Delhi Tamil Education Association (Regd.) vs Government Of Nct Of Delhi & Anr.
- Court
- Delhi High Court
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
th
Reserved on: 15 October, 2026
th
Pronounced on: 17 November, 2026
th
Uploaded on: 17 November, 2026
# CNR No. DLHC010725762025
+ W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & CM APPLs. 60823/2025, 66233/2025, 18976-
18977/2026
DELHI TAMIL EDUCATION ASSOCIATION (REGD.)
. ... Petitioner
Through: Mr. Kartikeye Dang, Advocate.
versus
GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ANR.
. ... Respondents
Through: Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, SC (GNCTD)
with Mr. N.K. Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam,
Mr. Mohnish Sehrawat & Ms. Ananya
Saxena, Adv. for GNCTD.
Mr. Kartik Sharma, Mr. Manhan
Chalwa and Ms. Pearl Sharma,
Advocates for UOI.
# CNR No. DLHC010885062025
+ W.P.(C) 17099/2025 & CM APPL. 7938/2026
PARUL SINGH & ORS. ….Petitioner
Through: Ms. Diya Kapur, Senior Advocate
with Mr. Naibedya Dash, Ms. Shruti
Jain, Mr. Naman Singh, Mr. Anil
Dalal, Mr. Sumit and Mr. Kshitiz,
Advocates.
versus
GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS. ….Respondents
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 1 of 31
Through: Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, SC (GNCTD)
with Mr. N.K. Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam,
Mr. Mohnish Sehrawat & Ms. Ananya
Saxena, Adv. for GNCTD.
Mr. Devvrat Yadav, Mr. Kartik
Sharma, Mr. Manhan Chalwa and Ms.
Pearl Sharma, Advocates for UOI. Mr.
Kartikeye Dang, Adv. for R3.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
JUDGMENT
SANJEEV NARULA, J.:
1. Established in 1923 to promote the educational interests of Delhi’s Tamil
linguistic minority, the Delhi Tamil Education Association [“DTEA”] was registered
th
as a society on 14 March, 1940. The Association administers seven recognised,
government-aided minority schools which, it states, cater to nearly 7,000 students and
employ approximately 400 teaching and non-teaching staff. The schools receive 95%
grant-in-aid from the Government towards the salary expenditure of their staff. Their
status as linguistic minority educational institutions protected under Article 30(1) of
the Constitution is not in dispute.
2. These connected petitions arise from DTEA’s recruitment of 100 teaching and
non-teaching employees to its aided schools and the refusal of the Directorate of
Education [“DoE”] to release grant-in-aid towards their salaries on the ground that
the appointments suffer from various deficiencies. While DTEA in W.P.(C)
14795/2025 challenges the decision refusing grant-in-aid, the employees in W.P.(C)
17099/2025 seek payment of outstanding salaries, regular disbursement of future
salaries, release of the requisite grant-in-aid and interest on delayed payments. The
controversy thus raises questions concerning the management’s autonomy in making
appointments, the statutory conditions governing the release of public funds and the
liability to remunerate employees for services rendered.
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 2 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
Background
3. The present dispute is the sequel to an earlier round of litigation between DTEA
th
and the DoE. By judgment dated 28 May, 2024 in W.P.(C) 15276/2023, this Court
set aside the DoE’s communication rejecting DTEA’s request to fill vacant posts on
the ground that its schools did not have Managing Committees. Having noted that
DTEA’s schools were aided linguistic minority schools, the Court held that DTEA
was entitled to make appointments against vacant posts of Principals and teachers
without prior approval of the DoE. The Court further held that the Selection
Committees would be constituted in accordance with Rule 96(3)(a) of the Delhi
School Education Rules, 1973 [“DSE Rules”] in the case of Principals and Rule
96(3)(b) in the case of teachers, with the role of the DoE’s nominees restricted in
terms of Rule 96(3-A).
4. The aforesaid judgment was affirmed by the Division Bench of this Court on
nd
22 July, 2024 in LPA 642/2024, which also bound DTEA to the statement made on
its behalf regarding strict compliance with Rule 96(3). The Supreme Court dismissed
th
the further challenge on 6 December, 2024 in SLP(C) 28295/2024. These
proceedings thus did not impinge upon DTEA’s authority to proceed with
recruitment, subject to the prescribed selection procedure. They did not, however,
examine the qualifications of the candidates subsequently appointed, nor determine
their individual eligibility for grant-in-aid.
th
5. Pursuant to the judgment dated 28 May, 2024, DTEA advertised 107
th
vacancies across its 7 schools through 3 newspapers on 26 June, 2024. According to
DTEA, 3,843 applications were received and scrutinised, and candidates were
thereafter shortlisted and interviewed. Of the advertised vacancies, 100 were filled.
These appointments comprise 4 Principals, 42 Assistant Teachers, 35 other teaching
staff (including TGTs, PGTs, specialised teachers and Librarians), 12 clerical and
laboratory employees, and 7 Peons and Malis.
6. DTEA asserts that, between April and May 2025, it forwarded the appointment
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 3 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
dossiers to the respective Zonal Offices of the DoE, seeking release of grant-in-aid
towards the salaries of the newly appointed employees. The DoE acknowledges
receipt of the appointment files but maintains that the records and subsequent
clarifications furnished by DTEA were incomplete or inadequate. Following further
rd
correspondence between the parties, this Court, by order dated 23 September, 2025,
directed the DoE to issue a comprehensive communication identifying specific
deficiencies with reference to the governing law, release proportionate grant-in-aid in
respect of appointments against which no discrepancy was raised, and take a final
decision on the remaining appointments within the stipulated timelines. Pursuant
st
thereto, the DoE communicated its objections on 1 October, 2025, to which DTEA
th th
furnished a response on 8 October, 2025. By order dated 4 November, 2025, the
DoE rejected grant-in-aid for all 100 appointments.
7. The objections raised by the DoE principally concern the professional
qualifications of Assistant Teachers. They also extend to the age, experience and
educational qualifications prescribed for other posts, the availability of sanctioned
vacancies, the permissible modes of recruitment, the constitution of Selection
Committees, the process of shortlisting and assessment, verification of candidates’
credentials and compliance with reservation requirements. While some objections
concern the recruitment exercise as a whole, others relate to the eligibility or
appointment of individual employees in particular schools.
8. The employees in W.P.(C) 17099/2025 state that they joined their respective
posts pursuant to formal appointment letters but have received no salary. However,
th
the appointment letter dated 16 January, 2025, placed on record, stipulates that salary
would be paid only upon receipt of grant-in-aid from the DoE. It further provides that
salary and allowances shall stand forfeited if the employee resigns during probation.
Principal Submissions of the Parties
9. Mr. Kartikeye Dang, counsel for DTEA, submits that the earlier judgments
have recognised its right, as a linguistic minority institution, to appoint Principals and
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 4 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
teachers without prior departmental approval, subject to the prescribed qualifications
and selection procedure. The DoE, he contends, cannot use the grant-in-aid process
to impose restrictions that it could not lawfully insist upon at the recruitment stage.
