Ghulam Ambiya vs Ajay Kumar Lahari
- Court
- Madhya Pradesh High Court
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91580
1 SA-2372-2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PRANAY VERMA
SECOND APPEAL No. 2372 of 2025
CNR No.: MPHC010663832025
GHULAM AMBIYA AND ANR
Versus
AJAY KUMAR LAHARI AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Mukhtar Ahmad - Advocate with Shri Mohd. Ruhban, Advocate
for the appellants.
Shri Arun Pandey - Advocate for the respondents.
Shri Ramji Pandey - Government Advocate for the respondent/State.
Reserved on 29.10.2026
Pronounced on:18.11.2026
JUDGMENT
1. This appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure has
been preferred by the appellants/defendants No.3 and 4, being aggrieved by
the judgment and decree dated 26/08/2025 passed in Civil Appeal
No.36/2025 by the 13th District Judge, Jabalpur, reversing the judgment and
decree dated 25/01/2025 passed in Civil Suit No. 8200214A/2015 by the
19th Civil Judge, Junior Division, Jabalpur, and decreeing the claim of
plaintiff / respondent No. 1 for declaration of his title to the suit plot,
permanent injunction restraining defendants from interfering with his
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: MOHD IRFAN
SIDDIQUI
Signing time: 19-11-2026
11:57:29
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91580
2 SA-2372-2025
possession over the same, and for mandatory injunction directing delivery of
possession of the land in their possession.
2. As per the plaintiff, defendant No.1 executed a power of attorney
in favour of defendant No. 2 on 05/01/2004. By a registered sale deed dated
31/03/2004, plot No. 20, area 20 ft. x 40 ft. = 800 sq. ft. of Khasra No. 32/8
was sold in favour of plaintiff, who was recorded over the same in the
revenue records. The plot of plaintiff is described by letters A, B, C, D and
marked by red colour in the map annexed to the plaint. The plaintiff started
making construction over his plot, but on 31/03/2004, defendant No. 2, by
including the land within the boundaries of plaintiff, executed a sale deed in
favour of defendant No. 3 on 25/05/2004 without mentioning any
boundaries. Defendants no.3 and 4 are pressurising him to sell his plot in
their favour and have not stopped despite requests by the plaintiff, and have
instead encroached over part of his land hence the suit has been instituted by
him.
3. The defence of defendant No.1 was that no power of attorney was
executed by him in favour of defendant No.2, which has even otherwise been
cancelled hence the sale deed executed in favour of plaintiff is without any
right, title, or authority. The defence of defendant No.2 was that on the basis
of a validly executed power of attorney in his favour, he has sold plots in
favour of different persons. The plot of plaintiff is No. 20. 4,800 sq. ft. has
been sold by him in favour of defendant No. 3 and 800 sq. ft. in favour of
plaintiff. He is still remaining with 1,208 sq. ft. of land. The defence of
defendants no.3 and 4 was that plaintiff has never purchased land from
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: MOHD IRFAN
SIDDIQUI
Signing time: 19-11-2026
11:57:29
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91580
3 SA-2372-2025
defendant No.1.
4. The Trial Court held that plaintiff is the owner of plot No.80, area
800 sq. ft., as shown by him in the plaint map and is in possession of the
same, but has not proved that defendants are interfering with his possession
over the plot and in consequence dismissed his claim for permanent
injunction and mandatory injunction. In appeal having been preferred by
him, the Lower Appellate Court modified the said judgment and decree and
has directed for delivery of possession of the encroached land in his favour
and has also issued permanent injunction in that regard.
5. By order dated 07/09/2026, the appeal was admitted on the
following substantial question of law:
"Whether in view of dispute between the parties being a
dispute as regards encroachment and/or boundaries it
was incumbent upon the Courts below to have
themselves appointed a local commissioner as
envisaged under Order 26 Rule 9 of the CPC for
demarcation of the suit land and submission of spot
inspection report?"
6. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have perused the
record.
7. From the pleadings of the parties, it is evident that the dispute
between them is as regards boundaries of the suit land and/or encroachment.
The plaintiff has contended that defendants no.3 and 4 have encroached over
his land with defendants no.3 and 4 contending that they are in possession of
their own land and have not encroached over any land of the plaintiff.
