Sunder Singh vs M/S Satish Kumar Garg And Company
- Court
- Supreme Court
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
2026 INSC 855
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026
(ARISING OUT OF SLP (CIVIL) NO. 21759 OF 2023)
SUNDER SINGH & ANR. APPELLANT(S)
VERSUS
M/S SATISH KUMAR GARG & COMPANY &
ORS.
RESPONDENT(S)
W I T H
CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026
(ARISING OUT OF SLP (CIVIL) NO. OF 2026)
DIARY NO.19180/2021
JUDGEMENT
SURYA KANT, CJI.
1. Due to similarity of issues and with the consent of the
learned counsel, SLP (Civil) No. 21759 of 2023 is also taken on
board.
2. I.A. No. 138820/2023 is allowed. The State Environment Impact
Assessment Authority, Haryana and State Level Expert Appraisal
Committee, Haryana are impleaded as party Respondents in both the
matters. The amended memo of parties be placed on record.
3. Delay condoned. Leave granted.
4. The instant appeals assail the order dated 26.04.2018
Signature Not Verified
(Impugned Order) passed by a Division Bench of the High Court of
Digitally signed by
NITIN TALREJA
Date: 2026.08.13
16:57:23 IST
Reason:
Punjab and Haryana (High Court) in CWP No. 2682 of 2018. Through
1
the Impugned Order, the High Court allowed the Writ Petition filed
by Respondent No. 1 - M/s. Satish Kumar Garg & Company (Mining
Lessee) and set aside the decision of the Forest Department,
Government of Haryana not to grant a ‘No Objection Certificate’
(NOC) for undertaking mining activities. The High Court, further,
permitted the Mining Lessee to mine in accordance with the mining
lease, while directing it to pay dead rent once the mining rights
are operationalised.
A. F ACTS OF THE C ASE
5. Given this scenario, it would be apposite to first examine the
factual background in which the instant appeals have been filed.
5.1 The Mining Lessee is a partnership firm, involved in the
business of mining and registered in Narnaul, District
Mahendergarh, Haryana. It applied to the State Government under
Section 10 of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation)
Act, 1957 read with the Mineral Concession Rules, 1960 for grant of
a mining lease for minerals including quartz, felspar, and barytes
over a land admeasuring 79.32 hectares, comprised in Khasra Nos.
599, 600, 601, 626, 627, 628, 648, and 649 situated in Village
Musnota, Tehsil Nangal Choudhary (earlier Narnaul), District
Mahendergarh, Haryana (Subject Land).
5.2 The State Government (Department of Mines and Geology),
accordingly, sanctioned the grant of a mining lease for 20 years,
and the same was formally executed on 29.04.2002.
2
5.3 For the purpose of an Environment Management Plan, the Mining
Lessee applied to the Forest Department for an NOC to the effect
that the land in question was not ‘forest land’. Such NOC was
initially granted on 16.09.2002, wherein it was recorded that the
“ land of Khasra No. 599, 600, 601 and 626, 627, 628, 648 and 649 in
Village Musnota is not in a forest land. ”
5.4 However, while the larger Environment Management Plan was
pending consideration before the Ministry of Environment,
Government of India, the regime for environmental permissibility of
mining projects changed by way of notification dated 14.09.2006,
passed under Section 3 of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986.
5.5 Meanwhile, in compliance with the directions of this Court in
1
M.C. Mehta v. Union of India , steps were taken to identify the
areas where plantation and afforestation activities under the
Aravalli Project were undertaken. The Deputy Commissioner,
Mahendergarh, in the course of this process, identified some of the
lands falling under ‘Aravalli Plantation’ in his report dated
05.04.2007 (DC Report). Notably, the list included the Khasra Nos.
of the Subject Land. The DC Report, additionally, recorded the fact
that such Khasra Nos. also fell within the mining/mineral bearing
area.
5.6 The Mining Lessee, finally, prepared and submitted an
Environmental Impact Assessment Report, which was deliberated on by
the Expert Appraisal Committee. In its meeting dated 21.08.2013,
the Committee called upon the Mining Lessee to obtain a fresh NOC
1 (2004) 12 SCC 118.
3
from the Forest Department. The Mining Lessee, thus, submitted an
application for the same on 12.10.2016.
5.7 However, vide communication dated 28.10.2016, the Divisional
Forest Officer, Mahendergarh informed that NOC could not be
granted, since the Subject Land fell within the list of land for
Aravalli Plantation.
5.8 Subsequently, the Mining Officer, Department of Mines and
Geology also sent a Notice dated 31.05.2017 to the Mining Lessee,
calling upon it to pay arrears of dead rent along with interest in
terms of the mining lease, which statedly amounted to Rs.
