SHEKAR EYE HOSPITAL vs STATE OF KARNATAKA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019




IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU


TH
DATED THIS THE 20 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI

CRIMINAL PETITION NO. 7946 OF 2019

BETWEEN:

1 . SHEKAR EYE HOSPITAL
C/O SHEKAR EYE HOSPITAL
(A UNIT OF VARASIDDI HOSPITALS)
NO.633, 100 FT RING ROAD,
RD
J P NAGAR, 3 PHASE,
BANGALORE - 560 078.
REP BY ITS PROPRIETOR,
DR. RAJASHEKAR Y L

2 . DR.RAJASHEKAR Y L
C/O SHEKAR EYE HOSPITAL,
(A UNIT OF VARASIDDHI HOSPITALS)
NO.633, 100 FT RING ROAD,
RD
J P NAGAR, 3 PHASE,
BANGALORE - 560 078.

3 . DR. ARCHANA SINGH,
SHEKAR EYE HOSPITAL
C/O. SHEKAR EYE HOSPITAL,
(A UNIT OF VARASIDDHI HOSPITALS)
NO.633, 100 FT RING ROAD,
RD
J P NAGAR, 3 PHASE,
BANGALORE - 560 078.

4 . DR.SHAILESH G M
SHEKAR EYE HOSPITAL
C/O. SHEKAR EYE HOSPITAL,
(A UNIT OF VARASIDDHI HOSPITALS)
NO.633, 100 FT RING ROAD,
RD
J P NAGAR, 3 PHASE,
BANGALORE - 560 078.











Digitally signed
by ANUSHA V
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019



…PETITIONERS
[BY SRI UDAYA HOLLA, SR. COUNSEL FOR
SRI VIVEK HOLLA, ADVOCATE]
AND:
1 . STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY SHO,
JAYAPRAKASH NAGAR POLICE
STATION,
ST TH
NO.36, 21 MAIN, 7 CROSS,
ND
2 PHASE, JP NAGAR,
BANGALORE - 560 078.

2 . SADIYA MOHAMMED
W/O FAIZAN AHMED,
D/O MOHAMMED KHALEEL PASHA,
AGED ABOUT 26 YEARS,
TH
R/A NO.104/5, 5 CROSS,
TANK ROAD, NR MOHALLA,
MYSORE - 570 007.
…RESPONDENTS
[BY SMT.SOWMYA R., HCGP FOR R1;
R2 - SERVED & UNREPRESENTED]
THIS CRIMINAL PETITION IS FILED U/S.482 CR.P.C
PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE ORDER DATED 10.07.2019
PASSED BY THE XLIV ADDL.C.M.M., BENGALURU IN
P.C.R.NO.8460/2019 VIDE ANNEXURE-B AND QUASH THE
PRIVATE COMPLAINT IN PCR NO.8460/2019 FIELD BY THE 2ND
RESPONDENT VIDE ANNEXURE-A AND QUASH THE FIR IN
CR.NO.141/2019 DATED 06.08.2019 LODGED BY THE 1ST
RESPONDENT - JAYAPRAKASH NAGAR POLICE STATION FOR
THE OFFENCE P/U/S 338 OF IPC (ANNEXURE-C).

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019



THIS PETITION IS HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
FOR ORDERS ON 03.09.2026, THIS DAY, THE COURT,
PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI

CAV ORDER

Challenging order dated 10.07.2019 passed by XLIV
ACMM, Bengaluru in PCR no.8460/2019 for registration of FIR
in Crime no.141/2019 by Jayaprakash Nagar Police Station,
Bengaluru, for offences punishable under Section 338 of Indian
Penal Code, 1860 ( IPC ), this petition is filed.


