Pranay Aneja vs State Of U.P. And 4 Others

Court
Allahabad High Court

AFR
Reserved on 29.09.2026
Delivered on 19.11.2026
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
CRIMINAL MISC. WRIT PETITION No. - 29359 of 2025
Pranay Aneja
…..Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
…..Respondent(s)
with
CRIMINAL MISC. WRIT PETITION No. - 29357 of 2025
Ashwani Upadhyay
…..Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
…..Respondent(s)
with
CRIMINAL MISC. WRIT PETITION No. - 29358 of 2025
Upendra Govind Rao
…..Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
…..Respondent(s)
with
CRIMINAL MISC. WRIT PETITION No. - 29994 of 2025
Ravindra Kishor
…..Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of U.P. and 3 others
…..Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s) : Atul Khaneja, Subir Lal, Sr.
Advocate, Ram Prakash
Counsel for Respondent(s) : G.A.

2
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
Court No. - 48
HON'BLE CHANDRA DHARI SINGH, J.
HON'BLE TARUN SAXENA, J.
Per: Hon’ble Chandra Dhari Singh,J.
INTRODUCTION
1. The instant writ petitions under Article 226 of the
Constitution arise from the same first information report and the
same gang chart. They have accordingly been heard together and
are being decided by this common judgment. The petitioners seek
quashing of FIR No. 645 of 2025 dated 09.12.2025, registered at
Police Station Kotwali Dehat, District Saharanpur, under Sections
2(b)(i), 3(1) and 3/2 of the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-
Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 1986 (“the Act”), together with
the gang chart on which it rests and all consequential
proceedings.
2. The FIR names twenty-seven persons. Pranay Aneja
(Petitioner in WP No. 29359 of 2025) is described as the gang
leader. Ashwani Upadhyay (Petitioner in WP No. 29357 of 2025),
Upendra Govind Rao (Petitioner in WP No. 29358 of 2025) and
Ravindra Kishor (Petitioner in WP No. 29994 of 2025) are shown
as members.

3
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
3. Since all the afore-captioned writ petitions arise out of the
same Case Crime Number and involve common questions of fact
and law, the same have been heard together and are being
decided by this common judgment. For the purpose of the
present judgment, the brief facts, as noticed hereinbelow, are
those of Writ Petition No. 29359 of 2025, preferred by Pranay
Aneja.
FACTUAL MATRIX
The base case
4. Co-operative Company Limited (“the Company”) held a PD-2
licence for the manufacture of country liquor at its unit at Yusufpur
Tapri, District Saharanpur. On 03.03.2021, a joint team of the
Excise Department and the Special Task Force intercepted
container truck No. UP-11 BT-0935 carrying 1,500 cases of country
liquor from that unit. The allegation was that the truck was on a
second trip under a PD-25 pass and bar code issued on 01.03.2021
for a single consignment to a CL-2 wholesale licensee at Unnao.
Duty was allegedly paid on one consignment while two were
removed.
5. On the written report of the Assistant Excise Commissioner
(Enforcement), Meerut, two FIRs were registered on 04.03.2021 at
Police Station Kotwali Dehat, bearing Case Crime No. 97 of 2021
under Section 60 of the U.P. Excise Act, 1910, and Case Crime No.

4
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
98 of 2021 under Sections 420, 467, 468, 471 and 477-A IPC.
Sixteen persons were named, including Pranay Aneja, Upendra
Govind Rao and Ashwani Upadhyay. Ravindra Kishor was not
named. The petitioners assert that the unit was sealed on
03.03.2021 and no manufacturing or commercial activity has taken
place there since.
6. Vide order dated 04.03.2021 passed by the Additional Chief
Secretary (Home), investigation was entrusted to the State Special
Investigation Team (SIT). The cases were re-registered on
06.03.2021 as Case Crime Nos. 03 and 04 of 2021 at Police Station
SIT, Lucknow, and were later merged by order dated 27.05.2021 of
the In-charge District and Sessions Judge, Lucknow.
7. Between 30.04.2021 and 19.07.2024, ten charge-sheets
were filed under Section 60(2) of the Excise Act, Sections 120-B,
420, 467, 468, 471 and 477-A IPC, Section 66 of the Information
Technology Act and, as regards certain officials, Sections 7 and 13
of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. Cognizance has been
taken. The trial is pending as Case No. 881 of 2021 before the
learned Special Judge, P.C. Act, CBI (Central), Lucknow. Upendra
Govind Rao was charge-sheeted on 30.04.2021 and 31.05.2021,
Ashwani Upadhyay on 23.10.2021, Pranay Aneja on 21.02.2022
and again on 19.07.2024, and Ravindra Kishor, then an Excise
Inspector, was charge-sheeted on 26.04.2022. The trial stands

5
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
stayed qua two other accused, Rakesh Ahuja and Mayur Ahuja,
vide orders of the Lucknow Bench dated 07.03.2025 and
02.06.2025. Each petitioner is on bail in the main case.
Parallel Proceedings
8. On the same FIRs, the Directorate of Enforcement filed a
complaint under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 on
31.03.2024 and issued a provisional attachment order on
03.05.2024. Pranay Aneja has furnished bonds under Section 88
CrPC in those proceedings. Against him, an FIR under Section 174-
A IPC was registered on 22.11.2021 following proceedings under
Section 82 CrPC, in which he was granted bail on 28.03.2022.
9. As per the material on record, the Company's licence has
been the subject of a separate line of litigation. Apparently, a show
cause notice dated 06.03.2021 was followed by cancellation of the
PD-2 licence on 01.04.2021; this Court quashed the cancellation in
Writ Tax No. 738 of 2021 on 05.01.2022 for want of compliance
with natural justice. The licence was cancelled again on 04.05.2022
and the revision was dismissed on 07.11.2023. Vide judgment
dated 10.10.2025 in Writ Tax No. 169 of 2024, this Court set aside
those orders, directed the Excise Commissioner to furnish each and
every material proposed to be used against the petitioner within
fifteen days, and further directed that in case of failure to provide
the proposed material to the petitioner as indicated above, the

6
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
present proceeding shall be deemed to be dropped. A fresh show
cause notice dated 24.10.2025 was issued and the Company
replied seeking the material. As per the written submissions dated
29.09.2026 filed on behalf of the petitioners in WP Nos. 29359,
29357 and 29358, it has been submitted that a modification
application in Writ Tax No. 169 of 2024 was rejected with costs on
23.03.2026, that the State's SLP (C) No. 13074 of 2026 against that
order was dismissed on 04.05.2026, and that the licences were
renewed on 26.05.2026.
The SIT's recommendation in 2023
10. A committee/SIT chaired by the Principal Secretary (Home),
in which the Additional Chief Secretary (Excise) and the Director
General of Police participated, met on 16.06.2023 and accepted
Recommendations 1, 2, 5 and 6. The decision was conveyed on
26.07.2023. Recommendation No. 5 proposed a case under the Act
in District Saharanpur against nine persons: Pranay Aneja, Upendra
Govind Rao, Ashwani Upadhyay, Mayur Ahuja, Rakesh Ahuja, Ajay
Jaiswal, Manoj Jaiswal, Neeraj Jaiswal and Santlal Jaiswal.
Recommendation No. 2, concerning four excise officials including
Ravindra Kishor, proposed departmental action, consideration of
termination of service and an inquiry into assets.

