GAGGAL AIRPORT EXPANSION AFFECTED SOCIAL WELFARE COMMITTEE vs THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY (TOURISM AND CA) AND OTHERS

Court
High Court of Himachal Pradesh

2026:HHC:49585
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
High Court of H.P.
CWP No.7846 of 2023
Reserved on: 30.07.2026
Date of decision: 18.11.2026
Uploaded on: 19.11.2026
Gaggal Airport Expansion Affected
Social Welfare Committee. ...Petitioner.
Versus
The Principal Secretary (Tourism & CA),
Government of Himachal Pradesh & Ors. …Respondents.
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Vivek Singh Thakur, Judge.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjan Sharma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? Yes.
For the petitioner : Ms. Ritta Goswami, Senior Advocate
with Ms. Komal Chaudhary & Ms. Rekha
Thakur, Advocates.

For the respondent(s) : Mr. Anup Rattan, Advocate General with
Mr. Ramakant Sharma, Additional
Advocates General and Ms. Swati Draik,
Deputy Advocate General, for
respondents No.1 & 2-State as well as
respondents No.3 & 4.

: Mr. Balram Sharma, Deputy Solicitor
General of India (Senior Advocate) with
Mr. Rajeev Sharma, Advocate, for
respondent No.5-UOI.

: Ms. Shreya Chauhan, Advocate, for
respondent No.6.


Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment? Yes
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-2-


Vivek Singh Thakur, Judge
High Court of H.P.
Petitioner-Gaggal Airport Expansion Affected Social
Welfare Committee (hereinafter to be referred as the ' Petitioner-
Committee '), through its President Rajneesh Mona, has filed this
petition invoking the provisions of Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, seeking the following substantial reliefs: -
"(1) That a writ in nature of certiorari may kindly be issued and the
Notification dated 07.07.2023 may kindly be quashed in the
interest of justice.
(2) That the report dated 03.05.2023 prepared by SIA (Social
Impact Assessment) and ditto stamped by the Expert Group vide
letter dated 05.06.2023 being violative of the rules as well as the
mandatory provisions of the Act ibid may kindly be rejected.
(3) That if the Hon'ble court comes to the conclusion that the
expansion of the Airport is for the public purpose than in that
eventuality, the three alternative sites mentioned in the SIA report
may kindly be considered in the interest of justice.”

FACTS OF THE CASE
2. In the State of Himachal Pradesh, there are three
airports, namely: Bhuntar Airport (Kullu), operational since 1956 and
metalled in 1967; Shimla Airport, operational since 1987; and Kangra
Airport (Gaggal Airport), operational since 1989.
3. Amongst the aforesaid airports, Kangra Airport has the
largest runway length of 1372×30 meters, which is suitable for
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-3-


landing 72-seater aircraft with load penalty, and at present, ATR-42
High Court of H.P.
aircraft is operating from this airport with load penalty.
4. Vide communication dated 11.07.2019, the Directorate
General of Civil Aviation communicated to the Chairman, Airports
Authority of India (AAI), that the Civil Aviation Department of the
Government of Himachal Pradesh had no objection for night landing
of Indian Air Force aircraft at Gaggal Airport in case of an actual
emergency and for any future drills, as requested by AAI and the
Ministry of Civil Aviation. However, during such operations, certain
conditions to be complied with were also communicated.
5. On the request of the State Government of Himachal
Pradesh, vide letter dated 15.11.2019 addressed to the Chairman,
Airports Authority of India (AAI), regarding development/expansion
of Kangra Airport, AAI officials visited the site on 21.12.2019 and
22.12.2019, and forwarded their preliminary analysis vide
communication dated 03.01.2020 along with a draft Master Plan,
with recommendation of runway extension of 1950 meters and to
explore the feasibility for acquisition of additional land, as well as
channelization of Manjhi Khad for a bridge of 380 meters width to be
constructed with the approval and specifications of the Bureau of
Civil Aviation Security (BCAS).
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-4-


6. Upon receipt of the draft Master Plan, vide letter dated
High Court of H.P.
29.10.2020, Government of Himachal Pradesh, Department of
Tourism and Civil Aviation, conveyed that the Deputy Commissioner,
Kangra at Dharamshala had identified the land for expansion of
Kangra Airport.
7. Vide communications dated 11.12.2020 and
15.01.2021, the Department of Tourism and Civil Aviation requested
for an Obstacle Limitation Surface (OLS) survey and a feasibility
study for the land identified for the purpose of expansion of Kangra
Airport.
8. An OLS survey was conducted by a team of officials of
AAI, and the OLS chart and obstacle penetration data for Kangra
Airport was forwarded to the Government of Himachal Pradesh on
16.04.2021 and 17.04.2021, which was confirmed by communication
dated 06.05.2021. Thereafter, a feasibility study report and
development plan were prepared for expansion of Kangra Airport in
two phases.
9. Vide communication dated 07.10.2021, the Airports
Authority of India communicated, the possibility of development of
Kangra Airport (Gaggal Airport) in two phases, to the Principal
Secretary (Tourism and Civil Aviation) to the Government of
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-5-


Himachal Pradesh (Annexure R-2), stating therein that Kangra
High Court of H.P.
Airport can be developed in two phases: Phase-I for operation of
ATR-72/Q-400 type of aircraft, and Phase-II for operation of A-320
type of aircraft.
10. Vide aforesaid communication dated 07.10.2021, AAI
informed the Government of Himachal Pradesh that major cutting
and filling involved in the project required to be studied for diversion
of streams, cutting and filling, and environmental clearances are to
be obtained before taking up the work for the project, and it was
decided by the State Government that land shall be acquired in only
one phase for the complete expansion plan of extension of runway
up to 3010 meters.
11. Vide letter dated 02.11.2021, the Airports Authority of
India communicated to the Principal Secretary (Public Works,
Tourism and Civil Aviation) to the Government of Himachal Pradesh
that it would not be advisable to go ahead with the proposal of
extension of the runway of Shimla Airport as well as Kullu (Bhuntar)
Airport.
12. The Central Government, through the Ministry of Civil
Aviation, constituted a Committee to carry out a study of earmarked
and additional safety measures of airports in the country so that
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-6-


remedial measures can be taken. The said Committee identified nine
High Court of H.P.
airports in the country which require additional safety measures, and
Kangra Airport (Gaggal Airport) was also one of those airports.
13. Vide communication dated 02.03.2022 (Annexure R-1),
the Airports Authority of India, through its Airport Director,
communicated to the Deputy Commissioner, Kangra (respondent
No.3) for expansion of Gaggal Airport as Brown Field Project so that
additional safety measures can be deployed to make air operations
more safe, with a request to hand over land adjacent to the airport
boundary near Runway End 33 up to Manjhi Khad to AAI
immediately on priority, so that AAI may take up work for provision
of Runway End Safety Area (RESA) as an immediate intermediate
measure till the runway extension work is taken up in the future.
Relevant para of the communication reads as under:-
“It has been suggested by the committee to explore the
construction of RESA (Runway End Safety Area) at Kangra
Airport. The State Govt. is already working on the land acquisition
for expansion of Kangra Airport for Runway length of 3010m as
per the proposed master plan. It is most humbly requested that
the immediate land adjacent to airport boundary near runway
end 33 upto Manjhi Khad, may please be handed over to AAI
on priority , so that we may take-up the work for provision of
RESA, as an immediate intermediate measure till the runway
expansion work is taken up in near future.”

::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-7-


14. Vide letter dated 16.02.2023, the Government of
High Court of H.P.
Himachal Pradesh was requested to provide the scope of work for
the techno-economic feasibility study, which was awarded to
WAPCOS Ltd.. The State Government had also engaged the Central
Water and Power Research Station (CWPRS) for a hydrological
study of River Manjhi Khad and recommendations for construction
of a bridge/box culvert on it, and WAPCOS Ltd. for a feasibility study
and preparation of DPR. CWPRS has submitted its report
recommending construction of a box culvert on River Manjhi
underneath the proposed runway with several river training works
upstream and downstream.
15. An interim report of the techno-economic feasibility
study was forwarded by the Government of Himachal Pradesh vide
communication dated 24.04.2023. A copy of the interim report of the
techno-economic feasibility study was sent by the Principal
Secretary (Tourism and Civil Aviation) vide letter dated 24.04.2023
to the Executive Director (Planning), Airports Authority of India, with
a request to examine the DPR and send comments/approval for
further necessary action.
16. Vide communication dated 25.08.2023, the Wing
Commander, Senior Air Traffic Control Officer, communicated to the
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-8-


Airport Director, Gaggal Airport, and intimated that an Air Force
High Court of H.P.
exercise was planned at Gaggal Airfield on 12.09.2023, details
whereof had not been finalized and would be intimated later, and
requested for necessary cooperation, including providing extension
of watch hours if required for the aforesaid exercise.
17. A similar letter dated 30.08.2023 (depicted to be of
12.09.2023) was sent to the Airport Director, Gaggal Airport, by the
Wing Commander, Commanding Officer, who vide communication
dated 08.09.2023 had informed and requested the Airport Director,
Gaggal Airport, Kangra, regarding issuance of necessary clearance
for conduct of exercise by the Air Force at Gaggal Airfield, Kangra,
tentatively on 12.09.2023.
18. The State of Himachal Pradesh, in exercise of the
powers conferred upon the Governor under Rule 4 of the Himachal
Pradesh Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement (Social Impact
Assessment and Consent) Rules, 2015 (hereinafter to be referred as
‘ HP Right to Fair Compensation Rules, 2015 ’), has notified the
constitution of the Social Impact Assessment Unit vide Notification
dated 27.11.2015, to act as an independent organization for carrying
out the purposes of the aforesaid Rules, comprising the Director, HP
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-9-


Institute of Public Administration (HIPA), Fairlawn, Shimla as
High Court of H.P.
Chairman; Incharge, State Institute of Rural Development, HIPA,
Shimla as Member; Head, Department of Sociology and Social
Work, HP University, Shimla, as Member; and Chief Scientific
Officer, Department of Environment, Scientific & Technology, Shimla
as Member.
19. On the basis of the Master Plan and Technical
Feasibility Report received from the Airports Authority of India, as
mentioned in the aforesaid communications, the course of action,
initiated by the State Government for expansion of Kangra Airport,
was undertaken, and the process for land acquisition under the Right
to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 was initiated.
20. The Social Impact Assessment Unit, vide advertisement
dated 11.02.2023, invited Expression of Interest (EOI) and financial
bids for conducting the Social Impact Assessment study from
organizations/institutions empanelled with the Social Impact
Assessment Unit, notifying the last date of submission as 14.02.2023
between 10:00 AM and 5:00 PM on any working day on or before
14.02.2023. The aforesaid bids were opened on 15.02.2023 in the
meeting of the Sub-Committee constituted for evaluation of the
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-10-


Expression of Interest. Three applicants, namely: (i) Ms. Taranjit
High Court of H.P.
Kaur, SR Asia, UP; (ii) M.R. Sharma, PRAN Foundation, Sanjouli,
H.P.; and (iii) Jignesh Patel, Envision, Surat, Gujarat, submitted their
bids. After evaluating the technical and financial bids, the Sub-
Committee recommended the name of SR Asia for having quoted
the lowest rates as compared to the other participants.
21. Vide letter dated 15.02.2023, the Chairman of the Social
Impact Assessment Unit submitted the case to the Principal
Secretary (Tourism and Civil Aviation) to the Government of
Himachal Pradesh for undertaking the Social Impact Assessment
study in respect of expansion of Kangra Airport, District Kangra.
22. Vide Notification dated 28.02.2023, in exercise of
powers conferred under Rule 3 of the Himachal Pradesh Right to
Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement (Social Impact Assessment and
Consent) Rules, 2015, the Governor of Himachal Pradesh
empowered the Social Impact Assessment Unit to carry out the
Social Impact Assessment for the purpose of land acquisition for
Kangra Airport. The Notification dated 28.02.2023 was published in
two newspapers on 02.03.2023 and 03.03.2023, and was also
uploaded on the official website of the State Government.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-11-


23. Vide communication dated 03.03.2023, the Chairman of
High Court of H.P.
the Social Impact Assessment Unit communicated that the Social
Impact Assessment Unit had decided to award the work of the Social
Impact Assessment study in respect of expansion of Kangra Airport
to SR Asia, by notifying the terms of reference in the said letter, and
in furtherance thereto, SR Asia was assigned the Social Impact
Assessment study.
24. The Social Impact Assessment study was carried out
through SR Asia. The draft Social Impact Assessment report was
submitted by the agency, which was circulated as per the provisions
of the Act. During the process of the Social Impact Assessment,
public hearings were conducted, and objections and comments of
project-affected families were recorded. The Social Impact
Assessment conducting agency contacted 349 families out of 1446
project-affected families, and formal discussions were held in each
Gram Panchayat.
25. The final Social Impact Assessment report was
submitted vide letter dated 03.05.2023. The report was circulated to
the general public through the concerned Gram Panchayats, the
office of the District Collector, Sub-Divisional Magistrate, and
Tehsildar, and was also uploaded on the official website of the
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-12-


Department of Tourism and Civil Aviation. The Social Impact
High Court of H.P.
Assessment study report was also supplied to the Pradhans of the
affected Gram Panchayats of District Kangra vide communication
dated 03.05.2023, with recommendations as contained at pages 234
to 236 of the record:-
“Chapter-10
Recommendations
SIA experts had in-depth consultation with relevant stakeholders,
suggestions and feedback received, discussions and FGD held
with PAFs, public hearing on draft SIA reports collection of all field
data, proposes the following recommendations.
10. The proposed expansion of Kangra Airport will seriously
affect the large population and businesses that have been
established over the years and are generally self-
sustaining. It has been learned from extensive discussions
with all the parties that if the proposed land is acquired, the
cost of the project will be about several thousand crores
and at the same time thousands of families will lose their
family business, source of employment and income and
social security. Will lose by making taunts. During the
discussion, it has also come to be known that thousands of
people working in big and small shops will also lose their
livelihood due to this. As there is already a lack of
opportunities for government jobs, in this situation, how will
the government be able to employ thousands of people,
this question is very worrying, so to deal with this situation,
the affected families have sought alternative places / land
and land acquisition for the project. The following
suggestions have been proposed for: -
III. The airport should be expanded from the present
runway direction of "west to north" towards
Dharamshala/Sarai, this will displace the least
number of families and save a lot of government
money. Local peoples also are in favor of this
option.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-13-


IV. The alternative land is available at the new location
which comprises of non-irrigated and government
land in village Bodkwalu and Lanj in Kangra Tehsil,
in which a new and big airport can be constructed
easily, and at the same time the social displacement
will be very low and economic burden on the
government will be minimum to build the airport. As
shared by project affected people cost of new
airport at new suggested location will be far too low
by many times than the expansion of existing
Kangra Airport.
High Court of H.P.
11. Before any land acquisition process starts, according to the
LARR-2015, rehabilitation and resettlement plan with the
cooperation of the local stakeholders is desirable.
12. The landowners are ready in the eventuality, government
decides the airport at the current and proposed land
provided they are made payment of four times of the
market value/circle rate (as applicable) of the land in rural
areas and two times the market rate of the land in urban
areas as compensation for land acquisition as per schedule
of the Act, 2013, which should be paid "as one project one
cost" formula applicable to all PAFs.
13. Due to the expansion of the project, the problem of water
logging/flood may arise in the villages and near bye areas,
so an integrated water management plan should be made
for the drainage and supply of water, so that the problems
of flooding in the area can be minimized and prevented.
14. Those families which in the past were affected by land
acquisition under any other project or by the Kangra airport
construction, should be avoided displacement or in
unavoidable conditions shall be given special
compensation if they are being affected by the re-
acquisition.
15. Social Impact Management Plan (SIMP) described in this
report detail out the measures to solve the village-wise
problems are mentioned in Appendix-one and Jansunwai
chapter number nine. Although the review of all the
submitted memorandums is presented in the SIMP, the
records of the memorandums received is presented in the
form of Appendix-IV for appropriate actions, person-wise
and pointwise.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-14-


16. The Detailed Project Report, Feasibility Report and
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Plan related to the
expansion of the airport are not available, therefore the
cost and benefit analysis has not been estimated under the
presented Social Impact Management Plan. The cost of the
project is not available hence proper cost-benefit analysis
cannot be derived objectively.
High Court of H.P.
17. This Kangra Airport expansion is in the public interest and
serve public purpose and the construction and operation of
the project will provide short term and long term benefits to
all the villagers and business around it. This analysis is
particularly relevant in relation to new employment
opportunities, the provision of goods and services, and
public investment that will result in long-term benefits to
villagers, thereby helping to mitigate short and long term
negative impacts.
18. Adequate data is not available on whether the potential
benefits from the Gaggal Airport Expansion Project will be
more or less than the cost price, so it is difficult to estimate
when and how much the investment of the scheme will be
profitable, although the scheme is being supported by a lot
of affected families. It has been said to be expensive, the
benefit of which has been said to be difficult for the
government and the public to get soon. If the construction
of the airport is shifted to alternative places, it will surely
prove to be very beneficial for all the parties from the social
and economic point of view, this conclusion has been
expressed by almost all the affected families and other
sections during the public hearing.
SIA experts nominated by SR Asia, after assessing all the social
impact impacts recommends land acquisition as per various
conditions mentioned in the social impact management plan
(SIMP) Annexure-I, Jansunwai Chapter Number-IX (Village and
person wise objections and, and Annexure-Four (objections and
suggestion in the form of memorandum).”

