MILAN KNATI CHATTERJEE vs THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
1
In the High Court at Calcutta
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Partha Sarathi Sen
WPA 14221 of 2025
Milan Kanti Chatterjee
v.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the Petitioner : Mr. Sarbababda Sanyal
Mr. Paulami Chakrabarty
For the State : Mr. Siddhartha Goswami
Mr. Lokeshs Singh
Heard on and Judgment on : 16-11-2026
Partha Sarathi Sen, J.:-
1. The writ petitioner and the respondent State are represented by their
respective learned counsel.
2. By filing the instant writ petition, the petitioner has prayed for
issuance of appropriate writ/writs against the respondent authorities,
more specifically, against the respondent no.6 authority commanding
him to consider the representation dated 22.04.2025, as submitted on
behalf of the writ petitioner, a copy of which has been enclosed at page
nos.42 to 45 of the instant writ petition.
3. At the time of hearing, Mr. Sanyal, learned advocate appearing on
behalf of the writ petitioner, at the very outset, draws attention of this
2
Court to page no.21 of the instant writ petition, being a copy of the
memo dated 20.09.1999, as has been issued by the Assistant
Secretary to the Government of West Bengal addressed to the
Commissioner, Burdwan Division, Post Office – Chinsurah, District –
Hooghly whereby and whereunder sanction was granted for long term
settlement of the land as mentioned in the said memo in favour of the
present writ petitioner in terms of Rules 219, 220, 222 and 223 of the
West Bengal Land Reforms Manual, 1991 (the said Manual, in short).
It is submitted by Mr. Sanyal that thereafter an indenture lease dated
28.01.2000 was executed by the respondent State in favour of the writ
petitioner in respect of the said plot of land and at present the period
of lease has already been expired.
4. In his next fold of submission, Mr. Sanyal while drawing attention to
page nos.38 and 41 of the instant writ petition submitted before this
Court that soon thereafter the writ petitioner approached the
respondent authorities for renewal of the long term settlement in
respect of the aforementioned plot of land but despite issuance of
several memos, namely; the memos dated 12.09.2019 and 28.12.2023
by the jurisdictional Additional District Magistrate i.e. the respondent
no.6 authority, the respondent no.5 authority i.e. the jurisdictional
BL&LRO did not submit his field enquiry and status report to the
respondent no.6 authority and as a result whereof the prayer of the
writ petitioner could not be processed by the respondentno.6
authority.
3
5. Mr. Sanyal, thus, submits that it is a fit case for directing the
respondent authorities to consider the representation dated
22.04.2025 in accordance with law, in a time bound manner. Mr.
Sanyal further submits before this Court that the instant writ petition
is very much maintainable, since the prayer of the writ petitioner does
not pertain to ‘inaction’ or ‘culpable negligence’ of an authority under
the West Bengal Land Reforms Act, 1955 (the said Act of 1955, in
short) which is a specified Act under Section 2(r) of the West Bengal
Land Reforms and Tenancy Tribunal Act, 1997 (the said Act of 1997,
in short) rather the respondent authorities are duty bound to
discharge their duty in terms of Rules 219, 220, 222 and 223 of the
said manual.
6. Per contra, Dr. Goswami , learned advocate appearing on behalf of the
respondent State also places his reliance upon page nos.38 and 41 of
the instant writ petition being two memos dated 12.09.2019 and
28.12.2023. Dr. Goswami submits before this Court that on careful
perusal of the photocopies of the aforementioned two memos, it would
reveal that the jurisdictional Additional District Magistrate i.e. the
respondent no.6 authority requested the jurisdictional BL&LRO i.e. the
respondent no.5 to submit field enquiry and to send a details status
report along with formal renewal proposal. It is further submitted by
Dr. Goswami that on careful perusal of the entire writ petition, as filed
before this Court, it would reveal that the writ petitioner is really
aggrieved for non-action and/or inaction on the part of the respondent
no.5 authority i.e. the jurisdictional BL&LRO and, therefore, such
4
alleged culpable negligence and/or inaction of the jurisdictional
BL&LRO who is an authority under the said Act of 1955 shall come
under the purview of the West Bengal Land Reforms and Tenancy
Tribunal as constituted under Section 4 of the said Act of 1997, since
the said Act of 1955 is a ‘specified Act’ within the meaning of Section
2(r)(ii) of the said Act of 1997. Dr. Goswami, therefore, submits that
the instant writ petition may be dismissed on the ground of non-
maintainability, since the writ petitioner has chosen a wrong forum.
