Kamal Prasad Dubey vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh
- Court
- Supreme Court
<div> <b>REPORTABLE </b><br /> 2026 INSC 353<br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA </b><br /> <b>CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION </b><br /></div><table><thead><tr><th>CIVIL APPEAL NOS._____</th><th></th><th>OF 2026</th></tr></thead><tbody></tbody></table><div><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>KAMAL PRASAD DUBEY </b> <b> </b> <b> …APPELLANT </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>VERSUS </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH </b><br /> <b>AND OTHERS </b> <b> …RESPONDENTS </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>J U D G M E N T </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>N.V. ANJARIA, J. </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> Leave granted. <br /> <b>2.</b> <b> </b> Discrimination is the other name of injustice. <br /> <b>2.1</b> <b> </b> The challenge in these appeals addressed by the <br /> appellant-original petitioner to the order dated 11.11.2019 <br /> passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Madhya <br /> Pradesh, Jabalpur, allowing Writ Appeal No. 1758 of 2019, <br /> and to order dated 17.12.2019 dismissing the corresponding <br /> Review Petition No. 1665 of 2019, deserves to be considered <br /> Signature Not Verified<br /> Digitally signed by<br /> KAVITA PAHUJA<br /> Date: 2026.04.10<br /> 17:38:24 IST<br /> Reason:<br /> in light of the above principle. <br /> <b>Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos.13578-13579/2020</b> Page <b>1</b> of <b>17</b> <br /> <br /><br /> <b>2.2</b> <b> </b> The appellant filed Writ Petition No. 12814 of 2016 <br /> before learned Single Judge of the High Court in which he <br /> challenged order dated 07.06.2016 passed by the <br /> Commissioner-cum-Registrar, Cooperative Societies, <br /> Bhopal-respondent No. 2 herein, whereby the request of <br /> respondent <i> </i> No. 5- Primary Agricultural Cooperative Society <br /> for relaxing the educational qualification of the appellant for <br /> the promotion to the post of Society Manager came to be <br /> rejected. <br /> <b>2.3</b> <b> </b> Learned Single Judge of the High Court, by his order <br /> dated 22.01.2019, allowed the Writ Petition, setting aside <br /> the aforementioned order dated 07.06.2016, and directed <br /> respondent No. 2-Registrar to pass order extending the <br /> benefit of relaxation in the educational qualification granting <br /> promotion to the appellant. <br /> <b>2.4</b> <b> </b> The Division Bench, however took the view, as per <br /> the impugned order, that the discretion to grant the <br /> relaxation was with the Board of Directors of the society, and <br /> not with the Registrar and that the appellant since did not <br /> have the necessary qualification, the Registrar was right in <br /> declining to grant the relaxation. <br /> <b>Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos.13578-13579/2020</b> Page <b>2</b> of <b>17</b> <br /> <br /><br /> <b>2.5</b> <b> </b> It may be mentioned that this Court, in the present <br /> proceedings, by order dated 05.11.2020, directed that the <br /> appellant shall not be demoted, which has continued till <br /> date. <br /> <b>3.</b> <b> </b> Outlining the attendant facts, the appellant who is <br /> presently posted as Manager, Primary Agriculture Credit <br /> Cooperative Society, Nayagaon, Panna District-respondent <br /> No. 5, a society registered under the Madhya Pradesh <br /> Cooperative Societies Act, 1960, and has the experience of <br /> 28 years of working in the Society, came to be appointed as <br /> <i>Sahayak Samiti Sevak</i> vide order dated 02.09.1987, on <br /> permanent basis. <br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>3.1</b> The service conditions of the employees of the society <br /> are governed by the service rules framed by the Registrar of <br /> Cooperative Society in exercise of powers under Section <br /> 55(1) of the Madhya Pradesh Cooperative Societies Act, <br /> 1960. It was stated that the earlier Rules framed by order <br /> dated 09.10.1990 came to be substituted with new Rules on <br /> 30.08.2013, repealing the old Rules. The appellant was <br /> appointed as <i>Sahayak Samiti Sevak</i> by order dated <br /> 02.09.1987. He had passed the Higher Secondary School <br /> <b>Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos.13578-13579/2020</b> Page <b>3</b> of <b>17</b> <br /> <br /><br /> Examination conducted by the Board of Secondary <br /> Education, Madhya Pradesh, in the year 1984. <br /> <b>3.2</b> <b> </b> At the time when the appellant was appointed as <br /> <i>Samiti Sevak</i> , he was Higher Secondary passed, and had <br /> undergone various training programmes. By order dated <br /> 23.07.1996, he was deputed