Afzal Alarakha Mansuri vs Chembur Shivmurti Co Operative Housing Society Through Its Secretary Mr. Vijay C.Sharma

Court
Bombay High Court

CNR No : HCBM010120442026

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
SECOND APPEAL NO. 302 OF 2026

1. Ashwin Jain
2. Bhavana Jain,
Age: Not known, Adult Indina Inhabitant
Both Appellant Nos. 1 and 2 having
Address at 203/204, Vishwas Building,
DK Sandu Marg, Chembur,
Mumbai 400 071. ...Appellants
Versus
1. Chembur Shivmurti Cooperative Housing
Society,
Registered under MCS Act, 1960,
bearing Registration No. OM/HSCi/7647
Through Its Secretary, Vijay C Sharma,
Having address at Bldg No. 22, Subhash Nagar,
Chembur, Mumbai – 400 071.
ARUN
RAMCHANDRA
SANKPAL
Digitally signed
by ARUN
RAMCHANDRA
SANKPAL
Date: 2026.11.19
18:28:27 +0530
2. Adityaraj Housing Corporation
a partnership firm, duly registered under the
Indian Partnership Act, 1932
Through its authorised parnter Rajkumar G
Khushalani.
3. Afzal Alarakha Mansuri
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address At 17, Khan Cottage,
nd
2 Floor, Flat No. 3 Tandel St, M. A. Marg,
Near Haji Abdul Rahman Shah Baba Dargha,
Dongri, Chinchbunder, Mumbai 400 009.
4. Arvind Chanderdev Singh,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having Address at -Flat No. 840,
ARS
1/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
MS Building No. 24, Chembur Camp,
Chembur, Mumbai 400 074.
5. Deepak Prabhakar Thakoor,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Flat No. C-305,
Springfields Housing Society,
Kothrud, Pune-411 038.
6. Ashok Vishwakarma,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at 4/40,
Sahyog Building, 5 Mint Road,
Fort, Mumbai 400 001.
7. Association of Allottees of Subhash
Nagar Building No.22,
An unregistered association not having
any specific address hence served
through Respondent Nos. 3 to 8 & 10
being members thereof.
8. G. A. Builders Pvt Ltd,
Having its address at 606,
RNA Business Park Near Ambedkar Garden,
Chembur, Mumbai 400 071.
9. Michael Mascarenhas
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 721, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
10. Jyoti H Chandragiri,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 722, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
11. Ragunath S Karle,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 723, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
ARS
2/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
12. Narangibai L Kasbe,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 725, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
13. Otilia Pinto
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 726, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
14. Suganda S Rant,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 727, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
15. Sanjay M Veshvikar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Address at Room No. 728, Chembur Senhasadan
CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash Nagar, Chembur
East, Mumbai 400 071.
16. Suresh G Narvekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 729, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
17. Chandrashekar N Devadiga,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 730, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
18. Chandrakant B Mayekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 731, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
19. Kanchan C Mayekar,
ARS
3/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 732, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
20. Pushpalata B Salvi,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 733, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
21. Naru G Waghmare,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 734, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
22. Anna Durai,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 742, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
23. Nita B Nalavde,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 743, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
24. Govind R Ambekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 744, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
25. Madhukar S Veshvikar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 745, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
26. P. L. Franics,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 746, Chembur
ARS
4/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
27. J. K. Fernandes,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 748, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
28. Prerna P Bhatkar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 750, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
29. Kashinath S Bhayje,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 751, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
30. John A D’Souza,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 752, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
31. Sandip B Akolkar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having Address at Room No. 754, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
32. Shobha B Chawan,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 755, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
…Respondents
33. Sunil B Chawan,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 756, Chembur
Senha Sadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
ARS
5/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
WITH
SECOND APPEAL NO. 313 OF 2026
Deepak Prabhakar Thakoor
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Flat No. C 305, Springfields
Housing Society, Kothrud, ...Appellant
Pune – 411 038.
Versus
1. Chembur Shivmurti Cooperative Housing
Society,
Registered under MCS Act, 1960,
bearing Registration No. OM/HSCi/7647
Through Its Secretary, Vijay C Sharma,
Having address at Bldg No. 22, Subhash Nagar,
Chembur, Mumbai – 400 071.
…Respondents
2. Adityaraj Housing Corporation
a partnership firm, duly registered under the
Indian Partnership Act, 1932
Through its authorised parnter Rajkumar G
Khushalani, Shop No. 9, Ground Floor,
Kambodhi CHS Ltd, Building No. 106,
Road No. 13, Tilak Nagar, Chembur,
Mumbai 400 089.
3. Afzal Alarakha Mansuri
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address At 17, Khan Cottage,
nd
2 Floor, Flat No. 3 Tandel St, M. A. Marg,
Near Haji Abdul Rahman Shah Baba Dargha,
Dongri, Chinchbunder, Mumbai 400 009.
4. Arvind Chanderdev Singh,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having Address at -Flat No. 840,
MS Building No. 24, Chembur Camp,
Chembur, Mumbai 400 074.
ARS
6/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
5. Ashwin Jain
6. Bhavana Jain
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Both Respondent Nos. 5 and 6 having address at
203/204, Vishwas Building, D. K. Sandu Marg,
Chembur, Mumbai 400 071.
7. Ashok Vishwakarma,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at 4/40,
Sahyog Building, 5 Mint Road,
Fort, Mumbai 400 001.
8. Association of Allottees of Subhash
Nagar Building No.22,
An unregistered association not having
any specific address hence served
through Respondent Nos. 3 to 8 & 10
being members thereof.
9. G. A. Builders Pvt Ltd,
Having its address at 606,
RNA Business Park Near Ambedkar Garden,
Chembur, Mumbai 400 071.
10. Michael Mascarenhas
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 721, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
11. Jyoti H Chandragiri,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 722, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
12. Ragunath S Karle,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 723, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
ARS
7/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
13. Narangibai L Kasbe,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 725, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
14. Otilia Pinto
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 726, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
15. Suganda S Rant,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 727, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
16. Sanjay M Veshvikar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Address at Room No. 728, Chembur Senhasadan
CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash Nagar, Chembur
East, Mumbai 400 071.
17. Suresh G Narvekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 729, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
18. Chandrashekar N Devadiga,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 730, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
19. Chandrakant B Mayekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 731, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
20. Kanchan C Mayekar,
ARS
8/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 732, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
21. Pushpalata B Salvi,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 733, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
22. Naru G Waghmare,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 734, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
23. Anna Durai,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 742, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
24. Nita B Nalavde,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 743, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
25. Govind R Ambekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 744, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
26. Madhukar S Veshvikar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 745, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
27. P. L. Franics,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 746, Chembur
ARS
9/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
28. J. K. Fernandes,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 748, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
29. Prerna P Bhatkar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 750, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
30. Kashinath S Bhayje,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 751, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
31. John A D’Souza,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 752, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
32. Sandip B Akolkar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having Address at Room No. 754, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
33. Shobha B Chawan,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 755, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
34. Sunil B Chawan,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 756, Chembur
Senha Sadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
ARS
10/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
WITH
SECOND APPEAL NO. 304 OF 2026
Afzal Alarakha Mansuri
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address At 17, Khan Cottage,
nd
2 Floor, Flat No. 3 Tandel St, M. A. Marg,
Near Haji Abdul Rahman Shah Baba Dargha,
Dongri, Chinchbunder, Mumbai 400 009.
Through Power of Attorney Holder Shabana
nd
Banu Afzal Mansuri, 17, Khan Cottage, 2 Floor,
Room No.3, Mumbai 400 009. ...Appellant
Versus
1. Chembur Shivmurti Cooperative Housing
Society,
Registered under MCS Act, 1960,
bearing Registration No. OM/HSCi/7647
Through Its Secretary, Vijay C Sharma,
Having address at Bldg No. 22, Subhash Nagar,
Chembur, Mumbai – 400 071.
…Respondents
2. Adityaraj Housing Corporation
a partnership firm, duly registered under the
Indian Partnership Act, 1932
Through its authorised parnter Rajkumar G
Khushalani, Shop No. 9, Ground Floor,
Kambodhi CHS Ltd, Building No. 106,
Road No. 13, Tilak Nagar, Chembur,
Mumbai 400 089.
3. Ashwin Jain
4. Bhavana Jain
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Both Respondent Nos. 3 and 4 having address at
203/204, Vishwas Building, D. K. Sandu Marg,
Chembur, Mumbai 400 071.
ARS
11/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
5. Arvind Chanderdev Singh,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having Address at -Flat No. 840,
MS Building No. 24, Chembur Camp,
Chembur, Mumbai 400 074.
6. Deepak Prabhakar Thakoor
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Flat No. C 305, Springfields
Housing Society, Kothrud,
Pune – 411 038.
7. Ashok Vishwakarma,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at 4/40,
Sahyog Building, 5 Mint Road,
Fort, Mumbai 400 001.
8. Association of Allottees of Subhash
Nagar Building No.22,
An unregistered association not having
any specific address hence served
through Respondent Nos. 3 to 8 & 10
being members thereof.
9. G. A. Builders Pvt Ltd,
Having its address at 606,
RNA Business Park Near Ambedkar Garden,
Chembur, Mumbai 400 071.
10. Michael Mascarenhas
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 721, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
11. Jyoti H Chandragiri,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 722, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
12. Ragunath S Karle,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
ARS
12/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
Having address at Room No. 723, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
13. Narangibai L Kasbe,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 725, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
14. Otilia Pinto
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 726, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
15. Suganda S Rant,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 727, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
16. Sanjay M Veshvikar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Address at Room No. 728, Chembur Senhasadan
CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash Nagar, Chembur
East, Mumbai 400 071.
17. Suresh G Narvekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 729, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
18. Chandrashekar N Devadiga,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 730, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
19. Chandrakant B Mayekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 731, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
ARS
13/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
20. Kanchan C Mayekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 732, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
21. Pushpalata B Salvi,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 733, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
22. Naru G Waghmare,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 734, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
23. Anna Durai,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 742, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
24. Nita B Nalavde,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 743, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
25. Govind R Ambekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 744, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
26. Madhukar S Veshvikar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 745, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
ARS
14/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
27. P. L. Franics,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 746, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
28. J. K. Fernandes,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 748, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
29. Prerna P Bhatkar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 750, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
30. Kashinath S Bhayje,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 751, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
31. John A D’Souza,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 752, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
32. Sandip B Akolkar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having Address at Room No. 754, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
33. Shobha B Chawan,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 755, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
34. Sunil B Chawan,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
ARS
15/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
Having address at Room No. 756, Chembur
Senha Sadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
WITH
SECOND APPEAL NO. 286 OF 2026
Arvind Chanderdev Singh
Age: Not known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address At Flat No. 840, M.S. Building
No. 24, Chembur Camp, Chembur, ...Appellant
Mumbai 400 074.
Versus
1. Chembur Shivmurti Cooperative Housing
Society,
Registered under MCS Act, 1960,
bearing Registration No. OM/HSCi/7647
Through Its Secretary, Vijay C Sharma,
Having address at Bldg No. 22, Subhash Nagar,
Chembur, Mumbai – 400 071.
…Respondents
2. Adityaraj Housing Corporation
a partnership firm, duly registered under the
Indian Partnership Act, 1932
Through its authorised parnter Rajkumar G
Khushalani.
3. Afzal Alarakha Mansuri
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address At 17, Khan Cottage,
nd
2 Floor, Flat No. 3 Tandel St, M. A. Marg,
Near Haji Abdul Rahman Shah Baba Dargha,
Dongri, Chinchbunder, Mumbai 400 009.
4. Ashwin Jain
5. Bhavana Jain
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
ARS
16/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
Both Respondent Nos. 4 and 5 having address at
203/204, Vishwas Building, D. K. Sandu Marg,
Chembur, Mumbai 400 071.
6. Deepak Prabhakar Thakoor
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Flat No. C 305, Springfields
Housing Society, Kothrud,
Pune – 411 038.
7. Ashok Vishwakarma,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at 4/40,
Sahyog Building, 5 Mint Road,
Fort, Mumbai 400 001.
8. Association of Allottees of Subhash
Nagar Building No.22,
An unregistered association not having
any specific address hence served
through Respondent Nos. 3 to 8 & 10
being members thereof.
9. G. A. Builders Pvt Ltd,
Having its address at 606,
RNA Business Park Near Ambedkar Garden,
Chembur, Mumbai 400 071.
10. Michael Mascarenhas
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 721, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
11. Jyoti H Chandragiri,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 722, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
12. Ragunath S Karle,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 723, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
ARS
17/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
13. Narangibai L Kasbe,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 725, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
14. Otilia Pinto
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 726, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
15. Suganda S Rant,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 727, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
16. Sanjay M Veshvikar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Address at Room No. 728, Chembur Senhasadan
CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash Nagar, Chembur
East, Mumbai 400 071.
17. Suresh G Narvekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 729, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
18. Chandrashekar N Devadiga,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 730, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
19. Chandrakant B Mayekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 731, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
ARS
18/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
20. Kanchan C Mayekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 732, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
21. Pushpalata B Salvi,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 733, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
22. Naru G Waghmare,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 734, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
23. Anna Durai,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 742, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
24. Nita B Nalavde,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 743, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
25. Govind R Ambekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 744, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
26. Madhukar S Veshvikar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 745, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
27. P. L. Franics,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
ARS
19/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
Having address at Room No. 746, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
28. J. K. Fernandes,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 748, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
29. Prerna P Bhatkar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 750, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
30. Kashinath S Bhayje,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 751, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
31. John A D’Souza,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 752, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
32. Sandip B Akolkar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having Address at Room No. 754, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
33. Shobha B Chawan,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 755, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
34. Sunil B Chawan,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 756, Chembur
Senha Sadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
ARS
20/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
WITH
SECOND APPEAL NO. 287 OF 2026
Ashok Vishwakarma
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Address at 4/40, Sahyog Bldg No. 5, Mint Road, ...Appellant
Fort, Mumbai 400 001.
Versus

