Govinda And Another vs State Of Haryana Through Its Principle Secretary

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

1
CWP-26070-2026 (O & M)

IN THE HI
IGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HA
ARYANA AT CHANDIGARH

CWP No.2
Date of d
108


Govinda a
26070 of 2026 (O & M)
decision :-13.11.2026
and another
…..Petitioners

Versus

State of H
Haryana and others
…..Respondents

CORAM:-

Present:-
- HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NIDHI G
UPTA
Mr. R. K. Girdhwal, Advocate
Mr. Rohit Mittal, Advocate
For the petitioners.

Mr. Harish Kumar Nain, DAG

*

UPTA J. (Oral)
e for
G, Haryana.
NIDHI GU


Present writ petition has b
een filed by the petitioners
under Art
ticles 226/227 of the Constitutio
on of India for issuance of a
writ in th
he nature of Certiorari, quash
hing the impugned relieving
order dat
ted 30.07.2025 (Annexure P-4), i
ssued by the respondent no.
4, relievin
ng the petitioners as Group 'D
D' in most illegal, arbitrary,
discrimina
atory and un-constitution mann
ner in violation of the policy
instructio
ons dated 07.08.2024 and 15.01
1.2025, (Annexures P-13 and
P-14), res
spectively, issued by the respon
dent no. 1;AND/OR issuance
a Writ in
the nature of Mandamus, the
respondents be directed to
grant the
e benefit of the policy instruct
tions dated 07.08.2024 and
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.16 17:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

2
CWP-26070-2026 (O & M)

15.01.202
25, (AnnexuresP-13 and P-14),
respectively, issued by the
responde
ent no. 1 and to adjust the
e petitioners in the same
responde
ent-Irrigation Department agains
st the available vacant posts,
admitted
by respondent no. 4 and not to
o discriminate the petitioners
in violatio
on of their fundamental rights
enshrined under Article 14,
16 and 21
1 of the Constitution of India.
2.
It is inter alia submitted b
by learned counsel for the
petitioner
rs that the petitioners were init
tially engaged on contractual
basis on
Group D post in respondent-
-Irrigation Department. The
petitioner
rs had initially joined the resp
pondent Department in the
year 2017
7. However, petitioners have n
no record in respect of their
initial ap
pointment. As per the record,
, Petitioners had joined on
01.12.201
19 and 01.01.2020 respectively.

3.
The State Government had
framed the Deployment of
Contractu
ual Persons Policy, 2022 pursua
ant to which the services of
the petit
tioners came to be regulated
d through HKRNL. As such
petitioner
rs continued to work without
any break in Service. The
petitioner
rs have been continuously disc
charging their duties and no
adverse m
material regarding their work
or conduct has ever been
recorded
against them.
4.
Thereafter, the State Gover
nment enacted the Haryana
Contractu
ual Employees (Security of Serv
vice) Act, 2024 (hereinafter
’the 2024
4 Act’), which came into force w
with effect from 15.08.2024
with the o
object of providing security of s
ervice to eligible contractual
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.16 17:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

3
CWP-26070-2026 (O & M)

employee
es. It is submitted that the petiti
oners are about to complete
five years
s of Service, and therefore, satis
sfy the conditions prescribed
under the
e said Act and are entitled to its
protection.
5.
It is also submitted that t
he respondents had earlier
relieved s
similarly situated HKRN employe
ees on the ground of joining
of regula
r employees. Such action was c
challenged before this Court
in CWP N
No.7437 of 2025 (Renu and oth
hers v. State of Haryana and
others) a
nd connected matters, which w
were decided vide common
judgment
t dated 24.12.2025 , whereby th
he relieving orders were set
aside and
d the respondents were directed
d to reconsider the matter by
passing fr
resh speaking orders while main
ntaining continuity of service
till such re
econsideration.
6.
Ld. Counsel submits that
t therefore the impugned
relieving
order dated 30.7.2025 has be
en passed without properly
considerin
ng the provisions of the Act, 202
24, or the HKRN Deployment
Policy, th
e availability of vacant posts wit
thin the same District/Circle,
and the d
directions issued by this Court.
It is further submitted that
similarly s
situated employees have been g
granted interim protection in
other con
nnected writ petitions and, the
erefore, petitioners are also
entitled to
o similar relief.
7.
Learned counsel argues that
t petitioners are fulfilling all
the requi
rements and conditions as man
ndated under the Act, 2024.
Thus, th
he impugned action is in
nequitable, arbitrary and
discrimina
atory; as, once the petitioners
have completed period of 5
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.16 17:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

