projected
by the appellants herein. The appellants herein
have sought to invoke the doctrine of promissory
estoppel to argue that C IDCO could not have walked
out of the bargain, merely because of the possibility
IDCO
of larger profits. It is pertinent to note that, C
has failed to prove any losses suffered.
61. When a contract is being evaluated, the
mere possibility of more money in the public coffers,
does not in itself serve public interest. A blanket
claim by the State claiming loss of public money
12
cannot be used to forego contractual obligations,
especially when it is not based on any evidence or
examination. The larger public interest of upholding
contracts and the fairness of public authorities is
also in play. The courts need to have a broader
understanding of public interest, while reviewing
such contracts.”
20. The respondents finds that at present river/reservoir dredging with no
cost approach is ongoing by the West Bengal Mineral Development and
Trading Corporation Limited (WBMDTCL), Irrigation and Waterways
Directorate (I&WD) and District Administrations at 81 locations for a
total length of 625 Km. (volume around 5.30 Crore Cum) adopting
“Volume Sharing Method”. The I&WD has no stackyard for keeping
shared dredged material. The respondent authorities proposed for new
approach of dredging for flood-management as “Revenue Sharing
Method” instead of “Volume Sharing Method”. The respondent
authorities are of the view that if “Revenue Sharing Method” is adopted,
dredging/ de-siltation/ removal of such river bed materials having
conglomeration of different kinds of river bed materials, can be done by
paying royalty and other statutory taxes as per nature of the dredged
materials.
21. A “Volume Sharing Method” refers to a framework or algorithm used to
distribute economic profits, savings or benefits among multiple
participants, such as employees, business stakeholders or members of
an energy community, based on their specific contributions. “Revenue
Sharing Method” is a business arrangement where a predetermined
percentage or formula of gross top-line income is distributed among
13
multiple stakeholders, participants, partners or contributors. The profit
sharing, which distributes money only after all operating costs,
expenses, and taxes are subtracted. The Revenue Sharing Method
distributes a slice of the total incoming revenue as soon as a sale is
made.
22. The judgments relied by the petitioner in the case of Mihan India
Limited (supra) and Vice-Chairman and Managing Director, City
and Industrial Development Corporation of Maharashtra Limited
(supra) are distinguishable from the facts of the present case. In the
preset case, the respondent authorities after issuance of LOA in favour
of the petitioner before issuance of work order and execution of
agreement have re-examined the matter for adopting revised
mechanism for carrying out dredging/ de-silting/ removal of river bed
materials and taken decision to adopt “Revenue Sharing Method”
instead of “Volume Sharing Method”.
23. In the case of Subodh Kumar Singh Rathour (supra), the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that:
“ 131. We caution the public authorities to be
circumspect in disturbing or wriggling out of its
contractual obligations through means beyond the
terms of the contract in exercise of their executive
powers. We do not say for a moment that the State
has no power to alter or cancel a contract that it
has entered into. However, if the State deems it
necessary to alter or cancel a contract on the
ground of public interest or change in policy then
such considerations must be bona fide and should
be earnestly reflected in the decision-making
process and also in the final decision itself. We say
14
so because otherwise, it would have a very chilling
effect as participating and winning a tender would
tend to be viewed as a situation worse than losing
one at the threshold.”
24. Considering the above facts and circumstances of the case, this Court
finds that the Request For Proposal was processed on the basis of
“Volume Sharing Method” and after issuance of LOA, the respondent
authorities have re-examined the matter and decided to adopt “Revenue
rd
Sharing Method” and issued an order dated 3 September, 2026. The
respondent authorities have taken a conscious policy decision by
adopting “Revenue Sharing Method” instead of “Volume Sharing
Method”.
25. Admittedly, no agreement is entered between the petitioner and no
work order is issued in favour of the petitioner and in the meantime,
the respondents have taken a policy decision, thus no order can be
passed for issuance of work order in favour of the petitioner.
26. The petitioner has submitted performance security of Rs. 29,33,035/-
th
and additional performance security of Rs. 1,17,32,139/- on 17
March, 2026 but now the respondents have changed the policy decision
for which work order is not issued in favour of the petitioner,
accordingly, the respondent authorities are directed to return the
amount submitted by the petitioner being performance security and
additional performance security within one month from the date of
receipt of this order with interest at the rate of 12% per annum from
th
17 March, 2026 till the payment is made to the petitioner.
15
27. WPA No. 26288 of 2026 is disposed of .
Parties shall be entitled to act on the basis of a server copy of the
Judgment placed on the official website of the Court.
Urgent Xerox certified photocopies of this judgment, if applied for,
be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
(Krishna Rao, J.)