SRI T MADHU vs SMT. NAGARATHNAMMA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 16 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO.1441 OF 2016 (PAR)
BETWEEN:
SRI T MADHU
S/O THIPPESWAMY
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
C/O NALANDA COLLEGE
JAGALUR TOWN – 577 512.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. D.P.MAHESH, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. SMT. NAGARATHNAMMA
W/O CHANDRASHEKHARAPPA
AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS
R/O D NO.520/68, VIGNESHWARA KRUPA
BEHIND BHAVANI RICE MILL
ST
1 MAIN, SHIVAKUMARASWAMY BADAVANE,
NEAR SANJEEVINI ANJANEYA TEMPLE
DAVANAGERE – 577 005.
2. VEERABHADRAPPA
S/O MAHESHWARAPPA
AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
RETIRED ENGINEER
NO.955/7, SMT VIJAYA NIVAS HADADI ROAD
NEAR SHIVAKUMARASWAMY BADAVANE
BUS STOP, DAVANAGERE – 577 005.
3. SRI B M VEERANNA
S/O MAHESHWARAPPA
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS
AGRICULTURIST
PETE VASAVANNA TEMPLE STREET
JAGALUR TOWN – RESIDENT OF NEAR KAMATA,
RAMALAYA ROAD,
JAGALUR TOWN – 577 528.
Digitally
signed by
VANDANA S
Location:
High Court of
Karnataka
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
4. SMT VINODAMMA
W/O VIRUPAKSHAPPA
AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS
HOUSEHOLD GUNDAMUNUGU VILLAGE
VIA CHIKKAJOGOHALLI
KUDLIGI TALUK – 583 126.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. S V PRAKASH, ADVOCATE FOR R-1 & R-4;
SRI. R. GOPAL, ADVOCATE FOR R-2 & R-3)
THIS RSA IS FILED UNDER SEC.100 OF CPC AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 19.02.2016 PASSED IN RA NO.104/2010
ON THE FILE OF THE I ADDL. DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE,
DAVANAGERE, DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND CONFIRMING THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 21.04.2010 PASSED IN OS NO.103/2008
ON THE FILE OF THE I ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN), DAVANGERE.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION , THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
The appellant was defendant No.4 in O.S.No.103/2008
instituted by respondent No.1 – Smt. Nagarathnamma / plaintiff for
partition and separate possession of her alleged share in the suit
schedule immovable properties and for other reliefs.
2. The respondent No.1 – plaintiff instituted the aforesaid
suit interalia contending that she was the sister of defendant Nos.1
and 2 viz Veerabhadrappa and Veeranna while defendant No.3
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
Vinodamma was their sister. It was contended that the plaintiff and
defendant Nos.1 to 3 were members of a Hindu undivided family
and the suit schedule immovable properties were joint family
properties, in which the plaintiff and defendant Nos.1 to 3 were
th
entitled to 1/4 share each. It was contended that since the
defendants did not effect partition of the suit schedule immovable
properties and put the plaintiff in separate possession of her
alleged share in the suit schedule properties, the plaintiff instituted
the instant suit for partition and for other reliefs. The defendant
No.3 remained ex-parte before the Trial Court while defendant
Nos.1, 2 and 4 appeared through their respective counsel and filed
separate written statement. According to defendant Nos.1 and 2,
they did not dispute their relationship interse between the plaintiff
and defendant Nos.1 to 3 and admitted that the plaintiff was
th
entitled to her legitimate 1/4 share in the suit schedule properties
and paid the requisite Court fee and sought for suit to be decreed
as sought for by the plaintiff. However, appellant – defendant No.4
filed a separate written statement disputing and denying the
various allegations and claim made by the plaintiff and interalia
contended that the suit schedule properties were the separate and
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
self-acquired properties of defendant Nos.1 and 2, who had
executed a Sale Agreement dated 16.11.2006 in favour of
defendant No.4, who had instituted one more suit in
O.S.No.114/2008 against defendant Nos.1 and 2 for specific
performance of the aforesaid Sale Agreement and other reliefs and
that the said suit was pending adjudication and consequently,
sought for dismissal of the present suit filed by the plaintiff.
3. On the basis of pleadings of the parties, the Trial Court
framed the following issues:
“1) Whether the plaintiff proves that the suit
properties are the joint family properties of herself and
defendants No.1 to 3 ?
2) Whether the plaintiff further proves her joint
possession over the suit properties along with
defendants No.1 to 3 ?
3) If so, whether the plaintiff is entitled to claim her
th
alleged 1/4 share in the suit properties ?
4) Whether the plaintiff further proves the alleged
attempt of defendants No.1 & 2 of alienating the suit
th
properties to the 4 defendant ?
5) If so, whether the plaintiff is entitled to seek the
relief of permanent injunction as prayed for?
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
6) Whether the fourth defendant proves that the
suit property is the separate property of defendants
Nos.1 & 2 ?
7) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the relief
claimed in the suit ?
8) What order or decree?
4. Plaintiff examined herself as PW1 and documentary
evidence at Ex.P1 to Ex.P10 were marked on her behalf.
Defendant No.4 – appellant examined himself as DW1 and
documentary evidence at Ex.D1 to Ex.D14 were marked on behalf
of defendants.