7
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
The gang chart and the FIR
11. Thereafter, in December 2025, the Inspector-in-charge,
Police Station Kotwali Dehat, Saharanpur, prepared a gang chart
naming twenty-seven persons, as against the nine originally
recommended. Two persons, namely Rakesh Ahuja and Mayur
Ahuja, were excluded in view of their pending proceedings under
Section 482 CrPC, as recorded with reference to Rule 15(2) of the
Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention)
Rules, 2021. Twenty other persons were added, including company
employees, transporters, liquor licensees and four excise officials,
including Ravindra Kishor. The gang chart refers to only one
criminal case, namely Case Crime No. 03 of 2021, against all
twenty-seven persons. All are shown to be on bail and active across
districts. Against each person, the chart records in identical terms
that the possibility of committing further offences cannot be ruled
out.
12. The gang chart thereafter passed through various levels of
approval. The Inspector-in-charge recorded that he had examined
the gang chart and the relevant forms and found the particulars
correct, but his endorsement is undated. The Assistant
Superintendent of Police/Circle Officer recorded his satisfaction that
sufficient grounds existed for action under the Act. The Nodal
Officer made a similar endorsement. The Superintendent of Police

8
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
and the Senior Superintendent of Police also endorsed their
satisfaction. Finally, on 09.12.2025, the District Magistrate
approved the gang chart, recording that a joint meeting had been
held, the relevant records and criminal history had been examined,
and approval was granted upon consensus.
13. On the same day, i.e., 09.12.2025, at 23:15 hours, FIR No.
645 of 2025 was registered at Police Station Kotwali Dehat, District
Saharanpur, on the report of the Inspector-in-charge, under the
provisions of the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities
(Prevention) Act, 1986. The FIR substantially reproduces the
allegations relating to the incident of March 2021, describes the
gang as active at the State level, and states that the free movement
of the accused in society would not be in the public interest.
SUBMISSIONS
For the petitioners
14. Mr. Purnendu Chakravarty, learned Senior Counsel assisted
by Mr. Rishabh Chauhan, learned counsel for the petitioners
submitted, in substance, as summarised hereunder:
1
(i) that in Shiv Pratap Singh v. State of U.P. , the Supreme Court
has held that the Act creates no offence and that proceedings under
1 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1677

9
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
it cannot survive, and has applied that decision in Jyoti Suri v. State
2
of U.P. , by quashing an FIR under the Act;
(ii) that, independently, the gang chart was approved without the
application of mind mandated by Rules 5(3)(a), 16 and 17 and by
3 4
Vinod Bihari Lal v. State of U.P. , and Gabbar Singh v. State of U.P. ,
there are no minutes, the endorsements are identical, several are
undated, and the District Magistrate recorded only consensus;
(iii) that the allegations disclose no violence, threat, intimidation or
coercion, and so do not satisfy Section 2(b) read with Rule 3;
(iv) that the Act was invoked on a single incident of March 2021,
more than four and a half years later, shortly after an adverse
judgment against the Excise Department, and with twenty persons
added to the SIT’s list without reason; and
(v) that the individual position of each petitioner was never
considered.
For the State
15. The learned Additional Government Advocate, relying on the
counter affidavits, submitted:
2 SLP (Crl.) No. 9028 of 2026
3 2025 INSC 767
4 2026 INSC 271

10
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
(i) that a single offence suffices to invoke the Act, relying on the
5
judgments passed in Shraddha Gupta v. State of U.P. , Rinku alias
6 7
Hukku v. State of U.P. , and Kishan Pal v. State of U.P. ,
(ii) that the constitutional validity of the Act was expressly left open
in the judgment in Shiv Pratap Singh (supra);
(iii) that a joint meeting was in fact held on 09.12.2025 and that
the register bears the signatures of the District Magistrate and the
Senior Superintendent of Police;
(iv) that the accused operate as an organised gang at the State
level, that the scale of the duty evasion is large, and that members
of the public do not dare to depose against them;
(v) that the petitioners have criminal antecedents, including,
against Pranay Aneja, cases under Section 174-A IPC and the PMLA
proceedings, and against Ravindra Kishor, a case of 2006 from
District Basti; and
(vi) that the investigation is in progress, with statements of some
witnesses and documents yet to be collected, and this Court should
not interdict it.
5 (2022) 19 SCC 57
6 2001 (4) ACC 4614
7 2006 (54) ACC 1015

11
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
16. Heard learned counsel for the petitioners and the learned
Additional Government Advocate for the State. We have perused
the record, including the petitions before us, the counter and
rejoinder affidavits, the supplementary affidavits and the written
submissions filed on behalf of the petitioners in the instant set of
Writ Petitions.
QUESTIONS FOR DETERMINATION
17. Upon a perusal of the record before this Court, the following
questions arise for determination:
i. First, whether proceedings under the 1986 Act can be
maintained in view of the judgment passed by the Supreme
Court in Shiv Pratap Singh (Supra).
ii. Second, whether the allegations forming the subject matter
of criminal proceedings initiated in the year 2021 for alleged
evasion of excise duty, in which ten charge-sheets have
already been filed and cognizance has been taken, furnish a
legally sustainable basis for invoking the provisions of the
Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities
(Prevention) Act, 1986 against the Petitioners, nearly five
years thereafter.
iii. Third, whether the preparation and approval of the gang
chart, culminating in the registration of the impugned FIR,
were undertaken in accordance with the procedure
prescribed by law and upon independent application of
mind by the competent authorities.

12
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
THE PRINCIPLE OF QUASHING, OBJECT OF THE ACT AND
SECTION 111 OF THE BHARATIYA NYAYA SANHITA
18. Before delving into the submissions advanced by both the
parties, it is essential to first examine the foundational principles
that govern the quashing of complaints and criminal proceedings
at the threshold. The Supreme Court in the case of State of Haryana
8
and Ors. vs Ch. Bhajan Lal and Ors. , has laid down parameters for
the quashing of an FIR and the proceedings subsequent thereto.
The relevant paragraphs are reproduced herein below:
“102. In the backdrop of the interpretation of the various
relevant provisions of the Code under Chapter XIV and of the
principles of law enunciated by this Court in a series of
decisions relating to the exercise of the extraordinary power
under Article 226 or the inherent powers under Section 482
of the Code which we have extracted and reproduced above,
we give the following categories of cases by way of
illustration wherein such power could be exercised either to
prevent abuse of the process of any court or otherwise to
secure the ends of justice, though it may not be possible to
lay down any precise, clearly defined and sufficiently
channelized and inflexible guidelines or rigid formulae and to
give an exhaustive list of myriad kinds of cases wherein such
power should be exercised.
(1) Where the allegations made in the first information report
or the complaint, even if they are taken at their face value
and accepted in their entirety do not prima facie constitute
any offence or make out a case against the accused.
(2) Where the allegations in the first information report and
other materials, if any, accompanying the FIR do not disclose
a cognizable offence, justifying an investigation by police
officers under Section 156(1) of the Code except under an
order of a Magistrate within the purview of Section 155(2) of
the Code.
(3) Where the uncontroverted allegations made in the FIR or
complaint and the evidence collected in support of the same
8 AIR 1992 SC 604

13
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
do not disclose the commission of any offence and make out
a case against the accused.
(4) Where the allegations in the FIR do not constitute a
cognizable offence but constitute only a non-cognizable
offence, no investigation is permitted by a police officer
without an order of a Magistrate as contemplated under
Section 155(2) of the Code.
(5) Where the allegations made in the FIR or complaint are
so absurd and inherently improbable on the basis of which
no prudent person can ever reach a just conclusion that there
is sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused.
(6) Where there is an express legal bar engrafted in any of
the provisions of the Code or the concerned Act (under which
a criminal proceeding is instituted) to the institution and
continuance of the proceedings and/or where there is a
specific provision in the Code or the concerned Act, providing
efficacious redress for the grievance of the aggrieved party.
(7) Where a criminal proceeding is manifestly attended with
mala fide and/or where the proceeding is maliciously
instituted with an ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance on
the accused and with a view to spite him due to private and
personal grudge.”
19. It is also pertinent to revisit what the Act is meant to do,
and how Parliament has since chosen to deal with organised crime
in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023.
20. The Preamble to the Act reads, “An Act to make special
provisions for the prevention of, and for coping with, gangster’s and
anti-social activities and for matters connected therewith or
incidental thereto”. As evident, it is directed to the prevention of
gangsters and anti-social activities.
21. The Supreme Court in Shiv Pratap Singh (Supra) discussed
the Scheme of the Act at great length, as extracted hereunder:

