RUPCHAND PATEL vs CHHATTISGARH STATE ELECTRICITY DISTRIBUTION COMPANY LIMITED
- Court
- Chhattisgarh High Court
1
CRA No. 99 of 2012
CGHC010004192012 2026:CGHC:47502
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ANKIT
KUMAR
SINGH
CRA No. 99 of 2012
Digitally
signed by
ANKIT KUMAR
SINGH
Judgment reserved on : 03 .11.2026
Judgment delivered on : 18.11.2026
Rupchand Patel, S/o Parasram Patel, aged about 66 years,
R/o Thangan , P.S. Dabhra, Distt. Janjgir Champa C.G.
... Appellant
versus
Chhattisgarh State Electricity Distribution Company Limited,
through the Assistant Engineer (Sanchar/Sudhar), Division
Dabhra, District – Janjgir-Champa, C.G.
... Respondent
For Appellant :- Mr. H.S. Patel and Mr. Ishwar Raj
Chandra, Advocates.
For Respondent :- Ms. Aditi Parak appears on behalf of Mr.
Raja Sharma, Advocate.
Hon'ble Shri Justice Sudhir Kumar
C A V Judgment
1. The present criminal appeal has been filed under Section
374(2) of the CrPC preferred by the appellant-accused,
2
CRA No. 99 of 2012
challenging the legality, validity and correctness of the
judgment dated 29.09.2011 passed by the Special Judge
(Electricity Act), Janjgir, District Janjgir-Champa,
Chhattisgarh, in Special Electricity Criminal Case No. 11/11 by
which the appellant herein has been convicted for offence
under Section 135(A) of the Electricity Act, 2003 (for brevity
“Act, 2003”), and sentenced to undergo imprisonment till
rising of the Court with fine of ₹500/-; in default of payment
of fine to further undergo additional simple imprisonment for
1 month.
Prosecution Case:-
2. Case of the prosecution in brief is that on 20.11.2010, the
appellant, at his premises situated at village Thangan,
dishonestly and without the consent of the Chhattisgarh State
Power Distribution Company Limited, with the intention of
causing wrongful gain to himself, illegally abstracted and
consumed electrical energy by directly hooking the LT line
and committed theft of electrical energy valued at Rs. 4,954/-.
3. As per the complaint, on 20.11.2010, Assistant Engineer V.K.
Rathia, Junior Engineer N.P. Patel and Narsingh Chandra
visited the premises of the appellant situated at village
3
CRA No. 99 of 2012
Thangan for inspection. During the inspection, in the
presence of the appellant, it was found that he was illegally
consuming electrical energy by directly hooking his premises
to the LT line, thereby using electrical energy through an
unauthorised connection with a connected load of 0.5 HP.
Accordingly, the inspection proceedings were conducted, and
the relevant panchnama, seizure memo and site map were
prepared. Thereafter, the Assistant Engineer prepared the
assessment/calculation sheet and issued a provisional penalty
bill to the accused. On the basis of the aforesaid inspection
and the alleged unauthorised use of electrical energy, the
complaint was filed against the accused for the commission of
an offence punishable under Section 135(A) of the Act, 2003
before the Special Judge (Electricity Act), Janjgir, District
Janjgir-Champa, Chhattisgarh
4. In order to bring home the offence, prosecution has examined
as many as 3 witnesses and exhibited 7 documents, whereas,
defence, in support of his case, has not examined any witness
however exhibited 2 documents. The statement of the
appellant / accused was recorded under Section 313 of the
CrPC in which he denied the circumstances appearing against
4
CRA No. 99 of 2012
him in the evidence brought on record by the prosecution,
pleaded innocence and false implication.
5. The trial Court after appreciating the oral and documentary
evidence available on record, convicted the appellant /
accused for the offence as mentioned in the opening
paragraph of the judgment, against which the appeal has been
preferred by the appellant herein questioning the impugned
judgment of conviction and order of sentence.
Submission of the Parties:-
6. Learned counsel for the appellant would submit that the
proceedings of the Electricity Department is doubtful, as
there are contradictions in the evidence regarding the
horsepower (HP) of the motor being operated by the
appellant at the time of inspection. He would also submit that
in some documents HP of motor pump is mentioned as 0.5
HP motor pump, while in several other documents, it is
mentioned as 1.5 HP motor pump. This discrepancy casts
doubt upon the entire proceedings conducted by the
Electricity Department, as such, the appellant is entitled for
acquittal and the appeal deserves to be allowed.
5
CRA No. 99 of 2012
7. Learned State counsel would support the impugned judgment
and submit that prosecution has been able to bring home the
offence beyond reasonable doubt and the appellant has been
convicted on the basis of evidences available on record. He
would also submit that the impugned judgment is just and
proper which does not warrant any interference and,
therefore, the present appeal deserves to be dismissed.
8. I have heard learned counsel for the parties, considered their
rival submissions made herein above and gone through the
records precisely.
Discussion & Analysis:-
9. M.R. Patel, (PW-1) in his statement before the Court has stated
that he along with V.K. Rathiya (PW-2) and Nar Singh had
conducted the inspection in the premises of the appellant. During
inspection he found that the appellant was illegally consuming
electricity by using load of ½ (0.5) HP motor pump by
directly hooking from his premises to the LT line and
prepared the panchnama in that regard. In the cross-
examination he has stated that in Exs.P/3 Seizure & P/4
Naksha panchnama, he mentioned 1.5 HP motor pump,
however, he has admitted that he did not inspect the motor
pump to ascertain whether it was ½ (0.5) HP or 1.5 HP
6
CRA No. 99 of 2012
though this witness himself is a main Inspection Officer, who
filed the complaint against the appellant.
10. In the complaint, he (PW-1) had mentioned 0.5 HP motor
pump, but in the seizure memo (Ex.P/3) & Naksha
Panchnama (Ex.P/4), he mentioned 1.5 HP motor pump.
Furthermore, in the calculation memo (Ex.P/6), on the basis
0.5 HP motor pump, loss amount to the tune of ₹4,954/- was
calculated for the theft of electricity. As such, there are
contradictions in the proceedings of the Electricity
Department.
11. Moreover, the important fact is the horsepower (HP) of the
motor pump being used at the time of theft of electricity and
the loss resulting from the electricity theft can only be
calculated based on the horsepower of the motor pump. In
the present case, the loss resulting from the electricity theft
was calculated on the basis of 0.5 HP motor pump, however
from the spot as per the seizure (Ex.P/3) 1.5 HP motor pump
was seized from the possession of the appellant.
12. From perusal of the aforesaid documentary evidences, it
appears that the proceedings conducted by the Officers of the
Electricity Department against the appellant is under cloud
7
CRA No. 99 of 2012
which creates doubt in the case of the prosecution. In
considered opinion of this Court, on the basis of contradictory
documents and contradictory statement of the witness,
conviction of the appellant cannot be sustained and, as such,
the appellant could not be convicted for the offence under
Section 135(A) of the Act, 2003.
Conclusion:-
13.In view of above discussion and analysis, the impugned judgment
of conviction and order of sentence dated 29.09.2011 is hereby set
aside and the appellant is acquitted of the charges under Section
135(A) of the Act, 2003. Appellant is stated to be on bail. He need
not surrender. However, his bail bond shall remain in operation
for a period of six months as per provisions contained in Section
437-A of the CrPC/Section 481 of Bhartiya Nagrik Suraksha
Sanhita, 2023.
14.Accordingly, the appeal is allowed .
15.A copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned trial Court for
information and compliance.
Sd/- Sd/-
(Sudhir Kumar)
Judge
Ankit