5. After hearing the parties, the Trial Court came to the
conclusion that the suit schedule properties were the joint family
properties of the plaintiff and defendant Nos.1 to 3 and that the
alleged Sale Agreement dated 16.11.2006 was not binding upon
th
the alleged 1/4 share of the plaintiff and defendant No.3 over the
suit schedule properties and consequently, decreed the suit of the
plaintiff against the defendants. However, the Trial Court took note
of the fact that the other suit in O.S.No.114/2008 instituted by the
appellant – defendant No.4 for specific performance of the Sale
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
Agreement dated 16.11.2006 was pending before the Trial Court
as on that day and consequently, adequately safeguarded the
claim of the appellant – defendant No.4 by directing him to workout
his remedies in the said suit by holding as under:
“9. Issue Nos.1, 2 & 6 :- Since all these issues are
interconnected, they are tried together to avoid repetition of
facts. It is the specific case made out by the plaintiff that the
suit schedule properties are the joint family properties of
herself and defendants 1 to 3, which were originally
belonged to her father Maheshwarappa, and she being his
daughter and sister of defendants 1 to 3, she is also one of
the co-owners of the suit properties, having been in the joint
possession of the same along with the defendants 1 to 3. It is
her further case that after the death of her father she along
with the defendants 1 to 3 continued to enjoy the suit
properties jointly, even though the khata of the suit properties
came to be mutated in the names of defendants 1 and 2. To
substantiate her claim she has relied upon documents which
are marked from Ex.P1 to P10. Ex.P1 and P2 are the RTC
and Index of Lands pertaining to suit item No.2 property
standing in the name of deceased Maheshwarappa. To show
that after his death the first and second defendants got
mutated their names to suit item No.1 property, she has
produced the Mutation Register Extract and RTCs pertaining
to this property which are marked from Ex.P4 to P6. In
support of these documentary evidence, she has deposed
before the court as PW1 reiterating the plaint averments. Per
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
contra, as against this claim of PW1, admittedly we have no
dispute or defence from the first and second defendants, as
they have not contested the matter, although they have filed
their written statement, whereas the third defendant has
remained exparte. The first and second defendants have
though denied the allegation of their refusing to effect
partition in the suit properties, they have admitted the
jointness of the properties and have also claimed their
respective shares in the suit properties.
10. The only contesting defendant in this case is the
fourth defendant, who claims to be the agreement holder of
the suit item No.1 property from first and second defendants.
According to the defence of this defendant, he has entered
into a registered sale agreement marked at Ex.D4 with
respect to the suit item No.1 property with the first and
second defendants, who had represented before him to be
the absolute owners of the suit item No.1 property. Thus, this
defendant has denied the claim of PW1 that the suit
properties are her joint family properties. The fourth
defendant has also set up a plea of earlier partition in the
family of PW1 and defendants 1 to 3, which defence has not
been proved by him. One material aspect to be noted here is
that the competent parties to question this disputed fact are
the defendants 1 to 3 who are the brothers and sister of
PW1, who have admittedly not attempted to contest the
matter. On the contrary, they themselves have admitted the
fact that the suit properties are their joint family properties.
The various documents produced before the court by PW1
which are marked from Ex.P1 to P10 nowhere disclose the
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
fact of any such earlier partition amongst the family members
of plaintiff and defendants 1 to 3. On the other hand, it is
material to note that although defendants 1 and 2 have got
mutated their names to the suit properties as per Ex.P4 and
P7, but their names are not entered to the records of these
properties by virtue of any partition deed, but the documents
clearly disclose the fact that they got mutated their names to
the suit properties by inheritance after the death of their
father. As against these documents, admittedly we have not
contra materials from the contesting fourth defendant to
prove the alleged earlier partition in the family of plaintiff and
defendants 1 to 3. Even the own documents produced by
DW1 nowhere disclose the fact of any such earlier partition.
Even there is unequivocal admission on the part of DW1 in
this regard, in his cross examination at para 3 wherein he
has admitted this fact as under :
“zÁªÁ LlA £ÀA.1 ªÀÄvÀÄÛ 2gÀ D¹ÛUÀ¼ÀÄ ªÀĺÉñÀégÀ¥Àà EªÀjAzÀ CªÀgÀ
ªÀÄPÀ̽UÉ §A¢ªÉ JAzÀgÉ ¤d, CzÉà jÃw zÁªÁ LlA £ÀA.3 ªÀÄ£É ªÉÆzÀ®Ä
AiÀiÁjUÉ ¸ÉÃjvÀÄÛ JAzÀgÉ £À£ÀUÉ UÉÆwÛ®è.”
In his further cross examination at para 5 DW1 has
admitted as under :
“ªÀĺÉñÀégÀ¥Àà EªÀgÀ PÀÄlÄA§zÀ°è «¨sÁUÀ DVzÉ JA§ §UÉÎ CªÀgÀ ªÀÄPÀ̼ÀÄ
ºÉýzÀÝ£ÀÄß ºÉÆgÀvÀÄ ¥Àr¹ £Á£ÀÄ ¨ÉÃgÉ zÁR¯ÉUÀ¼À£ÀÄß £ÉÆÃr®è, D jÃw «¨sÁUÀ DzÀ
§UÉÎ zÁR¯ÉUÀ¼À£ÀÄß PÉÆqÀĪÀAvÉ £Á£ÀÄ ºÉüÀ°®è, D jÃw «¨sÁUÀ DVzÉAiÉÆÃ E®èªÉÇÃ
JAzÀÄ w½zÀÄPÉÆ¼Àî®Ä £Á£ÀÄ G¥À£ÉÆÃAzÀuÁ¢üPÁj PÀqɬÄAzÀ zÁR¯ÉUÀ¼À£ÀÄß
vÉUɸÀ°®è.”
