Amarjit Singh And Anr. vs The Financial Commissioner Revenue Pb. And Anr.

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CWP No.8981 of 1993 1
CWP No.11214 of 1993
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
st
Reserved on 21 of August, 2026
th
Pronounced on 19 of November, 2026
th
Uploaded on 20 of November, 2026
Whether only operative part of the judgment is pronounced? No
Whether full judgment is pronounced? Ye s
CWP No.8981 of 1993
Amarjit Singh and another ....Petitioners
Versus
The Financial Commissioner, Revenue, Punjab and others .....Respondents
CWP No.11214 of 1993
Surjan Singh (deceased) through LRs and another ....Petitioners
Versus
The Financial Commissioner, Revenue, Punjab and others .....Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR JUSTICE PANKAJ JAIN
Present: Mr. Ashwani K. Chopra, Senior Advocate with
Ms. Ridhima Khindria, Advocate
for the petitioners in CWP-8981-1993 and
for respondents No.4 and 5 in CWP-11214-1993.
Mr. Akhil Ahuja, Advocate
for the petitioners in CWP-11214-1993 and
for respondent No.4 in CWP-8981-1993.
Mr. H.P.S. Ishar, Addl. Advocate General, Punjab.
PANKAJ JAIN, J.
By way of instant order, I intend to dispose off the afore-
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.20 17:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.8981 of 1993 2
CWP No.11214 of 1993
captioned two writ petitions.
2. CWP No.11214 of 1993 is at the behest of the landowners.
CWP No.8981 of 1993 is at the behest of transferees.
3. For convenience, the facts are being culled out from CWP
No.11214 of 1993.
4. Petitioner No.1 Surjan Singh furnished a declaration in
prescribed Form under Section 5(1) of the Punjab Land Reforms Act, 1972
(hereinafter referred to as 'the 1972 Act'). As per the same, petitioner No.1
claimed to be owner of 189 Kanal 8 Marlas of land in village Kamal Wala
on the appointed date, i.e., 24.01.1971. It was further claimed that petitioner
No.2 owns land measuring 67 Kanal 3 Marlas apart from their sons owning
land measuring 216 Kanal 15 Marlas. Thus, the total land holding of the
petitioners including their sons, was 12.2951 hectares. Petitioner No.2, i.e.,
Binder Kaur, wife of petitioner No.1, sold 136 Kanal 2 Marlas, i.e., 3.4400
hectares first quality land to respondent No.4 and 67 Kanal 2 Marlas, i.e.,
1.8443 hectares first quality land to respondent No.5 through registered sale
deeds dated 09.05.1972. Collector (Agrarian), Fazilka vide order dated
03.10.1977 (Annexure P-1) decided the surplus area case ignoring sales
made by petitioner No.2 in favour of respondents No.4 and 5. The land was
declared surplus.
5. Two separate appeals were preferred before the Divisional
Commissioner against order dated 03.10.1977 (Annexure P-1). JA No.86 of
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.20 17:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.8981 of 1993 3
CWP No.11214 of 1993
1978 was filed by petitioner No.1 Surjan Singh. JA No.13 of 1978 was filed
by respondents No.4 and 5.
6. Appeal preferred by petitioner No.1 Surjan Singh was accepted
vide order dated 28.04.1980 (Annexure P-2) holding that sales made by
petitioner No.2 in favour of respondents No.4 and 5 need to be accepted.
Divisional Commissioner, accordingly, held that there is no surplus area in
the hands of Surjan Singh.
7. Appeal preferred by respondents No.4 and 5 was decided vide
order dated 19.11.1981 (Annexure P-3) by the Divisional Commissioner
upholding the order passed by the Collector. Thus, in two separate appeals
preferred against same order dated 03.10.1977 (Annexure P-1), two
divergent views were taken by the Divisional Commissioner. Vide order
dated 28.04.1980 (Annexure P-2), the order Annexure P-1 was set aside
whereas vide order dated 19.11.1981 (Annexure P-3), the order Annexure P-
1 was upheld.