2,56,40,170, failure of which would lead to termination of the
lease.
5.9 Aggrieved by the non-grant of NOC and the simultaneous demand
notice for dead rent, the Mining Lessee filed Writ Petition bearing
CWP No. 2682/2018 before the High Court. The Mining Lessee, inter
alia , prayed for: (i) non-recovery of mining charges, including
dead rent, for the period of the mining lease when extraction could
not be done due to lack of environmental clearance; (ii) direction
that the mining lease shall operate from the date when the Mining
Lessee is actually allowed to begin mining; (iii) setting aside of
communication dated 28.10.2016; and (iv) direction to the
Divisional Forest Officer to grant NOC.
5.10 The High Court finally allowed the Mining Lessee’s Writ
Petition vide the Impugned Order. The High Court based its decision
on two facts: (i) the land in question had been granted for mining
4
from 1977 up to 2007; and (ii) there was some ambiguity as to the
exact area and contours of the land on which Aravalli Plantation
had taken place. It was, thus, held that the non-grant of NOC by
the Forest Department and the demand for dead rent for the period
when no mining was permitted was unfounded. The High Court also,
consequentially, directed that Mining Lessee to pay dead rent,
subject to being permitted to operationalise its mining rights.
5.11 Initially, a Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 6160/2019
came to be filed by one Ramniwas, a similarly aggrieved resident of
the area, seeking leave to challenge the Impugned Order. Therein, a
2-Judge Bench of this Court, vide order dated 12.07.2019, stayed
the operation of the Impugned Order and directed that no further
action shall be taken based on a Fresh NOC, if any is granted.
However, that SLP came to be dismissed as withdrawn upon an
application made by Ramniwas.
5.12 Consequently, due to the stay having been vacated, the State
Authorities proceeded to process the Mining Lessee’s proposal for
grant of permission to initiate mining. This resulted in the
Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change preparing the
Terms of Reference dated 23.03.2021 for Environmental Impact
Assessment of the proposal.
5.13 The Appellants herein, who are residents of Village
Panchnota, being concerned about the adverse impact of mining
activities in the Aravalli areas on the ecology, filed a fresh
challenge to the Impugned Order by way of the instant Appeals.
5
6. While these cases were pending at SLP stage, the State
Environment Impact Assessment Authority (SEIAA) concluded its
consideration of the Mining Lessee’s case and granted Environmental
Clearance dated 08.08.2023 (EC). It was, thus, anticipated that the
Mining Lessee would now move for obtaining requisite permission to
fell the standing trees on the land in question. In this context,
vide order dated 28.08.2023, this Court directed the Mining Lessee
not to cut trees by relying upon the EC. This interim bar on
further activities was furthered through order dated 22.09.2023,
whereby no further steps were permitted to be taken in pursuance of
the EC. We are informed that, in terms of the previous directions
of this Court, no mining has been initiated by the Mining Lessee,
pending final disposal of these Appeals.
B. B RIEF C ONTENTIONS OF THE P ARTIES
7. We have heard learned Senior Counsel and Counsel for the
parties at length and also carefully perused the record. At this
stage, we deem it necessary to briefly record the stand of each
party and the foundation therefor.
8. Mr. Maninder Singh, learned Senior Advocate on behalf of the
Appellants, relied upon the communications from the Forest
Department, State of Haryana to submit that the Khasra Nos. which
form part of the mining lease are part of the Aravalli plantation.
In such circumstances, challenge is made against the grant of NOC
and the subsequent EC, as they permit mining activities in areas
for afforestation.
6
9. Mr. Mukul Rohatgi, Mr. Guru Krishna Kumar, and Mr. Narendra
Hooda, learned senior counsel appearing for the Mining Lessee,
apart from making preliminary objections re: delay and statutory
appeal against the EC before the NGT, defended the findings of the
High Court. They sought to make out a case that no plantation had
ever taken place on the 79.32 hectares of land allotted under the
mining lease.
10. The State of Haryana was represented by the learned Additional
Advocates General for the State. The Mines and Geology Department
of the Government of Haryana supported the case of the Mining
Lessee, especially on the count that mining activities have taken
place on the said land under prior leases. It was submitted that
the data regarding the afforestation did not correspond to the
Subject Land.
11. On the contrary, the Forest Department of the State Government
has backed the stand of the Petitioners, specifically regarding the
land covered by the mining lease being part of the list of lands
for the Aravalli Project.