1. Chembur Shivmurti Cooperative Housing
Society,
Registered under MCS Act, 1960,
bearing Registration No. OM/HSCi/7647
Through Its Secretary, Vijay C Sharma,
Having address at Bldg No. 22, Subhash Nagar,
Chembur, Mumbai – 400 071.
…Respondents
2. Adityaraj Housing Corporation
a partnership firm, duly registered under the
Indian Partnership Act, 1932
Through its authorised parnter Rajkumar G
Khushalani.
3. Afzal Alarakha Mansuri
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address At 17, Khan Cottage,
nd
2 Floor, Flat No. 3 Tandel St, M. A. Marg,
Near Haji Abdul Rahman Shah Baba Dargha,
Dongri, Chinchbunder, Mumbai 400 009.
4. Arvind Chanderdev Singh
Age: Not known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address At Flat No. 840, M.S. Building
No. 24, Chembur Camp, Chembur,
Mumbai 400 074.
5. Ashwin Jain
ARS
21/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
6. Bhavana Jain
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Both Respondent Nos. 5 and 6 having address at
203/204, Vishwas Building, D. K. Sandu Marg,
Chembur, Mumbai 400 071.
7. Deepak Prabhakar Thakoor
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Flat No. C 305, Springfields
Housing Society, Kothrud,
Pune – 411 038.
8. Association of Allottees of Subhash
Nagar Building No.22,
An unregistered association not having
any specific address hence served
through Respondent Nos. 3 to 8 & 10
being members thereof.
9. G. A. Builders Pvt Ltd,
Having its address at 606,
RNA Business Park Near Ambedkar Garden,
Chembur, Mumbai 400 071.
10. Michael Mascarenhas
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 721, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
11. Jyoti H Chandragiri,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 722, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
12. Ragunath S Karle,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 723, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
13. Narangibai L Kasbe,
ARS
22/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 725, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
14. Otilia Pinto
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 726, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
15. Suganda S Rant,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 727, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
16. Sanjay M Veshvikar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Address at Room No. 728, Chembur Senhasadan
CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash Nagar, Chembur
East, Mumbai 400 071.
17. Suresh G Narvekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 729, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
18. Chandrashekar N Devadiga,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 730, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
19. Chandrakant B Mayekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 731, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
20. Kanchan C Mayekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 732, Chembur
ARS
23/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
21. Pushpalata B Salvi,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 733, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
22. Naru G Waghmare,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 734, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
23. Anna Durai,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 742, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
24. Nita B Nalavde,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 743, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
25. Govind R Ambekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 744, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
26. Madhukar S Veshvikar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 745, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
27. P. L. Franics,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 746, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
ARS
24/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
28. J. K. Fernandes,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 748, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
29. Prerna P Bhatkar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 750, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
30. Kashinath S Bhayje,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 751, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
31. John A D’Souza,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 752, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
32. Sandip B Akolkar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having Address at Room No. 754, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
33. Shobha B Chawan,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 755, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
34. Sunil B Chawan,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 756, Chembur
Senha Sadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
ARS
25/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
WITH
SECOND APPEAL (ST) NO. 10515 OF 2026
Association of Allottees of Subhash Nagar,
Building No. 22, an unregistered association
not having any specific address hence served
through Respondent Nos. 3 to 9 being members
thereof ...Appellant
Versus