2. Sri Udaya Holla, learned Senior Counsel appearing
for Sri Vivek Holla, advocate for petitioners submitted that
petitioners were accused no.1 to 4 ( petitioners ) in PCR
no.8460/2019 filed by respondent no.2 ( complainant ) stating
that she was residing with family at Mysuru and got married on
05.10.2017. She stated that she was suffering from short-
sightedness and was using spectacles. And that on 01.08.2017,
she visited Sneha Eye Hospital at Mysuru for routine check-up
when she discussed about her left eyelashes rubbing inside
eye. On examination, Doctor advised her to visit Shekar Eye

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019



Hospital, JP Nagar, Bengaluru ( accused no.1 ). Accordingly, on
13.08.2017, she went to said hospital and consulted
Dr.Rajshekar ( accused no.2 ). She further stated that after
examining her, accused no.2 told her that it was not a serious
issue and could be addressed later. He however suggested her
about Implantable Contact Lens ( ICL ) to enable her dispense
with spectacles and referred her to Dr.Udayashree - Retina
Specialist and Dr.Shailesh - Glaucoma Specialist ( accused
no.4 ) of same hospital. It was alleged that neither accused
no.2 nor Dr.Archana Singh ( accused no.3 ) and accused no.4
explained to her about consequences of ICL and risks
associated with said procedure.


3. And that on 15.08.2017, Specular Microscopy of
both eyes of complainant was completed and on 16.08.2017,
accused no.3 took measurements of her eyes and accused no.2
informed her about ICL implantation on left eye on 23.08.2017
and right eye on 26.08.2017. Accordingly, on 16.08.2017
complainant paid advance amount of Rs.50,000/- and
remaining Rs.15,000/- on 23.08.2017. She further stated that
on 23.08.2017 accused no.2 performed ICL implantation on her

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019



left eye on 23.08.2017 in presence of accused no.3. Even
though she complained about discomfort in left eye to accused
no.2, she was assured that it would subside after few days and
on 24.08.2017, bandage was removed from left eye. And that
she complained to accused no.2 and 3 about discomfort in her
left eye even when she visited Hospital again on 26.08.2017,
but accused no.2 assured her that it would be alright and
instructed her to pay Rs.65,000/- for her right eye ICL
implantation. She alleged that despite her continued complaints
about discomfort, accused no.2 and 3 performed ICL
implantation on her right eye by convincing her that everything
would be all right. Further, after removal of bandage on right
eye on 27.08.2017, she complained to accused no.2 about
discomfort in both eyes but was snubbed describing it as
psychological problem. On 02.09.2017, she complained to
accused no.3 about diminishing vision in both eyes. She was
counselled and asked to visit Hospital.


4. And on 03.09.2017, she met accused no.2 and 3 at
Hospital and after some investigation, informed her that some
residual refractive error was left out after ICL implantation,

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019



which accused no.2 promised to rectify by Epi-LASIK Surgery,
which required one month for healing and prescribed
BRIMOLOL eye drops to prevent Intraocular Pressure ( IOP ) in
eyes. She further stated that after 5 days, when complainant
visited accused no.1, accused no.2 examined her and informed
that IOP remained elevated and advised her to undergo YAG
Laser Peripheral Iridotomy ( YAG-PI ) and which was eventually
performed by accused no.4 on 10.11.2017, but without any
improvement.


5. When she visited accused and complained about
diminishing vision, accused no.2 advised her to undergo Epi-
LASIK Surgery, which was performed by accused no.3 on
01.12.2017. But despite above procedures, her vision
continued to deteriorate. Therefore, she complained to accused
no.2 to 4 who assured her that healing required additional
three months. On 03.02.2018, she travelled to Oman to visit
her husband, where she required assistance of flight attendants
and that she struggled to move about at her husband’s house
due to poor vision. On 04.02.2018, complainant’s mother
informed accused no.1 about deterioration of vision and about

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019



complainant sent back to India by her husband on 10.02.2018
her loss of vision. And despite assurances by accused no.2 to 4
on 14.02.2018 when she consulted them her problems
increased.


6. Therefore, she consulted Dr.Mahesh - Eye Specialist
at Mysuru, who advised her to visit Dr.Prabhu at Sushruta Eye
Hospital, Mysuru. On 17.02.2018, she visited Sushruta Eye
Hospital, where Dr.Pallavi diagnosed post-ICL secondary
glaucoma and sent her back to accused no.1 on finding that
accused no.2 had not given complete medical records.
Accordingly, she went back to accused no.1 on 27.02.2018,
where accused no.2 to 4 altered her medication and accused
no.2 advised her to consult psychiatrist. On 10.03.2018, she
visited psychiatrist at JSS Hospital, Mysuru, who examined her
and cleared her of any psychological issues and referred her to
Ophthalmologist in same Hospital, who explicitly opined that
loss of vision was caused due to negligent ICL implantation at
accused no.1. Complainant further stated that for second
opinion, she consulted Dr.Prabhu at Sushruta Eye Hospital on
same day, who confirmed post-ICL secondary glaucoma

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019



diagnosis and advised her to go to Narayana Nethralaya or
Prabha Eye Clinic at Bengaluru, since her IOP was high.


