SMT SUBBAMMA (SINCE DECEASED) vs STATE OF KARNATAKA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 4 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R. NATARAJ
WRIT PETITION NO. 53842 OF 2014 (LA-BDA)
BETWEEN:
1. SMT. SUBBAMMA
(SINCE DECEASED)
2. SHRI. H.M. MUNINARAYANA
(SINCE DECEASED)
3. SHRI H.M. SURESH
SINCE DECEASED BY LR'S
3(a)
SMT. N. SHYALAJA
WIFE OF LATE H.M. SURESH
AGED 50 YEARS
3(b) SHRI H.S.CHIRANTAN
SON OF LATE H.M.SURESH
AGED 25 YEARS
3(c) SHRI H.S.KARTHIK
SON OF LATE H.M.SURESH
AGED 20 YEARS
4.
SHRI H.M. VENUGOPAL
SON OF LATE L. MUTHAPPA,
AGED 53 YEARS,
5. SMT. CHANDRAKALA
SON OF LATE H.M. BHAGAVAN,
DAUGHTER-IN-LAW OF LATE L. MUTHAPPA
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
Digitally
signed by
HEMALATHA J
Location:
HIGH COURT
OF
KARNATAKA
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
ALL ARE RESIDENTS OF SY.NO.38/2,
ARAKERE GATE, BENNARGHATTA MAIN ROAD,
BEGUR HOBLI, BANGALORE SOUTH TALUK,
BANGALORE-560 076.
…PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. ARUN B M., ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY ITS SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF URBAN DEVELOPMENT,
MULTISTORIED BUILDING,
AMBEDKAR VEEDI,
BANGALORE-560 001.
2. BANGALORE DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
T.CHOWDAIAH ROAD,
BANGALORE-560020.
BY ITS COMMISSIONER.
3. SRI. S. BALAJI @ BALAJEE SUBRAMANIYAN
S/O SRI. S.A. SUBRAMANIAN
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
RESIDING AT NO.100, 'KOUDINYA',
TH TH
18 MAIN ROAD, 6 BLOCK,
BENGALURU-560095.
4. SRI. D.S.VEERAIAH
SON OF LATE SIDDAIAH,
AGED 69 YEARS,
RD
NO.73, BANASHANKARI 3 STAGE,
TH
AVALAHALLI, 8 MAIN ROAD,
GIRINAGAR,
BANGALORE-560016.
5. SRI. P. SUKHANAND SHETTY
SON OF SHRI P.A.SHETTY,
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS,
NO.326, 'SUKHANAND',
TH TH
10 CROSS, 4 MAIN,
VIJAYA BANK LAYOUT,
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
BANNERGHATTA ROAD,
BANGALORE-560076.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. POOJA M. KOORSE, HIGH COURT GOVERNMENT PLEADER
FOR RESPONDENT NO.1;
SRI. UNNIKRISHNAN M., ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO.2;
SRI. G.V.SUDHAKAR, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO.3;
SRI. Y.V.PRAKASH, ADVOCATE FOR SRI. Y.K.NARAYANA SHARMA,
ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NOS.4 AND 5)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DECLARE THAT THE
PRELIMINARY NOTIFICATION ISSUED UNDER SECTION 17 OF BDA
ACT BEARING NO.BDA/ALAO/A5/18/87-88 DATED 08.09.1987,
PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL GAZETTE ON 11.02.1988 VIDE
ANNEXURE-A IN SO FAR AS THE PETITIONERS LAND BEARING
SY.NO.16/3, MEASURING 39 GUNTAS (INCLUDING 2 GUNTAS
KHARAB) AT SL.NO.50 AND SY.NO.21/1A, MEASURING 16 GUNTAS
(INCLUDING 2 GUNTAS KHARAB) OF HULIMAVU VILLAGE, BEGUR
HOBLI, BANGALORE SOUTH TALUK, BANGALORE DISTRICT AT
SL.NO.56 AND THE FINAL NOTIFICATION ISSUED UNDER SECTION
19 OF THE BDA ACT, BEARING NO.HUD/231/MNX/90, DATED
28.07.1990 PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL GAZETTE ON 28.07.1990,
VIDE ANNEXURE-B, IN SO FAR AS THE AFORESAID LANDS OF THE
PETITIONERS AT SL.NO.44 AND 50 AS HAVING LAPSED UNDER THE
PROVISIONS OF SECTION 24(2) OF THE ACT, 2013, AS NO
PHYSICAL POSSESSION IS TAKEN AND COMPENSATION HAS NOT
BEEN PAID, FROM THE DATE OF THE AWARD SAID TO HAVE BEEN
PASSED ON 11.10.1993, IN RESPECT OF SY.NO.16/3 AND FROM THE
DATE OF AWARD SAID TO HAVE BEEN PASSED ON 08.06.1993, IN
RESPECT OF SY.NO.21/1A AND ETC.