1. Chembur Shivmurti Cooperative Housing
Society,
Registered under MCS Act, 1960,
bearing Registration No. OM/HSCi/7647
Through Its Secretary, Vijay C Sharma,
Having address at Bldg No. 22, Subhash Nagar,
Chembur, Mumbai – 400 071.
…Respondents
2. Adityaraj Housing Corporation
a partnership firm, duly registered under the
Indian Partnership Act, 1932
Through its authorised parnter Rajkumar G
Khushalani.
3. Afzal Alarakha Mansuri
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address At 17, Khan Cottage,
nd
2 Floor, Flat No. 3 Tandel St, M. A. Marg,
Near Haji Abdul Rahman Shah Baba Dargha,
Dongri, Chinchbunder, Mumbai 400 009.
4. Ashwin Jain
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
5. Bhavana Jain
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Both Respondent Nos. 4 and 5 having address at
203/204, Vishwas Building, D. K. Sandu Marg,
Chembur, Mumbai 400 071.
ARS
26/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
6. Arvind Chanderdev Singh
Age: Not known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address At Flat No. 840, M.S. Building
No. 24, Chembur Camp, Chembur,
Mumbai 400 074.
7. Deepak Prabhakar Thakoor
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Flat No. C 305, Springfields
Housing Society, Kothrud,
Pune – 411 038.
8. Ashok Vishwakarma
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Address at 4/40, Sahyog Bldg No. 5, Mint Road,
Fort, Mumbai 400 001.
9. G. A. Builders Pvt Ltd,
Having its address at 606,
RNA Business Park Near Ambedkar Garden,
Chembur, Mumbai 400 071.
10. Michael Mascarenhas
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 721, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
11. Jyoti H Chandragiri,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 722, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
12. Ragunath S Karle,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 723, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
13. Narangibai L Kasbe,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 725, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
ARS
27/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
14. Otilia Pinto
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 726, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
15. Suganda S Rant,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 727, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
16. Sanjay M Veshvikar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Address at Room No. 728, Chembur Senhasadan
CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash Nagar, Chembur
East, Mumbai 400 071.
17. Suresh G Narvekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 729, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
18. Chandrashekar N Devadiga,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 730, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
19. Chandrakant B Mayekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 731, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
20. Kanchan C Mayekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 732, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
ARS
28/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
21. Pushpalata B Salvi,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 733, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
22. Naru G Waghmare,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 734, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
23. Anna Durai,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 742, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
24. Nita B Nalavde,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 743, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
25. Govind R Ambekar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 744, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
26. Madhukar S Veshvikar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 745, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
27. P. L. Franics,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 746, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
28. J. K. Fernandes,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
ARS
29/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
Having address at Room No. 748, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
29. Prerna P Bhatkar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 750, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
30. Kashinath S Bhayje,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 751, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
31. John A D’Souza,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 752, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
32. Sandip B Akolkar,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having Address at Room No. 754, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
33. Shobha B Chawan,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 755, Chembur
Senhasadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
34. Sunil B Chawan,
Age: Not Known, Adult Indian Inhabitant,
Having address at Room No. 756, Chembur
Senha Sadan CHS, Building No. 21, Subhash
Nagar, Chembur East, Mumbai 400 071.
Dr. Sanjay Chaturvedi, for the Appellant in SA/302/2026,
SA/304/2026, SA/313/2026, SA/286/2026 and SA/287/2026.
ARS
30/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
Mr. Sarosh Bharucha, with Shreeram and Mehdarin Bhatt, I/b M/s
MV Law Partners, for the Appellant in SAST/10515/2026 and
for Respondent No.7 in SA/302/2026.
Mr. Mohanish Chaudhari, for Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 in All Appeals.
Ms. Dipashri Raorane, for Respondent No.8.
CORAM : N. J. JAMADAR, J.
th
RESERVED ON : 12 AUGUST 2026
th
PRONOUNCED ON : 18 NOVEMBER 2026
JUDGMENT:
1.
These Appeals are directed against a common judgment and
order passed by the Maharashtra Real Estate Appellate Tribunal,
th
Mumbai (“the Appellate Tribunal”) dated 6 January 2026, in the
appeals preferred by respondent Nos. 1 and 2 herein, whereby the
common order passed by the Maharashtra Real Estate Regulatory
st
Authority (“the Authority”) dated 31 July 2025 on the complaints filed
by the complainants-appellants herein, inter alia, directing that the
registration of the project to be kept in abeyance and status-quo be
maintained till the proceedings between the parties in the other
Courts/Forums were adjudicated, came to be set aside.
2.
Though there is a chequered history of litigation before the
Arbitral Tribunal, this Court and the Consumer Fora, yet, the
background facts necessary for the determination of these appeals can
be stated in brief as under:
ARS
31/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
2.1 As these appeals arise out of identical background facts and the
authorities below have adverted to the common questions of law, which
in their estimation arose for consideration, all these appeals were heard
together and are being decided by this common judgment.
2.2 For the sake of clarity and convenience, the appellants are
hereinafter referred to as the complainants, respondent No.1 as the
society, and respondent No.2, as the new developer and respondent
No.8 as the erstwhile developer. The facts in Second Appeal (Stamp)
No. 10515 of 2026 arising out of Appeal No. AT006/00937/2025 before
the Appellate Tribunal and Complaint No. CC12400064, preferred
before the Authority, are taken as a representative case.
2.3 Chembur Shivsmruti Cooperative Housing Society (“the society)-
respondent No.1, is a society registered under the Maharashtra
Cooperative Societies Act, 1960. It comprised 36 members. The society
is the holder of land and building No. 22, Wings A and B, situated at
Subhash Nagar, Chembur, Mumbai (“the society premises”). Under a
th
development agreement dated 25 October 2007, G.A. Builders Pvt Ltd,
respondent No. 8 (the erstwhile developer), was initially appointed by
the society as a developer to redevelop the society premises, as it was in
a dilapidated state.
2.4 The erstwhile developer committed default in the performance of
its part of the contract. The erstwhile developer allegedly abandoned
ARS
32/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
the redevelopment project with partially constructed structures on the
society premises. The erstwhile developer also committed default in
payment of transit rent to the members of the society who had vacated
their respective premises in the said building. Eventually, the society
th
professed to terminate the said development agreement on 8 August
2019.
2.5 The society also appointed respondent No.2 as a new developer,
to redevelop the society premises. However, the society alleged, the
erstwhile developer put hindrances in the redevelopment of the society
premises by the new developer. A series of proceedings followed.
2.6 The society filed an arbitration petition No. 1474 of 2019, under
Section 9 of the Arbitration And Conciliation Act, 1996 (“the Act,
th
1996”) and by an order dated 4 December 2019, the erstwhile
developer was restrained from obstructing the process of appointing a
new developer or the self-development process initiated by the society
for redevelopment of the society premises. Eventually, the said order
th
was made absolute by a further order dated 20 February 2020.
2.7 Two applications under Section 17 of the Act, 1996, were filed
th
before the Arbitral Tribunal. By an order dated 26 June 2023, the
prayers in the application of the erstwhile developer were rejected,
whereas the application filed by the society came to be allowed and the
ARS
33/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
erstwhile developer was directed to remove articles, things and
machinery from the society premises.
2.8 The appellants-complainants claim that they had entered into
agreements with the erstwhile developer to purchase the respective
units, in the sale component of the project in question and parted with
varying amounts. It was alleged that, there were 17 persons who had
purchased the units in the sale component of the project. Out of those
persons, nine purported allottees filed Writ Petition (L) No. 1776 of
2023 before this Court.
th
2.9 By a judgment and order dated 12 October 2023, a Division
Bench of this Court dismissed the said petition, opining inter alia that
the purported allottees of the units in the sale component of the project
being the third party purchasers from the erstwhile developer were not
entitled to enforce their substantive rights qua the society.
2.10 Seven purported allottees filed a consumer complaint before the
National Consumer Dispute Redressal Commission (“NCDRC”), being
th
complaint No. 170 of 2023. By an order dated 13 May 2024, the
NCDRC vacated the ex parte interim order initially granted. Those
complainants preferred an appeal before the Supreme Court, being Civil
Appeal (Dairy) No. 23166 of 2024 which was disposed of by the
Supreme Court observing that a fresh application, if any, for interim
relief could be considered on its own merits by the NCDRC.
ARS
34/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
2.10A Another group of allottees filed a second consumer complaint No.
27 of 2024, before the NCDRC, in which interim application was filed
but not moved.
2.11 In the backdrop of the aforesaid proceedings, the appellants-
complainants filed complaints before the Authority. An association of
purported allottees of the Subhash Nagar Building No.22 in the sale
component of the project, filed another complaint No. CC1250081. The
complainants inter alia sought directions to direct the erstwhile
developer and the society to give possession of their respective units
and also directions to the society to grant the complainants its
membership.
st
2.12 By a common order dated 31 July 2025, the Authority, after
noting the history and outcome of the proceedings that had taken place
between the parties and the pendency of the proceedings, posed unto
itself the question, whether it would be appropriate to adjudicate the
complaints on merits, in the face of aforesaid orders and the pendency
of the proceedings.
2.13 The Authority was of the view that, the new developer was not
the promoter of the subject project. Yet, the new developer was
executing the redevelopment project. The record to be mandatorily
disclosed by the promoter under the regime of the Real Estate
(Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (“ the RERA”) did not disclose
ARS
35/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
the fact that the new developer was not the promoter of the project and
thus there was a risk of further third party rights being created in the
subject project, which may impair the rights and interests of the
purported allottees of the units in the sale component of the project.
2.14 Adverting to the object of the RERA, the Authority considered it
appropriate to protect the rights of the allottees and, thus, without
delving into the merits of the matter, disposed the complaints by
directing that the registration of the subject project be kept in abeyance
till the proceedings before the Arbitral Tribunal and all other Courts of
law, were finally determined, restrained the new developer from
advertising the project and entering into any transaction in connection
with the subject project and directed all parties to maintain status-quo
with respect to all the activities pertaining to the subject project.
2.15 Being aggrieved, the society and the new developer preferred the
appeals before the Appellate Tribunal.
2.16 By the impugned common judgment and order, the Appellate
Tribunal was persuaded to interfere with the order passed by the
Authority, primarily for the reason that, in the backdrop of the facts that
there was no privity of contract between the society and the
complainants, who were the allottees of the erstwhile developer, the
complainants were not entitled to enforce their remedies against the
society and the new developer.
ARS
36/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
2.17 Support was sought to be drawn from a line of judgments
delivered by this Court starting from a decision of a learned Single
Judge in the case of Vaidehi Akash Housing Pvt Ltd Vs New D. N. Nagar
1
CHS Union Ltd & Ors , wherein it has been consistently enunciated that
the third party purchasers will have no rights over the assets of the
society on the basis of the contract entered into by them with the
erstwhile developer, whose appointment has been terminated, and that
they cannot enforce their rights against the society or the new
developer. The Appellate Tribunal thus allowed the appeals and set
aside the orders passed by the Authority.
2.18 Being aggrieved, the complainants have preferred these appeals.
3.
I have heard Dr. Sanjay Chaturvedi, the learned Counsel for the
appellants in Second Appeal Nos. 302 of 2026, 304 of 2026, 313 of
2026, 286 of 2026 and 287 of 2026, Mr. Sarosh Bharucha, the learned
Counsel for the appellant in Second Appeal (Stamp) No. 10515 of 2026
and for respondent No. 7 in Second Appeal No. 302 of 2026, Mr.
Mohanish Chaudhari, for respondent Nos. 1 and 2 in all appeals and
Ms. Dipashri Raorane, the learned Counsel for respondent No. 8, at
some length. With the assistance of the learned Counsel for the parties,
I have perused the material on record.
4.
Dr. Sanjay Chaturvedi, the learned Counsel for the appellants in
Second Appeal Nos. 302 of 2026, 304 of 2026, 313 of 2026, 286 of
1
2014 SCC OnLine Bom 5068.
ARS
37/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
2026 and 287 of 2026 would submit that the Appellate Tribunal
completely misdirected itself in overturning the findings of the
Authority by following the line of decisions in regard to the rights of the
third party purchasers from the erstwhile developer qua the society,
without appreciating the significant legislative change brought by the
enactment of the RERA 2016. It was submitted that the Appellate
Tribunal was completely swayed by the aforesaid line of decisions
rendered while the legal regime was completely different.
5.
Under the provisions of Section 15 (1) of RERA 2016, obligations
are cast on the promoter not to transfer, or assign his majority rights
and liabilities in a project to a third party without obtaining prior
written consent from 2/3 allottees, and without prior written approval
of the Authority. Section 18 of RERA 2016 confers indefeasible
substantive rights on the allottees in the event of default on the part of
the promoter. The effect of the aforesaid change in the legislative
regime was not properly appreciated by the Appellate Tribunal.
6.
Moreover, Dr. Chaturvedi would urge that the Supreme Court in
the case of
Goregaon Pearl Cooperative Housing Society Limited
2
deviated from the line of
Vs Sandeep Grover and Ors has
decisions representing Vaidehi Akash Housing Pvt Ltd (Supra). The
Appellate Tribunal simply observed that the said decision in the case of

