N.C. ARYA SNUFF AND CIGAR CO. vs NICO QUALITY PRODUCTS
- Court
- Madras High Court
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Reserved on : 12.11.2026
Delivered on : 20.11.2026
CORAM :
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE N. SATHISH KUMAR
AND
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE GK.MUTHUKUMAAR
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
CNR:{HCMA010581502025}
AND
OSA(CAD) NO. 90 OF 2025, OSA(CAD) NO. 96 OF 2025,
CMP NO. 21700 OF 2025, CMP NO. 20580 OF 2025
CMP NO. 21739 OF 2025
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
M/s.N.C. Arya Snuff & Cigar Co.,
A partnership firm, represented by its partner
K.R.Ragurramun,
having office at
th
D-32, 7 Cross, West Extension,
Thillai Nagar, Trichy -18.
.. Appellant(s)
Vs
1. M/s.Nico Quality Products
A partnership firm, represented by its partner
K.C. Vijay,
st
1 Floor, No.4/1, Kandaswamy Street,
Chandrabagh Avenue, Mylapore,
Chennai – 600 004.
2. M/s.Sakthi Snuff & Co.,
Proprietorship concern,
represented by S. Karthikeyan, Proprietor,
193/2A, Thuraiyur Road, Nochiam,
Manachanallur Taluk, Trichy – 621 216.
__________
Page 1 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
3. M/s.Adhinayagam Agencies,
Partnership firm, represented by its partner
Su.Krishnadhas,
20/A, Thennur Main Road,
Thennur, Trichy - 17.
..Respondent(s)
OSA(CAD) No. 90 of 2025
CNR:{HCMA010581492025}
M/s. N.C. Arya Snuff & Cigar Co.,
Represented by its Partner K.R.Ragurramun,
19, Davidson Street, Chennai-600 001.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. M/s. Nico Quality Products,
Represented by its Partner K.C.Vijay,
st
1 Floor, No.4/1, Kandaswamy Street,
Chandrabagh Avenue, Mylapore,
Chennai-600 004.
2. M/s.Sakthi Snuff Co.,
Manufacturer for M/s N.C.Arya Snuff & Cigar
Co., Thuraiyur Road, Nochiyam,
Trichy-621 126.
3. M/s.Adinayagan Agencies
20-A, Tennur High Road,
Tennur, Trichy-17.
4. V. Shankar Amarnath
5. V. Sreenivasan
..Respondent(s)
[Cause title accepted vide Court order dated
05.08.2025 made in C.M.P.No.18678 of 2025 in
O.S.A.(CAD) SR No.40864 of 2025]
__________
Page 2 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
OSA(CAD) No. 96 of 2025
CNR:{HCMA010581512025}
M/s.N.C.Arya Snuff & Cigar Co.,
Represented by its partner KR. Ragurramun,
19, Davidson Street, Chennai - 600 001.
th
Residing at No. 32, 7 Cross Street,
West Extension, Thillainagar,
Trichy - 620 018.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. M/s.Nico Quality Products
Represented by its partner K.C.Vijay,
st
1 Floor, No.4/1, Kandaswamy Street,
Chandrabagh Avenue, Mylapore,
Chennai - 600 004.
2. K.C. Vijay
3. Zanakanabady
4. Anuradha
..Respondent(s)
[Cause title accepted vide Court order dated
26.08.2025 made in C.M.P.No.19513 of 2025 in
O.S.A.(CAD) SR No.40866 of 2025]
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
Original Side Appeal filed under Section 13 of the Commercial Courts
Act, 2015, to set aside the Judgment and decree passed by the learned Single
Judge of this Court in CS No.587 of 2015 dated 24.01.2025 and allow the
appeal.
__________
Page 3 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
OSA(CAD) No. 90 of 2025
Original Side Appeal filed under Section 13 of the Commercial Courts
Act, 2015 r/w. Order XXXVI Rule 9 of the Original Side Rules and Section 96
of the Code of Civil Procedure to set aside the Judgment and Decree passed by
the learned Single Judge of this Court in C.S.No.605 of 2013 dated 24.01.2025
and allow the Appeal.
OSA(CAD) No. 96 of 2025
Original Side Appeal filed under Section 13 of the Commercial Courts
Act, 2015 r/w. Order XXXVI Rule 9 of the Original Side Rules to set aside the
Judgement and Decree passed by the learned Single Judge of this Court in
CS.No.882 of 2013 dated 24.01.2025 and allow the appeal.
For Appellant (s): Mr.Sathish Parasaran
Senior Counsel
for Mr.G.Ramesh
in all Appeals
For Respondent(s): Mr.P.S.Raman
Senior Counsel
for Mr.Gautham S. Raman
for R1 in all Appeals
COMMON JUDGMENT
N. SATHISH KUMAR, J.
Challenging the common judgment and decree passed by the learned
Single Judge of this Court, dated 24.01.2025, in C.S.(Comm.Div) Nos.605, 882
of 2013 and 587 of 2015, the present three Appeals have been filed.
__________
Page 4 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
2.The suit in C.S.(Comm.Div.) No.605 of 2013 has been filed by
M/s.Nico Quality Products for (i) permanent injunction restraining the
defendant therein (M/s.N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar Company), its men, agents,
servants and persons acting on its behalf from infringing the plaintiff's
registered trade mark bearing Nos.454103, 454106, 454109, 592763, 180448,
180449, 559308, 178484, 179074 and 194656 in Class 34 in any manner either
by using the plaintiff's work mark and/or logo or otherwise in relation with the
products manufactured marketed by the defendant and (ii) for permanent
injunction from passing-off the products manufactured and marketed by them
using the plaintiff's trade mark or any other mark deceptively similar or closely
resembling the plaintiff's mark.
st
3.The suit in C.S.(Comm.Div.) No.882 of 2013 has been filed by the 1
defendant in the suit in C.S.(Comm.Div.) No.605 of 2013, namely N.C.Arya
Snuff and Cigar Company for (i) a declaration declaring that the Deed of
Assignment dated 15.12.2011 as illegal, null and void and non-est in the eye of
law; (ii) for permanent injunction restraining the defendant (Nico Quality
Products), its men, agents, servants or persons acting on its behalf from
infringing the plaintiff's registered trade mark bearing Nos.454103, 454106,
454109, 592763, 180448, 180449, 559308, 178484, 179074 and 194656 in
__________
Page 5 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
Class 34 in any manner or otherwise in relation with the products manufactured
and marketed by the defendant and (iii) for permanent injunction restraining
from passing-off the products manufactured and marketed by them using the
plaintiff's trade mark.
4.N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar Company has also filed a suit in C.S.
(Comm.Div.) No.587 of 2015 for a permanent injunction restraining the
defendant (Nico Quality Products) from passing-off the product manufactured
and marketed by them using the schedule mentioned trade marks or other marks
deceptively similar or closely resembling the plaintiff's mark in any manner,
either by using the plaintiff's work mark or logo more fully described in the
schedule thereunder or otherwise in relation with the products manufactured and
marketed by the defendant.
5.Since the suit in C.S.(Comm.Div.) No.882 of 2013 filed by
M/s.N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar Company is a comprehensive suit seeking
declaration in respect of the Assignment Deed dated 15.12.2011 as null and
void, we are of the view that the parties shall be referred to as per their ranking
in the said suit in C.S.(Comm.Div.) No.882 of 2013 for convenience. In other
words, M/s.N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar Company will hereinafter be referred as
“the plaintiff” and M/s.Nico Quality Products and its partners will hereinafter be
__________
Page 6 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
referred to as “the defendant”.
