State of WB and Ors vs KALPATARU MAITY AND ORS

Court
Calcutta High Court

Form No.J(2)
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present : The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya
&
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Md. Shabbar Rashidi

W.P.L.R.T. 215 of 2026
The State of West Bengal and Ors.
Vs.
Kalpataru Maity and Ors.
For the petitioners : Mr. Suryaneel Das, A.G.P.,
Mr. Atreya Chakraborty, Advs.
For the respondent nos.
1-2, 3(a) to 4, 5(a), 5(b) &
6 -14 : Mr. Golam Mastafa,
Mr. Tarasankar Samanta, Advs.
Heard on : November 17, 2026.
Judgment on : November 17, 2026.
Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya , J. :
1. Affidavit of service filed today be kept on record.
2.
This writ petition has been preferred against an order whereby
the learned Tribunal, while adjudicating upon a contempt

2
application, traversed beyond the scope of the original order and
passed a direction on the Block Land and Land Reforms Officer
concerned to record the names of the respondents in the Records
of Rights.
3. Upon hearing learned counsel for the parties and perusing the
narrative, as evident from the materials before us, it is found that
the chronology of events proceeded as follows:
4. After a bout of litigation initially, the matter came up before the
West Bengal Land Reforms and Tenancy Tribunal by way of an
original application bearing OA No. 1460 of 2006 (LRTT), which
was disposed of on February 28, 2008 by the learned Tribunal by
directing the Block Land and Land Reforms Officer, Belda, District –
Paschim Medinipur to consider and dispose of the demand justice
notice/application filed by the applicants (present respondents) on
March 17, 2006 in accordance with law by a reasoned order, after
affording just, fair and reasonable opportunity of being heard to the
applicants and all other parties interested in the subject land,
preferably within a period of six months from the date of
communication of the said order, in terms of the order passed by
the Division Bench of this Court in FMA 918 of 1990 read with FMA
331 of 1988.

3
5.
Subsequently, however, the D.L. & L.R.O., by a cryptic order
dated July 18, 2016 disposed of the said demand justice/application
of the present respondents without taking into consideration the
order of the Division Bench of this Court in proper perspective. This
prompted the present respondents to move the Tribunal again, by
way of a contempt application, giving rise to MA 128/2017 in
connection with OA 713 of 2016 (LRTT).
6. Vide Order dated March 23, 2018 passed therein, the learned
Tribunal rejected the compliance report submitted by the B.L. &
L.R.O. on the premise of his subsequent cryptic order and directed
him to pass a well-reasoned, speaking order afresh after taking into
account the judgment passed by this Court, having due regard to
other relevant provisions of law / Acts and to submit a fresh
compliance report within six months from the date of receipt of the
Tribunal’s order.
7. It was also recorded that the ratio of the judgments of the
Hon’ble Apex Court and/or High Court as may be relied upon by
him while disposing of the case should be well explained to
establish its or their relevance to the case.
8.
Subsequently, a detailed and reasoned order was passed on
March 17, 2022, whereby the concerned B.L. & L.R.O. took into

4
consideration several judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court as
well as of the Division Bench of this Court in FMA 918 of 1990 and
331 of 1988 and, upon his own interpretation of the said judgments
as well as the facts of the case, came to a reasoned conclusion on
the representation/application of the respondents.
9. However, thereafter the learned Tribunal, apparently being
dissatisfied with such order, vide the impugned order dated June
29, 2026, recorded that the petitioners therein (present
respondents) have endured the ordeal of protracted litigation in
order to establish their legitimate claim for more than four decades
and that any further delay in complying the solemn order of the High
Court, Calcutta is likely to cause irreparable mental agony and loss
to the petitioners further. The learned Tribunal went on to record
that it was not unmindful of the fact that the purpose and objective
of contempt application is not to punish but to ensure that the order
of the judicial authorities are given effect to in true letter and spirit.
10. However, thereafter, the learned Tribunal held that the B.L. &
L.R.O., Narayangarh, Paschim Medinipur, was being given a last
and peremptory opportunity “to comply the order of the Hon’ble
High Court, Calcutta and the order dated 06.01.2026 passed by this

