V JAYARAM vs M/o Railways
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
1 of 13
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CHENNAI BENCH
OA No. 310/00518 of 2022
.
th
DATED WEDNESDAY, THE 11 DAY OF NOVEMBER, TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
CORAM :
HON'BLE MS. VEENA KOTHAVALE, MEMBER (J)
HON'BLE MR. M.L. SRIVASTAVA, MEMBER(A)
BETWEEN
V. Jayaram
Rtd.Sr. Section Engineer/Tele
Electronic Lab, S&T Workshop
Podanur, Coimbatore 641 023. ...Applicant
(Advocate: M/s. Ratio Legis )
Versus
1. Union of India rep. By
The Secretary
Ministry of Railways
Railway Board
New Delhi-110001;
2. The General Manager,
Southern Railway,
Park Town, Chennai 600 003;
3. The Workshop Personnel Officer
S&T Workshop Southern Railway,
Podanur, Coimbatore 641 023. …….Respondents
(Advocate: Mr. J. Vasu )
CAV ON : 24.09.2026
2 of 13
O R D E R
(Hon'ble Ms. Veena Kothavale, Member(J)
This Original Application is filed by the applicant under Section 19 of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 seeking to quash the impugned order dated
04-12-2013 and for a direction to the respondents to accord sanction for two up-
gradations to the grade pay of Rs.5400/- with effect from 2011 with all attendant
benefits.
2. The brief facts of the case as stated by the applicant are that he was appointed
in the railway service on 01.05.1981 as Telecommunication Inspector Grade III and
after he successfully completed post appointment training, he joined the working post
on 17-12-1982 in Rs.425-700. Thereafter, the applicant was promoted to the grade of
Rs.1600-2660 as Grade II on 06-11-1989 which was later revised as Rs.5500-9000 by
the V Pay commission with effect from 01.01.1996. The applicant was further
promoted to the grade of Rs.6500-10500 as Grade I on and from 31-10-1997. Later,
the applicant was promoted to the grade of Rs.7450-11500 on 12-02-2007 as Sr.
Section Engineer.
3. After the implementation of the recommendations of the VI CPC with effect
from 01.01.2006, the grades of Rs.5000-8000 and Rs.5500-9000 were merged and
upgraded to Rs.6500-10500 and revised as Pay Band-2, Rs.9300-34800 plus Grade
Pay of Rs.4200 and the grade of Rs.6500-10500 was upgraded to Rs.7450-11500 and
revised as Pay Band-2, Rs.9300-34800 plus Grade Pay of Rs.4600/-. Thus the
3 of 13
promotions earned by, and the upgradations bestowed on, the applicant were nullified
due to merger of grades by successive Pay Commissions and were brought under a
common Pay Band of Rs.9300-34800 with Grade Pay of Rs.4200/- and the present
Pay Band Rs.9300-34800 with Grade Pay Rs.4600/- is due to upward revision by way
of replacement and thus, in the entire span of more than three decades of his service,
applicant did not have a single promotion during the period from 1981 to 2008 but
was given only one financial upgradation to the grade pay of Rs.4800/- under MACP
on 01-09-2008. As per para 5 of MACP/ Railway Board circular No.101/2009, the
applicant is eligible for two MACP financial upgradations. However, his
rd
representation dated 28.11.2013 seeking financial upgradation was rejected by the 3
respondent vide impugned order dated 04-12-2013 without considering said para 9.
Hence, this original application for the aforestated relief.
4. In the reply, the respondents have stated that the applicant was appointed as
Apprentice Telecommunication Inspector Gr. III in the Railway Service on
01.05.1981. Mandatory training of two years for this post which commenced on
01.05.1981 was to end on 30.04.1983, but applicant was absorbed into the working
post as Temporary Telecommunication Inspector Gr. III on 17.12.1982, curtailing his
training period due to the exigencies of service. However, the date of absorption
against working post for the purpose of seniority etc. will be reckoned only from
01.05.1983, i.e. the date following the date of completion of the normal period of
training of two years.