7. She stated that in March, 2018 she visited
Narayana Nethralaya. There, Dr.Satidevi advised her to get all
reports from accused no.1. Despite making complainant wait till
late evening, she was given only filled test report and not entire
medical records. On returning to Narayana Nethralaya,
Dr.Satidevi, advised her that increased IOP and consequent
loss of vision were associated with ICL implantation and that
implanted lenses required early removal. She alleged that by
then, accused no.1 had called Doctors at Narayana Nethralaya
and informed to send her back. Therefore, Dr.Satidevi changed
stance and sent her back to accused no.1, where accused no.2
and 3 once again performed ICL explantation on 14.03.2018.
Even thereafter her vision did not improve, and she developed
corneal bullae with difficulty in opening her eyes and when she
informed accused no.2 about it, he asked to come after one
week. On 22.03.2018, accused no.4 examined her and advised
continuing same eye drops.

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019




8. On 26.03.2018, she got checked her IOP at
Sushruta Hospital, Mysuru and later visited Nethradhama on
06.04.2018, where Dr.Monica advised her to go to accused
no.1 and undergo Trabeculectomy Surgery, but accused no.4
refused to perform same when she approached accused no.1
on 07.04.2018. Therefore on 08.04.2018, she consulted
Dr.Satidevi of Narayana Nethralaya and underwent several
tests later met Dr.Sunitha of Retina Institute, who advised her
to visit Prabha Eye Clinic. Accordingly, on 10.04.2018,
complainant visited Prabha Eye Clinic, where Dr.Gowrimurthy
addressed a letter to Dr.Satidevi, Narayan Nethralaya to
perform surgery. On 12.04.2018, when she visited Narayana
Nethralaya, Dr.Satidevi refused to perform surgery. Therefore,
she went to Prabha Eye Clinic and on 13.04.2018,
Trabeculectomy Surgery was performed on her right eye and
on 18.04.2018, on her left eye. She alleged that accused no.2
subsequently had called complainant and her family members
to Hospital and explicitly admitted responsibility for loss of
vision in both her eyes and offered Rs.50,000/- as
compensation, which they refused. On 10.04.2019, she was

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019



examined at Krishna Rajendra Hospital, MMC, Mysuru and
issued disability certificate about 100% blindness in both eyes.
Thereafter, on 22.04.2019, when complainant visited Minto Eye
Hospital, Bengaluru, Ophthalmologist examined her and issued
disability certificate indicating 100% blindness.


9. Complainant alleged that permanent loss of vision
in both eyes was entirely due to negligence of accused no.1 to
4, who failed to conduct adequate pre-operative examinations,
assess IOP and optic nerve condition, explain risks associated
with ICL implantation, provide appropriate post-operative care,
respond adequately to her repeated complaints and take timely
measures to control increased IOP and prevent further
deterioration of vision. She alleged that doctors failed to
exercise skill and reasonable care and therefore their acts and
omissions resulted in irreversible blindness, rendering her
unable to work or attend to her daily activities independently.
She stated that she had incurred expenses of around Rs.8
Lakhs for treatment and travelling expenses and that loss of
vision adversely affected her employment prospects and
marital life.

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019





10. She alleged that despite issuing a legal notice dated
14.02.2019 and a rejoinder notice dated 26.04.2019, accused
failed to reply. Therefore, she on 25.04.2019, she filed a
complaint before Karnataka Medical Council ( KMC ) as well as
complaint with jurisdictional police on 26.04.2019. She alleged
that police did not registered her case. Therefore on
02.05.2019, she filed complaint with Deputy Commissioner of
Police, Bengaluru, but even after repeated visits, no action was
taken. Hence, left with no other option, she filed private
complaint against accused for offence punishable under Section
338 of IPC and seeking reference of matter to jurisdictional
police under Section 156 (3) of Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 ( CrPC ) for investigation and submission of report.


