Raj Kumar vs State Of Haryana And Ors
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
1
LPA-3221-2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
115
LPA-3221 of 2026 (O&M)
Reserved on: 05.11.2026
Pronounced on: 18.11.2026
Uploaded on 18.11.2026
Whether only operative part of the judgment is
pronounced or the full judgment is pronouned: Full judgment
RAJ KUMAR
…..Appellant
V/S
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS.
… Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUVIR SEHGAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH GAUR
Present: Mr. Deepak Singh Saini, Advocate,
Ms. Vamika Johar, Advocate and
Mr. Paramjit Singh, Advocate for the appellant.
Mr. Deepak Vashisth, Deputy Advocate General Haryana.
RAJESH GAUR, J.
1. Present intra-Court Appeal has been filed under clause X of the
Letters Patent preferred by the appellant challenging the judgment dated
17.08.2026 passed in CWP-36920 of 2019 by the learned Single Judge,
whereby the writ petition filed by respondent No. 4 was allowed and
respondent No. 4 was appointed as Lambardar of village Simbalwal.
2. The brief facts of the case are that the appellant applied for
appointment as Lambardar of Village Simbalwal following the death of his
father, who was the incumbent Lambardar of the village. Upon consideration
of the candidature of the appellant, the Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil)-cum-
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.18 18:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
2
LPA-3221-2026
Assistant Collector Ist Grade, Shahbad, recommended his appointment. The
Gram Panchayat also passed a resolution in favour of the appellant, supporting
his candidature for the said post. On the other hand, the candidature of
respondent No. 4 was recommended only by the Assistant Collector, Second
Grade.
3. However, the Collector-cum-Deputy Commissioner, Kurukshetra,
appointed respondent No. 4 as Lambardar, observing that appointment of a
person merely on the ground of being the son of the deceased Lambardar
would not, by itself, be in the interest of justice.
4. Aggrieved by the order passed by the Collector, Kurukshetra, the
appellant preferred an appeal before the Commissioner, Ambala Division,
Ambala. After undertaking a comparative assessment of the merits and
suitability of both candidates, the Commissioner, Ambala Division, Ambala,
found the appellant to be a more competent and suitable candidate for
appointment as Lambardar. Accordingly, the appeal was allowed by the
Commissioner, Ambala Division, Ambala vide order dated 26.09.2018, and
the appellant was appointed to the post of Lambardar.
5. The aforesaid order was challenged by respondent No. 4 before
the Financial Commissioner, Haryana by way of revision. However, the
Financial Commissioner, Haryana dismissed the revision petition vide order
dated 30.10.2019 and affirmed the order passed by the Commissioner, Ambala
Division, Ambala.
6. Thereafter, respondent No. 4 preferred a writ petition before the
learned Single Judge seeking quashing of the orders passed by the
Commissioner, Ambala Division, Ambala and the Financial Commissioner,
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.18 18:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
3
LPA-3221-2026
Haryana. The learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition on 17.08.2026
and set-aside the orders passed by Commissioner and Financial Commissioner.
Order passed by Collector whereby respondent no.4 was appointed as
Lambardar was restored. Aggrieved by the judgment dated 17.08.2026 passed
by the learned Single Judge, the appellant preferred the revision petition which
was dismissed as withdrawn. Hence, the present Letters Patent Appeal.
7. Learned counsel for the appellant contends that the Collector-
cum-Deputy Commissioner, Kurukshetra, failed to consider the
recommendation made by the Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil)-cum-Assistant
Collector Ist Grade, Shahbad, as well as the resolution passed by the Gram
Panchayat in favour of the appellant. It was further submitted that the
appellant's claim is not based merely on his being the son of the deceased
Lambardar as alleged, but was also supported by his good reputation in the
village and knowledge of the duties attached to the office. In support of his
submissions, learned counsel placed reliance upon the judgment passed in case
titled ‘ Vikramjit Singh v. Financial Commissioner (Cooperation), Punjab,
Chandigarh and others ’, Law Finder Doc ID #634414 .