6.The case of the plaintiff in C.S.(Comm.Div.) No.882 of 2013 is as
follows :
6.1.The plaintiff firm is involved in the business of manufacturing, selling
and dealing with the Snuff and Cigar for several decades. The business includes
manufacturing, branding and selling the whole-sale stock of cigars, snuffs,
agarbathis, scented sticks and perfumes, etc. The family of the plaintiff
comprises of one S.Chandrasekaran and his brother S.Viswanathan and the
business was flourishing one and N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar Company has its
business all over India. With the careful stewardship of Chandrasekaran, who is
the elder member of the family, the business touched new horizon and the name
of N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar Company became a reputed one and established
trade mark for the products like agarbathis, scented sticks and perfumes, etc.
There is a specific reputation and value attached to the brand name of
M/s.N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar Company in the trading market.
6.2.While that being so, the members of the family decided to constitute a
partnership firm in order to carry out the aforesaid business in the name and
style of “N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar Company” and accordingly, a partnership
deed was executed between S.Chandrasekaran and S.Thara, who is the wife of
__________
Page 7 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
his brother Viswanathan. Since the business started to expand and diversify, it
was thought and necessary to induct one more partner in the business.
th
Therefore, the 4 defendant, namely Anuradha, who is the daughter of
Viswanathan and Thara, was inducted as a partner in the business by virtue of a
partnership agreement deed, dated 01.04.1995 and 18.06.1998. As per the said
partnership agreement, the profits and losses of the business were agreed to be
divided and apportioned among the three partners as follows :
th
S.Chandrasekaran – 40%; Thara – 35%; and 4 defendant Anuradha : 25%.
th
6.3.After induction of the 4 defendant, the other two partners of the
th
plaintiff firm namely, Chandrasekaran and Thara, were marginalised and the 4
defendant, being the young blood, wanted to lead the business. The said two
partners of the plaintiff, namely, Chandrasekaran and Thara, who were all along
by their business shrewdness, patience, acumen and experience to build up the
th
business, were marginalised by the 4 defendant. The said two partners of the
plaintiff, i.e., Chandrasekaran and Thara, considering the relationship and also
considering the fact that a fresh approach would jet pack the business to new
th
horizon, agreed for the 4 defendant to conduct and lead the business.
th
However, the business came to a cropper under the management of the 4
defendant. The reputed partnership name N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar Company
had to undergo heavy financial crisis because of the rash decisions and
__________
Page 8 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
th
mismanagement of the 4 defendant. After a couple of years, the roaring
business and the Company, which is an undisputed leader in India in the field of
snuff and cigar, had lost the name due to the reckless mismanagement and the
th
unwanted ventures of the 4 defendant. The Company faced heavy financial
crisis and at one point of time, it became almost impossible to retrieve and
rescue the business. There were several people who had given huge amount of
loan and also supplied raw materials on credit basis.
6.4.On seeing that the traditional family brand of M/s.N.C.Arya Snuff and
th
Cigar Company would collapse under the management of the 4 defendant, the
other two partners of the plaintiff Company, i.e., Chandrasekaran and Thara,
th
who had voluntarily kept quiet and have given the space for the 4 defendant to
th
lead, intervened in the business in order to rescue the same. The 4 defendant,
by that time, had realised that the business has crashed down only on account of
th
the fault on her part and further, the 4 defendant, being a married lady and also
having a family, felt it difficult to face the creditors. Therefore, she wanted to
th
wash her hands off the partnership business. The 4 defendant further
rd
apprehended that her husband, the 3 defendant and son would also be put into
th
trouble by the creditors if she decided to continue in the firm. Therefore, the 4
rd
defendant and her husband (3 defendant) executed separate affidavits making
it amply clear that they are no longer associated with the partnership firm,
__________
Page 9 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
th
namely N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar Company. The 4 defendant executed an
affidavit to that effect on 10.08.2012 in the presence of Notary Public at
Pondicherry stating that she has retired from the partnership, namely,
M/s.N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar Company with effect from 30.06.2012 on the
assurance given by the other two partners of the plaintiff, namely
S.Chandrasekaran and Thara that they will undertake the liability and absorb the
same. Similarly, she has also relinquished all her rights over the trade marks
th rd
and business from 01.07.2012. The husband of the 4 defendant, namely the 3
defendant, has also executed similar affidavit to that effect on 10.08.2012. That
apart, a fresh partnership agreement was executed on 01.07.2012, in which also,
th
the 4 defendant signed as a retiring partner. Thus, it is crystal clear that the
partnership firm, namely, N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar Company shall comprise of
only two partners, namely, S.Chandrasekaran and S.Thara.
th
6.5.After the 4 defendant retired from the Company, the two partners of
the plaintiff firm took all efforts to settle the creditors in order to run the
business smoothly and their attempt to settle the creditors, reputation and brand
name, had been resolved by the hard work of the two partners, namely,
S.Chandrasekaran and Thara. After several rounds of negotiations and efforts,
the creditors were settled at the instance of the said partners of the Company.
The business of the plaintiff started to gain momentum and the brand name of
__________
Page 10 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
the plaintiff firm had been reactivated. The re-emergence of the plaintiff,
namely N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar Company was only due to the hard work of
the two partners of the plaintiff, namely, S.Chandrasekaran and S.Thara. After
witnessing that the plaintiff firm, namely N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar Company,
th
flourishing in the market, the 4 defendant wanted to take a share in the credits
th rd
and profits. The 4 defendant and her husband 3 defendant, having
relinquished their rights in sharing the credits and participating in the Company
by virtue of the above said affidavits and deed, colluded together and attempted
to pass off the trade marks of the plaintiff Company with the help of her
st
brother-in-law in the name of one M/s.Nico Quality Products (1 defendant).
Therefore, the plaintiff immediately lodged a Police complaint and a search was
th
also conducted by the concerned Police. The 4 defendant issued a legal notice
th
dated 24.07.2013 to hand over the management of the plaintiff firm to the 4
defendant.
th rd
6.6.While that being the situation, the 4 defendant and 3 defendant
colluded together and brought out several forged documents to claim ownership
in respect of the trade marks registered in the name of the plaintiff firm,
including (i) an authorisation letter dated 27.10.2011 as if the partners of the
th
plaintiff, namely S.Chandrasekaran and S.Thara, had authorised the 4
defendant to assign the trade marks; and (ii) an assignment deed dated
__________
Page 11 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
15.12.2011 as if 10 trade marks of the plaintiff firm were assigned to M/s.Nico
st nd
Quality Products (1 defendant) represented by its partners one K.V.Vijay (2
rd
defendant) and one Z.Gnanakanabady (3 defendant). Based on the said
documents, the suit in C.S.(Comm.Div.) No.605 of 2013 came to be filed by the
st
1 defendant.
6.7.However, according to the plaintiff, the alleged authorisation letter
th
issued to the 4 defendant, dated 27.10.2011, is a rank forgery and it is their
case that the signature in the said authorisation letter is found at the bottom of
the page, whereas, the contents in the document is only of four lines, which is
typed on the top of the page. There is a large gap between the contents of the
letter and the signatures of the other two partners. It is the contention of the
th
plaintiff that, while the 4 defendant was in-charge of the Company, the two
partners namely S.Chandrasekaran and S.Thara used to give blank signed
th
papers to the creditors and therefore, there is a possibility for the 4 defendant
to misuse those signed blank papers for fabricating the alleged authorisation
letter. Therefore, according to the plaintiff, the so-called authorisation letter
said to have been issued by the remaining partners namely S.Chandrasekaran
and S.Thara on 27.10.2011 is a fabricated one.
