Sunil Kumar@Sushil Kumar vs State Of Punjab

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

1
CRWP-12803-2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH

CRWP-12803-2026
Reserved on Pronounced on FULL/OPERATIVE PART UPLOADED ON
04.11.2026 18.11.2026 FULL 19.11.2026

Sunil Kumar @ Sushil Kumar ...Petitioner

VS


State of Punjab and others ....Respondents


CORAM: JUSTICE ANOOP CHITKARA
JUSTICE SUBHAS MEHLA

Present: Mr. Umesh Sharma, Advocate
for the petitioner

Mr. Ajit Pal Singh Mander, Addl. AG, Punjab.


ANOOP CHITKARA, J.
1. Challenging the denial of parole by respondent No.3- Additional Director General of Police
(Prisons), Punjab, the convict has come up before this Court under Article 226¹ of the Constitution
of India for grant of eight weeks parole under the Punjab Good Conduct Prisoners Temporary
Release Act 1962, to meet his family members as well as to look after his children.
2. The petitioner was arrested in FIR No. 265 dated 22.11.2020 registered under Sections 302,
201, 404, 120-B IPC at Police Station Model Town, Hoshiarpur.
3. Vide judgment dated 21.03.2025, the learned Additional Sessions Judge (Fast Track
Special Court), Hoshiarpur, convicted the petitioner in the above-mentioned case and sentenced
him to undergo imprisonment for life with a fine of Rs. 10,000/- under Sections 302, 201, 404,
120B IPC.
4. As per the custody certificate dated Oct 15, 2026, the period of custody undergone by the
petitioner in the above-mentioned case is of 03 years, 04 months and 14 days.
5. The petitioner had sought parole for eight weeks under the provisions of the Punjab Good
Conduct Prisoners (Temporary Release) Act, 1962. The reason for seeking parole is that he wants
to meet his family members and to look after his children.
6. However, vide order dated 21.11.2025, the Additional Director General of Police (Prisons),
Punjab, rejected the petitioner’s parole application, relying upon the report dated 17.10.2025
received from the District Magistrate, Bulandshahr (Uttar Pradesh) and SSP, Bulandshahr (Uttar
Pradesh). The District Magistrate, Bulandshahr (Uttar Pradesh) and SSP, Bulandshahr (Uttar
ANJU RANI
2026.11.19 09:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

2
CRWP-12803-2026
Pradesh) have not recommended the grant of parole of eight weeks to the convict.
7. The reasons for rejection of parole read as follows:
“The convict Sunil Kumar S/o Brijpal is a prisoner of heinous crime, there is a possibility
of disturbance of peace in the village if he is released on parole and roams freely in the
society, due to which it is not recommended to grant parole.”
8. The above order passed by the Additional Director General of Police (Prisons), Punjab, on
the face of it merely adopts the report of the District Magistrate, Bulandshahr (Uttar Pradesh) and
SSP, Bulandshahr (Uttar Pradesh). It records the conclusion reached in that report, but does not
show that the authority has independently considered the report or the material, if any, underlying
it.
9. The order does not disclose any objective ground or supporting evidence to substantiate
the conclusion that the petitioner may abscond or may take part in anti-national activities while on
parole. Nor does it identify any person, group or organization with whom he is said to be
associated, or the source of that information. In the absence of any supporting material or reasons
in the impugned order, these findings remain mere conclusions unsupported by any cogent
justification.
10. Further, the impugned order does not indicate that on the basis of the given considerations,
the petitioner's release on parole would pose a risk of fleeing to evade arrest, nor does it explain
how the apprehension of anti-national activities can be said to remain unaddressed by the
conditions on which parole could be granted.
11. The scope of interference by this Court in a challenge to an order refusing parole is limited,
and the Court would intervene by issuing an appropriate writ only if the order is arbitrary, perverse,
or based on irrelevant considerations.
12. In T.C. Basappa v. T. Nagappa and Another,1955 SCR 250, May 5, 1954, a four-judge
bench of the Supreme Court holds,
Certiorari may lie and is generally granted when a Court has acted without or in excess
of its jurisdiction. The want of jurisdiction may arise from the nature of the subject-
matter of the proceeding or from the absence of some preliminary proceeding or the
Court itself may not be legally constituted or suffer from certain disability by reason of
extraneous circumstances
(1). When the jurisdiction of the Court depends upon the existence of some collateral
fact, it is well settled that the Court cannot by a wrong decision of the fact give it
jurisdiction which it would not otherwise possess
(2). A Tribunal may be competent to enter upon an enquiry but in making the enquiry
it may act in flagrant disregard of the rules of procedure or where no particular
procedure is prescribed, it may violate the principles of natural justice. A writ of
certiorari may be available in such cases. An error in the decision or determination itself
may also be amenable to a writ of certiorari but it must be a manifest error apparent on
the face of the proceedings, e.g., when it is based on clear ignorance or disregard of the
provisions.
13. It shall be relevant to refer to Section 3 of the Punjab Good Conduct Prisoners (Temporary
ANJU RANI
2026.11.19 09:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