2
2023 SCC OnLine SC 1687.
ARS
38/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
(Supra) did not govern the facts of the
Sandeep Grover and Ors
case, and the Appellate Tribunal was bound by the law laid down by
this Court. The aforesaid reasoning of the Appellate Tribunal gives rise
to substantial questions of law, especially, in the light of the judgment of
the Supreme Court in the case of Sandeep Grover (Supra).
7.
Mr. Sarosh Bharucha, the learned Counsel for the appellant in
Second Appeal (Stamp) No. 10515 of 2026, while supplementing the
aforesaid submissions of Dr. Chaturvedi, would urge that the Appellate
Tribunal has completely ignored the doctrine of merger. The decision of
the Supreme Court in the case of Sandeep Grover And Anr (Supra)
arose out of a statutory appeal preferred against the order passed by the
National Consumer Commission. It was not rendered in a Special Leave
Petition under Article 136 of the Constitution of India. Therefore, the
decision of the National Consumer Commission merged into the
decision of the Supreme Court. Consequently, the decision of the
Supreme Court, in the case of Sandeep Grover And Anr (Supra) which
takes a different view than the one that has been followed in the
judgments of this Court commencing from Vaidehi Akash Housing Pvt
Ltd (Supra) impliedly overrules the said line of decisions.
8.
Mr. Bharucha would urge that, if the view of the Appellate
Tribunal is accepted, then it would imply that the judgment of the
Supreme Court is not binding on the Appellate Tribunal. Therefore, a
ARS
39/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
substantial question of law as to whether the decision of the Supreme
Court in the case of Sandeep Grover and Anr (Supra) overrules the
earlier line of decisions and consequently protects the rights of the third
party allottees of the erstwhile developer arises for consideration. To
lend support to these submissions, Mr. Bharucha placed reliance on the
decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Kunhayammed And Ors Vs
3
State of Kerala and Anr and another decision in the case of Pernod
Ricard India Private Limited Vs Commissioner of Customs, ICD
4
Tughlakabad.
9.
Mr. Bharucha further submitted that the impugned judgment and
order suffers from another patent error. The Appellate Tribunal has not
at all delved into the reasons ascribed by the Authority to direct the
parties to maintain status-quo and keep the project in abeyance. As the
Authority had not delved into the merits of the matter, the Appellate
Tribunal, if it was not inclined to affirm the view of the Authority, that
the project was required to be kept in abeyance till the final decisions of
the arbitral proceedings and proceedings before the Courts/Forums, it
ought not to have decided the matter on merits. To buttress this
submission, Mr. Bharucha placed reliance on a judgment of the
3
(2000) 6 SCC 359.