__________
Page 12 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
rd st
6.8.Further, the 3 defendant, who is one of the partners of the 1
defendant firm namely M/s.Nico Quality Products, is none other than the
th
husband of the 4 defendant. The deed of assignment dated 15.12.2011 recites
st
as if a huge sum of Rs.75 Lakhs is alleged to have been paid by the 1 defendant
th
firm in favour of the 4 defendant in cash and the receipt of which is stated to
th
have been acknowledged by the 4 defendant. According to the plaintiff, the
cash transfer exceeding Rs.20,000/- ought to have made only through
cheque/demand draft or bills under the Income Tax Rules at the relevant point
of time. Hence, according to the plaintiff, the deed of assignment, dated
15.12.2011, is a manufactured one subsequent to the raid at Pondicherry.
6.9.Further, it is the contention of the plaintiff that the so-called
assignment deed has not been properly stamped. Further, as per Section 42 of
the Trade Marks Act, any assignment without goodwill of the business should
be presented for advertisement and registration within a period of six months
from the date of assignment, failing which, the assignment shall not have any
effect. In the present case, even according to the defendants, the assignment
was presented for registration only on 19.08.2013, nearly 18 months after the
date of assignment. Hence, according to the plaintiff, the authorisation letter
dated 27.10.2011 is a rank forgery and the assignment deed is also not valid in
__________
Page 13 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
the eye of law. Hence, the plaintiff firm, namely M/s.N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar
Company, filed the suit in C.S.(Comm.Div.) No.882 of 2013 seeking
declaration of the assignment deed, dated 15.12.2011, as illegal, null and void
and non-est in the eye of law.
7.1.A written statement has been filed by the defendants 1 and 2 in the
said suit in C.S.(Comm.Div.) No.882 of 2013. According to the defendants 1
st
and 2 (M/s.Nico Quality Products), the 1 defendant Company originally started
nd
as a partnership firm consisting of one Vijay (2 defendant) and
rd st
Gnanakanabady (3 defendant) as partners of the 1 defendant firm in the year
2010, which is engaged in the business of manufacturing, marketing and supply
of snuff and allied products in India and abroad, registered on 17.10.2013 under
the Societies Registration Act. On 06.11.2014, one of the partners, namely
rd st
Gnanakanabady (3 defendant) resigned from the 1 defendant firm by deed of
dissolution and thereby, he relinquished all his rights in the suit trade marks
including the copyrights in the artistic works upon receipt of his settlement
nd st
amount. Thus, the 2 defendant Vijay became the sole proprietor of the 1
defendant firm and also the present owner of the trade mark exclusively.
st
7.2.According to the defendants, the proprietor of the 1 defendant firm,
Vijay, was introduced to the plaintiff's partners by his close friend one
__________
Page 14 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
nd
Srinivasan, who is the son of Thara. Since Vijay (2 defendant) was normally
of very helpful character, he was approached by S.Chandrasekaran and S.Thara
nd
and Anuradha to help them to clear their various debts. The 2 defendant also
agreed to help, owing to his close association with the plaintiff's family. Since
nd
the plaintiff's partners had authorised the 2 defendant to deal with the Banks in
nd
December, 2011 to clear their loans, the 2 defendant had approached various
Banks on behalf of the plaintiff firm as their representative to clear their debts.
The defendant received e-mail communications from various Banks
acknowledging/recognizing him (Vijay) as the representative of the plaintiff for
clearing their debts. In spite of his best efforts to help the plaintiff firm, the
large scale losses and debts made saving the plaintiff's business impossible.
Various factories of the plaintiff had been closed down and their sales tax
registration was cancelled. It was during that time, the partners of the plaintiff
firm offered the defendant to take on assignment of their 10 trade marks and
that the consideration amount for those 10 trade marks could be used for
clearing the plaintiff's debts and also suggested that the defendant could start a
nd
new business venture using their 10 trade marks. Since the 2 defendant had no
rd
experience in the Snuff industry, the plaintiff had recommended the 3
nd
defendant namely, Z.Gnanakanabady, to Vijay (2 defendant) to take him as
partner to start a new business venture. The said Gnanakanabady, who is the
husband of Anuradha, has experience in running a snuff business as he already
had a firm which manufactures and sells tobacco and snuff products called 'Nico
__________
Page 15 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
allied Products' at Puducherry. Hence, the partners of the plaintiff firm
convinced Vijay to jointly start a business with the said Gnanakanabady after
buying the trade marks namely 454103, 454106, 454109, 592763, 180448,
180449, 559308, 178484, 179074 and 194656.
7.3.Accordingly, the plaintiff firm had executed an assignment deed on
st
15.12.2011 in favour of the 1 defendant firm transferring the above mentioned
10 trade marks. As per the said deed of assignment, the defendants have
acquired all benefits of the 10 trade marks including good will associated with
nd
the trade marks. The 2 defendant, after obtaining the assignment from the
plaintiff vide the assignment deed dated 15.12.2011, had invested huge money
in promoting the brand and in fact, gave new life to the brand in the market.
st
According to the defendants, the assignment deed made in favour of the 1
defendant is valid and appropriate stamp duty has also been paid. Subsequently,
rd
by virtue of another assignment deed from the 3 defendant, who was the
st nd
partner of the 1 defendant, the 2 defendant has become the sole owner of the
nd
mark. The 2 defendant has also filed appropriate request before the trademark
nd
office in FORM TM-24 to record the assignments. The 2 defendant has also
filed renewals of the trade marks and renewed it accordingly.
__________
Page 16 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
7.4.At that point of time, the plaintiff’s Bank accounts maintained at
M/s.Axis Bank, Barclays Bank and other accounts had all been frozen. Hence,
the plaintiff’s partners requested that if the defendants were to issue cheque
payments to them, the amount would be appropriated by their Banks for long
overdue loan accounts and requested the defendant to pay a sum of Rs.75 Lakhs
to the plaintiff firm in cash as consideration for making the assignment deed
dated 15.12.2011. Due to the cordial relationship the defendant had with the
plaintiff firm and believing the plaintiff’s partners, the defendant made
arrangements and agreed to pay the said amount. Accordingly, the said deed of
th
assignment was duly executed by the plaintiff’s firm and Anuradha (4
defendant) as a partner acted as the authorised representative of the plaintiff
firm. When the defendant asked the plaintiff about the proof of authorisation,
he was furnished with the authorisation letter, dated 27.10.2011, wherein all the
partners of the plaintiff firm namely S.Chandrasekaran and S.Thara had given
an authority in favour of the said Anuradha to execute the assignment deed.
After being satisfied with the letter of authorisation, the defendant paid the
consideration in cash to the partner of the plaintiff’s firm V.Anuradha. Vijay,
st
the proprietor of the 1 defendant, was personally aware that the sum handed
over in person to the said Anuradha was received with the knowledge and
consent of the other partners of the plaintiff firm and the said amount went
__________
Page 17 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
towards settling several creditors of the plaintiff firm who were paid in cash.
The defendant is having sufficient proof for payment of consideration to the
plaintiff.