8. The said dispute ought not to have been decided by the courts
below without appointing a local commissioner as envisaged under Order 26
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: MOHD IRFAN
SIDDIQUI
Signing time: 19-11-2026
11:57:29
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91580
4 SA-2372-2025
Rule 9 of the CPC for demarcation of the suit land and submission of spot
inspection report. This issue has already been considered in detail by this
Court in Second Appeal No.23 of 2005 (Bagdiram vs. Ramsingh), decided
on 06/03/2025 in which it has been held as under:
10. Order 26 Rule 9. Commissions to make
local investigations.--
In any suit in which the Court deems a
local investigation to be requisite or proper for
the purpose of elucidating any matter in dispute, or
of ascertaining the market-value of any property, or the
amount of any mesne profits or damages or annual net
profits, the Court may issue a commission to such
person as it thinks fit directing him to make such
investigation and to report thereon to the Court:
Provided that, where the State Government has made
rules as to the persons to whom such commission shall
be issued, the Court shall be bound by such rules.
11. In Prembai V/s. Ghanshyam 2010 (3) M.P.L.J. 345
it has been held by this Court that if there is a dispute
about demarcation of the boundaries then in such a
situation it would be appropriate for the Court to
appoint a competent Commissioner and it is the law of
land which is to be followed. It was held as under :-
13. That apart, I do not find any merit in the contention
of learned counsel for the respondent No. 1/plaintiff,
that an application was submitted by plaintiff to appoint
the Commissioner which was vigorously opposed by
defendants and accordingly the learned trial Court
dismissed that application on 28- 7-1995 and, therefore,
now the defendants are estopped from raising this
ground. According to me, if there is a dispute about
the demarcation of the boundaries, the Supreme Court
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: MOHD IRFAN
SIDDIQUI
Signing time: 19-11-2026
11:57:29
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91580
5 SA-2372-2025
and this Court have interpreted the law as envisaged
under Order XXVI, Rule 9, Civil Procedure Code that
in such a situation it would be appropriate to the Court
to appoint a competent Commissioner and, hence, it is
the law of land which is to be followed and, therefore,
in these facts and circumstances, there cannot be
any estoppel against law. The substantial question
of law No. 1 is thus answered in favour of appellants.
12. In Loknath Gautam V/s. State of M.P. 2018
SCC Online MP 600 it has been held by this Court that
whenever there is dispute as to encroachment the fact
whether there is an encroachment or not cannot be
determined in absence of agreed map except by
appointment of a Commissioner under Order 26 Rule 9
of the CPC. It was held as under :
“16. The ancillary question is whether for
the purpose of determining the identity of
land orincase of boundary dispute power
under Order 26 Rule 9 can be exercised? This
point is no more res integra. The Division
Bench of this Court in the case reported in
1975 JLJ 440, [Durga Prasad v. P.Foujdar]
opined that in case where there is a dispute as
to encroachment, the fact whether there is
such an encroachment or not cannot
be determined in the absence of an agreed
map, except by the appointment of a
Commissioner under Order 26 Rule 9 CPC.
17. The Bombay High Court has consistently
taken the view that in cases of boundary
dispute and dispute about the identity of land,
courts should order local investigation under
Order 26 Rule 9 CPC. (See : (2004) 3 Mah LJ
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: MOHD IRFAN
SIDDIQUI
Signing time: 19-11-2026
11:57:29
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91580
6 SA-2372-2025
724, [Sukhdeo Parashramji Bhugul (Dr.) v.
Wamanroa Nagorao Charhat]; (2009) 6 AIR
Bom R (NOC 1033) 329, [Girish Vasantrao
Bhoyar v. Nimbaji Warluji Bambal]; (2010) 4
AIR Bom R (NOC 450) 127, [Yeshwant
Bhaduji Ghuse v. Vithabaji
Laxman Ladekar]; (2014) 1 AIR Bom R 16 :
AIR 2014 (NOC173) 59, [Malhar v. Shivaji]
and (2015) 4 AIR Bom R (NOC 3) 2, [Shyam
Janardam Chaoudary v. Asha Ramdas
Katkar]). Alok Aradhe, J in 2012 (III)MPWN
62, [Beejanwala Talukdar (Smt.) v.
Radhakrishna Rai] opined as under:
“6. The appellant in the plaint has stated that defendant
nos. 1 and 2 have taken possession of the land
belonging to him which has been marked with letters A,
B, C,D which forms part of Khasra No. 32. On the other
hand, defendants nos. 1 and 2 in the written statement
have denied the factum of encroachment and have
stated that they are in possession of the land which has
been purchased by the defendant no. 2 on 20-01-1976
which forms part of Khasra No.32. There is no agreed
map. In the absence of any agreed map, the trial
court could not have decided the issue of encroachment.