THIS PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR
ORDER ON 04.08.2026 AND COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF
ORDER THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:-
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R. NATARAJ
CAV ORDER
The petitioners have sought for a declaration that the
preliminary notification bearing No.BDA/ALAO/A5/18/87-88
dated 08.09.1987 published in the official gazette on
11.02.1988 in so far as the land bearing Sy.No.16/3 and
Sy.No.21/1A, measuring 39 guntas including 2 guntas kharab
and 16 guntas including 2 guntas kharab respectively, both
situate at Hulimavu Village, Begur Hobli, Bengaluru South
Taluk, Bengaluru District and the final notification bearing
No.HUD/231/MNX/90 dated 28.07.1990 published in the official
gazette on 28.07.1990 in so far as the aforesaid lands are
concerned, have lapsed under Section 24(2) of the Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (henceforth referred
to as 'Act, 2013'). They have also sought for a direction to the
respondents to de-notify Sy.No.16/3 measuring 39 guntas and
Sy.No.21/1A measuring 16 guntas of Hulimavu Village, Begur
Hobli, Bengaluru South Taluk in the light of the materials
placed by applying the judgment of the Division Bench of this
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
Court in The Commissioner BDA and others vs. State of
Karnataka by its Secretary and others [ILR 2006 KAR
318] and the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Bondu Ramaswamy and Others vs. Bangalore
Development Authority and others [(2010) 7 SCC 129] .
2. (i) The petitioners contend that the petitioner
No.1 is the wife and petitioner Nos.2 to 4 are the sons of late L.
Muthappa and the grandsons of late Lakshmaiah. The petitioner
No.5 is the wife of deceased - H.M. Bhagavan, who was one of
the sons of late L. Muthappa. They contend that they were the
owners of the land bearing Sy.Nos.16/3 and 21/1A of Hulimavu
village, Begur Hobli, Bengaluru South Taluk, Bengaluru. They
contend that in the year 1987, the respondent No.2 issued a
preliminary notification dated 08.09.1987 under Section 17 of
the Bangalore Development Authority Act, 1976 (henceforth
referred to as 'BDA Act') proposing to acquire 805 acres 21
guntas including the aforesaid lands for the purpose of
formation of 'Byrasandra, Tavarekere, Madivala VI Stage
Layout' (for short 'BTM VI Stage layout'). Pursuant thereto, a
final notification dated 28.07.1990 was published in respect of
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
562 acres 34 guntas. As far as Hulimavu village is concerned,
the preliminary notification was in respect of 524 acres 9
guntas, while the final notification was in respect of 388 acres 9
guntas, which included the Hulimavu tank which measured 124
acres 25 guntas. The petitioners contend that the respondent
No.2 never came near the land bearing Sy.Nos.16/3 and 21/1A
and never took possession of the aforesaid land either from the
petitioners or their predecessors in interest. They contend that
they are in possession of the aforesaid land without any
disturbance by anybody. However, when it was proposed by all
concerned for expansion of the road running in front of
Sy.No.21/1A, at the intervention of the petitioner No.2, all the
landowners throughout including those landowners whose lands
were not part of the development scheme, agreed to leave bits
of their lands voluntarily as it benefited everybody. The
petitioners also left 5 guntas of land in Sy.No.21/1A for the
aforesaid purpose voluntarily.
(ii) The petitioners contend that in the year 2005, there
was interference by the respondent No.2 in respect of the land
in Sy.No.16/3 and in that regard, the petitioner No.4 filed
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
O.S.No.2628/2005 against the respondent No.2 for perpetual
injunction. Initially, an interim order of status-quo was passed
on 13.04.2005, which was continued from time to time.