7.5.Upon payment of the entire consideration, the partners of the plaintiff
firm, viz, S.Chandrasekaran and S.Thara issued the letters dated 20.12.2011
individually addressed to the defendant and thereby, confirming the receipt of
st
Rs.75 Lakhs as consideration for assigning the trade marks in favour of the 1
defendant. It is the case of the defendants that a total sum of Rs.75 Lakhs was
paid by the defendant. A sum of Rs.45 Lakhs was generated by Vijay, whereas,
his partner Gnanaganabady had contributed Rs.30 Lakhs. This sum has been
declared in the Books of Accounts of the defendant firm and further, it is their
case that, both of the partners of the defendant firm can individually show the
sources of the funds.
7.6.It is the contention of the defendants that, even after the execution of
the assignment deed, the plaintiff firm was taking time to furnish the original
certificates pertaining to the said trade marks due to the reason that the plaintiff
was facing problems with their creditors. The plaintiff, by letter dated
21.06.2012, represented by their partner S.Chandrasekaran sent to the
defendant, explained their difficulty in furnishing the original trade mark
__________
Page 18 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
certificates to the defendant, stating that, since the plaintiff’s creditors had
locked the factory, their partners were unable to enter into the premises and
retrieve the original trade mark certificates. In the said letter, the partner of the
plaintiff had further requested the defendant to lend a further sum of Rs.20
Lakhs to them to clear their debts and also gave blank cheque signed by the
partner of the plaintiff towards security for arranging the said loan amount of
Rs.20 Lakhs. Even after the execution of the assignment deed, the plaintiff's
firm had various stocks in trade with regard to the assigned marks, and hence,
they had orally requested the defendant to wait for 12 to 18 months to clear their
stocks. They then agreed to hand over the original certificates for the assigned
marks in order to facilitate the defendant to run the new business without any
hindrance. According to the defendant, they had to wait till the plaintiff cleared
their stocks.
7.7.Thereafter, the defendant submitted the assigned marks to the
th
Registrar of Trade Marks on 14 August 2013. Since the trademarks were
assigned along with the goodwill associated with the marks, the defendant filed
Form TM-24 under Section 45 of the Trade Marks Act for the change of the
registered owner to the name of the defendant firm. Meanwhile, the defendant
started its business by contacting dealers and distributors across India and also
started manufacturing products under the assigned marks from August 2013.
__________
Page 19 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
st st
Accordingly, the 1 defendant consignment was dispatched on 21 May 2013
from the defendant's factory at Puducherry to one T. Balaji, a distributor in
Andhra Pradesh. When the defendant started distributing its products in the
market, they were shocked to find that the plaintiff's firm was still continuing to
manufacture and distribute the products already assigned to the defendant, even
after the time undertaken by the plaintiff to clear their stocks had expired.
st
Therefore, the 1 defendant firm (assignee) filed a suit in C.S.(Comm.Div.)
No.605 of 2013 against the plaintiff herein for infringement based on the deed
of assignment given by the plaintiff on 15.12.2011 in respect of the 10 trade
marks.
8.The plaintiff filed C.S. (Comm.Div.) No.882 of 2013 challenging the
very assignment deed and the letter of authorisation on the ground that the same
has been fabricated and forged and also for permanent injunction from
infringement. The plaintiff in C.S.(Comm.Div.)No.882 of 2013 also filed
another suit in C.S.(Comm.Div.) No.587 of 2015 for passing-off.
9.Since the pleadings in the comprehensive suit in C.S.
(Comm.Div.)No.882 of 2013 are sufficient for the disposal of the Appeals, we
are of the view that the pleadings made in the other two suits need not be
elaborated once again in order to avoid repetition since same allegations are
__________
Page 20 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
pressed into service in the other two suits also.
10.Based on the pleadings of the parties, the learned Single Judge has
framed the following issues in C.S.(Comm.Div.)Nos.605 and 882 of 2013 :
i. Whether the letter of authorization dated 09.12.2011 executed in
favour of Anuradha is genuine or forged?
ii. Whether the deed of assignment dated 15.12.2011 is genuine,
forged or concocted?
st
iii.Whether the 1 defendant in C.S.No.882 of 2013 use of the
assigned trademarks, amounts to infringement and passing off?
iv.Whether the trademarks mentioned in the deed of assignment are
assigned with or without the goodwill associated with the mark ?
v. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the relief claimed in the suits ?
and
vi.To what other reliefs?
11.The learned Single Judge has framed the following issues in C.S.
(Comm.Div.) No.587 of 2015 :
i. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to maintain a joint suit for
passing off?
ii. Whether the defendant attempted to pass off its products as that of
the plaintiffs’ by adopting a deceptively similar trademark?
iii.Whether the pendency of the suits in C.S.Nos.605 of 2013 and 882
__________
Page 21 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
of 2013, in which the assignment alleged to have been executed by
the plaintiffs in favour of the defendant is being questioned, would
operate as a bar for the plaintiffs prosecuting this suit?
iv.Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to the injunction as prayed for ?
and
v. To what other reliefs are the parties entitled to ?
12.In all the three suits, a joint trial was conducted, and evidence was
recorded in C.S.(Comm.Div.)No.605 of 2013. On the side of the plaintiffs,
P.W.1 to P.W.3 were examined, and Exs.P1 to P31 were marked. On the side of
the defendants, D.W.1 and D.W.2 were examined, and Exs.D1 to D13 were
marked.
13.On the basis of the pleadings and the oral and documentary evidence
on record, the learned Single Judge, by the common judgment and decree dated
24.01.2025, dismissed the suits filed by the plaintiff firm (M/s.N.C.Arya Snuff
and Cigar Company) viz., C.S.(Comm.Div.)Nos.882 of 2013 and 587 of 2015
for declaration of the deed of assignment dated 15.12.2011 as null and void and
also for infringement and passing off, however, decreed the suit filed by the
st
assignee (1 defendant) viz., C.S.(Comm.Div.)No.605 of 2013 in favour of the
assignee for infringement of the trademarks and passing off of the goods.
__________
Page 22 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
14.Aggrieved by the common judgment and decree of the learned Single
Judge, the present appeals have been filed by M/s.N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar
Company.
15.1.Mr.Sathish Parasaran, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
appellant, would submit that the learned Single Judge has not properly
appreciated the evidence. The deed of assignment dated 15.12.2011 was
brought about by collusion between the daughter of D.W.2 (Thara) namely
Anuradha, her husband Gnanakanabady and Vijay. According to him, Vijay, in
whose favour the trademarks are said to have been assigned, is a stranger to the
family. According to him, the so-called authorisation letter dated 27.10.2011
(Ex.P2) itself clearly shows that the document has been created by ante-dating it
using the blank signatures of the partners. Further, it is his contention that the
assignment deed dated 15.12.2011 (Ex.P3) shows as if a sum of Rs.75 lakhs had
been paid as consideration for the 10 trademarks of the appellant. Absolutely,
there is no evidence, whatsoever, to show that the sum of Rs.75 lakhs had been
paid. In the absence of any evidence to show payment of such a huge
consideration, the very deed of assignment ought not to have been relied upon
by the learned Single Judge. According to him, the original trademark
registration certificates are still with the appellant. Therefore, the very deed of
__________
Page 23 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
assignment (Ex.P3) cannot be relied upon.
15.2.The learned Senior Counsel would further submit that, admittedly,
Anuradha was in charge of the appellant firm's business. During the period
when she was in charge, the appellant firm had witnessed a downfall and she
had also retired from the firm with effect from 01.07.2012 as per Ex.D7
(Partnership Agreement). Though she had signed the partnership agreement as
a retiring partner, she has never whispered anything about the alleged
authorisation letter or the deed of assignment in favour of Vijay. This fact
creates serious doubt about the very authorisation letter and the assignment
deed.