26. Vide Notification dated 19.04.2023, the State of
Himachal Pradesh constituted a Multi-Disciplinary Expert Group
under Section 7(1) of the Act, 2013, to examine the Social Impact
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-15-


Assessment report and submit its appraisal report. The Multi-
High Court of H.P.
Disciplinary Expert Group examined the report of the Social Impact
Assessment and, vide communication dated 05.06.2023,
recommended the acquisition of land for the public purpose.
27. In the opinion of the Technical Expert Member of the
Multi-Disciplinary Expert Group constituted for appraisal of the Social
Impact Assessment of Kangra Airport, the extension of a greenfield
airport at the suggested alternative sites, namely Lunj and Borkwalu,
was found to be not feasible, as these sites were located quite far
from the central location, and in comparison to Brown Field Airport
Project, construction of a Greenfield airport involved huge cost, a
long timeline, and visual requirements for No Objection Clearance
from multiple agencies, which is a time-consuming exercise. The
Committee also considered the location of Dharamshala, close
proximity to high hills, and weather/topographical aspects, and
recommended the project as not only fulfilling public interest
considerations, but also having potential benefits which would
outweigh the social costs and social impacts. Recommendations of
the Expert Group are as under:-
“ 5. RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE EXPERT GROUP
After going through the recommendations of the Social Impact
Assessment Report, and taking into consideration the expert
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-16-


opinions of members, the Expert Group makes the following
High Court of H.P.
observations:-
i) Whether the project serves any public purpose?
The proposed project will boost up tourism in Kangra by ensuring
affordable and better aviation facilities to the tourists who intend
to visit Kangra and surrounding destinations to explore
RELIGIOUS, HERITAGE, ADVENTURE, SPORTS, NATURE,
WILDLIFE AND HEALTH TOURISM. The promotion of Tourism
will increase economic status of project affected families. It will
provide affordable air services to local passengers who need to
use air service in emergency to airlift their relatives to PGI
Chandigarh and Delhi, benefit business persons and farmers to
promote their business and farm products. The project will benefit
students and job aspirants who intend to acquire high education
and appear in competitive exams in metropolitan and major cities
of India. Therefore, apparently the project to expand existing
kangra Airport serves the public purpose.
ii) Whether Potential benefits of the project outweigh the
social costs and adverse social impact?
The expansion of Kangra Airport is likely to displace a large
number of families who are presently living in 14 muhals of
Shahpur and kangra Tehsils in Kangra district and adversely
affect their livelihood support and business. However, the
upcoming of world class aviation infrastructure and 3010-meter-
long run way with increased capacity, would accommodate Turbo
Fan Aircrafts such as Airbus 320/330 etc., due to which the
tourists, local passengers and students would benefit from the
affordable and reasonable airfares. The increase in footfall of
tourists to kangra would promote better employment avenues
and better livelihood support for local people. In view of these
facts, it is quite apparent that the potential benefits of the project
outweigh the social costs and adverse social impact.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-17-


iii) Whether there is other less displacing option available
High Court of H.P.
with effective Relief and Rehabilitation Plan?
Expert Group also concluded that Project affected families’ /
People’s suggestion to acquire lands at Lunj, Borkawalu to
construct a green airfield was not found to be technically feasible,
because both the suggested sites are quite far away from the
central location / the existing Airport and also setting up a Green
airfield Airport with world class aviation infrastructure there would
incur huge costs and likely to take years for various clearances
and non-objection certificates from multiple agencies. And, as far
as proposal to expand the existing Airport from West to north side
towards Dharamshala- Sarah was concerned, that patch of land
being hilly was not found to be feasible and fit to expand the
existing Kangra Airport. Technical Expert and member of the
Expert Group constituted to evaluate the Social Impact
Assessment Report for the project- expansion of Kangra Airport
has shown his reservations on the Construction of a green airfield
either at Lunj and Borkwalu as well as expansion of existing
airport from west side to north side towards Sarah – Dharamshala
and Department of Tourism and Civil Aviation to Himachal
Pradesh government has found the above proposal/ suggestion
of local people about constructing a green airfield at the
suggested sites or expansion of the existing airport from west
side to north side towards Sarah- Dharamsala, because the
proposal to expand the existing airport after construction of a
bridge across Manji -khad was technically approved /cleared by
Airport Authority of India – the sole nodal body to clear/ approve
all types of aviation infrastructures or run- way alignments. And
this point was clarified by Tourism and Civil aviation to HP
Government vide their no. TSM-F(6)-2015-ii-i dated 24.05.2023
(Annexure 2). So, the Expert Group noted that there was no less
displacing option available with effective R&R plan which could
be chosen to complete the said project. Therefore, as per the
technical clearance of the proposal by Airport Authority of India to
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-18-


expand existing Kangra airport after constructing a bridge across
High Court of H.P.
Manjhi Khad after was the only option left.
iv) Whether the extent of Land proposed to be acquired is
bare minimum extent needed for the project- Expansion of
Kangra Airport?
The Expert Group also noted that the quantum of government
and private land proposed for acquisition in 14 identified muhals,
(10 and 4 muhals of Kangra tehsil and Shahpur tehsil,
respectively) was bare minimum extent of land required for the
project and cannot be avoided to expand existing Airport. If
people would give their land for projects work, provided that they
were adequately compensated for their loss. Proper
Resettlement and Rehabilitation of PAFs/ PAPs be ensured as
per the provisions of Right to fair compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition Act, 2013 and HP Social Impact
Assessment Rules 2015. Extent of Land proposed to be acquired
for the expansion of Kangra Airport calculated to be 147-75-47
hectare is bare minimum extent required for the project.
6. CONCLUSION
After making the detailed evaluation and appraisal of Social
Impact Assessment Report of the project, the multi-disciplinary
Expert Group concluded and recommended that the expansion
of Kangra Airport would create world class aviation infrastructure
and boost the Tourism sector and allied activities in a big way,
thereby improving the Kangra economy and economic status of
local people and thus the proposed project served the public
purpose. Secondly, despite adverse social impact and
adverse social costs, the potential benefits outweighed
them.
The Expert Group suggested that the adverse social impact and
social costs arising out of project execution should be mitigated
to the minimum by the measures suggested in Social Impact
Management Plan and Relief and rehabilitation Plan that should
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-19-


adequately address the concerns and apprehensions of the
High Court of H.P.
projected affected families and project affected people for
livelihoods and future. It was therefore recommended that the
Relief and Rehabilitation Plan should contain the provision of
highest compensation package for the project affected families /
project affected people including those families who were
displaced previously due to the undertaking one project or the
other. In addition, Identified vulnerable persons be provided with
the best support and economic assistance that could help them
lead a dignified life after the displacement. Expert group also
comprehensively examined the alternative sites and less
displacing option with effective Relief and rehabilitation plan and
concluded that construction of a green Airport at suggested sites
namely Lunj and Borkwalu was not feasible in the first instance,
due to legal requirement of non-objection certificates and
clearances from multiple agencies, isolated location, long
distance from the present airport, long time line of 10-15 years
and clearance given to the proposed project to expand the
existing airport after the construction of a bridge on Manji
khad by Airport Authority of India -the sole and nodal agency to
give technical approval to all types of Run-way alignments and
Aviation infrastructure. Most importantly the expert group noted
that in case a green airfield was proposed at the suggested sites,
then the existing Airport situated in Gaggal would not be of any
usage and public utility. The suggestion to expand the existing
airport from west to north side towards Sarah- Dharamshala
seemed to be non-feasible due to proximity of hills. Thus, the
Expert group noted that there was no less displacing site with
effective R&R plan was available; hence the only option left
was to go ahead with the proposal to expand the existing
airport after construction of a bridge across Manjhi Khas as
finalized by Airport Authority . Expert Group was also of the
opinion that total 147-75-87 hectare extent of land proposed
to be acquired is the absolute bare minimum extent needed
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-20-


for the project and the expansion of Kangra Airport at the
High Court of H.P.
proposed land would create world class Aviation infrastructure
and boost the Tourism sector and allied activities in a big way
thereby improving the Kangra economy and economic status of
local people. However, the opinion notes and suggestions, of
panchayat - representatives, especially, setting up a satellite-
town in the radius of 5 kilometres near the central point/
existing airport catering to the commercial as well as
residential needs of local people might be considered by the
Himachal Pradesh government .(Annexure-3)
In view of the above facts, finally, the Expert Group has no
hesitation in recommending the project because besides
fulfilling the public interest considerations, its potential
benefits would outweigh the social costs and social
impacts .”

28. Thereafter, a preliminary notification under Section
11(1) of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 was issued
by the Government of Himachal Pradesh on 07.07.2023, inviting
objections from any interested or aggrieved person within 60 days
from the date of publication. For the purpose of the acquisition
proceedings, the Divisional Commissioner, Kangra was appointed
as Commissioner for Rehabilitation and Resettlement under Section
43, the Additional District Magistrate, Kangra at Dharamshala under
Section 3(a) and 43, and the Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil), Kangra
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-21-


was appointed as Land Acquisition Collector under Section 3(g) of
High Court of H.P.
the Act.
29. Vide communication dated 26.09.2023, the Government
of Himachal Pradesh informed that land acquisition had reached an
advanced stage, 60% of land acquisition had been completed, and
the State Government was in a position to transfer the same to the
Airports Authority of India by November 2023.
30. Vide communication dated 20.10.2023, the draft
Techno-Economic Feasibility Report prepared by WAPCOS Ltd. was
forwarded to the Airports Authority of India, depicting the estimated
cost of the project at approximately Rs. 10,995 crores excluding land
acquisition cost, out of which the major cost component was for earth
cutting and filling, soil stabilization, and bridge construction to be
borne by the State Government.
31. The project cost was assessed as too high by the AAI
management, and therefore it was suggested to the State
Government to carry out a financial viability study in addition to a
technical study, and also to take a second opinion on technical
viability by taking into consideration high flooding, landsliding, etc.,
and also the falling of the area in Seismic Zone V, vide
communication dated 09.11.2023.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-22-


32. In response, vide communication dated 06.12.2023, it
High Court of H.P.
was communicated by the respondent State that Kangra has been
declared as the tourism capital of Himachal Pradesh, the State
Government is committed to carry out this expansion project, and it
is ready to provide land free of cost and free from all encumbrances
for this project, with a request for marking and erection of 126 more
boundary pillars in the field as per the Master Plan, and verification
and certification by the AAI team. Vide communication dated
02.02.2024, it was also communicated that the Government is ready
to bear the cost of cutting and filling apart from providing land free of
cost and free from encumbrances.
33. Government of Himachal Pradesh got the TEFR report
reviewed from M/s WAPCOS Ltd., wherein the project cost has been
worked out to Rs. 4064.27 crores, and the modified TEFR report was
submitted to AAI vide communication dated 15.03.2024. Certain
comments and observations on the TEFR report were
communicated by AAI vide letter dated 20.05.2024 to the State
Government. The TEFR report is a prerequisite for environmental
clearances.
34. In the meanwhile, after filing of present writ petition on
12.10.2023, following order was passed on 06.12.2023:-
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-23-


“Learned Deputy Solicitor General of India has placed
High Court of H.P.
before this Court as D.O. letter dated 09.11.2023. The said letter
is taken on record. It states as under:-
“Reference is invited to your D.O. letter No. TSM-F(6)-
1/2015-IV dated 26/09/2023 and TSM-F(6)-1/2015-III
th
dated 20 Oct. 2023 forwarding Draft Techno-Economic
Feasibility Report on the subject cited above.
2. In this connection it is intimated that on the
request of State Government of Himachal Pradesh
(GoHP) vide letter dated 07.10.2021 AAI has prepared
development plan of Kangra Airport in two Phases-
Phase-I for operation of ATR-72/Q-400 type of aircraft
without load penalty for VFR operations and Phase-II for
operation of A-320 type of aircraft without load penalty
for IFR operations.
3. It is seen from the Techno-Economic Feasibility
Report of Kangra Airport prepared by WAPCOS and
forwarded vide letter dated 20.10.2023 by GoHP that
estimated cost of the project is approx. Rs. 10,995
Crores, excluding land acquisition cost. Out of it, cost of
earth cutting & filling, soil stabilization and bridge, almost
Rs.10,242 Crores, is to be borne by the State
Government. Therefore, it is felt that State Government
may carry out financial viability, in addition to technical
viability. As far as technical viability is concerned, we
would like to recommend State Government to take
second opinion because proposed construction is in the
area which in the recent past has witnessed heavy
flooding, land sliding etc. and also comes in Seismic
Zone V. IIT, Roorkee (Department of Water Resources
Development and Management) can be one of the
Agency which may be consulted for second opinion. In
case it is found by State Government project to be
technically and financially viable then AAI will take
approval of the Competent Authority for extending the
runway with other facilities.”
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-24-


Learned Advocate General states that reply has been filed
High Court of H.P.
by the State Government in the matter, but the same has not been
put up.
Registry to put up the reply filed by the State Government.
List on 07.12.2023.”

35. On 07.12.2023, recording the assurance extended by
learned Advocate General, following order was passed:-
“Due to paucity of time, the matter could not be taken up
today.
Learned Advocate General assures that till the next date of
hearing, the respondents will not dispossess anybody from the
land, which is forming part of notification issued under Section
11(1) of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, notified for
expansion of Gaggal (Kangra) Airport, and that no structure
located within the land, which is subject matter of the said
notification, will be demolished. The said undertaking of the State
is placed on record.
List on 26.12.2023.”

36. Thereafter, on 26.12.2023 the Court passed the
injunction order as under:-
“Heard in part.
Learned Advocate General shall produce Newspaper
advertisement said to have been published prior to the public
hearing on the draft Social Impact Assessment Report along with
other connected record.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-25-


Mr. Balram Sharma, learned Deputy Solicitor General of
High Court of H.P.
India shall obtain instructions from 5th respondent or file a reply in
the Writ Petition by the next date of hearing.
Learned counsel for the petitioner shall prepare a table of
the alleged violations of the provisions of law, pleadings in the
petition in that regard, and reply to those allegations in the reply
filed by the respondents.
List on 02.01.2024.
Learned Advocate General assures that the undertaking
given on the previous date of hearing will continue till the next date
of hearing.”

37. On 26.12.2023 undertaking given by the learned
Advocate General on previous date was assured to be continued till
next date of hearing. It was continued on 02.01.2024, 04.01.2024,
and on 09.01.2024, the following order was passed:-
“It is stated by Mr. Neeraj Gupta, learned Senior Counsel,
appearing for respondents No.3 and 4 that the matter is being re-
examined in light of letter dated 9.11.2023 addressed by the
Airport Authority of India (5th respondent) to the 1st respondent,
particularly with regard to financial viability as well as technical
viability. He also placed before us Minutes of Meeting held on
02.12.2023 under the Chairpersonship of the Director Tourism
recording the observation that Techno Economic Feasibility
Report submitted by WAPCOS is a shoddy work and requires to
be rejected.
2. Having regard to the fact that the matter is under re-
consideration by the State Government, at this stage, it would not
be proper to permit the respondents to proceed with the taking of
possession of lands, which are notified for acquisition or demolish
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-26-


the structure thereon or to proceed with the R&R process till the
High Court of H.P.
next date of hearing.
3. Mr. Neeraj Gupta, learned Senior Counsel, states on
instructions that some steps in the R&R process have
commenced, which would not affect the rights of the persons, who
are likely to be affected by the acquisition.
4. Be that as it may, since there is a possibility that the State
Government may re-visit its own decision to proceed with the
expansion of the Gaggal Airport after examining all aspects of the
matter and in such an event, there is every possibility of the time
and expenses incurred in the R&R process commenced, would go
waste, till the next date of hearing, status quo in all respects with
regard to the R&R process as well as taking of possession of the
lands notified for acquisition or demolition of structure located in
the lands notified for acquisition, shall be maintained.
List on 29.02.2024.”

