Mark Splendour Nonwovens (P) Ltd. vs Rakesh Gupta

Court
Delhi High Court

$~
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
% Judgment reserved on: 08.07.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 17.09.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 17.09.2026
# CNR No. DLHC010374502024
+ RFA(COMM) 240/2024
MARK SPLENDOUR NONWOVENS (P) LTD. .....Appellant
Through: Mr. Anjani Kumar Singh, Adv.

versus

RAKESH GUPTA .....Respondent
Through: Mr. A.K. Thakur, Mr. Rishi
Raj, Mr. Ningthem Oinam,
Advs.

CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SHAIL JAIN
J U D G M E N T
SHAIL JAIN, J.:
1. The present Appeal has been filed under Section 13 of the
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 (hereinafter also referred to as the “Act
of 2015”), read with the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 (hereinafter also referred to as the “CPC”), assailing the
Judgment and Decree dated 08th January, 2024 (hereinafter also
referred to as the “impugned Judgment”), passed by the learned
District Judge (Commercial Court)-02/West, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi,
in CS (COMM.) No.39/2020, titled Rakesh Gupta v. M/s Mark
Splendour Nonwovens (P) Ltd.

Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 1 of 18

2. By way of the impugned Judgment, the learned Commercial
Court decreed the suit instituted by the Respondent/Plaintiff for a
principal sum of Rs.36,35,584/- (Rupees Thirty-Six Lakh Thirty-Five
Thousand Five Hundred and Eighty-Four only), together with costs
and interest at the rate of 18% per annum from 31st October, 2018 till
institution of the suit, and pendente lite and future interest at the rate
of 12% per annum from the date of institution of the suit till
realisation.
BRIEF FACTS
3. The brief factual background leading to the filing of the present
Appeal is set out hereunder:
A. The Appellant/Defendant, M/s Mark Splendour Nonwovens (P)
Ltd., is a private limited company having its office/manufacturing unit
at Chopanki, Bhiwadi, District Alwar, Rajasthan.
B. The Respondent/Plaintiff, Rakesh Gupta, is the proprietor of M/s
G.G. Enterprises, situated at WZ-524, Basai Darapur, Near Fun
Cinema, New Delhi-110015, and is engaged in the business of supply
of different varieties of coating powder, including scrap.
C. The parties entered into commercial dealings in the year 2015.
According to the Respondent/Plaintiff, goods were supplied to the
Appellant/Defendant on credit against invoices raised from time to
time. The Respondent maintained a Ledger Account in the regular
course of business and the Appellant made part-payments towards the
supplies.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 2 of 18

D. The Respondent claimed that, after giving credit for all payments
received from the Appellant, including the last payment of
Rs.1,04,040/- (Rupees One Lakh Four Thousand and Forty only)
made on 30th October, 2018, a sum of Rs.36,35,584/- remained
outstanding as on 31.10.2018.
E. Upon failure of the Appellant to clear the outstanding amount
despite requests, the Respondent issued a legal demand notice dated
22.06.2019. The amount remained unpaid and the proceedings for pre-
institution mediation also did not fructify. Consequently, the
Respondent instituted the commercial suit on 18.01.2020.
F. During the pendency of the suit, the opportunity of the Appellant to
file its Written Statement was initially closed vide Order dated 27th
September, 2021. The said Order was challenged before this Court
and, vide Order dated 16.11.2022, the Appellant was granted an
opportunity to file its Written Statement, pursuant whereto the defence
of the Appellant came on record.
G. The Appellant disputed its liability. Its principal defence was that
the Respondent had approached it at Bhiwadi with a proposal to
supply material at a rate lower than the prevailing market rate.
According to the Appellant, it had agreed to purchase only such
material as conformed to the agreed specifications and was
accompanied by the requisite Test Reports. It was pleaded that mere
delivery of material at the Appellant’s premises did not amount to
acceptance thereof.

Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 3 of 18

H. The Appellant further alleged that the Respondent supplied
scrap/waste powder without Test Reports and subsequently supplied
material which did not conform to specifications. The Appellant
claimed to have rejected goods worth Rs.34,15,742/- (Rupees Thirty-
Four Lakh Fifteen Thousand Seven Hundred and Forty-Two only) and
asserted that it was compelled to procure substitute material from the
market at higher rates.
I. In support of the alleged rejection, the Appellant principally relied
upon its Ledger, exhibited as Ex. DW1/2 (Colly.), and a summary
statement of allegedly rejected bills.
J. The Appellant also objected to the territorial jurisdiction of the
learned Commercial Court. It pleaded that the Respondent had
approached the Appellant at Bhiwadi; that the negotiations had taken
place there; that the goods had been received at Bhiwadi; and that the
contract had been concluded there. On this basis, it was contended that
the Courts at Bhiwadi alone possessed territorial jurisdiction.
K. The Respondent, in support of his claim, entered the witness box as
PW-1 and relied upon the invoices raised during the course of
dealings, his Ledger Account, Bank Statement, legal notice and other
documents. The Appellant examined Daya Singh, its Authorised
Representative, as DW-1 and relied, inter alia, upon its own Ledger.
L. On completion of pleadings, the learned Commercial Court framed
the following issues:
“1. Whether plaintiff is entitled to recovery of Rs.42,46,455/-?
OPP
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 4 of 18

2. Whether this court lacks territorial jurisdiction to entertain the
present suit? OPD
3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to recovery of interest? If so, at
what rate and from which period? OPP
4. Relief.”

M. On the issue of territorial jurisdiction, the learned Commercial
Court noticed the admission of PW-1 that he had visited the Appellant
at Bhiwadi and that the negotiations had taken place there. It also
noticed that the goods were received by the Appellant at Bhiwadi. The
learned Commercial Court, however, held that these circumstances did
not exclude its jurisdiction. It found that no place of payment had been
fixed between the parties and, applying the principle that in the
absence of an agreed place of payment the debtor must seek the
creditor, held that part of the cause of action arose at the Respondent’s
place of business at Basai Darapur, which fell within its territorial
jurisdiction.
N. The learned Commercial Court also noticed that the invoices
contained a clause stipulating that disputes would be subject to the
jurisdiction of Courts at Delhi.
O. On the merits of the claim, the learned Commercial Court rejected
the Appellant’s defence regarding rejection of goods. It found, inter
alia , that the alleged requirement of Test Reports had not been
established; the purchase orders in which the said condition was
claimed to have been incorporated had not been produced; no written
communication of rejection had been proved; the allegedly rejected
goods had never been returned; and the alleged oral communication
through Rajpal had not been proved by examining him as a witness.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 5 of 18

4. The principal grounds urged by the Appellant in the present
Appeal are as follows:
A. The learned Commercial Court erred in assuming territorial
jurisdiction despite the Respondent admitting that he had visited the
Appellant at Bhiwadi and that the dealings between the parties had
originated there. According to the Appellant, no representative of the
Appellant had visited the Respondent at Delhi and the contract stood
concluded at Bhiwadi.
B. The Appellant contends that the mere fact that the
Respondent/Plaintiff, being the supplier or creditor, carried on
business at Delhi could not confer territorial jurisdiction upon the
Courts at Delhi.
C. On merits, it is contended that the Respondent supplied scrap/waste
powder without the requisite Test Reports and that the material
subsequently supplied did not conform to the agreed specifications. It
is asserted that goods worth Rs.34,15,742/- were rejected and that
such rejected material was duly reflected in the Appellant’s Ledger.
D. It is further contended that, owing to such defective supplies, the
Appellant was compelled to procure material from the market at
higher rates and consequently suffered losses. The learned
Commercial Court is stated to have failed to appreciate the evidence in
this regard.
5. Per contra, the Respondent supports the impugned Judgment.
His case, in substance, is as follows:
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 6 of 18

A. The goods supplied to the Appellant were received and retained
without any contemporaneous objection regarding quality,
specifications or absence of Test Reports.
B. The Appellant failed to establish that furnishing of Test Reports
was an agreed contractual condition or that any particular consignment
was rejected and such rejection communicated to the Respondent
within a reasonable time.
C. On the issue of territorial jurisdiction, the Respondent relies upon
the fact that supplies originated from Delhi; that no different place of
payment had been agreed; that payment was consequently payable to
the creditor at his place of business; and that the invoices contained a
clause subjecting disputes to the jurisdiction of Courts at Delhi.
QUESTIONS FOR CONSIDERATION
6. In view of the grounds urged in the Appeal, the following
questions arise for consideration:
A. Whether the learned Commercial Court possessed territorial
jurisdiction to entertain and try CS (COMM.) No.39/2020?
B. Whether the finding of the learned Commercial Court rejecting the
Appellant’s defence that goods worth Rs.34,15,742/- had been
rejected for want of Test Reports and non-conformity with the
requisite specifications calls for interference in the present first
appeal?

Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 7 of 18

ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION
7. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and having perused
the pleadings, the oral and documentary evidence and the impugned
Judgment, this Court proceeds to examine the aforesaid questions.
TERRITORIAL JURISDICTION
8. The first objection of the Appellant is that the learned
Commercial Court at Delhi lacked territorial jurisdiction since the
Respondent had himself approached the Appellant at Bhiwadi,
negotiations had taken place there, the goods were received there, and
the contract stood concluded there.
9. The evidence does establish that the Respondent initially visited
the Appellant’s premises at Chopanki, Bhiwadi. PW-1 stated in cross-
examination that he had met Rajpal at the Appellant’s office at
Bhiwadi, carried samples with him and commenced supply after
approval of the samples.
10. The learned Commercial Court, therefore, correctly recognised
that material components of the transaction arose at Bhiwadi. The
question, however, is whether that circumstance necessarily excluded
the territorial jurisdiction of the learned Commercial Court at Delhi.
11. Section 20(c) CPC permits a suit to be instituted before a Court
within whose territorial limits the cause of action, wholly or in part,
arises. In a contractual dispute, different components of the cause of
action may arise at different places. The place where the contract was
made, the place where it was to be performed and the place where
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 8 of 18

payment was expressly or impliedly payable are all relevant
connecting factors.
1
12. In A.B.C. Laminart Pvt. Ltd. v. A.P. Agencies, Salem , the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, while considering Section 20(c) CPC in the
context of contractual disputes, recognised that part of the cause of
action may arise where money payable under the contract is expressly
or impliedly payable. It was also recognised that where more than one
Court otherwise possesses jurisdiction, the parties may agree to
confine their disputes to one of such Courts.
13. In the present case, there is evidence connecting the
performance of the transactions with Delhi as well. PW-1 stated that
the goods were manufactured and supplied to the Appellant from his
establishment at Delhi.
14. More importantly, DW-1, the Authorised Representative
examined by the Appellant itself, admitted in cross-examination that
the supplies were made by the Respondent to the Appellant from
Delhi. He, however, qualified his answer by stating that the material
was received at the Appellant’s factory at Bhiwadi and that payments
were released from Chopanki.
15. Thus, while the goods were admittedly received by the
Appellant at Bhiwadi, the evidence led by both sides establishes that
the supplies originated from Delhi. The place from which the goods
were supplied may not, in every contractual dispute, by itself be

1
(1989) 2 SCC 163

Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 9 of 18

determinative of territorial jurisdiction. Nevertheless, on the facts of
the present case, it forms one of the connecting circumstances in the
course of the parties’ commercial dealings.
16. The place at which payment was required to be made
constitutes a further and significant connecting factor.
17. The learned Commercial Court found that none of the invoices
specified a particular place at which payment was required to be
made. The Appellant also failed to establish any separate agreement
under which payment was required to be made at Bhiwadi or at any
other specified place.
18. The learned Commercial Court relied upon the decision of this
2
Court in Satyapal v. Slick Auto Accessories Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. ,
wherein the principle that the debtor must seek the creditor was
applied in circumstances where no place of payment had been agreed
upon.
19. The Appellant has specifically contended that the place of the
Plaintiff/supplier/creditor cannot, by itself, confer territorial
jurisdiction and that any such proposition would run contrary to
Section 20 CPC.
20. There can be no quarrel with the proposition that the mere
residence or place of business of a plaintiff does not, by itself, furnish
territorial jurisdiction under Section 20(c) CPC. The relevance of the
creditor’s place in the present case, however, arises for a different

