A. Velayutham vs The State Of Tamil Nadu Rep. By Its Principal Secretary To Government Labour And Employment(E2) Department And Ors
- Court
- Supreme Court
NON-REPORTABLE
2026 INSC 801
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL No. 1071 OF 2016
A. VELAYUTHAM …APPELLANT
VERSUS
THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU
REP. BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
TO GOVERNMENT LABOUR AND
EMPLOYMENT (E2) DEPARTMENT AND ORS. …RESPONDENTS
J U D G M E N T
DIPANKAR DATTA, J.
th
1. This appeal, by special leave granted on 8 February, 2016, is
directed against a judgment and order of reversal.
2. The dispute centres around the date from which the appellant is
entitled to regularisation of his service.
3. Name of the appellant along with others was sponsored by the local
1
employment exchange for appointment as a watchman in the office
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
MANIK KUMAR
Date: 2026.08.04
19:33:43 IST
Reason:
of the respondent no.3. Having succeeded in the process of selection,
1
District Employment O Ư icer, Tirunelveli
1
th
on 26 August, 1992, the appellant was appointed as “daily wages
watchman” on purely temporary basis. Appellant joined the post and
continued to serve as watchman without any blemish.
th 2
4. G.O. No. 22 dated 28 February, 2006 , was issued by the Personnel
and Administrative Reforms (F) Department in the Government of
Tamil Nadu. The order reads as follows:
1. The Hon’ble Chief Minister had announced during the Tamil
Nadu Government Officials Union and Government Servants and
Teachers Associations General Conference held on 08.02.2006, that
the services of employees working in various Government
Departments on daily wages basis who completed more than 10
years of service as on 01.01.2006 will be regularized.
2. Based on the announcement made by the Hon’ble Chief
Minister on 08.02.2006, the Government direct that the services of
the daily wages employees working in all Government Departments
who have rendered 10 years of service as on 01.01.2006 be
regularized by appointing them in the time scale to pay of the post in
accordance with the service conditions prescribed for the post
concerned, subject to their otherwise qualified for the post.
3. The Departments of Secretariat may, therefore, be directed to
pursue action to regularize the services of the daily wages employees
working in all Government Departments, who have rendered 10 years
of service as on 01.01.2006 as ordered in para 2 above, in
consultation with the respective Heads of Departments wherever
necessary. In special cases wherein relaxation of rules is required,
proposal shall be sent to Government.
4. The order issues with the concurrence of Finance Department
vide its U.O.No.985/FS/P/2006 Dated 28.02.2006.
5. Despite G.O. No.22 being plain and clear that daily wages employees,
working in all the government departments having rendered at least
st
ten years of service as on 1 January, 2006, be regularised, the
appellant’s service was not regularised immediately upon issuance
thereof; instead, his service was regularised in terms of Government
2
G.O. No. 22
2
th 3 th
Order No. 187 dated 17 September, 2010 with effect from 17
September, 2010, that is, after 18 years of continuous service
rendered by the appellant.
6. Aggrieved by the omission and / or neglect of the respondents to
th
regularise his service on completion of ten years with effect from 26
August, 1992, the appellant invoked the writ jurisdiction of the High
4
Court of Judicature at Madras. His writ petition was allowed by a
nd
Single Judge vide a judgment and order dated 02 July, 2012. The
Single Judge noted that writ petitions of several other similarly placed
daily-wages employees were allowed by coordinate Benches which,
5
in appeal, were upheld by Division Benches and such orders were
also not disturbed by this Court, resulting in regularisation upon
completion of ten years’ service. Accordingly, the Single Judge
proceeded to pass the following order:
7. On perusal of the above referred orders, it is evident that persons
similarly placed i.e., part Time Sweepers employed in government
Schools were granted regularisation of their services on completion
of 10 years of service by relaxing the rule whenever required in terms
of G.O.Ms.No.22, P&AR Department dated 28.02.2006 and they were
paid arrears of full time salary. The Government having passed such
an order has to be apply the same to all similarly placed persons
without any discrimination.
8. In the light of the above cited decisions, the writ petition is allowed
and the Impugned order in G.O.Ms.No.187, Labour and Employment
(E2) Department dated 17.09.2010 of the first respondent insofar as
it restricts the regularisation of petitioner’s services from the date of
the order, is set aside and the first respondent is directed to pass
orders regularising the services of the petitioner from the date of
completion of ten years of service with time scale of pay applicable
at the relevant period and pay arrears of salary to him. Necessary
3
G.O. No. 187
4
W.P. No. 11640 of 2012
5
one such decision being W.A. (SR) No. 75291 of 2009
3
revised order is directed to be passed by the first respondent within
a period of four months from the date of receipt of a copy of this
order. No costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition is
closed.
6
7. The order of the Single Judge upon being carried in appeal by the
respondents, they argued before the Division Bench that G.O. (MS)
7
No. 74 dated 27th June, 2013 , ought to be considered. Appellant
contended that on the date the writ petition was allowed, G.O. No.
74 was not in existence and, thus, need not be considered.
8. However, vide the impugned judgment and order dated 17th April,
2015, the Division Bench allowed the appeal and set aside the order
of the Single Judge. It is against such judgment and order that the
appellant obtained leave to appeal.