4
CWP-26070-2026 (O & M)

years of s
service as stipulated under the A
Act, 2024, the petitioners are
eligible fo
or protection under the Act. H
However, the same has not
been con
nsidered. It is accordingly pra
ayed that the present Writ
Petition
be allowed, the impugned re
lieving orders be quashed,
along wit
h a direction for their reinstatem
ment/continuation in service
and all co
onsequential benefits.
8.
Per contra, learned counse
el for the respondent-State
opposes
submissions advanced on beh
half of the petitioners and
submits t
that the petitioners do not fulfil
l the condition precedent of
completio
on of five years of service t
to make them eligible for
protectio
n under the 2024 Act. Moreove
r, the impugned order dated
30.07.202
25 (Annexure P-4) has been pas
ssed in terms of Instructions
dated 27.
.12.2024 and 15.01.2025. Howev
ver, the same have not been
challenge
ed by the petitioners. It is ac
ccordingly prayed that the
present W
Writ Petition be dismissed being
without merit.
9.
No other argument is raised
d by learned counsel for the
parties. I
have heard learned counsel a
and perused the case file in
great deta
ail. I find merit in the submission
ns of the respondent-State.
10.
It is the case of the petition
ners that they were initially
appointed
d as Beldars/Group-D on cont
tractual basis in 2019-2020;
whereafte
er services of the petitioners
were converted under the
HKRNL. P
Petitioners have claimed prote
ection under the Act, 2024
which is
available for contractual emplo
oyees who have rendered 5
years of s
service. It is the contention of
the petitioners that as they
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.16 17:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

5
CWP-26070-2026 (O & M)

were ap
ppointed on 01.12.2019 and
01.01.2020, respectively,
therefore
e, as on the date of relieving i.e
e. 30.07.2025 (Annexure P-4)
petitioner
rs had completed 5 years’ servic
ce; and, therefore, under the
Act, 2024
4, they could not have been relie
eved.
11.
Although the said submissio
on of the petitioners appears
to be c
correct in the first instance
e, however, the same is
misconce
ived. Section 3 of the 2024 Act r
reads as under: –
“ 3. The eligible contractu
ual employee shall be an
employee
e who,-
(i)
(a) has been engag
ged on contract by the
Government Organization a
and is in the service of such
Government Organization o
on the appointed date and
receiving remuneration upto
Rs. 50,000/- per month; or
(b) is deployed by the Har
ryana Kaushal Rozgar Nigam
under the Deployment of
Contractual Persons Policy,
2022 and is in the service of
f a Government Organization
on the appointed date;
(ii)
has completed at least f
five years service in the
Government Organization o
on full time basis as on the
appointed date.
Explanati
ion 1.- The period of service shal
ll be considered as the period
for which remuneration was
s made, directly or indirectly,
by the Government Org
ganization to the eligible
contractual employee and sh
hall include the period of any
leave approved by the compe
etent authority.
Explanati
ion2.- For the purposes of calcul
ation of the number of years
of engagement, a contra
actual employee who has
received remuneration for at
t least 240 days in a calendar
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.16 17:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

6
CWP-26070-2026 (O & M)

year shall be deemed to have
e worked for the entire year,
but shall not include an empl
loyee who,-
(i) has been engaged
under Centrally Sponsored
Schemes paid in pa
art or full by the Central
Government; or
(ii) has been engaged on
honorarium basis;or
(iii) has been paid remun
neration for service rendered
on a part time b
basis by the Government
Organization; or

(iv) has attained the age
e of fifty-eight years on the
appointed date; or
(v) has been terminat
ted or removed by the
appropriate authorit
ty on or before the date of
commencement of th
his Act.”

