SMT.PREMAVATHI vs K C VENKATESH

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026





IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 6 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP SINGH YERUR

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 5269 OF 2026 (CPC)

BETWEEN:

1. SMT. PREMAVATHI
W/O SRI. KODANDARAMAYYA M
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
NO. A-309, 8TH CROSS,
NEAR NARASIMHA SWAMY TEMPLE,
KAMMAGONDANAHALLI, JALAHALLI WEST,
BENGALURU - 560 015.

2. SRI. DILIP KUMAR M
S/O SRI. KODANDARAMAYYA M
AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
NO. A-309, 8TH CROSS,
NEAR NARASIMHA SWAMY TEMPLE,
KAMMAGONDANAHALLI, JALAHALLI WEST,
BENGALURU - 560 015.

3. SRI. NAGENDRAN K
S/O SR.I KODANDARAMAYYA M
AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS
NO. A-360, 8TH CROSS,
NEAR NARASIMHA SWAMY TEMPLE,
KAMMAGONDANAHALLI, JALAHALLI WEST,
BENGALURU - 560 015.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. K.K. VASANTH, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. ASHOK BANNIDINNI, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. K.C. VENKATESH
S/O LATE CHIKKAVENATAPPA
AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS












Digitally

signed by
VINUTHA M
Location:
HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



NO. 12TH CROSS,
SHAKTHI MARIYAMMA TEMPLE ROAD,
NEARBY RAMA TEMPLE,
KAMMAGONDANAHALLI,
BENGALURU - 560 015.

2. VIJAY KUMARK
S/O VENKATARAMAIAH
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS
RESIDING AT 12TH CROSS,
SHAKTHI MARIYAMMA TEMPLE ROAD,
NEAR BY RAMA TEMPLE,
KAMMAGONDANAHALLI,
BENGALURU - 560 015.

3. CHANDRASHEKARK K.V
S/O K.C. VENKATESH
AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
RESIDING AT NO.12TH CROSS,
SHAKTHI MARIYAMMA TEMPLE ROAD,
NEARBY RAMA TEMPLE,
KAMMAGONDANAHALLI,
BANGALORE - 560 015.

4. RAJSHEKAR S
S/O SAMPANGI
AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
RESIDING AT PRASANNA BUILDING,
KAMMAGONDANAHALLI MAIN ROAD,
NEARBY RAMA TEMPLE,
KAMMAGONDANAHALLI,
BENGALURU - 560 015.

5. SRIDHAR V
S/O LATE VENKATARAYAPPA
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
RESIDING AT PRASANNA BUILDING,
KAMMAGONDANAHALLI MAIN ROAD,
NEARBY RAMA TEMPLE,
KAMMAGONDANAHALLI,

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



BENGALURU - 560 015.

6. PRATAP S
S/O SAMPANGI
AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
RESIDING AT PRASANNA BUILDING,
KAMMAGONDANAHALLI MAIN ROAD,
NEARBY RAMA TEMPLE, KAMMAGONDANAHALLI,
BENGALURU - 560 015.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. RAJESH A, ADVOCATE FOR C/R1 TO C/R6)

THIS MFA IS FILED U/O XLIII RULE 1(r) OF THE CPC,
AGAINST THE ORDER DT. 07.07.2026 PASSED ON IA.NO.1
AND IV OS.NO.7209/2025 ON THE FILE OF THE XXV
ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE, BENGALURU
CCH-23, REJECTING THE IA. FILED U/O 39 RULE 1 AND 2 R/W
SEC. 151 OF CPC AND ALLOWING THE IA.NO.IV FILED U/O.39
RULE 4 OF CPC, 1908.

THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP SINGH YERUR
ORAL JUDGMENT
This appeal is preferred by the appellants, who were
the plaintiffs before the trial Court, challenging the order
dated 07.07.2026 passed on I.A.Nos.I and IV in
O.S.No.7209/2025 by XXV Additional City Civil and
Sessions Judge, Bengaluru (for short, "trial Court"). The

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



respondents herein are the defendants before the trial
Court.

2. With the consent of both parties, the matter is
taken up for final disposal.

3. Parties shall be referred to as per their status
before the trial Court.

4. Brief facts of the case are as under:
The suit came to be filed by the plaintiffs against the
defendants seeking relief of permanent injunction in
respect of the suit schedule properties.

