Davinder & Ors vs State Of Haryana & Ors

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

LPA-1770-2016 (O&M)
1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
(205) LPA-1770-2016 (O&M)
Date of Decision : November 12, 2026
Davinder and others ..Appellants
Versus
State of Haryana and others .. Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MINDERJEET YADAV
Present: Mr. Davinder- appellant No.1 in person.
Ms. Akshita Chauhan, DAG, Haryana.
Mr. Deepak Balyan, Advocate, for respondent No.4.
HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI, J. (ORAL)
1. In the present Letters Patent Appeal, the challenge is to the order
dated 19.05.2016 passed by the learned Single Judge in CWP No.15384 of
2011 titled as Davinder and others vs. State of Haryana and others by
which, the claim raised by the appellants for the grant of minimum of pay
scale of the post on which they are working, has been denied.
2. It is a conceded position that since 09.07.2009, the appellants
are working on the post of Pump Operators and posted in different Municipal
Corporations. Initially, the water supply scheme was prepared by the
Panchayati Raj Institution/Gram Panchayat where the appellants were
appointed as Pump Operators by different Gram Panchayats and thereafter,
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 16:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

LPA-1770-2016 (O&M)
2
such scheme of the water supply was transferred to the Municipal
Council/Corporation, Karnal, as the case may be. The salary/wages which is
being paid to the appellants while working a Tubewell Pump Operator, were
the minimum wages at the relevant time fixed for such job profile as Pump
Operators. In the year 2011, a request was made by the appellants that as
they are working as full time Pump Operator as there is no one other than
them posted at a particular Pump Station and they are discharging the same
duties as being discharged by a regular Pump Operator, they should be
granted the pay of a regular Pump Operator as keeping in view the duties
performed by the appellants. The said plea was rejected vide letter dated
14.07.2011 (Annexure P-6) which was made the subject matter of the
litigation before the learned Single Judge.
3. The learned Single Judge vide judgment dated 19.05.2016 held
that as, the appellants are not working on regular basis and appellants have
been engaged on part time basis pursuant to a decision taken on 09.07.2009
for a particular scheme they are being granted the minimum wages, no
benefit of regular salary can be granted to the petitioners and their claim was
rejected which led to the filing of the present appeal.
4. Appellant No.1, who appears in person, argues that there is no
other employee than the appellants who are managing the water pump and
they are operating the same single handedly wherever they are posted hence,
treating them as part time worker is incorrect as their duties continues
throughout the day as and when required.
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 16:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

LPA-1770-2016 (O&M)
3
5. Appellant No.1 further submits that keeping in view the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Civil Appeal No.213 of
2013 titled as State of Punjab and others vs. Jagjit Singh and others,
decided on 26.10.2016 where, there exist the regular post with the
Government and the same duties are being discharged by the regular
employees also, the employees like the appellants are entitled for the
minimum of the pay scale along with allowance and therefore, as per the
judgment in Jagjit Singh’s case (supra), they are entitled for their salary of
at least minimum of pay scale with allowances from the date the judgment in
Jagjit Singh’s case (supra) was pronounced by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
of India in the year 2016.
6. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of respondent No.4-
Corporation does not dispute the fact that at a particular Pump Station only
the appellants are operating/managing the work and no one else.
7. Learned counsel for respondent No.4 further submits that as
initially the scheme was with the Gram Panchayat and thereafter the same
was transferred to the Municipal Corporation, Karnal, the appellants are
continuing on the same terms and conditions on which they were initially
appointed and the salary of the appellants as paid by the Department of
Public Health and Engineering Government of Haryana.
8. Learned counsel for respondent No.4 further submits that as the
wages are being made by the Department of Public Health and Engineering
Department, Government of Haryana, they are the appropriate authority to
look into the issue raised by the appellants.
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 16:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

LPA-1770-2016 (O&M)
4
9. Learned counsel for respondent-State submits that as the
appellants are working as Pump Operators on part time basis, their claim for
the grant of minimum wages as granted to regular employees or even the
minimum of the pay scale along with the allowances is not made out.
10. Learned counsel for the respondent-State further submits that
part time employees are not entitled for the said benefit and therefore, the
order dated 19.05.2016 passed by the learned Single Judge denying them the
benefit of minimum of pay scale as prescribed for such post, which is being
given to the regular employee, is perfectly valid and legal.
11. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and have gone
through the record with their able assistance.
12. It may be noticed that the appellants are only four in number,
who are working as Pump Operators for the last 17 years with the
respondents. They are working on a meager salary. They are being paid the
salary of Rs.4629/- per month. The salary was being remitted by the
Department of Public Health Government of Haryana to the Gram Panchayat
which is further being given to the appellants. Same process is being
adopted after Gram Panchayats concerned were upgraded to Muncipal
Council/Corporation.
13. The question which arise for consideration is that once there
exist the post of Tube-well Operator with the Government of Haryana and
the same is also being manned by a regular employee whether, paying a
salary of Rs.4629/- for the last 17 years to the appellants is contrary to the
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 16:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