However, the suit was dismissed vide judgment and decree
dated 01.04.2011. An appeal filed therefrom in RFA
No.1215/2011 was also dismissed on the ground that the suit
for injunction is not maintainable in respect of a land which is
notified. The petitioners contend that they were thereafter
advised that the scheme is not implemented within five years
as contemplated under the BDA Act and therefore the scheme
had lapsed. Based upon this, the petitioner Nos.2 to 4 and their
brother late Sri. H.M. Bhagavan filed W.P.Nos.25277-
25280/2012 before this Court. The respondent No.2 filed
objections and after hearing the parties, the writ petitions were
dismissed in terms of the order dated 06.02.2013 on the
ground that the petitioners had filed the petitions belatedly
challenging the acquisition of the year 1987. This Court while
dismissing the writ petition, relied upon the statement of the
counsel for the respondent No.2 that possession of the land in
Sy.Nos.16/3 and 21/1A was taken over on 22.03.1994. The
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
petitioners contend that the respondent No.2 did not produce
any documents in support of its case that physical possession
of the properties were taken. They contend that since the
possession of the property was not taken, the judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Offshore Holdings (P) Limited vs.
Bangalore Development Authority [(2011) 3 SCC 139]
squarely applied and the writ petitions should have been
allowed. They contend that they were advised to then challenge
the order passed by the learned Single Judge in
W.P.Nos.25277-25280/2012 before the Division Bench in
W.A.Nos.2097-2100/2013. However, the Division Bench also
dismissed the appeals vide its judgment dated 21.11.2013 on
the ground that possession of the land was taken over on
22.03.1994 and hence, the petitions filed before the learned
Single Judge were belated.
(iii) Petitioners contend that when they were proposing
to challenge the judgment of the Division Bench before the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Parliament passed the Act, 2013
and certain provisions were made therein safeguarding the
interests of landowners similar to the petitioners and therefore,
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
a new cause of action arose for them to challenge the
acquisition. The Act, 2013 came into effect from 01.01.2014
and that they continued in possession of the aforesaid lands
notwithstanding the claim of the respondent No.2 that an
award was passed in respect of Sy.No.16/3 on 11.10.1993 and
Sy.No.21/1A on 08.06.1993. They contend that they had
placed on record the orders of de-notification issued by the
State Government in W.P.Nos.25227-25280/2012 to establish
that the scheme was not implemented as provided under
Section 27 of the BDA Act. They contend that they were given
to understand that if they were able to demonstrate that large
extents of land are either deleted between preliminary and final
notification or de-notified after final notification or left out as
fully developed or if the acquisition was set aside, then in such
an event if they showed that they were similarly placed and
there was discrimination etc., they were entitled to challenge
the acquisition. In this regard, they contend that the Division
Bench of this Court in The Commissioner, BDA and others
[ILR 2006 KAR 318], referred supra and the judgment of the
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
Hon'ble Apex Court in Bondu Ramaswamy and others,
referred supra, were squarely applicable.
(iv) The petitioners contend that they made enquiries
and faced hurdles at every stage and after an elaborate effort,
they secured additional documents and information which show
that initially 524 acres 9 guntas was proposed for acquisition in
Hulimavu village in the preliminary notification, out of which
135 acres 12 guntas was deleted and only 388 acres 9 guntas
was notified including 124 acres 25 guntas of Hulimavu tank.
They also represented to the then Hon’ble Chief Minister in
terms of a letter dated 24.08.2006 and the former Prime
Minister by letter dated 06.06.2007 requesting them to de-
notify the subject lands. However, they have not received any
information from the addressees. They contend that they were
furnished with an internal correspondence between the
respondent No.1 and respondent No.2 dated 21.06.2011,
wherein the Deputy Commissioner (Land Acquisition) of the
respondent No.2 had informed the Principal Secretary of the
respondent No.1 that the subject lands were notified for
acquisition in terms of the preliminary and final notifications,
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
referred supra and that possession is handed over to the
Engineering section on 22.03.1994 for formation of the layout
and that they are required for the layout of the respondent
No.2. They contend that the Deputy Commissioner (Land
Acquisition) had however informed that no notification under
Section 16(2) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 was issued.
They contend that the fact of taking possession on 22.03.1994
is therefore misleading as the petitioners continue in possession
of the subject lands.
(v) The petitioners contend that the respondent No.1
has de-notified several lands by notifications dated 29.09.2007,
05.06.2010, 07.08.2010, 13.09.2010 running into several acres
of land. The respondent No.2 had also prepared a statement
showing the lands de-notified from 01.01.1995 to 29.09.2010.
