SUBRATA HALDER vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.

Court
Calcutta High Court


IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE

PRESENT:
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE UDAY KUMAR

CRR 1269 OF 2022

SUBRATA HALDER
-VS-
STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.

For the Petitioners : Mr. Sabyasachi Mukherjee, Ld. Adv.
Mr. Tapan Jyoti Bose, Ld. Adv.
Ms. Saheli Mukherjee, Ld. Adv.

For the State : Mr. Kallol Mondal, Ld. P.P.
Mr. Somnath Adhikary, Ld. Adv.
Ms. Samira Grewal, Ld. Adv.

Reserved on : 28.09.2026
Pronounced on : 06.10.2026

UDAY KUMAR, J.: –
1. The present criminal revisional application under Section 482 read with
Sections 397 and 401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, has
been instituted by the petitioner, Subrata Halder, seeking the quashing
of the First Information Report arising out of New Town Police Station
Case No. 30 of 2022 dated February 03, 2022, under Sections
420/406/448/427/506/120B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, along
with the consequential charge-sheet and the entire criminal proceeding

2
CRR 1269 OF 2022

pending before the Court of the Learned Chief Judicial Magistrate at
Barasat, North 24 Parganas.
2. The background facts of the prosecution case, as revealed from the
materials on record, present a distressing narrative concerning the de
facto complainant, Sri Ajit Das @ Ojhir Das, a senior citizen aged about
77 years. The complainant originally owned a two-storied residential
building standing on a plot of land measuring 2 cottahs of Sali land
situated at Mouza Chandiberia, New Adarshapally, under New Town
Police Station (formerly Rajarhat) in the District of North 24 Parganas.
The genesis of the controversy traces back to a troubled domestic
background wherein the elderly complainant suffered physical ouster
from his said residential property at the hands of his son, Birender Das,
and daughter-in-law, Rina Das. Though living separately, they forcibly
entered his premises, subjected him to continuous physical and mental
torture, and ultimately drove him out of his own home, compelling him
to take shelter at his daughter's residence at Bagmari Road, Kolkata.
3. Seeking legal recourse and shelter to regain his rightful home and
counter the harassment meted out by his son and daughter-in-law, the
complainant sought professional assistance and consulted the present
petitioner, Subrata Halder, an advocate by profession, along with co-
accused Rahul Biswas. Pursuant to legal steps initiated before this
Court in W.P.A. No. 10918 of 2021, culminating in solemn orders
passed by this Court directing police assistance, the elderly
complainant was successfully restored to the physical possession of his
property on July 15, 2021. During these proceedings, it was suggested

3
CRR 1269 OF 2022

to him by the petitioner that as an aged person, the complainant would
face severe hardships running around courts and police stations, and
consequently, a registered General Power of Attorney came to be
executed on March 24, 2021, in favour of Rahul Biswas, described as
an office assistant/clerk of the petitioner. However, the core controversy
erupted within twenty-four hours on March 25, 2021, when the said
Power of Attorney holder executed a registered sale deed transferring
the property in favour of the petitioner, Subrata Halder.
4. The friction intensified further when the elderly complainant left for
Jharkhand for a brief period to attend his granddaughter’s wedding.
Upon returning after a month, he discovered that his former advocate,
Subrata Halder, had allegedly broken the locks of the house,
demolished four rental rooms and a bathroom causing substantial
structural loss, and taken over forcible possession. The state of affairs
culminated in the complainant lodging a written complaint at New Town
Police Station, giving rise to New Town P.S. Case No. 30 of 2022. During
the investigation, the police recorded statements under Section 161
Cr.P.C., secured a judicial statement of the complainant under Section
164 Cr.P.C., seized original deeds, and noted financial transactions
involving money transfers and receipts. Subsequently, the Investigating
Officer submitted a charge-sheet under Section 173 Cr.P.C. on selfsame
penal sections. Parallelly, a civil suit being Title Suit No. 237 of 2022
st
was instituted by the petitioner before the 1 Court of the learned Civil
Judge (Junior Division), Barasat, Dsitrict- North 24 Parganas wherein
the learned Civil Court, by Order No. 16 dated March 03, 2023,