Thus, what can be gathered from the above
admission of DW1 is that except the hearsay information, he
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
has no personal knowledge about the fact as to whether
there has been partition in the family of the plaintiff and
defendants 1 to 3, from which the only inference which could
be drawn is that the suit schedule properties are the joint
family properties of PW1 and defendants 1 to 3, after the
death of their father Maheshwarappa.
11. However, the defendant No.4 produced some
documents at Ex.D10 and D11, which are the Assessment
and Khata Extracts of D.No. 955, standing in the name of the
first defendant to show that this property is also the joint
family property of defendants 1 to 3 and for the non-inclusion
of this property in the present suit schedule, the suit of the
plaintiff is untenable, but in his cross examination he has
clearly pleaded his ignorance as to the fact that the first
defendant had purchased this property while he was in
service. It would be relevant to refer that material piece of his
statement, which is evident from his cross examination at
para 9, which reads thus:
“qÉÆÃgï £ÀA.955 D¹Û, 1£Éà ¥ÀæwªÁ¢AiÀÄ MlÄÖ PÀÄlÄA§zÀ D¹ÛAiÀiÁVgÀÄvÀÛzÉ
CªÀgÀÄ ¸ÀzÀj D¹ÛAiÀÄ£ÀÄß AiÀiÁªÁUÀ Rjâ¹zÁÝgÉ JA§ §UÉÎ zÁR¯ÉUÀ¼ÀÄ E®è. 1£ÉÃ
¥ÀæwªÁ¢ ¸ÀgÀPÁj £ËPÀjAiÀİèzÀÄÝ FUÀ ¸ÉêɬÄAzÀ ¤ªÀÈvÀÛgÁVzÁÝgÉ JAzÀgÉ ¤d.
CªÀgÀÄ ¸ÀgÀPÁj ¸ÉêÉAiÀİèzÁÝUÀ vÀªÀÄä ¸ÀéAvÀ zÀÄrªÉĬÄAzÀ PÉ®ªÀÅ D¹ÛUÀ¼À£ÀÄß
Rjâ¹zÀÝgÀÄ JAzÀgÉ £À£ÀUÉ UÉÆwÛ®è.”
Thus, the above statement of DW1 clearly proves that
he has utterly failed to prove that the properties comprised in
Ex.D10 and D11 are the properties purchased by defendant
No.1 out of joint family funds.
12. Though DW1 has denied the joint possession of
PW1 over the suit properties, but the fact that she is the
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
daughter of deceased Maheshwarappa and sister of
defendants 1 to 3, has not been denied by him, nor it could
be disproved by him that the suit properties are the joint
family properties of PW1 and defendants 1 to 3. Under such
circumstances, although she is a married daughter and
residing away from the suit properties, she continues to be
the joint owner of the suit properties along with defendants 1
to 3, so far as her status is concerned. Though an attempt
has been made by the fourth defendant to deny the status of
P.W-1 as the joint owner of the suit schedule property by
stating that she has no right to claim share in the suit
properties in view of the fact that the propositus
Maheshwarappa died in the year 2002, whereas P.W-1 is
proved to have been married prior to 1956 and as such she
has no right to claim share in the suit properties. This
contention of the fourth defendant cannot be accepted for the
simple reason that P.W-1 is claiming share in the schedule
properties not as a coparcener along with defendants No.1 to
3, but that she is claiming share in the schedule properties in
the capacity as a joint owner of the same, since it is her
definite case that the suit schedule properties are the
properties purchased by her father Maheshwarappa and as
such these properties are not their ancestral properties.
Therefore, the question of she becoming the coparcener to
claim share in the schedule properties does not arise.
Therefore, viewed from all these angles it can safely be held
that P.W-1 could be successful to prove that the suit
schedule properties are the joint family properties of herself
and defendants No.1 to 3 and that she is in joint possession
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
of the suit schedule properties. On the contrary the fourth
defendant has miserably failed to prove that these schedule
properties are the self acquired properties of defendants
No.1 and 2. Therefore, I answer all these issues accordingly
thereby answering the first and second issues in favour of
the plaintiff in the affirmative and the sixth issue against the
fourth defendant in the Negative.