The respondent No.2 had also prepared a status of the land
handed over to its Engineering section which showed that out
of 388 acres acquired in the final notification, only 117 acres 1
gunta was handed over to the Engineering section and layout is
formed only in 31.01 acres. It was also stated that 85.99 acres
is built up over a period of time. They contend that several
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
owners had challenged the acquisition proceedings and this
Court had passed orders in several matters quashing the
acquisition proceedings including in respect of the lands
adjacent to the lands in question. Attention of Court is drawn to
the order dated 16.12.2013 passed in W.P.Nos.17421-
17432/2012 and connected matters and the order dated
06.03.2014 passed in W.P.Nos.57428-57430/2013. It is
contended that the respondent No.2 then issued endorsements
dated 09.05.2014 and 12.08.2014 to the effect that the
acquisition proceedings in respect of the lands forming part of
the aforesaid petitions and others are abandoned. Based on the
above information, the petitioners got prepared a sketch
indicating the lands notified, the lands excluded from
acquisition, the lands de-notified, etc. They contend that the
respondent No.2 itself acknowledged the fact that layout is
formed only in 31 acres 2 guntas in Hulimavu village. However,
they contend that the layout formed is only in respect of 5
acres 30 guntas in Sy.No.54 and a few allottees have
constructed houses therein. They contend that there are
constructions in portions of the subject lands and the same is
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
evident from the revenue records. It is thus contended that the
lands situate around the subject lands are either deleted or de-
notified or acquisition proceedings are quashed and thereafter,
the respondent No.2 has abandoned the acquisition and the
same cannot be disputed by the respondents. They therefore
contend that the acquisition has lapsed and hence, the
petitioners are entitled to assail the notifications.
3. (i) The writ petition is opposed by the
respondent No.2 who has filed a detailed statement of
objections contending that the writ petition is filed after nearly
27 years from the date of the preliminary notification. It is
claimed that the land in Sy.Nos.16/3 and 21/1A of Hulimavu
village is acquired for the formation of BTM VI Stage. It is
contended that the petitioners had earlier filed W.P.Nos.25277-
25280/2012 challenging the notifications on the ground that
the acquisition had lapsed under Section 27 of the BDA Act.
The said writ petitions were dismissed on 06.02.2013 and the
learned Single Judge of this Court had specifically held that
there was no lapse of acquisition and that the petitions were
barred by time. Appeals preferred by the petitioners in
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
W.A.Nos.2097-2100/2013 were dismissed. It is also contended
that the Division Bench came to a conclusion that the
possession of the lands was taken over by the respondent No.2
on 22.03.1994 and that the contention of the petitioners that
they are in possession was suspicious. Therefore, it is
contended that the present petition is hit by the principles of
res judicata. Further, it is contended that the petitioners having
lost in the earlier round of litigation cannot come to this Court
again with new grounds in order to circumvent the orders
passed in the earlier writ petition.
(ii) It is also contended that the claim of the petitioners
that the acquisition had lapsed under Section 24(2) of the Act,
2013 is not maintainable as the provisions of the Act, 2013 are
not applicable to an acquisition under the BDA Act, as it is a
self contained Code. It is contended that since the Co-ordinate
Bench of this Court in writ petitions and the Division Bench of
this Court in the Writ Appeals, referred supra, had specifically
held that possession of the land in Sy.Nos.16/3 and 21/1A was
taken over, the question of de-notification of the said land
would not arise. It is contended that the respondent No.2 had
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
passed an award under Section 11 of the Land Acquisition Act,
1894, on 08.06.1993 and notice of the award was issued to the
petitioners on 03.11.1993 and possession of the land was taken
over which was evidenced by a mahazar. It is also claimed that
the compensation was deposited before the City Civil Court,
Bengaluru. It is contended that the notification under Section
16(2) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 was published on
16.06.1994 and hence, the acquisition in respect of land in
Sy.Nos.16/3 and 21/1A is complete and the land is vested in
the respondent No.2. It is also claimed that the respondent
No.2 has formed a residential layout over the land in
Sy.Nos.16/3 and 21/1A and has also allotted sites to various
allottees who are in possession.