He maintains that DTEA advertised the vacancies, scrutinised the applications and
conducted selections through duly constituted Committees. Despite repeated requests,
the DoE declined to nominate its representatives because it proposed to challenge the
earlier judgments, although neither had been stayed. As regards Assistant Teachers,
th th
he relies upon the Recruitment Rules dated 24 February, 2022 and published on 4
March, 2022, which, according to DTEA, recognised B.Ed. as an eligible
qualification subject to stipulated conditions. He argues that their subsequent
rescission could not alter the eligibility criteria governing recruitment already
commenced. He also disputes the objections concerning qualifications, experience
and sanctioned vacancies for other teaching posts. Regarding clerical and laboratory
posts, DTEA maintains that direct recruitment was undertaken because eligible
candidates for promotion were unavailable. It further relies upon the post-fixation
records to contest the objections concerning the appointment of Peons and Malis.
10. Ms. Diya Kapur, Senior Counsel appearing for the employees, supports
DTEA’s position on the legality of the recruitment, including the applicability of the
2022 notification. She submits that the employees joined pursuant to formal
appointment letters and discharged their duties without receiving salaries, compelling
some of them to resign. She relies upon Rule 98(4) of the DSE Rules and contends
that the appointments stood approved in the absence of disapproval by the DoE within
the prescribed period following statutory communication. The employees also invoke
Section 10 of the Delhi School Education Act, 1973 [“DSE Act”], in support of their
entitlement to salary and allowances in accordance with the statutory mandate. They
further submit that the dispute between DTEA and the DoE over the release of grant-
in-aid cannot deprive them of remuneration for services already rendered.
11. Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, SC (GNCTD) appearing for the DoE, submits that the
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 5 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
constitutional protection afforded to minority institutions does not exempt
appointments for which public funds are sought from compliance with statutory
rd
recruitment requirements. The DoE relies upon the Recruitment Rules notified on 23
January, 1989, which prescribe JBT/BTC qualifications for Assistant Teachers in
aided schools. It contends that the 2022 notification applied only to recruitment in
government schools and maintains that B.Ed. is not equivalent to the prescribed
elementary-teacher training qualification. The DoE also questions the constitution of
the Selection Committees, the shortlisting and assessment procedures, verification of
candidates, compliance with reservation requirements and the completeness of the
recruitment records. Its screening reports inter alia identify further deficiencies
concerning qualifications, experience, age and sanctioned vacancies for teaching
posts. In respect of non-teaching posts, the DoE raises objections concerning
promotional avenues, typing requirements and restrictions on direct recruitment.
According to the DoE, neither the minority status of the schools nor the services
rendered by the appointees can oblige the State to finance appointments made in
breach of mandatory recruitment requirements.
Governing Principles
12. Article 30(1) protects the right of a minority educational institution to establish
and administer an institution of its choice. This right includes the freedom to appoint
its teaching and non-teaching staff. The grant of State aid does not alter the nature or
character of the minority institution or dilute its right to administer. The right is,
however, not absolute and does not include the right to maladminister. The State may
prescribe eligibility conditions and qualifications for appointment and impose
regulations to ensure educational standards, academic excellence and the welfare of
students and teachers. It may also impose conditions relevant to the proper utilisation
of grant-in-aid, provided they do not involve a surrender of the institution’s
substantial right of management or otherwise impair its minority character. These
principles emerge from T.M.A. Pai Foundation & Ors. v. State of Karnataka &
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 6 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
1 2
Ors. ; Secy., Malankara Syrian Catholic College v. T. Jose & Ors. and Sk. Mohd.
3
Rafique v. Managing Committee, Contai Rahamania High Madrasah & Ors. . The
respective spheres of the institution’s managerial autonomy and the State’s regulatory
authority must, therefore, be recognised and preserved.
13. Section 8 DSE Act provides for the prescription of minimum qualifications and
conditions of service. Section 10 inter alia regulates the payment of salaries and
allowances in aided schools. The second proviso to Rule 98(2) DSE Rules dispenses
with the requirement of approval for appointments in aided minority schools. It does
not, however, dispense with the prescribed qualifications, the requirement of a
sanctioned vacancy or other binding statutory requirements. Rule 66(2) excludes the
pay of an unqualified teacher from admissible grant-in-aid, save where Rule 98(5)
applies or the applicable exemption has been granted.
14. The management’s authority to make appointments without prior departmental
approval must be distinguished from the eligibility of those appointments for grant-
in-aid. The former does not dispense with compliance with the statutory requirements
governing recruitment and eligibility. At the same time, the department cannot, under
the guise of examining eligibility for State aid, assume control over the management’s
choice of candidates or impose restrictions inconsistent with its rights under Article
4
30(1) of the Constitution. In Queen Mary’s School v. UOI , the Court examined, inter
alia , Rules 47 and 64 of the DSE Rules and held that the provisions concerning
absorption of surplus employees and conditions for grant of aid could not be applied
in a manner that infringed the management rights of aided minority schools. The
Court separately considered Rule 96 and held that minority aided schools were not
bound to adopt the Selection Committee composition prescribed under the said Rule.
The applicability of Rule 96 to minority aided schools and the extent of the DoE’s
1
(2002) 8 SCC 481.
2
(2007) 1 SCC 386.
3
(2020) 6 SCC 689.
4
2011 SCC OnLine Del 4884.
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 7 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
regulatory authority over their recruitment have since been referred to a Larger Bench
5
in Government of NCT of Delhi v. Raisina Bengali School . The reference does not,
however, displace the specific directions issued in the earlier proceedings between
DTEA and the DoE, which required DTEA to comply with Rule 96(3). The present
recruitment requires examination in light of those directions.
15. The scrutiny of the individual objections must, therefore, focus on the legal
requirement alleged to have been breached and the consequence prescribed for that
breach. The absence of an essential qualification stands on a different footing from a
document awaiting verification. Similarly, the existence of a sanctioned vacancy does
not, by itself, establish that the post could be filled through direct recruitment. Nor
can a defect in one appointment justify rejection of the others unless the DoE
establishes that the irregularity extends to those appointments or affects the
recruitment process as a whole. Each objection must accordingly be examined on its
own merits.
Post-Wise Examination of Recruitment Objections
Assistant Teachers
16. The DoE objects to the appointment of Assistant Teachers possessing B.Ed.
degrees but lacking the JBT/BTC qualification prescribed under the 1989 Recruitment
Rules for aided schools. DTEA, however, relies upon the 2022 notification, which
recognised graduation with B.Ed. as an eligible qualification, subject to stipulated
conditions. The question therefore is whether the 2022 notification governed
recruitment to DTEA’s aided schools or whether the 1989 Recruitment Rules
continued to apply.