4 of 13
5. When the applicant was initially appointed, he was in scale Rs.425-700. He
was promoted to TCI Gr. II in scale Rs.1600-2660 which was later revised as
Rs.5000-8000 by the V Pay commission. He was further promoted to Section
Engineer w.e.f 31.10.97 in Rs.6500-10500 scale and was granted further promotion
as Senior Section Engineer in Rs.7450-11500 scale w.e.f. 14.02.07. On the
recommendations of VI Pay Commission and as per RBE No.226/2009, the grades
of Rs.5000-8000 and Rs.5500-9000 were merged and revised as Pay Band of
Rs.9300-34800 with a Grade Pay of Rs.4200 and the grades of Rs.6500-10500 and
Rs.7450-11500 were merged and revised as Pay Band of Rs.9300-34800 with the
Grade Pay Rs.4600/-with effect from 01.01.2006. As such, the applicant has earned
st
one promotion, i.e. from the Grade Pay of Rs.4200/- to Rs.4600/-, which was his 1
promotion. Hence, the applicant was eligible for only the second MACP as on
01/09/2008 as he had completed 25 years of service i.e. from 01/05/1983 to
01/09/2008.
6. As per RBE No.101/2009, there shall be three financial upgradations under the
MACPs, counted from the direct entry grade on completion of 10, 20 and 30 years of
service respectively. As per Para 9 of Annexure-I to RBE No.101/2009, for the
purpose of MACP, regular service is counted from the date of regular absorption into
the working post after completing the training period, but the training period cannot
be taken into reckoning the regular service. The date of regular absorption of the
applicant was 01.05.1983 and he retired from service on 31.12.2012. As the
5 of 13
applicant has not rendered 30 years of regular service at the time of his retirement and
rd
hence not eligible for 3 MACP. Hence, there is no merit in the claim of the
applicant and OA is liable for dismissal.
7. Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that as per FR 9(6), duty includes
service as a Probationer or Apprentice provided that such service is followed by
confirmation. As per DoP&T OM dated 22/10/1990, if a person has been selected for
regular appointment and before formally taking over charge of the post for which
selected person is required to undergo training, training period undergone by such
Government servant, whether on remuneration of stipend or otherwise, may be
treated as duty for the purpose of drawing increments. In the Service Certificate
rd
issued by the 3 respondent, the period of service of applicant is shown as 31.5 years.
Hence the applicant is entitled for the MACP so claimed and relied on the following
decisions: -
(i) Order dated 16/04/2024 of CAT, Mumbai in OA. No. 81/2019;
(ii) Order dated 07/08/2025 of CAT, PB, New Delhi in OA. No.
2143/2021;
(iii) Order dated 13/02/2026 of CAT, Allahabad in O.A. No.
980/2013;
(iv) Order dated 08/11/2023 of CAT, Cuttack in OA.No.485/2021;
(v) Order dated 27/03/2025 of High Court of Orissa at Cuttack in
W.P. No.17872 of 2024;
(vi) Hon'ble Supreme Court's Order dated 20/08/2025 in Sp. Leave
to Appeal (C) No.24399 of 2025 (arising out of order dated
6 of 13
27/03/2025 of High Court of Orissa at Cuttack in W.P.No.17872 of
2024);
8. Learned counsel for the respondents Mr. J Vasu reiterated the averments made
in the reply statement and submitted that as per Note (i) under Para 302 of IREM Vol.
I, in case the training period of a direct recruit is curtailed in the exigencies of
service, the date of joining the working post in such case shall be the date he would
have normally come to a working post after completion of the prescribed period of
training. As two years' mandatory training was to end only on 30.04.1983 and as per
Para 9 of MACPS, the training period cannot be taken into reckoning the regular
service for the purpose of MACP, at the time of his retirement from service on
31.12.2012, applicant had not rendered 30 years of regular service and hence
ineligible for MACP as claimed.
9. We have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel on both sides
and perused the record.
10. There is no dispute as to the date of appointment of applicant. The applicant
claims that he was appointed on 01.05.1981 as Telecommunication Inspector Grade
III and after successfully completing post-appointment training, he joined the
working post on 17-12-1982 in Rs.425-700. According to respondents, the applicant
was appointed as Apprentice Telecommunication Inspector Gr.III on 01.05.1981 and
had to undergo two years’ mandatory training for the said post commencing from
7 of 13
01.05.1981 and ending on 30.04.1983. It is further contended by the respondents that
his training period was curtailed due to the exigencies of service, and he was
absorbed into the working post as Temporary Telecommunication Inspector Gr. III on
17.12.1982. However, for the purpose of MACP, regular service is to be counted
from the date of regular absorption into the working post after completing the training
period and therefore, the date of absorption against the working post in the case of
applicant is to be reckoned only from 01/05/1983, i.e., the date following the date of
completion of the normal period of training of 2 years. Therefore, the dispute is on
the date to be reckoned for counting qualifying service for the purpose of MACP.
According to the respondents, the applicant has not rendered 30 years of regular
service as on the date of his retirement from the date of completion of his training on
rd
01/05/1983 and hence, he is not eligible for 3 MACP.