8. It appears that Collector Agrarian, Fazilka sought clarification
as to which order needs to be implemented. Divisional Commissioner vide
communication dated 05.10.1982 sought permission to review order dated
28.04.1980, i.e., Annexure P-2. The permission was granted.
9. Commissioner accordingly passed order dated 17.09.1984
(Annexure P-4) reviewing order dated 28.04.1980 (Annexure P-2). The
same was set aside and the order dated 19.11.1981 (Annexure P-3) was
upheld to govern the rights of the parties.
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.20 17:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.8981 of 1993 4
CWP No.11214 of 1993
10. Two separate revisions were preferred against order dated
17.09.1984 (Annexure P-4). ROR No.284 of 1984-85 was at the behest of
transferees, i.e., respondents No.4 and 5 in the present writ petition. ROR
No.319 of 1984-85 was at the behest of petitioner No.1 Surjan Singh.
11. Both revision petitions stand dismissed vide order dated
27.04.1993 (Annexure P-5).
12. Accordingly, these two writ petitions have been preferred.
13. CWP No.11214 of 1993 is at the behest of big land owner
Surjan Singh and his wife Binder Kaur. CWP No.8981 is at the behest of
transferees under Binder Kaur.
14. Learned Senior Counsel while assailing the orders dated
17.09.1984 and 27.04.1993 (Annexures P-4 and P-5) would submit that the
review itself is impermissible. Different findings recorded by two different
officers exercising the same power, cannot be a ground to review the order.
It has been further contended that permission was sought from the Financial
Commissioner to review specifically the order dated 28.04.1980 (Annexure
P-2) which shows a predetermined mind. Prior to seeking permission for
review of order dated 28.04.1980, no opportunity of hearing was granted to
the petitioners. He submits that the authorities have failed to take into
consideration that the sale deeds were executed in favour of Amarjit Singh
and Paramjit Singh by petitioner No.2-Binder Kaur prior to Act came into
nd
force on 2 of April 1973. The sale deeds have been ignored merely on the
ground that no specific khasra number was mentioned in which the
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.20 17:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.8981 of 1993 5
CWP No.11214 of 1993
transferees were put in possession of, ignoring the fact that the sale was of a
share by a co-sharer. He submits that inadequacy of sale price cannot be a
ground to set aside the sale deeds. The parties are not related to each other.
Sale deeds having been registered on payment of valid sale considerations
and the mutations having been sanctioned, the sale deeds cannot be held to
be not bona fide transfers.
15. I have heard counsel for the parties and have carefully gone
through records of the case.
16. Facts are not much in dispute. The issue that falls for
consideration of this Court, is:

“Whether the land transferred by Binder Kaur in favour of
respondents No.4 and 5 by way of registered sale deeds dated
09.05.1972 needs to be ignored or not while computing surplus
land in the hands of Surjan Singh?”
17. Section 4 of the 1972 Act deals with permissible area and the
same reads as under:
“4. Permissible area – (1) Subject to the provisions of section 5,
no person shall own or hold as landowner or mortgagee with
possession or tenant or partly in one capacity and partly in another
in excess of the permissible area].
(2) `Permissible area’ shall mean in respect of –
(a) land under assured irrigation and capable of yielding
at least two crops in a year (hereinafter in this Act
referred to as `the first quality land’) seven hectares;
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.20 17:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.8981 of 1993 6
CWP No.11214 of 1993
or
(b) land under assured irrigation for only one crop in a
year, eleven hectares; or
(c) barani land, 20.5 hectares; or
(d) land of other classes including banjar land, an area
to be determined accordingly to the prescribed scale
with reference to the intensity of irrigation,
productivity and soil classification of such classes
having regard to the respective valuation and the
permissible area of the classes of land mentioned at
(a), (b) and (c), above [subject to the condition that
the area so determined shall not exceed 21.8
hectares].