11. It was stated that on 10.07.2019, learned
Magistrate perused complaint and documents and passed
impugned order directing SHO, Jayaprakash Nagar Police
Station, Bengaluru to conduct investigation and submit report.
Accordingly, FIR in Crime no.141/2019 was registered by
Jayaprakash Nagar Police Station against accused for offences

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019



punishable under Section 338 of IPC, on 06.08.2019. Aggrieved
by said order, this petition was filed.


12. It was firstly submitted, there was inordinate and
unexplained delay in filing complaint. It was submitted though
complainant underwent ICL implantation procedures from
23.08.2017, complaint was filed only on 03.07.2019 i.e., after
lapse of nearly 2 years, indicating afterthought and malafide
intention to harass accused.


13. Further, complainant visited more than 5 hospitals
about issues with her vision and underwent several tests,
procedures and treatments, instead of following up treatment
by accused no.1 on prescribed dates. It was further submitted
that complainant had previously filed a complaint before KMC
and thereafter filed this complaint indicating malafide intention
to harass petitioners.


14. It was submitted, Hon'ble Supreme Court in Jacob
Mathew v. State of Punjab & Anr. , reported in (2005) 6
SCC 1 , held that a private complaint cannot be entertained
unless complainant has produced prima facie evidence in form

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019



of credible opinion given by another competent doctor to
support charge of rashness or negligence on part of accused
doctors. It was submitted learned Magistrate erred in ignoring
non-compliance with said requirement at time of directing
investigation by Jayaprakash Nagar Police Station.


15. It was submitted, even police had not obtained
report from expert opinion before registering FIR against
accused. It was submitted that under similar circumstances
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Martin F. D'Souza v. Mohd.
Ishfaq , reported in (2009) 3 SCC 1 , held that Consumer
Forum or concerned Criminal Court should first refer matter to
a competent doctor or committee of doctors specialized in
relevant field and only in case, such doctor or committee report
about prima facie case of medical negligence, to issue notice to
doctor concerned. It was submitted, Apex Court cautioned
against Courts substituting their views over that of specialists
and observed that police officers and should not harass doctors
unless facts fell within parameters of Jacob Mathew 's case
( supra ) by cautioning that non-compliance would subject errant
police personnel to legal action.

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019





16. It was submitted this Court in Dr.Shyamala Bai &
Ors. v. State of Karnataka & Anr. [ 2023:KHC:22438 ] relied
on Jacob Mathew and Martin F. D'Souza 's cases ( supra ) and
held, when expert opinion indicated no negligence of accused,
this Court upheld contention of abuse of process and quashed
criminal proceedings. And since in present case, KMC had held
no negligence on part of accused and dismissed complaint
dated 27.04.2019, filing of private complaint would be abuse of
process.


17. It was submitted, Hon'ble Supreme Court in ASV
Narayan Rao v. Ratnamala & Anr. , reported in (2013) 10
Jacob Mathew's
SCC 741 referring to case ( supra ) and held
that for an act to amount to criminal negligence, degree of
negligence should be much higher i.e. ‘gross’ or of very high
degree and differs from negligence in civil law. It emphasized
that criminal complaints against doctors should not be
entertained in routine manner without independent opinion
from competent medical specialist. It was submitted that in its
order dated 03.05.02025, KMC found no material about

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019



Criminal Medical Negligence by petitioner. Consequently,
impugned proceedings would not sustain.


18. Smt.Sowmya R., learned HCGP for respondent no.1
- State, opposed petition. It was submitted that due to
negligence of accused, complainant had lost vision in both her
eyes. It was submitted since proceedings were still in initial
stage and only FIR registered expert opinion could be obtained,
therefore sought for opportunity to proceed with investigation.
It was submitted, there was no clarification in Jacob Mathew 's
case ( supra ), when expert opinion was to be obtained, whether
prior to registration of FIR or thereafter. It was submitted even
High Court of Punjab and Haryana in Hardeep Singh Aulakh
v. State of Punjab & Anr. , reported in 2018 SCC OnLine
P&H 5506 , had held when matter was still at stage of
investigation, Investigating Officer could take expert opinion
and comply with directions in Jacob Mathew and ASV
Narayan Rao 's cases ( supra ). Therefore, challenge of
proceedings at this stage was premature and prayed for
dismissal.