4
CRR 1269 OF 2022

evaluated the rival claims, noted that money had been accepted and
withdrawn through banking and cash channels, and concluded that the
defendants failed to establish a prima facie case of fraud at that stage,
protecting the plaintiff's possession over the suit land through an order
of injunction.
5. Turning to the submissions advanced on behalf of the petitioner-
accused, the learned counsel vehemently argued that the entire
criminal proceeding is an abuse of the process of law, being a malicious
attempt to convert a purely civil and contractual property dispute into a
criminal prosecution. It was submitted that the transaction in question
is firmly rooted in registered statutory instruments; namely, a
registered General Power of Attorney and a subsequent registered Sale
Deed executed before the competent Additional District Sub-Registrar,
which carry a statutory presumption of validity until set aside by a
competent civil court.
6. The learned counsel for the petitioner further contended that one of the
fundamental ingredients of cheating under Section 415 IPC punishable
under Section 420 IPC, specifically dishonest inducement ab initio , are
entirely absent, as the monetary considerations were duly advanced,
documented through cheques and bank transfers, and further
substantiated by contemporaneous money receipts and payment
directions acknowledged by the complainant and his family members.
7. In support of his contentions, the learned counsel for the petitioner
relied heavily upon the celebrated pronouncement of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Nageswar Prasad Singh v. Narayan Singh & Anr.,

5
CRR 1269 OF 2022

[(1998) 5 SCC 694] , as well as the overarching principles laid down in
Indian Oil Corpn. v. NEPC India Ltd. & Ors. , [(2006) 6 SCC 736] , wherein
the Apex Court repeatedly cautioned against the growing tendency of
utilizing criminal machinery as a pressure tactic or a shortcut to settle
civil property disputes and contractual disagreements.
8. The petitioner further emphasized that the competent Civil Court in
Title Suit No. 237 of 2022, after a meticulous evaluation of the bank
accounts, money receipts, and third-party agreements, categorically
held that the defendants could not establish any fraud at this stage and
protected the plaintiff's peaceful possession over the suit property by an
order of injunction, thereby rendering the continuance of a criminal
trial completely redundant and untenable.
9. Per contra , the submissions on behalf of the opposite parties and the
prosecution countered that the criminal proceeding cannot be throttled
at the threshold, given the fiduciary relationship that existed between
the parties. It was argued that the petitioner, who stood as an advocate
and legal advisor to a vulnerable, septuagenarian senior citizen ousted
from his home, abused that position of trust by orchestrating a
lightning-fast transfer of property within twenty-four hours of obtaining
a power of attorney, without any contemporaneous cash consideration.
Pointing to the judicial statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C. and the
investigative findings of the Investigating Officer, the prosecution urged
that the subsequent token payments credited months later, grossly
disproportionate to the actual market value of the property, coupled
with the forcible breaking of locks and demolition of rental structures

6
CRR 1269 OF 2022

during the elderly man's absence, disclose sterling prima facie materials
constituting cognizable offenses of cheating, criminal breach of trust,
criminal trespass, and mischief, which warrant a full-fledged trial
rather than premature quashing.
10. Upon a comprehensive evaluation of the pleadings, the statutory
materials collected during investigation, the subsequent charge-sheet,
and the solemn judicial pronouncements rendered by the competent
civil court, the core and cardinal questions that fall for determination in
the present revisional application are formulated as under:
Firstly, Whether a dispute arising out of registered instruments of
property transfer, where financial transactions have been acted
upon and the substantive issues of title, agency, and contractual
validity are actively sub judice before a competent Civil Court, can
form the lawful foundation of a criminal prosecution under
Sections 420, 406, 448, 427, 506, and 120B of the Indian Penal
Code?
Secondly, Whether the invocation and continuation of criminal
machinery in such factual matrices constitute an abuse of the
process of law warranting interference of this Court under Section
482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure?
11. To resolve these central questions conclusively, it is imperative to
examine the legal parameters governing the co-existence of civil and
criminal remedies and the binding ratio decidendi laid down by the