(iii) It is contended that the petitioners have relied upon
the order dated 15.09.2017 passed by the learned Single Judge
in W.P.No.55991/2015 and the judgment passed in
W.A.No.6936/2017 and the dismissal of the appeal of the
respondent No.2 in SLP No.19776/2019. It is contended that
though the Division Bench had held that the scheme was not
implemented in toto and that the acquisition stood abandoned,
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
even then the acquisition of properties bearing Sy.Nos.16/3
and 21/1A of Hulimavu village, Begur Hobli, Bengaluru South
Taluk could not be de-notified. It is contended that by the
scheme lapses, the acquisition would not. Even if it is held in
some writ petitions that the scheme of BTM VI Stage has
lapsed, the acquisition of the properties belonged to the
petitioners would not lapse, as it is the respondent No.2 which
is in possession of the properties, having exercised all rights as
planning authority, formed a layout over the same and allotted
it to various allottees. It is also contended that the provisions of
the Act, 2013 is not applicable and the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in the case of Bondu Ramaswamy, referred
supra, is also not applicable to the case on hand.
4. (i) The respondent No.3 has filed a statement of
objections contending that the respondent No.2 had passed an
award in respect of the lands in question on 08.06.1993 and
the award notices were served to the petitioners. Possession of
the lands in question was taken over on 16.11.1993 and
handed over to the engineering section of the respondent No.2.
The compensation was deposited before the City Civil Court on
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
27.09.1995. The respondent No.2 has addressed a letter to the
State Government stating that the award has been passed in
respect of Sy.No.21/1A and possession was taken over on
16.11.1993 and compensation was deposited before the City
Civil Court and a notification under Section 16(2) was issued on
16.06.1994. It is contended that after completion of the land
acquisition proceedings, the respondent No.2 formed a layout
in the land bearing Sy.Nos.16/3 and 21/1A. It allotted the site
bearing No.509 in favour of the respondent No.3 vide allotment
letter dated 12.11.1998. The respondent No.2 executed a
lease-cum-sale agreement dated 29.02.2000 in favour of the
respondent No.3 and he was placed in possession of the site so
allotted, which is evidenced by possession certificate dated
21.06.2000. The respondent No.2 has registered the khata of
the aforesaid site in the name of the respondent No.3. After
completion of the lease period, the respondent No.2 has
executed a deed of absolute sale dated 04.12.2013 in favour of
the respondent No.3.
(ii) It is contended that the site now lies within the
limits of the Brhuat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP),
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
which has registered the khatha in the name of the respondent
No.3 who has been paying the property tax. He contends that
he is in possession of the site mentioned above and on
08.09.2022, he had obtained a plan to construct a building in
the aforesaid site and he has started construction and he has
completed the basement floor. He contends that Site No.508
has been formed in Sy.Nos.16/3 and 21/1A of Hulimavu Village
and the said site was allotted to one Sri. Veeraiah who also
started putting up construction and he has completed the
construction of the ground floor. He contends that Site
Nos.507, 527 and 528, which are formed in Sy.No.16/3 and
Site No.526 which is formed in Sy.No.21/1A, are allotted to
different persons. It is contended that Site Nos.504, 505, 506,
529, 530, 531 and 532, are formed in Sy.No.16/2 which is
adjacent to Sy.No.16/3 and the said sites are allotted to
different persons. Similarly, Site No.510 is formed in
Sy.No.21/1B and 21/1C which is allotted. It is also claimed that
Site No.506 is allotted to T. Parthasarthy, site No.530 is
allotted to Sri. Raviraj Patil and site No.510 is allotted to Sri.
H.S. Venkataramaiah and that the allottees of Site Nos.504,
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
505, 506 have constructed buildings in the respective sites and
roads are formed in Sy.Nos.16/3 and 21/1A. Photographs
showing the roads etc., are placed on record as Annexure -
R22.
(iii) It is contended that the petitioners have filed the
writ petition suppressing the formation of layout in the land in
Sy.Nos.16/3 and 21/1A and the allotment of sites to various
persons. It is thus contended that the BDA has formed a layout
in the land bearing Sy.Nos.16/3 and 21/1A and the scheme is
substantially implemented. It is contended that one Sri.