14
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
“The Acts and the Rules
18. The U.P. Act as the preamble suggests, intends prevention
of and proliferation of gangsters and anti-social activities, as also
matters connected therewith and incidental thereto, a laudable
object indeed. Section 2 is the definition clause which, in addition
to the other definitions, defines ‘Gang’ & ‘Gangsters’. Sub-
sections (b) & (c) of Section 2 are extracted hereinbelow: -
“2. In this Act, —
(a) “Code” means the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973;
(b) “Gang” means a group of persons, who acting either
singly or collectively, by violence, or threat or show of
violence, or intimidation, or coercion or otherwise with the
object of disturbing public order or of gaining any undue
temporal, pecuniary, material or other advantage for
himself or any other person, indulge in anti-social
activities, namely —…
(i) offences punishable under Chapter XVI, or Chapter
XVII, or Chapter XXII of the Indian Penal Code, or
(ii) distilling or manufacturing or storing or transporting
or importing or exporting or selling or distributing any
liquor, or intoxicating or dangerous drugs, or other
intoxicants or narcotics or cultivating any plant, in
contravention of any of the provisions of the U. P. Excise
Act, 1910 or the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances Act, 1985 or any other law for the time being
in force, or
(iii) occupying or taking possession of immovable property
otherwise than in accordance with law, or setting-up false
claims, for title or possession of immoveable property
whether in himself or any other person, or
(iv) preventing or attempting to prevent any public
servant or any witness from discharging his lawful duties,
or
(v) offences punishable under the Suppression of Immoral
Traffic in Women and Girls Act, 1956, or
(vi) offences punishable under section 3 of the Public
Gambling Act, 1867, or

15
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
(vii) preventing any person from offering bids in auction
lawfully conducted, or tender, lawfully invited, by or on
behalf of any Government department, local body or
public or private undertaking, for any lease or rights or
supply of goods or work to be done, or
(viii) preventing or disturbing the smooth running by any
person of his lawful business, profession, trade or
employment or any other lawful activity connected
therewith, or
(ix) offences punishable under section 171-E of the Indian
Penal Code, or in preventing or obstructing any public
election being lawfully held, by physically preventing the
voter from exercising his electoral rights, or
(x) inciting others to resort to violence to disturb
communal harmony, or
(xi) creating panic, alarm or terror in public, or
(xii) terrorising or assaulting employees or owners or
occupiers of public or private undertaking or factories and
causing mischief in respect of their properties, or
(xiii) inducing or attempting to induce any person to go to
foreign countries on false representation that any
employment, trade or profession shall be provided to him
in such foreign country, or
(xiv) kidnapping or abducting any person with intent to
extort ransom, or
(xv) diverting or otherwise preventing any aircraft or
public transport vehicle from following its scheduled
course ;
(xvi) offences punishable under the Regulation of Money
Lending Act, 1976 ;
(xvii) illegally transporting and/or smuggling of cattle and
indulging in acts in contravention of the provisions in the
Prevention of Cow Slaughter Act, 1955 and the Prevention
of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960 ;
(xviii) human trafficking for purposes of commercial
exploitation, bonded labour, child labour, sexual

16
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
exploitation, organ removing and trafficking, beggary and
the like activities;
(xix) offences punishable under the Unlawful Activities
(Prevention) Act, 1966;
(xx) printing, transporting and circulating of fake Indian
currency notes;
(xxi) involving in production, sale and distribution of
spurious drugs;
(xxii) involving in manufacture, sale and transportation of
arms and ammunition in contravention of sections 5, 7
and 12 of the Arms Act, 1959;
(xxiii) felling or killing for economic gains, smuggling of
products in contravention of the Indian Forest Act, 1927
and the Wildlife Protection Act, 1972;
(xxiv) offences punishable under the Entertainment and
Betting Tax Act, 1979;
(xxv) indulging in crimes that impact security of State,
public order and even tempo of life.
(c) “gangster” means a member or leader or organizer of
a gang and includes any person who abets or assists in
the activities of a gang enumerated in clause (b), whether
before or after the commission of such activities or
harbors any person who has indulged in such activities;
xxx xxx xxx.”
19. Section 3 refers to penalty which is also extracted
hereinbelow: -
“3. (1) A gangster shall be punished with imprisonment of
either description for a term which shall not be less than
two years and which may extend to ten years and also
with fine which shall not be less than five thousand rupees
: Provided that a gangster who commits an offence
against the person of a public servant or the person of a
member of the family of a public servant shall be punished
with imprisonment of either description for a term which
shall not be less than three years and also with fine which
shall not be less than five thousand rupees.

17
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
(2) Whoever being a public servant renders any illegal
help or support in any manner to a gangster, whether
before or after the commission of any offence by the
gangster (whether by himself or through others) or
abstains from taking lawful measures or intentionally
avoids to carry out the directions of any court or of his
superior officers, in this respect, shall be punished with
imprisonment of either description for a term which may
extend to ten years but shall not be less than three years
and also with fine.”
20. Section 4 speaks of the special rules of evidence by which
additional aspects, regarding prior specified criminal
antecedents, could be reckoned by the Special Court constituted
to try the cases under the Act, notwithstanding the provisions of
the CrPC and the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. Section 5 enables
constitution of Special Courts and appointment of a Presiding
Judge in consultation with the Chief Justice of the High Court.
Section 6 empowers the Special Courts to sit at any place other
than the ordinary place of sitting, even on a certification made
by the Public Prosecutor, but after hearing the accused. Section
7 dealing with the jurisdiction of the Special Courts, is a non
obstante clause restricting trial of ‘every offence punishable
under any provision of this Act or any rule made thereunder’ to
be exclusively tried by the Special Court.
21. We specifically emphasize and extract the above words from
the provision under Section 7, since ‘any offence punishable
under this Act’ has also been referred to in Sections 8, 10, 11,
12 and 13 of the Act. Section 8 empowers the Special Courts to
try any other offence with which the accused, under any other
law is charged, to be tried along with the offence punishable
under the U.P. Act. Section 9 confers power on the Government
to appoint Public Prosecutors; Additional PP or Special PP too,
and prescribes the eligibility to be so appointed. Section 10
permits cognizance to be taken by a Special Court, of any offence
triable by it, without a committal proceeding, even on a
complaint of facts received by it or a police report, and enables
a summary trial in cases where the punishment does not exceed
three years imprisonment or with fine or both. It also bestows
the Special Courts with the powers; of a Sessions Court; to
convert a summary trial to a regular one and tender a pardon in
accordance with the CrPC. Section 11 is with respect to incamera
proceedings and keeping secret the identity of the witnesses,
which we will deal with a bit later. As of now, we highlight the
employment of the words: ‘an offence under this Act’ only to
emphasize that there is no action or omission penalized as an
offence under the subject Act.
22. The other provisions except Section 19 and Section 23 are
not relevant for our purposes. Section 19 also is a non obstante
clause deeming every offence punishable under the Act or the
Rules made thereunder to be a cognizable offence within the

18
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
meaning of Section 2(c) of the CrPC and enhancing the period
for default bail as provided under the CrPC. Sub-section (4) also
stipulates that no person arraigned under the Act shall be
released on bail or on bond, unless the Public Prosecutor is given
opportunity to oppose and on such opposition, the Court is
satisfied that there are reasonable grounds for believing that the
accused is not guilty of such an offence and is not likely to
commit any offence while on bail. Section 23 enables the State
Government to frame rules to carry out the purposes of this Act
which provides that any contravention of any provisions of the
Rules shall also be made punishable with imprisonment for a
term of 6 months with or without fine.
23. Purportedly, in exercise of Section 23, the Rules of 2021 have
been brought out wherein the condition of criminal liability with
respect to gangs have been fixed under Rule 3. Rule 3 speaks of
the offences mentioned under clauses (i) to (xxv) of Section 2(b)
of the Act to be punishable under the Act, only if they disturb
public order or causes violence or threat or display of violence,
intimidation, coercion or otherwise, either singly or collectively,
for the purpose of obtaining any unfair advantage; the
advantage being worldly, economic, material, pecuniary or
otherwise. The term ‘worldly’ being defined under the Rules as
audacious acts which are illegal and aimed at seeking temporal
gratification. Rule 4 speaks of a person being liable even if he is
not at the scene of the incident or directly participating in the
incident, if the offence is committed together with his passive
involvement.
24. Chapter 3 prescribes the procedure for preparing the gang
chart which has to be done at the grass root level by the
Incharge of a Police Station/Station House Officer/Inspector,
forwarded with the recommendation of the Additional
Superintendent of Police (ASP), but approved only after due
decision is taken in the joint meeting of the Commissioner of
Police/District Magistrate/Senior Superintendent of
Police/Superintendent of Police. While preparing the gang chart,
it is provided by Rule 6 that the specific provision, the violation
of which is alleged under sub-section (b) of Section 2 of the Act
has to be mentioned. The other provisions in Chapter 2 provides
for, restriction in; including the charges mentioned in an earlier
gang chart (R.7), stating unconfirmed or false information (R.8)
and requires support by records of; additional aspects as coming
out from Section 4 of the Act (R.9) & also of base cases (R.10),
the present status of the witnesses and the accused (R.11) and
so on and so forth. A procedure is clearly prescribed as to how
the gang chart is to be forwarded under Rule 16.
25. Chapter IV deals with the sanction of investigation and
prosecution. Rule 22 provides that a single prosecution in certain
class of cases, which are enumerated thereunder; all under the
Penal Code, out of the sub-clauses mentioned under the various
clauses of Section 2(b), if committed as a single offence, on