13. Issue Nos.3 to 5 & 7 :- Since all these issues are
interconnected they are tried together to avoid repetition of
facts. As I have already discussed above, now it is proved
that the suit schedule properties are the joint family
properties of P.W-1 and defendants No.1 to 3 and as such
she is also entitled to claim share in the schedule properties
along with the defendants No.1 to 3. As regards the fourth
issue to the effect that defendants No.1 and 2 are attempting
to alienate the suit item No.1 property to the fourth
defendant, whether D.W-1 could prove that there has been
an agreement of sale with respect to this property in his
favour by defendants No.1 and 2. So far as this aspect is
concerned there is not denial on the part of D.W-1 or
defendants No.1 and 2, since the defendants No.1 and 2
though have filed their W.S admitting the claim of P.W-1,
nowhere they have specifically denied the fact that they had
agreed to sell the suit item No.1 property to fourth defendant
under the registered sale agreement which is produced by
D.W-1 at Ex.D4. It is a registered sale agreement under
which defendants No.1 and 2 as well as the son of the first
defendant Shivakiran had agreed to sell the suit item No.1
property to D.W-1 for a valuable consideration of
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
Rs.2,25,000/- per acre by receiving Rs.5,00,000/- as earnest
amount from him and have agreed to execute the sale deed
within one year from the date of the execution of Ex.D4 after
getting measured the schedule property through the
competent surveyor. Though P.W-1 has denied that
defendants No.1 and 2 have executed Ex.D4 in favour of
D.W-1, but she could not disprove the said aspect in view of
the fact that defendants No.1 and 2 themselves have not
disputed this aspect, nor they have contested the suit by
adducing any oral or documentary evidence to deny Ex.D4.
Even D.W-1 has not at all been cross examined by the
counsel for the defendants No.1 and 2 to deny the execution
of Ex.D4, which clearly establishes the admission of D.Ws.1
and 2 regarding the execution of Ex.D4 in favour of D.W-1.
14. It is also an undisputed fact that D.W-1 in order to
get the registered sale deed executed from defendants No.1
and 2 in pursuance of Ex.D4 has filed a suit for specific
performance against defendants No.1 and 2 as well as
against the said Shivakiran the son of the first defendant in
OS.No.114/08 which is evident from the order of the first
defendant in OS.No.114/08 which is marked at Ex.D12 as
well as the sheet of this proceeding which is marked at
Ex.D13 and the W.S plaint copy in the said suit which is
marked at Ex.D14. All these three documents have remained
uncontraverted and undisputed by the defendants No.1 and
2 and also by the plaintiff. If Ex.D14 is perused, there is a
categorical admission on the part of the present D.W-1 who
was the second defendant in that said suit with regard to the
execution of Ex.D4 in favour of D.W-1 although he has
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
denied the claim of the present D.W-1 in the said suit with
regard to the failure of defendants No.1 and 2 to perform
their part of contract by executing registered sale deed in his
favour. On the contrary the defence putforth by the present
first defendant in the said suit is that the plaintiff therein i.e.,
the present D.W-1 had never approached them for the
payment of balance sale consideration amount and to get the
registered sale deed executed in his favour although they
have got rectified and measured the schedule property by
filing an application before the A.D.L.R, Davangere. The
present first defendant in the said suit had also referred
regarding the filing of the present suit by the present plaintiff
and by taking this contention the first defendant herein has
pleaded his inability to execute the registered sale deed in
favour of D.W-1 by pleading that since their sister i.e., the
present P.W.1 has filed this present suit seeking partition in
the schedule properties, they are unable to execute the
registered sale deed in favour of D.W-1 and they are ready
to refund the advance sale consideration amount paid by
D.W-1 to them. There is no dispute or denial with regard to
all these facts, which clearly implies that there is a clear
admission on the part of P.W-1 as well as defendants No.1
and 2 that they had agreed to sell the suit item No.1 property
to D.W-1 as per Ex.D4 agreement. Now the next crucial
aspect which remains for consideration is as to whether P.W-
1 can be held bound by this sale agreement and is debarred
from claiming share in this property.
15. According to P.W-1 she is not bound by the said
sale agreement at Ex.D4, since she is not a party to this
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
document nor she has consented or permitted defendants
No.1 and 2 to execute Ex.D4 in favour of D.W-1 thereby
including her share in the suit item No.1 property and as
such she cannot be held bound by this sale agreement which
is taken place beyond her back and as such it does not
bound her. However, the fact remains that by executing
Ex.D4 sale agreement in favour of the D.W-1, there has
been an attempt on the part of defendants No.1 and 2 to
alienate the suit item No.1 property in favour of D.W-1. The
fact that there has been no division or partition in the suit
schedule properties by metes and bounds amongst P.W-1
and defendants No.1 to 3 also stands established and there
is no dispute about the said aspect. Under such
circumstances certainly P.W-1 is entitled to restrain the
defendants No.1 and 2 from meddling with any portion of the
suit schedule properties until and unless the shares of the
parties are carved out by a decree of court by way of
partition. In other words defendants No.1 and 2 would get no
legal right to alienate any portion of the suit schedule
properties which is also inclusive of the property covered
under Ex.D4, unless and until the shares of the sharers are
determined. Therefore, so far as this attempt of defendants
No.1 and 2 to alienate the suit Item No.1 is concerned,
certainly P.W-1 is entitled to seek for equitable relief of
permanent injunction as against defendants No.1 and 2 until
the rights of the parties in the schedule properties are
established and their shares are amicably carved out by a
decree in the present suit.