[See: Haryana Waqf Board v. Shanti Sarup, (2008) 8
SCC 671 and decision of Division Bench of this court
in the case of Durga Prasad v. Parveen Foujdar,
1975MPLJ 801]. For the aforementioned reasons, the
substantial question of law framed by this court is
answered in negative and in favour of the appellant.”
13. In Suman Pandagre V/s. Madhu Pandagre and
Others 2022 SCC Online MP 6030 it has been held by
this Court that application under Order 26 Rule 9 of the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: MOHD IRFAN
SIDDIQUI
Signing time: 19-11-2026
11:57:29
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91580
7 SA-2372-2025
CPC can be filed at any stage of the proceedings. It is
purely a legal question that can also be raised at the
appellate stage. It has been held as under :-
8. From the perusal of the aforesaid
judgments by the various Courts it is
apparently clear that the application under
Order 26 Rule 9 of CPC can be filed at any
stage of the proceedings even prior to the
defendants marking their presence before
the Court or at the final stage of the
proceedings. It is purely a legal question that
can also be raised at the appellate stage also.
The basic concept for filing an application
seeking appointment of Commissioner for
identity of a land in question or is there is
any boundary dispute or dispute with respect
to the maps or where there is dispute with
respect to encroachment, which cannot be
determined in absence of any agreed map
normally the Court should have appointed the
Commissioner. In the present case the civil
suit has been filed on the ground of
easmentrary right by the petitioner/plaintiff
stating that the by-lane is in existence and it
has been used by the plaintiff and his
forefathers since long. There is a
specific denial to the aforesaid aspect by the
defendants in their written statement. In such
circumstances, it is not a Government land or
a Government road that the identity of the
land is of a material aspect in the matter.
There is nothing on record to show that
the particular land is being identified as a
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: MOHD IRFAN
SIDDIQUI
Signing time: 19-11-2026
11:57:29
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91580
8 SA-2372-2025
disputed land in the matter. In such
circumstances, the application filed under
Order 26 Rule 9 of CPC should have been
allowed by the learned trial Court for
identification of the land in
question. Allowing such an application will
amount to substantial justice to the parties
and will also expedite the proceedings of the
civil suit.
14. In Jaswant V/s. Dindayal 2011 (2) MPLJ 576 it has
been held that when there is a dispute about
demarcation it is the duty of the Court itself to issue
commission by appointing an employee of Revenue
Department not below the rank of Revenue Inspector to
get the land in dispute demarcated and for its
identification no application is required for
that purpose.
15. In Vayathinattar and Another V/s. Sakkubai Ammal
AIR 2004 Madras 419 the dispute between the parties
was as regards demarcation. None of the parties filed
any application before the Courts below for
appointment of a local Commissioner. In such
circumstances it was held that the best evidence in cases
of such nature could have been obtained only by
appointment of a Commissioner and that the same was a
legal necessity and has to be complied with. Holding so
the judgment and decree passed by the Courts below
were set aside and the matter was remanded back to the
trial Court for appointment of a local Commissioner
as envisaged under Order 26 Rule 9 of the CPC. It was
held as under :
“17. None, particularly, the plaintiff who
claims that the suit property is lawfully
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: MOHD IRFAN
SIDDIQUI
Signing time: 19-11-2026
11:57:29
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91580
9 SA-2372-2025
belonging to her has been encroached upon
by the defendants and annexed to their lands
has filed an application for the appointment
of Commissioner to measure the property and
submit a report with sketch, and this Court
wonders as to why the plaintiff has
not resorted to file an application nor even
the defendants thought of in this line, as a
result of which the Courts have to arrive at
their own conclusions based on the paltry
evidence placed on record and, therefore,
since the best of evidence in cases of such
nature could have been obtained only by
appointment of a Commission
and ascertainment of the extent of lands in
possession and enjoyment of each party to
the contest, and since this legal necessity has
not been complied with, the lower Courts
have not been in a position to act with the
conclusive proof which could be relied upon
and, therefore, it is only desirable to do this
requirement which is absolutely necessary in
the case in hand and, therefore, needless
to mention that it is a case which has to be
remanded back to the trial Court for
observing this requirement in the
circumstances of the case and to give a
decision based on such report obtained and
hence, both the judgments rendered by
the trial Court and the first appellate Court
have to be set aside and the case remanded
for reconsideration and hence, the sole
substantial question of law has to be decided
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: MOHD IRFAN
SIDDIQUI
Signing time: 19-11-2026
11:57:29
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91580
10 SA-2372-2025
in the manner and with the following
result. In result
(i)
(ii) the case is remanded to the trial Court for
reconsideration in appointing a commissioner
and measuring the suit property and the
other properties surrounded by the suit
property so as to ascertain the facts regarding
the possession of the extent of lands by
parties and to file a report with sketch and the
trial Court shall decide on such additional
evidence placed on record also with further
opportunity for the learned counsel for
both to be heard and to decide the dispute on
merits and in accordance with law;”
16. In Baliram V/s. Melaram and Another AIR 2003 HP
87 it has been held that to issue commission under Rule
9 of Order 26 of the CPC it is not necessary that either
or both the parties must apply for issue of commission.