7
CRR 1269 OF 2022

Hon’ble Supreme Court. It is a well-settled principle of criminal
jurisprudence that civil and criminal remedies are not mutually
exclusive, and a given set of facts may simultaneously give rise to civil
and criminal liabilities. However, the Apex Court has repeatedly
cautioned that criminal courts must exercise extreme vigilance to
prevent the weaponization of criminal proceedings as a pressure tactic
or an alternative shortcut to settle civil property disputes, contractual
breaches, and title disagreements.
12. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the landmark ruling of Indian Oil Corpn.
v. NEPC India Ltd (supra) , at paragraph 13 of the report, authoritatively
held:
"13. …..A growing tendency has been noticed …… to convert purely
civil disputes into criminal cases. This is obviously on account of a
prevalent impression that civil law remedies are time-consuming
and do not adequately protect the interests of lenders/creditors...
… Any effort to settle civil disputes and claims, which do not
involve any criminal offence, by applying pressure through criminal
prosecution should be deprecated and discouraged….."
13. The ratio decidendi of this judgment firmly establishes that where a
dispute is fundamentally civil in nature, turning upon contractual
rights, agency powers, and property transfers, and in view of absence of
the essential foundational elements of criminal intent ( mens rea ) such
as dishonest inducement from the very inception ( ab initio ) to fasten the
offence of cheating, criminal prosecution cannot be allowed to proceed.
Similarly, in Narayan Singh (supra) , the Supreme Court emphasized
that civil property disputes concerning the execution and validity of

8
CRR 1269 OF 2022

deeds must be adjudicated by a civil forum, and routing them through
criminal courts is a clear abuse of process.
14. Applying the aforesaid authoritative ratio to the facts of the present
case, the transaction in question rests upon statutory registered
instruments, namely the registered General Power of Attorney and the
registered Sale Deed. While the complainant alleges breach of trust and
fraud, the contemporaneous documentary evidence, including bank
statements, structured payment directions, and money receipts dated
January 08 and January 13, 2022, proves that monetary
considerations were indeed remitted and withdrawn through banking
channels. More crucially, the learned Trial Court in Title Suit No. 237 of
2022, while adjudicating upon injunction applications, meticulously
evaluated these financial trails, third-party agreements, and conduct of
the parties, recording a categorical finding that Opposite Party No. 2
failed to establish a prima facie case of fraud at this stage and protected
the petitioner’s peaceful possession over the suit property by an order of
injunction.
15. When a competent Civil Court exercising civil jurisdiction is already
seized of the lis concerning title, the validity of deeds, and the civil
consequences of a transaction, and has explicitly observed that monies
were accepted and withdrawn and that fraud has not been established
at the threshold, permitting a parallel criminal trial on identical
allegations against an advocate and connected parties would lead to
conflicting judicial outcomes and perpetrate a gross abuse of the
judicial process. The dispute between the parties is quintessentially civil

9
CRR 1269 OF 2022

and proprietary in character, turning upon the interpretation of power
of agency, contractual performance, and property rights. In the absence
of clear, unequivocal ingredients of cheating punishable under Section
420 of the IPC viz. dishonest inducement ab initio , the criminal
prosecution loses its foundational legitimacy.
16. Consequently, upon a holistic evaluation of the materials on record, the
findings of the Learned Civil Court in T.S. No. 237 of 2022, and the
binding ratio decidendi of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Indian Oil
Corpn. v. NEPC India Ltd (supra) and Narayan Singh (supra) , this Court
is of the considered view that the continuation of the impugned criminal
proceeding is wholly unwarranted and constitutes an abuse of the
process of the court.
17. Both questions are determined in favour of the petitioner. Accordingly,
the revisional application succeeds.
18. C.R.R. 1269 of 2022 is allowed.
19. Consequently, the First Information Report arising out of New Town
Police Station Case No. 30 of 2022 dated February 03, 2022, under
Sections 420/406/448/427/506/120B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860,
along with the consequential charge-sheet and the entire criminal
proceeding connected thereto, pending before the Court of the Learned
Chief Judicial Magistrate at Barasat, North 24 Parganas, are hereby
quashed and set aside as against the petitioner, Subrata Halder.
20. All connected pending application(s), if any, stand disposed of.
21. Interim orders, if any, stand vacated.
22. There shall be no order as to costs.

10
CRR 1269 OF 2022

23. Let a copy of this judgment along with the Trial Court Records (T.C.R.)
be transmitted to the learned Trial Court forthwith for necessary
compliance and information.
24. Case diary, be returned to the Learned Counsel for the State.
25. Urgent photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance with all requisite formalities.

(Uday Kumar, J.)