17. Rule 100 DSE Rules provides that until separate rules specifying the minimum
qualifications for teachers in schools, whether aided or not, are made, the
qualifications for teachers in aided schools shall be those prescribed for corresponding
5 rd
LPA 372/2025, order dated 3 February, 2026 (Delhi High Court).
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 8 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
posts in Government schools. The DoE relies on the Recruitment Rules notified on
rd th
23 January, 1989, bearing No. F.5/ADC/RR/AT/88/241-644 and circulated on 27
October, 1993, for the post of Assistant Teacher. Those Rules prescribe Higher/Senior
Secondary or Intermediate qualification, together with study of Science and
Mathematics up to Matriculation, and JBT/BTC. The JBT/BTC requirement is
relaxable on the recommendation of the Selection Committee where the candidate
possesses a higher teachers training qualification.
th
18. The notification dated 24 February, 2022 was issued under the proviso to
Article 309 for recruitment to the post of Assistant Teacher (Primary) in the DoE. It
expressly superseded the 2013 Recruitment Rules governing that post. It neither refers
to nor purports to supersede the 1989 Recruitment Rules applicable to aided schools.
Although the 2022 notification included a B.Ed. route among the prescribed
qualifications, it was framed for recruitment to the DoE’s own establishment and did
not extend that route to recognised private aided schools. The two sets of Rules, thus,
govern distinct services. The DoE itself continues to rely on the 1989 Rules as
applicable to aided schools. Nothing placed on record establishes that those Rules
were withdrawn or replaced.
19. The 2022 notification was withdrawn by a notification published in the Delhi
th
Gazette Extraordinary on 15 October, 2024. This was after the vacancies had been
rd
advertised but before the Assistant Teacher Selection Committee met on 23
th
November, 2024. The withdrawal notification was circulated on 28 October, 2024.
This chronology, however, does not advance DTEA’s case. The Supreme Court, in
6
Tej Prakash Pathak & Ors. v. Rajasthan High Court & Ors. , held that the eligibility
criteria notified at the commencement of the recruitment process cannot be changed
midway. This principle protects the eligibility criteria lawfully applicable to the
recruitment from being altered after the process has commenced. It does not, however,
6
(2025) 2 SCC 1.
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 9 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
permit a recruiting body to rely upon a different set of Rules which did not govern the
posts in the first place. Since the 2022 notification did not govern the Assistant
Teacher posts in question, its subsequent withdrawal does not alter the applicable
eligibility criteria.
20. This Court has considered the same 1989 Recruitment Rules in Divya Bhaskar
7
& Anr. v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Anr . There, a government-aided school had
initially advertised vacancies for Assistant Teachers, recognising JBT/ETT and
Graduation with B.Ed. as alternative qualifications. It subsequently issued a
corrigendum clarifying that candidates having only Graduation with B.Ed. would not
be considered for the post. The DoE questioned the corrigendum, including on the
ground that it had been issued without prior approval, and refused grant-in-aid for the
teachers subsequently appointed. The Court held that B.Ed. was neither a qualification
prescribed by the 1989 Rules nor a higher teachers training qualification permitting
relaxation of the JBT/BTC requirement. It upheld the corrigendum and declared the
appointments made pursuant to it valid, noting that the DoE’s nominee had
participated in the selection process and that the Selection Committee had proceeded
without dissent. Grant-in-aid was consequently directed to be released. Although the
applicability of the 1989 Rules was not in dispute in that case, their interpretation is
relevant here. In Divya Bhaskar , the school excluded candidates possessing only
Graduation with B.Ed., whereas DTEA relies upon the 2022 notification to justify the
appointment of candidates possessing B.Ed. without the prescribed elementary-
teacher training.
8
21. In P.M. Latha & Anr. v. State of Kerala & Ors. and Yogesh Kumar & Ors.
9
v. Govt. of NCT, Delhi & Ors. , the Supreme Court rejected the contention that B.Ed.
is a higher qualification than TTC (Teacher’s Training Certificate). It held that the
7
2024 SCC OnLine Del 7720.
8
(2003) 3 SCC 541.
9
(2003) 3 SCC 548.
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 10 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
training imparted through B.Ed. equips candidates to teach classes above primary,
whereas TTC imparts specialised training for teaching children at the primary level.
10
Devesh Sharma v. UOI & Ors. reiterated this distinction and held that B.Ed. was
not a qualification, much less a better or higher qualification, for teaching at the
primary level. It accordingly upheld setting aside of the NCTE notification, which
had introduced B.Ed. as an eligible qualification for primary teachers. Subsequently,
11
in Navin Kumar & Ors. v. UOI & Ors. , the Supreme Court clarified the limited
protection available to B.Ed.-qualified candidates appointed before the date of
th
decision in Devesh Sharma i.e., 11 August, 2023. That protection was confined to
candidates who had been appointed without any condition imposed by a Court, were
in regular employment and had been appointed pursuant to an advertisement which
stipulated B.Ed. as a valid qualification. Mere selection or participation in the
recruitment process did not suffice.
22. DTEA cannot also invoke the relaxation provision under the 1989 Recruitment
Rules merely by describing B.Ed. as a higher teachers training qualification. Such
qualification must satisfy the requirements as lawfully construed; the academic title
alone is insufficient. Further, under Rule 97 DSE Rules, any recommendation of the
Selection Committee to relax an essential qualification cannot be given effect to
without the Director’s prior approval. No such approved relaxation has been
established on the record. The exemption from approval of appointments under Rule
98(2) does not extend to relaxation of essential qualifications under Rule 97.
23. DTEA’s written submissions identify 39 selections through the B.Ed. route and
3 through the JBC/BTC route. The DoE’s screening material, however, refers in
places to 43 appointments and alleges that 42 candidates lack JBT/BTC. The
appointment schedules and original merit sheet, rather than these inconsistent
aggregate figures, must govern the individual exercise. Three appointees merit
10
(2023) 18 SCC 339.
11
2024 SCC OnLine SC 2360.
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 11 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
specific mention: S. Pinkala (R.K. Puram), V. Subramanya Siva (Mandir Marg) and
V. Shamilee (Mandir Marg), whose names appear in the Senior Secondary/JBT
candidates category of the merit sheet. Their exact qualifications, the recognition of
the awarding institutions and their eligibility on the relevant date require verification.
Mr. Subramanya Siva is stated to have resigned. That fact is relevant to the period of
service, but not to the qualification required at the time of recruitment.
24. Thus, 1989 Recruitment Rules govern the appointment of Assistant Teachers
in DTEA’s aided schools. B.Ed., without the prescribed JBT/BTC qualification, does
not satisfy the essential training requirement, nor can it be treated as a higher teachers
training qualification for the purpose of relaxation. The protection recognised in
th
Navin Kumar is confined to certain appointments made before 11 August, 2023,
whereas DTEA commenced its recruitment in 2024. A qualification acquired
subsequently cannot retrospectively satisfy the eligibility requirements governing
recruitment. In the absence of the prescribed qualification or a lawful relaxation or
exemption, an appointment founded upon B.Ed. cannot qualify for regular grant-in-
aid merely because the candidate was selected, appointed or permitted to teach.
