Pritam Singh vs State Of Punjab
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
-1-
RFA-1664-2003 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
*
113
Date of Decision: 16.11.2026
1. RFA-1664-2003 (O&M)
PRITAM SINGH (DECEASED) THROUGH LRS & OTHERS
…Appellants
Versus
STATE OF PUNJAB & OTHERS
…Respondents
And
Sr.
No.
Case No. Appellant(s) Respondent(s)
2. RFA-2187-2003 PARTAP SINGH
(DECEASED) THROUGH
LRS & OTHERS
STATE OF PUNJAB &
OTHERS
3. RFA-2755-2003 DALIP SINGH
(DECEASED) THROUGH
LRS & ANOTHER
STATE OF PUNJAB &
OTHERS
4. RFA-2756-2003 MALKIAT SINGH & STATE OF PUNJAB &
OTHERS OTHERS
5. RFA-2467-2006 AVTAR SINGH STATE OF PUNJAB &
OTHERS
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE JAGMOHAN BANSAL
Present:- Mr. Gursimran Singh Jasson, Advocate
for appellants/landowners (In RFA-1664-2003,
RFA-2187-2003, RFA-2755-2003 & RFA-2467-2006 )
Mr. Puru Jarewal, Deputy Advocate General, Punjab
Mr. S.P. Garg, Advocate for respondent No.3
*
JAGMOHAN BANSAL, J. (ORAL)
1. These appeals under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act,
1894 (for short ‘1894 Act’) are directed against award dated 08.01.2003
passed by learned Additional District Judge, Ferozepur (hereinafter called as
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.16 17:34
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
-2-
RFA-1664-2003 (O&M)
‘Reference Court’). The landowners are seeking enhancement of amount of
compensation whereas the State is claiming otherwise.
2. As common issues are involved in the captioned appeals, with
the consent of both sides, the same are hereby disposed of by this common
order. For the sake of brevity and convenience, facts are borrowed from
RFA-1664-2003 .
3. Tabulated details of the assessment made till date read as: -
Date of notification under Section 4 28.07.1992
Date of notification under Section 6 29.07.1993
Purpose of acquisition For setting up a grain market
Location Village - Mallanwala
District - Ferozepur
Area (Total) 24 Acres
Date of Collector (LAC) Award 07.08.1995
₹
Market value as per LAC ( per acre) 50,000/-
Date of Reference Court (RC) Award 08.01.2003
₹
Market value as per RC ( per acre) 1,00,000/-
4. The State Government issued notification dated 28.07.1992
under Section 4 of the 1894 Act for the acquisition of 24 Acres land situated
in Village Mallanwala, District Ferozepur for setting up a grain market. The
said notification was followed by notification dated 29.07.1993 issued under
Section 6 of 1894 Act.
5. The Land Acquisition Collector (for short ‘Collector’) vide
award dated 07.08.1995, in terms of provisions of 1894 Act, determined
compensation payable to the landowners. Market value of the acquired land
₹
was determined @ 50,000/- per acre. Landowners were held entitled to
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.16 17:34
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
-3-
RFA-1664-2003 (O&M)
solatium and other statutory benefits. Feeling dis-satisfied from the aforesaid
award, landowners preferred petitions before the Collector which were
referred to the Court under Section 18 of the 1894 Act.
6. The landowners as well as State, in support of their contentions,
led their evidence. State attempted to justify market value determined by the
Collector, however, landowners vehemently pleaded that value of their land
has been assessed on lower side.
7. The Reference Court while appreciating evidence led by the
landowners, by impugned award adjudicated reference petitions. The
Reference Court by impugned award dated 08.01.2003 has assessed market
₹
value of the land in question @ 1,00,000/- per acre.
8. Learned counsel for the appellants submit that the State of
Punjab was facing militancy during 1990-95. The notification under
Section 4 was issued on 28.07.1992. There were stray sale transactions, thus,
it was impossible to lead contemporaneous sale data. The appellants
furnished sale deed dated 01.10.1992 and 30.04.1992 which were executed
close to the Section 4 notification. Those sale deeds have been rejected on
the ground of area comprised therein. The Reference Court has further
ignored sale deeds executed on 15.03.1995 and 22.11.1995 disclosing
₹ ₹
market price @ 5,05,000/- per acre and 3,76,500/- per acre respectively.
Militancy came to an end in 1995 and thereafter transactions of agricultural
land started. In such exceptional circumstances, market price should be
determined considering sale deeds executed in the year 1995.
9. Per contra , learned counsel for respondents submit that as per
Section 23 as well as judgments of Hon’ble Supreme Court, sale deeds
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.16 17:34
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
-4-
RFA-1664-2003 (O&M)
executed post Section 4 notification cannot be considered. Sale deeds
executed prior to Section 4 notification represented shops or residential area,
thus, are bound to be ignored.
10. Heard the arguments and perused the record.
11. Sale deed dated 01.10.1992 (Ex. P-3) was executed after
Section 4 notification and sale deed dated 30.04.1992 (Ex. P-24) was
executed pre Section 4 notification. Both sale deeds comprised small area
and most probably related to residential plots. Area acquired was 24 Acre.
Sale deed Ex. P-5 was executed on 15.03.1995 and it comprised 8 Kanal 17
Marla land. Market price disclosed in the aforesaid sale deed comes to
₹
5,05,000/- per acre. Sale deed dated 22.11.1995 (Ex. P-10) comprised 1
₹
Acre area and disclosed market price @ 3,76,500/- per acre. It is well
known fact that the State of Punjab was facing militancy during 1992 and
area in question was one of the most affected areas. It was difficult to collect
sale deed of agricultural land especially representing sizable area. Militancy
came to an end during 1994-95. Transactions started in 1994-95. Sale deeds
dated 15.03.1995 and 22.11.1995 cannot be ignored because of peculiar
political and social conditions in the State of Punjab during the year of
acquisition. It is true that sale deeds executed post Section 4 notification
should not be relied upon, however, there is no absolute bar. In the absence
of reliable contemporaneous sale data, the Courts may rely upon sale deeds
executed post Section 4 notification provided genuineness of the transaction
is undoubted. There is no doubt about the genuineness of Exhibits P-5 &
P-10. Both are ignored just because of being executed post Section 4
notification. Exhibits P-3 & P-24 on account of size of the area and nature
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.16 17:34
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
-5-
RFA-1664-2003 (O&M)
of land may be ignored, however, it would not be fair to ignore Exhibits P-5
& P-10 in the wake of peculiar social and political conditions of the State of
Punjab during 1992-95.
12. Learned counsel for the appellants has agreed that a reasonable
cut may be imposed while relying upon Exhibits P-5 & P-10. Hon’ble
Supreme Court has evolved doctrine of de-escalation. Considering the
factual and legal position as well as statement of counsel for the appellants,
this Court finds it appropriate to consider 50% of sale deed Ex. P-5 as just
and fair market price of the land in question. Accordingly, market price of
₹
the land in question is determined @ 2,50,000/- per acre. The appellants
shall be entitled to statutory benefits as provided under 1894 Act.
13. Accordingly, RFA Nos.1664, 2187, 2755 & 2756 of 2003 are
allowed in above terms.
14. In the wake of assessment of market price of the acquired land
₹
@ 2,50,000/- per acre, RFA No.2467 of 2006 is hereby dismissed.
15. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
(JAGMOHAN BANSAL)
JUDGE
16.11.2026
SDK
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.16 17:34
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document