15.3.Further, it is his contention that the deed of assignment (Ex.P3)
shows as if a sum of Rs.75 lakhs had been paid in cash, which is totally
improbable. According to him, any cash payment exceeding Rs.2 Lakhs ought
to have been made only by way of a bank transaction. Absolutely, there is no
evidence on the part of the assignee to show the source of the sum of Rs.75
lakhs. The cross-examination of P.W.1 clearly shows that he was not even in a
position to name the persons from whom he had allegedly mobilised the funds.
This fact has not been considered by the learned Single Judge. Therefore, he
would submit that Ex.P3 ought not to have been believed by the learned Single
__________
Page 24 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
Judge. Hence, according to him, after a police complaint was lodged against
Anuradha and her husband, the documents, namely, Exs.P3 and P4 should have
been created subsequently. It is his contention that the possibility of the said
Anuradha creating these documents in collusion with her husband and the said
Vijay cannot be ruled out. However, these aspects have not been considered by
the learned Single Judge.
15.4.Further, the learned Senior Counsel would submit that, even
assuming without admitting, that there was a deed of assignment in favour of
Vijay on 15.12.2011, the assignment had not been registered within a period of
six months, as mandated under Section 42 of the Trade Marks Act. This itself
clearly shows that the entire deed of assignment relied upon by the respondent
herein was created only for the purpose of knocking out the business.
Admittedly, the respondent has also been carrying on the manufacture of snuff
and cigarette products in the course of its business. Hence, he would submit
that the learned Single Judge has not appreciated the entire evidence.
15.5.The learned Senior Counsel would further submit that the appellant
firm was originally run by two partners, namely, Chandrasekaran and Tara. The
goods were marketed and the business acquired a wide reputation in the field.
th
After the said Anuradha, the 4 defendant, was inducted, she was fully entrusted
__________
Page 25 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
with the responsibility of managing the business. Hence, she has taken
advantage of the blank signatures of the other partners, who were none other
than her mother and uncle, and along with her husband, she had ante-dated and
created those documents. Therefore, for all these reasons, the learned Senior
Counsel would submit that the judgment of the learned Single Judge has to be
set aside and the appellant is entitled not only to a declaration but also to an
injunction against infringement of their 10 trade marks.
16.1.Whereas, Mr.P.S.Raman, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
respondents, would submit that Vijay was known to Anuradha's husband and
was a successful businessman. According to the learned Senior Counsel, the
firm of the appellant had become defunct. No business was being carried on and
their bank accounts had been frozen. In fact, from 2012 to 2014, no sales had
taken place. Even in the suit filed in C.S.(Comm.Div.)No. 587 of 2015, there
was no pleading with regard to the turnover of the business. The TIN and GST
registrations of the appellant had become defunct and no business activities had
been carried out by them.
16.2.It is his contention that the entire issue revolves only around the
disputed documents, namely, Exs.P2, P3 and P4. However, absolutely, there is
no denial with regard to Exs.P20, P22 to P27. Ex.P20, which is a letter dated
__________
Page 26 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
21.06.2012 addressed by the partner of the appellant firm to Vijay, not only
confirms the assignment in favour of Vijay, but also shows that he had further
requested another sum of Rs.20 lakhs and authorised Vijay to clear the loans. In
fact, the payments have been made by Vijay to the Banks which is evident from
the documents Exs.P23 to P25. These facts have not been denied.
16.3.The learned Senior Counsel would further submit that the evidence
of D.W.2 (Thara) clearly shows that the entire firm was under the control of
Anuradha. She was actively dealing with the firm's business and had executed
various assignments with proper authorisation from the other partners. When
the authorisation is also accepted and the subsequent correspondence is taken
into consideration, it is improbable to contend that the assignment had not been
acted upon. Hence, he would submit that, if any of the partners is in charge of or
actively dealing with the partnership business, any act done by such partner as
an agent of the firm, law presumes implied authority for such acts, which binds
the firm. In any event, the correspondence from the other partner, who was an
elder member of the family, clearly shows that the deed of assignment was
known to the other partners and that they had accepted the same. Therefore, it is
unbelievable that the assignment deed is being challenged at this stage,
particularly when it has already been acted upon.
__________
Page 27 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
16.4.The learned Senior Counsel would submit that based on the
trademarks assigned, the business has been developed by the respondents.
Further, it is his contention that, merely because the assignor/Anuradha retired
from the partnership at a later point of time, that would not take away the rights
of the assignee, as the assignment had been made with proper authorisation.
16.5.Further, it is his contention that the evidence of D.W.2 also clearly
shows that she had admitted her signature in Ex.P4. Therefore, once the
signature is admitted, the question of forgery does not arise at all. Forgery and
fabrication cannot go together. In the absence of any evidence to the contrary
and considering the entire circumstances, including the admission by D.W.2,
who was the other original partner, with regard to her signature in the
documents, and the fact that the other documents under Exs.P20 to P25, which
have not been denied or challenged in any manner, acknowledge not only the
assignment but also the receipt of cash, the learned Single Judge was right in
dismissing the suit filed by the appellant firm for declaration of the deed of
assignment as null and void and in decreeing the suit filed by the respondent
firm for infringement and passing off in favour of the assignee. The learned
Single Judge was also right in dismissing the suit filed by the appellant for
infringement and passing off.
__________
Page 28 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
16.6.Further, it is his contention that the very deed of assignment
indicates that the assignment was not confined merely to the trademarks but also
included all the benefits associated with them. According to him, such benefits
include goodwill. Therefore, once all the marks had been assigned along with
all the benefits and the good will, registration under Section 42 was not
required.
16.7.It is his further contention that the Income Tax amendment relating
to cash transactions came into effect only from 01.04.2017 and that, prior to that
date, there was no specific ban or prohibition on cash transactions. Further,
when the parties themselves had spoken about the cash transaction and
acknowledged receipt of the amount, it cannot be said that the assignment deed
was invalid in the eye of law merely because the consideration was paid in cash.
Further, the deed of assignment (Ex.P3) is admittedly in writing. It is
unconditional and is also supported by consideration and the assignment relates
to specific trademarks. Therefore, the assignment is valid in the eye of law.
16.8.Therefore, the learned Senior Counsel prayed for dismissal of these
Appeals. In support of his arguments, he relied upon the following two
judgments :
__________
Page 29 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
i. The Commissioners of Inland Revenue v. Muller & Co.’s
Margarine Limited [House of Lords H.L.(E) 1901 May 20
ii. T.I.Muhammad Zumoon Sahib v. Fathimunnisssa alias Bibijan
and others [1959 72 L.W. 620]
17.In the light of the above submissions, the points that now arise for
consideration in these appeals are as follows:
i. Whether the authorisation letter dated 27.10.2011 (Ex.P2) and the
deed of assignment dated 15.12.2011 (Ex.P3) are a result of
fabrication or forgery?
st
ii. Whether the deed of assignment in favour of the respondent/1
defendant in C.S.(Comm.Div.)No.882 of 2013 is valid in the eye of
law?
iii.Whether there is any infringement of trademarks by the
respondent herein?
iv. Whether the appellant is entitled to a permanent injunction from
passing off?
v. To what other reliefs are the parties entitled?
18.We have perused the entire materials available on record.