5
Tribunal”, failing which, the Tribunal would be constrained to hold
that the order was being violated wilfully.
11.
It is the said last abovementioned order which is under
challenge before us.
12. The State contends that in view of the B.L. & L.R.O. having
passed a well-reasoned order in consonance with the Tribunal’s
direction, even if there was some demur or grievance about the
merits of the same, it furnished a fresh cause of action for an
appropriate appeal before the Appellate Authority. Within the limited
scope of contempt, it is argued, it could not be decided as to
whether the said order was in consonance with law.
13.
Learned counsel for the respondents, on the other hand,
submits that the order dated March 17, 2022 was further set aside
in appeal, which is disputed by the present petitioners.
14. Learned counsel for the respondents, however, fails to furnish
any document to show the order setting aside the decision of the
B.L. & L.R.O. dated March 17, 2022. Learned counsel for the
respondents argues that in view of the said order of the B.L. &
L.R.O. being set aside in appeal, the contempt revived.
15.
We are rather surprised with the argument of the private
respondents. It is well-settled that once an order is complied with,

6
no further contempt lies in respect thereof. In the present case, the
original order, in connection with which the contempt application
was filed in the first place, did not direct the B.L. & L.R.O. to outright
record the names of the respondents but merely directed the B.L. &
L.R.O. to consider the demand justice/application of the
respondents in the light of certain judgments of this Court and the
Hon’ble Supreme Court. It is precisely such exercise which has
been undertaken by the B.L. & L.R.O. by passing a well-reasoned
order dated March 17, 2022.
16.
From the said order, it appears that the B.L. & L.R.O. adverted
to all the facets of the direction of the Tribunal and arrived at its own
conclusions on an interpretation of law and fact as per the direction
of the Tribunal, in the process considering the relevant orders of
this Court as well as the Hon’ble Supreme Court as directed by the
Tribunal.
17. The legality of such order, even if challenged, furnishes a fresh
cause of action amenable to an appeal under Section 54 of the
West Bengal Land Reforms Act, 1955. The Tribunal, in contempt
jurisdiction, had limited powers, only to ascertain whether its original
order was complied with. In view of such compliance, we find that
the learned Tribunal traversed well beyond its jurisdiction in the

7
contempt proceeding, by passing directions on the B.L. & L.R.O.
which are much beyond the scope of the original order itself.
18.
Such exercise of jurisdiction is palpably misconceived and
unlawful and cannot be sustained.
19. In the event the respondents had any grievance against the
order dated March 17, 2022, the appropriate course of action would
be to prefer an appeal under the relevant provisions of law. The
Tribunal, however, flouted its limited jurisdiction in the contempt
proceeding by directing the B.L. & L.R.O. to record the names of
the respondents, which is much beyond the scope of the original
order.
20.
Since the B.L. & L.R.O. has passed an elaborate and reasoned
order in terms of the Tribunal’s direction, the contempt proceeding
ought to have been dropped.
21. In such view of the matter, the impugned order cannot be
sustained.
22. Hence, W.P.L.R.T 215 of 2026 is allowed on contest, thereby
setting aside the order dated June 29, 2026 passed by the Second
Bench, West Bengal Land Reforms and Tenancy Tribunal in MA
128 of 2017 (OA 713 of 2016)/LRTT.

8
23.
Consequentially, MA 128 of 2017 is hereby dismissed in view of
the concerned B.L. & L.R.O. having already complied with the
parent order of the Tribunal.
24. We make it clear that nothing in the above judgment shall
preclude the respondents, if otherwise aggrieved by the order of the
B.L. & L.R.O. dated March 17, 2022, to challenge the same by way
of an appropriate appeal under the relevant provisions of law. We
further clarify that we have not entered into the merits of the
proposed challenge of the respondents to such order, if any.
25.There will be no order as to costs.
26.
Urgent photostat certified copies of this judgment, if applied for,
be supplied to the parties upon compliance of all requisite
formalities.
I agree. ( Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J .)
( Md. Shabbar Rashidi, J .)
AD-8
Ct No.16
(SSS)