3
CRWP-12803-2026
1
Release) Act,1962 ,
Section 3 Temporary release of prisoners on certain grounds
(1) The State Government may, in consultation with the District Magistrate
and subject to such conditions and in such manner as may be prescribed,
release temporarily for a period specified in sub-section (2) any prisoner if
the State Government is satisfied that–
(a) [ a member of the prisoner's family has died; or [Substituted by Punjab
Act No. 1 of 2016, dated 7.1.2016.]
(aa) husband or wife or son or daughter or father or mother or brother or sister
or grand-father or grand-mother or grandson or grand-daughter or father-in-
law or mother-in-law of the prisoner is seriously ill; or]
(b) the marriage of the prisoner's son or daughter is to be celebrated; or
(c) the temporary release of the prisoner is necessary for ploughing, sowing
or harvesting or carrying on any other agricultural operation on his land and
no friend of the prisoner or a member of the prisoner's family is prepared to
help him in this behalf in his absence;
(cc) a lady prisoner is pregnant and is likely to deliver a child; or] [Inserted
by Punjab Act No. 1 of 2016, dated 7.1.2016.]
(d) it is desirable to do so for any other sufficient cause
[Explanation. [Added by Punjab Act No. 1 of 2016, dated 7.1.2016.] - The
expression "sufficient cause" includes –
(1). serious damage to life or property of the member of the family caused by
any natural calamity; or
(2). critical condition of any member of the family on account of accident; or
(1). delivery of child by the wife of the prisoner.]
(2) [The period for which a prisoner may be released shall be determined by
the State Government so as not to exceed –
( a) where the prisoner is to be released on the ground specified in clause
(a) of sub-section (1), fifteen days;
(b) where the prisoner is to be released on the ground specified in clause
(aa) or clause (b) or clause (c) or clause (d) of sub-section (1), [eight
weeks]; and
(c) where the prisoner is to be released on the ground specified in clause (cc)
of sub-section (1), one hundred and twenty days (sixty days prior to the
date of delivery of child and sixty days after the date of delivery of
child).]

1
The Punjab Good Conduct Prisoners (Temporary Release) Act,1962 (Website; legitquest; English).
The Punjab Good Conduct Prisoners (Temporary Release) Act ,1962 (Original Act in Punjabi).
The Punjab Good Conduct Prisoners (Temporary Release) Act ,1962 (Original Act in Punjabi).
The Punjab Good Conduct Prisoners (Temporary Release) Amendment Act,2015.
The Punjab Good Conduct Prisoners (Temporary Release) Amendment Act,2018.
The Punjab Good Conduct Prisoners(Temporary Release) Amendment Act,2020.
ANJU RANI
2026.11.19 09:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