4
(2010) 8 SCC 313.
ARS
40/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
Supreme Court in the case of Surendra G Shankar and Anr Vs Esque
5
Finamark Pvt Ltd & Ors.
10.
In opposition to this, Mr. Mohanish Chaudhari, the learned
Counsel for respondent Nos. 1 and 2, would submit that the Appellate
Tribunal has justifiably exercised the jurisdiction to correct the manifest
error committed by the Authority. In fact, the complainants and/or the
purported allottees of the units in the sale component of the project of
the erstwhile developer have instituted multiple proceedings before the
Courts and Authorities seeking identical reliefs. Having been
unsuccessful in those proceedings, the complainants approached the
Authority belatedly, with the self-same assertions. In fact in Writ Petition
(L) No. 1776 of 2023, the Division Bench, had expressly dealt with the
question whether the third party flat purchasers from the erstwhile
developer could claim substantive rights as against the society and after
an elaborate analysis dismissed the petition. The said order was not
challenged by the petitioners/appellants and has thus attained finality.
It was, therefore, not open to the petitioners to agitate again the very
same point before different forums. Yet, the purported allottees
continued to file proceedings.
11.
Even otherwise, Mr. Chaudhari would urge, the order passed by
the Authority was riddled with contradictory and inconsistent findings.
The Authority had directed that the project be kept in abeyance and the

5
2025 SCC OnLine SC 134.
ARS
41/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
status-quo be maintained despite having noticed that on account of the
default on the part of the erstwhile developer, the members of the
society were made to suffer incalculable hardship and prejudice, and
that the erstwhile developer had not succeed in any of the proceedings.
12.
Mr. Chaudhari submitted that, reliance on the order passed by the
Supreme Court in the case of Sandeep Grover and Anr (Supra) is of no
assistance to the appellants as the decision in the said case was confined
to the facts therein and cannot be said to operate as a precedent. A very
strong reliance was placed by Mr. Chaudhari on a three Judge Bench
judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Experion Developers
6
Private Limited Vs Himanshu Dewan and Ors.
13.
I have given anxious consideration to the submissions canvassed
across the bar.
14.
The background facts in the context of the jural relationship
between the society and the erstwhile developer, on the one part, and
the erstwhile developer and the complainants on the other part, are not
much in dispute. As noted above, the erstwhile developer was
appointed as a developer to redevelop the society premises, pursuant to
th
the development agreement dated 25 October 2007. It is indubitable
that the redevelopment did not take place in the manner and within the
time-frame, intended by the society and the erstwhile developer. The
th
society thus professed to terminate the development agreement on 8

6
2023 SCC OnLine SC 1029.
ARS
42/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
August 2019. In the wake of the dispute, the society invoked the
jurisdiction of this Court in Arbitration Petition No. 1474 of 2019, and
th
by an order dated 4 December 2019, this Court restrained the
erstwhile developer from obstructing the process of appointing a new
developer or undertaking the self-development process for completion
of the redevelopment project and also granted allied interim reliefs in
th
favour of the society. By a subsequent order dated 20 February 2020,
the said petition under Section 9 of the Act, 1996, was made absolute.
th
15.
Secondly, by a common order dated 26 June 2023, the learned
sole arbitrator by invoking the power under Section 17 of the Act, 1996,
directed the erstwhile developer to remove all his articles, things and
machinery lying on the society premises. An appeal preferred against
the said order, being Commercial Arbitration Petition (L) No. 20764 of
2023, was dismissed by a learned Single Judge of this Court by a
rd
judgment and order dated 23 October 2023.
16.
Thus the situation which now obtains as between the society and
th
the erstwhile developer is that, the development agreement dated 25
October 2007 stands terminated, the erstwhile developer has been
removed from the society premises, and a new developer has been
appointed to execute the redevelopment project, though the legality and
validity of the said termination is yet to be decided by the Arbitral
Tribunal. In contrast, the complainants claim that they had entered into
ARS
43/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
agreements to purchase the respective units in the sale component
portion which was to be developed by the erstwhile developer in the
said project. They have parted with valuable consideration. They being
the allottees, their rights cannot be trampled upon by terminating the
development agreement between the society and the erstwhile
developer. The complainants thus seek to enforce their purported rights
as the allottees of the erstwhile developer qua the society.
17.
The aforesaid scenario gives rise to a familiar question as to
whether the third party purchasers of the erstwhile developer can
enforce their rights against the society and its assets, where the society
professes to terminate the development agreement with the erstwhile
developer.
18.
In fact, the complainants did not expressly raise the aforesaid
question in Writ Petition (L) No. 1776 of 2023 (Deepak Prabhakar
Thakoor & Ors Vs Maharashtra Housing And Area Development
7
Authority (MHADA) & Ors ). Though the reliefs sought in the said
petition were couched in a different language, yet, the Division
Bench appreciated what was at the heart of the controversy and
considered the question whether the third party flat purchasers
from the erstwhile developer could claim substantive rights as
against the society.
th

7
Original Side Writ Petition (L) No. 1776 of 2023, decided on 12
October 2023.
ARS
44/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
19.
While exploring an answer to the aforesaid question, the
Division Bench, observed that the aforesaid question and the
subsidiary issues sought to be agitated on behalf of the petitioners
were no longer res integra. Those questions were answered by the
decisions of a learned Single Judge in the cases of Vaidehi Akash
Housing Pvt Ltd (Supra) and Goregaon Pearl CHSL Vs Dr Seema
8
Mahadev Paryekar and Ors. After extracting the observations in
Vaidehi Akash
paragraphs 80 to 93 of the decision in the case of
Housing Pvt Ltd (Supra), the Division Bench observed that it was in
respectful agreement with all the findings of law and it emphatically
reaffirmed Vaidehi Akash Housing Pvt Ltd (Supra).
20.
It is imperative to note that the Division Bench also gave its
imprimatur to the judgment in the case of Goregaon Pearl CHSL
(Supra) wherein a submission was sought to be canvassed on the basis
of the provisions contained in RERA 2016, to question the correctness of
the view in Vaidehi Akash Housing Pvt Ltd (Supra). The observations of
the Division Bench in paragraphs 11 and 12 are material and hence
extracted below:
“11. We are in respectful agreement with all these findings
on law. We emphatically reaffirm Vaidehi Akash.
12. The second decision also by Gupte J is of 14th October
2019 in Goregaon Pearl CHSL (Supra). This dealt inter alia not

8
2019 SCC OnLine Bom 3274.
ARS
45/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
only with the issue of third-party flat purchasers but
specifically from paragraph 7 onwards the question of whether
RERA gave them additional or superior rights. Goregaon Pearl
referenced the previous decision in Vaidehi Akash expressly.
The distinguishing feature of that case was set out in
paragraph 8. Ultimately, the learned Single Judge held on a
careful consideration of these provisions that the provisions of
RERA do not make any difference. RERA was introduced to set
up a regulatory authority for the real estate sector and to
ensure efficiency and transparency and consumer protection in
that sector. It defines promoter in a manner similar to that in
the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act, 1969 (“MOFA”). Even
Section 18 of RERA, on which considerable emphasis was laid
in Goregaon Pearl, requires promoters to discharge obligations
and provides remedies for purchasers without prejudice to
other rights if there is a default by the promoter. Section 19
entitles the allottee to obtain possession. Purchasers’
grievances are redressed by the authority. None of these
provisions, Gupte J held, make the owner of the freehold or
leasehold interest in the land (the party who enters into a
development agreement with a developer) liable for
compliance with and fulfillment of the developer’s
obligations.”
(emphasis supplied)
21.
The aforesaid legal position has been reiterated by another
Division Bench of this Court in the case of Kapilkunj Cooperative
9
Housing Society Ltd Vs State of Maharashtra & Ors. The
th