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
16. As regards the entitlement of P.W-1 to claim the
relief of partition and separate possession of her 1/4th share
in the suit schedule properties is concerned, as I have
already discussed supra, there is no dispute or denial on the
part of defendants No.1 to 3 to give her legitimate share in
the suit schedule properties. On the contrary defendants
No.1 and 2 themselves have conceded to the fact that they
are ready to give share of P.W-1 in the suit schedule
properties. This admission of defendants No.1 and 2 who are
being one of the co-owners of the suit schedule properties
along with P.W-1 itself is sufficient to prove the entitlement of
P.W-1 to claim share in the schedule properties although
defendants No.1 to 3 are proved to have colluded with P.W-
1. The only contesting defendant i.e., fourth defendant has
specifically denied the entitlement of P.W-1 to claim share in
the suit item No.1 property although he has no specific
dispute or denial with regard to her claim over rest of
schedule properties. Even otherwise he being a totally
stranger to the family of P.W-1 and defendants No.1 to 3, will
have no voice to raise any objection with regard to the
entitlement of P.W-1 or defendants No.1 to 3 to claim their
legitimate shares in the suit schedule properties by way of
partition. His claim if any, would be restricted only to suit item
No.1 property which is agreed to be sold to him by
defendants No.1 and 2 under Ex.D4. However, defendant
No.4 has raised so many legal pleas to non-suit the plaintiff
from claiming share in the suit schedule properties, firstly on
the ground that the suit filed in the present form by not
including the other family properties in the suit is not
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
maintainable under law. In this regard D.W-1 has stated in
his evidence that defendants No.1 and 2 and son of first
defendant Shivakiran have also allegedly sold two other
family properties in favour of one Umashankar and
S.Manjunath under a registered sale deed Dt:08/07/2002
which is a landed property bearing Sy.No.31/1 measuring
7A-32G and the said registered sale deeds in this regard are
produced at Ex.D5 & D6. However, it is pertinent to note that
even as per these documents it is revealed that the
properties comprised in these sale deeds are prima facie
shown to have been sold by the father of P.W-1
Maheshwarappa and his sons i.e., defendants No.1 and 2
and the son of the first defendant Shivakiran. In other words
it is proved from the own document produced by D.W-1 that
these properties were sold not by defendants No.1 and 2 and
the said Shivakiran alone but that the father of defendants
No.1 and 2 and P.W-1 was also one of the parties to these
documents which clearly implies that these properties were
sold during the life time of the said Maheshwarappa who was
the owner of these properties. When the suit schedule
properties and the other family properties of P.W-1 and
defendants No.1 to 3 are not proved to be the ancestral or
coparcenary properties at the hands of P.W-1 and
defendants No.1 to 3, but when it is admitted by D.W-1
himself that even family properties were exclusively acquired
by the father of defendants No.1 to 3 and P.W-1
Maheshwarappa, then these properties are to be considered
as the self acquired properties of Maheshwarappa. Under
such circumstances the alienation of these properties during
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
his life time cannot be questioned by D.W-1 in this
proceeding. Therefore, the proposition of law laid down in the
rulings cited by the learned defence counsel with regard to
the partial partition, i.e., reported in Kenchegowda (since
deceased) by legal representatives V/s Siddegowada @
Motegowda in (1994) 4 Supreme Court Cases 294,
Kalloomal Tapeswari Prasad (HUF), Kanpur V/s The
C.I.T, Kanpur in 1982 AIR 716 , cannot be made applicable
to the facts on hand for the reasons which I have assigned
supra.
17. Another ground of defence raised by the fourth
defendant to non suit P.W-1 is with regard to her claiming
share in the suit schedule properties in favour of a legal bar
contained under the Hindu Succession Act. The learned
defence counsel vehemently argued that since the P.W-1 is
proved to have got married prior to 1956 and when
admittedly her father Maheshwarappa died in the year 2003,
then the succession has opened in the year 2003 to claim
partition by the legal heirs. Hence, P.W-1 cannot be held
entitled to claim partition in the family properties. To
substantiate his argument he has relied upon a decision
reported in M.Prithiviraj and others V/s Smt. Leelamma N
and others in ILR 2009 Karnataka 3612, wherein it has been
held while deciding the case involved in the said decision
that on facts of the said case before the Hon'ble High Court it
was proved that the succession was opened in the year
1969, i.e., earlier to the Amended Act 39 of 2005 coming into
force then the provisions of Amended Act would have no
obligation since the sons had obtained in the year 1969 and
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
consequently a coparcener would be held entitled to claim
share as per the Hindu Succession Act which was in force in
the year 1969 where the disputed properties are the
ancestral properties of deceased propositus and therefore in
such an event at a partition, the propositus was held entitled
to half share in which the legal heirs would be entitled to get
share as per the provisions of Hindu Succession Act which
was in force in the year 1969 and they cannot be benefited
with the Amended Provisions of 2005 Act. With due regards
to the proposition of law laid down in the above cited
decision it cannot be held that the same principles can be
extended to the facts on hand for the simple reason that the
suit properties in the instant case are now proved to be not
the ancestral or coparcenary properties of P.W-1 and
defendants No.1 to 3 since admittedly all these properties
are proved to have been acquired by deceased
Maheshwarappa which were his self acquisitions. Under
such circumstances as has been rightly argued by the
learned counsel for the plaintiff the provisions of Section 6 of
the Amended Act will have no application to the facts on
hand.