4
CRWP-12803-2026
[(2-A) The total period of temporary release of the prisoner, excluding the
release availed of, -
(i). on the death of a family member of the prisoner; or
(ii). by a female prisoner on account of delivery of child, as the case may be,
shall not exceed sixteen weeks, during a calendar year and shall be availed
of on quarterly basis:
Provided that a prisoner, may avail such release for a continuous period
of sixteen weeks , during the period falling between the 23rd day of
November, 2018 to the 23rd day of November, 2019, as a onetime measure
on pro-rata basis, however, subject to the other provisions of the Act:
Provided further that any prisoner, who is on temporary release for a
specified period and wants to surrender before the expiry of his temporary
release period, he shall be allowed to do so.] [Substituted by Punjab Act No.
2 of 2019, dated 16.1.2019.]
(3) The period of release under this section shall not count towards the
total period of the release of a prisoner.
(4) The State Government may by notification authorise any officer to
exercise its power under this section in respect of all or any of the grounds
specified therein.
14. Thus, Section 3 of the Punjab Good Conduct Prisoners (Temporary Release) Act, 1962,
provides for a prisoner’s release, and had they not been rendered hugely beneficial, the State would
have repealed the provisions.
15. Regarding the other objections, the concept behind the grant of parole needs an overview,
and the rejection or grant has to be within the legal parameters.
16. The form of punishment evolved from its ancient forms to the model prisons, and from the
prisons to rehabilitation. Before the prison became the principal instrument of punishment, the
penal system was dominated by the body of the condemned and by the spectacle of its suffering.
In ancient and pre-modern systems of torture, punishment was a public event, staged in the open
so that the community might see it, fear it, and remember it. Michel Foucault, in Discipline and
Punish , traces the shift from that world to the birth of the modern prison and argues that the
spectacle of the scaffold was once an accepted mode of punishment, and that public execution
should be understood not merely as a legal act but as an exercise of sovereign power. [T]he public
execution… has to be understood not only as a judicial, but also as a political ritual. It belongs,
2
even in minor cases, to the ceremonies by which power is manifested.
17. This display of power did not last. In time, it came to be realized that the spectacle of the
tortured body served neither dignity nor justice, and that even the gravest offender retained some
measure of humanity which the State was bound to respect. As Foucault records, the call for a
penalty without torture was, at first, not a doctrine but a protest,
“The need for a punishment without torture was first formulated as a cry from the heart
or from an outraged nature: in the worst of murderers, there is one thing, at least, to be

2
ANJU RANI
Michel Foucault, Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison 47 (Alan Sheridan trans., Vintage Books, 1995).
2026.11.19 09:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

5
CRWP-12803-2026
respected when one punishes: his ‘humanity’. The day was to come, in the nineteenth
century, when this ‘man’, discovered in the criminal, would become the target of penal
intervention, the object that it claimed to correct and transform, the domain of a whole
3
series of ‘criminological’ sciences.”
18. Once the offender was seen as a person to be corrected, and no longer as a body to be
destroyed, the search began for a penalty suited to that purpose. The idea of the prison emerged
from this search, and, within a short span of time, detention became the essential form of
punishment, displacing the scaffold, the pillory and the gallows. Yet the prison system did not
emerge without criticism. The reformers who had envisaged penalties that were visible,
proportionate and publicly intelligible found the new institution at odds with their design, and
Foucault records their objection in the following words:
“Prison as the universal penalty is incompatible with this whole technique of penalty-
effect, penalty-representation, penalty-general function, penalty-sign and discourse. It
is obscurity, violence and suspicion. It is a place of darkness in which the citizen’s eye
4
cannot count the victims.”