NALYSIS
C. A
12. Having considered the facts and rival submissions canvassed
before us, it seems that the singular issue under consideration in
the instant appeals is whether the Subject Land falls within the
Aravalli Project.
13. From a bare perusal of the record, it is apparent that the
7
Department of Mines and Geology invited applications for a mining
lease on the Subject Land in 2000, which was formally allotted in
2002. In that year itself, NOC was also granted by the Forest
Department. The learned Senior Counsel for the Mining Lessee have
placed great reliance on the 2002 NOC to claim that the land in
question was not covered by forests or plantation and could not
have been part of the Aravalli Project.
14. The High Court, although not necessarily relying upon the
stipulations in the 2002 NOC, has noted that plantation under the
Aravalli project was undertaken on only 505 hectares out of the
original plan of 785 hectares of land. The High Court thus
concluded that merely the DC Report, which stated that the Subject
Land fell in the plan for Aravalli plantation, was not sufficient,
and what needed to be demonstrated was that trees were planted on
the land in question.
15. The above reasoning is premised on the idea that if actual
plantation has not taken place on the land earmarked for
afforestation, it is permissible to undertake mining activities on
the same.
16. There is, however, in our view, an inherent fallacy in such a
conclusion or inference.
17. When Government Departments initiate planning for
afforestation activities, whether they are preservatory, like in
the Aravalli Project, or compensatory, they must identify the land
on which such plantation can take place. The final step of actual
8
plantation, resulting in semi- and fully grown trees, requires
protective intervention as well as the passage of substantial time.
18. If the submission of the Mining Lessee is to be accepted, then
such areas would always be susceptible to permissions for mining
activities, since the authorities would only consider whether trees
or plantations are standing on the land. In that case, if part of
the originally planned plantation is completed, but due to
intervening factors, the plantation on the rest of the land could
not be initiated, the remaining land will not be considered part of
the plantation. This result would be entirely antithetical to the
true nature of that remaining land, i.e., that it is an essential
part of the afforestation drive.
19. Afforestation and reforestation are undoubtedly ongoing and
long-term projects. That being so, in our considered opinion, the
lands which are identified for near future use for such plantation
drives must be held to bear the character of the land on which
plantation already has taken place. Earmarking of the land for
plantation ought to, thus, necessarily accord the same protection
which is attributed to afforestation plantations.
20. What appears in the instant case is analogous to the above
framework. Plantation drives had been initiated in the early 1990s
across the Aravallis by utilising funds received by the Government
through foreign aid for the express purpose of afforestation in
that region. Such afforestation efforts were also given judicial
impetus through M.C. Mehta (supra) and M.C. Mehta v. Union of
9
2
India , whereby this Court recognised the need to protect such
plantations in the face of disruptive activities, especially
mining. Through the above-cited judgements, this Court specifically
acknowledged the grave risk posed to the plantations if mining is
allowed to continue in the region, leading to the direction that no
mining activity would be done on areas covered by the Aravalli
plantation.
21. It is admitted that plantation drives could not cover the
entire area identified for plantations under this Aravalli Project.
That being so, the lands which had been earmarked for Aravalli
plantation drives, including those which may not have had any fresh
saplings planted, ought to have the same protective status as those
which bore the afforestation.
22. The record of the instant case, however, depicts that this has
not been taken into account.
23. On one hand, it was amply evident that the Subject Land was
earmarked for plantation under the Aravalli Project. None of the
parties has, on the other hand, been able to conclusively state
whether the plantation actually took place over the Subject Land.
The Impugned Order proceeded on the premise that in the case of
such ambiguity as to actual use of the land for plantation, the NOC
ought to be granted and mining ought to be allowed.
24. The High Court has, however, not given much importance to the
fact that the land fell within the plan for the Aravalli Project or
2 (2006) 11 SCC 582.
10
had been identified for plantation under the same. By permitting
mining in such a situation, the Mining Lessee was allowed to
effectively undermine the afforestation efforts of the Forest
Department by clearing existing trees and initiating excavation of
minerals. Such an outcome, in our view, is impermissible.
25. Hence, we have no other option but to conclude that the
direction for granting an NOC for mining on the Subject Land was
unfounded and is, accordingly, liable to be set aside. As a
consequence, the decision of the SEIAA and the EC granted thereby
would also become uncalled for and ought to be set aside.
26. Before we conclude, we must also take serious note of the
contrary stand taken by the Department of Mines and Geology and the
Forest Department of the State of Haryana on this matter. It
appears to us that the stand of the former has been motivated by
its underlying claim for dead rent and other mining royalties/dues
under the mining lease. However, it is surprising that no action
was taken by the said Department regarding the continuation of the
mining lease once it was brought to light by the latter Department
that the land in question was earmarked for Aravalli plantation. In
our considered opinion, the mining lease dated 29.04.2002 must be
cancelled and all consequential rights be purged forthwith.