2
RSA No.40/2013, decided on 05.03.2014

Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 10 of 18

reason. Where no place of payment has been contractually fixed, the
obligation to make payment is ordinarily required to be performed at
the place of the creditor. The performance of that contractual
obligation forms part of the cause of action.
21. The Respondent is the proprietor of M/s G.G. Enterprises,
whose business establishment at WZ-524, Basai Darapur, New Delhi
falls within the territorial jurisdiction of the learned Commercial
Court. In the absence of any agreed place of payment to the contrary, a
material component of the contractual obligation was therefore
performable within its territorial jurisdiction.
22. It is relevant to notice that the learned Commercial Court itself
found that the Respondent’s Axis Bank account, into which certain
payments were credited, was maintained at Shastri Nagar and was not
situated within the territorial jurisdiction of that particular Commercial
Court. The finding regarding territorial jurisdiction therefore need not,
and does not, rest merely upon the location of the bank account into
which electronic payments were ultimately received.
23. There is yet another circumstance. DW-1 admitted in cross-
examination that the invoices raised by the Respondent contained a
clause stipulating that the Courts at Delhi would have jurisdiction.
24. It is settled that parties cannot, by agreement, confer jurisdiction
upon a Court which otherwise does not possess it. However, where
two or more Courts are otherwise competent on account of parts of the
cause of action having arisen within their respective territorial limits,
the parties may agree to confine their disputes to one such jurisdiction.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 11 of 18

25. In the present case, the jurisdiction clause is therefore not being
treated as the source of jurisdiction. A material part of the cause of
action independently arose within the territorial jurisdiction of the
learned Commercial Court, particularly because the contractual
obligation to make payment was performable at the place of the
creditor. The stipulation contained in the invoices operates as an
additional circumstance supporting the parties’ choice of Delhi as the
contractual forum.
26. The fact that the contract was concluded and the goods were
received at Bhiwadi may establish that the Courts at Bhiwadi also
possessed jurisdiction, but it does not establish that their jurisdiction
was exclusive.
27. Accordingly, upon an independent consideration of the
pleadings and evidence, this Court finds no error in the conclusion of
the learned Commercial Court that it possessed territorial jurisdiction
to entertain the suit. Question A is accordingly answered against the
Appellant and in favour of the Respondent.
REJECTION OF GOODS
28. The second and principal challenge on merits is founded upon
the Appellant’s assertion that goods worth Rs.34,15,742/- were
rejected because they were not accompanied by Test Reports and did
not conform to the agreed specifications.
29. The Appellant does not dispute receipt of the material supplied
by the Respondent. Its defence is founded upon a subsequent event,
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 12 of 18

namely, rejection of a substantial portion thereof. The burden of
establishing that defence necessarily lay upon the Appellant.
30. In order to succeed on this defence, it was incumbent upon the
Appellant to establish, at the minimum:
A. that furnishing of Test Reports and conformity with identified
specifications constituted agreed conditions governing the supplies;
B. that particular consignments supplied by the Respondent failed to
satisfy those conditions; and
C. that rejection of such consignments was communicated to the
Respondent within a reasonable time.
31. On the first aspect, the testimony of DW-1 is significant. In his
affidavit, he stated that it had been agreed that only material
accompanied by Test Reports and conforming to specifications would
be accepted by the Appellant.
32. During cross-examination, DW-1 further stated that the
requirement relating to Test Reports was contained in the purchase
orders. When specifically called upon to identify the said term and the
relevant purchase order from the judicial record, the witness, after
examining the record, stated that no such purchase order was on
record.
33. PW-1, on the other hand, denied that Rajpal had ever required
the material to be accompanied by Test Reports. He further stated that
no purchase orders were issued by the Appellant and that the orders
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 13 of 18

were placed verbally.
34. In these circumstances, the Appellant failed to establish by
satisfactory evidence that furnishing a Test Report constituted an
agreed and mandatory condition precedent to acceptance of the goods.
35. The record is equally deficient on the alleged non-conformity of
the goods. The Appellant has not identified any contemporaneous
material establishing the precise specifications allegedly agreed
between the parties or demonstrating that any identified consignment
failed to conform thereto.
36. The evidence relating to the alleged rejection assumes greater
significance in this background.
37. DW-1 admitted in cross-examination that no letter had ever
been written to the Respondent with respect to the rejected material.
He also admitted that the allegedly rejected material was never
returned to the Respondent.
38. DW-1 volunteered that the Respondent had been orally
informed through Rajpal to collect the rejected material. However,
DW-1 himself admitted that he had never met the Respondent and that
the discussions with the Respondent were stated to have taken place
through Rajpal. Rajpal was not examined as a witness.
39. The Appellant also relied upon a summary Ledger Statement of
allegedly rejected bills, Ex. DW1/P1. DW-1 stated that a copy thereof
had been handed over to the Respondent when the material was
rejected. However, he was unable to recall either the date or time
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 14 of 18

