Monika And Anr vs Manmohan And Ors

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CR-3455-2025 (O&M) -:1:-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
CR-3455-2025 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 17.11.2026
Monika and Another
… Petitioners
Versus
Manmohan and Others
... Respondents
-.-
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIRINDER AGGARWAL
Present:- Mr. Manmeet Singh Rana, Advocate
for the petitioners.
Mr. Varun Aryan Sharma, Advocate
for the respondents.
-.-
VIRINDER AGGARWAL , J . (Oral)
1. The present revision petition has been preferred under Article
227 of the Constitution of India, invoking the supervisory jurisdiction of
this Court, to assail the order dated 02.01.2025 (Annexure P-4) passed by
the Civil Judge (Junior Division), Ambala, whereby the petitioners’
application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC (Annexure P-2), seeking
rejection of the plaint, was dismissed. The petitioners seek setting aside of
the impugned order and stay of further proceedings before the Trial Court
during the pendency of the present petition, along with any other
appropriate relief deemed fit in the facts and circumstances of the case.
2. Briefly stated, respondents No. 1 to 4 instituted a suit for
possession by way of specific performance of an alleged agreement to sell
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.17 16:48
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CR-3455-2025 (O&M) -:2:-
dated 03.03.2002, concerning Plot No. 6, measuring 190 square yards, for
a sale consideration of 74,100/-. The petitioners deny its execution and ₹
contend that the suit, instituted on 03.07.2023, more than 21 years
thereafter and after the death of the alleged executant on 06.03.2019, is
hopelessly barred by limitation. Their application under Order VII Rule 11
CPC was, however, dismissed by the Trial Court vide order dated
02.01.2025, giving rise to the present revision petition.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioners contended that the Trial
Court had erred in dismissing the application under Order VII Rule 11
CPC, despite the suit having been instituted on 03.07.2023, more than 21
years after the alleged agreement to sell dated 03.03.2002. It was
emphasised that the original executant, Karam Chand, remained alive until
06.03.2019 but never initiated any proceedings for enforcement of the
alleged agreement during his lifetime. Learned counsel argued that the
respondents had failed to disclose any legally sustainable explanation for
such prolonged inaction and that the claim was ex facie barred by
limitation. Accordingly, it was urged that the impugned order be set aside
and the plaint rejected under Order VII Rule 11 CPC.
4. Learned counsel for respondents, controverting the
submissions advanced on behalf of the petitioners, contended that the issue
of limitation could not be conclusively determined at the threshold, as it
required examination of the terms of the alleged agreement, the stipulated
date for performance and the attending circumstances. It was further
submitted that the respondents, being the legal heirs of the original
executant, were competent to enforce the contractual rights devolving
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.17 16:48
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CR-3455-2025 (O&M) -:3:-
upon them and that the denial of the agreement’s execution and
genuineness raised disputed questions of fact requiring evidence. Learned
counsel argued that, since the alleged bar of limitation was not apparent
from the plaint itself, the Trial Court had rightly declined rejection under
Order VII Rule 11 CPC. Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that
the question of limitation ordinarily constitutes a mixed question of law
and fact and, where the bar is not apparent from the plaint, rejection
thereof at the threshold is unwarranted. Reliance was placed upon the
following judicial pronouncements titled as Suman @ Suman Punia vs.
Chameli, Law Finder Doc ID #2856940; Babasaheb Ramdas Shirole
and Ors. vs. Rohit Enterprises and Ors. 2026(1) RCR(Civil) 60;
Kulabandhu Ram Adarsh Sharma vs. Nam Estates Private Limited
and Another, Law Finder Doc ID #2789332; Krishan Chand and
Others vs. Nawab Singh (Dead) and Others, Law Finder Doc ID #
2786150 and Harjinder Pal Singh vs. Narender Kumar Nangia, Law
Finder Doc ID # 2981565 . Accordingly, dismissal of the revision petition
was sought.
5. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and, with their
able assistance, having meticulously scrutinised the paper-book, this Court
finds that, while adjudicating an application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC,
the Court is required to consider the averments contained in the plaint,
read as a whole, along with the documents relied upon by the plaintiff.
5.1. The impugned application was dismissed primarily on the
reasoning that the plaintiff had explained the delay by pleading that he
acquired knowledge of death of defendant No.2, daughter of the original
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.17 16:48
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CR-3455-2025 (O&M) -:4:-
vendor, only subsequently and that registration of sale deeds in the area
had remained suspended. The Trial Court further observed that the
agreement was open-ended in nature and that the question of limitation
involved disputed questions of fact.