as Clerk in <i>Jila Sahkari </i><br /> <i>Kendriya</i> <i>Bank</i> . In view of experience of the appellant, <br /> respondent No.5-Society passed a resolution dated <br /> 26.02.2014 deciding and resolving to promote the appellant <br /> from the post of <i>Sahayak Samiti Prabandhak</i> to <i>Samiti </i><br /> <i>Prabandhak</i> (Society Manager). <br /> <b>3.3</b> <b> </b> One Mr. Sajid Ali was transferred on 19.06.2014 to <br /> respondent No.5-Society and came to be posted as <i>Samiti </i><br /> <i>Prabandhak</i> , which was the post on which the appellant had <br /> already been working. In that view, when guidance was <br /> sought from the Registrar, by his communication dated <br /> 15.10.2015 the Registrar accepted the recommendation <br /> made by the Assistant Registrar and allowed the appellant <br /> to continue on the post of Society Manager, having regard to <br /> his long work experience. It was provided that reasonable <br /> <b>Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos.13578-13579/2020</b> Page <b>4</b> of <b>17</b> <br /> <br /><br /> time may be given to him to acquire the necessary eligibility <br /> qualification of graduation as requisite under the new rules. <br /> <b>3.4</b> <b> </b> Respondent No. 5-Society in its meeting held on <br /> 02.07.2015 passed a resolution recommending the grant of <br /> relaxation in the educational qualification of the appellant <br /> for the purpose of promotion to the post of Society Manager, <br /> in light of the fact that under the old Rules, an employee <br /> possessing the educational qualification of Higher <br /> Secondary was eligible and that the appellant possessed <br /> such qualification, and further he had a long work <br /> experience. The General Body of the Society ratified the <br /> aforesaid resolution of the Board of Directors, in the General <br /> Body meeting held on 28.09.2015. However, the Registrar <br /> rejected the proposal made by the Board of Directors which <br /> was also approved by the General Body, taking a stance that <br /> relaxation could not have been granted. <br /> <b>3.5</b> <b> </b> It is the case of the appellant, based on admitted <br /> facts, that one Sushil Kumar Tripathi, who also held the <br /> qualification of Higher Secondary, was promoted by order <br /> dated 29.02.2016. Similarly, another employee named Ram <br /> Swaroop Pandey, also a Higher Secondary pass, came to be <br /> <b>Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos.13578-13579/2020</b> Page <b>5</b> of <b>17</b> <br /> <br /><br /> appointed as Society Manager on 12.12.2014, who had 20 <br /> years’ work experience as against the work experience of <br /> more than 28 years to the credit of the appellant. <br /> <b>3.6</b> <b> </b> As stated, under the old rules prevailing at the time <br /> of the appointment of the appellant, the educational <br /> qualification prescribed for the purpose of promotion to the <br /> higher post of <i>Samiti Prabandhak</i> (Society Manager) was <br /> Higher Secondary. In the new Rules which came into force <br /> on 30.08.2013, any additional qualification for the <br /> promotion to the said post was not prescribed. <br /> <b>4.</b> <b> </b> Heard learned advocate on record Ms. Ruchi Gupta <br /> with learned advocate Mr. Anirudh Sharma for the appellant <br /> <br /> and learned advocate Mr. Yashraj Singh Bundela for <br /> respondent Nos.1 to 4 and 6 and learned advocate Mr. <br /> Chand Qureshi for respondent No.5. <br /> <b>5.</b> <b> </b> It is to be noted that when in the meeting of the <br /> Board of Directors of respondent No.5-Society passed <br /> resolution dated 02.07.2015 to consider the case of <br /> promotion of the appellant to the post of <i>Samiti Prabandhak</i> <br /> from the post of <i>Sahayak</i> <i>Samiti Prabandhak</i> and <br /> <b>Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos.13578-13579/2020</b> Page <b>6</b> of <b>17</b> <br /> <br /><br /> recommended him for promotion, several relevant <br /> considerations were taken into account as could be seen <br /> from the proceedings of the meeting figuring on record. It <br /> was noted in decision No.3 corresponding to proposal No.3 <br /> that no employee of the cadre of <i>Samiti Prabandhak</i> has <br /> been posted during the last 5 months and that due to the <br /> same, the work of the institution had been suffering. <br /> <b>5.1</b> <b> </b> It was noted that the appellant had been working in <br /> the Institution since last 26 years, having been appointed <br /> on 02.09.1987, and that his track record was clean and no <br /> charge of irregularities of any kind was levelled against him. <br /> Further, it was recorded that as the society had been <br /> receiving satisfactory services since last 26-27 years from <br /> the appellant, who was the senior-most employee, he was <br /> unanimously