Point Nos.(i) and (ii) :
19.On a perusal of the records, it is not in dispute that the original family
partnership of the appellant firm consisted of Chandrasekaran, Thara and
__________
Page 30 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
Anuradha in the year 1995 for carrying on the business of manufacturing,
selling and dealing in snuff and cigarettes for several decades. It is also the
admitted case of the plaintiff who challenged the assignment that Thara
(D.W.2)’s daughter, namely, Anuradha, was inducted as a partner in the
business by virtue of the partnership deeds dated 01.04.1995 and 18.06.1998.
They had agreed that the profits and losses would be shared in the ratio of 40%
by Chandrasekaran, 35% by Thara and 25% by Anuradha. It is relevant to note
that Chandrasekaran is the elder member of the family, and Thara is the wife of
Viswanathan, the brother of the said Chandrasekaran. Anuradha is the daughter
of Thara. These facts are not in dispute.
20.It is also an undisputed fact that, after the induction of Anuradha, the
entire partnership business was carried on by her and she was in charge of the
firm. In this regard, the evidence of D.W.2 (Thara), one of the original partners
who was alive and had given evidence, is also relevant. In the cross-
examination, in answer to Question No.7, she categorically admitted that, due to
her advanced age, they had voluntarily entrusted the business responsibilities to
Anuradha. She had also admitted in answer to Question No.6 that Anuradha
took over the management of the business and ran it by taking her own
decisions. Her evidence also clearly shows that, since D.W.2 (Thara) and
Chandrasekaran were growing old and had become marginalised, they had
__________
Page 31 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
entrusted the responsibility of managing the business to Anuradha. She had also
admitted that Anuradha was put in charge of the snuff business. Further, it is
her case that, only after Anuradha took charge of the business, the business had
seen a downfall. Further, the evidence of D.W.2 also shows that all the other
businesses had already been closed and that the other trademarks had no value.
They had not renewed the other trademarks. Therefore, from her evidence and
the pleadings, it is clearly established that, though Chandrasekaran and Thara
were partners, Anuradha was in charge of the affairs of the firm. Therefore, as
per Section 19 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, she had the implied
authority as agent of the firm, whereby, any act of a partner which is done to
carry on, in the usual way, business of the kind carried on by the firm, binds the
firm.
21.It is the contention of the appellant/plaintiff in the lead suit, namely,
C.S.(Comm.Div.) No.882 of 2013, that Anuradha had retired from the firm only
to escape liability towards the creditors. Her husband was also excluded and an
affidavit was executed expressing that he was not connected with the firm.
However, though much reliance has been placed on Ex.D7 (partnership
agreement) in which the said Anuradha had signed as a retiring partner, the
entire issue revolves around the deed of assignment (Ex.P3) executed by
Anuradha while she was in charge of the firm.
__________
Page 32 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
22.It is the case of the appellant that the deed of assignment (Ex.P3) is the
result of forgery and fabrication. According to them, the authorisation letter
(Ex.P2), said to have been issued by the other partners, was antedated and
created by using their signatures. It is their contention that there is a large gap
between the contents and the signature in Ex.P2 and hence, there is a possibility
of the said Anuradha creating the document by using the blank signatures of
other partners, while she was in charge of the firm. Though the said contention
appears probable at the first blush, considering all the other documents,
particularly Exs.P4, P20, P22 to P27, we are of the view that the contention
cannot be countenanced for the following reasons.
23.The suits have proceeded mainly on the ground that Exs.P2 and P3
were forged and fabricated. Much emphasis has been made on Ex.P2
(authorisation letter). It is relevant to note that forgery and fabrication cannot
travel together. Having pleaded two mutually destructive pleas, the plaintiff has
not chosen to elect either one. Be that as it may.
24.On a careful perusal of Ex.P2 (authorisation letter), the signatures of
both the partners, Chandrasekaran and Thara, are very much available. D.W.2
(Thara) has admitted her signature in Ex.P2 in the cross-examination. The
__________
Page 33 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
dispute is with regard to the signature of Chandrasekaran alone. Once the plea
of forgery is taken by the plaintiff, it is for them to establish the forgery in the
manner known to law. The burden lies on the party who sets up the plea of
forgery. Having taken a mutually inconsistent plea of fabrication, the plaintiff in
C.S.(Comm.Div) No.882 of 2013 would contend that, since the gap between the
contents of the letter and the signatures in Ex.P2 is large, with the signatures
appearing at the bottom and the contents appearing only at the top, there is a
possibility that the document was created by antedating it. It is relevant to note
that, even assuming that such a contention appears reasonable, the fact remains
that Ex.P4, the letter dated 20.12.2011 addressed by the original partners
st
Chandrasekaran and Thara to the 1 defendant firm, contains absolutely no gap,
whatsoever, between the signatures and the contents. In fact, both the partners
addressed a letter to M/s.Nico Quality Products, wherein they have clearly
admitted the assignment in respect of the trademarks and also acknowledged the
receipt of consideration of Rs.75 Lakhs on behalf of the firm, namely,
M/s.N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar Company.
25.Further, though the entire attack was made only with regard to Exs.P2
and P3, absolutely no denial, whatsoever, was made in respect of Ex.P20, the
letter addressed to K.C.Vijay, which clearly shows that it was signed by one of
the partners, Chandrasekaran, on behalf of the plaintiff company. It is relevant
__________
Page 34 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
to extract the said letter dated 21.06.2012 as under :
“ Our office at No.19, Davidson St., Chennai-600 001 was
lastly occupied by the Company during Nov. 2011. There after
unfortunately, one of the creditors have put their lock over the lock
of the Company. As a result, now the premises is inaccessible to us.
Therefore, we are unable to retrieve the original trademark
Certificate which were assigned to you. We assure you that we will
hand it over to you at the earliest. After we have resolved this issue
with the creditors we would also like you to conduct business from
the said premises to which we are sentimentally attached and have
been conducting business for the past so many decades.
Incidentally it is a fact that the commercial tax department of
West Bengal has issued a huge tax due and which you all aware
off. If we do not clear the tax dues, it would not be possible for us
to conduct business in Bengal as most of our business is done here.
We were able to meet some very pressing demands from the
payments received from you, but we were unable to clear the tax
demand.
Therefore I kindly request you one last time to lend us a sum
of rupees 20,00,000 (Rupees Twenty Lakhs only) to clear pressing
debts. I have also enclosed blank cheque a Security. Lending us
this amount will help us conduct Business and clear the stock. So
that we can hand over the business as agreed between us.
Thanking you ”
__________
Page 35 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
The above letter (Ex.P20) addressed by one of the partners of the plaintiff firm
not only confirms the assignment in favour of Vijay, but also records the
agreement to hand over the original trademark certificates after retrieving them
from the premises that had been locked down by the creditors. That apart, by the
said letter, the company also sought further financial assistance of Rs.20 lakhs
from the said Vijay. Along with the letter, a blank cheque bearing the signature
of Chandrasekaran was also handed over to Vijay.
26.These documents were never denied during the entire proceedings and
not even a suggestion disputing the documents was made. Therefore, once the
original partners have sent Ex.P4 acknowledging the assignment and receipt of
Rs.75 Lakhs and also Ex.P20 agreeing to hand over the original trademark
certificates and also requesting for further financial assistance of Rs.20 Lakhs
and such documents having not been challenged in any manner, the contention
of the appellant with regard to the alleged fabrication and forgery of Exs.P2 and
P3 has to fall to the ground.