The Court can appoint local Commissioner suo moto if
it is deemed necessary that a local investigation is
required. If local investigation is requisite and proper it
should be exercised so that a final and just decision is
rendered in the case. It was held as under :
“13. Rule 9 of Order 26 of the Code of
Civil Procedure (hereafter referred to as 'the
Code'), empowers the Court to issue
commission to make local investigation
which may be required for the purpose of
elucidating any matter in dispute. Though the
object of the local investigation is not to
collect evidence which can be taken in
the Court, but the purpose is to obtain such
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: MOHD IRFAN
SIDDIQUI
Signing time: 19-11-2026
11:57:29
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91580
11 SA-2372-2025
evidence, which from its peculiar nature, can
only be had on the spot with a view to
elucidate any point which is left doubtful on
the evidence produced before the Court. To
issue a commission under Rule 9 of Order 26
of the Code, it is not necessary that either or
both the parties must apply for issue
of commission. The Court can issue
local commission suo motu, if, in the facts
and circumstances of the case, it is deemed
necessary that a local investigation is
required and is proper for the purpose of
elucidating any matter in dispute. Though
exercise of these powers is discretionary with
the Court, but incase the local investigation is
requisite and proper in the facts and
circumstances of the case, it should
be exercised so that a final and just decision
is rendered in the case.”
17. The principles which thus emerge are that if there is
a dispute about demarcation of boundaries or where
there is a dispute as to encroachment the fact whether
there is such an encroachment or not and for the
purpose of determining identity of land by local
investigation in absence of an agreed map, exercise of
power under Order 26 Rule 9 of the CPC
by appointment of a competent Commissioner is
necessary. In case of such a dispute best evidence can
be obtained only by appointment of a Commissioner
and ascertainment of the extent of lands in possession
or enjoyment of the parties. The same is the law of land
and is a legal necessity in absence of which the Court
would not be in a position to act with the conclusive
proof which could be relied upon. When there is a
dispute about demarcation, it is the duty of the Court
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: MOHD IRFAN
SIDDIQUI
Signing time: 19-11-2026
11:57:29
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91580
12 SA-2372-2025
itself to issue commission and it can issue
such commission suo moto also if in the facts and
circumstances of the case it is deemed necessary that a
local investigation is required for elucidating any
dispute in the matter. For that purpose no application is
required. It is not necessary that either or both the
parties must apply for issue of commission. An
application under under Order 26 Rule 9 of the CPC
can be filed at any stage of the proceedings even prior
to the defendants marking their presence before the
Court or at the final stage of the proceedings. It is purely
a legal question that can also be raised at the appellate
stage. Though exercise of power is discretionary but in
case local investigation is requisite and proper it should
be exercised so that a just decision is rendered in the
case since it is the duty of the Courts to ensure that
substantial justice is delivered to the parties."
9. In the present case also, the dispute between the parties is as
regards boundaries and/or encroachment. Such a dispute ought not to have
been decided by the courts below without appointment of a local
commissioner as envisaged under Order 26 Rule 9 of the CPC.
10. Resultantly, the substantial question of law as framed is answered
in favour of the appellants and against the respondents. The judgment and
decree passed by the courts below insofar as they have not appointed a local
commissioner under Order 26 Rule 9 of the CPC, are hereby set aside. The
matter is remanded back to the Trial Court for appointment of a local
commissioner under Order 26 Rule 9 of the CPC and obtaining a
commissioner's report and thereafter deciding the matter afresh in accordance
with law.
11. It is made clear that the parties would be entitled to lead evidence
only to the extent of the report to be submitted by the local commissioner.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: MOHD IRFAN
SIDDIQUI
Signing time: 19-11-2026
11:57:29
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91580
13 SA-2372-2025
However, it is clarified that the finding as regards plaintiff's title to the suit
land/plot as recorded by the courts below is not being disturbed and is being
maintained, since the same has not been challenged by the plaintiff.
12. The appeal is accordingly allowed. No order as to cost.
(PRANAY VERMA)
JUDGE
irfan
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: MOHD IRFAN
SIDDIQUI
Signing time: 19-11-2026
11:57:29