Ponna Venkatamma, vs Sri Kishen Singh S.I. of Police,
- Court
- High Court for the State of Telangana
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
WRIT PETITION NO.4377 OF 2002
(CNR NO. HBHC010770982002)
Between:
Ponna Venkatamma
…. Petitioner
and
Sri Kishen Singh, S.I.of Police,
Chegunta Police Station and two others.
…. Respondents
DATE OF JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED : 13.11.2026
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
1. Whether Reporters of Local Newspapers: No
may be allowed to see the Judgments ?
2. Whether the copies of judgment may be : Yes
marked to Law Reporters/Journals
3. Whether His Lordship wish to : Yes
see the fair copy of the Judgment ?
__________________________________
SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO, J
2
* HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
+ WRIT PETITION NO.4377 OF 2002
(CNR NO. HBHC010770982002)
% 13.11.2026
Between:
# Ponna Venkatamma
…. Petiti
and
$ Sri Kishen Singh, S.I.of Police,
Chegunta Police Station and two others.
…. Respondents
!Counsel for the Petitioner : Ms. Vasudha Nagaraj
Counsel for the Respondents : Mr. Mahesh Raja, learned
Government Pleader for Home
appearing for the respondents
<Gist :
>Head Note:
? Cases referred:
(2017) 8 SCC 417
(2014) 10 SCC 635
(1993) 2 SCC 746
3
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WRIT PETITION NO.4377 OF 2002
(CNR NO. HBHC010770982002)
DATE: 13.11.2026
Reserved on: 29.07.2026 Pronounced on : 13 .11.2026
Uploaded on : 16 .11.2026
Between:
Ponna Venkatamma
…. Petitioner
and
Sri Kishen Singh, S.I.of Police,
Chegunta Police Station and two others.
…. Respondents
ORDER:
Heard Ms. Vasudha Nagaraj, learned counsel for the petitioner,
and Mr. Mahesh Raja, the learned Government Pleader for Home
appearing for the respondents.
2. This writ petition has been filed seeking to grant the following
relief:
“ …to issue an order direction or writ in the nature of writ of
mandamus declaring that the action of the nature of writ of
st
mandamus declaring that the action of the 1 respondent in killing
the petitioner’s husband on 11.12.2001 in cold blood in the guise of
an ‘encounter’ at Chetla Thimmayapalli, Chegunta Mandal, Medak
District, and the action of the respondent Nos.2 and 3 in not
st
investigating the matter and prosecuting the 1 respondent is
unlawful and unconstitutional and further direct the respondent
Nos.2 and 3 to, (i) forthwith register an offence of culpable
4
st
homicide amounting to murder against the 1 respondent for the
said killing and have the matter investigated fairly and impartially;
and (ii) pay compensation of Rs.2 lakhs to the petitioner and her
children and pass … “
3. The relevant facts, shorn of unnecessary details, are that the
petitioner along with her husband Mr. B.Balanarsaiah, who stated to
be small farmer, are residents of Chetla Thimmayapalli village,
Chegunta Mandal, Medak District. The petitioner contends that a
squad of People’s War Group, who are the extremists, came to their
village on 20.10.2001 and some of the villagers met the said squad
and it is not uncommon in the said area for armed Naxalite squads to
visit villages and summon the many villagers, who do not have any
option, but to obey and go to meet them. It is stated that, on the said
day, when the naxalites were in the village, the then Sub-Inspector of
Police, Chegunta P.S., along with some other Police Constables came
to the village and there was accidental confrontation between the
naxalites and the Police personnel that lead to a melee and the
villagers, who were caught in the midst of the confrontation, ran
helter-skelter. The naxalites kidnapped the then S.I.of Police Mr.
Raghu from Chetla Thimmayapalli village and fortunately on the
next day, the said S.I. of Police Mr. Raghu reached to the station
safely. However, among others, nine villagers who were suspected of
5
having involved in kidnapping the S.I.of Police, the petitioner’s
husband Mr. Balanarsaiah, was also one among them arrayed as
accused of along with certain underground naxalites. Further, it is
stated that seven out of nine surrendered before the Police soon
thereafter, however, the petitioner’s husband Mr. Balanarsaiah could
not surrender at that time, as the petitioner was admitted in a
hospital for delivery of child, and subsequently, with the help of a
local political leader i.e., the Mandal Praja Parishad President Mr.
Teegala Venkata Goud, petitioner’s husband wanted to surrender
before the Police. Further, on 11.12.2001 at about 8.30 a.m., when the
petitioner’s husband went to a toddy shop at the outskirts of village,
st
the 1 respondent accompanied by Armed Policemen came there, on
two wheelers and enquired about Mr. Balanarsaiah and thereafter by
creating a situation of drama, pumped bullets into the petitioner’s
husband, who fell down and succumbed to the bullet injuries.