7. On careful perusal of the entire materials as placed before this Court
and after hearing the learned advocates for the contending parties, this
Court finds that the argument of Dr. Goswami regarding the non-
maintainability of the instant writ petition is found to be attractive at
the first blush, however, if I look to page no.21 of the instant writ
petition being a copy of the memo dated 20.09.1999 along with the
copy of the earlier registered deed of lease dated 28.01.2000 as has
been executed by the respondent State in favour of the writ petitioner,
it would reveal that in respect of the plot of land in question as
involved in the instant writ petition, such lease was granted in favour
of the writ petitioner under Rules 219, 220, 222 and 223 of the said
Manual. It, thus, appears to this Court that by no stretch of
imagination any of the provisions of the said Act of 1955 is attracted in
connection with the instant writ petition.
8. On further perusal of the entire materials as placed before this Court,
it appears that the prayer for renewal of the long term settlement of the
plot in question as involved in the instant writ petition cannot be
5
processed basically on account of non-submission of field enquiry,
detail status report as called for by the respondent no.6 authority as
well as for non-sending the formal renewal proposal of the long term
settlement in favour of the writ petitioner also by the respondent no.5
authority.
9. It thus appears to this Court that the writ petitioner has not
complained about any culpable negligence and/or inaction on the part
of the respondent no.6 authority in discharge of his duty under the
said Act of 1955 and on the contrary such inaction and/or culpable
negligence as has been complained in terms of the said Manual of
1991. Consequently, this Court is constrained to hold that the
instant writ petition is very much maintainable before this Court, since
the respondent no.5 authority is an authority under Article 12 of the
Constitution of India.
10. It further appears to this Court that the writ petitioner has made out a
good case to substantiate that despite submission of repeated
representations, the respondent no.5 authority remains mum and he
is equally not interested to comply with the requisition of his superior
i.e. the respondent no.6 authority.
11. In view of such, this Court while disposing the instant writ petition
directs the respondent no.5 authority to comply with requisition of the
memos dated 12.09.2019 and 28.12.2023 positively within fifteen
working days from date of communication of the server copy of this
order by submitting field enquiry report, detail status report as well as
by sending formal renewal proposal of the long term lease, if he is
6
prima facie satisfied regarding the entitlement of the writ petitioner
after causing field enquiry and other paraphernalia. On receipt of the
said field enquiry report, status report and formal renewal proposal, if
there be any, from the respondent no.5 authority, the respondent no.6
authority shall treat the copy of the instant writ petition as a
representation of the writ petitioner and after giving due chance of
hearing to the writ petitioner and/or his authorized representatives
shall pass a reasoned order and shall forthwith communicate the same
to the writ petitioner within thirty days from the date of receipt of the
status report and other reports from the respondent no.5.
12. The time limits, as fixed by this Court, are peremptory and mandatory.
13. Liberty is given to the learned advocate-on-record for the writ
petitioner to communicate the server copy of this order together with a
copy of the instant writ petition to the respondent nos.5 and 6
authorities, who are directed to act on the server copy of this order. It
is further directed that, in the event, the respondent no.6 authority
passes a reasoned order favourable to the writ petitioner, he is directed
to take all consequential actions soon thereafter.
14. Before parting with, it is, however, made clear that while disposing the
instant writ petition, this Court has not made any comment regarding
the entitlement of the claim of the writ petitioner regarding his prayer
for long term settlement and, thus, all points are kept open for
adjudication both by the respondent nos.5 and 6 authorities.
15. With the aforesaid observations, WPA 14221 of 2025 stands disposed
of.
7
16. There shall, however, no order as to costs.
17. Urgent photostat certified copies of this order, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance with all the necessary
formalities.
(Partha Sarathi Sen, J.)
S.R. [AR(C)]