38. Order dated 09.01.2024 was assailed by State before
the Apex Court by filing SLP(C ) No. 1676 of 2024 wherein on
22.01.2024 operation of order, passed by the Division Bench of this
High Court on 09.01.2024, was stayed.
39. Civil Appeal No. 3909 of 2024 was registered, arising out
of SLP(C ) No. 1676 of 2024 and it was disposed of by the Apex
Court on 7th March, 2024 in the following terms:-
“……..
7. During the course of the hearing Mr. Kapil Sibal,
senior counsel appearing on behalf of the State of Himachal
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-27-


Pradesh has assured the Court that the statement which was
High Court of H.P.
made by the Advocate General before the High Court shall
continue to remain in operation in the meantime, unless the Court
is moved for appropriate modification in view of any change in
circumstances. We take the assurance on the record.
8. In that view of the matter, we vacate the impugned
order dated 9 January, 2024. The High Court would be at liberty
to proceed ahead with the disposal of the writ petition on merits.
In the event that there is any change in circumstances warranting
an alteration of the statement by the Advocate General for the
State of Himachal Pradesh, we grant liberty to the State to move
the High Court in that regard…….”

40. In aforesaid background, process of acquisition of land
continued during pendency of present petition.
Status of Land Acquisition/Response of the State
41. During pendency of the petition, the status of land
acquisition for extension of Gaggal Airport was produced on behalf
of the respondent State, with the submission that after approval of
the appraisal report submitted by the Multi-Disciplinary Expert Group
by the Cabinet, notification under Section 11(1) of the Act was issued
on 07.07.2023, which was published in the Gazette and in two daily
newspapers as required under law.
42. It has been further communicated that after issuing
notification dated 07.07.2023, objections under Section 15 of the
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-28-


Acquisition Act were heard from August 2023 to February 2024, and
High Court of H.P.
after deciding the objections, report was submitted by the Land
Acquisition Collector-cum-Collector, Kangra to the Government on
15.03.2024.
43. It was further communicated that draft R&R plan was
prepared by the Administrator under Section 16 of the Act, and notice
to the general public for hearing was given on 20.12.2023. General
public hearing was conducted from 05.02.2024 to 07.02.2024. Draft
R&R scheme was reviewed by the Collector through the R&R
Committee on 24.02.2024 under Section 17(1) of the Acquisition Act,
and approval of the Government was conveyed on 15.03.2024. The
R&R scheme was made available in the local language to the
Collector, SDM Office, Tehsil, concerned Panchayats, and affected
area vide letter dated 16.03.2024, and it was published on the
Collector's website on 22.03.2024.
44. Declaration and notification under Section 19 of the Act
was issued by the Government on 16.08.2024, which was published
in the Gazette on 17.08.2024, and in newspapers on 21.08.2024.
45. Notices under Section 21 of the Acquisition Act were
issued on 08.09.2024, which were published on the Collector's
website and sent to the concerned Gram Panchayats, and the date
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-29-


for hearing of objections/claims was fixed on 18.10.2024 in the office
High Court of H.P.
of the Land Acquisition Collector, Gaggal Airport. Total 6429 notices
were served under Section 21 of the Act, 158 notices stand unserved
due to insufficient addresses, and a total of 44 objections were
received, out of which 13 pertained to land and 31 pertained to R&R.
46. The Government has approved the R&R plan worth
Rs.3349 crores. Thereafter, awards were issued under Section 23 of
the Acquisition Act. As on 15.10.2024, an amount of more than
Rs.460,35,82,920.33 had been disbursed in pursuance to
announced R&R awards, whereas balance awards to be disbursed
or announced for worth Rs.132,50,41,003/- was and is under
process.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF PETITIONER
47. Assailing the impugned acquisition proceedings, it has
been contended on behalf of the petitioner that the Social Impact
Assessment Authority failed to take an appropriate decision on the
questions and substantive objections raised by the landowners
during the survey and public hearing regarding the feasibility of the
project and alternative sites, and mechanically recommended
acquisition without conducting a proper survey.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-30-


48. It has been further contended that out of 1446 affected
High Court of H.P.
families across the fourteen villages, the SIA team interviewed only
399 families (34.04%), on the basis of which the social, cultural, and
economic status was assessed within a week without even having a
Detailed Project Report (DPR) in hand. It has been contended that
incorrect information was supplied in Table 48 that 52.63% of the
people gave consent, whereas 100% of the land owners are
unwilling to part with their fertile agricultural land.
49. It has been vehemently contended that the proposed
acquisition violates Section 10(1) of the Right to Fair Compensation
and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Act, 2013, which mandates that no irrigated multi-
cropped land shall be acquired under the Act. Referring to Tables 44
and 45 of the SIA report, it is pointed out that 69.67% of the land is
fertile, 32.58% is highly fertile, and 63.91% is used for food grains,
24.56% for oilseeds, and 68.17% for commercial crops, with double
cropping (wheat/mustard in Rabi, paddy/maize in Kharif, and
vegetables) across 100% of the villages. It has been contended that
under Section 10(2), such land can only be acquired under
exceptional circumstances as a demonstrable last resort, but the SIA
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-31-


team failed to report or demonstrate that the acquisition was an
High Court of H.P.
unavoidable last resort.
50. Though, it has not been specifically pleaded, however,
it has been contented by learned counsel for the petitioner that there
is violation of mandatory provisions of Rule 3(1) of the Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement (Social Impact
Assessment and Consent) Rules, 2014, Section 4(2) of LARR Act,
2013, Section 4(4)(a), 4(4)(e), 4(4)(f), Section 5, 7, 8 & 15(2) of
LARR Act.
51. It has been submitted on behalf of the petitioner-
Committee that there is violation of mandatory clearance, related to
Techno-Economic Feasibility Report, Environment Clearance
Report, Forest Clearance, Clearance from Bureau of Civil Aviation,
DG, Civil Aviation, Central Water and Power Research Station as
required before commencing the work of expansion of the airport,
because as on date there is neither Technical Economic Feasibility
Report, nor Environmental Impact Assessment Report or
Environmental clearance has been obtained by the respondents.
Further, that till date, site has not been declared suitable for runway
expansion after survey feasibility study and clearance from BCAS
and DGCA.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-32-


52. It has been contended that in SIA report, it has been
High Court of H.P.
incorrectly recorded that the expansion of Kangra Airport will serve
the supreme interest of the State and meet the defense requirements
of the Indian Air Force, whereas vide communication dated
13.04.2018 (Annexure P-4) obtained under the Right to Information
Act, Air Headquarters (IAF) specifically it has been clarified that
presently the IAF has no plans to expand Kangra Airport.
53. It has also been contended that a portion of the land
proposed for airport expansion was already acquired by the Central
Government for construction of a four-lane highway through the
National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) vide notification dated
21.09.2021 (Annexure P-5), and Section 99 of the Act of 2013
specifically prohibits any change of purpose from that for which the
land was originally sought to be acquired.
54. The petitioner has further raised the grievance that
functional educational institutions in eight villages, Primary Schools,
Colleges, ITIs, Anganwadis, Health sub-centres, and 132 KV
transmission lines (with over 50 towers) will be uprooted, resulting in
the destruction of one public purpose for another.
55. It has been highlighted that the bridge constructed over
Manjhi Khad on NH-154 at a public cost of over Rs.9,23,26,012/- and
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-33-


completed on 25.10.2020 (Annexure P-6) will be ruined and
High Court of H.P.
dismantled to make way for the airstrip, causing colossal wastage of
public funds.
56. It has been urged that the Panchayats had suggested
three viable alternative sites, namely: (i) expansion towards the
north-west (Dharamshala/Sarah); (ii) non-irrigated, less fertile land
at Bodkwalu; and (iii) land in the Lanj area, which would displace far
fewer families, involve barren land, and save substantial public
money, but the SIA team and Expert Group arbitrarily dismissed
them without conducting any technical survey.
57. It has been submitted that Kangra district falls in Seismic
Zone V (98.6% seismic/sinking zone) and is an eco-sensitive area
where massive construction and tree felling without prior
environmental and forest clearances will trigger catastrophic
ecological damage.
58. It has been further contended that the Multi-Disciplinary
Expert Group failed to independently examine the severe negative
impacts documented in the SIA report and merely rubber-stamped
the agency's findings.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-34-


59. It has been further contended that the Director General
High Court of H.P.
of Civil Aviation, which is the final authority for airport site approval,
has not granted any permission, as confirmed vide RTI
communication dated 25.04.2023 (Annexure P-9).
60. It has been further urged that the impugned notification
dated 07.07.2023 is an outcome of a colorable exercise of power
and arbitrary exercise of administrative discretion. It has been
contended that the power of eminent domain is being wielded not for
a bona fide public purpose or for the benefit of the public at large,
but with the sole intent of conferring undue advantage upon an elite
and affluent class of persons under the guise of tourism, thereby
violating the settled principles governing judicial review of
administrative discretion.
61. It has been specifically contended that proceeding with
the acquisition without obtaining mandatory environmental and
forest clearances, and in the absence of a genuine, thorough
assessment of the ecological fragility of the terrain, constitutes a
flagrant infraction of the constitutional right to property guaranteed
under Article 300-A of the Constitution of India, as well as the basic
human rights of the affected populace, rendering the impugned
reports and notification wholly arbitrary and illegal.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-35-


62. Learned counsel for the petitioner has further laid stress
High Court of H.P.
upon the plight of historically and economically vulnerable segments
residing within the acquisition zone, pointing out that the proposed
expansion directly displaces more than 15 families of Pong Dam
oustees who have remained unrehabilitated even after a lapse of
more than 47 years, as well as over 150 families who were uprooted
during the 1947 Partition and have been living hand-to-mouth. It has
been contended that the State has completely abdicated its duty to
scrutinize its actions with heightened care, vigilance, and
circumspection when dealing with marginalized citizens who are now
faced with the prospect of being rendered homeless, landless, and
destitute for a second time.
63. It has also been urged that the respondents acted in
breach of the statutory mandate requiring the land proposed for
acquisition to be the bare minimum necessary for the project. In this
regard, it is contended that the SIA Authority failed to assess the
catastrophic economic displacement of an established commercial
hub comprising 5 Banks, 2 Petrol Pumps, and major commercial
markets that provide direct employment and livelihood to upwards of
20,000 persons, which could have been entirely averted had the
respondents evaluated the vacant and barren alternative sites.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-36-


64. To substantiate the submission that where a statute
High Court of H.P.
provides for a thing to be done in a particular manner, it has to be
done in that manner and in no other manner, learned Senior Counsel
for the petitioner has placed reliance on pronouncements of the Apex
Court in Narindrajit Singh and Ranjit Singh & Ors. vs. State of
U.P. & Ors. , (1973) 1 SCC 157 (paragraphs 1 to 3); Chandra
Kishore Jha vs. Mahavir Prasad & Ors. , (1999) 8 SCC 266
(paragraph 17); Competent Authority vs. Barangore Jute
Factory , (2005) 13 SCC 477 (paragraph 5); and Opto Circuit India
Ltd. vs. Axis Bank & Ors. , (2021) 6 SCC 707 (paragraph 14).
65. It has been submitted by the learned Senior Counsel for
the petitioner that for violation of mandatory statutory provisions, the
action of the State deserves to be quashed and the petition deserves
to be allowed. In this regard reliance has been placed on judgments
passed by the Apex Court in Competent Authority v. Barangore
Jute Factory & Ors. , (2005) 13 SCC 477 (paragraph 5 & 14);
Women's Education Trust vs. State of Haryana & Ors., AIR 2013
SC 2488 (paragraphs 6, 7, 13, 15, and 20); Gojer Brothers Pvt. Ltd.
& Anr. vs. State of West Bengal & Ors. , (2013) 16 SCC 660
(paragraphs 13 to 18, 20, and 22); Ravindra Singh and Others vs.
State of Haryana and Others , (2020) 17 SCC 819 (paragraph 2 to
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-37-


5); Opto Circuit India Ltd. v. Axis Bank and Others, (2021) 6 SCC
High Court of H.P.
707 (paragraph 14); and Kolkata Municipal Corporation and
another v. Bimal Kumar Shah and others , AIR 2024 SC 2819
(paragraphs 29, 30, and 34).
66. It has been submitted that it is case of violation of
provisions of public hearing, contained in Section 15 of the LARR
Act, and therefore, the proceedings are liable to be quashed and set-
aside. To substantiate this plea, counsel for the petitioner has placed
reliance on pronouncements of Apex Court in various cases, i.e.,
case titled Raghbir Singh Sehrawat v. State of Haryana and
Others , reported in (2012) 1 SCC 792 , case titled Kamal Trading
Pvt. Ltd. vs. State of West Bengal & Ors. , reported in (2012) 2
SCC 25 , case titled Surinder Singh Brar and Others vs. Union of
India and Others , reported in (2013) 1 SCC 403 , case titled Gojer
Brothers Private Limited & Anr. v. State of West Bengal & Ors ,
reported in (2013) 16 SCC 660 , (Paragraphs 17, 20, 21 and 26),
case titled Woman’s Education Trust and Anr. vs. State of
Haryana and Ors. , reported in AIR 2013 SC 2488 , (Paragraphs 6,
7 and 15).’
67. Placing reliance on Woman’s Education Trust and
Anr. vs. State of Haryana and Ors , (2013) 8 SCC 99 (paragraph
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-38-


5), it has been contended that the violation of the statutory mandate
High Court of H.P.
of Section 15(2) of the Land Acquisition Act is fatal to the acquisition
proceedings, and thus, the petition deserves to be allowed,
68. It has been urged that in the absence of mandatory
clearances and where there is a clear-cut violation of fundamental
and constitutional rights, the petitioner is entitled to maintain the writ
petition and the acquisition deserves to be quashed. In support of
this contention, learned counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance
on judgments of the Apex Court in Sachidananda Pandey and
another v. State of West Bengal & Ors. , reported in (1987) 2 SCC
295 ; Karnataka Industrial Areas Development Board v. C.
Kenchappa , (2006) 6 SCC 371 (paragraphs 3, 4, 36 to 41, 66, 100,
and 101); Hanuman Laxman Aroskar vs. Union of India , (2019)
15 SCC 401 (paragraphs 5, 9, 10, 11, 12, 15, 16.1, 16.2, 21.5, 31,
32, 34, 40, 42, 44, 63.1, 64, 83 to 106, and 159 to 165 ); Ravindra
Singh and Others vs. State of Haryana and Others , (2020) 17
SCC 819 (paragraphs 3 and 4); and Project Director, Project
Implementation Unit vs. P.V. Krishnamoorthy & Ors. , (2021) 3
SCC 572 (paragraphs 74 and 103). Reliance has also been placed
on judgment dated 16.05.2024 passed by High Court of Bombay in
Vanashakti v. Union of India and others , CWP (C) No. 1394 of
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-39-


2023 , decided on 16.05.2025. Judgment passed by this High Court
High Court of H.P.
in Dhani Ram vs. Sunder Ram , 2016 (4) Him.L.R. 2433
(paragraph 12) has also been referred.
69. It has been substantially pleaded that in the absence of
a genuine public purpose, land cannot be acquired and there is no
public purpose in the present case, and in this regard reliance has
been placed on Sri-La-Sri Subramania Desika Gnanasambanda
Pandarasannadhi v. State of Madras and Another , AIR 1965 SC
1578 (paragraph 17).
70. It has been contended on behalf of petitioner that before
commencing the project, prior environmental clearance is
mandatory, as provided in EIA Notification 2006, which has not been
obtained so far, and until and unless there is environmental
clearance in favour of respondents, these proceedings are liable to
be quashed and set-aside.
71. To substantiate aforesaid plea, reliance has been placed
on the judgment dated 29.07.2026 of the Constitutional Bench of the
Apex Court in Writ Petition (C) No. 1394 of 2023 , titled
Vanashakti vs. Union of India . In this regard, reliance has also
been placed on judgment dated 28.07.2025 of the Apex Court in
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-40-