19. Foucault’s account of the prison is, at its core, an account of how incarceration
manufactures docile bodies. Inside the walls, the prisoner’s day is divided into rigid timetables of
waking, labor, meals, and silence; his movements are confined to the cell and the corridor; and his
conduct is recorded in files that rank him against a norm.
20. Through hierarchical observation and the permanent possibility of being seen, as in
Bentham’s Panopticon, the prisoners learn that they are always visible while the watcher remains
unseen, and so begin to police themselves.
21. The foremost principle of a prison structure is isolation; the isolation of the convict from
the external world, from everything that motivated the offense, from the complicities that
facilitated it, and most importantly the isolation of prisoners from one another. Power thus no
longer rests on the spectacle of the suffering body; it works through routine and constant
surveillance. Freedom is curtailed not only physically but psychologically; the prisoner becomes
the principle of their own subjection, trained into an obedient and predictable body whose will is
gradually worn down. Not only is the penalty to be individual, but it must also be individualizing.
22. It was this very rigidity, and the growing recognition that unbroken confinement and under
constant surveillance may produce obedience without reform, that gave rise to the movement for
reform of the prison system. If prisons were meant to correct, it could not do so merely by isolating
and disciplining the offender; it had to prepare him for life beyond the walls. Reformers therefore
sought to humanize confinement through inmate classification, education, the imparting of ethics,
values, and morals, and the gradual relaxation of restrictions, so that a sentence would end in a
return to society and not in permanent exclusion. Measures for the conditional and temporary
release of prisoners, of which parole is the most prominent, are the product of this reformative
impulse: they open the closed system of the prison, in a controlled manner, to the world outside.

3
Michel Foucault, Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison 74 (Alan Sheridan trans., Vintage Books, 1995).
4
ANJU RANI
Michel Foucault, Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison 114 (Alan Sheridan trans., Vintage Books, 1995).
2026.11.19 09:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

6
CRWP-12803-2026
23. Parole emerged when the decline of capital punishment and transportation brought a need
for aftercare of prisoners related into the community, and the public demanded protection against
prisoners released without improved character―Parole shortens his exposure to the possibly
injurious effects of imprisonment; it is a device for timing the prisoner’s release to coincide with
the point in his prison career when he is most likely to become an effective member of the free
community―By providing guidance, parole offers a partial answer to the readjustment problems
5
of the released prisoner.
24. Parole developed from a number of independent measures: penal transportation to
America and Australia, the English and Irish experiences with the ticket-of -leave system, and the
th 6
work of 19 century American reformatories.
25. Under Zebulon Brockway, New York’s Elmira Reformatory combined several known
operating principles when it opened in 1876: the indeterminate sentence, relating privileges
granted the prisoner to his conduct, compulsory education and the release of selected prisoners on
parole―A reaction against the classical school’s assumption that punishments should be
standardized and equated to the basis of the crime, these principles stem from the positive school’s
thesis that crimes are acts of men who differ in physical, psychological and social
backgrounds―Parole was seen as the culmination of a course of institutional training whereby the
inmate’s capacity for reform would be developed. Brockway also saw parole as a test period to
determine whether the offender had absorbed the training―Consequently, parole was perceived
7
as part of the program of the correctional institution.
26. The consequence of every conviction is the imposition of sentences prescribed in law for
such a violation. All sentences are for a limited term, except the death penalty and life
imprisonment. Thus, in all cases, except for death sentences and where it is specifically mentioned
in the sentencing order that the sentence of imprisonment for life shall run till the end of the natural
life, the sentences are of indefinite period, and even these sentences are subject to reduction by the
8
President of India, in exercise of their sovereign powers conferred under Article 72 of the
Constitution of India; and by the Governors, in exercise of their sovereign powers conferred under
9
Article 161 of the Constitution of India. What follows is that, except in the rarest of rare cases,
extraordinary situations, and exceptional circumstances, all other sentences are for a definite
period, and the confinement lapses after a certain time. Its natural corollary is that such convicts
shall come out of the prison walls one day, and their return is not in isolation but back to society.
27. The paramount question sociologists struggle with while undergoing their quest to
convince the Executive is ‘how to condition the prisoner’? Every prisoner must be rehabilitated to
ensure their dignified return to the community, with consistent behavior that never puts them back
under surveillance inside the Panopticon. A few relationships are like a cactus and do not require