Section 2 (a) of the said Act d
defines ‘appointed date’ as
follows:
“ (a)“appointed d
th
15 August,2024 ;”
date” means the
12.
A conjoint reading of the a
above said S.3(ii) and S.2(a)
shows tha
at in order to be eligible for pro
otection under the Act, 2024,
petitioner
rs ought to have been appointe
ed before the cut-off date of
15.08.201
19; whereas admittedly, petition
ners were appointed only on
01.12.201
19 and 01.12.2020, respectively.
. As such, petitioners are not
eligible fo
or protection under the Act.
13.
It further needs to be
clarified that after the
promulga
ation of the 2024 Act; the issue
arose as to how and in what
manner
are the newly selected em
ployees which have been
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.16 17:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

7
CWP-26070-2026 (O & M)

appointed
d through the Haryana Staff Sele
ection Commission (for short
‘HSSC’), a
re to be accommodated against
t the posts which are already
occupied
by the contractual empl
loyees. Pursuant to the
Advertise
ement No.1/2023, HSSC had
conducted recruitment for
Group D
posts; and posting orders we
ere issued on 24.12.2024 in
respect
of selected candidates. Sev
veral departments of the
responde
ent-State had raised objectio
ons on the ground that
contractu
ual employees were already oc
cupying the said posts, and
no vacanc
cies were available.

14.
It in this background whe
en faced with this peculiar
situation,
that the Government of Harya
na issued Instructions dated
27.12.202
24 to resolve the above situati
on and to ensure joining of
newly sel
lected regular employees, whil
e simultaneously protecting
contractu
ual employees covered under t
the 2024 Act. Vide the said
Instructio
ons dated 27.12.2024, it is direct
ted that: –
Regular H
HSSC Candidates: All newly sele
ected employees were to be
permitted
d to join. Department was no
ot authorized to deny the
joining m
erely on the ground that contra
actual employees are already
working.
Contractu
ual employees (Protected): T
Those employees who had
rendered
five years of Service up to c
ut-off date were not to be
removed.
. Their cases were to be adju
sted. Therefore, employees
engaged b
before cut-off date of 15.08.201
19 will not be relieved.
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.16 17:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

8
CWP-26070-2026 (O & M)

HKRNL E
mployees: Surplus employees
who could not be adjusted
were dire
ected to be relieved.
First in F
First Out (FIFO): The said Circu
ular further prescribed that
amongst
the unprotected HKRNL emplo
oyees, the employee having
longest le
ength of engagement would be r
relieved first.
15.
Subsequently, certain Depa
rtments continued refusing
joining to
o regularly selected candidate
es, citing non-availability of
vacancies
s and sanctioned posts.
16.
Consequentially, a further
clarificatory Circular dated
15.01.202
25 was issued directing that: -
Joining c
cannot be denied: Departmen
nt cannot refuse joining to
selected
candidates merely because c
contractual employees are
working.
Vacancies
s verified: Posting orders ar
e issued after considering
vacancy
data available on designated
portal. Thus, Department
cannot cla
aim non-availability of vacancy.
17.
All the aforesaid facts also fi
nd mention in the impugned
order da
ated 30.07.2025 (Annexure P
P-4) thereby giving cogent
reasons a
as to why services of the petitio
ners are no longer required,
as under:
-
“No. 9422/HKRN: Consequen
nt upon instructions received
from EIC/I&WRD, Panch
hkula vide No. 5810-
40/101/SFNs/A-II/EG-I dated
d 15.07.2025, it is observed
that after joining of regular
Group-D Beldar& case of 30
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.16 17:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

9
CWP-26070-2026 (O & M)

Numbers HKRN Beldar subm
mitted for providing benefit of
Security of Service Act, the de
etail of vacant post of Group
D Beldar is as under:-
Sr.
Total no. of
Regular
Number of Beldar
Vacant
No.
sanctioned post of
Beldar
covered under Security
Post
Beldar
Act
1. 158+19=177 119
30 28