27. It also merits iteration that the findings forwarded and
directions issued by High Court through the Impugned Judgement lie
in the teeth of the continuing directions issued by this Court
regarding protection of ecology and forest cover in the ‘Aravalli
11
Hills and Ranges’. A brief reference thereto was also made in this
Court’s order dated 29.12.2025 passed in In Re: Definition of
Aravalli Hills and Ranges and Ancillary Issues , registered as Suo
Moto Writ Petition (Civil) No. 10/2025. Recognising the extensive
and irreversible impact that mining could have on the region,
directions were issued therein to the effect that no mining
activities in the ‘Aravalli Hills and Ranges’ could take place
without prior permission from this Court. This restriction was
reiterated through order dated 26.02.2026. Finally, vide order
dated 25.05.2026, so as to obtain a circumspect expert opinion on
the nature of the Aravalli region and the implications of mining
activities, a five-member High-Powered Committee comprising domain
experts was constituted to consider various issues raised in the
suo motu proceedings and submit a comprehensive report. The said
report is yet to be received, and any mining in the region during
the pendency of the matter is unquestionably barred. Such
circumstances constrain us to disapprove of the continuing stand of
the State Government in favour of permission to initiate mining. We
are, thus, of the firm opinion that there is a need to issue some
directions for the protection of lands which have been earmarked
for afforestation purposes, whether compensatory or arising out of
foreign aid/charitable contributions.
IRECTIONS
D. D
28. For the reasons set out above, the instant Appeals are
allowed, and the following directions are issued:
12
(i)
The Impugned Judgement of the High Court is set aside;
(ii)
The non-grant of the NOC, communicated vide letter dated
28.10.2016, is upheld. As a corollary, the NOC dated
16.09.2002 and its consequences stand effaced;
(iii) The decision of the SEIAA recorded in the minutes of
meeting dated 02.08.2023 and the resultant EC dated
08.08.2023 are quashed;
(iv) The Subject Land, as well as other lands identified in the
DC Report, having been earmarked for Aravalli plantation,
shall not be made available for any mining activity. Any
mining lease or other right permitting mining activity in
respect of these lands, if presently subsisting, shall be
terminated forthwith. This direction shall be subject to
the final directions to be issued by this Court in Suo Moto
Writ Petition (Civil) No. 10/2025;
(v)
In order to preserve and secure the plantations and
accompanying ecology within the Aravalli regions, the State
Government shall:
(a)
undertake a comprehensive survey of the entire area
earmarked for Aravalli plantation, including lands
identified in the revenue records as Aravalli
plantation/Aravalli Project and the gair mumkin pahad
falling in such areas;
(b)
identify all parcels of land falling in the above areas
13
in respect of which any mining lease or other mining-
related right is presently subsisting;
(c) take immediate steps to cancel and terminate all such
subsisting mining leases or other rights permitting
mining activity, in accordance with law; and
(d)
file a comprehensive compliance report before this
Court, setting out, inter alia , the area surveyed, the
parcels of land identified as falling within the
Aravalli plantation area, the mining leases or other
rights found to be subsisting in respect thereof, and
the action taken for their cancellation or termination.
Such report shall be placed before this Court as part
of the record of Suo Moto Writ Petition (Civil) No.
10/2025.
29. The State Government and all its authorities shall ensure
strict compliance with the above directions. It goes without saying
that the Government of Haryana as well as those of Rajasthan,
Gujarat, and the NCT of Delhi are bound to faithfully and strictly
comply with the directions issued by this Court regarding
preservation of the ecological resources in the Aravalli Region,
including with order dated 29.12.2025 passed in Suo Moto Writ
Petition (Civil) No. 10/2025, and subsequent orders passed therein.
30. Any violation of the aforesaid directions, including the
commencement or continuation of mining activity in the area
earmarked for Aravalli plantation, shall be viewed seriously by
14
this Court and may invite appropriate action against the
authorities responsible for ensuring compliance.
31. Ordered accordingly. The Registry is directed to convey a copy
of this judgement forthwith to the respective Chief Secretaries of
the States of Haryana, Rajasthan, and Gujarat and the NCT of Delhi
for necessary compliance.
32. The pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
..........................CJI.
(SURYA KANT)
..........................J.
(JOYMALYA BAGCHI)
..........................J.
(V. MOHANA)
NEW DELHI;
JULY 29, 2026.
15