8. We have heard learned counsel for the appellant and have
carefully examined the comparative merits of the candidates for appointment
as Lambardar, the relevant statutory provisions governing the appointment of
Lambardar and the material available on record.
9. It is a well-settled proposition of law that the choice exercised by
the Collector in the matter of appointment of a Lambardar ought not to be
interfered with unless the same is found to be perverse, arbitrary or contrary to
law. Even the comparative merit table reproduced in paragraph 9 of the appeal
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.18 18:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
4
LPA-3221-2026
does not establish any ground warranting any interference with the choice
exercised by the Collector.
10. The sole basis of the appellant’s claim is that he is son of the
deceased Lambardar, whereas the claim of hereditary preference had already
been declared unconstitutional by the Division Bench of this Court in ‘ Karnail
Singh v. State of Haryana and Others ’, Law Finder Doc ID # 59385 .
11. The appellant has also placed reliance upon the judgment passed
in Vikramjit Singh’ case (supra), wherein the petitioner and respondent were
the contesting candidates for appointment to the post of Lambardar. In the said
case, the Collector had appointed the petitioner therein as Lambardar of the
village. A perusal of the order passed by the Collector reveals that the
comparative merits of respondent No. 4 were not considered nor discussed at
all. The Collector had merely recorded that Jaswant Singh had not appeared
before him and proceeded to appoint the petitioner therein as Lambardar.
Thus, the merits of respondent No. 4, who was one of the contesting
candidates, were not taken into consideration, clearly demonstrates non-
application of mind on the part of the Collector.
12. However, the facts and circumstances of the present case are
entirely distinguishable. In the present case, both the contesting candidates
appeared before the Collector and their respective merits were duly considered
and discussed. Therefore, the principle laid down in Vikramjit Singh’ case
(supra) has no application to the facts of the present case. The reliance placed
upon the said judgment is, therefore, wholly misplaced and is based upon a
misconstruction and misinterpretation of the judgment.
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.18 18:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
5
LPA-3221-2026
13. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, the relevant
statutory provisions and the judgments referred to hereinabove, no ground for
interference with the judgment passed by the learned Single Judge is made out.
14. Consequently, present appeal is dismissed.
15. The practice of hereditary succession to the office of Lambardar
has several adverse implications for the lives of people in rural areas. Under
such a system, a person often assumes the office of Lambardar immediately
upon the death of his father and continues to hold the position throughout his
lifetime, with the office being passed on to another member of the same family
for generations, irrespective of whether its successive holders possess the
requisite ability, competence or inclination to discharge the duties attached to
the office.
16. It is pertinent to question why Lambardar, despite being incapable
of performing their statutory duties, are often reluctant to relinquish their
positions in favour of more suitable and deserving persons. The answer may
lie in the social and economic advantages associated with the office rather than
in any genuine commitment to the discharge of responsibilities.
17. In certain rural settings, the authority exercised by the Lambardar
and his family is perceived by ordinary villagers as virtually unquestionable,
reminiscent of the obedience traditionally accorded to authority in monarchical
times. Such a situation is fundamentally inconsistent with the principles of
equality, accountability and democratic participation.
18. The States of Punjab and Haryana, therefore, need to address
these concerns by ensuring the effective and impartial implementation of the
existing statutory rules and administrative instructions governing the
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.18 18:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
6
LPA-3221-2026
appointment, continuation and removal of Sarbrah Lambardars/Lambardars.
The office must be treated as a position of public responsibility rather than as a
hereditary privilege or an instrument for perpetuating family influence. Its
continuance should depend upon the incumbent's competence, integrity,
availability and actual performance of the duties entrusted to him.
19. Such corrective measures would not only restore the institution of
Lambardar to its intended administrative purpose but would also help
eliminate undemocratic practices, reduce the concentration of local influence
in a few families and strengthen the principles of equality, accountability and
participatory democracy at the villages.
20. All pending civil miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also
stand disposed of.
(SUVIR SEHGAL) (RAJESH GAUR)
JUDGE JUDGE
18.11.2026
Kamal Gandhi
Whether speaking Yes
Whether reportable Yes
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.18 18:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document