4.1 Upon entering appearance, the respondents-
defendants filed their statement of objections and
contested the matter.

4.2 Along with the plaint, the plaintiffs filed I.A.No.I
under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 read with Section 151 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short, “CPC”),

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



seeking an ad interim order of temporary injunction
against defendants not to cause any interference to their
possession over the suit schedule properties.
Consequently, the defendants filed I.A.No.IV under Order
XXXIX Rule 4 of CPC, seeking to vacate the order of ad-
interim temporary injunction granted by the trial Court,
prior to issuance of notice to the defendants.

4.3 Upon hearing the learned counsels for parties,
the trial Court did not find favour with the case of the
plaintiffs and also did not accept the contention of the
defendants that they were in possession of or had
established their possession over the suit schedule
properties. However, the trial Court held that the plaintiffs
had failed to make out a prima facie case or establish the
balance of convenience in their favour or demonstrate the
hardship likely to be caused to them. Accordingly, the trial
Court rejected I.A.No.I and consequently, allowed
I.A.No.IV, thereby vacating the order of temporary

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



injunction granted in favour of the plaintiffs. It is this order
passed on I.A.Nos.I and IV that is challenged by the
appellants-plaintiffs before this Court.

5. It is the vehement contention of the learned
counsel for appellants-plaintiffs that the trial Court has
committed an illegality and perversity in passing the
impugned order. It is further contended that the trial Court
has passed a mechanical order without properly
considering the materials placed by the plaintiffs. The
documents relied upon by the plaintiffs, including the
grant certificate, khata and succession certificate, the
subsequent registered gift deed executed in favour of the
legal representatives, namely, the plaintiffs and the decree
passed in favour of the plaintiffs in an earlier suit
instituted against the State in respect of the suit schedule
properties, have been conveniently ignored. It is further
contended that the trial Court, without properly examining
the documents relating to the title and ownership of the

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



plaintiffs, including the photocopy of the grant certificate
issued in their favour, has mechanically rejected the
application for temporary injunction.

5.1 It is further contended that the trial Court has
failed to appreciate that even a person in settled
possession is entitled to protection of such possession
unless dispossessed in accordance with law. Therefore, the
defendants cannot take the law into their own hands by
dispossessing the plaintiffs or interfering with their
peaceful possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule
properties.

5.2 It is further contended that the plaintiffs have
produced sufficient and voluminous relevant documents to
establish that they are the absolute owners in possession
and enjoyment of the suit schedule properties since as
early as 1991, pursuant to the grant certificate and the
subsequent revenue records standing in their names. It is
further contended that the finding of the trial Court that

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



the khata documents do not establish possession and title
is beyond the scope of enquiry under Order XXXIX Rules 1
and 2 of CPC.

5.3 It is further contended that the trial Court has
placed excessive reliance on the documents produced by
the defendants to contend that they are making public use
of the suit schedule properties, despite the fact that the
defendants have failed to establish any independent right,
title or possession over the suit schedule properties. It is
further contended that the trial Court has erroneously
concluded that the plaintiffs have failed to establish a
prima facie case and balance of convenience in their
favour and that there are no material documents to
demonstrate their possession over the suit schedule
properties.

5.4 It is further contended that despite the trial Court
having come to the conclusion that the defendants failed
to establish their possession or title over the suit schedule

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



properties, it ought to have granted an order of temporary
injunction in favour of the plaintiffs. It is further contended
that the suit schedule properties require to be protected
from being wasted or damaged by the public, as the same
belong to the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs would establish and
prove their right and entitlement over the suit schedule
properties during the course of trial.

5.5 It is further contended that despite the trial Court
coming to the conclusion that neither of the parties
established a prima facie case, it could have directed the
parties to maintain status quo so as to protect the suit
schedule properties from being exposed to antisocial
elements. Therefore, learned counsel contends that the
trial Court has passed perverse and illegal order without
properly considering these crucial aspects and materials
on record, consequently rejected I.A.No.I and allowed
I.A.No.IV by vacating the ex parte ad interim order of
temporary injunction. Hence, learned counsel seeks to

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



allow the appeal by setting aside the impugned order and
consequently, allowing I.A.No.I filed under Order XXXIX
Rules 1 and 2 of CPC.