27.Coupled with Ex.P20, we have also perused other documents. Ex.P23,
the letter dated 09.12.2011 addressed by one of the partners, Chandrasekaran, to
the Manager, Barclays Bank, Chennai, dated 09.12.2011, authorising Vijay on
behalf of their firm, reads that they were not in Chennai and that they had
__________
Page 36 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
entered into a settlement with the Bank to repay the outstanding loan amount
availed by their company. They had further stated that the monthly
commitments would be transferred to Mr.K.C.Vijay, whose signature is also
attested therein, and requested the Bank to collect the same from him on their
behalf.
28.Ex.P25 is the receipt dated 15.05.2012 for the payment made by Vijay
to the Bank on behalf of the plaintiff/appellant company, wherein, he had paid a
sum of Rs.16 Lakhs towards the dues of the plaintiff company, namely,
M/s.N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar Company. In fact, the Bank receipt also
contains the signature of K.C. Vijay.
29.These documents clearly establish the contention of the respondents
that they had paid the consideration and had also discharged various debts of the
plaintiff firm.
30.Ex.P24, which is a letter from Axis Bank, dated 14.12.2011, addressed
to the plaintiff, also clearly indicates that only Vijay was representing the
plaintiff company, namely, M/s.N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar Company, in
connection with the proposed sale and repayment of the outstanding amount. It
is further stated that the said Vijay had also requested the Bank to consider
__________
Page 37 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
granting a concession in the repayment amount. Further, the letter states that, till
then, no one from the appellant's side had approached the Bank for any
discussion regarding the closure of the account or grant of any concession.
Therefore, the Bank had sought to recover the interest. This fact clearly shows
that a substantial amount had also been paid by Vijay to the Bank.
31.Ex.P26, the Form-A dated 23.09.2013 issued by the Registrar of
Firms, confirms that the plaintiff firm, namely, M/s.N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar
Company, had not renewed its registration from 2009 till 23.09.2013. Ex.P27
dated 28.09.2013 shows that the sales tax registration of the firm had been
cancelled. These documents clearly establish that the plaintiff firm had not been
renewed and probabilises the case of the respondents that the Company was not
carrying on any business in the name of the firm after the assignment of the
trademarks.
32.Ex.P.31 dated 20.09.2021, which is the registration of trademarks in
the name of the respondent issued by the Registrar of Trademarks, Chennai,
shows that the respondent/K.C.Vijay has also obtained registration for the other
trademarks for snuff, tobacco and smoker articles, etc. Even when the
respondent obtained registration for the other marks in respect of the same
products, no objections, whatsoever, were raised by the appellant. Such marks
__________
Page 38 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
were registered in respect of similar snuff products with a similar logo as that
obtained by the plaintiff herein. The appellant has not raised any objections as
required under Section 21 of the Act.
33.Ex.P.20 and Ex.P.25 prove the acknowledgement of receipt of
consideration and also the payment of a substantial sum by Vijay to the Bank
towards the liability of the appellant firm. Ex.P.20 and Ex.P.25 have not even
been denied during the entire cross-examination or at any stage during the entire
proceedings. Therefore, now, it is too late for the appellant to contend that the
assignment deed, dated 15.12.2011, is a result of forgery or fabrication.
34.In view of the above discussion, we hold that the contention of the
appellant that the authorisation letter dated 27.10.2011 (Ex.P2) and the deed of
assignment dated 15.12.2011 (Ex.P3) are a result of forgery or fabrication, has
to fail. Point No.(i) is answered as against the appellant.
35.On a careful perusal of Ex.P3 (assignment deed), it is seen that the 10
trademarks belonging to the appellant firm M/s.N.C.Arya Snuff and Cigar
Company, viz., Nos.454103, 454106, 454109, 592763, 180448, 180449,
559308, 178484, 179074 and 194656 in Class 34 duly registered with the
Registrar of Trademarks have been assigned to the respondent firm, namely
__________
Page 39 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
M/s.Nico Quality Products. The assignment deed also clearly shows that the
assignor granted the following:
“The assignor does hereby grant, transfer and assign upon the
terms hereunder mentioned for the exclusive use and all benefits of
the aforesaid trademark in relation to the manufacturing and
marketing of all products in Class 34 in India and abroad.”
The very recitals in the assignment deed make it clear that all benefits of the
aforesaid trademarks, including those relating to the manufacture and marketing
of all products in Class 34 in India and abroad, have been assigned. Therefore,
once the contention of the appellant that the assignment deed is a result of
forgery has been negatived and fabrication has not been established, particularly
in view of the acknowledgment of consideration under Ex.P4, concrete
admission on the part of the firm under Ex.P20, followed by the payment
evidenced by Ex.P25, we are of the view that the assignment deed has been
acted upon.
36.It is further to be noted that, under Exs.P18 and P19, several other
marks have also been registered under Class 34 for snuff and tobacco articles in
favour of K.C.Vijay. These registrations have also not been opposed by the
appellant. All these facts clearly show that the contention of the appellant that
the assignment was a result of forgery and fabrication cannot be countenanced.
__________
Page 40 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
37.Another contention raised by the learned Senior Counsel is that, even
assuming without admitting that the assignment was executed on 15.12.2011,
the assignment was not registered within a period of six months as required
under Section 42 of the Trademarks Act. Whereas, admittedly, it was presented
for registration only on 19.08.2013, i.e., after 18 months, as evident under
Ex.P5. Therefore, according to him, unless the assignment is registered within
the period stipulated under Section 42, the assignment shall not take effect.
38.In this regard, it is relevant to extract Section 42 of the Trademarks
Act as under :
“42. Conditions for assignment otherwise than in
connection with the goodwill of a business.—
Where an assignment of a trade mark, whether registered or
unregistered is made otherwise than in connection with the goodwill
of the business in which the mark has been or is used, the
assignment shall not take effect unless the assignee, not later than
the expiration of six months from the date on which the assignment
is made or within such extended period, if any, not exceeding three
months in the aggregate, as the Registrar may allow, applies to the
Registrar for directions with respect to the advertisement of the
assignment, and advertises it in such form and manner and within
such period as the Registrar may direct.
__________
Page 41 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
Explanation.—
For the purposes of this section, an assignment of a trade mark of
the following description shall not be deemed to be an assignment
made otherwise than in connection with the goodwill of the business
in which the mark is used, namely:—
(a) an assignment of a trade mark in respect only of some of the
goods or services for which the trade mark is registered
accompanied by the transfer of the goodwill of the business
concerned in those goods or services only; or
(b) an assignment of a trade mark which is used in relation to
goods exported from India or in relation to services for use outside
India if the assignment is accompanied by the transfer of the
goodwill of the export business only. ”
39.On a perusal of the above section, it is clear that any mark which is
assigned otherwise than in connection with the goodwill of the business is
required to be registered within a period of not less than six months from the
date on which the assignment is made or within such extended period, failing
which such assignment will not take effect.
40.In the present case, when the deed of assignment Ex.P3 is carefully
perused, it shows that what was assigned was not only the trademarks but also
the exclusive use of all benefits of the aforesaid trademarks in relation to the
__________
Page 42 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
manufacture and marketing of all products in Class 34 in India and abroad.
Therefore, we are of the view that when the assignment includes the transfer of
the exclusive use of all the benefits of the aforesaid trademarks in relation to the
manufacture and marketing of all products in Class 34, it is not a mere
assignment of trademarks alone but also includes the goodwill of the
trademarks.