19
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
which investigation is pending, to reckon that for inclusion in the
Gang Chart, the it ought to be approved by the Investigating
Officer (I.O) of that single crime too. The provision seems to
indicate that even if there is pending only one crime, which is
also in the stage of investigation then the rigor of the Act can be
applied to the accused, if the I.O in that case approves the Gang
Chart.”
22. The Indian Penal Code had no offence of organised crime.
The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, in force from 01.07.2024,
created one for the first time in the general penal law. Section 111
of the Sanhita is extracted hereunder:
“111. Organised crime.—(1) Any continuing unlawful activity
including kidnapping, robbery, vehicle theft, extortion, land
grabbing, contract killing, economic offence, cyber-crimes,
trafficking of persons, drugs, weapons or illicit goods or services,
human trafficking for prostitution or ransom, by any person or a
group of persons acting in concert, singly or jointly, either as a
member of an organised crime syndicate or on behalf of such
syndicate, by use of violence, threat of violence, intimidation,
coercion, or by any other unlawful means to obtain direct or indirect
material benefit including a financial benefit, shall constitute
organised crime.
Explanation.—For the purposes of this sub-section,—
(i) “organised crime syndicate” means a group of two or more
persons who, acting either singly or jointly, as a syndicate or gang
indulge in any continuing unlawful activity;
(ii) “continuing unlawful activity” means an activity prohibited by law
which is a cognizable offence punishable with imprisonment of three
years or more, undertaken by any person, either singly or jointly, as
a member of an organised crime syndicate or on behalf of such
syndicate in respect of which more than one charge-sheets have
been filed before a competent Court within the preceding period of
ten years and that Court has taken cognizance of such offence, and
includes economic offence;
(iii) “economic offence” includes criminal breach of trust, forgery,
counterfeiting of currency-notes, bank-notes and Government
stamps, hawala transaction, mass-marketing fraud or running any
scheme to defraud several persons or doing any act in any manner
with a view to defraud any bank or financial institution or any other
institution or organisation for obtaining monetary benefits in any
form.
(2) Whoever commits organised crime shall,—
(a) if such offence has resulted in the death of any person, be
punished with death or imprisonment for life, and shall also be liable
to fine which shall not be less than ten lakh rupees;

20
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
(b) in any other case, be punished with imprisonment for a term
which shall not be less than five years but which may extend to
imprisonment for life, and shall also be liable to fine which shall not
be less than five lakh rupees.
(3) Whoever abets, attempts, conspires or knowingly facilitates the
commission of an organised crime, or otherwise engages in any act
preparatory to an organised crime, shall be punished with
imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than five years but
which may extend to imprisonment for life, and shall also be liable
to fine which shall not be less than five lakh rupees.
(4) Any person who is a member of an organised crime syndicate
shall be punished with imprisonment for a term which shall not be
less than five years but which may extend to imprisonment for life,
and shall also be liable to fine which shall not be less than five lakh
rupees.
(5) Whoever, intentionally, harbours or conceals any person who has
committed the offence of an organised crime shall be punished with
imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than three years
but which may extend to imprisonment for life, and shall also be
liable to fine which shall not be less than five lakh rupees:
Provided that this sub-section shall not apply to any case in
which the harbour or concealment is by the spouse of the offender.
(6) Whoever possesses any property derived or obtained from the
commission of an organised crime or proceeds of any organised
crime or which has been acquired through the organised crime, shall
be punishable with imprisonment for a term which shall not be less
than three years but which may extend to imprisonment for life and
shall also be liable to fine which shall not be less than two lakh
rupees.
(7) If any person on behalf of a member of an organised crime
syndicate is, or at any time has been in possession of movable or
immovable property which he cannot satisfactorily account for, shall
be punishable with imprisonment for a term which shall not be less
than three years but which may extend to imprisonment for ten
years and shall also be liable to fine which shall not be less than one
lakh rupees.”
23. Upon a perusal of the said provisions, it is evident that
Section 111(1) defines organised crime as any continuing unlawful
activity, including economic offences, carried on by a person or
group acting as or on behalf of an organised crime syndicate, by
violence, threat, intimidation, coercion or other unlawful means, to

21
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
obtain material benefit. “Continuing unlawful activity” requires
more than one charge-sheet within the preceding ten years on
which a competent court has taken cognizance. Sub-sections (2) to
(7) prescribe punishments, including for membership of a
syndicate.
24. Three features of Section 111 stand out. It creates an
offence and prescribes punishment for it. Its threshold is objective
and verifiable from judicial records, not left to executive
assessment. And it retains both the means (force or unlawful
means) and the object (material benefit), so that economic
offences fall within it only when they carry the character of
organised criminality.
25. Section 111 does not apply here, since the acts alleged pre-
date it, and Article 20(1) bars its retrospective application. We refer
to it only because it shows what Parliament has regarded as the
essential safeguards of a law on organised crime, viz. - a statutory
offence, a threshold demonstrable from court records, and the
elements of force or unlawful means and of benefit.
QUESTION (i): THE EFFECT OF SHIV PRATAP SINGH JUDGMENT
26. In Shiv Pratap Singh (Supra), the Supreme Court observed
that the Act creates no offence. It held that Section 2(b) is merely
a definition clause, and that prescribing punishment for a status

22
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
without an offence created by statute makes the penal act,
stillborn. On that footing, it quashed the two proceedings before it.
27. The Supreme Court, however, expressly refrained from
deciding the constitutionality of the Act, while observing as under:
“29. We reiterate that we are not dealing with a challenge on the
constitutionality of the enactment, hence we would not examine
the U.P. Act in that perspective but however on the facts coming
out from the two cases before us, we have to look at two
issues….”
28. The Supreme Court in the said judgment further clarified
that all the contentions against the Act would be left open for
consideration, as extracted hereunder:
“59. … We may also not be mistaken as having approved the Full
Bench of the Allahabad High Court and or upheld the negation
of all the contentions raised against the Act, which would be left
open for consideration, especially since we have only held the
Act to be stillborn on the provisions as existing now.”
29. Those very contentions were considered and rejected by a
9
Full Bench of this Court in Ashok Kumar Dixit v. State of U.P. . The
Full Bench upheld the Act. It negatived the arguments that no
offence had been created and that the Act punishes a mere status.
It held that it is not the status but the act which is made punishable,
and that the activities of gangsters are offences under the Act
because they pose a grave threat to the even tempo of society. The
Supreme Court in Shiv Pratap Singh (Supra) noticed this decision.
It did not overrule it, and expressly stated that it was not to be
9 1987 SCC OnLine All : AIR 1987 All 235