SLP(C) No. 19426/2025, titled M/s Pristine Hotels and Resorts
High Court of H.P.
Pvt. Ltd. vs. State of Himachal Pradesh and Anr .
STAND OF RESPONDENTS NO.1 TO 4
72. On first date, i.e. 17.10.2023, service on behalf of
respondents No.1 to 4 was waived by learned Additional Advocate
General in presence of learned Advocate General. However, on
04.01.2024, Mr. Neeraj Gupta, Senior Advocate, has also appeared
on behalf of these respondents-State, but since 09.01.2024, Mr.
Neeraj Gupta, had appeared only for respondents No.3 & 4, but later
on he did not appear for anyone. Common and joint reply has been
filed on behalf of respondents No.1 to 4.
73. It has been canvassed on behalf of respondents No. 1
to 4 that there has been a substantial increase in passenger flow at
Kangra Airport over the years. In the year 2009, 10,149 passengers
availed air services from Kangra Airport, which increased to 1,76,015
passengers in 2022, and during the year 2023, up to the filing of the
reply in September 2023, 1,36,353 passengers had availed the
service. There were 428 total scheduled flights from Kangra Airport
in 2009, which increased to 3,729 in 2022, and stood at 2,452 in
2023 up to September 2023. Three airline operators, Alliance Air,
SpiceJet, and IndiGo are operating from this airport, besides one
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-41-


heli-taxi service operator, namely M/s Pawan Hans Limited.
High Court of H.P.
However, due to load penalties and the shorter runway length, bigger
charters cannot land or take off from Kangra Airport, which results in
higher airfares, on account of which most local residents as well as
students cannot avail of the air facility.
74. It has been submitted that Himachal Pradesh is a State
with vast tourism potential for attracting tourists, and Kangra district
has emerged as a hub of many tourist activities during the recent
past. The famous Shaktipeeths in Kangra and adjoining districts—
such as Brijeshwari temple, Chamunda Devi temple, Jwalamukhi
temple, Bagalamukhi temple, Masroor Rock-Cut temple, and
Chintpurni Mata temple—have made this region one of the most
sought-after destinations. The State Government also intends to
establish a software industry and IT Park in Dharamshala and
Palampur in District Kangra.
75. It has been further averred that on account of favourable
climatic conditions and the majestic view of the snow-clad
Dhauladhar ranges, Dharamshala has emerged as the most
preferred venue for national and international conventions, such as
the G-20, the Tourism Ministers' Conference, and the Chief
Secretaries' Conference in recent years. Tourist inflow in District
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-42-


Kangra has increased considerably over the years: in the year 2008,
High Court of H.P.
a total of 12,45,974 tourists (70,819 foreign and 12,75,155 domestic)
visited District Kangra, which increased to 28,23,289 (1,38,341
foreign and 26,84,948 Indian) in the year 2017, and during the year
2022, 4,10,843 tourists (6,538 foreign and 4,04,305 Indian) visited
Kangra. Hence, it has been submitted that the expansion of the
Kangra Airport is the need of the hour.
76. It has been further submitted that the tourism sector in
Himachal Pradesh not only creates job opportunities for youth, but
also plays a pivotal role in the State Gross Domestic Product (GDP),
contributing approximately 7% of the total GDP. The tourism sector
has the potential to rejuvenate and mobilize the financial resources
of the State, which is a major priority of the State Government.
77. It has been highlighted that the Kangra valley is famous
for the scenic beauty of the Dhauladhar ranges and its landscapes,
and by virtue of being the abode of His Holiness the Dalai Lama, the
region commands an important presence on the world map. The
valley is visited by a large number of tourists, including an
appreciable number from foreign countries every year, on account of
its climatic conditions, tranquil atmosphere, and historic and religious
significance. Dharamshala also possesses the world's highest
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-43-


international cricket ground where national and international
High Court of H.P.
matches are played, while Bir-Billing is a world-famous paragliding
destination where World Paragliding Championships are organized,
which are contributing significantly to the region's prominence on the
world tourism map. The tourist industry, which is considered of
utmost importance to boost the economy of the State and uplift the
social status of the people of the area, cannot flourish until the means
of communication are properly developed and places of tourist
interest are linked with reliable transport infrastructure.
78. It has been further submitted that Presently, limited
flights of civil aviation companies like IndiGo, Air India, and SpiceJet
operate on the Delhi–Kangra and Kangra–Chandigarh routes,
ferrying only a limited number of tourists because big aircraft cannot
land at Kangra Airport due to the small runway (1372 meters) and
associated load penalties. Therefore, the expansion of Kangra
Airport is a vital project capable of bringing about a paradigm shift in
improving the economic status of the people through the tourism
sector.
79. It has been submitted that in the aforesaid background,
a Committee constituted by the Central Government through the
Ministry of Civil Aviation to carry out a study to earmark additional
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-44-


safety measures for airports in the country identified nine airports
High Court of H.P.
requiring additional safety measures, and Kangra Airport was
included in the said list. In furtherance thereto, the Airports Authority
of India (AAI), vide communication dated 02.03.2022 (Annexure R-
1), requested the Deputy Commissioner, Kangra (respondent No. 3),
to expand Gaggal Airport so that additional safety measures can be
deployed to make air operations safer, recommending the provision
of a Runway End Safety Area (RESA) and expanding the runway to
a length of 3010 meters, requesting that land adjoining the airport
boundary near Runway End 33 up to Manjhi Khad be handed over
to AAI on priority.
80. It has been submitted that the process for acquisition of
land for development of the airport as proposed by AAI was
accordingly initiated by assigning the work of Social Impact
Assessment to the Social Impact Assessment Unit already notified
in the State of Himachal Pradesh under the Himachal Pradesh Right
to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement (Social Impact Assessment and
Consent) Rules, 2015, framed under the Land Acquisition Act, 2013
vide Notification dated 27.11.2015, because the development work
is to be undertaken by AAI subject to the availability of land to be
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-45-


provided by the State Government free of cost and free of all
High Court of H.P.
encumbrances, including road diversions, shifting of transmission
lines, river training, and removal of obstacles.
81. It has been further submitted that expansion of Gaggal
Airport is beneficial not only to tourists and travellers, but also to the
public at large, as enhanced connectivity will result in a proportionate
increase in tourism activities, generating opportunities for self-
employment across various sectors including taxis, hotels,
restaurants, and homestays. Therefore, expansion of the airport
would not only serve the purpose of deploying additional safety
measures to enable bigger aircraft to land and take off, but would
also improve the livelihood of the people of Himachal Pradesh,
particularly in District Kangra and adjoining districts.
82. It has been submitted that the Airports Authority of India,
vide communication dated 07.10.2021 (Annexure R-2),
recommended the expansion of Kangra Airport to a total runway
length of 3010 meters, which shall be suitable for the operation of
ATR-72/Q-400 and A-320 types of aircraft with an Instrument
Landing System (ILS) approach on the Runway 33 side. AAI
submitted the Master Plan of the project after conducting an
Obstacle Limitation Surface (OLS) survey and consulting various
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-46-


airline operators, requesting the State Government to assess
High Court of H.P.
techno-economic feasibility and revert with a feasible way forward.
83. It has been further submitted on behalf of the respondent
State that, as per the survey and study carried out by the Airports
Authority of India (Annexure R-III), the expansion of the two other
existing airports in Himachal Pradesh, namely Shimla and Kullu
(Bhuntar), is not feasible or viable on account of constraints such as
non-feasibility of instrument approach procedures, high obstacles,
environmental concerns arising from river diversion, and prohibitive
costs. Therefore, Kangra Airport is the only airport in the State of
Himachal Pradesh that is technically feasible for expansion, capable
of being developed into a high-end tourist destination for domestic
and international travellers, and resulting in significant improvement
in the transport sector of the State.
84. It has been stated that in the event the expansion of the
airport is accomplished, significant strategic advantages shall accrue
because of the expanded runway and the ability of bigger airplanes
to land. The airstrip of Kangra Airport is frequently used by the Indian
Air Force for mock drills and operational exercises, as evidenced by
official communications placed on record (Annexure R-IV).
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-47-


85. Regarding alternative locations for the airport, it has
High Court of H.P.
been submitted that the Technical Expert Member of the Multi-
Disciplinary Expert Group constituted for appraisal of the SIA report
examined the feasibility and opined (at pages 15–16 of the appraisal
report) that establishing a greenfield airport at the suggested sites,
namely Lanj and Bodkwalu—was not feasible in the first instance, as
those sites are situated far from the central location, and the
construction of a greenfield airport would involve enormous financial
expenditure, prolonged timelines, and statutory clearances from
multiple agencies. It has been further clarified by Technical Expert
that expansion of the existing airport from the west towards the north
(towards Sarah-Dharamshala) is not feasible due to steep valleys
and close proximity to high hills. The Technical Expert concluded
that expansion of the existing airport after construction of a bridge
across Manjhi Khad was the only viable option available, and was
far more feasible than developing a greenfield airport.
86. It has been further submitted that the technical feasibility
for expansion has been established by AAI, which possesses
specialized technical expertise in the field and the respondent-State
has taken follow up action as desired and required.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-48-


87. It has been submitted that in accordance with the Master
High Court of H.P.
Plan and technical feasibility report received from AAI (Annexure R-
2), the State Government initiated the requisite course of action. The
task of conducting a techno-economic feasibility study and
channelization of Manjhi Khad was entrusted to specialized
Government of India undertakings, namely WAPCOS Ltd. and the
Central Water and Power Research Station (CWPRS), Pune.
88. It has been submitted that the Airports Authority of India,
while preparing the Master Plan, requisitioned the land required for
the expansion of Kangra Airport, whereupon the procedure for land
acquisition under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency
in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 was
initiated. In compliance with the statutory provisions, the notification
under Section 4 regarding the Social Impact Assessment was issued
by the Governor of Himachal Pradesh on 28.02.2023, published in
the Gazette on 01.03.2023, and duly published in two daily
newspapers on 02.03.2023 and 03.03.2023 (Annexure R-VI), as well
as uploaded on the State Government website.
89. Learned Advocate General has submitted that the SIA
conducting agency consulted project-affected families in each
village. Out of 1446 total project-affected families, 349 participated
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-49-


in the process. Focused group discussions were conducted in each
High Court of H.P.
Gram Panchayat between 27.02.2023 and 10.03.2023, and people's
participation regarding agreement and disagreement for providing
land was duly recorded in the SIA report dated 03.05.2023. The
recommendations in Chapter 10 of the SIA report reflect the voice of
the project-affected families, and the agency covered all aspects
including the public interest involved in the airport expansion. The
report was thereafter placed before the Multi-Disciplinary Expert
Group, which vide letter dated 05.06.2023 (Annexure R-V) strongly
recommended the project, recording that it had no hesitation in
recommending the acquisition because, besides fulfilling public
interest considerations, its potential benefits would outweigh the
social costs and social impacts.
90. It has been stated that in terms of Section 7 of the Act,
the Multi-Disciplinary Expert Group was constituted by the State
Government vide Notification dated 19.04.2023 (Annexure R-VII),
comprising of Deputy Commissioner (Relief & Rehabilitation); Joint
Secretary (Revenue); Professor, Central University of Himachal
Pradesh (Social Scientist); Associate Professor of Social Welfare,
Central University of Himachal Pradesh (Social Scientist); Ex-
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-50-


General Manager (Architecture) (Technical Expert); Pradhan, Gram
High Court of H.P.
Panchayat, Gaggal; and Pradhan, Gram Panchayat, Rachhyalu.
91. It has been further submitted that the Government of
Himachal Pradesh has also examined the recommendations of the
Social Impact Assessment (SIA) and the Expert Group, and found
that the public purpose outweighs the social impact, and accordingly
decided to acquire the land in view of the facts and circumstances
mentioned hereinabove.
92. It has been submitted that after undertaking aforesaid
exercise, the preliminary notification under Section 11 of the Act was
issued by the Government of Himachal Pradesh (Annexure P-10) in
consonance with relevant provisions of the Act and Rules as
applicable. The Divisional Commissioner, Kangra at Dharamshala
was appointed as Commissioner under the Act, the Additional
District Magistrate, Kangra at Dharamshala as Administrator under
Sections 3(a) and 43, and the Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil), Kangra
was appointed as Collector under Section 3(g) of the Act in view of
the proposed land acquisition for expansion of Kangra Airport in both
Shahpur and Kangra Sub-Divisions of District Kangra. Therefore,
affected persons have filed objections before respondent No.4, most
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-51-


of which have been adjudicated in consonance with provisions of the
High Court of H.P.
Act, 2013, including Section 15 thereof.
93. The Multi-Disciplinary Expert Group examined the SIA
report and, vide communication dated 05.06.2023 (Annexure R-5),
recommended the acquisition of land for the public purpose.
94. It has been further submitted that consequent to the
preliminary notification dated 07.07.2023, a total of 571 objections
were received before the Land Acquisition Collector, which were
categorized as under: -
Sr.
No.
Objections Related to Total
Number
1. Social Impact Assessment (S.I.A.) 82
2. Rehabilitation & Resettlement (R&R) 82
3. Rehabilitation & Resettlement and
Compensation
104
4. Compensation 67
5. Mutation 64
6. Correction of Revenue Entries 25
7. Missing Khasra Numbers and Left-Out
Land
141
8. Others 6
Total 571

::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-52-


95. It has been submitted that taking into consideration the
High Court of H.P.
total number of land parcels likely to be affected by the acquisition,
the number of objections challenging the acquisition itself represents
a microscopic minority (only 18 objections pertained to shifting the
airport site), while the vast majority pertained to compensation, R&R,
and revenue corrections, which does not reflect the general
sentiment of the public.
96. On behalf of respondents No.1 to 4, it has been further
submitted that the petitioner has no cause of action, as all
procedures prescribed under the Act and Rules are being strictly
adhered to. The writ petition is premature and not maintainable,
inasmuch as the contentions raised by the petitioner are being duly
considered by the Land Acquisition Collector during the hearing of
objections under Section 15 of the Act and during the preparation of
the Rehabilitation and Resettlement Scheme.
97. It has been contended on behalf of the respondent State
that there has been no arbitrary or colourable exercise of power.
There is no violation of the provisions of the 2013 Act in issuing the
notification dated 07.07.2023, which was issued strictly in
accordance with due process of law. The Social Impact Assessment
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-53-


study was carried out through an independent agency, M/s SR Asia,
High Court of H.P.
in consonance with the statutory provisions.
98. It has been further submitted that though the petitioner
has challenged the SIA report submitted by SR Asia by raising
technical objections with regard to the methodology and
recommendation of Multi-disciplinary Expert Group by raising
quantum of capability and competency, however, neither M/s SR
Asia nor the Multi-Disciplinary Expert Group has been impleaded as
a party respondent in the present petition. In the absence of the
survey conducting agency and the Expert Group that approved the
report, the allegations leveled against them cannot be adjudicated,
and the petition is liable to be dismissed for non-joinder of necessary
parties.
99. It has been specifically averred that the airport is not
being expanded by the Indian Air Force and since it is operated as a
civilian airport, the prerogative of expansion does not lie with the
Armed Forces. However, expansion of the airport will provide
significant strategic advantages by virtue of the extended runway
and the capability to handle larger aircraft. The airstrip is frequently
utilized by the Air Force for mock drills and exercises, as confirmed
by communication Annexure R-IV.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-54-