4. It is further contended, thereafter the police concocted a story
projecting the said Balanarsaiah i.e., husband of the petitioner, as a
member of Indupriyala Local Guerrilla Squad of outlawed People’s
War Group along with naxalites, when accosted by the police on the
fateful day, all of a sudden, they tried to run away by firing at the
6
police, police in turn fired back at the naxalites in self-defence, due to
which, the husband of the petitioner Mr. Balanarsaiah expired. The
petitioner contends that her husband Mr. Balanarsaiah was an
innocent person and that the respondent police authorities caused his
death and projected it as if firing taken place between two groups
and death occurred due to self-defence of police authorities. The
st
petitioner states that instead of registering an FIR against the 1
respondent in respect of the alleged incident, the Police registered
false case, as Crime No.129/2001, dated 11.12.2001 against the
People’s War Group extremists by including the name of petitioner’s
husband, Mr. Blnarsaiah, as one of the accused. The petitioner
contending that the respondent No.1 has caused his death, therefore,
the petitioner sought registration of a crime against the respondent
No.1 and also sought for appropriate compensation from the
respondent-State.
5. The petitioner vehemently contends that, it was a false and
brutal encounter and the respondents neither conducted an
investigation into the matter by following due procedure against the
respondent No.1 and others, nor followed the guidelines issued by
the National Human Rights Commission (HRC), which were in force
7
at the relevant point of time. It is contended that as per the said
guidelines of 1997, the respondents are bound to register an FIR
against the Police personnel and conduct an independent
investigation into the alleged false encounter death of the petitioner’s
husband. It is contended that the respondent-State has taken away
the life of the petitioner’s husband violating right of the petitioner
under Article 21 of the Constitution of India on the ground of self-
defence sought a direction to the respondents to investigate into the
matter and also to pay appropriate compensation to the petitioner,
being the wife of said Mr. Balanarsaiah.
6. The respondent Nos.1, 2 and 3, police authorities, have filed
separate counter-affidavits and contend the petitioner’s husband was
one of the members of outlawed People’s War Group (PWG) of
Indupriyal Dalam, and on reliable information that the members of
the said Group were conducting a meeting near Chetla Thimmaipally
village, the police party proceeded to the said village on 11.12.2001
and found the naxalites near a toddy shop, and on noticing the
arrival of the police party, the naxalites opened fire on the police
party and thereafter the police personnel repeatedly warned the
naxalites to surrender themselves, but in spite of the same, they
8
continued firing at the Police party and as there was no option, the
police party was compelled to retaliate the fire in self-defence.
7. It is further contended that after a short while, the police found
a dead body left behind at the scene, which was subsequently
identified as that of Mr. Balanarsaiah, who is husband of the
petitioner. Therefore, it is contended death is caused purely out of
self-defence, and there is no act of any committing murder of the
petitioner’s husband. It is also stated that the said incident was
investigated by the Sub-Divisional Police Officer, Kamareddy,
Nizamabad District and enquiry was stated to be pending as on that
date. A case in Crime No.129/2001 under Sections 147, 148, 307 r/w
149 IPC and Sections 25(1) & 27 of the Indian Arms Act, and Section
174 of Cr.P.C. has been registered in respect of the said incident. The
respondents specifically denied all the contentions in the affidavit
and as the said death of petitioner’s husband occurred only out of
self-defence, which is not an intentional and, therefore, it cannot be
termed as murder. It is also stated that the District Collector, Medak
District, has already ordered a Magisterial Enquiry in respect of the
above incident and appointed the Revenue Divisional Officer/Sub-
Divisional Magistrate, Medak, as an enquiry officer vide his
9
proceedings No.C1/850/M/2001, dated 12.11.2002 and as on date of
filing of the counter, it is stated that the magisterial enquiry is
pending.
8. Learned counsel Ms. Vasudha Nagaraj appearing for the
petitioner would contend that, even as on the date of incident, i.e.,
11.12.2001, the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) has laid
down certain guidelines prescribing the procedure to be followed in
cases involving deaths arising out of the police encounters with
extremists. It is further contended that, in terms of the said
guidelines, the respondent police authorities have to register a case
for cognizable offences and it should be investigated by an
independent agency, such as, the State CID, and not by officers of the
same Police Station and appropriate compensation should also be
paid if the cases ended in conviction.
9. It is further contended that, despite said NHRC guidelines, the
respondent authorities merely registered a case against the members
of the Indupriyal Dalam of outlawed People’s War Group by
including the name of the petitioner’s husband, without registering a
case against the police personnel allegedly responsible for the death
of petitioner’s husband, particularly the respondent No.1. Therefore,
10
it is contended that the respondent-State has failed to establish,
through an appropriate investigation, the actual circumstances in
which the said Mr. Balanarsaiah died. In the absence of the same, the
respondent-State is liable to pay compensation to the petitioner by
awarding appropriate compensation as precious life of the
petitioner’s husband, guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution
of India, was taken away without the procedure established under
law.