23
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
understood as having approved or disapproved it. The Full Bench
therefore continues to bind this Bench. Since the constitutionality
of the Act has not been decided, the Act remains on the statute
book and carries the presumption of constitutionality. This Court
cannot treat it as non est.
30. Question (i) is accordingly answered in the aforesaid terms.
QUESTION (ii): WHETHER THE ALLEGATIONS FURNISH A LEGALLY
SUSTAINABLE BASIS FOR INVOKING THE ACT
31. A proceeding under the Act needs a base case, and the
allegations in it must be examined to see whether they disclose the
activity of a gang. The Supreme Court in Vinod Bihari Lal v. State
10
of U.P. , held as under:
“26. Although the present matter presently before us pertains
solely to the subject FIR in question, yet it must be noted that
an FIR registered under the Act of 1986 cannot be sustained in
the absence of a base case/FIR. Accordingly, it becomes
imperative to undertake a prima facie examination of the
allegations underlying the registration of the subject FIR and the
consequent preparation of gang-chart.”
32. The base case alleges the following. Officers and employees
of a licensed distillery, together with a transporter, wholesale
licensees and some excise officials, removed liquor twice on one
pass by using duplicate bar codes. They manipulated records, and
so evaded duty. The informant was an Assistant Excise
Commissioner. The evidence described is documentary and
10 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1216

24
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
electronic: passes, bar codes, registers, software entries, invoices
and statements recorded during a raid. An official team intercepted
the truck near the factory and seized the records there. If proved,
the allegations make out cheating, forgery and evasion of duty, all
of which are already being prosecuted.
33. What the allegations do not disclose is any of the means
that Section 2(b) and Rule 3 require. No act of violence, threat,
show of violence, intimidation or coercion is attributed to any
petitioner. No member of the public, witness or official is said to
have been threatened. Public officers reported the case, a
specialised agency investigated it, and ten charge-sheets have
been filed. The gang chart itself records that no accused has faced
proceedings under the U.P. Goondas Act, Sections 107 to 110 CrPC
or the NDPS Act. It is pertinent to refer to the discussion in Vinod
Bihari Lal (supra) in this context:
“19. Section 2(b) of the Act of 1986 should be read alongside
Rule 3 of the Rules of 2021, which states as follows:
“3. Conditions of criminal liability.- (1) The offences mentioned
in sub sections (i) to (xxv) of clause (b) of Section 2 of the Act
shall be punishable under the Act only if they are:—
(a) committed for disturbing public order; or
(b) committed by causing violence or threat or display of
violence, or by intimidation, or coercion or otherwise, either
singly or collectively, for the purpose of obtaining any unfair
worldly, economic, material, pecuniary or other advantage to
himself or to any other person.”
20. The definition of “gang” under Section 2(b) of the Act of
1986 comprises the following essentials;
i. A group of persons i.e., there can be no gang of one person;
ii. The group of persons, acting either individually or collectively,

25
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
indulges in anti-social activities as enumerated in clauses (i) to
(xxv) of Section 2(b);iii. Indulgence in such anti-social activities
is by means of violence, or threat, or show of violence, or
intimidation, or coercion, or otherwise;
iv. Use of such means is with the object of disturbing public order,
or gaining any undue temporal, pecuniary, material or other
advantage for himself or any other person.
21. It is apparent that the definition of the term “gang” is not
attracted by mere association with a miscreant group. For such
a group to metamorphize into a gang, it must engage in anti-
social activities enumerated in clauses (i) to (xxv) of Section
2(b), and these must be committed for the object mentioned
thereunder. In essence, a group of persons falls within the ambit
of Section 2(b) only when the requirements set forth in Rule 3
are satisfied.”
34. The counter affidavits assert that nobody from the public
dares to depose or lodge a report. The assertion is bare. It carries
no particulars, and it sits uneasily with a prosecution that was in
fact reported, investigated and charge-sheeted. The only reference
on record to anything resembling a threat is a submission made by
the State at a bail hearing in March 2022. It concerned telephone
calls made by two company officials to a security in-charge. The
bail order notes that no FIR was shown to have been lodged about
those calls, and neither of those officials is a petitioner before us.
35. The words “or otherwise” do not dispense with this
requirement. They take colour from the words around them. That
is why the Full Bench in Ashok Kumar Dixit (supra), on which the
State itself relies, read Section 2(b) as a whole as bringing in
violence, intimidation or coercion. In Vinod Bihari Lal (supra),
allegations of forgery and embezzlement fell within offences under
the IPC. They were nevertheless held not to have been committed

26
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
with the object contemplated by Section 2(b), even in the remotest
possibility. In Vinod Bihari Lal (supra), it was discussed and held as
under:
“23. A Full Bench of the High Court of Allahabad in Ashok Kumar
Dixit v. State of U.P., reported as 1987 SCC OnLine All 203, while
deciding on the constitutional validity of the Act of 1986 noted
that the term “gang” means a group of persons who by violence,
or threat, or show of violence, or intimidation, or coercion, or
otherwise indulge in anti-social activities with the object of
disturbing public order or gaining any undue temporal or
pecuniary material or other advantage for himself. The relevant
observations are reproduced hereinbelow:
“12. Section 2(b) defines the term “Gang” to mean a group of
persons who by violence, or threat, or show of violence or
intimidation or coercion etc. indulge in anti-social activities with
the object of disturbing public order of gaining any undue
temporal or pecuniary material or other advantage for himself. S.
2(b) read as a whole necessarily brings in the concept of violence
or intimidation or coercion etc. which is resorted to for gaining
material advantage. Then we have cl. (c) of S. 2 which defines
the word “Gangster”. It means a member or leader or organiser
of a group which indulges in the kind of activities set out under
the various sub-clauses of cl. (b) of S. 2, by use of violence or
threat or show of violence or intimidation etc. S. 3(i) lays down
the penalty for being the member or leader or organiser of a
group which engages or indulges in the kind of unsocial activities
enumerated under S. 2(b) by use of violence etc.”
(Emphasis supplied)
24. A more lucid exposition of the essential requirements was
provided in the recent decision of Sukarmpal v. State of U.P.,
reported in 2024 SCC OnLine All 5848. The relevant observations
are reproduced hereinbelow:
“11. From the definition of gang under Section 2(b) of the
Gangster Act, it is clear that merely becoming a member of a
gang will not be punishable unless the gang falls within the
purview of Section 2(b) of Gangster Act and for the punishment
of the member or organizer or leader of a gang under the
Gangster Act, conditions mentioned in Rule 3 must be fulfilled,
which prescribes that offence mentioned in Sub-section (i) to
(xxv) of Section 2(b) of the Gangster Act must be committed for
disturbing public order or committed by causing violence or
threat or coercion or otherwise for the purpose of obtaining
unfair trustworthy, pecuniary, economic, material or other
advantage. Therefore, merely because a person has committed
any offence mentioned in Sub-section (i) to (xxv) of sub-section
(b) of Section 2 of the Gangster Act will not itself come within
the purview of the Gangster Act unless he is member of a gang
falling under Section 2(b) of Gangster Act.

27
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
12. Even the Rule 4(2) of the Gangster Rules itself provides that,
if a member of a gang has committed any offence which comes
within the purview of the Act along with any other members then
he will be presumed to be a gang. Therefore, punishing a person
under the Gangster Act basic condition to be a member of a gang
under Section 2(b) of the Gangster Act must be satisfied.
13. Rule 6 of the Gangster Rules also provides that at the time
of preparation of gang chart, it must be mentioned that act of
gang falls within the purview of Section 2(b) of the Gangster Act.
Therefore, it is clear that for bringing an offence within the
purview of Gangster Act, it must be committed by a member of
a gang for the object mentioned in Section 2(b) of the Gangster
Act by doing the activities mentioned in Sub-Section (i) to (xxv)
of Clause (b) of Section 2 of the Gangster Act. Therefore, if any
offence is committed whether the same falls within the category
of Sub-Section (i) to (xxv) of Section 2(b) of the Gangster Act or
not, that will not come within the purview of the Gangster Act
unless the same is done with the object mentioned in Section
2(b) of the Gangster Act.”
(Emphasis supplied)
25. From the above exposition of law, a group of persons may
be said to constitute a gang only when they, either singly or
collectively, indulge in any of the anti-social activity enumerated
in clauses (i) to (xvv) of Section 2(b), by means specified therein,
or otherwise, and most importantly, with the object of disturbing
public order, or securing any undue temporal, pecuniary, material
or other advantage for himself or any other person.”
36. The FIR invokes clause (i) in its table and clauses (i) and (ii)
in its narrative. Clause (ii) speaks of manufacturing or transporting
liquor in breach of the Excise Act. The listing of an activity is,
however, only one element of the definition. The activity must be
pursued by the means, and for the object, that the opening words
of Section 2(b) and Rule 3 require. Otherwise, those engaged in it
are co-accused in an ordinary prosecution, and not a gang.
Employees who act within a hierarchy, on the instructions of their
superiors and in the course of a company’s business, do not
become a gang merely because that business is alleged to have
been run unlawfully. The State Government’s own Guidelines dated