9
Original Side Writ Petition No. 2157 of 2021, decided on 13
December 2023.
ARS
46/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
observations in paragraphs 23, 41 and 42, which have been
extracted by the Appellate Tribunal also, read as under:
“23. The Society will have to now take an informed decision in
regard to its redevelopment agreement and about the completion
of the construction at the Society’s cost. We understand that
there are third party sale agreements that may have been entered
into by Ved. These will not be allowed to compromise the rights
of the members. In any case, even as against the rights of the
Society, the claims of third party purchasers and their rights are
issues that have been decided by this Court in Vaidehi Aakash
Housing Pvt Ltd (Supra) and Goregaon Pearl CHSL (Supra) and
both of which our Division Bench in Deepak Prabhakar Thakoor
& Ors (Supra) has reaffirmed. Third party purchasers will have
no rights over the assets of the Society. If, therefore, the balance
development is done by the Society following a termination of its
redevelopment agreement, then any additional Floor Space Index
(“FSI”) or buildable area benefits will be to the benefit of the
Society and may be used to defray costs.
… … …
41. Some of the Respondents to the Petition are third party
flat purchasers. Once again, as we have set out above, their
rights as against Ved are preserved intact in law by series of
judgments including our own reaffirmation as a Division Bench
of two decisions of the Single Judge in Vaidehi Aakash Housing
Pvt Ltd (Supra) and Goregaon Pearl (Supra) . This necessarily
means that after termination of the agreement, third party flat
purchasers can have no rights, claims or equities in respect of
assets of the Society. This means not only the original structure
but the entire redevelopment project including all additional FSI
and all free-sale components. It is always open to those flat
ARS
47/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
purchasers to negotiate with the Society. It is, however, clear that
amounts paid to Ved cannot possibly be given credit to by the
Society. This Court has already repeatedly held that in such a
situation, in law, there is absolutely no privity of contract
between third party flat purchasers and the Society or its
members. We declined to revisit that aspect of the law or to
permit fresh arguments re-agitating the same issue. That law is
no longer res integra.
42. It is impossible for any authority or tribunal, such as
Maharashtra Real Estate Regulatory Authority (“MahaRERA”), to
take a different view in law. The law declared by this court will
control every single tribunal in the State of Maharashtra
including MahaRERA.”
(emphasis supplied)
22.
The position in law which thus seems to have crystallised is that,
in case the society terminates the development agreement entered into
with an erstwhile developer and either enters into a development
agreement with a new developer or proceeds to self-develop the society
premises, the third party purchasers cannot enforce their rights against
the society or its assets as the third party purchasers have no right,
claim or equities in respect of the assets of the society, inclusive of the
additional FSI and free sale components. Such third party purchasers
are required to workout their remedies against the erstwhile developer.
The absence of privity of contract between the third party purchasers
ARS
48/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
and the society is the rationale for not upholding the claim of such third
party purchasers, to enforce their rights against the society.
23.
If the facts of the case are appraised in the light of the aforesaid
well-settled position in law, the submissions of Mr. Chaudhari that the
complainants who were the petitioners in Writ Petition (L) No. 1776 of
2023, cannot be permitted to agitate the same question in the
proceedings before the authorities under RERA, at least qua the society,
cannot be said to be unfounded. The Division Bench considered the
precise question of the entitlement of the petitioner therein - the
purported allottees, to enforce their rights qua the society premises and
expressly negatived the same.
24.
The learned Counsel for the appellants joined the issue by
canvassing the submission that the aforesaid position in law cannot be
said to be no longer res integra in view of the decision of the Supreme
Court in the case of Sandeep Grover and Anr (Supra). It was urged that
the facts in the said case have a striking resemblance to the facts of the
case at hand. In that case as well, the society had terminated the
development agreement with the developer with whom the allottees
therein had entered into the agreements to purchase the flat. As the
society had contested the claim of the third party flat purchasers, they
had approached the NCDRC. The NCDRC, after considering the
submissions on behalf of the parties, including the contention of the
ARS
49/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
society that there was no privity of contract between the society and flat
purchasers, was persuaded to allow the complaint and direct the society
to refund the entire amount deposited by the complainants with
interest. The NCDRC was of the view that after deriving the benefits
under the development agreement, the society could not be permitted
to usurp the flat falling to the share of the developer. Since the society
had taken possession of the flats (allotted by the erstwhile developer to
complainants) and had allotted those flats to its members, the society
was liable to return the entire amount deposited by the complainants.
25.
In the appeals before the Supreme Court, i.e. Civil Appeal No.
5188 of 2023 with Civil Appeal No. 5288 of 2023 and Civil Appeal No.
rd
5186 of 2023, decided on 3 October 2023, the Supreme Court passed
the following order:
“ ORDER
1. On the last date of hearing, Mr. Amit Sibal, learned
Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant had addressed
lengthy arguments in the matters, but we were not persuaded
by the submission made.
2. At that stage, a request was made to this Court that the
appellant be permitted to negotiate a settlement with the
respondents-flat buyers and the developer. At the request, the
matters were adjourned.
3. Today, Mr. Sibal, the learned Senior Counsel, states
that a settlement could not be worked out with the
respondents-flat buyers.
ARS
50/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
4. If that is the position, then the appeals having already
been heard on merits on the last date of hearing, need no
further consideration and the same are dismissed.
5. Pending applications are disposed of.”
26.
It was the thrust of the submission on behalf of the appellants
that the aforesaid decision of the Supreme Court which affirms the
decision of the NCDRC which has in turn completely deviated from the
line of the decisions representing Vaidehi Aakash Housing Pvt Ltd (Supra)
binds all the Courts and Tribunals and, therefore, the Appellate Tribunal
was not at all justified in allowing the appeals by banking upon Vaidehi
Aakash Housing Pvt Ltd (Supra) line of judgments.
27.
At this juncture the implications of the doctrine of merger
become relevant. In the system of hierarchy of Courts, the orders passed
by the Courts/Tribunals of the first instance are subject to appeal or
revision before the superior Courts/Tribunals. Thus where a decree or
order passed by a Court or Tribunal of first instance is carried in appeal
or revision before the superior Courts/Tribunals, the validity of the
decree or order passed by the former is, in a sense, put in jeopardy and
if the superior Court affirms, sets aside or modifies the decree or order
passed by the first Court/Tribunal, then it is the decree or order of the
superior Court/Tribunal that becomes operative and in the said decree
or order, the decree or order passed by the Court or Tribunal of first
instance (which is affirmed, set aside or modified) merges. The
ARS
51/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
rationale for the application of the doctrine of merger is that there
cannot be more than one decree or operative order governing the same
subject matter at a given point of time.
28.
At the same time, it must be noted that, the doctrine of merger is
held not to be of universal or unlimited application. The factors like the
nature of the jurisdiction exercised by the superior forum, and the scope
and content of the challenge to the decree or order of the Court of first
instance., bear upon the applicability of the doctrine of merger. Whether
the superior forum exercises full appellate jurisdiction or discretionary
jurisdiction, the extent of scrutiny of the decree or order challenged by
the superior forum, and the necessity to record adequate reasons are
also the matters which may bear upon the applicability of doctrine of
merger.
29.
In the case of Kunhayammed And Ors (Supra), a three Judge
Bench of the Supreme Court culled out the propositions in regard to the
application of the doctrine of merger, with special reference to the
provisions contained in Article 136 of the Constitution of India. They
read as under:
44. To sum up our conclusions are :-
(i) Where an appeal or revision is provided against an order
passed by a court, tribunal or any other authority before
superior forum and such superior forum modifies, reverses or
affirms the decision put in issue before it, the decision by the
subordinate forum merges in the decision by the superior
ARS
52/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
forum and it is the latter which subsists, remains operative and
is capable of enforcement in the eye of law.
ii) The jurisdiction conferred by Article 136 of the Constitution
is divisible into two stages. First stage is upto the disposal of
prayer for special leave to file an appeal. The second stage
commences if and when the leave to appeal is granted and
special leave petition is converted into an appeal.
(iii) Doctrine of merger is not a doctrine of universal or
unlimite application. It will depend on the nature of
jurisdiction exercised by the superior forum and the content or
subject-matter of challenge laid or capable of being laid shall
be determinative of the applicability of merger. The superior
jurisdiction should be capable of reversing, modifying or
affirming the order put in issue before it. Under Article 136 of
the Constitution the Supreme Court may reverse, modify or
affirm the judgment-decree or order appealed against while
exercising its appellate jurisdiction and not while exercising
the discretionary jurisdiction disposing of petition for special
leave to appeal. The doctrine of merger can therefore be
applied to the former and not to the latter.
iv) An order refusing special leave to appeal may be a non-
speaking order or a speaking one. In either case it does not
attract the doctrine of merger. An order refusing special leave
to appeal does not stand substituted in place of the order
under challenge. All that it means is that the Court was not
inclined to exercise its discretion so as to allow the appeal
being filed.
v) If the order refusing leave to appeal is a speaking order, i.e.
gives reasons for refusing the grant of leave, then the order
has two implications. Firstly, the statement of law contained in
the order is a declaration of law by the Supreme Court within
the meaning of Article 141 of the Constitution. Secondly, other
ARS
53/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
than the declaration of law, whatever is stated in the order are
the findings recorded by the Supreme Court which would bind
the parties thereto and also the court, tribunal or authority in
any proceedings subsequent thereto by way of judicial
discipline, the Supreme Court being the apex court of the
country. But, this does not amount to saying that the order of
the court, tribunal or authority below has stood merged in the
order of the Supreme Court rejecting special leave petition or
that the order of the Supreme Court is the only order binding
as res judicata in subsequent proceedings between the parties.
(vi) Once leave to appeal has been granted and appellate
jurisdiction of Supreme Court has been invoked the order
passed in appeal would attract the doctrine of merger; the
order may be of reversal, modification or merely affirmation.
(vii) On an appeal having been preferred or a petition seeking
leave to appeal having been converted into an appeal before
Supreme Court the jurisdiction of High Court to entertain a
review petition is lost thereafter as provided by sub-rule (1) of
Rule (1) of Order 47 of the C.P.C.”
30.
In the case of Khoday Distilleries Limited (Now Known As
Khoday India Limited) And Ors Vs Sri Mahadeshwara Sahakara Sakkare
Karkhane Limited, Kollegal (Under Liquidation) represented by the
10
Liquidator , a three Judge Bench of the Supreme Court summarised the
legal position on merger and the relevant paragraphs read as under:
“20. The Court thereafter analysed number of cases where orders
of different nature were passed and dealt with these judgments by
classifying them in the following categories:
(i) Dismissal at the stage of special leave petition — without
reasons — no res judicata, no merger.