10. Learned counsel would also place reliance upon the judgment
of a Five-Judge Bench of this Court in W.P.No.15419 of 2006, dated
06.02.2009, wherein a Five-Judge Bench while considering the
procedure to be followed in investigating police encounters had laid
down certain guidelines. The learned counsel would contend that
said directions are also not followed by the respondent police
authorities. Learned counsel also places reliance upon the judgment
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Extra Judicial Execution
of Victim Families Association and others v. Union of India and
1
others , wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court considering the death
occurring out of the extremists encounters, has framed certain
1
(2017) 8 SCC 417
11
guidelines and directed the State to scrupulously follow the same.
Learned counsel also places reliance upon the judgment in the case of
People’s Union for Civil Liberties and another v. State of
2
Maharashtra and others , wherein certain guidelines and directions
were issued to the State while dealing with said police encounters.
Learned counsel also placed reliance upon the judgment of the
3
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Nilabati Behera v. State of Orissa ,
wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court considering the facts of the said
case specifically held that the protection of life and personal liberty
cannot be done away except in accordance with law and directed the
respondent State to pay compensation.
11. Learned counsel would contend that though as on the date of
filing of the present writ petition, the Hon’ble larger Bench of this
Court has envisaged certain guidelines, however, this writ petition
was not tagged on with said judgment of a Five-Judge Bench of this
Court, apparently, wherein the said matter was carried to the
Hon’ble Supreme Court and the Hon’ble Supreme Court eventually
held that the guidelines of the larger Bench of this Court have been
affirmed in the case of People’s Union for Civil Liberties (supra).
2
(2014) 10 SCC 635
3
(1993) 2 SCC 746
12
Therefore, the learned counsel would contend that, as the procedure
under law along with guidelines framed by NHRC and judgments of
Hon’ble Supreme Court envisaging certain guidelines are not
followed, as such, it can be inferred that the State has caused the
death of innocent person, and is liable to pay the compensation to the
petitioner.
12. Per contra, Mr. Mahesh Raja, learned Government Pleader for
Home, would contend that in fact, the incident alleged to have taken
place on 11.12.2001 and further investigation was carried upon by the
respondent State by proceedings, dated 12.11.2002. Therefore,
without any incriminating material so as to prove the guilt of the
respondent No.1 and without any conclusive proof to show that the
respondent No.1 has caused the death, fixing the liability on the
respondent-State is not justified. Thus, the question of compensation
does not arise. It is vehemently contended that the petitioner’s
husband Mr. Balanarsaiah, was also one of the members of the
outlawed People’s War Group of Indupriyal Dalam and when the
naxalites opened a fire against the police, as a self-defence the Police
party opened fire and it was only a private self-defence. Therefore,
the question of compensation to the petitioner along with registration
13
of a case against the respondent authorities is unwarranted and the
learned Government Pleader for Home would contend that the
present writ petition is devoid of merits and is liable to be dismissed.
13. Having heard the learned counsel for the petitioner along with
the learned Government Pleader for Home and having given earnest
consideration to their submissions, perused the record.
14. Evidently, on 11.12.2001 in the unfortunate incident,
petitioner’s husband expired. On a perusal of Crime No. 129/2001,
dated 11.12.2001, apparently the said FIR was registered on the name
of PWG Naxalites and Mr. Balanarsiah i.e., husband of the petitioner,
were arrayed as accused. It is significant to note that, as on the date
of the said incident, the National Human Rights Commission had
already issued specific guidelines prescribing the procedure to be
followed in cases involving deaths arising out of police encounters.
As per the said guidelines, the respondent-State has to register
appropriate cases and ensure that such incidents were investigated
by an independent agency, such as, the State Crime Investigation
Department (CID), and not by the officers of the same Police Station.
14
15. For better understanding of the case, the relevant NHRC
guidelines are extracted hereunder:
“ On 29.03.1997 NHRC issued Guidelines recommending the
procedure to be followed by the States and Union Territories with
regard to encounter deaths. It was recommended, inter alia, that:
(i) Deaths should be entered in an appropriate register at the
police station;
(ii) It should be treated as a cognizable offence and investigation
should commence;
(iii) It should be investigated by an independent agency such as the
State CID, and not by officers of the same police station;
(iv) Compensation to the victim's dependants should be
considered in cases ending in conviction.