18. On the contrary the claim of P.W-1 in this case
would be governed by Section 8 of Hindu Succession Act
which applies to the provisions of a male Hindu dying
intestate and the devolution of interest of the said male
Hindu on his legal heirs would be as per the provisions
contemplated U/s 8 of the act and not as per Section 6 of the
Act which would exclusively deal with the devolution of
interest in case of a coparcenary property. Therefore, the
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
citation relied upon by the learned defence counsel would
not come to the aid of fourth defendant in any way. This
consequently proves that P.W-1 is entitled to claim her
legitimate share in the suit schedule property as one of the
co-owners along with the defendants No.1 to 3. However, the
facts and circumstances as on today clearly establish that
the fact that defendants No.1 and 2 have executed Ex.D4
sale agreement in favour of defendant No.4 has not at all
been denied by the either P.W-1 or by the defendants No.1
to 3. This proceeding being one for partition in the suit
schedule properties, this court has to merely decide or
determine the shares of the sharers and ultimate allotment of
the properties would take place only in the final decree
proceedings. Under such circumstances though the
defendants No.1 and 2 have sold the suit item No.1 property
to the fourth defendant, it is an undivided interest in this
property which has been agreed to be sold to D.W-1. Under
such circumstances though this sale transaction is not
binding on P.W-1, but at the same time this transaction binds
as regards the interest of defendants No.1 and 2 in the
schedule properties. Therefore, from the facts and
circumstances of the case it is now clearly proved by P.W-1
that she is entitled to her legitimate 1/4th share in the suit
schedule property and so also defendants No.1 to 3 are also
to be held entitled to equal 1/4th share in the suit properties.
Under such circumstances the fourth defendant being the
lawful agreement holder can agitate his name before the
competent court where he has already filed a suit for specific
performance based on Ex.D4. Therefore, keeping open the
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
final adjudication of the said suit, the interest of defendant
No.4 can be held protected by the said 1/4th share of
defendants No.1 and 2 each which is now carved out in this
case. In the event of the fourth defendant succeeding in the
said suit, it is only the shares of defendants No.1 and 2
which are decided in this case, which would bind the interest
of the fourth defendant. With this observation, I answer all
these issues in favour of the plaintiff in the Affirmative.
19. Issue No.8 :- In the light of the findings given on
the above issues and in the facts and circumstances of the
case, having regard to the close relationship interse the
parties, they are directed to bear their own cost of litigation.
Accordingly, I proceed to pass the following:-
:- ORDER :-
The suit filed by the plaintiff against the
defendants for partition and separate possession is
hereby decreed as prayed for.
The plaintiff is hereby held entitled to her 1/4th
share in suit schedule properties along with
defendants No.1 to 3. The plaintiff can get divided her
share in the schedule properties by actual division in
the final decree proceeding in pursuance of this
preliminary decree.
The defendants No.1 and 2 are hereby restrained
by an order of injunction not to alienate the suit
schedule properties to third parties in any way until
the shares of the sharers are finally determined in the
final decree proceedings.
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
In the event of the fourth defendant succeeding in
OS.114/08, it is the 1/4th share of defendants No.1
and 2 each which is carved out in this case, which
would be bound by the interest of defendant No.4 in
the said suit.
Parties to bear their own costs.
Draw decree accordingly.”
6. As can be seen from the aforesaid judgment and
decree of the Trial Court, in particular, the operative portion, the
Trial Court has adequately safeguarded the interest of the
appellant – defendant No.4 by restraining defendant Nos.1 and 2
by an order of temporary injunction not to alienate the suit schedule
properties in favour of third parties but has not restrained them
from executing a Sale Deed in favour of the appellant – defendant
No.4 pursuant to the decree to be obtained by appellant –
defendant No.4, which would be subject to the final outcome of
O.S.No.114/2008.
7. Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and decree of the
Trial Court passed in O.S.No.103/2008 dated 21.04.2010, the
appellant – defendant No.4 approached the First Appellate Court in
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
R.A.No.104/2010, which came to be dismissed by the First
Appellate Court on 19.02.2016 by holding as under:
“14. I have heard the arguments on both the sides, the
following points arise for my consideration are :
1. Whether the plaintiff proved that, suit schedule
properties were self-acquired properties of her father and
after his death the plaintiff and defendant No.1 to 3 have
succeeded to the suit properties and she is entitled for 1/4th
share in the suit schedule properties ?
2) Whether the impugned judgment and decree
passed by the trial Court requires interference by this Court ?
3) What Order ?
15. My answer to the above points are as under:-
Point No.1: In the Affirmative.
Point No.2: In the Negative.
Point No.3: As per final order, for the following :
REASONS
16. POINT NO.1 AND 2:- Since both these points are
inter-linked with each other, for the sake of convenience and
in order to avoid repetition of evidence, they are taken up
together to dispose off the same under common discussion.
17. The learned counsel for the appellant-defendant
No.4 submitted that, the defendant No.1 and 2 told to the
defendant No.4 that, they are the absolute owners of the item
No.1 of the suit schedule property, accordingly they have
agreed to sell the same in favour of the appellant.
Consideration amount has been fixed at the rate of
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
Rs.2,25,000/- per acre. The defendant No.1 and 2 by
receiving earnest money of Rs.5,00,000/- have executed the
registered agreement of sale with respect to the item No.1 of
the suit schedule property. The defendant No.1 and 2 have
admitted the said fact. Now the plaintiff and defendant No.1 to
3 colluding with each other have brought this false suit only
with an intention to avoid to execute the sale deed in favour of
the defendant No.4 with respect to item No.1 of the suit
schedule property. He further submitted that, the evidence
available on record clearly goes to show that, the family of the
plaintiff and defendants have owned other properties. But all
the joint family properties have not been included in the suit,
so the suit for partial partition is not maintainable. The trial
Court has not considered that aspect, so it has resulted in
miscarriage of justice. He further submitted that, the suit
schedule properties are the ancestral properties of the plaintiff
and defendant No.1 to 3. Admittedly the father of the plaintiff
and defendant No.1 to 3 expired in the year 2003.