Provided that—
(i) where land consists of two or more classes, the
permissible area shall be determined on the basis of
relative valuation of such classes of land, subject to
the condition that it does not exceed 21.8 hectares;
(ii) where the number of member of a family exceeds
five, the permissible area shall be increased by one-
fifth of the permissible area for each member in
excess of five, subject to the condition that
additional land shall be allowed for not more than
three such members.
(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (2),
where any land is comprised in an orchard [on the appointed day],
such land shall, for the purpose of determining the permissible
area, be treated as barani land.
[(4)(a) Where a person is a member of a registered co-
operative farming society, his share in the land held by such society
together with his other land, if any, or if such person is a member
of a family, together with the land held by every member of the
family shall be taken into account for determining the permissible
area;
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.20 17:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.8981 of 1993 7
CWP No.11214 of 1993
(b) Where a person is a member of a family, the land
held by such person together with the land held by
every other member of the family, whether
individually or jointly, shall be taken into account
for determining the permissible area].
(5) In determining the permissible area any land which was
transferred by sale, gift or otherwise, other than a bona fide sale or
transfer, after the appointed day but before the commencement of
this Act, shall be taken into account as if such land had not been
transferred and the onus of proving the transfer as bona fide shall
be on the transferor.
(6) For the purpose of valuation of land one and quarter
hectares of banjar land shall be treated as equivalent in value to one
hectare of barani land.
(7) For evaluating the land of any person at any time under
this Act, the land owned by him immediately before the
commencement of this Act as well as the land acquired by him
after such commencement by inheritance, bequest or gift from a
person to whom he is an heir shall be evaluated as if the evaluation
was being made on the appointed day and the land acquired by him
after such commencement in any other manner shall be evaluated
as if the evaluation was being made on the date of such
acquisition.”

18. In terms of Section 4(5), a sale or transfer, after the appointed
day but before the commencement of this Act, needs to be taken into
account subject to discharge of onus of proving the same as bona fide by the
transferor.
19. In the present case, the sale deeds in favour of respondents No.4
and 5 are after the appointed day but prior to the date on which the Act came
into being. Thus, the petitioners have a right to prove that the transfer made
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.20 17:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.8981 of 1993 8
CWP No.11214 of 1993
by petitioner No.2 in favour of respondents No.4 and 5 is a bona fide
transfer.
20. Considering valuable right vested not only in petitioners but
also in respondents No.4 and 5, this Court finds that prior to seeking
permission from Financial Commissioner to review order dated 28.04.1980
(Annexure P-2) passed by Commissioner, Ferozepur Division, stakeholders
were required to be heard. The fact that the permission was sought only to
review order dated 28.04.1980 leads to inference that the authority acted
with predetermined mind to review order dated 28.04.1980 and to uphold the
conflicting order dated 19.11.1981.
21. In view thereof, this Court finds that the approach of the
authorities in reviewing the order dated 28.04.1980 cannot be sustained. As
a consequence thereof, order dated 17.09.1984 (Annexure P-4) passed by
Commissioner and the order dated 27.04.1993 (Annexure P-5) passed by
Financial Commissioner upholding the same, cannot be sustained and are
hereby set aside.
22. Accordingly, the matter is remanded back to Divisional
Commissioner to hear all the parties, i.e., petitioners, respondents as well as
the State Authorities and, thereafter, to consider both the orders, i.e.,
Annexure P-2 and P-3 and decide whether any of them needs to be reviewed
or not.
23. The parties are directed to appear before the Divisional
Commissioner, Ferozepur, on 01.12.2026.
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.20 17:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.8981 of 1993 9
CWP No.11214 of 1993
24. Needless to observe here that while deciding these writ
petitions, this Court has not opined on the sale deeds in question. The issue
w.r.t. the sale deeds being bona fide or not shall be decided by the Revenue
Authorities after taking into consideration the evidence on record without
being prejudiced by any observation made by this Court in the instant order.
25. The instant writ petitions are accordingly disposed off.
26. A copy of this order be kept on the file of other connected case.
November 19, 2026 (Pankaj Jain)
Dpr Judge
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.20 17:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document