6. Per contra , learned counsel for respondents-
defendants vehemently contends that the suit is one for
permanent injunction and therefore, the onus is on the
plaintiffs to establish their ownership, title, possession and
enjoyment of the suit schedule properties by producing
cogent and sufficient documentary evidence. It is further
contended that the plaintiffs are required to place on
record material to establish their actual physical
possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule properties.
However, according to the defendants, the plaintiffs have
neither produced sufficient documents nor placed any
cogent material on record to establish the said aspects.
The trial Court has rightly come to the conclusion that the
plaintiffs have failed to produce sufficient material,

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



particularly the grant certificate, which is the primary
document relied upon by them.

6.1 It is further contended that, till date, the
plaintiffs have produced only a photocopy of the said grant
certificate and have not placed the original document
before the trial Court. It is further contended that the said
grant certificate is a fictitious and concocted document and
therefore, cannot be relied upon, as rightly observed by
the trial Court. Learned counsel for defendants reiterates
and sustains the said finding/observation.

6.2 It is further contended that there is a serious
dispute with regard to the identity of the properties
claimed by the plaintiffs under the grant certificate,
particularly in comparison with the description of the
properties in the plaint and the subsequent records relied
upon by the plaintiffs themselves. It is further contended
that the khata extract and other municipal records
pertaining to the suit schedule properties standing in the

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



names of the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (for
short, “BBMP”) and the Government and therefore, the
plaintiffs have no right, title or interest in respect of the
suit schedule properties.

6.3 It is further contended that the plaintiffs are
neither the owners of the suit schedule properties nor are
they claiming any independent right over the same. It is
their specific case that the suit schedule properties are
Government lands and that the relevant records are
standing in the name of the BBMP. It is further contended
that the public are utilising the properties for social
activities and conducting public functions. Therefore, when
the plaintiffs approach the trial Court seeking an order of
temporary injunction, the onus is on them to establish a
prima facie case warranting grant of such relief. However,
the plaintiffs have not produced any cogent documentary
evidence, except the documents referred to hereinabove,
which, according to the defendants, are concocted and

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



fictitious. Hence, learned counsel contends that the trial
Court is justified in rejecting I.A.No.I for temporary
injunction.

6.4 It is further contended that the defendants have
produced sufficient documents before the trial Court,
including the letter dated 16.09.2005 to establish that the
State Government had taken possession of an extent of 11
guntas, which forms part of the suit schedule properties.
In this regard, the relevant endorsement has also been
placed on record. It is further contended that the State
Government has issued an order stating that the grant
certificate relied upon by the plaintiffs, as well as the
endorsement produced in support of their claim of having
obtained the grant from the Government, are fictitious
documents and that no such documents are available in
the Government records.

6.5 It is further contended that all these aspects
have been duly considered and dealt with by the trial

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



Court in its order. The trial Court has rightly come to the
conclusion that the plaintiffs have failed to make out a
prima facie case for grant of temporary injunction.
Therefore, the question of considering the other two
essential requirements, namely, balance of convenience
and irreparable injury or hardship, would not arise. The
defendants have no grievance with regard to the finding of
the trial Court that they have also failed to establish any
right, title or possession over the suit schedule properties.
However the land is being used as a public property
belonging to the State. Therefore, learned counsel
contends that there is no illegality or perversity in the
impugned order passed by the trial Court. Hence, he seeks
dismissal of the appeal.

6.6 Learned counsel for respondents-defendants
relying upon the judgment in the case of
Dr.B.R.Ambedkar Dalitha and Hindulida Alpa
Sankhyatara Gramabhivruddhi Sangha (Regd.) and

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



1
Another vs. State of Karnataka and Others , contends
that the Ashraya Scheme, which is claimed by the
plaintiffs to have been introduced by the Government
under Order No.HUD 535 KHB 91 dated 27.11.1991, was
not in existence in the year 1992.

7. Having heard learned counsel for appellants-
plaintiffs and learned counsel for respondents-defendants,
the following points arises for consideration:
"1. Whether the impugned order passed by the trial
Court calls for interference?
2. If so what order?"

8. Apparently, it is not in dispute that the suit filed
by the plaintiffs is one for the relief of permanent
injunction. I.A.No.I was filed seeking an order of
temporary injunction restraining the defendants or their
agents from interfering with the plaintiffs' peaceful
possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule properties.
The said application was initially allowed by way of an

1
ILR 2000 KAR 250

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



ex parte ad interim order of temporary injunction. Upon
appearance of the defendants, I.A.No.IV came to be filed
under Order XXXIX Rule 4 of CPC, seeking to vacate the
interim order of injunction, which came to be allowed by
the trial Court, thereby vacating the order of temporary
injunction.