These Guidelines were revised and circulated on 2-12-2003 to
introduce greater transparency and accountability, since the States
were not regularly intimating NHRC of encounter deaths thereby
affecting statistical data. The revised Guidelines contained the
following major changes, in addition to the previous Guidelines:
( a ) If a specific complaint was made against the police, an FIR must be
lodged;
( b ) A magisterial inquiry was now mandatory in every encounter
death;
( c ) It also required the State Director General of Police to send a six-
monthly statement of details of all deaths in police action to NHRC.”
16. Further, though the respondents averred that the concerned
Revenue Divisional Officer was appointed as Enquiry Officer vide
Proceedings No.C1/850/M/2001, dated 12.11.2002, however, no
material has been placed on record to establish that the enquiry was
15
concluded and its details are not even placed on record. Article 21 of
the Constitution of India specifically envisages that, no person shall
be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to
procedure established by law. Time and again, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court along with this Court specifically have held that Article 21 of
the Constitution of India confers sacred and cherished right under
the Constitution, which cannot be violated, except according to
procedure established by law. Further, when once Article 21
guarantees personal liberty to every citizen in the country, which
includes the right to live with human dignity, such right cannot be
taken by any State or any instrumentality except by law established.
The NHRC guidelines, which are in force as on the date of the
incident, would bind the State to follow. Though the respondent
State authorities washed out their hands by registering a case against
the extremists and also the petitioner’s husband, the respondent
Police authorities were legally bound to register a case against the
police personnel, who had participated in the alleged encounter, a
proper investigation into the same should have been carried by a
private agency and if it was revealed that the police firing was
resorted to, purely in the exercise of the right of self-defence, no
16
liability could have been fastened upon the respondent-State, no
attempt of this nature was made by the respondents. However, when
NHRC guidelines specifically envisages for registration of the same,
the respondent police authorities have not followed the said
procedure. Further, Hon’ble Supreme Court in People’s Union for
Civil Liberties case (supra), has mandated certain guidelines,
wherein several conditions and directions were given to the
respondent-State to follow the same, the said judgment was passed
in the year 2014. A Five-Judges Bench of this Court in W.P.No.15419
of 2006, dated 06.02.2009, had already issued specific guidelines
governing the cases of deaths arising out of police encounters in the
year 2009, the said directions issued by the Five-Judge Bench were
subsequently affirmed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, and as there
was also available in People’s Union for Civil Liberties case (supra),
as held by the Supreme Court in 2014. The PUCL guidelines and the
guidelines issued by this Court in W.P.No.15419 of 2006, dated
06.02.2009, affirmed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court are law of the
land. Furthermore, the facts in the instant case fit into the guidelines
of NHRC, 1997, which the State neglected to follow.
17
17. A perusal of the counter-affidavit filed by the respondent-State
would go to show that the death of the petitioner’s husband is sought
to be justified on the ground that police resorted to firing in the
exercise of their right of self-defence, even such circumstances were
required to be proved by conducting an investigation or magisterial
enquiry. When once the procedure specifically contemplated by the
NHRC, to register a case and conduct investigation, the respondent
State was duty bound to follow the same. Despite the same, no
investigation was done and no evidence of any enquiry report was
filed before this Court to come to a conclusion that death caused is
purely as self-defence. However, now by efflux of time directing the
respondent State to register an FIR and investigate into the matter, at
this length of time, may not serve any purpose. More particularly, an
investigation undertaken after such a long lapse of time may not
yield any fruitful results, having regard to the difficulties in
collecting evidence and ascertaining the actual circumstances existed,
as on the said date.
18. In the light of the above, in the considered opinion of this
Court, referring the matter to the respondent-State with a direction to
register an FIR and conduct an investigation by a separate
18
independent agency, the said relief stands negated. However, in a
case of the present nature, where the death of an individual is sought
to be justified by the respondent-State on the ground of exercise of
the right of private defence, such a plea must be supported by cogent
and specific material. Significantly, the respondent State has not
followed the NHRC guidelines and investigated the matter. No
material to support the said version is produced. Thus, in the
considered view of this Court, the State has not followed the
prescribed procedure.
19. At the cost of repetition, it is apposite to state that Article 21 of
the Constitution of India, the life of any person cannot be taken away
by the State or any instrumentality, except in accordance with law.
Therefore, in the considered view of this Court, the respondent police
authorities along with State are liable to compensate the petitioner
for loss of her husband at the hands of the respondent Police
authorities on the fateful day. Thus, in the above stated facts and
circumstances, the respondents are hereby directed to pay
compensation of Rs.2,00,000/- to the petitioner for causing the death
of Mr. Balanarsaiah, i.e., husband of the petitioner, within a period
of eight weeks from the date of copy of this order.
19
20. The Writ Petition is accordingly partly allowed. There shall be
no order as to costs.
Pending miscellaneous applications if any shall stand closed.
________________________________
SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO, J
Date: 13.11.2026
kkm
20
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WRIT PETITION NO.4377 OF 2002
Date: 13.11.2026
kkm