5.2. No doubt, limitation ordinarily constitutes a mixed question of
law and fact; however, there is no absolute bar against rejection of a plaint
under Order VII Rule 11(d) CPC where the suit is ex facie barred by
limitation on the basis of the averments of plaint themselves. In the present
case, the respondent-plaintiff seeks specific performance of an agreement
to sell dated 30.03.2002, which expressly records that, owing to the
suspension of registration of sale deeds in Ambala, the sale deed would be
executed upon resumption of registration, whenever required by the
vendee. Significantly, as pleaded in paragraph 6 of the plaint, the
restriction on registration in Ambala City had been lifted well before 2019.
The cause of action, therefore, prima facie acumen with reference to the
date of resumption of registration, whereas, in paragraph 17, the
respondent-plaintiff has pleaded that the cause of action arose upon
defendant No. 1’s refusal to execute the sale deed. Accordingly,
paragraphs 6 and 17 of the plaint assume significance and are reproduced
as under:-
6. That later on when the Plaintiffs' father Sh. Karam Chand came to
know that the government had lifted the ban of execution and
registration of the sale deed for the properties in the Shivpuri
locality of Ambala City, he made several efforts to contact the
Defendants No.1 and 2 for execution and registration of the sale
deed for the above said plot. But there were no response from the
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.17 16:48
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CR-3455-2025 (O&M) -:5:-
Defendants No.1 and 2. Meanwhile said Sh. Karam Chand had
died on 06.03.2019 leaving behind the Plaintiffs as his legal heir (A
true photocopy of the death certificate of said Sh. Karam Chand is
annexed herewith). After death of their father, Sh. Karam Chand,
the Plaintiffs being the legal heirs/representative of their father, Sh.
Karam Chand (since deceased) are legally entitled to get the
ownership of the said plot transferred in their name. Accordingly,
the Plaintiffs tried to contact the Defendants on their address (as
mentioned in the said agreement to sell), but the Plaintiffs came to
know that the Defendant No.2, namely, Smt. Amarjit Kaur @
Amarjit Singla had also died and after her death, the Defendant
No.1 is the legal heir of her mother i.e. Defendant No.2 and also
that after death of her mother, the Defendant No.1, had moved to
some new location.
17. That cause of action has arisen in favour of the Plaintiffs and
against the Defendants when the Defendant No. 1 refused to
accede to the genuine requests of the Plaintiffs and she refused to
execute and get registered sale deed of the suit property in favour
of the Plaintiffs and the cause of action further arose in favour of
the Plaintiffs and against the Defendants when the Defendant No.1
threatened the Plaintiffs to execute and get registered the sale deed
of the suit property in favour of someone else with the help of the
employees/officials of the Defendant No.3 and the cause of action
is still continuing one .
6. A conjoint reading of the aforesaid paragraphs of the plaint
clearly reveals that the father of the respondents-plaintiffs expired on
06.03.2019, whereas the restriction on registration of sale deeds had been
lifted during his lifetime. Despite resumption of registration, he repeatedly
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.17 16:48
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CR-3455-2025 (O&M) -:6:-
approached defendants No. 1 and 2 for execution of the sale deed, but his
requests remained unheeded. Thus, the cause of action had accrued to him
during his lifetime upon refusal by the defendants to honour his requests.
Even if the period of limitation of three years is reckoned from
06.03.2019, the date of demise, the prescribed period expired on
06.03.2022, whereas the suit was instituted only on 03.07.2023. The suit
was, therefore, ex facie barred by limitation, as borne out from the
averments contained in the plaint itself. The Civil Judge, thus, committed a
material error in dismissing the application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC,
particularly when the statutory bar of limitation was discernible from the
plaintiff's own pleadings. Accordingly, the present petition is allowed and
the plaint is rejected under Order VII Rule 11(d) CPC.
7. In view of the final disposal of the principal matter, all
pending miscellaneous applications, if any, stand disposed of accordingly.
No further orders are warranted.
( VIRINDER AGGARWAL )
17.11.2026 JUDGE
Gaurav Sorot
Whether reasoned / speaking? Yes / No
Whether reportable? Yes / No
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.17 16:48
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document