Manohar Lal vs M/o Health And Family Welfare

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

1
OA No. 1318/2020
Item No. 31 (C-3)
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI

OA No. 1318/2020

RD
This the 03 Day of November, 2026

Hon’ble Ms. Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member (J)
Hon’ble Dr. Sumeet Jerath, Member (A)


1. Shri Manohar Lal, Group-(C)-Ambulance Driver
S/o Late Shri Chattar Singh,
H. No.1/46, 92-A,
Balbir Nagar, aged about 54 years.
Ext. Loni Road, Shahadara,
Delhi-110032.

2. Shri Amar Chand, Group-(C)-Ambulance Driver
S/o Late Shri Mange Ram,
H. No.WZ-7, Village- Dasghara, aged about 51 years.
New Delhi-110012

3. Shri Rajender Kumar, Group-(C)-Ambulance Driver
S/o Ram Chander,
H. No.10/5, Dharm Colony, Nangloi, aged about 51 years.
New Delhi-110041.

4. Shri Ram Bilas Dass, Group-(C)-Ambulance Driver
S/o Shri Ramji Dass,
H. No. H-65, Nanakpura, aged about 50 years.
New Delhi-110021.

5. Shri Vijay Singh, Group-(C)-Ambulance Driver
S/o Shri Daya Chand,
H. No.67, Village & Post- Mukhamelpur, aged about 54 years.
Delhi-110036.

6. Shri Jagdish Prasad, Group-(C)-Ambulance Driver
S/o Late Shri Budh Ram,
H. No.453, MCD Girls School Wali Gali, aged about 47 years.
Village- Samalka,
New Delhi-110037.

7. Shri Sudarshan Kumar, Group-(C)-Ambulance Driver
S/o Shri................
Ambulance Driver,
Dr. R. M. L. Hospital, aged about 57 years.
New Delhi-110001.

8. Shri Sanjay, Group-(C)-Ambulance Driver
NISHA KUMARI 2026.11.19 17:19:22+05'30'

2
OA No. 1318/2020
Item No. 31 (C-3)
S/o Shri Ram Bharose,
H. No.1046, Sector-7,
R. K. Puram, aged about 48 years.
New Delhi-110022.

9. Shri Surender, Group-(C)-Ambulance Driver
S/o Shri Kartar Singh,
H. No. E-10, Om Vihar Ext.,
Uttam Nagar, aged about 52 years.
New Delhi-110059.

10. Shri Om Pal Singh, Group-(C)-Ambulance Driver
S/o Shri Khazan Singh,
H. No.74, Karam Singh Wali Gali,
Village -Tigipur, aged about 49 years.
Delhi-110036

11. Shri V. V. Joseph, Group-(C)-Ambulance Driver
S/o Shri Varghese,
H. No. RZC/81, aged about 52 years.
Mahaveer Enclave, Palam,
New Delhi-110045.

12. Shri Prem Kumar, Group-(C)-Ambulance Driver
S/o Shri Pokar Dass,
H. No.93, V. P. O. Khampur, aged about 50 years.
Delhi-110036.

13. Shri Anil Kumar, Group-(C)-Ambulance Driver
S/o Shri Ramphal,
Village & Post- Ghagha, aged about 51 years.
Delhi-110039.

14. Shri Suresh Chander, Group-(C)-Ambulance Driver
S/o Shri Hoshiar Singh,
Village & Post-Mundka, aged about 50 years.
Delhi-110041.

.…Applicants

(By Advocate : Mr. Virender Kumar, Mr. Ranjan Rani Sagar)


VERSUS


1. Union of India,
Through Secretary,
Ministry of Health & Family Welfare,
Govt. of India,
Nirman Bhawan,
New Delhi-110011.
NISHA KUMARI 2026.11.19 17:19:22+05'30'

3
OA No. 1318/2020
Item No. 31 (C-3)

2. The Director General of Health Services,
Ministry of Health & Family Welfare,
Govt. of India,
Nirman Bhawan,
New Delhi-110011.

3. The Superintendent,
Dr. Ram Manohar Lohia Hospital,
New Delhi-110001.

.... RESPONDENTS

[By Advocate : Ms. Sangita Singh, Mr. Rajiv R. Raj]
































NISHA KUMARI 2026.11.19 17:19:22+05'30'

4
OA No. 1318/2020
Item No. 31 (C-3)
ORDER (ORAL)

Hon’ble Ms. Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member (J)
This is the second round of litigation. The applicants,
fourteen in number, had earlier approached this Tribunal by
filing OA No. 2542/2019, which was disposed of by this
Tribunal vide order dated 27.09.2019. Thereafter, vide order
dated 17.12.2019, the representations submitted by the
applicants were considered and disposed of by the
respondents. The respondents, in the said order, have stated
as under :

6. The OA along with MA stands disposed of in the above terms."
And whereas in pursuance of above order of Hon'ble CAT one of
the applicants in the above OA, Shri Amar Chand S/o Late. Shri
th
Mange Ram, submitted his representation on 10 October, 2019
praying for his promotion as Driver grade-1.
Now, therefore, after having considered the representation
submitted by Shri Amar Chand it is stated that:

(i) The existing RRs for the post of Driver/Ambulance
were notified on 22.12.1973 has no promotion avenue.