5 th
Elmer H. Johnson, Crime, Correction and Society 375-376 (Robin M. Williams, Jr., 4 ed, The Dorsey
Press,1978).
6 th
Elmer H. Johnson, Crime, Correction and Society 377 (Robin M. Williams, Jr., 4 ed, The Dorsey Press,1978).
7 th
Elmer H. Johnson, Crime, Correction and Society 378 (Robin M. Williams, Jr., 4 ed, The Dorsey Press,1978).
8
72. Power of President to grant pardons, etc., and to suspend, remit or commute sentences in certain cases.
9
ANJU RANI
161. Power of Governor to grant pardons, etc., and to suspend, remit or commute sentences in certain cases.
2026.11.19 09:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

7
CRWP-12803-2026
frequent watering, and a sufficiently long oblivion brings about the ‘Out of sight, out of mind’
phenomenon, which can wither even a resilient cactus.
28. Within this closed system of control, parole appears as a respite, where good conduct is
rewarded, so the prisoner is encouraged to reflect, to reform, and to rebuild themselves as a person
capable of living lawfully in society. Once released, they are spared the full severity of confinement
and are allowed to return to family, work, and community. In this context, parole is the humane
face of the reformative movement; it softens the prison’s rigidity. It converts punishment into an
opportunity for reintegration into society.
29. Parole is a temporary release granted to a convict in the discretion of the competent
authority; it is not a matter of right, and it may be denied even when a case is made out if the
release is not in the interest of society.
30. In Sunil Fulchand Shah v. Union of India and Others, [2000] 1 SCR 945; 2000 INSC 74;
Feb 16, 2000; a five-judge bench of the Supreme Court holds,
[7.] ‘Parole' is a form of “temporary release” from custody, which does not
suspend the sentence or the period of detention, but provides conditional release
from custody and changes the mode of undergoing the sentence. In this country,
there are no statutory provisions dealing with the question of grant of paroie. The
Code of Criminal Procedure does not contain any provision for grant of parole.
By administrative instructions, however, rules have been framed in various
States, regulating the grant of parole. Thus, the action for grant of parole is
generally speaking an administrative action. [962-G; E]
31. In Smt. Poonam Lata v. M.L. Wadhawan and Others, [1987] 2 SCR 1123; 1987 INSC
124; 22.04.1987, the Supreme Court holds,
[3.] Parole is the release of a prisoner from a penal or correctional institution after
he has served a part of his sentence under the continuous custody of the State and
under conditions that permit his incarceration in the event of misbehaviour. It is
a grant of partial liberty or lessening of restrictions to a convict prisoner and does
not change the status of the prisoner.
32. In Maru Ram Etc. Etc. v Union of India and Anr., [1981] 1 SCR 1196, 1980 INSC 212,
Nov 11, 1980, 5J, the Supreme Court holds,
[p.1250] [12.] In our view, penal humanitarianism and rehabilitative desideratum
warrant liberal paroles, subject to security safeguards, and other humanizing
strategies for inmates so that the dignity and worth of the human person are not
desecrated by making mass jails anthropoid zoos. Human rights awareness must
infuse institutional reform and search for alternatives.
33. In State of Gujarat & Anr. v. Lal Singh @ Manjit Singh & Ors.; [2016] 4 S.C.R. 816; 2016
INSC 463; June 29, 2016; SC, the Supreme Court holds,
[p. 837] [33.] So far as direction for grant of parole is concerned, we find that the
learned Judge has directed parole to be granted for three months forthwith. In
Sunil Fulchand Shah v. Union of India and others [(2000) 3 SCC 409] the
Constitution Bench while dealing with the grant of temporary release or parole
under Section 12( 1) and Section 12( 1-A) of the Conversation of Foreign
ANJU RANI
2026.11.19 09:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

