Anu vs St Of Hry
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
6
CRA-S-82-SB-200 (O&M) 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
346
CRA-S-82-SB-2006 (O&M)
Date of decision : 17.11.2026
ANU
..... APPELLANT
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA ..... RESPONDENT
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SURYA PARTAP SINGH
Present : Mr. Paramjit Singh Sullar, Advocate
for the appellant.
Mr. Vishal Singh, AAG, Haryana.
*
SURYA PARTAP SINGH , J .
The present appeal has been filed
by the appellant/convict
against the judgment of conviction dated 06.10.2005 and order of sentence
learned Sessions Judge, Panchkula
dated 10.10.2005, passed by the Court ,
hereinafter being referred to as ‘trial Court’ only.
Briefly stating the facts emerging from record are that one FIR,
2.
i.e. FIR No.35 dated 21.02.2004, was registered in Police Station Raipur
Rani, District Panchkula, for the commission of offence punishable under
Sections 302/323/506/34 of Indian Penal Code. In the wake of
abovementioned FIR, the investigation was taken up by the police, and on
completion of the same, the appellant was sent to face trial in the Court.
3. The appellant participated in the above-mentioned trial, and by
virtue of judgment dated 06.10.2005, hereinafter being referred to as
‘impugned judgment’, the abovesaid trial culminated into conviction of the
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.18 19:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
6
CRA-S-82-SB-200 (O&M) 2
appellant. Thus, vide order dated 10.10.2005, hereinafter being referred to as
‘impugned order’, on the point of quantum of sentence, following sentences
were awarded to appellant:-
Offence under Section Sentence
304 Part II IPC Rigorous imprisonment for a period of seven
years and to pay a fine of Rs.2000/-. In default
thereof to undergo further imprisonment
(rigorous) for a period of three months.
Rigorous imprisonment for a period of six
323 IPC months.
All the sentences were ordered to run concurrently.
4. In nut-shell, the facts emerging from the record are that the FIR
of this case came into being at the instance of ‘Geeta Rani’, hereinafter being
referred to as ‘complainant’. It was stated by the above-named complainant
that marriage of her brother-in-law ‘Jaipal’ was solemnized with ‘Alka’ about
seven years ago. According to complainant in June, 2003 ‘Alka’ had eloped
with his neighbour ‘Anu’ (the appellant herein). As per complainant after
about two months both Anu and Alka were apprehended.
5. The complainant further stated that on 04.02.2204, ‘Alka’ again
left the matrimonial home, for her parental home, along with cash and her
dowry articles. According to complainant, from that day, ‘Anu’ and his cousin
‘Vijay’ were also absconding. The complainant further alleged that on
20.02.2004 at about 06:00 pm, ‘Anu’, his uncle ‘Sham Lal’, and his cousin
‘Vijay’ came in front of their house and started knocking the door. As per
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.18 19:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
6
CRA-S-82-SB-200 (O&M) 3
complainant, when her brother-in-law ‘Satpal’ came down and asked them
not to do this, an altercation took place between them and her brother-in-law
‘Satpal’. According to complainant ‘Anu’ picked up a stone from the road and
hit the same on the chest of ‘Satpal’. It was further stated by the complainant
that ‘Vijay’, too, picked up a stone and hit on the head of ‘Satpal’ due to
which ‘Satpal’ fell down on the road. According to complainant, thereafter
‘Sham’ thrashed ‘Satpal’ with kicks and punches, when he was lying on the
ground.
6. The complainant further stated that she screamed for help for the
rescue of ‘Satpal’ from the clutches of the assailants. According to
complainant thereafter ‘Anu’ picked up a stick from the road and hit two
blows of the stick upon her head. As per complainant on her hue and cry,
brothers in-law ‘Mahesh Pal’, ‘Ram Kumar’ and ‘Jai Pal’ came on the spot.
As per complainant when ‘Vijay’ and ‘Sham’ saw them, they brought wooden
lathies Kulhari
sticks ( ) and ‘Anu’ brought an axe ( ) from their house.
According to complainant, thereafter, ‘Vijay’, ‘Sham’ and ‘Anu’ inflicted
injuries upon the persons of ‘Mahesh Pal’, ‘Ram Kumar’ and ‘Jai Pal’. The
complainant further alleged that when ‘Mahesh Pal’, ‘Ram Kumar’ and ‘Jai
Pal’ raised alarm, the assailants fled from the spot. As per complainant,
thereafter, the injured were rushed to the hospital, but ‘Satpal’ succumbed to
injuries on the way.
7. It was a case of the prosecution that pursuant to above-
mentioned complaint, formal FIR of this case was lodged and the
investigation taken up. It was further alleged by the prosecution that, during
the course of investigation, the Investigating Officer inspected the spot,
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.18 19:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
6
CRA-S-82-SB-200 (O&M) 4
prepared rough site-plan of the place of occurrence, recorded the statement of
witnesses under Section 161 CrPC, and completed usual formalities of
investigation. Thereafter, the final report under Section 173 CrPC was filed.