9. When an application for temporary injunction is
filed by the plaintiffs, the trial Court is required to examine
the three essential requirements, namely, the existence of
a prima facie case, balance of convenience and the
likelihood of irreparable injury or hardship. The trial Court
is also required to assess which party would suffer greater
hardship and in whose favour the balance of convenience
would lie.

10. Admittedly, the suit is one for bare injunction and
not for declaration of title. Therefore, the onus is on the
plaintiffs to establish their possession over the suit
schedule properties by producing cogent and sufficient

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



material to the satisfaction of the Court. Insofar as vacant
land is concerned, the plaintiffs are required to establish
their title over the property, as possession is presumed to
follow title.

11. In the present case on hand, the plaintiffs have
placed reliance on the grant certificate, a photocopy of
which has been produced before the trial Court. They have
also relied upon the order passed in an earlier suit
instituted against the State Government, wherein an order
of injunction came to be granted in their favour. However,
the said order was passed ex parte against the State
Government and the present defendants were not parties
to the said proceedings. Therefore, the said order would
not be binding on the present defendants. Further, the
grant certificate relied upon by the plaintiffs is seriously
disputed by the defendants and the trial Court has not
accepted the same. Admittedly, the original grant
certificate has not been produced before the trial Court.

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



The plaintiffs have also not produced any other material
documents to establish their possession and enjoyment of
the suit schedule properties. On the contrary, the revenue
records and municipal records pertaining to the suit
schedule properties are standing in the name of the
Government.

12. On the contrary, substantial material has been
placed by the defendants to demonstrate that the suit
schedule properties forms part of a larger extent of 11
guntas of land, possession of which had already been
taken over by the State Government, as evidenced by the
letter dated 16.09.2005. It is also pointed out that several
materials have been placed on record by the defendants to
demonstrate that Government Order No.HUD 535 KHB 91
and the grant certificate relied upon by the plaintiffs do
not find a place in the Government records. Therefore, it is
for the trial Court to decide, on merits and upon
appreciation of the evidence adduced during trial, whether

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



the plaintiffs have established any valid right over the suit
schedule properties for grant of the relief sought. At this
stage, while considering an application for temporary
injunction, the Court is required to examine the affidavits
and the material documents placed on record, without
entering into a detailed examination of the merits of the
case.

13. The trial Court, having considered the documents
produced by both the plaintiffs and the defendants, has
rightly come to the conclusion that the plaintiffs have
failed to make out a prima facie case, much less establish
the balance of convenience in their favour or demonstrate
the likelihood of irreparable injury or hardship. Once the
plaintiffs fail to establish a prima facie case, the question
of further examining the other two essential requirements,
namely, balance of convenience and irreparable injury,
would not arise. This proposition is laid down in the
judgment in the case of Kashi Math Samsthan and

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



another vs. Shrimad Sudhindra Thirtha Swamy and
2
Another in paragraph No.16 which reads as under:
"16. It is well settled that in order to obtain an
order of injunction, the party who seeks for grant of
such injunction has to prove that he has made out a
prima facie case to go for trial, the balance of
convenience is also in his favour and he will suffer
irreparable loss and injury if injunction is not
granted. But it is equally well settled that when a
party fails to prove prima facie case to go for trial,
question of considering the balance of convenience
or irreparable loss and injury to the party concerned
would not be material at all, that is to say, if that
party fails to prove prima facie case to go for trial, it
is not open to the court to grant injunction in his
favour even if, he has made out a case of balance of
convenience being in his favour and would suffer
irreparable loss and injury if no injunction order is
granted. Therefore, keeping this principle in mind, let
us now see whether the appellant has been able to
prove prima facie case to get an order of injunction
during the pendency of the two appeals in the High
Court."


2
(2010) 1 689
SCC

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



Therefore, I do not find any good ground or cogent
reason to interfere with the well-reasoned order passed by
the trial Court. It is also relevant to note that this Court,
while exercising its appellate jurisdiction, is considering an
appeal against an order passed by the trial Court on an
application for temporary injunction.