8
CRWP-12803-2026
Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 (COFEPOSA Act)
had observed that the exercise of the said power is administrative in character but
it does not affect the power of the High Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution. However, the constitutional court before directing the temporary
release where the request is made to be released on parole for a specified reason
and for a specified period should form an opinion that request has been
unjustifiably refused or where the interest of justice warranted for issue of such
order of temporary release. The Court further ruled that jurisdiction has to be
sparingly exercised by the Court and even when it is exercised, it is appropriate
that the Court should leave it to the administrative or jail authorities to prescribe
the conditions and terms on which parole is to be availed of by the detenu.
34. In the case of The Home Secretary (Prisons) And Ors., v. H. Nilofer Nisha; [2020] 1 S.C.R.
456; Jan. 23, 2020; SC; 2J, the Supreme Court holds,
[p. 473] [27.] We would also like to point out that the grant of remission or parole is
not a right vested with the prisoner. It is a privilege available to the prisoner on
fulfilling certain conditions. This is a discretionary power which has to be exercised
by the authorities conferred with such powers under the relevant rules/regulations.
The court cannot exercise these powers though once the powers are exercised, the
Court may hold that the exercise of powers is not in accordance with rules.
35. In the case of Deepak Kumar vs State Of Punjab And Others, CRWP 7882 of 2022, Feb
27,2023, Punjab and Haryana High Court observed,
[13.] Both 'Parole' and 'Furlough' are considered as reformative processes. These
provisions were introduced with a view to humanizing the prison system. Parole is
not a right, and is given to a prisoner for a specific reason. It may be denied to a
prisoner even when he makes out a sufficient case, if the competent authority is
satisfied that releasing the convict would not be in the interest of society. Parole can
only be granted in event of some emergency and circumstances, such as the death of
a family member, the marriage of a family member, a family member's major illness,
or any other emergency situation. 'Furlough' is similar to 'parole', but with some
significant differences. It is given in cases of long-term imprisonment. The period of
furlough granted to a prisoner is treated as remission of his sentence. Though, unlike
parole, furlough is seen as a matter of right for a prisoner, to be granted periodically
irrespective of any reason, and merely to enable the prisoner to retain family and
social ties, and to counter the ill-effects of long time imprisonment but as a matter of
fact, even 'furlough' is not an absolute right and grant of furlough is subject to the
conditions as prescribed, the most significant being the period already spent in
custody and his conduct during such period.
36. In light of the aforementioned, the impugned order dated 08.01.2026 cannot sustain the
legal scrutiny and deserves to be set aside.
37. The Additional Director General of Police (Prisons), Punjab, Chandigarh, shall consider
the material on record and shall not reject parole based on general statements, apprehensions, or
undisclosed information.
38. This Court has not expressed any opinion on whether the petitioner should or should not
be released on parole, which is for the competent authority to decide on the material before it.
Liberty is reserved to the petitioner to approach this Court again, if need arises. All pending
miscellaneous applications, if any, stand disposed of.
39. The decision shall be made within 30 working days from the date of receipt of the digital
ANJU RANI
2026.11.19 09:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

9
CRWP-12803-2026
copy of this order and the same shall be communicated to the petitioner.
40. Given the above, the writ petition is allowed, and the impugned order dated 21.11.2025 is
set aside. The matter is remanded to the Additional Director General of Police (Prisons), Punjab,
Chandigarh, to decide the petitioner's application for parole afresh by a reasoned order. All pending
miscellaneous applications, if any, are disposed.


(ANOOP CHITKARA)
JUDGE



(SUBHAS MEHLA)
JUDGE


18.11.2026
Anju rani

Whether speaking/reasoned YES
Whether reportable NO


ANJU RANI
2026.11.19 09:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document