100. With regard to the plea taken by the petitioner about the
High Court of H.P.
construction of a four-lane National Highway by the National
Highways Authority of India (NHAI), it has been submitted that NHAI,
vide letter dated 02.05.2023 (Annexure R-X), informed that earlier
the project from Sihuni to Ichhi from km 51.00 to km 78.090 was
being taken up together, for which notifications under Section 3A had
been published on 18.08.2021 and 21.09.2021. However, due to the
expansion of Gaggal Airport, the highway project is now restricted
up to km 72.00 (Rajol, Kuthman, Jugehr, Bheri, Sanour, Dhugiari,
Gaggal, Jhikli Ichhi, Barswalkar, Mungrehr, and Balla), and for the
balance length, an alternate alignment is being finalized. Gazette
notifications Nos. 3389 and 3897 dated 18.08.2021 and 21.09.2021
lapsed on 18.08.2022 and 21.09.2022, respectively, and are no
more part of the alignment. In light of this communication, the
question of acquisition of land for a second time does not arise at all.
101. While admitting that the acquisition of land for the
expansion of Kangra Airport shall entail the acquisition of public
utilities such as schools, Anganwadis, health facilities, and public
infrastructure, it has been submitted that the State Government is
bound by the provisions of the Third Schedule of the Act, under
which the provision of all infrastructural facilities and basic minimum
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-55-


amenities shall be ensured, details whereof have been brought out
High Court of H.P.
and narrated in the SIA report. The shifting of transmission lines will
no doubt entail financial implications, but the potential benefits of the
proposed expansion of Kangra Airport are immense, and the State
Government is committed to bearing such expenditure in order to
allow the benefits of expansion to be reaped by its citizens.
102. It has been submitted that, as per the report of the
Deputy Director of Agriculture (Annexure R-IX), out of a total 122-52-
42 hectares of land to be acquired, 90-04-62 hectares is cultivated
and 32-04-43 hectares is uncultivated. Due to the lack of a
permanent system of irrigation, agriculture work has been
decreasing, and in the Rabi season, most of the area remains fallow.
The State Government is bound by statutory provisions to provide
compensation for land, structures, crops, and all other assets as per
the Act. Similarly, as far as commercial establishments and loss of
livelihood are concerned, suitable compensation shall be provided
as per the Act, and the State Government is committed to including
suitable provisions in the R&R scheme as well to cater to the
demands and aspirations of the people of the area, details whereof
have been brought out in the SIA report.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-56-


103. It has been submitted that any activity of Kangra Airport
High Court of H.P.
expansion shall be undertaken strictly as per due process of law and
in tune with the seismic and ecological profile of the area. It is denied
that the proposed expansion has been started with an aim to provide
benefit to an eminent class of people; rather, it has been undertaken
in the public interest, and the State Government is bound by the
provisions of the Third Schedule of the Act to ensure the provision of
all infrastructural facilities and basic minimum amenities.
104. It has been reiterated that the Airports Authority of India
opined that expansion of the existing airport from the west towards
the north side (towards Sarah-Dharamshala) was not feasible due to
steep valleys and close proximity to high hills, and expansion of the
existing airport after the construction of the bridge across Manjhi
Khad was technically proposed by AAI as the only option available.
Shifting the airport to alternate locations is not feasible because
those sites are located far from the central location, and construction
of greenfield airports involves huge cost, a long timeline, and multi-
agency clearance processes. The Multi-Disciplinary Expert Group,
which included the Pradhans of Gram Panchayats Gaggal and
Rachhyalu (where a substantial fraction of land is proposed to be
acquired), evaluated the proposal neutrally and independently and
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-57-


recommended expansion of the existing airport as a last resort after
High Court of H.P.
exhausting all other options. The Expert Group did not rubber-stamp
the SIA report, but strongly recommended that adverse social
impacts and social costs must be mitigated to the minimum through
the Social Impact Management Plan and Relief and Rehabilitation
Plan to adequately address the livelihood concerns of project-
affected families.
105. It has been stated that the work of designing the runway
bridge over Manjhi Khad has been entrusted to the Central Water
and Power Research Station (CWPRS), Pune, a renowned
specialized unit of the Government of India, to ensure that the project
is executed in tune with the seismic and ecological profile of the area.
106. It has been submitted that the question of approval of
the Directorate General of Civil Aviation does not arise at all at this
stage, since the expansion plan has been submitted by the Airports
Authority of India itself (Annexure R-2). Under Section 15 of the Act,
affected persons have filed their objections before respondent No. 4,
which are pending statutory adjudication. It has also been submitted
that Hans Raj Chaudhary, Ved Prakash Chhattani, and Vijay Kumar,
members of the petitioner Committee, had themselves availed of the
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-58-


statutory right of filing objections under Section 15 of the Acquisition
High Court of H.P.
Act.
107. In sequel to the order dated 13.11.2024 passed in the
present writ petition, a Supplementary Affidavit was filed on behalf of
the respondent State through the Special Secretary (Tourism & Civil
Aviation) to the Government of Himachal Pradesh, placing on record
a detailed chronological chart indicating the steps taken by the
respondents in consonance with the provisions of the law and rules
as applicable: -
Date Details
2019 The expansion of the Gaggal Airport in the State,
whereby the respondent State has been making
constant endeavors for expansion of present
runway length of Gaggal Airport.
10.12.2019 The respondent State had requested to Airport
Authority of India (Herein referred to as 'AAI' for
short) to revisit the expansion plan for the Kangra
airport and explore the possibility of runway
length up to at least 3100 mtr so that wide bodied
aircrafts like Airlines and Boeing 737-800 are
able to operate from this Airport.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-59-


Obstacle Limitation Surface Survey (Herein referred to as 'OLS' for
High Court of H.P.
short), is a pre-requisite condition for construction/ development of
any airport which ensure safe aircraft operations.
03.01.2020 The respondent Airport Authority of India clearly
mentioned that AAI officials had visited the site
from 21.12.2019 to 22.12.2019 and had
categorically observed that there is a steep valley
towards Rwy15 side, hence the only possibility of
runway extension is towards Rwy 33 side.
Henceforth, it becomes crystal clear that all the
possibilities for runway direction qua expansion
of runway/ project in question have been
explored and the behest of respondent AAI,
which likely in all probabilities is towards Rwy 33
side. Also, the respondent AAI vide the aforesaid
communication supra had enclosed a Draft
Master Plan for the proposed expansion of
Gaggal Airport.
04.03.2021–
OLS survey was done by AAI team for the
11.03.2021
proposed runway extension of Kangra airport
from 1376 Mtr. to 2150 Mtr. towards RWY-33
considering the total runway length up to 3526
Mtr. for IFR operation.
07.10.2021 The site plan for approach runway for expansion
of airport was prepared by the Airport Authority of
India which clearly envisages the entire details of
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-60-


the manner in which the proposed expansion has
High Court of H.P.
to be carried out.
State Government conveyed the consent to the
Draft Master Plan (for 1st Phase extension in
runway from1376 to 1900 mtrs and 2nd phase
from 1900 mtrs. to 3010 mtrs) received from AAI
As per the above communication received from
AAI, the development of airport is subject to
availability of land to be provided by the State
Govt. free of cost and free of all encumbrances,
diversion of road, transmission lines, removal of
obstacle, river training etc.
09.08.2021 The respondent AAI after carrying out OLS
survey of Gaggal Airport for its expansion
whereby all physical. features including essential
and critical objects were collected in and around
the aerodrome within a radius of around 15 km of
the aerodrome covering all obstacle limitation
surfaces as per DGCA CAR specifications.
07.10.2021 The respondent AAI had submitted that the
master plan for the expansion of Kangra Airport
in two phases up to runway length of 3010 mtr. to
respondent State with a request to study techno
economic feasibility and revert with feasibility
way forward
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-61-


02.11.2021 That the AAI had informed that the expansion of
High Court of H.P.
runway at Shimla & Kullu Airports is not advisable
keeping in view the constraints like non-feasibility
of instrument approach procedure, high
obstacles, environmental concerns arising out of
diversion of river and huge cost etc. Hence, the
Gaggal is the only Airport in the State where
expansion is possible.
28.02.2023 SIA notification under Section 4 of the Right to
Fair Compensation in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation & Resettlement Act, 2013
(hereinafter referred as Act) was issued on
28.02.2023 which was published in newspapers
on 02.03.2023 and 03.03.2023.
The SR ASIA submitted SIA report which was
evaluated by the independent Multi-Disciplinary
Expert Group notified by the Government as per
the Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
and Resettlement Act, 2013 which recommended
the project citing that besides fulfilling the public
interest considerations, its potential benefits
would outweigh the social costs and social
impacts.
18.03.2023 After receiving the draft SIA report, notices under
Section 5 of the Act ibid were issued by the SDM
Kangra and SDM Shahpur regarding public
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-62-


hearings which were received by the concerned
High Court of H.P.
Gram Panchayat Pradhans.
10.04.2023–
Public hearings were conducted The
12.04.2023
proceedings of the public hearing are available at
Chapter IX of SIA report and the videography of
hearing are also posted/available on public
domain i.e. You tube channel of HIPA (Pen drive
available).
06.05.2023 The objections/ suggestions received from the
public were incorporated in the final SIA report.
The District Administration Kangra identified the land measuring
147-75-87 hectare (out of which 122-54-86 hectare land is private
land) for the expansion of the Kangra Airport.
07.07.2023 The appraisal report submitted by the Multi-
Disciplinary Expert Group was further approved
by the cabinet and thereafter the notification
under section 11 of the Act was issued.
The respondent State Government had engaged the services of
Centre Water & Power Research Station Khadakwasla (CWPRS)
Pune for Mathematical model studies to hydraulically route flood
below the proposed expansion of Kangra Airport runway crossing
Manjhi Khad in Shahpur, District Kangra. A draft report of CWPRS
Pune was also received from CWPRS.
The Special Land Acquisition Unit (SLAU) has also been set for
land acquisition. The work regarding facilitation in implementation
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-63-


of land acquisition and Resettlement & Rehabilitation for
High Court of H.P.
expansion of Kangra airport has also been awarded to Consultant
for Rural Area Development Linked Economy (CRADLE) through
HPRIDCL.
20.10.2023 The task of Techno-Economic Feasibility Report
(Herein referred to as 'TEFR') was assigned by
the respondent State to WAPCOS Ltd.
Accordingly, the draft TEFR was submitted by
WAPCOS, wherein, project cost excluding the
land acquisition cost was estimated to Rs.
10995.69 Cr . The draft report was then further
forwarded to respondent no.5, i.e. Airport
Authority of India.
09.11.2023 The respondent Authority no.5 communicated to
the Applicant Department to reexamine the TEFR
in view of financial viabilities and further seek
technical opinion from IIT, Roorkee (Department
of Water Resource Development & management.
20.11.2023 The State Government vide its notification no.
TSM-F (6)-1/2015-IV-L dated 15.09.2023
constituted a Rehabilitation & Resettlement
Committee at project level under Section 45 (1)
of the Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
and Resettlement Act, 2013 to monitor and
review the progress of implementation social
audits in consultation with Gram Sabha in rural
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-64-


areas and Municipality in urban areas in r/o
High Court of H.P.
Expansion of Kangra Airport.
02.12.2023 A meeting under the Chairpersonship of the
Director T&CA was convened and WAPCOS was
directed to re-examine their draft TEFR as
pointed out by respondent no.5. The Company
was also directed to get the draft TEFR
technically vetted from IIT Roorkee estimates for
expansion of Kangra Airport and resubmit the
revised TEFR.
26.02.2024 The WAPCOS Limited submitted revised TEFR
stating that revised CAPEX cost is now to a tune
of Rs. 3,504/- Crores plus applicable taxes (INR
4, 249 Cr. Incl. of applicable taxes.) The IRR &
ERR for the project has been obtained as 2.0%
and 2.90% respectively considering the rate of
interest as 8%. WAPCOS Ltd.
12.03.2024 Consequently, the aforesaid R&R Committee in
consultation with State Government approved
the R & R scheme. Rehabilitation & Resettlement
Scheme was finalized by the State Government
and stands conveyed to District Administration,
Kangra
15.03.2024 The State Govt. sent the revised draft TEFR to
AAI on 15.03.2024 for comments/approval
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-65-


02.04.2024 WAPCOS Ltd. had sent the draft TEFR to IIT,
High Court of H.P.
Roorkee for vetting.
19.04.2024 As per the section 7 of the Act, Multidisciplinary
Expert Group was constituted which examined
the SIA report as per the mandate of the Act. The
Multidisciplinary Expert Group in its appraisal
report has recommended the acquisition of the
land for the public purpose. Most of the
objections of affected families were regarding
missing Khasra numbers and R & R plan
09.05.2024 After carrying out all due processes related to
fixing of boundary marks, finalization of forest
Land and enumeration of trees, the case for
seeking approval under the Forest Conservation
Act has been uploaded on the portal by the
Department of Tourism and Civil Aviation.
15.05.2024 That the respondent Department had convened
a meeting with respondent no. 5, i.e. Airport
Authority of India & WAPCOS Ltd. on 15th May'
2024 to discuss the submitted TEFR and the
process of addressing the observations raised by
respondent Airport Authority of India have been
taken up with WAPCOS. It is further submitted
that once observations so raised by the Airport
Authority of India are attended, final vetting of
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-66-


TEFR shall be expedited by WAPCOS Ltd. from
High Court of H.P.
IIT, Roorkee.
24.05.2024 The respondent no. 5 AAI conveyed the:
observations / comments on draft TEFR which
were then again conveyed to WAPCOS Limited
for necessary action.
16.08.2024 Notification under Section 19 of the Act ibid was
been issued by the Government which was
published in the Gazette on 17.08.2024.
21.08.2024 After attending all observations, WAPCOS has
submitted draft TEFR 21.08.2024 wherein, the
CAPAX has been estimated at Rs. 4064.27 Cr.
(Inclusive GST). The TEFR was sent to the Govt.
which has further been sent to AAI for approval.
October' 2024 The Land Acquisition Collector Gaggal Airport-
cum-SDM Kangra issued the notices on
08.09.2024 under Section 21 of the Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act,
2013 to the families likely to be affected by the
proposed expansion. Out of the total 6429
notices served u/s 21 of the Act , 158 notices
stands un-served due to insufficient addresses.
Total 44 objections were received out of which 13
pertains land and 31 pertains to R & R.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-67-


October' 2024
As per the proposed timeline received from the
High Court of H.P.
to December'
Land Acquisition Collector Gaggal airport -cum-
2024
SDM Kangra enquiries of objections received u/s
21 of Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
and Resettlement Act, 2013 which shall be
conducted.
October 2024
Award shall be issued by the Collector u/s 23 of
to June 2025.
the Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
and Resettlement Act, 2013.
Land Acquisition Collector Gaggal Airport-cum-
SDM-Kangra passed award u/s 23 of the Right to
Fair Compensation in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation & Resettlement Act, 2013 to the
extent of 02-60-66 hectare land of Village
Jugehar, Tehsil Shahpur, District Kangra, HP to
the tune of Rs. 32, 43, 66,466.40 which has been
released to DTDO Kangra by IDB, HP from the
amount of Rs. 300.00 Cr. deposited with them for
execution of work regarding of Kangra airport.
30.10.2024 The Land Acquisition Collector Gaggal Airport-
cum-SDM Kangra has also passed award for the
Village Rachhiyalu, Tehsil Shahpur, District
Kangra to the extent of 14-94-48 hectare to the
tune of Rs. 126, 39, 53,826.67/-.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-68-


06.11.2024 The SDM Kangra has passed the award for
High Court of H.P.
Villages of Dhugiari Khas, Bhadot and Bheri to
the tune of Rs. 31, 49, 46,662.04/-. The approval
to release the funds is under process. The
awards for the villages of Kior and Sanour to the
tune of Rs. 131.23 Cr. has also been issued.
October' 2024
Individual award u/s 30 and R & R awards u/s 31
to July 2025.
of the Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
and Resettlement Act, 2013.
October 2024
Payment of Compensation

to December
2025.
December'
After releasing of full payment of compensation
2024 to
and R& R entitlements the site shall be handed
February 2026
over u/s 38 of the Act at 04 Villages of Shahpur
Tehsil.

108. In sequel to the orders dated 25.11.2024, 12.12.2024,
and 24.12.2024, a Status Report was placed on record on behalf of
the respondent State through the Joint Secretary (Tourism & Civil
Aviation) to the Government of Himachal Pradesh, stating that the
respondent State is duty bound to execute the aforesaid project, for
which an application has already been filed to seek forest clearance
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-69-


for diversion of 06-10-68 hectares of forest land out of the entire
High Court of H.P.
project area measuring 147-75-87 hectares (which comprises 122-
66-23 hectares of private land), which does not form even 1% of the
total land in question, and the project will be executed only after
securing the land with all necessary statutory compliances as and
when required.
109. It has also been stated in the Status Report that the
respondent State has awarded an amount of Rs. 4,89,10,01,358.47
to affected persons having private land, and compensation is being
deposited in the bank accounts of only those affected persons who
voluntarily agree to accept compensation upon furnishing written
undertakings.
110. It has been submitted that as per the EIA Notification
dated 14.09.2006 issued by the Ministry of Environment, Forest
and Climate Change (MoEF), under paragraph 2, prior
environmental clearance is required, wherein it has been
provided as under: -
"...before any construction work, or preparation of land by the
project management except for securing the land, is started on the
project or activity..."