14. However, this Court places reliance on the
judgments of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of
3
Wander Ltd. And Another v/s Antox India P. Ltd. ,,
which has been reiterated in Ramakant Ambalal Choksi
4
v/s Harish Ambalal Choksi and Others ., particularly in
paras - 9, 14, 21 and 22 which reads as under:
9. Usually, the prayer for grant of an
interlocutory injunction is at a stage when the
existence of the legal right asserted by the plaintiff
and its alleged violation are both contested and
uncertain and remain uncertain till they are
established at the trial on evidence. The court, at
this stage, acts on certain well settled principles of
administration of this form of interlocutory remedy
which is both temporary and discretionary. The
object of the interlocutory injunction, it is stated

3
1990 Supp Supreme Court Cases 727
4

(2024) 11 Supreme Court Cases 351

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



“...is to protect the plaintiff against injury
by violation of his rights for which he could not
adequately be compensated in damages
recoverable in the action if the uncertainty were
resolved in his favour at the trial. The need for
such protection must be weighed against the
corresponding need of the defendant to be
protected against injury resulting from his having
been prevented from exercising his own legal
rights for which he could not be adequately
compensated. The court must weigh one need
against another and determine where the ‘balance
of convenience’ lies.”
The interlocutory remedy is intended to
preserve in status quo, the rights of parties which
may appear on a prima facie case. The court also,
in restraining a defendant from exercising what he
considers his legal right but what the plaintiff
would like to be prevented, puts into the scales, as
a relevant consideration whether the defendant
has yet to commence his enterprise or whether he
has already been doing so in which latter case
considerations somewhat different from those that
apply to a case where the defendant is yet to
commence his enterprise, are attracted.
14. The appeals before the Division Bench
were against the exercise of discretion by the
Single Judge. In such appeals, the appellate court
will not interfere with the exercise of discretion of
the court of first instance and substitute its own
discretion except where the discretion has been
shown to have been exercised arbitrarily, or
capriciously or perversely or where the court had
ignored the settled principles of law regulating
grant or refusal of interlocutory injunctions. An
appeal against exercise of discretion is said to be
an appeal on principle. Appellate court will not
reassess the material and seek to reach a
conclusion different from the one reached by the

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



court below if the one reached by that court was
reasonably possible on the material. The appellate
court would normally not be justified in interfering
with the exercise of discretion under appeal solely
on the ground that if it had considered the matter
at the trial stage it would have come to a contrary
conclusion. If the discretion has been exercised by
the trial court reasonably and in a judicial manner
the fact that the appellate court would have taken
a different view may not justify interference with
the trial court's exercise of discretion. After
referring to these principles Gajendragadkar, J. in
Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd. v. Pothan Joseph
[(1960) 3 SCR 713 : AIR 1960 SC 1156] : (SCR
721)
“... These principles are well established, but
as has been observed by Viscount Simon in
Charles Osenton & Co. v. Jhanaton [1942 AC 130]
‘...the law as to the reversal by a court of appeal
of an order made by a judge below in the exercise
of his discretion is well established, and any
difficulty that arises is due only to the application
of well settled principles in an individual case’.”
The appellate judgment does not seem to defer
to this principle.
21. The order of the appellate bench is
common to the present suit as well as certain
other proceedings between Antox on the one hand
and certain other parties on the other. This
judgment and the observations therein are
confined to the facts Civil Suit No. 1220 of 1988.
The correctness of the appellate order in respect of
other cases is not the subject matter of these
appeals and that, therefore, whatever we have
said shall not prejudice the parties in those other
proceedings.

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62251
MFA No. 5269 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010485822026



22. Having regard to the nature of the
controversy, it will be appropriate for the High
Court to dispose of the suit expeditiously and we
request the High Court to dispose of the suit within
six months from today."

15. In view of the principles laid down therein, this
Court is not required to substitute its own opinion merely
because another view is possible, when the trial Court has
exercised its discretion judiciously. Under the
circumstances, I do not find any merit in the appeal.

16. Accordingly, I pass the following:
ORDER

i. The appeal is dismissed ;

ii. It is made clear that this Court has not
expressed any opinion on the merits of the
matter.

iii. All contentions are kept open.

Sd/-
(PRADEEP SINGH YERUR)
JUDGE


CPN, List No.: 1 Sl No.: 23