41.In this regard, it is relevant to extract the classic exposition as to what
constitutes goodwill, as found in the decision of the House of Lords in Inland
Revenue Commissioners v. Muller & Co.'s Margarin, Ltd reported in (1901)
AC 217 (HL) , wherein, it was held as follows:
“What is goodwill? It is a thing very easy to describe, very
difficult to define. It is the benefit and advantage of the good-
name, reputation, and connection of a business . It is the
attractive force which brings in custom. It is the one thing which
distinguishes an old-established business from a new business at
its first start …. If there is one attribute common to all cases of
goodwill it is the attribute of locality. For goodwill has no
independent existence. It cannot subsist by itself. It must be
attached to a business. Destroy the business, and the goodwill
perishes with it, though elements remain which may perhaps be
gathered up and be revived again.”
__________
Page 43 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
42.In Earl Jowitt's Dictionary of English Law, “goodwill” is defined thus:
“ The goodwill of a business is the benefit which arises from
its having been carried on for some time in a particular house, or
by a particular person or firm, or from the use of a particular
trade mark or trade name. ”
43.The aforesaid observations were approved by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in S.C.Cambatta & Co. (P) Ltd. v. CEPT reported in (1961) 41 ITR 500 .
Similarly, in CIT v. B.C. Srinivasa Setty reported in (1981) 2 SCC 460 , the
Hon’ble Supreme Court termed goodwill as “the benefit arising from
connection and reputation” . Thus, there is little doubt that “goodwill”
constitutes a “benefit” in the context of the business to which it attaches.
44.Another important consideration is the fact that goodwill cannot have
an independent existence apart from the business. Thus, where the business is
sold, a natural presumption arises that goodwill is sold along with it. In
K.A.Subramaniam v. CED reported in AIR 1962 Mad 315 , a Division Bench of
this Court had observed as under:
“ The goodwill of a business is the intangible value
independent of its visible assets by reason of the business being a
well established one having a good reputation. Generally where
the owner of a business sells it as such, the goodwill enables the
purchaser to trade as a recognised successor to the business. It
__________
Page 44 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
has been recognised that the business reputation or goodwill
owned by a partnership or by a company is a valuable asset which
can be disposed of at the time of the winding up of the concern. But
at the same time it is obvious that goodwill is inseparable from the
business to which it adds value. ”
45.A similar observation was made by a Division Bench of the Calcutta
High Court in CIT v Chunilal Prabhudas and Co reported in AIR 1971 Cal 70 ,
wherein, it was held as follows:
“ There can be no sale of a goodwill without the business
associated with that goodwill or the name. From that point of view
goodwill has no separate existence apart from business. One
cannot sell the goodwill and retain the business that the goodwill
represented, nor can one sell the business and retain the
goodwill. ”
Thus, unless there exists evidence to the contra, a presumption of transfer of
goodwill arises where there is a sale or transfer of the entire business to a third
party.
46.While interpreting a commercial contract, it has to be borne in mind
that the words and expressions used therein have to be interpreted having regard
to the joint intention of both parties and not just one party. This principle can be
garnered from the decision of the Supreme Court in Great Eastern Shipping
__________
Page 45 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
Co. Ltd. v. State of Karnataka reported in (2020) 3 SCC 354 , wherein it was
held:
“ Consistent with the character of purposive interpretation,
the court is required to determine the ultimate purpose of a
contract primarily by the joint intent of the parties at the time the
contract so formed. It is not the intent of a single party; it is the
joint intent of both the parties and the joint intent of the parties is
to be discovered from the entirety of the contract and the
circumstances surrounding its formation. ”
47.Thus, the objective is to ascertain the true scope and purpose of the
assignment from the standpoint of the assignor and the assignee. It must be
remembered that a contract is a commercial document between the parties and it
must be interpreted in such a manner as to give efficacy to the contract. Equally
well settled is the principle that the meaning of words in a document is what the
parties using those words against the relevant background would reasonably
have been understood to mean. The decision in BESCOM v ES Solar Power
Private Limited reported in (2021) 6 SCC 718 holds as follows :
“ Interpretation is the ascertainment of the meaning which
the document would convey to a reasonable person having all the
background knowledge which would reasonably have been
available to the parties in the situation in which they were at the
time of the contract. ”
__________
Page 46 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
48.Thus, while judging the import of the expression “benefit” used in the
assignment, the Court must have regard to the intention of both parties, the
surrounding circumstances including the dominant purpose for which the
contract was entered into.
49.In the above background, while analysing the present case on hand, it
is seen that, when the appellant company was in a debt trap and wanted to pay
off its liabilities, it assigned its 10 trade marks to the respondent Company for
the exclusive use and all benefits of the aforesaid trade marks in relation to the
manufacture and marketing of all products in Class 34 in India and abroad.
This assignment was for a consideration and the receipt of the said
consideration has also been acknowledged and proved. Pursuant to the
assignment, certain liabilities of the assignor firm were also paid by the
assignee. The business was also run by the assignee. The appellant company
also did not run its business up to 2013 and its trademarks, including the other
marks, were also not renewed. The cancellation of the sales tax registration also
clearly indicates that the appellant was running its business and the intention of
the appellant company was to fully assign and transfer the benefits, including
the goodwill of the business to the assignee. Further, the very conduct of the
appellant in not opposing registration of further marks of the same class of
__________
Page 47 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
goods in favour of the respondent, also clearly shows that the assignment was
intended not only for the marks but also for the entire business and its goodwill.
Therefore, we hold that the trademarks have been assigned to the assignee vide
assignment deed (Ex.P3) along with goodwill.
50.Once it is held that the assignment (Ex.P3) is along with goodwill, the
contention of the appellant that the assignment is not valid for non-registration
within six months as required under Section 42 of the Trademarks Act, has to
fail. Further, the assignment deed is unconditional, supported by consideration
and it relates to specific trade marks. Hence, we hold that the assignment deed
(Ex.P3) is valid in the eye of law. Point No.(ii) is answered against the
appellant.
Point Nos.(iii) to (v) :
51.As we have held that the entire trademarks and business have been
assigned along with the goodwill and the respondents are now carrying on the
business, the appellant cannot contend that the respondents have infringed their
trademarks. Hence, we hold that the appellant is not entitled to the relief of
permanent injunction against infringement as well as passing off. Point Nos.
(iii) and (iv) are answered against the appellant.
__________
Page 48 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
52.However, on the contrary, having assigned the entire trademarks to the
respondents, the appellant cannot carry on their business or infringe the marks
already assigned to the respondents. Therefore, the respondents are entitled to
the relief of permanent injunction against infringement as sought for by them as
well as passing off. Point No.(v) is answered accordingly.
53.In view of the above discussion, the suits filed by M/s.N.C.Arya Snuff
and Cigar Company, have to fail and the suit filed by M/s.Nico Quality
Products has to succeed, as has been rightly done by the learned Single Judge.
Therefore, we do not find any infirmity in the judgment and decree of the
learned Single Judge.
54.As a result, these Original Side Appeals are dismissed, confirming the
impugned judgment and decree of the learned Single Judge. No costs.
Consequently, connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.
(N.S.K.,J.) (G.K.M.,J.)
20.11.2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
MKN
__________
Page 49 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
N.SATHISH KUMAR J.
AND
GK.MUTHUKUMAAR J.
MKN
Common Judgment in
OSA(CAD) No. 84 of 2025
and
OSA(CAD) NO. 90 OF 2025,
OSA(CAD) NO. 96 OF 2025
20.11.2026
__________
Page 50 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 06:06:09 pm )