Principals
25. DTEA appointed four Principals through direct recruitment. The DoE
questions both the method of recruitment and the eligibility of the appointees. The
former objection is answered by the Division Bench decision in St. Anthony’s Girls
12
Sen. Sec. School & Ors. v. Govt. of N.C.T. of Delhi & Ors. . This Court struck down
Column 8 of the impugned recruitment rules, which prescribed promotion, failing
which direct recruitment, for the post of Principal. It held that the requirement
impermissibly interfered with the minority management’s right to choose the Head of
the Institution. The Court clarified that the post was to be filled by selection from
amongst persons who had offered their candidature, with the choice of candidate
12
2008 SCC OnLine Del 1174.
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 12 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
remaining with the Selection Committee. DTEA was, therefore, not required to
exhaust the promotional channel before resorting to direct recruitment. This
autonomy, however, does not dispense with the prescribed qualifications, experience
and other lawful conditions of eligibility.
26. The qualifications and experience prescribed for Principals in recognised
private schools are governed by the 1980 Recruitment Rules, as amended in 1991.
th
DTEA also relies upon the Government notification dated 30 January, 2023,
prescribing an upper age limit of 50 years for the corresponding post in Government
schools. Although that notification does not, by itself, amend the Recruitment Rules
applicable to private schools, Rule 104 DSE Rules links the age limits for recruitment
in recognised private schools to those prescribed for corresponding Government
posts. The DoE cannot, therefore, reject an appointment by merely invoking the
earlier limit of 45 years without considering the effect of Rule 104 and the subsequent
notification. In St. Anthony’s Girls Sr. Sec. School & Anr. v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
13
& Anr. , this Court held that the prescribed age limit constitutes an essential
qualification for appointment as Principal. It further held that the provision for
relaxation under the recruitment rules must be read with Rule 97 DSE Rules. The
competent authority is, therefore, required to examine a request for relaxation and
pass a reasoned order. Any such relaxation must also satisfy the requirements of the
governing Rules, including prior approval under Rule 97.
27. The DoE records that Ms. Karthika S.N. had 9 years, 11 months and 14 days
th
of qualifying experience as on 16 July, 2024, after excluding the service rendered
nd
before she obtained her B.Ed. degree on 2 August, 2014. DTEA, on the other hand,
relies upon her teaching service from May 2014 to June 2024 at St. Thomas Mar
Thoma Higher Secondary School and SMR National School. In B. Ramakichenin @
14
Balagandhi v. UOI & Ors. , the Supreme Court considered whether the prescribed
13 th
W.P.(C) 14149/2009, order dated 28 February, 2017 (Delhi High Court).
14
(2008) 1 SCC 362.
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 13 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
experience had to be acquired after obtaining the requisite educational qualification.
It held that experience acquired after obtaining the degree could not, merely on that
account, be treated as higher than experience acquired before it. In the absence of any
such stipulation in the prescribed criteria, a requirement that the experience must
follow acquisition of the degree could not be read into them. This principle was
15
applied by this Court in Santosh Pal Meena v. UPSC & Ors. , which concerned the
reckoning of teaching experience for appointment as Principal. The Court held that
the Recruitment Rules required an aggregate of ten years’ teaching experience, along
with the prescribed educational qualifications. Since the Rules did not stipulate that
the experience must be acquired after obtaining the required degree, the respondents’
interpretation to that effect was not borne out. The same principle applies here. Unless
the Recruitment Rules governing the post expressly require the prescribed teaching
experience to be acquired after obtaining B.Ed., the period preceding that cannot be
excluded merely on that account. The nature, duration and admissibility of the service
relied upon by Ms. Karthika S.N. must, however, be verified under the applicable
Rules.
28. Ms. Yuvaranni S. relies principally on approximately 10 years’ experience as
an Assistant Professor in a college. The DoE, however, contends that the prescribed
experience is 10 years as a TGT, PGT or Vice-Principal in a school. DTEA maintains
that her experience as an Assistant Professor is higher in rank and academic content
and cannot be treated as disqualifying. The question, however, is not whether college
teaching is academically higher, but whether it satisfies the experience prescribed
under the applicable Recruitment Rules. On the material presently relied upon, the
prescribed experience has not been established. Her experience as an Assistant
Professor, by itself, cannot be treated as a substitute for the experience specified under
the Rules.
15
2014 SCC OnLine Del 3759.
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 14 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
29. Ms. G.M. Prema’s case turns principally on age. The DoE invokes the 45-year
limit prescribed under the Recruitment Rules, while DTEA relies on the 2023
notification prescribing an upper age limit of 50 years for the corresponding
Government post. The DoE cannot sustain the objection merely by invoking the 45-
year limit. It must examine the issue in light of Rule 104 of the DSE Rules, and the
principles set out above, with reference to her age on the closing date.
30. Ms. Sumathi M.’s case raises distinct questions concerning teaching experience
claimed from 2009, degrees obtained during the period of service, discrepancies in
the experience certificates and recognition of her Shiksha Visharad qualification.
DTEA maintains that the subsequent acquisition of B.A. and B.Ed. degrees did not
interrupt her earlier teaching experience and that the Shiksha Visharad qualification
was recognised when obtained. The DoE disputes the nature, duration and
authenticity of the claimed service and the recognition of that qualification. These
issues require examination of the applicable Recruitment Rules and the original
educational, employment and experience records.
31. The objections concerning the four Principal appointments do not raise a
common issue. The challenge to the mode of recruitment fails in view of the law
governing the autonomy of minority institutions to choose their Head. The remaining
objections turn on the qualifications, age and experience prescribed under the
applicable Recruitment Rules and must be examined separately in the case of each
appointee. A finding in one case cannot determine another.
Other Teaching Posts and Librarians
32. The objections to the remaining TGTs, PGTs and Librarians concern both
eligibility and proof of eligibility. Mr. J. Bharat Kumar, PGT (Biology), holds an
M.Sc. described in the record as Plant Biology and Plant Biotechnology. The DoE
relies on the Recruitment Rules which include Biotechnology among the prescribed
Master’s subjects, subject to the candidate having studied Botany and Zoology at
graduation level. The question cannot be decided merely by comparing the
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 15 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
nomenclature of the degree with the prescribed subjects. The DoE must examine the
actual course and award and verify the subjects studied at graduation. It must also
reconcile the conflicting entries in its own screening report, which records B.Ed. in
the qualification column but alleges in the remarks that the candidate does not possess
that qualification.