::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-70-


111. Referring aforesaid, it has been further submitted that
High Court of H.P.
securing the land is expressly permitted prior to obtaining
environmental clearance, and the executing agency (AAI) would be
the user agency for seeking environmental clearance once the land
is secured and transferred. Furthermore, the proposal for diversion
of 06-10-68 hectares of forest land under the Forest (Conservation)
Act, 1980 is pending before the Technical Officer, and Section 2 of
the 1980 Act applies only to land entered as 'Forest' and not to
private land. The respondent State is strictly adhering to the statutory
provisions of the 2013 Act and following the law laid down by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Kolkata Municipal Corporation & Anr.
v. Bimal Kumar Shah & Ors. (Civil Appeal No. 6466 of 2024,
decided on 16.05.2024).
112. Learned Advocate General by referring judgment dated
10.07.2024 passed by the Apex Court in Civil Appeal No.
8048/2019 , titled New Okhla Industrial Development Authority
vs. Darshan Lal Bohra and Ors . , reported in 2024 INSC 508 , has
submitted that if State Government opines that the land is needed
for a larger public purpose and development projects, such land can
be acquired notwithstanding the fact that it was residential and also
that it is an admitted position that acquisition proceedings in instant
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-71-


case have nearly attained finality. Significant investment has been
High Court of H.P.
made in acquisition of land, and for accepting petitioner’s plea, claim
would be required to turn back the clock, which would have adverse
impact on the larger public interest.
113. Learned Advocate General to substantiate the plea that
in cases of land acquisition, in larger public interest, the plea of
deprivation of right to livelihood under Article 21 of the Constitution
is un-sustainable, and ordinary rehabilitation should only be meant
for those persons who have been rendered destitute because of loss
of residence or livelihood, as a consequence of land acquisition, and
on the ground of loss of residence of livelihood, an acquisition cannot
be halted, has referred judgment dated 14.07.2025 passed by the
Apex Court in Civil Appeal No. 7707 of 2025 , titled Estate Officer,
Haryana Urban Development Authority and Ors. vs. Nirmala
Devi reported in 2025 INSC 843.
114. Referring judgment of Coordinate Division Bench of
this High Court in case titled Vivek Sharma vs. Union of India
Through Its Secretary, Ministry of Road Transport And
Highways & Connected Matter , reported in 2022 (1) Him.L.R.
575 , it has been submitted that Court is not at all equipped to
decide upon viability or feasibility of a particular project, and it is
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-72-


only an expert body, having experience in the field of development
High Court of H.P.
and maintenance of airports, which can evaluate the feasibility and
viability of the project, and therefore, for such plea, scope of
judicial review is extremely limited.
115. Learned Advocate General to substantiate respondent-
State’s plea and oppose the petitioner’s plea has also referred
judgment passed by the Apex Court in Jilubhai Nanbhai Khachar
and others v. State of Gujarat and another , 1995 Supp (1) SCC
596 ; Ramniklal N. Bhutta and another v. State of Maharashtra
and others , (1997) 1 SCC 134 ; Sooraram Pratap Reddy and
others v. District Collector, Ranga Reddy District and others ,
(2008) 9 SCC 552 ; Project Director, Project Implementation vs.
P.V. Krishamoorthy & Ors. , (2021) 3 SCC 572; N.G. Projects
Limited v. Vinod Kumar Jain and others , (2022) 6 SCC 127; and
Kolkata Municipal Corporation and another v. Bimal Kumar
Shah and others , AIR 2024 SC 2819 as well as of this High Court
in Vivek Sharma vs. Union of India Through Its Secretary,
Ministry of Road Transport And Highways & Connected Matter ,
(2022) 1 HLR 575 and in M/s. Garg and Garg Co. vs. Union of
India and others, AIR 2023 HP 183 .
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-73-


STAND OF RESPONDENT NO.5-AIRPORTS AUTHORITY OF
High Court of H.P.
INDIA
116. In the reply filed on behalf of respondent No. 5, Airports
Authority of India (AAI), it has been submitted that no fundamental
or constitutional right whatsoever of the petitioner has been
infringed, and as such the writ petition is not maintainable and the
petitioner has no locus standi to file the same. At the very outset, it
has been submitted that land for the expansion of Kangra Airport is
required to be acquired by the State of Himachal Pradesh, and only
after completion of the acquisition, the Airports Authority of India will
carry out the development and expansion and seek necessary
permissions from the concerned statutory authorities. It has been
reiterated that AAI shall take up the expansion work after additional
land is acquired by the State Government and handed over to AAI,
whereas all statutory actions related to land acquisition such as
Social Impact Assessment (SIA), publication of Gazette Notifications
under the Land Acquisition Act, evaluation of land and property, and
Rehabilitation and Resettlement are being done by the State
Government. After the land is handed over by the State Government
to AAI, AAI shall obtain necessary clearances and approvals from
the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) and all other
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-74-


concerned statutory authorities during execution as well as
High Court of H.P.
commissioning of the infrastructure.
117. Tracing the sequence of communications, it has been
submitted that in reference to the letter dated 15.11.2019 addressed
to the replying respondent by the State of Himachal Pradesh, the
replying respondent responded on 03.01.2020 and submitted a draft
plan to explore the feasibility for acquisition of additional land
(Annexure R/5-A). On 03.01.2021, the State of Himachal Pradesh
through its Additional Secretary wrote a letter observing that
conducting of SIA and proposing realignment of the National
Highway without obtaining pre-feasibility report and OLS survey
report will be a futile exercise, and can be initiated only after the site
is declared suitable for runway expansion by a survey feasibility
study and clearance from BCAS and DGCA (Annexure R/5-B). On
17.04.2021, the OLS chart and obstacle penetration details for the
Runway 33 extension at Kangra Airport were forwarded to the State
of Himachal Pradesh. On 07.10.2021, the replying respondent
issued a letter to the State of Himachal Pradesh mentioning therein
that Kangra Airport can be developed in two phases, i.e., Phase-I for
operation of ATR-72/Q-400 type of aircraft and Phase-II for operation
of A-320 type of aircraft (Annexure R-5/C). On 08.11.2021, the State
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-75-


of Himachal Pradesh constituted a Committee for identification of
High Court of H.P.
land for development of Kangra Airport for operation of ATR-72/Q-
400 and A-320 type of aircraft (Annexure R-5/D).
118. It has been further submitted that on 26.09.2023, the
State of Himachal Pradesh informed that the acquisition process for
the expansion of Kangra Airport was in an advanced stage and
requested to finalize the construction of the extended portion of the
airport (Annexure R-5/E). On 20.10.2023, the State of Himachal
Pradesh submitted a draft Techno-Economic Feasibility Report
(TEFR) prepared by WAPCOS Ltd. for examination (Annexure R-
5/F). On 09.11.2023, the replying respondent wrote a letter to the
State advising it to carry out a study on financial viability in addition
to technical viability (Annexure R-5/G). In a review meeting
convened on 02.12.2023, it was observed that the TEFR submitted
was shoddy and not made in a professional way, reflecting a
lackadaisical approach by WAPCOS, and it was conveyed that the
points and observations raised were only indicative and the onus lay
on WAPCOS to expedite revision of its report, address all
shortcomings, and make the report in sync with reality based on facts
and figures (Annexure R-5/H). On 06.12.2023, the State of Himachal
Pradesh issued directions to carry out necessary verification and
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-76-


certification of boundary pillars in consonance with the approved
High Court of H.P.
Master Plan, explore alternate locations for DVOR, and plan the
creation of new infrastructure (Annexure R-5/J & K), and on
01.01.2024, WAPCOS Ltd. informed the State Government that its
team would visit the site in the second week of January, 2024
(Annexure R-5/L).
119. It has been further submitted by respondent No. 5 that
in various meetings, it was suggested and opined that possibilities
may be explored for extension of the runway for operation of bigger
aircraft and making the airport operations from Visual Flight Rules
(VFR) to Instrument Flight Rules (IFR) to reduce flight cancellations,
load penalties, and airfares. Accordingly, based on the OLS survey
report, the Airports Authority of India prepared a Master Plan for
expansion of Kangra Airport for extension of the existing runway
length from 1376 meters to 3010 meters suitable for operation of AB-
320 type of aircraft, while catering to other requirements like Runway
End Safety Area (RESA) and land for approach lighting on the same
alignment. The Master Plan has been shared with the State
Government, which involves an additional land requirement of
369.82 acres for the proposed expansion. AAI has reiterated that it
shall take up the expansion work after additional land is acquired by
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-77-


the State Government, all statutory actions relating to land
High Court of H.P.
acquisition, notifications, valuation, and Rehabilitation and
Resettlement are completed, and possession is handed over to AAI,
whereafter AAI shall obtain necessary clearances and approvals
from DGCA and other concerned statutory authorities during
execution as well as commissioning of the infrastructure.
120. Subsequently, in compliance with the order dated
08.01.2025 passed by this Court in the present writ petition—
whereby the replying respondent was directed to file a status report
regarding the TEFR submitted by the State of Himachal Pradesh and
apprise whether it is technically viable that the expansion can be
carried out on the airport to the extent proposed by the State
Government for Phase-I for operation of ATR-72/Q-400 type of
aircraft without load penalty for VFR operations and Phase-II for
operation of A-320 type of aircraft without load penalty for IFR
operations—an affidavit dated 03.03.2025 was placed on record on
behalf of respondent No. 5 through Shri Dhirendra Singh, Airport
Director, Kangra Airport.
121. In the aforesaid response and affidavit, it has been
stated regarding the latest status on the TEFR for expansion of
Kangra Airport that in October 2024, a revised report was submitted
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-78-


to AAI by the State Government in which the proposal for expansion
High Court of H.P.
of Kangra Airport, including extension of runway for IFR operations
for A-320 type of aircraft along with construction of new terminal
building, ATC tower, fire station, and associated facilities in a single
phase was given, and the capital expenditure cost was revised to
Rs. 4,064 crores. Comments on the same were conveyed to the
State Government by AAI in December 2024, advising it to
incorporate the same and re-submit a revised TEFR. The revised
TEFR is awaited from the State Government, and upon its
submission, it will be analyzed by AAI. If the project is found to be
technically and financially viable and the State Government is willing
to bear the cost of cutting and filling, soil stabilization, and
construction of the bridge over Manjhi Khad, then AAI can take up
the work for extension of the runway and other facilities subject to
approval of the Competent Authority. Regarding whether it is
technically viable that the expansion can be done on the airport to
the extent proposed by the State Government for Phase-I and
Phase-II, it has been stated that since the revised TEFR is currently
pending from the State Government, AAI will conduct a thorough
analysis of its technical feasibility once it is submitted, and only after
such evaluation will the replying respondent be able to provide any
comments.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-79-


122. With regard to proposed expansion and alternatives
High Court of H.P.
sites suggested in SIA Report as well as proposed by the petitioner,
including alternative depicted in Annexure P-7 appended with the
petition, the AAI has responded as under:-
"i. The Kangra Airport is under operational and the expansion
proposed is extension of Runway and that shall not hinder
the ongoing operations.
ii. The proposal suggested is re-orienting the Runway and
that needs study of feasibility with respect to Wind
directions, Obstacles, Hazards and Dangerous zones etc
and the financial viability.
iii. This needs the whole procedures of Feasibility study, OLS
study and the Tecno- Economic feasibility study to be once
again carried out as carried out earlier by GoHP in co-
ordination with AAI for the earlier expansion proposed
which leads time overrun & cost overrun and fresh pocket
of land to be identified for the feasibility study.
iv. The present proposal of Expansion of Runway is on same
alignment which require the least span of the bridge over
Manjhi Khad. The re-orientation suggested in Annexure P-
7, is crossing through two branches of rivers Sarah and
Manjhi Khad, required to construct larger span of bridge
which may not structurally suitable to construct runway
over it.
v. The re-orientation suggested such that even if the study on
the alternative proposal turns out to be financially viable for
GoHP, technically it may not be possible to carry out on an
operational Airport. Also, the the cost co incurred to shift all
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-80-


the existing infra structures to be ascertained the same to
High Court of H.P.
be borned by whom?
vi. Further, to go with re-orientation of expansion, the
operations of the Airport had to be closed for the re-
orientation process, it is to bring in here that there are only
two airports Kullu and Kangra Airports in this valley. Shimla
is situated in the down southern part of Himachal Pradesh.
vii. Therefore, in this case, operation of Kangra Airport may
hinder and it may impact to potential efficiency as well as
effectiveness of AAI at Kangra."

123. Learned Deputy Solicitor General of India has also
questioned locus of the petitioner and submitted that present petition
is not maintainable, as it has not been filed by an aggrieved person,
and petitioner-Committee is not legal entity to be an aggrieved
person. According to him, three persons, namely, (1) directly
aggrieved, (2) person authorized by aggrieved person or, (3) person
having no personal interest, but public interest at large is involved,
can only file writ petition of present nature. He has submitted that
petitioner-Committee is not a directly aggrieved person, though it is
claiming authorization by the Panchayat, but authorization is in
favour of persons, but not in favour of petitioner-Committee. It has
been further submitted that present case has not been filed as a
Public Interest Litigation, as mandatory requirements for filing Public
Interest Litigation have not been followed.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-81-


124. It has been further submitted by learned Deputy
High Court of H.P.
Solicitor General that resolution passed by Gram Panchayat,
Nandehar, is in favour of persons named in the resolution, but writ
petition has been filed in the name of Committee, whereas there is
no authorization in favour of the Committee either by the Gram
Panchayat, Nandehar or anyone else to agitate their cause in
present matter. Therefore, it has been contended that petition
deserves to be dismissed on this sole ground.
125. Learned Deputy Solicitor General has also submitted
that no locus lies in favour of petitioner or anyone else. It has been
submitted that petitioner-Committee has misled the Court by
concealing necessary facts and thus, petition deserves to be
dismissed.
126. To substantiate his plea, learned Deputy Solicitor
General has referred pronouncements of Apex Court in various
cases, i.e., in case titled Ayaaubkhan Noorkhan Pathan vs. State
of Maharashtra and Others , reported in (2013) 4 SCC 465 , case
titled Ghulam Qadir vs. Special Tribunal and Others , reported in
(2002) 1 SCC 33 , case titled Vinoy Kumar vs. State of U.P. & Ors ,
reported in AIR 2001 SC 1739 , case titled State of Bihar and
Another vs. P.P. Sharma, IAS and Another reported in (1992)
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-82-


Supp 1 SCC 222 and case titled Dr. J.N. Banavalikar vs Municipal
High Court of H.P.
Corporation Of Delhi And Anr. , reported in AIR 1996 SC 326 .
127. Learned Deputy Solicitor General has submitted that
SIA and Expert Committee are not party, who have prepared and
affirmed the report and the nature of pleadings are clear that there
are no mala fide allegations against SIA and Expert Committee.
128. According to learned Deputy Solicitor General, as there
is defect in pleadings, the writ petition deserves to be dismissed, as
held by the Apex Court in various pronouncements referred
hereinafter, i.e., case titled Udit Narain Singh Malpaharia vs.
Additional Member, Board of Revenue, Bihar and Anr . , reported
in AIR 1963 SC 786 , case titled Prabodh Verma and Others etc.
etc. v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Others , reported in AIR 1985
SC 167 , case titled Public Service Commission, Uttaranchal vs.
Mamta Bisht and Others , reported in (2010) 12 SCC 204 , and in
CWP No. 6652 of 2022 , titled Bishamber Singh vs. State of H.P.
& others , decided on 27.04.2023.
129. Learned Deputy Solicitor General has further submitted
that though Order 1 Rule 10 CPC is not strictly applicable to the writ
proceedings, however, principles of CPC are always applicable, and
there is complete non-compliance of Order 1 Rule 10 CPC, and
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-83-


therefore, for non-compliance thereof, petition deserves to be
High Court of H.P.
dismissed.
130. To substantiate aforesaid plea, learned Deputy Solicitor
General has referred to pronouncements of Apex Court, i.e., case
titled The Chairman , Tamil Nadu Housing Board, Madras vs. T.N.
Ganapathy , reported in AIR 1990 SC 642 , case titled Ramchander
Sunda and Another v. Union of India and Others , reported in
(1999) 9 SCC 105 , case titled V. Chandrasekaran and Another v.
Administrative Officer and Others , reported in (2012) 12 SCC 133 ,
case titled Ayaaubkhan Noorkhan Pathan v. State of
Maharashtra & Ors. , reported in (2013) 4 SCC 465 and case titled
Narmada Bachao Andolan v. Union of India and Others , reported
in (2000) 10 SCC 664 .
STAND OF RESPONDENT NO.6
131. On behalf of respondent No. 6, National Highways
Authority of India (NHAI), it has been submitted that the replying
respondent is an autonomous agency of the Government of India
and a nodal agency of the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways,
responsible for the development and management of highway
networks in the country. The Government of India, vide Gazette
Notification dated 15.09.2016, upgraded NH-20 (Himachal
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-84-