recommended for promotion in the interests of <br /> smooth conduct and working of the society. <br /> <b>5.2</b> <b> </b> While ratifying the recommendation of the Board of <br /> Directors, the General Body in its meeting held on <br /> 28.09.2015 expressly noted that the proposal of the Board <br /> of Directors to promote the appellant on the basis of his long <br /> work experience was justified, that he was rendering regular <br /> <b>Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos.13578-13579/2020</b> Page <b>7</b> of <b>17</b> <br /> <br /><br /> services for the last 28 years, and looking to his seniority, <br /> competence, and experience, the relaxation given in <br /> educational qualification was justified. It was unanimously <br /> decided by the General Body to submit the recommendation <br /> to the Commissioner-cum-Registrar, Cooperative Societies <br /> for his approval. <br /> <b>5.3</b> <b> </b> It is to be noticed that the Registrar, by his <br /> communication dated 07.06.2016, which was the decision <br /> impugned in the writ petition, without assigning any reason <br /> and in a cryptic manner, rejected the proposal of the Board <br /> of Directors and the General Body for granting relaxation in <br /> the educational qualification to promote the appellant. <br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>5.4</b> The said communication dated 07.06.2016, whereby <br /> the proposal was filed, is extracted hereunder in its relevant <br /> part, <br /> To, <br /> The Chairman, <br /> Primary Agriculture Credit Cooperative Society <br /> Nayagaon District Panna M.P. <br /> Subject: Regarding grant of relaxation in <br /> educational qualification to Shri Kamal Prasad <br /> Dubey posted as Samiti Prabandhak in the Society. <br /> <b>Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos.13578-13579/2020</b> Page <b>8</b> of <b>17</b> <br /> <br /><br /> Reference:-Your Office Letter Number Q dated <br /> 15/10/2015, <br /> Please peruse the letter under reference under <br /> the above mentioned subject. By the letter under <br /> reference, proposal to grant relaxation in the <br /> educational qualification to Shri Kamal Prasad <br /> Dubey Samiti Prabandhak as per the proposal <br /> number 5 Decision number 5 dated 02/07/2015 of <br /> the Board of directors has been forwarded. <br /> After examining the same, the aforesaid <br /> proposal is filed. <br /> (Approved by the Commissioner Cooperative) <br /> Sd/- Illegible <br /> Additional Commissioner <br /> Cooperative, Madhya Pradesh <br /> <br /> <b>5.5</b> <b> </b> At this stage, Rule 19-A of the <i>Prathmic, Krishi Saakh </i><br /> <i>Sahakari Sanstha, Vrihattakar Saakh Sahakari Sanstha, </i><br /> <i>Adim Jati Sewa Sahakari Sewa Sanstha, Krishak Sewa </i><br /> <i>Sahakari Sanstha Karmchari Sewa (Niyojan, Nibandhan, </i><br /> <i>Tatha Karya Stithi) Niyam, 2013</i> may be considered with <br /> relevance. It <i>inter alia</i> provided that upon acquiring the <br /> prescribed qualification, promotion to the various classes of <br /> posts shall be granted to the employees. It was stated that <br /> from Class II to Class I, promotion to the post of <i>Samiti </i><br /> <i>Prabandhak</i> from the post of <i>Sahayak</i> <i>Samiti </i><br /> <i>Prabandhak</i> /Accountant would be granted. It was stated <br /> that for the purpose of promotion, minimum 5 years’ tenure <br /> on the present post and acquiring of the prescribed <br /> <b>Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos.13578-13579/2020</b> Page <b>9</b> of <b>17</b> <br /> <br /><br /> educational qualification shall be compulsory requirement <br /> and that the criteria of promotion shall be seniority-cum-<br /> merit. <br /> <b>5.6</b> <b> </b> Proviso to said Rule 19A becomes relevant in the <br /> facts of the case, which reads as under, <br /> ‘Provided that on the basis of employee's special <br /> experience/competence/seniority, relaxation in the <br /> educational qualification for promotion may be <br /> granted by the Registrar.’ <br /> <br /> <b>5.7</b> <b> </b> Rule 11 of the aforesaid Rules, however, mentioned <br /> about eligibility criteria. It required that a person should <br /> have a graduation degree along with diploma/degree in <br /> computer application and further that a person holding <br /> graduation in Commerce and diploma/degree in <br /> Cooperative Management will be given preference. At the <br /> same time, as mentioned above, Proviso to Rule 19A <br /> contemplated about relaxation in the educational <br /> qualification to promote the employee on the post of <i>Samiti </i><br /> <i>Prabandhak </i> on the basis of <i> </i> employees’ special <br /> experience/competence/seniority. <br /> <b>6.</b> <b> </b> Recollecting at this stage the relevant facts, when the <br /> appellant was appointed as an Assistant Society Manager in <br /> <b>Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos.13578-13579/2020</b> Page <b>10</b> of <b>17</b> <br /> <br /><br /> the year 1987 by the Board of Directors of respondent No. <br /> 5-Society, the educational qualification necessary for the <br /> purpose of appointment to the Society Manager was Higher <br /> Secondary. This was as per the Rules in force at that time. <br /> From 30.08.2013 in the new Rules, the qualifications for the <br /> post of Society Manager were revised to requirement of <br /> graduation with diploma in computer, and it was further <br /> provided that the relaxation in such educational <br /> qualification could be granted by the Registrar to the <br /> employees who had been working for more than 5 years. <br /> <b>6.1</b> <b> </b> In light of the appellant's experience of work, his case <br /> was recommended for promotion to the post of Society <br /> Manager by the Board of Directors and was approved and <br /> furthered by the General Body. The Registrar, by order dated <br /> 07.06.2016, did not grant the relaxation in educational <br /> qualification, refusing the recommendation of the Board of <br /> Directors and the General Body. <br /> <b>6.2</b> <b> </b> There is no gainsaying that at all material times, the <br /> power to grant relaxation was available and was vested with <br /> the Board of Directors. In the case of the appellant, it was <br /> the Board of Directors which passed the resolution granting <br /> <b>Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos.13578-13579/2020</b> Page <b>11</b> of <b>17</b> <br /> <br /><br /> the relaxation to the appellant, exercising the powers duly <br /> vested in it. The Registrar could not have disapproved the <br /> resolution, once it was validly passed by the Board of <br /> Directors, which was a competent authority exercising its <br /> powers. <br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>7.</b> In the entire scenario, what becomes conspicuous is <br /> that during the same period, two other employees named <br /> Sushil Kumar Tripathi and Ram Swaroop Pandey were <br /> recommended for promotion by the Board of Directors of the <br /> society and that the Registrar accepted those <br /> recommendations by his order. Both the above employees <br /> named Sushil Kumar and Ram Swaroop possessed the same <br /> qualification of Higher Secondary as that of the appellant at <br /> the time they were approved by the Registrar to be promoted <br /> upon recommendation by the Board of Directors. <br /> <b>7.1</b> <b> </b> Sushil Kumar and Ram Swaroop could be grouped <br /> together to be the homogeneous class of persons to be <br /> approved for promotion, without inviting a breach of any law <br /> or statutory rule. The relaxation in educational qualification <br /> was permissible and the Board of Directors extended the <br /> same to the appellant in view of his long-standing service <br /> <b>Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos.13578-13579/2020</b> Page <b>12</b> of <b>17</b> <br /> <br /><br /> and work experience. The Registrar, in approving two other <br /> employees for promotion and negativing and discarding the <br /> case of the appellant though all the three cases were <br /> attended by similar circumstances, acted arbitrarily. <br /> <b>7.2</b> <b> </b> It is not that said Sushil Kumar and Ram Swaroop <br /> were not eligible to be promoted and yet they were promoted. <br /> In the same way stands the case of the appellant who was <br /> also otherwise qualified and eligible, by extending the <br /> provision for relaxation in educational qualification, to be <br /> promoted to the post of Society Manager to sail in the same <br /> boat with the said two similarly situated employees. Thus, <br /> the case of the appellant is not one that the appellant seeks <br /> parity and equality for promotion with ineligibles or that he <br /> is not fit to be promoted. No concept of negative equality is <br /> attracted that the appellant is to be given equal treatment <br /> with those persons who are not eligible. <br /> <b>8.</b> <b> </b> Learned Single Judge could rightly notice the <br /> equality aspect as observed thus, <br /> ‘9. ...The respondents have also not denied the fact <br /> that other two persons namely Sushil Kumar <br /> Pandey and Ramswaroop Pandey, whose <br /> appointments have been placed on record as <br /> <b>Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos.13578-13579/2020</b> Page <b>13</b> of <b>17</b> <br /> <br /><br /> Annexure P-16 and P-17 have been given relaxation <br /> in their educational qualification. In view of the <br /> same this Court does not find any reason or <br /> justification to uphold the impugned order passed <br /> by the respondent No.2 as reproduced herein above <br /> which is cryptic in nature and does not disclose any <br /> reason for rejection of relaxation in petitioner's <br /> educational qualification for the post of Society <br /> Manager as has been recommended by the <br /> respondent No.5 in their resolution. Thus on merits <br /> as also on the ground of parity, the petitioner is <br /> entitled for relaxation in his educational <br /> qualification for his promotion to the post of Society <br /> Manager.’ <br /> <br /> <b>8.1</b> <b> </b> Even as the discriminatory treatment writ large in <br /> case of the appellant, the Division Bench, for no good <br /> reason, did not approve the finding of the learned Single <br /> Judge regarding discrimination. It was observed in <br /> paragraph 11 of the impugned order by the Division Bench <br /> that since the appellant did not have the necessary <br /> qualification to be promoted, the Registrar, Cooperative <br /> Societies, was well within his powers in declining to grant <br /> the relaxation, overlooking the fact that the relaxation was <br /> permissible under the rules itself. <br /> <b>8.2</b> <b> </b> While on one hand, the Division Bench of the High <br /> Court in its impugned order recorded that the Registrar was <br /> within his jurisdiction to refuse the relaxation, it specifically <br /> <b>Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos.13578-13579/2020</b> Page <b>14</b> of <b>17</b> <br /> <br /><br /> observed in the previous paragraph 10 of the impugned <br /> order that at the relevant time, the discretion for granting <br /> relaxation was vested with the Board of Directors of the <br /> society and not with the Registrar. The reasoning in the <br /> impugned order amounted to a clear contradiction. <br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>9.</b> While the Division Bench of the High Court in its <br /> impugned order misdirected itself in its approach and <br /> reasoning to reverse the judgment of Learned Single Judge <br /> for all the aforesaid facts, reasons and circumstances, the <br /> non-acceptance of the case of the appellant for promotion to <br /> the post of Society Manager, does not stand to reason, defies <br /> rationale, smothers reasonableness and does not hold good <br /> on merits. <br /> <b>9.1</b> <b> </b> The equal treatment came to be denied to the <br /> appellant to his discrimination. The facts obtained strikingly <br /> attract the tenets of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution, <br /> to violate the fundamental concept of equality in law and <br /> equal treatment in the matters of employment. Substantive <br /> justice and real justice is always subserved by applying the <br /> doctrine of equality. <br /> <b>Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos.13578-13579/2020</b> Page <b>15</b> of <b>17</b> <br /> <br /><br /> <b>9.2</b> <b> </b> In the year 2019, new Rules came into force. The <br /> educational qualification for the post of Society Manager <br /> came to be reframed to be lowered again and the <br /> requirement was re-enacted to Higher Secondary with one-<br /> year diploma in computer education. Order dated <br /> 01.11.2019, whereby the aforesaid qualification was <br /> provided for, figures on record, having been produced by the <br /> appellant. It further contemplated that if the person <br /> concerned does not possess the computer-related <br /> qualification, he would be granted one-year period to acquire <br /> such qualification. <br /> <b>9.3</b> <b> </b> It is to be noted that the appellant has attained the <br /> said qualification in the year 2020. The appellant now holds <br /> the degree of M.A. and has also successfully completed the <br /> diploma in computers. <br /> <b>10.</b> <b> </b> In view of the foregoing reasons and discussion, the <br /> impugned order passed by the Division Bench of the High <br /> Court of Madhya Pradesh, Jabalpur is rendered <br /> unsustainable in law. Resultantly, order dated 11.11.2019 <br /> passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Madhya <br /> Pradesh, Jabalpur in Writ Appeal No.1758 of 2019 and <br /> <b>Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos.13578-13579/2020</b> Page <b>16</b> of <b>17</b> <br /> <br /><br /> order dated 17.12.2019 in Review Petition No.1665 of 2019, <br /> are hereby set aside. <br /> <b>11.</b> <b> </b> The Appeals stand allowed. <br /> In view of the disposal of the Appeals, the <br /> interlocutory applications, as may be pending, shall not <br /> survive. <br /> <br /> <b>……………………….……………..,J. </b><br /> <b>[PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA] </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>…………………………………..,J. </b><br /> <b>[N.V. ANJARIA] </b><br /> <b>NEW DELHI; </b><br /> <b>APRIL 10, 2026. </b><br /> <b>Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos.13578-13579/2020</b> Page <b>17</b> of <b>17</b> <br /> </div>