when the document was allegedly furnished. His testimony does not
disclose any contemporaneous acknowledgment or other material
corroborating its delivery to the Respondent.
40. The Appellant further relied upon its Ledger, Ex. DW1/2, in
support of the alleged rejection. Even if the entries therein are taken at
their highest and assumed to correctly reflect the Appellant’s books of
account, they establish only the entries made by the Appellant in its
own records. Such unilateral entries, without supporting evidence,
cannot by themselves establish that the goods were in fact rejected or,
more importantly, that such rejection was communicated to the
Respondent.
41. Section 42 of the Sale of Goods Act, 1930 is relevant in this
regard. The provision contemplates, inter alia , that a buyer is deemed
to have accepted the goods where, after delivery, the buyer retains
them beyond a reasonable time without intimating the seller that they
have been rejected.
42. The present case is not one where the Appellant denies receipt
of the goods. The material was admittedly delivered to and retained by
the Appellant. The allegedly rejected material was never returned. The
alleged Test Report condition itself remained unproved. No reliable
contemporaneous communication establishing rejection of identified
consignments was proved.
43. The Appellant has also asserted that it was compelled to procure
substitute material from the market at higher rates. However, no
documentary material has been pointed out to this Court establishing
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 15 of 18

such replacement purchases or correlating them with any particular
consignment supplied by the Respondent.
44. Viewed cumulatively, therefore, the Appellant failed to
establish the essential factual foundation of its defence. The alleged
Test Report condition was not proved, the agreed specifications were
not established, non-conformity of any identified consignment was not
demonstrated by satisfactory independent material, and rejection was
not proved to have been reliably communicated to the Respondent.
FIRST APPELLATE APPRAISAL
45. Since the present proceedings constitute a first Appeal, this
Court is required to examine the findings returned by the learned
Commercial Court upon an independent appreciation of the evidence
on record. Questions of fact as well as law are open for
reconsideration.
46. Having undertaken the aforesaid exercise, this Court finds itself
in agreement with the ultimate conclusion reached by the learned
Commercial Court. The conclusion does not rest merely upon
deference to the view taken by the learned Commercial Court. It
follows independently from the evidence on record, particularly the
admissions made by DW-1, the absence of the purchase orders relied
upon by him, the absence of reliable contemporaneous evidence
establishing rejection, and the admitted retention of the goods.
47. The last payment of Rs.1,04,040/- has consistently been stated
by the Respondent in his evidence to have been made on 30.10.2018.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 16 of 18

The Memorandum of Appeal also proceeds on the same date. The
present Appeal shall therefore be considered on that basis.
48. Once the defence regarding rejection of goods worth
Rs.34,15,742/- fails, the Memorandum of Appeal does not disclose
any specific ground challenging the computation of the outstanding
principal amount of Rs.36,35,584/- or asserting that any further
payment or adjustment was omitted from consideration.
49. The learned Commercial Court was therefore justified in
holding the Respondent entitled to recover the principal sum of
Rs.36,35,584/-. Question B is accordingly answered against the
Appellant and in favour of the Respondent.
50. It may further be noticed that no specific ground or submission
has been urged challenging the award of pre-suit, pendente lite or
future interest. No separate determination on the rate or period of
interest is therefore called for in the present Appeal.
CONCLUSION
51. The Appeal thus fails on both grounds on which the impugned
Judgment and Decree have been assailed. The learned Commercial
Court possessed territorial jurisdiction to entertain the suit and the
Appellant failed to establish its defence that goods worth
Rs.34,15,742/- had been validly rejected.
52. The present Appeal is, accordingly, dismissed and the
impugned Judgment and Decree are affirmed. The Respondent shall
be entitled to the decretal amount together with interest in terms of the
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 17 of 18

impugned Judgment and Decree.
53. The amount deposited by the Appellant with the Registry of this
Court, together with the interest accrued thereon, if any, shall be
released in favour of the Respondent, subject to due verification, and
shall stand adjusted towards satisfaction of the decree.
54. The Appellant shall satisfy the balance decretal liability, if any,
after giving effect to the aforesaid adjustment, within four weeks from
today.
55. There shall be no order as to costs in the present Appeal.


SHAIL JAIN, J.

ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
SEPTEMBER 17, 2026
Adi/MM
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
Signing Date:17.09.2026
15:39:10
RFA(COMM) 240/2024 Page 18 of 18