28
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
02.12.2024, which the Supreme Court subsumed as part of its
judgment in Vinod Bihari Lal (supra), say the same. Guideline (1),
extracted in paragraph 64 of that judgment, reads as under:
“(1) Provisions of the Act be applied only when gangster commits
the crime by violence, threat or show of violence or
intimidation or coercion etc. alone or group with the object of
disturbing public order or of gaining any undue temporal,
pecuniary, material or other advantage for himself or any other
person.”
37. The scheme of Section 111 of the Sanhita, noticed in
paragraphs 21 to 24, is consistent with this reading. Under that
scheme, an economic offence becomes organised crime only when
it is committed as a continuing unlawful activity of a syndicate, by
the means and for the object stated in the provision. It is not
enough that the offence is an economic one.
38. The State relies on the proposition that a single offence may
suffice. That reliance does not help it. The decision on which the
State relies itself makes the means and the object a condition of
prosecution. In Shraddha Gupta (supra), the Supreme Court held
as under:
“27. As per the settled position of law, the provisions of the
statute are to be read and considered as it is. Therefore,
considering the provisions under the Gangsters Act, 1986 as they
are, even in case of a single offence/FIR/charge-sheet, if it is
found that the accused is a member of a “gang” and has indulged
in any of the anti-social activities mentioned in Section 2(b) of
the Gangsters Act, such as, by violence, or threat or show of
violence, or intimidation, or coercion or otherwise with the object
of disturbing public order or of gaining any undue temporal,
pecuniary, material or other advantage for himself or any other
person and he/she can be termed as “gangster” within the
definition of Section 2(c) of the Act, he/she can be prosecuted
for the offences under the Gangsters Act. Therefore, so far as
the Gangsters Act, 1986 is concerned, there can be prosecution

29
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
against a person even in case of a single offence/FIR/charge-
sheet for any of the anti-social activities mentioned in Section
2(b) of the Act provided such an anti-social activity is by violence,
or threat or show of violence, or intimidation, or coercion or
otherwise with the object of disturbing public order or of gaining
any undue temporal, pecuniary, material or other advantage for
himself or any other person.”
39. The facts of that case also stand in contrast to those before
us. The base offence there was a murder in which, according to the
prosecution, the accused rammed their car into the deceased’s
scooty and shouted that the witness should also be killed. The other
co-accused were already being prosecuted under the Act. Vinod
Bihari Lal (supra), para 22, read Shraddha Gupta (supra) in the
same way: an accused can be termed a gangster only when, as a
member of a gang, he has indulged in the enumerated activities,
“whether by means expressly stated or otherwise, with the object
of disturbing public order or of gaining any undue temporal,
pecuniary, material or other advantage for himself or any other
person”.
40. In the instant case, the only incident is that of 03.03.2021,
and the unit has been sealed since that day. The gang chart was
prepared on 01.12.2025, four years and nine months later. Nothing
falling within Section 2(b) is alleged against any petitioner in the
intervening period. The FIR gives the date and place of occurrence
as “various”. In the meantime, the base case has been charge-
sheeted ten times, cognizance has been taken, and each petitioner
has been admitted to bail. In Vinod Bihari Lal (supra), the Supreme

30
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
Court thought it noteworthy that the FIR under the Act had been
registered about a year after the first base FIR. Here, the interval
is nearly five times as long. The approving authority is bound to
apply its mind to the pertinent and proximate matters and eschew
those which are irrelevant & remote. The Preamble shows that the
Act is directed to the prevention of, and coping with, gangster and
anti-social activities. The record does not show what activity
remained to be prevented in December 2025.
41. Where a proceeding is said to have been instituted for a
purpose other than its proper one, the Court must look at the FIR
with care and somewhat more closely. In Mohammad Wajid v. State
11
of U.P. , as extracted in Vinod Bihari Lal (supra), para 39, the
Supreme Court observed as under:
“34. ... In frivolous or vexatious proceedings, the Court owes a
duty to look into many other attending circumstances emerging
from the record of the case over and above the averments and,
if need be, with due care and circumspection try to read in
between the lines. The Court while exercising its jurisdiction
under Section 482 of the CrPC or Article 226 of the Constitution
need not restrict itself only to the stage of a case but is
empowered to take into account the overall circumstances
leading to the initiation/registration of the case as well as the
materials collected in the course of investigation.”
We need not, and do not, record a finding of mala fides.
The circumstances are relevant because they bear on
whether the decision to invoke the Act rested on a genuine
basis.
11 2023 SCC OnLine SC 951

31
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
42. The sequence of events, as evident from the record, is as
follows:
a. The proposal to invoke the Act was approved in June
2023 and conveyed in July 2023. Nothing was done
on it for over two years.
b. On 10.10.2025, this Court set aside the cancellation
of the Company’s licence for the second time. It
directed that the excise proceedings would be
deemed to be dropped unless the material was
supplied within fifteen days.
c. A fresh show cause notice was issued on
24.10.2025, and the Company replied seeking the
material.
d. The gang chart was prepared on 01.12.2025, and
the FIR followed on 09.12.2025.
This sequence does not by itself prove an improper
purpose. It does, however, require that the decision to invoke
the Act at that particular moment be shown, from the
contemporaneous record, to rest on reasons of its own. No
such reasons are on record.
43. The selection of persons calls for the same scrutiny. In Vinod
Bihari Lal (supra), the Supreme Court observed as under:

32
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
“33. ... if the subject FIR and the gang-chart were indeed
prepared on the strength of the base FIRs, there is no good or
plausible explanation coming from the investigating agency as to
why no investigation was initiated against other similarly placed
accused persons named therein. This selective approach raises
serious doubts about the bona fides of the investigating agency
and integrity of the investigation undertaken under the Act of
1986.”
The gang chart gives a reason for leaving out the
Ahujas. It gives none for bringing in twenty persons beyond
the nine named by the SIT. Selectivity can operate in both
directions, in whom one leaves out and in whom one brings
in.
44. The antecedents relied upon by the State do not change the
position. Against Pranay Aneja, the State cites three matters: a
case under Section 174-A IPC, arising from his non-appearance; a
second such case, which he denies; and the PMLA proceedings,
which arise from the same base case. Against Ravindra Kishor, the
State cites a case of 2006 from District Basti under Sections 323,
324, 325, 504 and 506 IPC. None of these is a base case in the
gang chart.
45. Even otherwise, it is settled law that, when it comes to
quashing of the FIR or criminal proceedings, the criminal
antecedents of the accused cannot be the sole consideration to
decline to quash the criminal proceedings. An accused has a
legitimate right to say before the Court that howsoever bad his
antecedents may be, still if the FIR fails to disclose commission of
any offence or his case falls within one of the parameters as laid

33
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
down by this Court in the case of Bhajan Lal (supra), then the Court
should not decline to quash the criminal case only on the ground
that the accused is a history sheeter.
46. Question (ii) is accordingly answered in favour of the
petitioners. At face value, the allegations disclose offences which
are already being prosecuted in the base case. They do not disclose
the activity of a gang within Section 2(b) read with Rule 3. Nor does
the record furnish any basis for invoking the Act nearly five years
after the solitary incident.
QUESTION (iii): THE PREPARATION AND APPROVAL OF THE GANG
CHART
47. Rule 5(3)(a) provides that the gang-chart will not be
approved summarily but after due discussion in a joint meeting of
the Commissioner of Police/District Magistrate/Senior
Superintendent of Police/Superintendent of Police.
48. Rule 16 requires every forwarding and approving authority
to record its satisfaction after perusing the gang chart and the
attached forms. Rule 16(3) requires that all the facts will also be
thoroughly perused by the Commissioner of Police/District
Magistrate and when he is satisfied that the basis of action exists
in the case, then he will approve the gang-chart.