11. The learned counsel for the applicant argued that Rule 148(2) (iii) of the IREM
(Chapter I Section-B, Sub-section-III of the Rules for Recruitment and Training of
Group C and Group D and Workshop Staff) which provides for recruitment, training,
stipend, etc. of Telecommunication Inspector Grade –III, It is provided that training
will be for a period of 12 months and in case of intermediate apprentices, period of
training is for 8 months. Therefore, it is contended by him that only after successful
completion of training that applicant was absorbed in the working post on
17/12/1982. However, according to respondents applicant’s training period was
curtailed and he was absorbed on 17/12/1982 and for the purpose of seniority, etc.,
8 of 13
such absorption will be reckoned only from 01/05/1983 (i.e., the date following the
date of completion of the normal period of training of 2 years). As regards the power
to curtail the training period, the learned counsel for the respondent has drawn our
attention to Para 2.1 of RBE 261/90 dated 27/11/1990 (Annexure R-5) which
provides as under: -
“2.1. The General Managers have powers of curtailing period of
training of non-gazetted categories (whether as apprentices or
otherwise) in exigencies of service, ensuring that the prescribed tests/
examinations mandatory for successful completion of training are
complied with. On such curtailment of training, the trainees shall be
posted against the posts for which they have been recruited. They
shall, on such posting, be entitled to benefits as applicable to
incumbents of such posts except seniority and benefit of
increment. Grant of seniority and increments will continue to be
regulated as per existing orders in this regard.”
(Emphasis supplied)
12. It is pertinent to note that in the above para, it is also clarified that on
curtailment of training, if the trainee is posted against the post for which they have
been recruited, he is entitled to all the benefits as applicable to incumbents of such
post, except seniority and benefit of increment. However, as per the clarification
issued by the DoP&T vide OM dated 22/10/1990, in a case where a person has been
selected for regular appointment and, before formally taking over charge of the post
for which selected person is required to undergo training, the training period
undergone by such a Government servant whether on remuneration of stipend
9 of 13
or otherwise may be treated as duty for the purpose of drawing increments.
(Emphasis supplied)
13. A combined reading of Para 2.1 above and the DoP&T OM dated 22/10/1990
makes it clear that even though the training period is curtailed, the trainee on being
absorbed and posted against the working post is entitled to all benefits applicable to
incumbents of such post except seniority.
14. However, learned counsel for the respondent has further argued that Para 9 of
the MACPS (RBE No.101/2009 dated 10/06/2009) clearly provides that the training
period will not be counted for calculating regular service for the purpose of MACP
rd
and therefore, applicant is not entitled to 3 MACP as he has not completed
rd
qualifying service of 30 years for grant of 3 MACP.
15. Para 9 of MACPS defines the term “Regular Service” as under: -
“ ‘Regular Service’ for the purpose of MACPS shall commence from
the date of joining of a post in a direct entry grade on a regular basis,
either on a direct recruitment basis or on an absorption/reappointment
basis. Service rendered on an ad hoc/contract basis before regular
appointment on pre-appointment training shall not be taken into
reckoning. However, past continuous regular service in another
Government Department in a post carrying same grade pay prior to
regular appointment in a new Department, without a break, shall also
be counted towards qualifying regular service for the purposes of
10 of 13
MACPS only (and not for the regular promotions). However, benefits
under the MACPS in such cases shall not be considered till the
satisfactory completion of the probation period in the new post.”.
16. A perusal of the Service Register of applicant at Annexure R-1 reveals that
applicant was absorbed as Ty. TCI/III in scale of Rs.425-700 on 17/12/1982 vide
order dated 17/12/1982 and was posted to Mas/Division. It is stated therein that
applicant will be on probation for a period of one year from the date of absorption to
working post and his date of absorption against the working post for the purpose of
seniority, etc., will be reckoned only from 1/5/1983 (i.e., the date following the date
of completion of the normal period of training of 2 years). It is observed that
applicant has reported to duty at the place of posting on 17/12/1982. It is further
observed that Applicant’s pay was increased to Rs. 440/- with effect from 01/12/1983
and was further increased to Rs.455/- w.e.f. 01/12/1984 and to Rs.470/- w.e.f.