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019




19. Respondent no.2 served and unrepresented.


20. Heard learned counsel, perused impugned order
and material on record.


21. This petition is by accused challenging order
directing registration of FIR, conduct investigation and filing of
report on a private complaint filed alleging criminal medical
negligence against medical professionals.


22. Main grounds of challenge are delay of two years in
filing complaint indicating complaint suffered from afterthought,
failure of complainant to follow-up with treatment, filing of
private complaint after filing complaint before KMC, indicative
of malafide intention to harass petitioners, non-compliance with
requirement of obtaining prior expert opinion, held necessary in
Jacob Mathew, Martin F D’Souza and ASV Narayan Rao ’s
cases ( supra ) and lastly, dismissal of complaint by KMC, expert
body, by opinion that there was no case of medical negligence
was established relying on Dr.Shyamala Bai ’s case ( supra ).

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019




23. At outset, it is seen that accused are challenging
order directing investigation and filing of report by police, on
ground of violation of procedural protection as laid down in
Jacob Mathew, Martin F D’Souza and ASV Narayan Rao ’s
cases ( supra ), there is no dispute about procedural protection
afforded to Medical Professionals from harassment by filing
criminal complaints or about fact that subject matter of private
complaint herein is criminal medical negligence.


24. On first contention, it is seen that safeguards in
criminal prosecution of medical professionals were evolved by
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Jacob Mathew ’s case ( supra ) to
ensure that medical professionals are not subjected to
harassment by criminal prosecution in routine manner.
Protection was contemplated at two stages. Firstly, it was held
that no complaint alleging criminal negligence against medical
practitioner ought to be entertained unless complainant
produces prima facie evidence in form of credible opinion of a
competent doctor supporting allegation of rashness or
negligence and secondly, even Investigating Officer would
require to obtain independent medical opinion preferably from

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019



doctor in Government service before proceeding against
medical professional on such allegations. With clarification in
ASV Narayan Rao ’s cases ( supra ) that for criminal medical
negligence, degree of negligence was much higher i.e. gross or
of very high degree.


25. Though, present case distinguishes on facts in
Jacob Mathew ’s case ( supra ) to extent that complaint therein
was filed with Police, whereas it is a private complaint herein,
wherein direction is issued for investigation and filing of report,
safeguards laid down in Jacob Mathew ’s case ( supra ) would
nevertheless apply.


26. But, private complaint is indisputably not
accompanied with opinion of independent and competent
medical professional about rashness or negligence and even
Investigating Officer has failed to obtain opinion from
Government Doctor. Merely on ground that direction for
investigation is issued by Magistrate, cannot be ground for
dispensing with prescribed safeguards. In this regard, learned
HCGP relied on observation of High Court of Punjab and

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019



Haryana in para-8 of decision in Hardeep Singh Aulakh ’s case
( supra ), to contend that compliance with procedural protection
as per Jacob Mathew and ASV Narayanan Rao ’s cases
( supra ) could be done prior to filing of charge sheet or arrest of
medical professional. But finding of Court is as follows:
“8.
The above observations of Hon'ble Apex Court
have not been disputed. In this case the
matter is still at the stage of investigation. The
investigating officer before filing of challan can
always take opinion of expert and comply with
directions in case of Jacob Mathew (supra) and
A.S.V. Narayanan Rao (supra).