(ii) As per clause 2.7 and 04 contained in Department of
Personnel and Training's OM No. 22036/1/92-Estt.(D),
th
dated 30 November, 1993, the powers to frame RRs
for Group C&D posts have been delegated to
Ministries/Departments, they may frame the rules in
accordance with the guidelines by indicating the
eligibility criteria laid down in this OM and these order
would not apply in the Ministries/Departments where
Drivers already have more than one scale of pay.

NISHA KUMARI 2026.11.19 17:19:22+05'30'

5
OA No. 1318/2020
Item No. 31 (C-3)
(iii) The amended Recruitment Rules (based on DoPT
Guidelines) for posts of Drivers are consideration in
Ministry of Health & Family Welfare.

(iv) Ministry of Health and Family Welfare has not
agreed to promotion of Driver Grade-I, Grade-II and
Special Grade on ad-hoc basis.

(v) However, as soon as Recruitment Rules for the post
are notified, the process of promotion will be initiated
accordingly.

2. The applicants have now filed the present OA seeking the
following reliefs:
a. That this Hon'ble Tribunal may kindly set-a-side the impugned
order dated 17.12.2019, direct the respondents to convene the DPC
for consideration of the Applicants as Driver Grade-I / Spl. Grade at
once without wasting any further time.

b. Direct the Respondents to consider and fill up the vacancies of
Driver Grade-I as per the existing scheme of promotion which was
available at the time of occurring of the vacancies with all
consequential benefits, since the case is squarely covered by S.C.
decision.

c. Award cost in favour of the applicants.

d. Pass such other and further order / orders as this Hon'ble
Tribunal may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of
the case.
3. Learned counsel for the applicants would submit that
during the pendency of the present OA, promotion orders in
respect of seven applicants have since been issued vide orders
dated 06.05.2023 and 19.08.2026. He has handed over copies
NISHA KUMARI 2026.11.19 17:19:22+05'30'

6
OA No. 1318/2020
Item No. 31 (C-3)
of both the promotion orders across the Bar. The same are
taken on record.
4. It is submitted that the grievance of the applicants has
been substantially addressed by the subsequent
developments. Learned counsel would, however, submit that
even prior to the issuance of the aforesaid promotion orders,
ad-hoc promotions from Grade-II to Grade-I had been granted
on 21.09.2017, pending finalisation of the new Recruitment
Rules (RRs).
5. It appears that, following the finalisation of the new RRs,
the aforesaid promotion orders have now been issued.
Although the new Recruitment Rules are not on record, the
issuance of the subsequent promotion orders indicates that
the process of promotion has since moved forward. In view of
these subsequent developments, the scenario in the present
OA has undergone a substantial change. Out of the fourteen
applicants, seven have since been promoted.
6. Learned counsel would, however, submit that the
respondents are still required to consider the cases of the
seven promoted applicants for grant of promotion with effect
NISHA KUMARI 2026.11.19 17:19:22+05'30'

7
OA No. 1318/2020
Item No. 31 (C-3)
from the year 2012, when they had become eligible for the
same.
7. Learned counsel for the respondents, on the other hand,
while relying upon the counter affidavit filed in the year 2021,
would submit that the respondents have a promotion policy
and had earlier been following the promotion scheme notified
by the DoPT pending finalisation of the new RRs. She submits
that with the new RRs now in place, the cases of the seven
applicants have also been considered for promotion in their
due turn.
8. Having considered the submissions made by learned
counsel for the parties and taking note of the subsequent
developments, we are of the view that it would not be
appropriate to keep the present OA pending any further. The
subsequent promotion orders have substantially altered the
circumstances in which the present OA was instituted.
9. Accordingly, the present OA is disposed of as having
been rendered infructuous on account of the subsequent
developments. However, the applicants shall be at liberty to
agitate their surviving grievances, including their claim for
grant of promotion with effect from the due date, before the
NISHA KUMARI 2026.11.19 17:19:22+05'30'

8
OA No. 1318/2020
Item No. 31 (C-3)
appropriate forum, in accordance with law. Pending MA, if
any, also stands disposed of. There shall be no order as to
costs.


(Dr. Sumeet Jerath) (Harvinder Kaur Oberoi)
Member (A) Member (J)

/nk/


NISHA KUMARI 2026.11.19 17:19:22+05'30'