01/12/1985. Thus, it is seen that applicant was absorbed against the working post
with effect from 17/12/1982 and he has been granted increments on annual basis with
effect from 17/12/1982. In terms of FR 9 (6), “duty” includes (i) service as a
probationer or apprentice, provided that such service is followed by confirmation and
(ii) joining time. As per para 9 of MACPS also, regular service for the purpose of
MACPS commences from the date of joining a post on a regular basis either on a
direct recruitment basis or on an absorption/reappointment basis. Since applicant's
absorption from 17/12/1982 onwards constitutes a regular and continuous service,
and he has been granted annual increments regularly thereafter from 17/12/1982,
11 of 13
rd
prima facie it appears that applicant is entitled to 3 MACP as he has completed 30
years therefrom.
17. During the course of hearing, the learned counsel for the applicant has also
produced Pension Payment Order issued to the applicant wherein the date of his
appointment is shown as 01/05/1981 and his total qualifying service as on the date of
his superannuation on 31/12/2012 is shown as 31.5 years. Even in the Service
Certificate dated 31/12/2012 issued to him by the Chief Workshop Manager, Podanur,
the period of his service is shown as 31.5 years. The pensionary benefits have been
granted to applicant on the basis of his date of appointment as 01/05/1981. Even from
the date of absorption of applicant into working post w.e.f. 7/12/1982 till the date of
his retirement on 31/12/2012, the applicant has clearly completed 30 years of
rd
qualifying service entitling him to 3 MACP as per the MACP Scheme.
18. However, the representation dated 28/11/2013 given by the applicant for grant
rd
of 3 MACP w.e.f. 16/12/2012 is rejected relying on Para 302 of IREM Vol-1 which
falls under chapter III providing for rules regulating seniority of railway servants. It
is observed that Para 302 provides for seniority in initial recruitment grades and Note
(i) thereunder is as under: -
“(i) In case the training period of a direct recruit is curtailed in the
exigencies of service, the date of joining the working post in case of
such a direct recruit shall be the date he would have normally come to
a working post after completion of the prescribed period of training.”.
12 of 13
The above rule regulates determination of seniority alone and is not applicable to
grant of increment, financial upgradation and other benefits. Para 2.1 of RBE 261/90
dated 27/11/1990 (Annexure R-5) makes it abundantly clear that on curtailment of
training if the trainee is posted against the post for which he was recruited, he is
entitled to all the benefits as applicable to incumbents of such post, except seniority
and benefit of increment. Subsequently, clarification has been given by DoP&T vide
OM dated 22/10/1990 that the training period undergone by a Government servant,
whether on remuneration of stipend or otherwise, may be treated as duty for the
purpose of drawing increments. Therefore, as per applicable rules, the applicant was
entitled to all benefits available to incumbents of the working post to which he was
posted, except for seniority. Therefore, it was wrong on the part of the respondents to
extend para 302, which was solely applicable for determination of seniority, to grant
of financial upgradation under MACP also, thereby denying the benefit of the MACP
scheme to the applicant even though he had completed 30 years of service. Since the
applicant has been in continuous service without break from the date of his
appointment on 01/05/1981, he is entitled to count his qualifying service for the
purpose of financial upgradation under MACP with effect from the date of his joining
training in respect of the post for which he is selected.
19. It is observed from the order of High Court of Orissa at Cuttack in W.P.(C)
No.17872/2024 dated 27/03/2025 which has been upheld by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Special Leave to Appeal (C) No.24399/ 2025 vide order dated 29/08/2025
13 of 13
and a number of other cases referred to therein, the issue of counting of the training
period as duty and the inclusion of training period for computing qualifying service
for grant of financial upgradation ACP/MACP is no more res integra. The
Cocordinate Benches of this Tribunal at Cuttack (OA.No.485/2021), Mumbai
(OA.No.81/2019), Principal Bench at New Delhi (OA.No.2143/2021), etc., have
granted relief to the applicant therein directing the respondents to count the training
period as qualifying service for grant of ACP/MACP and the orders have been upheld
by the Hon’ble High Court and Suprme Court.
20. In view of the above observations, the impugned order dated 04-12-2013 is
rd
quashed and set aside. The respondents are directed to grant 3 MACP to applicant
under MACP Scheme by counting the qualifying period of 10, 20, and 30 years from
the initial date of his joining training on 01/05/1981 and accordingly revise the pay
and grant him all attendant benefits as per rules and applicable law within a period of
6 months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
21. In the result, OA is allowed to the extent as stated above. There shall be no
order as to costs.
(M.L. Srivastava) (Veena Kothavale)
Member(A) Member(J)
11.11.2026
asvs
Digitally signed by ASAPU
SRINIVASA VIDYASAGAR
Date: 2026.11.20 16:51:30
+05'30'
A.S.V. Sagar
P.S., CAT,
Chennai Bench.