9.
The question, which arises for consideration in
this petition, is as to whether there is any
merit in submission of learned counsel for the
petitioner that recording of instant FIR against
petitioner is misuse of process of law? The
answer to this can only be in negative. The
police while recording FIR has considered
expert opinion of doctors of PGI, Chandigarh.
While proceeding further, the investigating
officer may take further steps to comply with
directions issued by the Director General of
Police to comply with observations of Hon'ble
Apex Court in case of Jacob Mathew (supra)
and to collect other expert opinion as required
before reaching the conclusion that offence of
negligence is made out against the petitioner.
It is not disputed that cannula remained
inserted in finger of infant for a period of about
one week. On finding swelling and blackening
of arm, he was referred to Cosmo Hospital,
Mohali, where complainant could not afford
expenses of the hospital and rushed to PGI,
Chandigarh. Fortunately, the child responded
to treatment there but the finger of his right
hand had to be amputated. Complainant has

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019



all the reasons particularly in view of opinion
of medical expert of PGI, Chandigarh to report
the matter to police and get the FIR
registered, which cannot be termed as misuse
of process of law.”


27. It is seen that decision therein pivoted on fact that
Police had considered expert opinion of Medical Expert from
PGI, Chandigarh at stage of registration of FIR and thus there
was compliance with procedural protection. In fact, it rejected
quashing petition by relying on very same expert opinion which
indicated negligence.


28. At same time, it has to be further clarified that
‘independent expert opinion’ need not necessarily be
understood as requiring complete assessment by expert.
Though in Para 9 and 13 of private complaint, there is assertion
about Opthalmologist of JSS Hospital opining that loss of vision
was due to negligence of accused no.1 in carrying out ICL
implantation on complainant, no such report was appended to
complaint. Therefore, failure of procedural protection would be
evident. Apart from above, it is seen that said opinion was
referred to by KMC at time of arriving at conclusion about

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019



failure to establish medical negligence and rejecting complaint
filed by present complainant.

29. Next contention about complaint being belated and
therefore suffering from afterthought to harass accused. But,
as held by Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of Skoda Auto
Volkswagen (India) (P) Ltd. v. State of U.P. , reported in
(2021) 5 SCC 795, reiterated in Punit Beriwala v. State
(NCT of Delhi) reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 983 , that
except where it was unexplained and deliberate, mere delay in
lodging complaint would not justify quashing of FIR. In instant
case, complainant has rather exhaustively narrated treatment
events almost upto date of filing complaint and which prima
facie appears sufficient. And when accused allege failure of
complainant to follow-up treatment prescribed by accused and
complainant has explained how she completed treatment
procedures suggested by accused, contention based on delay
would not be justified. In any case, since complaint is for
offence under Section 338 of IPC, it would suffice if complaint
were filed within three years of alleged incident as per Section
468 (2) (c) of CrPC.

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019





30. And lastly about untenability of complaint after
dismissal of complaint by KMC, there is no dispute about
dismissal of complaint filed by present complainant, by KMC on
03.05.2025 rejecting allegation of medical negligence against
accused after examining virtually very same allegations.
Incidentally, proceedings before KMC involved calling for
explanation from accused doctors, receiving evidence by way of
affidavits, permitting cross-examination of parties and
considering documentary evidence and as per Sections 16 and
17 of Karnataka Medical Registration Act, 1961 ( KMR Act ),
KMC is vested with powers of Civil Court while holding inquiries
and proceedings would be judicial proceedings though for
purposes of Sections 193 and 228 of IPC. However, in view of
conclusion about violation of procedural protection in terms of
Jacob Mathew ’s case ( supra ), petition would succeed.


31. Hon'ble Supreme Court in Anukul Singh v. State
of U.P. , reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2060 , has held that
in a quashing petition filed invoking jurisdiction under Section
482 of CrPC, this Court would exercise jurisdiction only under

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64497
CRL.P No. 7946 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010478912019



three circumstances, firstly, where it is necessary to give effect
to any order under CrPC; secondly, to prevent abuse of process
of any Court and thirdly, to secure ends of justice. In view of
findings hereinabove, instant case would qualify for quashing of
proceedings for prevention of abuse of process.

succeeds
32. Consequently, petition , order dated
10.07.2019 passed by XLIV ACMM, Bengaluru in PCR
no.8460/2019 and all further proceeding including registration
of FIR in Crime no.141/2019 by Jayaprakash Nagar Police
Station, Bengaluru for offence punishable under Section 338 of
IPC are quashed .

Sd/-
(RAVI V HOSMANI)
JUDGE


YKL,AV,GRD
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 1