33. Ms. Divyanshi, PGT (Computer Science), relies upon an MCA and teaching
experience at G.R. Memorial Sr. Sec. Public School. The Recruitment Rules notified
rd
on 3 March, 2015 prescribe one year’s teaching experience for the MCA route. The
DoE has counted only the experience acquired after completion of her MCA and
th
contends that she had 9 months of such experience by the closing date of 16 July,
2024. The question is whether the applicable Recruitment Rules require the
experience to be acquired after obtaining the MCA. If they do not, the earlier teaching
experience cannot be excluded merely because it preceded the degree. The total
duration and nature of the experience must be verified from the original service
records and the certificate issued by the school.
th
34. For Librarians, the Recruitment Rules dated 16 January, 2003 prescribe an
academic qualification in Library Science and a separate requirement of library
experience or the specified computer-application qualification. Ms. Divya relies on
B.A., B.Lib. and M.Lib. degrees and university verification. The DoE must address
those documents and the additional requirement instead of maintaining an
unsupported assertion that she lacks a bachelor’s degree. Mr. Suresh Krishna V. relies
on B.Sc., an integrated Library Science qualification and a postgraduate diploma in
Library Automation and Networking. Whether his diploma satisfies the separate
computer-application alternative depends on its duration, content and any legally
recognised equivalence. An advanced academic award does not automatically
dispense with an independently prescribed qualification.
35. The DoE has also raised objections concerning NCTE recognition of the B.Ed.
programmes completed by certain TGT and PGT appointees, including Ms. Akriti
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 16 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
Dhama, Ms. Saloni Kaushik, Ms. Isha, Ms. Jyoti Dangi, Ms. Sweeti Tomar, Ms. Parul
Singh and Mr. Vineet Kumar. DTEA contends that the B.Ed. degrees were verified
by the respective universities and that the verification reports were supplied to the
DoE. The two inquiries are distinct. Verification of a degree by the university which
issued it does not, by itself, establish that the institution and the B.Ed. programme had
NCTE recognition for the relevant academic session. The DoE must examine the
recognition status of the institution and programme for the period in which each
candidate pursued the course. Equally, the fact that a verification report was produced
at a later stage does not, by itself, establish that recognition was absent when the
degree was obtained.
36. Other objections concern vacancies rather than qualifications. Mr. Anmol
Mehra’s appointment as TGT (English) is questioned on the ground that the vacancy
arose upon the promotion of Ms. C. Vijaylakshmi to PGT (English), which the DoE
claims was not approved by the competent authority. DTEA states that the promotion
st
took effect on 1 November, 2022, and that the proposal for pay fixation was
th
submitted to the DoE on 25 April, 2023, but remained pending for want of a DoE
nominee to the DPC. The promotion order, applicable procedure, service records and
sanctioned strength must be examined to determine whether the promotion validly
took effect and resulted in a vacancy. Pending pay fixation, by itself, does not
establish that no vacancy arose. In the cases of Ms. Sakshi Chopra and Ms. Himanshi,
appointed as TGTs (Computer Science), the DoE alleges that they were selected
against vacancies advertised for TGTs (Natural Science). DTEA disputes this and
th
relies on the advertisement dated 26 June, 2024, which it states included 7 vacancies
for TGT (Computer Science). The advertisement, school-wise sanctioned strength,
Selection Committee minutes and appointment orders must be examined to determine
whether Computer Science vacancies were available and advertised. A clerical
misdescription may be corrected, but recruitment against a vacancy advertised for a
different subject cannot be sustained.
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 17 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
37. The DoE also questions the appointments of Mr. Naman Sharma, TGT
(Computer Science), and Mr. Chirag, TGT (Special Education), on the ground that
the corresponding vacancies have not been established. DTEA maintains that both
posts were sanctioned under the staffing assessment undertaken by the DoE for 2022-
23. The DoE must therefore verify whether sanctioned vacancies existed in the
respective schools on the dates of appointment, having regard to the 2022-23 staffing
assessment and the relevant records. Its inability to ascertain a vacancy cannot,
without examining those records, be treated as proof that no such vacancy existed.
The verification must remain confined to the specific objections raised.
Clerical and Laboratory Appointments
38. Rule 102 prescribes for non-teaching employees the qualifications applicable
to corresponding government-school posts. Rule 108 provides for filling aided-school
vacancies by promotion or direct recruitment in accordance with the rules made by
the Administrator. Rule 108, by itself, does not impose a universal preference for
promotion. The applicable Recruitment Rules must establish the source of recruitment
and any priority or quota. A departmental description of a post as “non-selection”
cannot override the governing Recruitment Rules.
39. Five UDCs were recruited directly. The DoE contends that the posts were to be
filled by promotion from the feeder cadre of LDCs, failing which by direct
recruitment. It alleges that eligible LDCs, including one Mr. A. Sivaram, were
available but were not considered. DTEA disputes this and states that no eligible
th
candidate was available for promotion. Mr. Sivaram was appointed as an LDC on 11
March, 2022. His presence in the feeder cadre, by itself, does not establish that he
satisfied the prescribed conditions for promotion on the relevant date. The applicable
Recruitment Rules, qualifying service, seniority and consideration of eligible
employees must be verified from the original records. DTEA also relies upon an
th
earlier communication dated 20 September, 2017, issued by the DoE, which it states
granted clearance for direct recruitment to a UDC post on account of the non-
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 18 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
availability of a suitable candidate in the LDC feeder cadre. The scope of that
communication must, however, be examined. It cannot, without more, be treated as a
standing approval for the present recruitment.
40. Mr. Sivaram’s appointment as Head Clerk has been questioned because he was
serving as an LDC when he applied. The DoE alleges that he had neither obtained
prior permission to apply nor submitted a technical resignation before joining. The
st
record, however, contains DTEA’s NOC dated 1 July, 2024 and Mr. Sivaram’s
st
technical resignation dated 21 March, 2025, submitted pursuant to the offer of
th
appointment dated 19 March, 2025. The effect of these documents must be examined
in the light of the applicable service rules. His existing employment, by itself, does
not establish ineligibility. Any surviving objection must identify the specific rule
allegedly breached. In the case of the other Head Clerk, Mr. Abhishon V., DTEA
states that the degree verification from SRM University, Tamil Nadu, was received
and placed on record. The DoE must examine that report. Non-production of
verification at an earlier stage does not, by itself, establish that the degree is invalid.
41. The two LDCs, Ms. Anu Divya R. and Mr. R. Mahesh, are questioned for
compliance with a typing requirement of 35 words per minute. DTEA refers to typing
tests, including a sheet produced for Ms. Anu Divya. The contemporaneous tests and
results must be examined separately. For the three Laboratory Assistants, Mr. Sachin,
Mr. Annu Kumar and Mr. Sagar Sharma, the issue is whether direct recruitment could
be resorted to before promotion. The DoE relies on Mr. K. Murugesan, a serving
Peon; DTEA questions his promotional eligibility and appraisal record. Length of
service is not, without the prescribed conditions being met, proof of eligibility for
promotion. Neither side’s assertion can substitute for the applicable Recruitment
Rules and the relevant service records.