10
(2019) 4 SCC 376.
ARS
54/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
(ii) Dismissal of the special leave petition by speaking or
reasoned order — no merger, but rule of discipline and Article 141
attracted.
(iii) Leave granted —dismissal without reasons —merger results.
… … …
26. From a cumulative reading of the various judgments, we
sum up the legal position as under:
… … ...
26.3 Once we hold that law laid down in Kunhayammed And Ors
(Supra) is to be followed, it will not make any difference whether
the review petition was filed before the filing of special leave
petition or was filed after the dismissal of special leave petition.
Such a situation is covered in para 37 of Kunhayammed And Ors
(Supra) case.”
31.
In the case of Pernod Ricard India Private Limited (Supra), on
which reliance was placed by Mr. Bharucha, the Supreme Court,
expounded the distinction between the application of the doctrine of
merger to the petitions decided by the Supreme Court under Article 136
of the Constitution of India and the statutory appeal. The Supreme
Court enunciated that once the statutory right of appeal is invoked,
dismissal of such appeal by the Supreme Court, whether by speaking
order or non-speaking order, the doctrine of merger does apply unlike in
the case of dismissal of special leave to appeal under Article 136 of the
Constitution of India by a non-speaking order.
32.
The observations of the Supreme Court in paragraphs 30 and 31
are material and hence extracted below.
ARS
55/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
“30. In the present case, the appellant preferred statutory
appeal under Section 130-E of the Act against order of the
Tribunal dated 25th March 2003 and, therefore, the dismissal of
appeal by this Court though by a non-speaking order, was in
exercise of appellate jurisdiction, wherein the merits of the
order impugned were subjected to judiciary scrutiny. In our
opinion, in the instant case, the doctrine of merger would be
attracted and the appellant is estopped from raising the issue of
applicability of Rule 6 in their case.
31. In the view we have taken, we are fortified by a decision
of this Court in V.M. Salgaocar & Bros (P) Ltd Vs Commissioner
of Income Tax ((2000) 5 SCC 373), wherein the Court was
called upon to consider the effect of dismissal of an appeal
under Section 261 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 by a non
speaking order. Speaking for the Bench, D.P. Wadhwa, J. while
drawing distinction between an order dismissing in limine a
special leave petition under Article 136 of the Constitution and
an appeal under Article 133, and drawing support from the
decision of this Court in Supreme Court Employees’ Welfare
Assn Vs Union of India ((1989) 4 SCC 187) held that former
case does not but the latter does attract the doctrine of merger.
The Court observed thus:-
"8. Different considerations apply when a special
leave petition under Article 136 of the Constitution is
simply dismissed by saying 'dismissed' and an appeal
provided under Article 133 is dismissed also with the
words 'the appeal is dismissed'. In the former case it
has been laid by this Court that when a special leave
petition is dismissed this Court does not comment on
the correctness or otherwise of the order from which
leave to appeal is sought. But what the court means is
that it does not consider it to be a fit case for exercise
ARS
56/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
of its jurisdiction under Article 136 of the
Constitution. That certainly could not be so when
appeal is dismissed though by a non-speaking order.
Here the doctrine of merger applies. In that case, the
Supreme Court upholds the decision of the High
Court or of the Tribunal from which the appeal is
provided under clause (3) of Article 133. This
doctrine of merger does not apply in the case of
dismissal of special leave petition under Article 136.
When an appeal is dismissed the order of the High
Court is merged with that of the Supreme Court."
33.
In the case of Experion Developers Private Limited (Supra) a
three Judge Bench of the Supreme Court considered the question from
the perspective of binding efficacy of the judgment delivered by the
Supreme Court in a statutory appeal as law declared by the Supreme
Court under Article 141 of the Constitution of India.
34.
In that case also, the Supreme Court had exercised the statutory
appellate jurisdiction against the order passed by the NCDRC in the case
11
of Pawan Gupta Vs Experion Developers Private Limited, and in that
backdrop the question whether the order passed by the Supreme Court
in the latter decision amounted to a precedent under Article 141 of the
Constitution of India, as the doctrine of merger was clearly attracted,
arose for consideration.