9. The Division Bench held that the choice of the effective date for
regularisation falls squarely within the policy wisdom of the
Government and that it cannot be deemed arbitrary or discriminatory
under Article 14 simply because the State chose the date of issuance
of G.O. No. 187 rather than backdating it to the completion of ten
years of service. Applying the ratio of the High Court’s own Full Bench
8
decision in S. Dhanasekaran v. Government of Tamil Nadu , it
was held that regularisation schemes take effect exactly from the
date the enabling G.O. is passed, confirming that the prospective
operation of G.O. No. 187 was legally sound to hold that the same
was in the nature of a clarification of G.O. No. 22; therefore, the
6
W.A. No. 14 of 2015
7
G.O. No. 74
8
2013 SCC OnLine Mad 3624
4
appellant’s case could only be considered in terms thereof. The
Division Bench of the High Court, thus, set aside the order of the
Single Judge reasoning that the order of regularisation of the
appellant’s service passed in accordance with G.O. No. 187 was just,
valid and proper.
10. Learned counsel for the respondents was called upon by us to justify
the impugned judgment. She relied on G.O. No. 74. Reliance was also
placed by her on the decision of this Court in State of Tamil Nadu
9
v. A. Singamuthu where this Court had the occasion to consider
G.O. No. 74 in some detail.
11. At the outset, we record having noted that the Division Bench did not
rely on G.O. No. 74 to record any adverse finding against the
appellant.
12. However, since we were referred to G.O. No. 74, we have read it and
are of the considered opinion that the same can have no application
on facts and in the circumstances of the present appeal.
13. First, G.O. No. 74 was issued not only after regularisation of the
th
appellant’s service with effect from 17 September, 2010 but also at
a point of time when his writ petition stood disposed of by the Single
Judge. Law is well-settled that the right of a party is determined by
the facts as they exist on the date the action is instituted unless the
statute or equity otherwise requires. Issuance of G.O. No. 74 after
9
(2017) 4 SCC 113
5
the appellant entered the portals of this Court cannot and did not
curtail his right.
14. Secondly, the reason necessitating issuance of G.O. No. 74 appears
in paragraphs 3 to 5 thereof which do not apply to the appellant.
15. Thirdly, G.O. No. 74 was issued to regulate services of daily wage
employees yet to be regularised; hence, reliance placed thereon is
wholly misplaced.
16. The decision in Singamuthu ( supra ) has been perused. Although this
Court read the words “full time” in G.O. No.22, with respect, we find
no warrant therefor. G.O. No. 22 does not refer to work rendered in
part-time or full-time capacity. The intention expressed in G.O. No.
22 admits of no ambiguity. Those employees working on daily wages
for more than 10 years and having requisite qualification for the post
on which they were working were assured of regularisation. Even if
we entirely agree with the decision in Singamuthu ( supra ), the same
does not aid the respondents since the appellant was not engaged in
voluntary part-time duties. His name was sponsored by the
employment exchange, he participated in a process of selection and
emerged successful. Part-time service was in no way involved.
17. Moving on to the decision in S. Dhanasekaran (supra), what we find
is that, factually, the Full Bench was called upon to deal with daily-
wage or consolidated-pay engagements lacking statutory sanction,
i.e., classic 'backdoor entries' where initial appointments bypassed
open competition and recruitment rules. Juxtapose this decision with
6
the case of the appellant before us: his initial induction in 1992 was
neither clandestine nor informal, having been channelled through the
local employment exchange against a sanctioned post. The State
cannot pick and choose – give one employee only prospective
absorption and give his peers retrospective regularisation after 10
years of service – and then hide behind the decision in S.
Dhanasekaran (supra) to avoid Article 14. To permit a rule of policy
conceived for illegal appointments to subvert the accrued equitable
rights of an employee recruited upon substantial compliance with the
relevant service rules would be to mistake form for substance.
18. Reverting to G.O. No. 22, we find that the stipulation is unambiguous.
st
The date 1 January, 2006, constitutes the cut-off date. Those daily
wage employees who had completed ten years of continued service
on or before such date were entitled to be regularised.
19. Submission of learned counsel that regularisation could amidst be
st
effective from 1 January, 2006, does not appear to us to be sound.
The interpretation sought to be placed is misconceived in view of the
several judgments of the same High Court which the Single Judge
relied on and which were not disturbed even by this Court. In our
considered opinion, the Division Bench was in error in its interference
with the order of the Single Judge.
20. We have earlier held why G.O. No.74 is not applicable here. For the
reasons aforesaid, it is also held that there was no valid reason for
the Division Bench to interfere with the order of the Single Judge. The
7
impugned judgment, thus, cannot be sustained and is hereby set
aside with the result that the order of the Single Judge shall stand
restored. Appellant shall be entitled to all the benefits in terms
thereof, which have to be released in his favour within three months
from date.
21. The civil appeal stands allowed. No costs.
………..……………………………J.
(DIPANKAR DATTA)
…….……..…………………………J.
(SHEEL NAGU)
NEW DELHI;
JULY 28, 2026.
8