Peons and Malis
42. The seven Group-D appointments comprise 2 Peons and 5 Malis. The DoE
describes the posts as abolished or recruitment as prohibited following
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 19 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
th
implementation of the 6 Pay Commission recommendations. DTEA produces post-
fixation records for 2022-23 reflecting sanctioned posts, including Mali posts. The
th
departmental order dated 4 November, 2020 refers to a restriction on constituting
committees for direct recruitment to Peon/Class-IV posts. It does not, by its terms,
demonstrate abolition of every Peon or Mali post.
43. The existence of a sanctioned post does not confer an indefeasible right to fill
it by direct recruitment. The State is competent to regulate or abolish posts as a matter
of policy, having regard to financial constraints and administrative efficiency. In State
16
of U.P. & Ors. v. Principal, Abhay Nandan Inter College & Ors. , the Supreme
Court, while considering a policy decision of the State of Uttar Pradesh, upheld the
abolition of permanent Class-IV posts in aided institutions and the replacement of the
method of appointment with outsourcing. It also held that an institution receiving aid
must comply with the conditions attached to it and cannot insist upon aid on its own
terms. However, that decision proceeded on the basis of an express policy decision
incorporated in the applicable Regulations. The DoE must, therefore, identify the
legal instrument by which the alleged restriction was imposed, its scope and period
of operation, and establish whether it extends to the posts in question. It must also
reconcile the asserted restriction with the post-fixation orders for 2022-23. The
question is not merely whether the posts were sanctioned, but whether the applicable
policy or Recruitment Rules permitted them to be filled in the manner adopted by
DTEA.
Common Objections to the Recruitment Process
44. The DoE also alleges procedural defects which, if established, could affect
appointments across categories. These objections require examination independent of
the qualifications of individual appointees. They cannot be accepted merely because
they are described in the DoE’s screening reports as evidence of a pre-determined
16
(2021) 15 SCC 600.
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 20 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
recruitment exercise.
Constitution of Selection Committees
rd
45. DTEA sought departmental nominees by communications dated 23 August
th rd
and 20 September, 2024. On 3 October, 2024, the Deputy Director of Education,
Zone VII, informed DTEA that the DoE proposed to challenge the Division Bench
judgment and instructed that the recruitment be kept in abeyance, pending outcome
of those proceedings. However, neither that judgment nor the Single Judge’s
th
judgment dated 28 May, 2024 had been stayed. The mere proposal to institute further
proceedings, additionally, did not suspend their operation. Accordingly, where DTEA
duly sought departmental nominees for a particular Selection Committee and afforded
the DoE a reasonable opportunity to participate, the absence of departmental
representatives attributable to the DoE’s refusal or failure to act cannot, by itself,
invalidate the selection. Whether these conditions stand satisfied in respect of each
Selection Committee must be determined from the contemporaneous correspondence.
46. The aforesaid finding does not dispense with DTEA’s obligation to constitute
Selection Committees in accordance with the governing requirements. The earlier
judgments expressly required compliance with Rule 96(3) DSE Rules, and the
Division Bench bound DTEA to its undertaking to that effect. Rule 96(3-A) restricts
the role of the specified departmental nominees to that of advisers, without voting
rights or control over the selection. Rule 96(3-B), in turn, permits the Managing
Committee of a minority school to determine the numerical strength of its Selection
Committee. Neither provision dispenses with the other applicable requirements under
Rule 96(3). The DoE’s failure to nominate its representatives cannot be treated as a
defect attributable to DTEA. Equally, it cannot excuse any independent deficiency in
the constitution of the Committee.
rd
47. The minutes dated 23 November, 2024 record that the Assistant Teacher
Selection Committee comprised the Chairman, two Educationists, a Professor of
Tamil (Subject Expert) and the Principal of DTEA’s Lodi Estate School. They
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 21 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
establish that a common Committee met and made recommendations for 42 Assistant
Teacher vacancies. They do not, however, establish compliance with Rule 96(3)(b) in
respect of appointments across all 7 schools. The Rule requires the Head of the School
to form part of the Selection Committee, besides the other members prescribed for the
relevant category. The participation of the Principal of Lodi Estate School does not,
by itself, establish compliance in respect of vacancies in the remaining schools.
DTEA’s centralised management may explain the common selection exercise, but
cannot displace the requirements governing the Committee’s composition. The DoE
shall therefore verify compliance school-wise and post-wise, applying the findings in
the preceding paragraphs and without reopening the legal consequence of its own
failure to nominate representatives.
Assessment, Shortlisting and Verification
th
48. The DoE alleges that DTEA departed from its marking scheme dated 26
February, 2014, by awarding more than the prescribed five marks for the interview
component. DTEA maintains that it followed the departmental scheme for all posts,
except where no such scheme existed. In Kiran Jain v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi &
17
Ors. , the Division Bench held that, in the absence of a marking scheme/evaluation
matrix prescribed under the DSE Rules, the DoE could not impose its marking scheme
upon an aided minority institution. While the State may prescribe eligibility criteria
for appointment, the selection and ranking of candidates who satisfy those criteria,
and the manner of their assessment, fall within the rights of a minority institution
under Article 30(1). The DoE cannot question the sufficiency or propriety of the
selection process merely because the institution adopted its own evaluation matrix.
Here, DTEA’s resolution records its decision to follow the departmental marking
scheme wherever one existed. The Assistant Teacher selection records separately
account for award points and interview marks. The dispute as to whether DTEA
17
2023 SCC OnLine Del 6353.
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 22 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
exceeded the prescribed five-mark limit may be examined with reference to the
contemporaneous selection records. Such scrutiny, however, cannot extend to
reassessing the merits or ranking of otherwise eligible candidates.
49. The DoE also questions the shortlisting and interview process for Assistant
Teachers. The Selection Committee’s minutes record 477 applications, of which 53
candidates were found eligible, 52 appeared for interview and 42 were selected. These
figures do not, by themselves, establish a pre-determined selection, particularly when
no prescribed ratio of candidates to vacancies has been identified. Although the DoE
nd
alleges that interview notices were issued on 22 November, 2024 for interviews the
following day, 52 of the 53 shortlisted candidates attended. Any finding of unfair
exclusion or inadequate notice must therefore rest on specific evidence showing that
an eligible candidate was denied a fair opportunity.
th
50. DTEA has produced newspaper advertisements dated 26 June, 2024. Any
objection founded upon the Employment Exchanges (Compulsory Notification of
Vacancies) Act, 1959 must identify the applicable duty and breach. Section 4(4)
distinguishes an obligation to notify a vacancy from an obligation to recruit through
the Exchange. Even a breach of the former does not, without a further legal basis,
automatically nullify every subsequent appointment.