Immediately after his death succession opened, under such
circumstances the plaintiff cannot be treated as coparcener
and she is not entitled for equal share that of her brothers
defendant No.1 and 2. But the trial Court without taking into
consideration that aspect also has hold that the plaintiff is
entitled for 1/4th share in the suit property that is not proper
and correct. He further submitted that, the trial Court ought to
have been allotted item No.1 of the suit schedule property in
favour of the defendant No.4 by equating the shares of
defendant No.1 and 2 with other properties to meet the ends
of justice. But that aspect is also not considered by the trial
- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
Court. Hence, the impugned judgment requires interference
by this Court. On these grounds he has requested to allow the
appeal.
18. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the
respondent No.1 submitted his arguments supporting the
judgment of the trial Court.
19. I have gone through the plaint averments
carefully, at para 3 of the plaint, plaintiff has specifically
contended that the propositus of the family Maheshwarappa
S/o Kaliveelappa owned agricultural lands as well as house
property and site in Jagaluru town and taluk. The propositus
of the family Maheshwarappa was the owner in possession of
the agricultural lands bearing Re. Sy. No.94/20 measuring 5
acres 39 guntas of Jagaluru and Re. Sy. No.60 measuring 11
acres 7 guntas of Medaginakere village in Jagaluru taluk.
Similarly, the house property and the sites situated in
Jagaluru town are the properties of the propositus of the
family Maheshwarappa.
20. I have carefully gone through the written
statement filed by the defendant No.1, which is adopted by
the defendant No.2. They have clearly admitted the
averments made in para 2 to 5 of the plaint. On careful
perusal of the written statement filed by defendant No.4, it
clearly discloses that the defendant No.4 has not specifically
denied the averments made by the plaintiff in para 3 of the
plaint. The defendant No.4 in the written statement no where
contended that the suit schedule properties are the ancestral
properties of the plaintiff and defendants. Even the defendant
No.1 and 2 have also not contended that the suit schedule
- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
properties are their ancestral properties and plaintiff is not
entitled for equal share. But they have admitted that, plaintiff
is also entitled for the equal share in the suit properties.
21. I have carefully gone through the evidence of the
PW.1, in her evidence by way of affidavit in examination-in-
chief, she has re-iterated the plaint averments. I have
carefully gone through the cross-examination of PW.1 by the
learned counsel for the defendant No.4. In the cross-
examination no where, it is suggested that, the suit properties
are ancestral properties of the plaintiff and defendant No.1 to
3. I have also gone through the evidence of the DW.1, no
where he has specifically stated that, suit properties are the
ancestral properties of the plaintiff and defendant No.1 to 3. In
the cross-examination the DW.1 has clearly deposed that,
“zÁªÁ LlA £ÀA.1 ªÀÄvÀÄÛ 2ÀgÀ D¹ÛUÀ¼ÀÄ ªÀĺÉñÀégÀ¥Àà EªÀjAzÀ CªÀgÀ
ªÀÄPÀ̽UÉ §A¢ªÉ JAzÀgÉ ¤d. CzÉà jÃw zÁªÁ LlA £ÀA.3gÀ ªÀÄ£É ªÉÆzÀ®Ä
AiÀiÁjUÉ ¸ÉÃjvÀÄÛ JAzÀgÉ £À£ÀUÉ UÉÆwÛ®è. CzÉà jÃw LlA £ÀA.4gÀ D¹Û PÀÆqÀ
ªÉÆzÀ®Ä AiÀiÁjUÉ ¸ÉÃjvÀÄÛ JAzÀÄ £À£ÀUÉ ªÀiÁ»w E®è.”
This evidence also goes to show that, suit schedule
properties are the self-acquired properties of
Maheshwarappa. The plaintiff no where contended that the
suit schedule properties are the ancestral properties of
plaintiff and defendant No.1 to 3. On perusal of the plaint
averments it is clear that it is a specific case of the plaintiff
that all the suit schedule properties are the self-acquired
properties of her father Maheshwarappa. The defendant No.1
and 2 who are the brothers of the plaintiff have not disputed
the case made out by the plaintiff. The defendant No.3 is the
- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
sister of the plaintiff has not appeared and contested the
case. The defendant No.4 is no way concerned to the family
of the plaintiff and defendant No.3, he is a stranger. He is only
an agreement holder with respect to item No.1 of the suit
schedule properties.
Under such circumstances he is not a competent
person to say whether the suit properties are the ancestral
properties or self-acquired properties of Maheshwarappa.