Pradesh/Punjab Border to Mandi, km 11.000 to km 208.000) from
High Court of H.P.
two lanes to four lanes, and the alignment of the proposed NH-154
was finalized on 10.01.2018. The highway project was divided into
five packages, and the stretch involved in the present petition falls in
Package-II (Sihuni to Parour) from chainage 51+000 to 100+840,
having a length of 49.840 km. Package-II is further sub-divided into
three sub-packages, namely Package-IIA (Sihuni to Rajol) which is
under construction, Package-IIB (Rajol to Thanpuri) which is under
Detailed Project Report (DPR) preparation due to the expansion of
Gaggal Airport, and Package-IIC (Thanpuri to Parour) which has
already been awarded.
132. It has been further submitted that respondent No. 2, vide
letter dated 27.08.2020, conveyed information regarding the
proposal for expansion of the existing Gaggal Airport from 1376
meters of landing strip to 3187 meters of landing strip as per the
drawing provided by respondent No. 5, which intersects with the
proposed National Highway. In a meeting held on 02.09.2020, the
Project Director, NHAI Palampur, was directed to prepare and
submit a revised alignment of Package-IIB (Rajol to Thanpuri) and
provide three alternative options in consultation with the Joint
Committee comprising the Deputy Director (Tourism & Civil
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-85-


Aviation), SDM Kangra, SDM Shahpur, revenue officials, and the
High Court of H.P.
Airport Director. The DPR consultant explored the feasibility of
alternate alignments and submitted a draft comparative report, and
based on suggestions from the Deputy Commissioner, Kangra,
proposed alternate Option-III was prepared and submitted to NHAI
Headquarters for approval, where it is under active consideration.
133. It has been submitted that Gazette Notifications under
Section 3A of the National Highways Act, 1956 were published on
18.08.2021 and 21.09.2021 (Annexure P-5) for the project Sihuni to
Ichhi from km 51.00 to km 78.090. However, due to the expansion of
Gaggal Airport, the highway project was restricted up to km 72.00,
and for the balance length, an alternate alignment was to be
finalized. Consequently, declarations under Section 3D of the
National Highways Act, 1956 were not issued within the statutory
period of one year as provided under Section 3D(3) of the Act, and
the notifications issued under Section 3A lapsed on 18.08.2022 and
21.09.2022, respectively, which was duly communicated to
respondent No. 2 vide letter dated 01.08.2023 (Annexure R-6/1). In
light of this, the highway alignment does not pass through the
proposed airport land, and the plea of the petitioner regarding dual
acquisition of the same land for a second time does not arise at all.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-86-


134. Respondent No.6 has further raised a preliminary
High Court of H.P.
objection that the petitioner Committee is an unregistered society
and an association of persons, which is not conferred with the status
of a legal entity under any statute. Not being a juristic person, an
unregistered society cannot sue or maintain a writ petition in its own
name, rendering the present petition bad in law and liable to be
dismissed on this ground alone.
135. It has been averred that there is no violation of any
statutory, legal, or vested right of the petitioner, no injustice has been
caused, and the petitioner has no cause of action. The impugned
preliminary notification dated 07.07.2023 has not been issued by
respondent No. 6, and no relief has been claimed against the
replying respondent, whereby the petition is frivolous, baseless, and
deserves to be dismissed.
REBUTTAL SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF PETITIONER
136. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner has submitted
that the rejoinder forms an integral part of the pleadings, and to
substantiate this submission, reliance has been placed on Vivek
Sharma vs. Union of India Through Its Secretary, Ministry of
Road Transport And Highways & Connected Matter , (2022) 1
HLR 575 (paragraph 11).
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-87-


137. In the rejoinder filed on behalf of the petitioner, it has
High Court of H.P.
been reiterated that the State and its instrumentalities have resorted
to massive acquisition of agricultural land without complying with the
statutory mandate. It has been pleaded that when the land of
uneducated agriculturists is acquired, who are not empowered to
adopt alternative livelihoods, not only the present but future
generations are ruined, which is one of the reasons why farmers who
are deprived of their landholdings are driven to suicide. It has been
urged that the authorities are unmindful of the plight of those sections
of society who are deprived of their only assets, like agriculture, small
houses, and small industrial units, and before acquiring private land,
the State should, as far as possible, utilize land belonging to the
State for specified public purposes; if acquisition of private land
becomes absolutely necessary, land that is barren, unfertile, and
involves zero displacement should be preferred, in strict compliance
with relevant statutory provisions and the rules of natural justice.
138. It is the case of the petitioner that the Social Impact
Assessment team visited the villages in an arbitrary manner, without
giving any prior information regarding their visit to the Gram
Panchayats and without publishing public notice of the substance of
the notification at convenient places in the locality through the
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-88-


Collector, and the rights of the people are being taken away in utter
High Court of H.P.
disregard of the provisions of law and statutory mandate.
139. Further, it has been submitted that the Rehabilitation
and Resettlement plan was not available with the SIA team, and
therefore, the SIA report is not based on complete facts, and thus
could not be relied upon to carry on the project of expansion of the
airport as proposed.
140. It has been highlighted in the rejoinder that due to the
peculiar topography of the State of Himachal Pradesh, the Gaggal
Airport expansion project involves the construction of a bridge of 380
meters width over the Manjhi River, which would form part of the
expanded runway and would entail massive river training and
diversion works, as well as realignment of the National Highway. In
its letter dated 09.11.2023, the Airports Authority of India had
recommended that the State Government take a second opinion
from the Department of Water Resources Development and
Management, IIT Roorkee, because the proposed construction is to
be carried out in an area that has in the recent past witnessed heavy
flooding, landslides, etc., and falls in Seismic Zone V. This
recommendation was made by AAI on the basis of the draft Techno-
Economic Feasibility Report issued by WAPCOS Ltd., a Public
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-89-


Sector Enterprise under the Ministry of Jal Shakti, Government of
High Court of H.P.
India. Even in its communication dated 07.10.2021, AAI had
categorically opined that techno-economic feasibility and
environmental clearance need to be obtained prior to the expansion
work.
141. Learned counsel for the petitioner has further submitted
that the State of Himachal Pradesh witnessed the wrath of nature in
the form of incessant rains, cloudbursts, flash floods, and landslides
during the monsoon season of 2023. The Manjhi River is prone to
floods every rainy season, and the proposed construction of a 380-
meter-wide bridge over the river to form part of the extended runway,
apart from requiring clearances from the Bureau of Civil Aviation
Security, would entail extensive river training and diversion. The
expansion work, if carried out at this natal stage without an approved,
vetted techno-economic study, would entail serious environmental
hazards, and the hapless public at large would suffer the brunt of
such an injudicious exercise carried out in a haphazard manner.
142. It has been contended that the Multi-Disciplinary Expert
Group constituted under Section 7 of the Act cannot be termed an
independent group, since it is chaired by the Deputy Commissioner
(Relief & Rehabilitation), who cannot be stated to be an independent
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-90-


person for the purpose of the evaluation to be carried out by the
High Court of H.P.
Expert Group. Because of an inherent element of institutional
prejudice, the Expert Group failed to appreciate that the social costs
and adverse social impacts of the project outweigh the potential
benefits. Moreover, the Expert Group brushed aside the alternative
sites suggested in the Social Impact Assessment study by a
sidewind without examining their technical and financial aspects,
whereas considering those alternative sites would be financially and
economically viable and would prevent mass displacement.
CONSIDERATION AND ANALYSIS
A. Competence and Status of the Petitioner Committee
143. Before adverting to consideration on merits with regard
to plea of the petitioner and response thereto, we are of the opinion
that in given facts and circumstances it would also be necessary to
consider competence and status of the petitioner-Committee to file
present petition as constituted and preferred, and accordingly, the
same has been considered hereinafter.
144. The petitioner is stated to be a committee constituted for
representing the grievances of local residents of the villages whose
land was and is proposed to be acquired by the respondents for
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-91-


expansion of Gaggal Airport, as averred in paragraph 1 of the writ
High Court of H.P.
petition.
145. There is nothing on record regarding the constitution of
the Committee and registration thereof. It is also not clear whether
the Committee is registered or unregistered. The aims and objects
of the Committee, as well as its Memorandum of Association, have
also not been placed on record.
146. There is no resolution of the Committee on record
authorizing the filing of the present petition, nor is there anything on
record to indicate the competence of the President of this so-called
Committee to file the petition on behalf of the Committee. Who are
the members of the Committee is also not traceable from the material
placed on record.
147. It has been claimed in paragraph 1 of the petition that
the Gram Panchayats of the villages referred in this para had passed
resolutions and authorized the President and other members of the
Committee to pursue the matter on their behalf. However, there is no
resolution on record except one purported to have been passed by
Gram Panchayat, Nandehar.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-92-


148. This resolution is also defective. In this resolution, it has
High Court of H.P.
been resolved to oppose the expansion of Kangra Airport on the
ground that most of the villagers depend for their livelihood on
agriculture, and their agricultural lands, residential houses, shops,
and commercial establishments are coming within the acquisition for
expansion of the airport, and for contesting the legal battle on behalf
of the Panchayat, Rajneesh Saini (President), Hans Raj Chaudhery
(General Secretary), Ved Chattani (Senior Vice President), and Vijay
Kumar (Member) are authorized.
149. It is worth noticing that in the memo of parties of the writ
petition, the President of the petitioner Committee has been
described as Rajneesh Mona, whereas in the resolution, he has
been named as Rajneesh Saini.
150. Further, the resolution has been passed in favour of and
authorizing the office bearers of "Gaggal Hawai Adda Vistar
Prabhavit Kalyan Committee", whereas the petitioner before this
Court is "Gaggal Airport Expansion Affected Social Welfare
Committee".
151. The name of the Committee in either language should
be one and the same. It cannot be that the name in Hindi is different
and in English it is different. If such a practice were to be permissible,
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-93-


then a person named "Lal Chand" in Hindi would have to be named
High Court of H.P.
as "Red Moon" or “Son of Moon” in English.
152. It is further noticeable that the authorization by the Gram
Panchayat was to contest the legal battle on behalf of the Panchayat,
but the present petition has not been filed on behalf of Gram
Panchayat, Nandehar, but on behalf of the Gaggal Airport Expansion
Affected Social Welfare Committee. It is not a petition by Gram
Panchayat through Committee or by Committee on behalf of Gram
Panchayat.
153. Further that there is no resolution on record to file a
petition by the Committee on behalf of the Gram Panchayat. In fact,
while the office bearers were authorized to contest on behalf of Gram
Panchayat, Nandehar, the petition has been filed by the Committee,
and not by the office bearers on behalf of the Gram Panchayat. The
petitioner-Committee has filed this petition independent of the
resolution passed by the Gram Panchayat.
154. Moreover, the resolution placed on record is only of one
Gram Panchayat, and there is nothing on record regarding the
resolutions of the other Gram Panchayats as claimed in paragraph
1 of the petition.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-94-


155. It is also a matter of fact that most of the residents and
High Court of H.P.
land owners of the villages comprising Gram Panchayat, Nandehar
have already accepted the amount of compensation.
156. In absence of any material on record regarding
registration of the petitioner-Committee with competent authority,
which has also not been placed on record despite objection taken by
the respondents with regard to maintainability and locus of the
petitioner-Committee to file the writ petition, the only inference which
can be drawn is that either Committee is not in existence or it is an
unregistered Committee.
157. Authorization by aggrieved person or Gram Panchayat
can be given to a natural person or at least a juristic person (which
includes natural person also), but an unregistered Committee is
neither a natural person nor a juristic person, and thus, even if
resolution passed by Gram Panchayat, Nandehar is taken as
resolution in favour of Committee, the Committee being a non-juristic
person is not competent to prefer the present writ petition.
158. Resolution of Gram Panchayat Nandehar, also appears
to be in favour of persons whose names are mentioned in the
resolution, though against their names, their status as office bearers
of the Committee has also been indicated, and in any case this
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-95-


resolution is not in favour of the Committee, but in favour of members
High Court of H.P.
authorized by Gram Panchayat, Nandehar for legal battle in the
matter. But petition has been filed by the Committee, and admittedly
Committee has no proprietary right in the land proposed to be
acquired or being acquired and, therefore, there is no threat of legal
injury likely to be caused to the petitioner-Committee, creating a
remedial right in favour of Committee, as available to an injured
person and being a non-affected entity, Committee has no right to
file present writ petition, as rights under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India can be enforced only by aggrieved person,
except in writ petitions, falling in the category of Habeas Corpus or
Quo Warranto or writ petition is filed in public interest. Present writ
petition, has not been stated to have been filed as a Public Interest
Litigation, and thus, it has been registered as ordinary petition, which
was never objected or got rectified by the petitioner, if the petitioner
was pursuing the matter in public interest. It appears that Committee
is a self-styled Committee of four persons only, who have their
personal interest in the matter and, thus, petition appears to have
been preferred to agitate the matter for personal reasons only.
159. We acknowledge that even petition under Article 226 of
the Constitution can be invoked even by unregistered Cooperative
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-96-


Body, but in such case, aggrieved person or class of person must be
High Court of H.P.
incapable, suppressed or without means to approach the Court,
whereas in present case, nothing material is available on record, so
as to construe that the petitioner-Committee is preferring this petition
on behalf of distressed, weaker, suppressed persons/class, who are
not able and/or afford the litigation.
160. In view of above referred facts, circumstances and
discussion, we are of the considered opinion that petitioner-
Committee is not competent to file and maintain present writ petition,
and for absence of locus of the petitioner-Committee, the petition is
liable to be dismissed, being not filed by competent/aggrieved
person.
B. Consideration and analysis on merit.
161. Though we are of the opinion that petitioner-Committee
is neither competent nor has locus to file and maintain present writ
petition, however, we have also dealt with the objections/plea taken
by the petitioner-Committee with regard to the acquisition process
initiated by the respondent-State for providing land to the Airports
Authority of India for expansion of Kangra Airport, and on merits also,
for discussion here-in-after, we find that no ground for interference is
made out at this stage.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-97-


162. We have gone through the pleadings and documents
High Court of H.P.
placed on record by the parties and have also considered the
submissions of respective counsels for the petitioner-Committee,
learned Advocate General, learned Deputy Solicitor General of India
as well as counsel for respondent No. 6 and judgments cited by them
in support of their respective contentions.
163. With regard to violation of Rule 3(1) of Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement (Social Impact Assessment and
Consent) Rules, 2014 as well as Section 4(2) and 5 of LARR Act,
2013, it has been submitted that Notification for conducting Social
Impact Assessment for the proposed expansion of Kangra Airport
was issued on 28.02.2023. However, SIA team visited the spot on
27.02.2023 and 28.02.2023, i.e., prior to issuance of Notification and
Publication of the same.
164. From the material on record, it is evident that possibility
of development of Kangra Airport by its expansion was being
considered since 2019, and vide Communication dated 07.10.2021,
it was formally communicated by the Airports Authority of India to
Principal Secretary (Civil Aviation) to Government of Himachal
Pradesh. Thereafter, Airports Authority of India had requested
Deputy Commissioner, Kangra, by Communication dated
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-98-