51. The DoE also questions medical examinations and police verification
undertaken before formal appointment letters were issued, as well as certificates
obtained outside Delhi. Rule 106(2) requires a candidate selected for appointment to
furnish medical fitness and character certificates from the prescribed sources. It does
not require a formal appointment letter to precede these formalities, nor does it restrict
compliant certificates to those issued in Delhi. Verification undertaken after selection
but before issuance of the appointment letter cannot, by itself, establish that the
selection was pre-determined. The DoE may nevertheless examine whether the
certificates satisfy the applicable requirements and whether the dates of selection,
communication and verification are consistent with the original records. Any
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 23 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
allegation of manipulation must be supported by specific evidence.
52. The DoE also alleges non-compliance with the requirement of 4% reservation
for persons with benchmark disabilities. Section 34 of the Rights of Persons with
Disabilities Act, 2016, read with Section 2(k), extends to bodies aided by the
Government. DTEA’s minority status does not, by itself, confer an exemption from
th
the statutory requirement. The advertisement dated 26 June, 2024, however,
expressly reserved one vacancy each for TGT (Tamil), Librarian and Assistant
Teacher for persons with disabilities. Whether this satisfied the statutory requirement
must be determined with reference to the cadre strength in each group of posts and
the applicable vacancy-based rosters, in accordance with Rule 15 of the Delhi Rights
of Persons with Disabilities Rules, 2018. Although the DoE alleges non-compliance
across Groups A, B and C, the material placed before the Court does not disclose the
cadre-wise calculation or roster position supporting that allegation, or identify any
particular appointment made against a vacancy required to be reserved. The general
allegation cannot, therefore, justify rejection of all 100 appointments. Any established
deficiency must be addressed in accordance with the Act and Rules, after hearing the
affected parties.
Communication of Appointments and Deemed Approval under Rule 98
53. Rule 98(3) DSE Rules requires particulars of every appointment in an aided
school to be communicated to the Director within 7 days, by registered post with
acknowledgement due or through a messenger against acknowledgement. Under Rule
98(4), an appointment is deemed approved if disapproval is not conveyed within 15
days of such communication, with consequential entitlement to salary and allowances
th
from the date of appointment. DTEA relies upon communications dated 16
rd
November, 2024 and 3 April, 2025, besides subsequent recruitment dossiers. The
former communication preceded several selections, while the latter followed
appointments made on different dates. Their legal effect cannot be determined from
these dates alone. The contents, mode of transmission, proof of receipt and any timely
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 24 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
disapproval must be examined in relation to each appointment. A general intimation
of proposed recruitment cannot, without more, be equated with communication of the
particulars of persons actually selected.
54. The scope and purpose of Rule 98(4) have been considered by this Court in
18
Promila Dixit v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Ors . The Court explained that the
provision protects employees from belated approval or rejection by the Director and
ensures certainty regarding the continuity of their employment. It held that where the
particulars of an appointment have been communicated and the Director does not
respond within 15 days, the statutory fiction of deemed approval must be given full
19
effect. The Division Bench, in Binu Chaudhary v. Lt. Governor of Delhi & Ors. ,
however, clarified that, for Rule 98(4) to apply, the recommendation of the Selection
Committee and the appointment of the candidate must conform to the applicable
Rules. In that case, deemed approval could not operate because the previous approval
required under Rule 97 for relaxation of an essential qualification had not been
obtained.
20
55. DTEA has also relied upon Delhi Tamil Education Assn. v. DoE . There, this
Court noted that the nominees of the Director had participated in the selection process
and signed the minutes without recording any dissent or disagreement. The particulars
of the selected candidates had also admittedly been received by the Director. No
disapproval was communicated within 15 days of such receipt. The Court accordingly
held that, even assuming that approval of the Director was required, it would be
deemed to have been granted under Rule 98(4). It further held that the teachers were
entitled to their salaries and allowances from the date of appointment. The present
case, however, is distinguishable. Unlike that case, communication of the particulars
of the appointees in the manner prescribed by Rule 98(3) is itself disputed. The
18
2010 SCC OnLine Del 4156.
19
2016 SCC OnLine Del 1651.
20
2008 SCC OnLine Del 1035.
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 25 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
compliance of several appointees with the essential qualifications is also in issue.
Further, the effect of Rule 98(4) must be considered alongside Rule 66(2), which
excludes the pay of an unqualified teacher from the assessment of grant-in-aid, save
as provided under Rule 98(5) or where the Director grants an exemption. Deemed
approval under Rule 98(4) cannot, by itself, dispense with that separate requirement.
56. The questions arising under Rule 98 must also be examined in the context of
the broader documentary record concerning the recruitment process. DTEA maintains
that it sought departmental nominees and subsequently furnished selection
proceedings, appointment particulars and dossiers seeking grant-in-aid. The DoE
disputes the receipt or completeness of these records. Although the departmental
screening reports show that some material was examined, they do not conclusively
establish what was received, by which office, and when. The distinction is material.
Requests for departmental nominations concern Rule 96; communication of
appointments attracts Rule 98; and submission of recruitment dossiers enables
scrutiny of grant-in-aid. These matters require examination of the contemporaneous
correspondence, acknowledgements and departmental records. Neither an assertion
of compliance nor a denial of receipt can substitute for that exercise.
Scope of Individual Verification and Effect of the Impugned Order
57. The employee-wise screening reports, objections, replies and supporting
documents placed before the Court identify the areas of dispute but do not resolve the
contested facts. This judgment settles the questions of law common to the recruitment
exercise. Whether an individual appointment satisfies the applicable legal standards
must be determined from the original recruitment and service records relating to that
appointee. That examination falls, in the first instance, within the DoE’s statutory
responsibility when deciding the admissibility of grant-in-aid. It would also not be
appropriate for this Court to choose between rival compilations in place of that
exercise. The DoE must therefore undertake appointment-wise scrutiny in accordance
with the findings recorded above.
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 26 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
th
58. The order dated 4 November, 2025, however, treats objections of differing
character and consequence as sufficient to reject all 100 appointments. Such a
collective conclusion cannot be sustained, even though some individual objections
may justify refusal of grant-in-aid. The impugned order is, accordingly, set aside. The
DoE shall make separate, reasoned determinations on the individual records after
affording the concerned appointees an opportunity to answer any specific adverse
material. Those determinations must proceed on the basis that this judgment neither
validates every appointment nor establishes an unconditional entitlement to grant-in-
aid. Questions of law settled herein shall not be reopened.
Remuneration for Services Rendered
59. The employees’ claim for remuneration raises a separate question. The fact that
they have worked and may face hardship does not, by itself, create an obligation on
the State to bear the financial burden of appointments which do not satisfy the
statutory requirements for grant-in-aid. In Government of A.P. & Ors. v. K.