11
2020 SCC OnLine NCDRC 788.
ARS
57/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
35.
While recognizing that in the case of Pawan Gupta (Supra), it
had exercised statutory appellate jurisdiction in contradistinction to the
jurisdiction conferred in Article 136 of the Constitution of India and,
thus in terms of the decision in the case of Kunhayammed And Ors
(Supra) , the final order passed by the Supreme Court became
executable and the principle of merger applied, the Supreme Court
enunciated that the dismissal of the appeal in the case Pawan Gupta
(Supra) without any reasons being recorded would not attract Article
141 of the Constitution as no law was declared by the Supreme Court
which would have a binding force on the Courts and Tribunals. Further
the Supreme Court emphasised the distinction between the binding law
of precedent in terms of Article 141 of the Constitution and the doctrine
of merger and res judicata. The observations in paragraphs 31, 32, 36
and 37 are instructive and hence extracted below.
“31. No doubt, in Pawan Gupta’s case (supra), this Court had
not exercised the power or jurisdiction conferred by Article 136 of
the Constitution of India, but had exercised its appellate power,
which would, in terms of the ratio in Kunhayammed And Ors
(Supra), becomes the final order which is executable. Thus, the
dismissal of the appeal by this Court in the case of Pawan Gupta
(Supra), had put a finality and an end to the litigation in the said
case. To this extent, therefore, the application of the general
principle of res judicata would bar the party from raising the plea
once again. The order passed by this Court, on the application of
the principle of judicial discipline, bars and prevents any tribunal
or parties from canvassing or taking a view which would have the
ARS
58/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
effect of re- examination of the issues and points determined in the
case of Pawan Gupta (supra) inter-se the parties to the decision.
However, dismissal of the appeal would not operate as res judicata
in the case of the respondents against the appellant as they were
not parties to the said case, and the proceedings initiated by Pawan
Gupta were fact specific and not in a representative capacity.
32. The dismissal of the appeal in the case of Pawan Gupta
(supra) without any reasons being recorded would not attract
Article 141 of the Constitution of India as no law was declared by
the Supreme Court, which will have a binding effect on all courts
and tribunals in India. There is a clear distinction between the
binding law of precedents in terms of Article 141 of the
Constitution of India and the doctrine of merger and res judicata .
To merge, as held in Kunhayammed And Ors (Supra), and Khoday
Distilleries Ltd (supra) means to sink or disappear in something
else, to become absorbed or extinguished. The logic behind the
doctrine of merger is that there cannot be more than one decree or
operative orders governing the same subject matter at a given
point of time. When a decree or order passed by an inferior court,
tribunal or authority is subjected to a remedy available under law
before a superior forum, then the decree or order under challenge
continues to be effective and binding; nevertheless, its finality is
put in jeopardy. Once the superior court disposes the dispute
before it in any manner, either by affirming the decree or order, by
setting aside or modifying the same, it is the decree of the superior
court, tribunal or authority, which is the final binding and
operative decree. The decree and order of the inferior court,
tribunal or authority gets merged into the order passed by the
superior forum. However, as has been clarified in both decisions,
this doctrine is not of universal or unlimited application. The
nature of jurisdiction exercised by the superior court and the
ARS
59/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
content or subject matter of challenge laid or could have been laid
will have to be kept in view.
… … …
36. In the context of factual background of the present case,
and on examining the judgment in the case of Pawan Gupta
(Supra) passed by the National Commission, we are clearly of the
view that the order passed by this Court dismissing the appeal in
the case of Pawan Gupta (Supra) would operate as res judicata in
the said case but does not lay down a binding precedent which
would be applicable to other cases. As it transpires from the
judgment in the case of Pawan Gupta (Supra), the National
Commission itself had specifically observed inter alia that “there
was no harm in communicating and charging for the extra area at
the final stage, but for the sake of transparency opposite party
must share the actual reason for the increase in the super area
based on comparison of the originally approved buildings and
finally approved buildings. Basically, the idea is that the allottee
must know the change in the finally approved layout and areas of
common spaces and the originally approved layout and areas”. It is
true that there was no material on record placed by the appellant
in the said case of Pawan Gupta (Supra) showing the actual
increase in the sale area. Nonetheless, the appellant in the instant
case, along with its detailed reply, had produced the documents,
i.e. the certificate dated 23.09.2020 given by the Architects D-idea,
the Report dated 23.09.2020 given by Knight Frank (India) Private
Limited, the affidavit dated 31.08.2021 by Mr. Muninder Pal Singh,
and the affidavit dated 26.04.2022 by Mr. Anurag Mahajan, to
show that there was an actual increase in the sale area, justifying
its demand for the extra payment. The respondents, in rejoinder,
had neither placed any material to contradict the said Architect’s
certificates and reports nor had they disputed the contents thereof.
The only contention raised by them was that the said documents
ARS
60/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
were produced as an afterthought and, therefore, could not be
taken into consideration. At this juncture, it is also pertinent to
note that clause 8.6 of the agreement, provided for an
increase/decrease in the sale area as defined and also the
corresponding sale price increase of upto 10%. The appellant, by
producing the said documents, had sought to justify that the
variance, i.e. increase in the built up area of the project, which was
less than 5% and such variance was within the permissible limits.”
37. Thus, we are clearly of the view that the order of this Court
dismissing the appeal in the case of Pawan Gupta (supra) cannot
be read as a precedent and applied to the cases in hand. In fact,
precedents cannot decide questions of fact. The decision in the
case of Pawan Gupta (supra) was based on evidence adduced by
the appellant/builder/developer, which in the said case was not
found to be sufficient and cogent to justify and substantiate the
demand raised in view of the increased sale area. No doubt, the
architect’s certificate and report dated 23.09.2020 was filed before
this Court as additional documents, but a non-reasoned order
passed by this Court dismissing the case cannot be read as
accepting and considering the additional evidence, or as rejecting
justification and reasons given therein for claiming
additional/increased sale area. Any additional evidence sought to
be produced at the appellate stage can only be introduced when an
appropriate application under Rule 27 to Order XLI of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 is moved and an order is passed taking them
on record. Therefore, the order passed by this Court dismissing the
appeal in the case of Pawan Gupta (supra) is confined to the facts
of the said case, including the evidence led by the parties before
the National Commission. The National Commission was therefore
required to consider and examine the contentions of the appellant
and not overrule the same on the grounds of the principle of res
ARS
61/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
judicata and on the rule of binding precedent, which do not apply.
An order of remand on the question of merits as to the stipulation
and increase in the sale area is therefore required.”

36.
The aforesaid enunciation of law makes it explicitly clear that
where the order dismissing the appeal is confined to the facts of the
case and the evidence adduced therein without any principle of law
having been enunciated, such order does not command the precedential
value and though it would bind the parties to the said proceeding as res
judicata, it would not lay down a binding precedent which would be
applicable to other cases. On the contrary, if the Supreme Court passes a
reasoned order from which the ratio decidendi is discernible, then,
howsoever brief the reasons may be, the law declared by the Supreme
Court would command observance as a precedent.
37.
On the aforesaid touchstone, reverting to the facts of the case at
hand, the two factors assume importance. First, the decision in the case
of Sandeep Grover And Anr (Supra) turned on its peculiar facts.
The NCDRC found that the society had taken benefit under the
development agreement in as much as the society had taken possession
of the flats falling to the share of the developer and allotted to
complainants therein, and had thereafter allotted those flats to its
ARS
62/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
members. In that context, the NCDRC ordered that the society was
liable to return the entire money deposited by the complainants therein.
38.
The facts of the case at hand are materially distinct. No
substantial development could be carried out by the erstwhile developer
although a period of more than 12 years had elapsed. The members of
the society had vacated their original flats a decade ago. The erstwhile
developer committed default in payment of transit rent. A partially
constructed building was left abandoned. Therefore, the decision in the
case of Sandeep Grover And Anr (Supra) cannot be imported to the
facts of the case at hand ,with equal force.
39.
Second the order passed by the Supreme Court (extracted above),
in the respectful understanding of this Court, does not record any
reasons. The fourth paragraph of the order simply records that as the
appeals had been heard on merits on the previous date and needed no
further consideration, the appeals were dismissed.
40.
In the aforesaid view of the matter, the decision in the case of
Experion Developers Private Limited (Supra), rendered by a three Judge
Bench of the Supreme Court, seems to govern the fact-situation in the
case at hand. The final order passed by the Supreme Court in the
statutory appeal against the order passed by NCDRC, in the case of
Sandeep Grover And Anr (Supra) may bind the parties thereto as res
judicata or it could be urged that the order of the NCDRC merged with
ARS
63/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
the final order passed by the Supreme Court, yet, the said order dated
rd
3 October 2023 passed by the Supreme Court, in Sandeep Grover And
Anr (Supra) cannot be construed as laying down a law which overrules
the line of decisions rendered by this Court which holds that, sans
privity of contract, the third parties are not entitled to enforce their
rights against the society, where the society terminates the development
agreement with the erstwhile developer, with whom the third party
purchasers, had entered into contract to purchase the units in the
project in question.
41.
The submission of Mr. Bharucha that this line of reasoning, which
is adopted by the Appellate Tribunal, amounts to holding that the
Appellate Tribunal is not bound by the decision of the Supreme Court,
does not merit acceptance as in the first place, no law can be said to
have been declared by the Supreme Court in the case of Sandeep
Grover And Anr (Supra). The decision therein turned on its peculiar
facts and the Supreme Court, in the backdrop of those peculiar facts
and the material which was fact specific, declined to interfere with the
order passed by the NCDRC without recording any reasons.
42.
The upshot of aforesaid consideration is that, in the backdrop of
the rather incontrovertible facts which indicate that the members of the
society have been left in the lurch for almost 15 years, the direction by
the Authority to keep the project in abeyance and maintain status-quo
ARS
64/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44

-SA-302-2026+.DOC
till the final determination of the proceedings before the Arbitral
Tribunal and the Courts/Forums would add insult to the injury, as their
aspirations to have units upon redevelopment of the society premises
would hinge upon the vicissitudes of fortunes in litigation. Since the
appellants can workout their remedies against the erstwhile developer,
the Appellate Tribunal was fully justified in interfering with the wholly
unsustainable order passed by the Authority.
43.
The second limb of the submission of Mr. Bharucha that the
Appellate Tribunal has not dealt with the reasons recorded by the
Authority for keeping the project in abeyance and directing the parties
to maintain status-quo need not detain the Court as the very foundation
of the order passed by the Authority was legally unsustainable.
44.
The upshot of the aforesaid consideration is that, no question of
law, much less a substantial question of law, arises for consideration.
45.
Hence, the following order:
: O R D E R :
(i) Second Appeals stand dismissed.
(ii) In view of the dismissal of the Second Appeals, Interim
Application/s, if any, stand/s disposed.
No costs.
[N. J. JAMADAR, J.]
ARS
65/65
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 18:42:44
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)