34
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
49. Rule 17 reads as under:
“17. Use of independent mind.—(1) The Competent Authority
shall be bound to exercise its own independent mind while
forwarding the gang-chart. (2) A pre-printed rubber seal gang-
chart should not be signed by the Competent Authority;
otherwise the same shall tantamount to the fact that the
Competent Authority has not exercised its free mind.”
50. The Rules thus separate two things that are easily confused:
a meeting of officers, and the application of mind by those officers.
Officers may meet and agree without examining anything. The
Rules do not require merely that the officers meet, or that they
agree. They require that each of them, and the District Magistrate
in particular, examine the material and arrive at a satisfaction
grounded in it. The joint meeting is the place where that
examination is meant to happen. It is not a substitute for
independent application of mind.
51. The Supreme Court explained the content of this
requirement in Vinod Bihari Lal (supra):
“51. The satisfaction of the approving authority is sine qua non
for taking action under the Act of 1986. It is indispensable for
the approving authority to record his satisfaction in his own
words, to indicate application of mind before approving the
gang-chart. The recording of satisfaction need not be
exhaustive, because at the stage of approval the investigation
under the Act of 1986 is yet to be conducted, but it must be
independent, indicating the reasons justifying the exercise of
jurisdiction under the Act of 1986.
52. It is equally apposite to mention that the satisfaction must
not be a cyclostyle reproduction of the application of mind
communicated by the recommending authority. This is only
possible when the approving authority meticulously refers to the
materials on record on the basis of which he will come to the
conclusion about existence of grounds justifying registration of
an FIR under the Act of 1986. Needless to say, reiteration of the
contents of the FIR or chargesheet does not constitute
application of mind.

35
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
53. Such satisfaction must stand on certain grounds; it cannot
arise in absence of any basis, leaving the liberty of the accused
in a precarious position. The basis of satisfaction must bear a
reasonable nexus with the facts present before the concerned
authority. Thus, the decision of the recommending, forwarding,
and approving authorities respectively must be at the behest of
the application of mind to the relevant and material facts
available on record.
54. An independent application of mind cannot be presumed
unless it is demonstrable from the record that the approving
authority has, in letter and spirit, independently considered all
the materials that culminated in the preparation and placement
of the gang chart before him. While the correctness of such
application of mind may lie beyond the scope of judicial scrutiny,
the absence thereof certainly does not. A mechanical or routine
exercise of power by the recommending, forwarding, and
approving authorities respectively is impermissible, as it directly
impinges upon the liberty of citizens.”
52. The Supreme Court further held therein that compliance with
the joint meeting requirement must be evident from the record:
“45. In the present case, there is nothing on record, even upon
a microscopic examination, to indicate that a joint meeting was
held prior to approval of the gang-chart. It is apparent that the
gang-chart was approved summarily, without any discussion. It
was forwarded and approved swiftly, without regard for
compliance with the relevant rules. The compliance with Rule
5(3)(a) ought to be evident through the record of minutes of the
joint meeting maintained in a register by the District Magistrate.”
53. The Supreme Court further subsumed the State
Government’s Guidelines dated 02.12.2024 as part of its judgment.
Guidelines (8), (9) and (10) as extracted therein, read as under:
“(8) On receiving the case file at the office of the Commissioner
of Police/District Magistrate, again end to end perusal of all the
facts be made and this be ensured according to rule 5(3)(a) of
the Rules 2021 that only after being satisfied by holding a joint
meeting with the Senior Superintendent of
Police/Superintendent of Police, gang-chart be approved by the
Police Commissioner/District Magistrate.
(9) After preparing the gang chart and getting the same
approved and after thorough investigations, legal scrutiny and in
addition to full compliance of the above-mentioned Government
Orders regarding other relevant proceedings, as per Rule 5(3)(a)
of the Rules 2011, it shshould also be ensured to maintain a
register for entry of the resolutions of the Joint Meetings of the
District Magistrate/the Police Commissioner/Senior

36
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
Superintendent of Police/Superintendent of Police. In addition to
the above, the Police Commissioner/Senior Superintendent of
Police/Superintendent of Police and the District Magistrate and
Nodal Officer, while appending their signatures on the gang-chart
shall also ensure to mention the date below their signatures.
(10) It should be shown to the satisfaction of the competent
authorities that they have applied their mind not only on the
gang chart but also on the documents/papers attached with
the gang-chart.”
54. Tested against these standards, the record discloses the
following:
(a) No minutes of the joint meeting are on record.
The only document produced is a certified copy of
signatures in a register dated 09.12.2025. It was
forwarded by a letter dated 05.01.2026, written after
these petitions were filed and interim protection was
granted. The document records no discussion. It
does not show what material was placed, which of
the twenty-seven persons was considered, or why
the Act was thought necessary in December 2025.
Further, the covering letter describes a different
case, against a different principal accused, at a
different police station, and that discrepancy
remains unexplained.
(b) The approval records a consensus, but not a
consideration. The District Magistrate approved the
chart “on the basis of consensus, being satisfied with
the report presented”. Consensus means that the
officers agreed. It says nothing about any
examination of the material. Satisfaction with the
report presented is satisfaction with the police
recommendation, not with the evidence. The
endorsement does not identify the clause of Section

37
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
2(b), the means of violence, threat, intimidation or
coercion, the object, or the role of any individual.
(c) The endorsements at the intermediate levels are
identical. The Circle Officer, the Nodal Officer and
the Superintendent of Police each wrote the same
three sentences. Rule 17(2) forbids signing a printed
satisfaction because a printed formula reflects no
thought. A formula copied out by hand at each level
stands no higher. It is a “cyclostyle reproduction” in
the words of Vinod Bihari Lal (supra). The model
words in Rule 16 do not save it. Those words are
expressly illustrative of the content of the
satisfaction. They do not dispense with the
requirement, explained in paragraphs 52 and 53 of
Vinod Bihari Lal (supra), that the satisfaction refer
to, and be grounded in, the material. The Rules
intend each tier to act as a filter. When every tier
repeats the tier below it, there is in truth only one
tier. The recommending, forwarding, and approving
authority are not mere rubber-stamping entities.
(d) The speed and volume of the exercise are
significant. The chart passed every level between
01.12.2025 and 09.12.2025. The FIR was registered
at 23:15 hours on the day of approval, against
twenty-seven persons spread over several districts
and States. Speed alone is not a vice. Read with the
formulaic character of every endorsement, however,
it supports the inference that no real examination of
twenty-seven individual cases took place. Several
endorsements, including that of the Inspector-in-
charge, are also undated, contrary to guideline (9)
adopted in Vinod Bihari Lal (supra). The absence of

38
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
dates was itself a matter of concern to the Supreme
Court in that case.
(e) The particulars in the chart were not checked:
Pranay Aneja is described as “MD/owner”, which he
disputes. Every one of the twenty-seven persons
carries the same entry, that the possibility of a
further offence “cannot be ruled out”, without a
single supporting fact about any of them. None of
this drew comment from any approving authority.
(f) The departure from the SIT’s recommendation is
unexplained. The only considered proposal on
record is Recommendation No. 5, approved in 2023
by a committee chaired by the Principal Secretary
(Home). The chart retains seven of its nine names
and adds twenty. Those added include four public
servants whom the SIT had recommended only for
departmental action. Whatever view one takes of
the reason recorded for omitting the Ahujas, a
considered exercise would have explained why
twenty more persons were now to be branded
members of a gang. No reason is recorded.
55. The absence of application of mind is most evident when
the position of each petitioner is examined. The record does not
reflect any individual consideration of any of them:
(i) Pranay Aneja is shown as the gang leader and as
“MD/owner”. He states that he is a shareholder.
While rejecting his first bail application, this Court
noted his substantial shareholding along with that of
his family. He has been on bail since 25.03.2022 and
has furnished bonds in the PMLA proceedings. Apart