Hen
nce from the above table, it
is very clear that only 28
num
mber Beldar engaged through H
HKRN may be kept in service.
Ho
wever, the detail of Beldar en
ngaged through HKRN is as
und
der:-
Sr.
Total Beldar
Number
r of Beldar
Number of
No.
engaged through
covered
under Security
Beldar not
HKRN against
Act
covered under
sanctioned post of
Security Act
Beldar
1. 98 30
68

Hen
nce from the above table, it is
is very clear that out of 68
num
mber Beldar, only 28 number Be
eldar may be kept in service
and
d hence, 40 number Beldar e
engaged through HKRN are
sur
rplus and their service is not requ
uired.
Hen
nce, as per direction received
from Principal Secretary to
Go
vernment Haryana, Human Reso
ources Department Common
Cad
dre -I vide Memo No. 01/39/20
023-2CC-I dated 15.01.2025
and
d Memo No. 16/17/2025-4HR-II
II dated 03.04.2025 i.e. 'First
In F
First Out', the services of followi
ing Group-D Beldar engaged
thr
rough HKRN (Against the vaca
ant post of Beldar), is not
req
quired as the regular Group-D
Beldar has been joined on
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.16 17:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

10
CWP-26070-2026 (O & M)

the
ese posts and hence, the serv
vices of following Group-D
Bel
ldar engaged through HKR
RN is terminated w.e.f.
31.
07.2025.AN:-
Sr.
No.
Nam
Fath
nam
me &
her’s
me S/Sh.
Designation Employee ID
No.
D Present
D.O.J. Length of
Service
(Years/
Months,
Days) up
to
15.08.2024
place of
posting
8.
Govi
S/o R
Sing
inda
Beldar 31287
Gohana
W/S Sub
Division,
Panipat
01.12.
2019
04Y,
08M,13D
Randhir

h
16 Rishi
S/o R
Sing
i Raj
Randhir
Beldar 31278
Gohana
W/S Sub
Division,
Panipat
01.01.
2020
04Y,
07M,14D
h

18.
From a bare reading of t
the above, it is clear that t
he
responde
ents have examined every aspe
ect of the matter threadbare an
nd
passed th
he impugned order only thereaf
fter. While passing the impugne
ed
order, th
e respondents have duly consi
idered the vacancy position; an
nd
keeping i
in mind the rights of the regu
ularly appointed candidates aft
ter
following
due process of selection throu
gh HSSC; against those who ha
ve
rendered
contractual service for five ye
ears and are therefore protecte
ed
under the
e 2024 Act; and persons such
as the petitioners who have n
not
been app
pointed before the cut-off date
e; thereafter, relieving/impugne
ed
orders of
f surplus employees have been
n issued. In the impugned ord
der
dated 30
0.07.2025 (Annexure P-4) respo
ondent-State has delineated th
he
factual po
osition; as also the reasons for
relieving the petitioners from t
he
post of Be
eldars.
19.
From the above facts, it is
s clear that continuation of t
he
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.16 17:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

11
CWP-26070-2026 (O & M)

petitioner
rs against non-available sanctio
ned post, would be in violation
of
the afor
re-referred Government Instr
uctions dated 27.12.2024 an
nd
15.01.202
25. Very importantly, the sa
aid Instructions have not bee
en
challenge
ed by the petitioners. It is a
also clear that petitioners we
ere
appointed
d after the cut off date of 15.08
8.2019 and, therefore, protectio
on
under the
e Act, 2024 is not available to t
he petitioners. Respondents ha
ve
also cate
egorically stated that services
s of the petitioners have bee
en
relieved a
as there is no available sanctio
oned posts after adjusting regul
lar
appointee
es and the protected contractua
al employees.
20.
The petitioners are unable to
o dispute the above said positio
on.
It is also
o not denied by the petitione
ers that prior to passing of t
he
impugned
d order, petitioners were gran
nted an opportunity of person
nal
hearing.
21.
As such, no infirmity can be f
found in the impugned orders.
22.
Present Civil Writ Petition ac
ccordingly stands dismissed .
23.
Pending application(s), if any
y, shall stand(s) disposed of.


13.11. 20
Neelam

26 ( N

IDHI GUPTA )
JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes
Whether Reportable Yes /
/ No
/ No
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.16 17:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document