Lakshminarayana filed W.P.No.38981/2014 to challenge the
acquisition proceedings in respect of land in Sy.No.21/1B,
which was allowed in terms of an order dated 29.03.2016. The
respondent No.2 filed W.A.No.4718/2016 which was allowed. A
review petition was filed in R.P.No.236/2021 which too was
dismissed vide order dated 20.09.2021. The petitioners also
had filed W.P.No.25277-25280/2012 challenging the very same
preliminary notification dated 08.09.1987 and final notification
dated 28.07.1990 which were dismissed. It is thus contended
that the petitioners cannot again challenge the very same
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
notifications precisely on the very same grounds and hence, the
writ petition is misconceived. Besides, this it is contended that
the petition is filed after nearly 24 years from the date of the
final notification. Hence, the petition is liable to be dismissed on
the ground of delay and laches. It is contended that petitioners
are claiming the benefit of the order passed in
W.P.No.57428/2013 against which W.A.No.1598/2015 was filed
and the Division Bench was pleased to allow the writ appeal
and remitted the case back to this Court for reconsideration.
Therefore, the petitioners cannot claim any benefit of the order
passed in W.P.No.57428/2013.
(iv) Without prejudice to the above contentions, the
respondent No.3 contends that the petition is liable to be
dismissed only on the ground that the second petition on the
same ground is not maintainable. They also contend that the
impugned notification is not issued under the Land Acquisition
Act, 1894 but is issued under the BDA Act and therefore, the
provisions of Section 24(2) of the Act, 2013 is not applicable.
5. The respondent Nos.4 and 5 have also filed a
statement of objections, reiterating the objections raised by the
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
respondent No.3. They contend that the respondent No.2 has
developed the land in Sy.No.16/3 and 21/1A and formed a
layout of sites and therefore, the said land is utilised by the
respondent No.2. They contend that the respondent No.2
allotted Site No.508 formed in Sy.Nos.21/1A and 16/3 of
Hulimavu village in favour of the respondent No.4 vide letter of
allotment dated 23.05.2011. A possession certificate was
thereafter issued on 22.07.2011 and possession of the Site
No.508 was delivered to the respondent No.4. The respondent
No.2 executed a lease-cum-sale agreement on 22.07.2011 in
favour of the respondent No.4 and thereafter, a sale deed
dated 20.01.2022 was executed in favour of the respondent
No.4. The khata of the said site is made out in the name of the
respondent No.4 and after the property was included within the
limits of BBMP, the name of respondent No.4 was included in
the municipal records and that the respondent No.4 has paid
the up-to-date tax. The respondent No.4 then entered into a
joint development agreement dated 05.02.2022 with the
respondent No.5 for development of the property and executed
a power of attorney dated 05.02.2022 in favour of the
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
respondent No.5. Based on the above, the respondent No.5
obtained a plan and license from the BBMP to construct a
building on the aforesaid site. The respondent No.5 has took up
construction of the building over the aforesaid site and that
parts of the structure have already been put up and
construction is in progress. Therefore, it is contended that the
petitioners cannot now assail the notifications, more particularly
when they had lost challenge on the same ground in the earlier
writ petition filed.
6. The learned counsel for the petitioners while
reiterating the contentions urged in the petition submitted that
the petitioners are entitled to assail the notifications on the
ground that the acquisition has lapsed notwithstanding
rejection of an earlier writ petitions on the same ground. He
contends that a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in
W.P.No.55159/2014, had specifically held that a cause of action
to challenge the notifications under Section 27 of the BDA Act is
continuous and that the petitioners can file any number of writ
petitions challenging the acquisition on the ground that the
same has lapsed. He contends that when all lands in and
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
around the land belonging to the petitioners are either de-
notified or excluded from acquisition, no useful purpose would
be served in continuing the acquisition of the lands in question.
In this regard, he relied upon the judgment of the Division
Bench of this Court in The Commissioner BDA and Others
[ILR 2006 KAR 318], referred supra and the judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Bondu Ramaswamy , referred
supra. He also relied upon the order dated 18.09.2017 passed
by a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in W.P.No.55991/2015 by
which the Co-ordinate Bench held that the acquisition for
formation of BTM VI stage had lapsed. He invited the attention
of the Court to a writ appeal filed by the respondent No.2 in
W.A.No.6936/2017 and the Division Bench vide its judgment
dated 16.08.2018 upheld the order of the Co-ordinate Bench in
W.P.No.55991/2015, which was confirmed by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in SLP (Civil) No.19776/2019. He therefore
contends that the acquisition for formation of BTM VI stage has
lapsed and hence, the petitioners are entitled to claim the
benefit. He also referred to the order dated 15.09.2017 passed
by a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in W.P.No.21831/2016
- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
and the judgment dated 11.12.2019 passed by the Division
Bench of this Court in W.A.No.3884/2014 and the order passed
in SLP (Civil) No.21136/2021, where the acquisition for
formation of BTM VI Stage was held to have lapsed. He
therefore, contends that the petitioners are entitled to assail
the notifications as they are in possession of the property and
the respondent No.2 has not implemented the scheme.
7. Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondent
No.2 submitted that the award in respect of land in Sy.No.16/3
was passed on 11.10.1993 and an award notice was issued to
the petitioners on 07.03.1994 and thereafter the compensation
was deposited before the City Civil Court. He contends that the
son of late L. Muthappa named Sri. H.M. Jayaram had
submitted a representation dated 23.09.2021 requesting the
payment of compensation. He therefore contends that the
petitioners cannot challenge the acquisition as the petitioners
have already acknowledged the acquisition. He also contends
that the possession of the land in Sy.Nos.16/3 and 21/1A is
taken over and hence, no indulgence can be shown to the
petitioners in this writ petition. Besides this, he contends that
- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
the petitioners having lost an earlier litigation on the very same
ground, are not entitled to challenge the acquisition again.
Hence the petition is liable to be dismissed with costs.
8. Learned counsel for the respondent No.3 and the
learned counsel for respondent Nos.4 and 5 reiterated the
submissions and contended that the respondent Nos.3 to 5 are
allottees of sites formed in Sy.Nos.16/3 and 21/1A and
therefore, no indulgence can be shown and that the respondent
No.2 has implemented the scheme in so far as Sy.Nos.16/3 and
21/1A and hence, the acquisition cannot be upset at the
instance of the petitioners at this point in time. They also
contend that they have put up constructions over the sites
allotted and hence, the petitioners cannot claim that they are in
possession of the aforesaid lands.
9. Learned counsel for the respondent No.3 has placed
on record the judgment dated 02.03.2021 passed by the
Division Bench of this Court in Ananthaswamy vs. The State
of Karnataka and others [W.A.No.1451/2018] , and the
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Chandragauda
Ramgonda Patil and another vs. State of Maharashtra
- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
and others [(1996) 6 SCC 405] in support of his contention
that land acquired for a public purpose can be utilized for any
other public purpose and restitution of surplus land cannot be
ordered. He also relied upon the judgment passed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Devilal Modi vs. State Tax Officer,
Ratlam and others [AIR 1965 SC 1150] to contend that
principles of constructive res judicata are applicable even to
writ petitions. He has also relied upon the judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of India and another vs.
Subhash Chander Sehgal and others [Civil Appeal
No.5439/2022] , where it was held that the provisions of the
Act, 2013 are applicable only when the compensation is not
paid and possession is not taken and that too only when the
acquisition is under the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act,
1894. He has also relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Offshore Holdings Private Limited,
referred supra, where it was held that on a conjunctive reading
of the provisions of Sections 27 and 36 of the BDA Act, it is
clear that when a scheme lapses, the acquisition would not,
and this would depend upon the facts and circumstances of a
- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
given case. He has also relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Bangalore Development Authority and
another vs. The State of Karnataka and others [Civil
Appeal Nos.7661-7663/2018] , which related to acquisition
of land for formation of peripheral ring road, where it was held
that the provisions of the Act, 2013 is only applicable to the
acquisition made under the provisions of the Land Acquisition
Act and not to acquisition made under the enactments in the IV
schedule.
10. I have considered the submissions of the learned
counsel for the petitioners as well as the learned counsel for
the respondent No.2 and learned counsel for respondent No.3
and the learned counsel for respondent Nos.4 and 5. I have
also perused the writ petition and the statement of objections
as well as the judgments relied upon by the respective counsel.
11. The fact that the petitioners had approached this
Court earlier in W.P.Nos.25277-25280/2012 challenging the
acquisition on the ground that it had lapsed under Section 27 of
BDA Act, is not in dispute. It is also not in dispute that the writ
petitions filed by the petitioners were dismissed and writ
- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
appeals filed thereagainst were also dismissed. Therefore, the
petitioners are now estopped by principles of res judicata from
again contending that the acquisition has lapsed. The reliance
placed by the learned counsel for the petitioners on the order of
a Co-ordinate bench of this Court in W.P.No.55159/2014 is not
convincing in as much as the cause of action to challenge the
acquisition on the ground that the acquisition has lapsed in
view of Section 27 of BDA Act arose soon after the expiry of
five years from the date of the final notification. In the instant
case, the petitioners having lost once, cannot again re-agitate
the same ground. This Court with all due respect is unable to
accept the finding recorded by a Co-ordinate Bench of this
Court that the challenge to an acquisition under Section 27 of
BDA Act, is a continuing cause of action. Therefore, the
contention that the petitioners are entitled to challenge the
acquisition for any number of times, is misplaced and is
accordingly rejected.