39
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
from the Section 174-A IPC matter arising from his
non-appearance in 2021, nothing is alleged against
him after 03.03.2021.
(ii) Upendra Govind Rao was the Unit Head. He was
in custody from 04.03.2021 until 14.12.2021. He
states that he resigned from the Company on
01.11.2023.
(iii) Ashwani Upadhyay is described as the Sales
Head. While granting him bail, this Court noticed
material showing that he was employed by Stellar
Capital Services Limited and not by the Company. It
also noticed that nothing had been pointed out
against him except the statement of a co-accused.
(iv) Ravindra Kishor is a public servant, and was then
an Excise Inspector at Unnao. He was not named in
the base FIRs. He states that his name surfaced
during investigation on the basis of a transcript of a
fifty-six second call. After completing its
investigation, the SIT recommended departmental
action, consideration of termination of service and
an inquiry into his assets. It did not recommend
action under the Act. The chart gives no reason for
departing from that assessment. Section 3(2) of the
Act, which deals with a public servant rendering
illegal help to a gangster, has not been invoked
against him. He is simply treated as a gang member
under Section 3(1).
56. Therefore, the satisfaction required by Rules 5(3)(a), 16 and
17 is a jurisdictional condition for registering an FIR under the Act.
Its absence goes to the root of the proceeding and is not a curable

40
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
irregularity. Question (iii) is accordingly answered in favour of the
petitioners.
OBSERVATIONS ON THE ROUTINE INVOCATION OF THE ACT
57. These petitions raise a concern that goes beyond the four
petitioners, namely, when an enactment of this kind should be
invoked at all. We record the following observations:
a. A law carrying graver consequences than the ordinary
penal law is an exception to the ordinary process, and not an
alternative to it. The decision to invoke it should rest on a
recorded determination of why the ordinary process is
inadequate in the particular case. The gravity of the base
offence alone cannot supply that determination, because the
general law already deals with grave offences.
b. Consider a case where the predicate offence is already
being prosecuted, the charge-sheets have been filed,
cognizance has been taken, the accused are on bail without
breach, and nothing is alleged in the interval. There, invoking
the Act adds no new fact. What it adds are the bail restrictions
under the Act, the extended period of remand, and exposure
to a minimum sentence before a Special Court. Consequences
of that weight for liberty should follow only from reasons that
are specific, contemporaneous and verifiable.
c. The gang chart is not a mere formality. Under the Rules, it
is the only instrument by which a person comes to be treated
as a gangster. Each tier of approval is meant to be an
independent check. When every tier repeats the one below

41
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
it, the checks collapse into one, and the decision is in truth
that of the officer who first prepared the chart.
d. A joint meeting is worth only what is done at it. The law
requires due discussion and independent application of mind.
It does not require consensus, and a consensus does not
prove that the requirement was met.
e. Heightened care is called for when penal proceedings of
an exceptional kind are begun shortly after the same State
authorities have suffered an adverse outcome in civil, fiscal
or regulatory proceedings on the same facts. The State may
pursue every lawful remedy. The record should then,
however, show on its face that the decision rests on
independent grounds.
f. Economic offences, including organised ones, are now
addressed by Section 111 of the Sanhita, which has a defined
offence and an objective threshold. They are also addressed
by specific statutes such as the excise laws and the
Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002. That is itself a
reason for restraint before the officers and employees of a
business, prosecuted for the manner in which the business
was run, are treated as members of a gang.
DIRECTIONS
58. The Act continues to be operative, as held under Question
(i). Building upon the directions already issued in the plethora of
judgments referred hereinabove, we direct that the following shall

42
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
be observed in any proceeding that may hereafter be contemplated
under the Act and the Rules:
(i) Threshold determination: Before a gang chart is prepared,
the officer preparing it shall record, for each person, the
following particulars, together with the material for each: (a)
the clause of Section 2(b) being invoked;
(b) the means of violence, threat, show of violence, intimidation
or coercion attributed to that person; and (c) the object alleged.
(ii) Individual assessment: Satisfaction at every stage shall be
individual to each person. It shall state why that person is a
member, leader or organiser of a gang, as distinct from a co-
accused in the predicate offence. A collective satisfaction, or an
identical entry against every person, shall be treated as no
satisfaction.
(iii) Inadequacy of the ordinary process: Where the predicate
case has been charge-sheeted or is pending trial, the authorities
shall record specific reasons, with particulars, why the ordinary
prosecution is inadequate. Those reasons may include any
breach of bail, interference with witnesses, or continuation of
the activity.
(iv) Proximity in time: The chart shall state the date of the last
act attributed to each person. Where that act is not proximate
to the chart, the reasons for invoking the Act at that time shall
be recorded.
(v) Full disclosure: The chart shall disclose the following:
(a) the current status of every base case, including any stay,
bail, discharge or quashing; (b) any order passed in civil, fiscal

43
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
or regulatory proceedings on the same facts; and (c) any
recommendation of an investigating agency on invoking the
Act, with reasons for any departure from it.
(vi) Joint meeting: The joint meeting under Rule 5(3)(a) shall
be one whose date, time, place and participants are recorded.
Minutes shall be written at the meeting and entered in the
register. They shall record, in respect of each person, the
material examined, the points considered and the reasons for
approval or rejection. A mere recital of consensus, or of
satisfaction with the report placed, shall not suffice.
(vii) Independent and dated satisfaction: Every forwarding and
approving authority shall record its satisfaction in its own words,
with reference to the material, and shall note the date and time
below its signature.
(viii) Sequence: No FIR shall be registered until the approval
and the minutes are complete. The time of approval shall be
recorded, so that the sequence of approval and registration can
be verified.
(ix) Scheduled activities only: Only cases falling within the
clauses of Section 2(b) shall be reckoned as base cases. Other
cases may be shown separately, as criminal history, in the
prescribed form.
(x) Public servants: Where a public servant is proposed to be
included, the authorities shall record why action under the
Act, rather than departmental and anti-corruption remedies, is
the appropriate course. They shall also record whether Section
3(1) or Section 3(2) is attracted, and why.

44
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
(xi) Production before the Court: Whenever an FIR under the
Act is challenged, the State shall produce the original gang
chart, the original register of minutes and the material
considered at the joint meeting.
(xii) Responsibility: Where non-compliance is found, a copy of
the judgment shall be sent to the Chief Secretary and the
Additional Chief Secretary (Home). It shall be sent for
examination of the conduct of the authorities concerned, and
for such training and corrective measures as may be needed.
59. Needless to state that these directions are issued to secure
compliance with the provisions of the Act and the Rules framed
thereunder.
CONCLUSION
60. To sum up, in view of the consideration in the foregoing
paragraphs, this Court holds as under:
(a) Question (i) is answered in favour of the State, and
Questions (ii) and (iii) are answered in favour of the
petitioners. Each of the conclusions on Questions (ii) and (iii)
is independently sufficient to require the impugned
proceedings to be quashed.
(b) Criminal Misc. Writ Petition Nos. 29359, 29357, 29358 and
29994 of 2025 are allowed.
(c) FIR No. 645 of 2025 dated 09.12.2025, Police Station
Kotwali Dehat, District Saharanpur, the gang chart on which
it is founded, and all proceedings consequential thereto, are

45
CRLP No. - 29359 of 2025
quashed qua the petitioners Pranay Aneja, Ashwani
Upadhyay, Upendra Govind Rao and Ravindra Kishor.
(d) Nothing in this judgment shall affect Case No. 881 of 2021
pending before the learned Special Judge, P.C. Act, CBI
(Central), Lucknow, the proceedings under the Prevention of
Money Laundering Act, 2002, or any departmental
proceedings against Ravindra Kishor. Those proceedings shall
continue in accordance with law, uninfluenced by any
observation made herein.
(e) The other persons named in the FIR are at liberty to seek
such remedy as may be available to them in law.
(f) The directions in Para 54 (f) shall be observed by all
concerned authorities.
(g) The Registrar (Compliance) shall forward a copy of this
judgment to the Chief Secretary and the Additional Chief
Secretary (Home), Government of Uttar Pradesh, within two
weeks. The copy shall be circulated to all District Magistrates,
Commissioners of Police and Senior Superintendents
/Superintendents of Police in the State.
(h) Pending applications, if any, shall stand disposed of. There
shall be no order as to costs.
(Tarun Saxena,J.) (Chandra Dhari Singh,J.)
November 19, 2026
Saurabh
Digitally signed by :-
SAURABH KUMAR
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad