State Of Goa vs Agniv Sengupta

Court
Supreme Court

Non-Reportable
2026 INSC 1245
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Criminal Appeal No.5416 of 2026
[@Special Leave Petition(Crl.) No.18768 of 2026 ]
State of Goa ...Appellant
Versus
Agniv Sengupta ...Respondent
O R D E R
Leave granted.
2. The appeal is filed by the State of Goa against
the order of the High Court granting bail to the
respondent, who was the accused in a case registered
as FIR No.4 of 2025 at Police Station Anti Narcotic
Cell, North Goa. The respondent allegedly was found
in possession of 50.03 grams of cocaine and 15.04
grams of MDMA/Ecstasy recovered from the room/flat
No.106, he occupied in Helen Oasis, Vagator, Goa.
nd
The room occupied by the 2 respondent was an Air-
B&B facility and the search was conducted following
all formalities, in the presence of Panchas and after
Signature Not Verified
first detaining the respondent from the basement and
Digitally signed by
VISHAL ANAND
Date: 2026.11.19
10:48:02 IST
Reason:
leading him to the room occupied by him. The
Page 1 of 7

respondent having refused to hand over the keys of
the room, the duplicate keys were obtained from one
Mr. Jerry D’Souza, who was managing the Air-B&B
facilities. Mr. Jerry D’Souza was also present when the
search was conducted and recovery made in the
presence of independent Panchas. A video recording
of the search conducted was also carried out by the
investigating team.
3. Before the High Court, it was argued that the
respondent was apprehended two days back and was
subsequently taken to the room after the contraband
was planted. It was also contended that he had been
tortured in the Police Station and a burn injury was
inflicted on his hand. While contending that he had
never been in occupation of the room, it was also
argued that when the police had first talked with the
Manager of the facility, Mr. Jerry D’Souza and then
detained the respondent from the basement, there
was sufficient time for Mr. Jerry D’Souza to plant the
contraband in his room.
4. We heard Sri Omkar Jayant Deshpande, AOR for
the State and Ms. Sana Raees Khan, learned Counsel
for the respondent.
Page 2 of 7

5. The AOR for the State argues that the High Court
strangely thought it fit to grant bail on the ground
that the Manager of the facility had unhindered
access to the room and hence prima facie there is
reason to believe that the respondent had not
committed the said offence as alleged. If such a
reasoning is accepted, then any recovery made from
a hotel or a rental facility cannot be pinned on the
person occupying the room or the facility. Since every
hotel has an alternate key with the management,
which is also used; even when in occupation, in the
absence of the occupants for cleaning purposes,
unless specifically prohibited by the occupants.
6. The learned Counsel for the respondent
specifically pointed out the counter affidavit filed by
the respondent and asserted that the respondent was
framed. The second respondent was taken into
custody, tortured and then taken to the room where
the contraband was planted. It is also argued that
even if the story of the prosecution is believed, the
apprehension was made from the basement of the
Air-B&B facility. There is nothing to show that he had
Page 3 of 7

been occupying room/flat No.106 in the facility. It is
contended that Mr. Jerry D’Souza had a lease
agreement of the premises and is in occupation of the
same and not the respondent.
7. We agree with the learned Counsel for the State
that if the reasoning adopted by the High Court is
accepted, then any recovery made from a hotel room
cannot be pinned on the occupant of the said room.
We have also looked at the counter affidavit, which
according to us demolishes the case set up by the
respondent. The FIR produced along with the appeal
and the search warrant produced as Annexure 2 in
the counter affidavit indicates the Raiding Officer
having intimated his superior on 22.01.2025 about a
reliable information of narcotic activities carried on by
the respondent, who is staying at the Air-B&B facility
at Helen Oasis in Room/Flat No.106. The Raiding
Officer had obtained the permission of the superior
officer to conduct house search as also obtained the
seal to secure the contraband.
8. The seizure report was made in the presence of
the Panch witnesses; Industries Inspector and a LDC
who accompanied the raiding team as also the
Page 4 of 7

Manager of the facility, Mr. Jerry D’Souza, which is
produced as Annexure 3. Annexure 4 is the medical
examination report of the accused on his arrest,
which indicates a burn injury on the forearm, which
was stated to have been caused with a lighter.
Though the exact age of injury could not be
determined, the doctor opined that it could have
occurred two days back. There was nothing stated by
the respondent as to the injury having been inflicted
by the police and the entire story set up of an arrest
two days back, plant of the narcotics in the room and
a bogus raid conducted prima facie does not impress
us.
9. Insofar as the occupancy of the premises
Annexure 6 Leave and License Agreement has been
projected. The owner of the premises had licensed it
to Mr. Jerry D’Souza who had specifically taken it for
commercial purposes. The agreement was dated
01.09.2024 and was applicable for a period of 7
months and it specifically indicates the licensee being
authorized to put the premises for commercial use on
daily basis whereas he would pay a monthly fee to
Page 5 of 7

the owner. The lease agreement though shows the
facility having been leased out by Mr. Jerry D’Souza,
the specific contention of the police as corroborated
by the Statement of Mr. Jerry D’Souza is that he had
rented out the premises to the petitioner from
17.01.2025 to 26.01.2025. It is within the period of
the said renting out and also within the license period
that the apprehension and recovery of contraband
was made from the premises.
10. We find absolutely no reason to sustain the
order granting bail and set aside the order passed by
the High Court impugned herein. We direct the
respondent to surrender within a period of three
weeks from today, failing which the respondent shall
be apprehended and produced before the
jurisdictional court for taking the said person into
judicial custody, subject only to the orders passed by
the said court for custody of police, if so required.
11. The appeal stands disposed of.
Page 6 of 7

12. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand
rejected.
.......…….……………………. J.
(J. B. PARDIWALA)
....……….……………………. J.
(K. VINOD CHANDRAN)
NEW DELHI;
NOVEMBER 16, 2026.
Page 7 of 7