12. The petitioners though contend that they are in
possession of the properties in question, the documents placed
on record by the respondent Nos.3, 4 and 5 establish the
- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
contrary and it is evident that the respondent No.2 has formed
a layout in the land bearing Sy.Nos.16/3 and 21/1A of
Hulimavu village. The photographs placed on record by the
respondent No.3 would also establish the fact that the
respondent No.3 is placed in possession and that the
respondent No.2 has formed roads in the land in Sy.Nos.16/3
and 21/1A of Hulimavu village and provided other amenities.
Therefore, it cannot now lie in the mouth of the petitioners that
they are in possession of the land bearing Sy.Nos.16/3 and
21/1A. The petitioners have filed this writ petition on the
premise that the Act, 2013 gave them a new cause of action as
under Section 24(2) of the Act 2013, if the compensation is not
paid and the possession is not taken, the acquisition would
lapse. Therefore, the petitioners cannot now again fall back
upon Section 27 of the BDA Act to contend that the acquisition
has lapsed, as they have lost that ground. The Division Bench
of this Court has categorically held that the provisions of the
Act, 2013 is not applicable to an acquisition under the BDA Act,
as acquisition is incidental to town planning as held by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Bangalore
- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
Development Authority vs. R. Hanumaiah and others
[(2005) 12 SCC 508] . The petitioners therefore are not
entitled to any reliefs sought for in the writ petition and
therefore, the petition is liable to be dismissed.
13. Before parting, it is relevant to note that though the
acquisition was initiated in the year 1987, the award was
passed in the year 1993. In the meanwhile, the provisions of
the Bangalore Development Authority (Incentive Scheme for
Voluntary Surrender of Land) Rules, 1989 came into force in
terms of which, whoever had not challenged the acquisition
were entitled to allotment of a site. The petitioners had not
challenged the acquisition till the year 1989 and therefore, they
are entitled to allotment of an incentive site. This Court has
held in W.P.No.10936/2016 vide order dated 01.04.2024 that
the petitioners therein are entitled to an allotment of an
alternate site. Therefore, there is no reason why the petitioners
should be deprived of the benefit of allotment of an alternate
site as provided under the Bangalore Development Authority
(Incentive Scheme for Voluntary Surrender of Land) Rules,
1989.
- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
14. In view of the above, this petition stands disposed
off on the following terms:-
(i) The validity of the preliminary notification
bearing No.BDA/ALAO/A5/18/87-88 dated
08.09.1987 published in the official gazette on
11.02.1988 issued by respondent No.2 and
the final notification bearing
No.HUD/231/MNX/90 dated 28.07.1990
published in the official gazette on 28.07.1990
issued by respondent No.1, in so far as the
land bearing Sy.Nos.16/3 and 21/1A,
measuring 39 guntas including 2 guntas
kharab and 16 guntas including 2 guntas
kharab respectively, both situate at Hulimavu
Village, Begur Hobli, Bengaluru South Taluk,
Bengaluru District, is upheld.
(ii) It is also declared that the BTM VI Stage
layout scheme is implemented in respect of
land bearing Sy.Nos.16/3 and 21/1A of
Hulimavu Village and therefore, the petitioners
- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61368
WP No. 53842 of 2014
CNR: KAHC010027872014
are not entitled to assail the notifications on
the ground that the acquisition has lapsed.
(iii) As the acquisition is not under the provisions
of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 but under
the Bangalore Development Authority Act,
1976, the challenge to the notifications on the
ground that they have lapsed under Section
24(2) of the Act, 2013 is also rejected.
(iv) Since the petitioners are owners of 1 acre 11
guntas of land in Sy.No.16/3 and 21/1A of
Hulimvau village, the respondent No.2 shall
allot an incentive site as provided under the
Bangalore Development Authority (Incentive
Scheme for Voluntary Surrender of Land)
Rules, 1989, preferably in the same layout or
in any nearby layout.
Sd/-
(R. NATARAJ)
JUDGE
PMR/List No.: 1 Sl No.: 122