8. Heard.
9. It has been contended on behalf of appellant that the impugned
judgment of conviction and order of sentence passed by the learned trial
Court were perverse and unsustainable. According to learned counsel for the
appellant, merely on the basis of assumptions and presumptions, the
unreliable and inconsistent evidence adduced by the prosecution was believed
by the learned trial Court. According to learned counsel for the appellant, the
learned trial Court failed to apply judicial mind to the facts of the instant
case, and that, merely, on the basis of conjectures and surmises the finding of
conviction of appellant, for the commission of offence under Section 304 Part
II and 323 of IPC was recorded.
10. It has been further contended by learned counsel for the
appellant that the learned trial Court ignored this cardinal principle of
criminal jurisprudence that prosecution had to prove its case beyond the
shadow of all reasonable doubts. According to learned counsel for the
appellant, the evidence adduced by the prosecution was grossly inadequate to
draw an inference that all the essential ingredients, meant for the commission
of offence, for which the appellant was convicted, had been proved. In view
of above, the learned counsel for the appellant has contended that the case
against the appellant was not proved by the prosecution, but erroneously the
learned trial Court returned the finding of conviction.
11. However, during the course of arguments, the learned counsel
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.18 19:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
6
CRA-S-82-SB-200 (O&M) 5
for the appellant has contended that in the instant appeal, the appellant is not
inclined to challenge the findings of conviction recorded by the learned trial
Court. The learned counsel for the appellant has categorically contended that
at this stage, by virtue of present appeal, the appellant is challenging the order
on the point of quantum of sentence only.
12. It has been further contended by learned counsel for the
appellant that the incident had taken place way back in the year 2004.
According to learned counsel for the appellant, the appellant is facing the
agony of litigation for the last more than 22 years and, in fact, he has already
suffered more punishment than he deserved.
13. In addition to above, the learned counsel for the appellant has
also argued that in the present case, the appellant namely ‘Anu’, has already
undergone imprisonment for a period of two years, four months and one day.
According to learned counsel for the appellant, in view of above-discussed
factors, and the fact that minimum sentence has not been prescribed for the
offence, for which the appellant has been convicted, the sentence already
undergone by the appellant may be treated to be sufficient.
Per contra
14. , the learned State Counsel has argued that the
appellant was found guilty for the commission of offence punishable under
Sections 304 Pat II and 323 of IPC. According to learned State Counsel, the
sentence awarded to the appellant, i.e. imprisonment for a period of seven
years, is already on lower side, and that the appellant is not entitled to a
sentence of less than seven years. As per learned State Counsel, the instant
appeal has no merits and deserves dismissal.
15. The record has been perused carefully.
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.18 19:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
6
CRA-S-82-SB-200 (O&M) 6
16. Although it is categorical stand of the appellant that he is not
challenging the judgment of conviction, passed by the learned trial Court, yet,
with a purpose to evaluate evidence, the record has been perused carefully. A
perusal of trial Court record shows that the evidence adduced by the
prosecution was thoroughly consistent, and good enough to bring home guilt
of the appellant, for which he was charge-sheeted. Thus, it is hereby held that
there is no scope for interference or indulgence in the findings recorded by
the learned trial Court, with regard to conviction of appellant, for the offence
under Sections 304 Part II and 323 of IPC. Accordingly, the above-mentioned
finding is hereby affirmed and qua the judgment of conviction instant appeal
is hereby dismissed.
17. As far as the order on quantum of sentence is concerned, in view
of the fact that the appellant namely ‘Anu’, has already undergone
imprisonment for a period of two years, four months and one day against the
awarded sentence of seven years, it is hereby held that the appellant is
entitled to a lenient view.
18. In the light of above observations, if the factual matrix of present
case is analyzed, it transpires that following are the points which are required
to be taken into consideration: -
(a) that the incident in question had taken place about 22 years
ago;
(b) that the appellant is facing the agony of protracted trial for
the last 22 years;
(c) that against the awarded sentence of seven years, the
appellant namely ‘Anu’, has already undergone
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.18 19:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
6
CRA-S-82-SB-200 (O&M) 7
imprisonment for a period of two years, four months and one
day; and
(d) that after the filing of present FIR, the appellant has not been
prosecuted for any other offence.
19. In view of abovementioned observations, the sentence awarded
to the appellant is hereby held to be harsh and, as a consequence thereof, it is
hereby observed that with regard to quantum of sentence, there is need for
interference and indulgence in the impugned order on the point of quantum of
sentence, by exercising the appellate jurisdiction vested in this Court. Thus,
in my opinion, by exercising the abovementioned jurisdiction, the sentence
awarded to the appellant needs to be rationalized and reduced.
20. As a cumulative effect of abovementioned observations, it is
hereby held that in the present case, the appellant is entitled to a lenient view,
and that the sentence already undergone in the present case, is adequate to
meet the ends of justice.
21. As a sequel to the aforesaid discussions, the present appeal is
hereby partly allowed . The judgment of conviction is upheld; but order on the
point of quantum of sentence is modified, and the sentence awarded to the
appellant is reduced to the period already undergone by him.
22. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, stand(s) disposed
of, accordingly.
(SURYA PARTAP SINGH)
JUDGE
17.11.2026
vipin
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.18 19:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document