21
Brahmanandam & Ors. , the Supreme Court held that the State’s liability to pay
salary to teachers appointed in recognised schools arises where the statutory
requirements governing their appointments are complied with. Where the right to
salary arises under a contract between the appointee and the institution, the liability
rests with the institution, subject to its right to seek reimbursement from the State in
accordance with the applicable law. The Court further held that, even in the absence
of a valid contract, teachers who had rendered services were entitled to remuneration
from the school authorities under Section 70 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. The
distinction is therefore between the State’s liability to fund the appointments under
the governing statutory framework and the liability, if any, of the institution which
engaged the employees to remunerate them for services actually rendered. The former
must be determined under the applicable grant-in-aid provisions, while the latter must
21
(2008) 5 SCC 241.
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 27 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
be examined with reference to the appointment terms, the services rendered and the
applicable law.
60. Section 10 of the DSE Act governs salary and benefits in recognised private
schools and the statutory disbursement mechanism for aided schools. The clauses in
DTEA’s appointment letters postponing salary until receipt of grant-in-aid cannot be
read as extinguishing its independent liability, if established, for services received.
Nor can a stipulation concerning resignation during probation effect a forfeiture of
remuneration already earned. The amount recoverable, the period actually worked,
any payments made and the applicable remuneration may nevertheless differ from
employee to employee. Those facts have not been conclusively established in these
petitions. A general award of arrears or interest against the State or DTEA, without
determining those matters and the legal basis of liability, would be unwarranted.
Conclusion and Directions
61. For the reasons recorded above, the DoE shall examine afresh the admissibility
of grant-in-aid in respect of the individual appointments, in accordance with the
following directions:
a. Within two weeks from the date of pronouncement of this judgment, DTEA
shall furnish an indexed, employee-wise statement identifying, for each appointment,
the school, post, sanctioned vacancy, applicable Recruitment Rules, prescribed and
possessed qualifications, relevant experience, dates of selection, appointment and
joining, period of actual service, salary paid, if any, and particulars of resignation or
cessation of service. The statement shall also identify the communications relied upon
under Rule 98(3) DSE Rules, along with supporting acknowledgements. Documents
already furnished may be identified by reference to the existing record and need not
be submitted afresh.
b. Within one week from the date of pronouncement, the Director of Education
shall designate an officer not below the rank of Additional Director, who was not
associated with the impugned decision, to undertake the fresh examination. The
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 28 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
officer may be assisted by other officials but shall remain responsible for the
individual determinations. The existing screening reports, DTEA’s responses and the
records already furnished shall form the basis of the exercise.
c. Within two weeks of receiving DTEA’s statement, the designated officer shall
reconcile the documents identified therein with the records of the concerned
departmental offices, including correspondence, acknowledgements, inward registers
and electronic records. The officer shall thereafter issue a single deficiency statement
identifying, separately for each appointment, the outstanding objections and
documents, if any, that remain to be furnished. Any dispute regarding receipt of a
document shall be examined with reference to the relevant departmental records.
DTEA shall have one week to furnish the required material or proof of its earlier
submission. Documents produced at this stage may establish facts existing on the
relevant date. Their production shall not, by itself, establish timely communication
under Rule 98(3) DSE Rules.
d. Before sustaining any objection, the designated officer shall identify the
applicable statutory provision, the precise deficiency and the material supporting it,
and afford DTEA and the employee concerned a reasonable opportunity to respond.
A personal hearing shall be afforded wherever necessary to resolve a material factual
dispute. If a specifically required document is not furnished despite reasonable
opportunity, the officer may decide the matter on the available record, while recording
the omission and its legal consequence. The exercise shall not extend to a general
reopening of the recruitment process. Nor shall successive requisitions be issued in
respect of matters already sufficiently addressed.
e. The legal findings recorded in this judgment shall govern the fresh
examination. In particular, the DoE shall apply the findings concerning the
Recruitment Rules applicable to Assistant Teachers, the insufficiency of B.Ed. alone
to satisfy the prescribed qualification, the rights of aided minority institutions, the
constitution of Selection Committees and the legal consequences of the DoE’s failure
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 29 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
to nominate its representatives. The remaining appointments shall be examined under
the Recruitment Rules applicable to the respective posts. The effect of communication
and deemed approval under Rule 98 shall be determined wherever raised, consistently
with the statutory requirements governing grant-in-aid. An objection rejected in
principle by this Court shall not be revived. This shall not preclude consideration of
an independent statutory deficiency affecting an individual appointment.
f. The entire exercise shall be completed within twelve weeks from the date of
pronouncement. The designated officer shall pass a separate, reasoned order for each
employee, identifying the applicable requirements, the material examined, the
findings on compliance and the resulting entitlement, or otherwise, to grant-in-aid.
Where grant-in-aid is admissible, the period for which it is payable shall also be
specified. Common legal findings may be incorporated by reference, but a
consolidated rejection shall not suffice. Each order shall be communicated to DTEA
and the employee concerned within three working days of its issuance. Appointments
against which no sustainable objection remains shall be decided without awaiting
completion of the examination of the other appointments.
g. Where an appointment is found eligible for grant-in-aid, the DoE shall
determine the admissible salary and allowances, including arrears for the verified
period of service, and arrange disbursement of its 95% share through the prescribed
statutory mechanism within four weeks of the individual determination. DTEA shall
deposit its corresponding share in accordance with Section 10(2) DSE Act. Any
default in depositing that share shall be dealt with under the applicable provisions.
Where the employee continues in service, future salaries shall thereafter be disbursed
regularly, in accordance with law. Resignation shall not, by itself, defeat the claim to
arrears otherwise admissible for services rendered before resignation.
h. Where grant-in-aid is refused, the determination shall be confined to the State’s
liability to provide aid. It shall not, by itself, terminate the employment or extinguish
the employee’s claim against DTEA for remuneration for services actually rendered.
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 30 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47
DTEA’s liability in this regard shall be governed by the applicable law, including the
principles recognised in K. Brahmanandam . Within four weeks of the individual
determination, DTEA shall furnish the employee concerned an authenticated
statement of service, payments made and remuneration claimed to be payable, and
discharge any undisputed liability. Claims involving disputed amounts, interest or
other consequential relief may be pursued before the appropriate forum. Any action
concerning an appointment found ineligible shall be taken separately and in
accordance with the prescribed procedure.
i. Any party aggrieved by an individual determination shall be at liberty to pursue
the remedies available in law. Questions of fact and consequential monetary claims
not decided in this judgment shall remain open. Nothing in these directions shall
require an additional departmental representation as a condition for seeking
appropriate relief, unless mandated by law.
62. The Court has not adjudicated the dispute concerning DTEA’s internal
management or the authority of its competing office-bearers, including the claim
raised in the application for impleadment (CM APPL. 18976/2026). The DoE shall
proceed on the available material where records are not furnished despite reasonable
opportunity, recording the consequence in its determination concerning the affected
appointment.
63. Both petitions are partly allowed in the aforesaid terms. Pending applications,
if any, shall stand disposed of.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
NOVEMBER 17, 2026 /as
Signature Not Verified
W.P.(C) 14795/2025 & W.P.(C) 17099/2025 Page 31 of 31
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:33:47