LPA-1770-2016 (O&M)
5
settled principle of law as settled by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
Jagjit Singh’s case (supra) or not.
14. As per the judgment in Jagjit Singh’s case (supra), in case there
exist a regular post with the Government and adhoc arrangement has been
made either by way of temporary appointment or contractual appointment,
such employees though might not be entitled for regular pay scale but will be
entitled for minimum of the pay scale along with allowances admissible
including dearness allowance. The relevant paragraph of the said judgment
is as under:-
“57. Having traversed the legal parameters with
reference to the application of the principle of ‘equal pay for
equal work’, in relation to temporary employees (daily-wage
employees, ad-hoc appointees, employees appointed on casual
basis, contractual employees and the like), the sole factor that
requires our determination is, whether the concerned employees
(before this Court), were rendering similar duties and
responsibilities, as were being discharged by regular employees,
holding the same/corresponding posts. This exercise would
require the application of the parameters of the principle of
‘equal pay for equal work’ summarized by us in paragraph 42
above. However, insofar as the instant aspect of the matter is
concerned, it is not difficult for us to record the factual position.
We say so, because it was fairly acknowledged by the learned
counsel representing the State of Punjab, that all the temporary
employees in the present bunch of appeals, were appointed
against posts which were also available in the regular
cadre/establishment. It was also accepted, that during the
course of their employment, the concerned temporary employees
were being randomly deputed to discharge duties and
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 16:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

LPA-1770-2016 (O&M)
6
responsibilities, which at some point in time, were assigned to
regular employees. Likewise, regular employees holding
substantive posts, were also posted to discharge the same work,
which was assigned to temporary employees, from time to time.
There is, therefore, no room for any doubt, that the duties and
responsibilities discharged by the temporary employees in the
present set of appeals, were the same as were being discharged
by regular employees. It is not the case of the appellants, that
the respondent-employees did not possess the qualifications
prescribed for appointment on regular basis. Furthermore, it is
not the case of the State, that any of the temporary employees
would not be entitled to pay parity, on any of the principles
summarized by us in paragraph 42 hereinabove. There can be
no doubt, that the principle of ‘equal pay for equal work’ would
be applicable to all the concerned temporary employees, so as
to vest in them the right to claim wages, at par with the
minimum of the pay-scale of regularly engaged Government
employees, holding the same post.”
15. Learned State counsel has not been able to dispute the said
settled principle of law.
16. It may be noticed that even the salary of a class IV employee is
more than Rs.5,000/- whereas, for the last 17 years, the appellants are being
paid the salary which as of now, is being assessed at Rs.4629/- despite
working on a class III post. This is exploitation of an employee, who has no
other option but to render his services in order to survive in these hard days.
17. As far as the argument of the learned State counsel that the
appellants are part time employees and are not entitled to the aforesaid
benefit of minimum of pay scale of the post of Tubewell Pump Operator as it
exists with the Government of Haryana, it may be noticed that the specific
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 16:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

LPA-1770-2016 (O&M)
7
factual averment that no employees other than the appellants are
posted/working at a particular Pump Station has gone unrebutted. In case
there is no other employee at a Water Pump Station except the appellant,
which Water Pump Station needs to be manned for 24 hours, it cannot be
said that the appellants are performing the duties on part time basis. Rather
they are performing duty which is even more than a regular employee.
Therefore, denial of the benefit of the minimum of the pay scale to the
appellants, is incorrect as the actual facts are different than one being
projected by the State by treating the appellants as part time employees.
18. Keeping in view the totality of the circumstances, the appellants
who are four in number and are working under the said scheme, are held
entitled for the minimum of the pay scale along with the dearness allowance
as admissible qua the post of Water Pump Operator. The same will be given
from the date the judgment in Jagjit Singh’s case (supra) was pronounced
and the respondents are liable to implement the said settled principle of law
qua the appellants. The appellants will be entitled for minimum of the pay
scale along with D.A from 01.11.2016 onwards and all the arrears admissible
to the appellants will also be released as the appellants have performed the
duties of Pump Operator for the last 17 years, which is a conceded fact.
19. It is directed that the arrears admissible will be released to the
appellants within a period of eight weeks and such arrears will also carry
interest @ 6% per annum from the date such arrears became due till their
actual payment.
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 16:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

LPA-1770-2016 (O&M)
8
20. Any amount which has already been paid to the appellants, will
be adjusted while calculating the actual arrears admissible to the appellants.
21. It may be noticed that in case there is any dispute with regard to
the payment of the amount to the appellants between the Municipal Council
or the State, the State will make the payment at the first instance with the
liberty that in case the same is permissible to be reimbursed by the
Municipal Corporation, such claim can be raised.
22. The present appeal is disposed of in above terms.
23. Civil miscellaneous application pending if any, also stands
disposed of.
(HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI)
JUDGE
(MINDERJEET YADAV)
November 12, 2026 JUDGE
harsha
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes
Whether reportable : No
HARSHA RANI
2026.11.17 16:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document