02.03.2022, to hand over the land adjacent to airport boundary, so
High Court of H.P.
that expansion work is taken up in future, and in continuation thereof,
vide Advertisement dated 11.02.2023, limited to empanelled Social
Impact Assessment partners/institutions, Expression of Interest
(EOI) and financial bids for conducting Social Impact Assessment
study were invited with last date of submission as 14.02.2023 and
bids were opened on 15.02.2023, wherein SR Asia was
recommended as an agency to be hired for Social Impact
Assessment. On the same day, that is on 15.02.2023, request was
submitted by Social Impact Assessment Unit to Principal Secretary
(Civil Aviation) to Government of Himachal Pradesh for undertaking
of Social Impact Assessment study in respect of expansion of
Kangra Airport at Gaggal. Therefore, though formally work was
awarded to SR Asia vide Communication dated 03.03.2023,
however, it was well within knowledge of SR Asia and all concerned
that it was the institution recommended by the Social Impact
Assessment Unit to be hired for Social Impact Assessment. It is true
that Notification for conducting Social Impact Assessment was
issued on 28.02.2023, but it was finalized on 27.02.2023. In
aforesaid facts and circumstances, there is every possibility that
officials from SR Asia were in touch with the concerned authorities
with regard to progress in the work, including issuance of Notification
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-99-


dated 28.02.2023 as well as recommendation and award of work to
High Court of H.P.
it, and in such situation, visiting by SIA team on the spot on
27.02.2023 and 28.02.2023 is by no means indicate any violation of
law as alleged. It is also apt to record that there is no material on
record to establish that SIA team visited the spot on 27.02.2023 or
28.02.2023. Further, except visiting the spot/village, no other activity
undertaken by SR Asia has been alleged.
165. The petitioner has also failed to establish any prejudice
caused to the Committee or public at large because of the spot visit
by the team of SIA on 27.02.2023 and 28.02.2023. No report has
been submitted on the basis of such visit, but the impact assessment
survey has been completed by SR Asia by conducting public hearing
after public notices.
166. It is also a matter of record that for commenting upon,
either accepting or rebutting, the plea of the petitioner with respect
to the methodology adopted and conduct of SR Asia and grounds
of appraisal by the Multi-Disciplinary Expert Group as well as
competency and expertise of its Technical Members, the
appropriate person/entity would have been SR Asia and the Multi-
Disciplinary Expert Group, but they have not been arrayed as
parties to the writ petition. Otherwise also, from material on record,
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-100-


including the response of the respondents, it is evident that no fault
High Court of H.P.
can be found in SR Asia's impact assessment report, which has
been considered and deliberated by the Multi-Disciplinary Expert
Group before recommending the expansion of the airport in its
appraisal report.
167. Referring Section 4(4)(e) of LARR Act, it has been
alleged that three alternative site locations were available for
constructing new airport, which would displace the least number of
families. Firstly, the Airports Authority of India was and is seeking
land adjacent to existing airport for expansion of airport. It is not a
project of new airport. Expansion of existing airports, have been
considered by the Committee constituted by the Central
Government, Civil Aviation Ministry, for additional safety measures
by expanding existing airport, wherein Kangra Airport has also been
included. Therefore, suggestion to shift the entire airport or to
construct a new airport in alternative site, clearly depicts non-
application of mind. Plea taken by the petitioner-Committee by
referring Para No. 18 of Chapter 10 of SIA report regarding
alternative sites is also misconceived, as in Para 1.5 of Chapter-1 of
its report, SIA team has suggested to select suitable alternative site
for project, but only after suggestions for technical team for site
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-101-


selection, and thereafter, report was considered by Multi-Disciplinary
High Court of H.P.
Expert Group, and appraisal report of the Expert Group was
submitted to Government, wherein all issues, including public
purpose, potential benefits of project, vis-a-vis social costs and
adverse social impact, alternative sites, have been duly considered
by the Expert Group. Expert Group has concluded and
recommended that apparently the project to expand existing Kangra
Airport serves the public purpose; the potential benefits of the project
outweigh the social costs and adverse social impact; there was no
less displacing option available with effective R&R plan, which could
be chosen to complete the said project. therefore, as per the
technical clearance of the proposal by Airport Authority of India to
expand existing Kangra airport after constructing a bridge across
Manjhi Khad was the only option left; Extent of Land proposed to be
acquired for the expansion of Kangra Airport calculated to be 147-
75-47 hectare is bare minimum extent required for the project; and
thus, the proposed project served the public purpose. Secondly,
despite adverse social impact and adverse social costs, the potential
benefits outweighed them; and the Expert Group has no hesitation
in recommending the project because besides fulfilling the public
interest considerations, its potential benefits would outweigh the
social costs and social impacts.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-102-


168. In its response, AAI has also rejected alternative
High Court of H.P.
proposed sites with submission that the present proposal of
Expansion of Runway is on same alignment which require the least
span of the bridge over Manjhi Khad. The re-orientation suggested
in Annexure P-7, is crossing through two branches of rivers Sarah
and Manjhi Khad, required to construct larger span of bridge which
may not structurally suitable to construct runway over it. The re-
orientation suggested such that even if the study on the alternative
proposal turns out to be financially viable for GoHP, technically it may
not be possible to carry out on an operational Airport.
169. In view of above material on record, it is apparent that
alternative sites being suggested by the petitioner-Committee are
not viable for expansion of airport. Two sites are far away and not
adjacent to existing airport, and definitely selection of those sites,
even if found suitable, would not have yield any result because
project of the Central Government is expansion of existing airport. In
case of shifting the airport to alternative sites, would have amounted
to shift the airport from present place to another place, situated at a
distance, which will be a project of construction of New Airport, for
which no proposal has yet been received either from Central
Government or Airports Authority of India.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-103-


170. Third proposal has also not been found suitable by the
High Court of H.P.
Multi-Disciplinary Committee as well as AAI on account of
topographical condition and situation on that site. This Court
cannot replace its opinion or petitioner’s opinion to the opinion of
expert body involved in task of expansion of airport, including
Airports Authority of India. Therefore, plea of petitioner to shift
airport to alternative site or realign/reorient the expansion, is not
sustainable.
171. Alternative sites have been considered by the Social
Impact Assessment report as well as the appraisal thereof, and
reasons for rejection of such proposal have also been given in the
response filed by the AAI, but the same is not under challenge.
172. With respect to plea of alternative sites, it is also relevant
to consider that it is not a case of construction or establishment of a
new airport, but the fact remains that there is an existing airport and
the Central Government has considered it fit for expansion, and it
has been included in the nine airports recommended by the
Committee constituted by the Central Government. Therefore,
suggestions of alternative sites, which would be amounting to the
construction of a new airport, are not acceptable, because in such
an eventuality Kangra Airport will be out of the list of the airports
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-104-


selected for expansion, and for establishment of a new airport there
High Court of H.P.
is no sanction of the concerned authority, and shifting of the airport
to another place would not be possible in the near future.
173. Multi-Disciplinary Expert Committee has considered the
purpose going to be served by expansion of airport in detail and the
material and information placed on record by respondents is also
sufficient to hold that expansion of airport is definitely in the larger
interest of public, and plea, that cost of expansion has not been
compared or estimated with the benefit to be achieved and loss to
be caused in monetary terms as well as social impact on account of
displacement, is not relevant, as everything cannot be calculated in
terms of money.
174. Plea of petitioner-Committee that expansion of airport
is being done for benefiting the elite or high profile class of society is
also misconceived, because as on date, maximum number of air
travellers in India are from middle class or lower middle class and
even the labour class is also travelling by air to reach their
destination at the earliest and it is possible only because of
affordable air fare due to frequency of air flights. It is apparent that in
case airport is expanded, bigger planes would be able to land and
take off, and definitely higher the number of passengers, lower the
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-105-


cost of traveling, which would be definitely beneficial to all classes of
High Court of H.P.
society and, thus, the plea taken by petitioner-Committee is not only
unsustainable, but absurd.
175. Plea with regard to violation of mandate of Section
10(1) and 10(2), providing that no irrigated multi-cropped land shall
be acquired under the Act, and such multi-crop irrigated land may be
acquired under exceptional circumstances as a demonstrable last
resort, is also not sustainable because from the material on record,
as discussed supra, it is evident that the expansion of airport is in a
larger interest of public, and expansion cannot be shifted to a land
not adjacent to the airport, and therefore, there is no other option
except to utilize the land adjacent to the airport irrespective of its
category or classification for expansion of the airport in the larger
public interest.
176. To substantiate the plea that no defence purpose is
going to be served by expansion of Kangra Airport, petitioner-
Committee has relied upon Communication dated 13.04.2018 issued
by Wing Commander, J.D. Operations (ATS), whereby it has been
informed that Indian Air Force (IAF) has no plans to expand Kangra
Airport. Response of the respondent-State demolishes this plea, as
it has been clarified in the reply that Kangra Airport is maintained by
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-106-


Airports Authority of India, but not by the Indian Air Force, and
High Court of H.P.
therefore, there is no question of any plan with the Indian Air Force
for expansion of Kangra Airport.
177. No one can dispute that Kangra Airport is nearer to the
international border, and in an emergency it can be used for Air
Force operations at the time of war. From record it is evident that it
is being used by Indian Air Force for mock drill as well as military
exercises. Therefore, this airport has also military strategic
importance.
178. With regard to aforesaid plea, it is also apt to record that
letter relied upon by the petitioner-Committee was issued on
13.04.2018, whereas proposal of expansion of Kangra Airport has
been initiated by Civil Aviation Ministry in the year 2019.
Respondent-State has also placed on record Communications
dated 11.07.2019, indicating that in the year 2019, Kangra Airport
was being used for Indian Air Force drill.
179. Respondent-State has also placed on record Letter
dated 25.08.2023 and 30.08.2023 received from Wing Commander,
Senior Air Traffic Control Officer, addressed to Airport Director,
Gaggal Airport, whereby it has been intimated that Air Force exercise
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-107-


was planned at Gaggal airfield on 12.09.2023, depicting that Kangra
High Court of H.P.
Airport is being used for operations of Indian Air Force aircraft.
180. With material on record, including aforesaid
Communications, clearly depicts the importance of Kangra Airport to
be used by the Defence Forces, including the Indian Air Force, and
expansion of which will definitely enhance the possibilities of landing
and taking off of the modern fighting aircraft as well as transport
aircrafts of the Indian Air Force. Therefore, on this count also, plea
of the petitioner-Committee is not acceptable.
181. Plea with regard to violation of Section 7 in constituting
Multi-Disciplinary Expert Group on the ground the members of
Expert Group were and are already part and parcel of acquisition
proceedings, and thus, the group is not an independent agency, is
also not sustainable because the land is not being acquired by the
State for itself or by the persons involved in acquisition for their
personal gain or their personal department. In both capacities, they
are performing their official function, which are independent of each
other. Unless any mala fide or personal interest in the expansion of
airport of the members of the Expert Group is brought on record, it
cannot be said that merely for the members were and are already
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-108-


involved in official capacity for acquisition of the land, the Expert
High Court of H.P.
Group loses its identity of independent agency.
182. Opposition of expansion of airport on the ground that
Kangra District is located in seismic zone and sinking zone, is also
not sustainable, as it is not a case of construction of new airport. The
airport is already existing, and the project of expansion of the existing
airport is being undertaken, and when airport is already functioning,
there cannot be any reason of preventing its expansion on the
ground that the area is situated in seismic zone. Otherwise also, it
has been submitted on behalf of respondents that at the time of
raising construction for expansion of airport, every care shall be
taken with regard to the location of the area in seismic zone and
sinking zone. It would also be apt to record here that District Bhuj in
Gujarat is also highly sensitive seismic zone/sinking zone, but the
airport has been constructed there, which is functioning in perfect
working condition. Thus, this plea of the petitioner-Committee is also
not sustainable.
183. In view of above discussion, plea with regard to
violation of Section 15(2) of the LARR Act is also not sustainable.
184. Plea with regard to violation of Fundamental Rights
guaranteed under Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution, is also not
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-109-


sustainable in the given facts and circumstances, as held by the
High Court of H.P.
Apex Court in case Estate Officer, Haryana Urban Development
Authority and Ors. vs. Nirmala Devi , referred supra .
185. Right of residence and livelihood envisaged under
Article 21 of the Constitution of India, cannot be a ground in cases of
land acquisition where land acquisition is inevitable in larger interest
of public. In present case, as evident from the material on record, the
expansion of Airport is in public interest, and acquisition for that
purpose is inevitable, and thus, opposition of expansion of airport on
this ground is not sustainable.
186. Objection with regard to the approval of Director
General of Civil Aviation is not relevant, as the expansion plan has
been submitted by Airports Authority of India only, and the process
has been initiated on the basis of recommendations of Committee
constituted by Civil Aviation Ministry of Central Government, and
such proposal has been made by identification of Kangra Airport,
suitable and necessary for expansion, as it has also come on record
that the Airports Authority of India has categorically stated that in
Himachal Pradesh, only Kangra Airport is suitable for expansion, but
not Kullu or Shimla Airport.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-110-


187. With regard to clearance in terms of EIA Notification
High Court of H.P.
2006 issued by Ministry of Environment and Forests, plea of the
petitioner-Committee is not sustainable for the reason that in
paragraph 2 of the said Notification, it has been provided that prior
environmental clearance shall be necessary for starting the project
or activity except for securing the land. Acquisition process is an act
for securing the land, and therefore, in view of the exception carved
out in the EIA Notification dated 14.09.2006 itself, plea of petitioner-
Committee regarding violation of relevant provision in this regard of
EIA Notification 2006, is not sustainable.
188. In case rejection of objections by the Land Acquisition
Collector was illegal, the aggrieved persons were having the right to
assail the same as provided in the scheme of the Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
and Resettlement Act, 2013, and in case there was no remedy
provided under the Act, such decision could have been assailed by
invoking the power of judicial review under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, but from the material placed on record, no such
challenge appears to have been laid by the any person, if someone
was aggrieved.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-111-


189. The total land proposed to be acquired for extension of
High Court of H.P.
Kangra Airport is 147-75-87 hectares, out of which 122-66-23
hectares is private land, and 06-10-68 hectares is forest land. There
is very less forest land involved in the project, whereas rest of the
land is owned and possessed by private owners.
190. Existence of schools, hospitals, and commercial
establishments has already been considered. Once the public
purpose for the project stands established and that the project is
required to be implemented in the larger interest of the public, the
other smaller interests have to give way for the larger public
interest.
191. Before parting, we would like to observe that though the
EIA Notification of 2006 permits that land can be acquired for any
project before environmental clearances, however, it has to be
considered by the respondent State that thousands of crores of
public money is likely to be spent for extension of the airport, and out
of that, more than Rs. 460 crores have been disbursed in sequel to
acquisition awards passed by the Land Acquisition Collector. But in
case of non-acceptance of the techno-economic feasibility report,
the entire public money shall be wasted. Therefore, irrespective of
the fact that the EIA Notification of 2006 provides a window for
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-112-


acquisition of land for any project before environmental clearances,
High Court of H.P.
however, there is a difference between public entities and private
entrepreneurs. A private entrepreneur may acquire or arrange land
for the project before environmental clearances and the TEFR
report, and on failure of getting environmental clearances, the private
entrepreneur can utilize the land for any other purpose, but it will not
be possible where the project proponent is a public authority
spending huge public money for the project.
192. Therefore, we would like to suggest, request, and direct
the respondent State to ensure completion of the TEFR report at the
earliest, and take appropriate steps for environmental clearances in
terms of the EIA Notification of 2006 immediately without waiting for
completion of the acquisition process, because otherwise also the
commencement of project work can be initiated only after having
environmental clearances, for which the TEFR report is a
prerequisite.
193. Needless to say that respondents shall ensure all
necessary clearances in terms of EIA Notification dated 14.09.2006
and also TEFR (Techno-Economic Feasibility Report) by taking
appropriate step for ensuring timely completion of expansion of
Kangra Airport.
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS

2026:HHC:49585
-113-


194. The writ petition is disposed of in above terms, along
High Court of H.P.
with all pending applications.
(Vivek Singh Thakur)
Judge


(Ranjan Sharma)
Judge
th
18 November, 2026
(Pardeep/Susheel)
::: Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 10:20:06 :::CIS