22. On perusal of the documentary evidence
produced by the plaintiff goes to show that, earlier the suit
lands were standing in the name of Maheshwarappa and after
his death, in the revenue records the names of the defendant
No.1 and 2 have been entered with respect to the said
properties and item No.3 and 4 properties are also standing in
the name of the defendant No.1 and 2. It is an admitted fact
that, the father of the plaintiff and defendant No.1 to 3,
Maheshwarappa died in the year 2003. It is also an admitted
fact that, their mother is no more. The trial Court considering
all these aspects has rightly hold that the plaintiff and
defendant No.1 to 3 being the Class-I heirs of deceased
Maheshwarappa, they have succeeded to the estate of the
Maheshwarappa as per Sec.8 of Hindu Succession Act. It is
an admitted fact that, the plaintiff and defendant No.3 are the
daughters of Maheshwarappa and defendant No.1 and 2 are
the sons. The suit properties are the self-acquired properties
of Maheshwarappa. The plaintiff and defendant No.1 to 3 are
th
entitled for 1/4 share each in the suit schedule properties.
23. On perusal of the written statement filed by the
defendant No.4, he has not at all specifically asserted that,
- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
the plaintiff and defendants No.1 to 3 has owned other
properties of the family of the plaintiff and defendants No.1 to
3 and those properties have not been included in this suit, so
the suit for partial partition is not maintainable. There is no
issue to that effect. Under such circumstances, without
foundation the learned counsel for the appellant-defendant
No.4 now cannot contend that, all the joint family properties
are not included in the suit, so the suit for partial partition is
not maintainable. Hence, I am of the opinion that, as there is
no foundation in the pleading, the submission of the learned
counsel for the appellant cannot be taken into consideration.
24. DW.1 in his examination-in-chief by way of
affidavit deposed as per the contention taken in the written
statement. He has produced the registered agreement of
sale, which is marked at Ex.D.4. This evidence goes to show
that the defendant No.1 and 2 have agreed to sell the item
No.1 of the suit schedule properties in favour of the appellant
and by receiving an earnest money, they have executed the
registered agreement of sale. It is also an admitted fact that,
the appellant-defendant No.4 has filed a suit for Specific
Performance before the Senior Civil Judge, Davanagere
against the defendant No.1 and 2 and son of the defendant
No.1 by name B.V.Shivakiran, that suit is bearing O.S.
No.114/2008. The appellant-defendant No.4 has produced
the certified copy of the order-sheet of that case, which is
marked at Ex.D.12 and the copy of the plaint in that case has
been produced and it is marked at Ex.D.13 and the written
statement filed by the present defendant No.1 in that case is
also produced, which is marked at Ex.D.14. On perusal of
- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
these documents, it clearly goes to show that the defendant
No.1 has admitted in that case, they have agreed to sell the
item No.1 of the suit schedule properties in favour of the
defendant No.4 and executed the registered agreement of
sale by receiving the earnest money. The evidence available
on record clearly shows that the defendant No.1 and 2 have
agreed to sell the item No.1 of the suit schedule property in
favour of appellant-defendant No.4 and executed the
registered agreement of sale by receiving earnest money.
Admittedly, the plaintiff is not a party to the alleged agreement
of sale. So, that is not binding on her.
25. It is the contention of the defendant No.4 in the
written statement that, already there was a partition in the
family properties of the plaintiff and defendants No.1 to 3 and
the plaintiff is no way concerned to the suit schedule
properties. But except the self serving testimony of the DW.1
there is no any corroborative evidence to show that already
there was a partition in the family properties of plaintiff and
defendant No.1 to 3. The defendant No.4 being the stranger
to the family of the plaintiff and defendant No.1 to 3, he is not
a competent person to say that already there was a partition
in the joint properties of the plaintiff and defendant No.1 to 3.
In the cross-examination DW.1 has clearly deposed that, the
sons of Maheshwarappa told him that already there was a
partition in their family properties. Except that he has not at all
verified any documents to get it confirmed that already there
was a partition. Even in the documents produced by the
defendants also no where it is shown that already there was a
partition between plaintiff and defendant No.1 to 3 in the
- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
family properties. The trial Court considering that aspect has
rightly hold that the defendant No.4 has not proved that
already there was a partition between plaintiff and defendant
No.1 to 3 in their family properties.
26. The documentary evidence produced by the
defendant No.4, which are marked at Ex.D.10 and 11 go to
show that, one of the properties is situated at Davanagere is
standing in the name of the defendant No.1 and that property
is not included in this suit. It is the contention of the learned
counsel for the plaintiff as well as defendant No.1 and 2 that,
that property is the self-acquired property of the defendant
No.1. The evidence available on record goes to show that,
defendant No.1 was working as an Engineer, now he has
been retired from the service. The defendant No.4 has not
produced any piece of paper to show that property has been
acquired out of the joint family nucleus. The documentary
evidence marked at Ex.D.1 to 3 discloses that, Sy. No.31/1 of
Uddagatti village is standing in the name of B.V.Shivakiran
S/o Veerabhadrappa i.e., the son of the defendant No.1 and
that property is not included in the suit. In the record of rights
of the said property, the Maheshwarappa is shown as a minor
guardian of B.V.Shivakiran, so it goes to show that the
Maheshwarappa has purchased the said property in the name
of his minor grandson. Under such circumstances it cannot be
said that, it is also the joint family property of the plaintiff and
defendant No.1 to 3. The documentary evidence marked at
Ex.D.5 and 6 go to show that, during the lifetime of
Maheshwarappa, himself, defendant No.1 to 3 and son of
defendant No.1 have jointly sold the said properties covered
- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
under the said sale deeds. So, it is clear that those properties
are not available for partition. The trial Court considering all
these aspects has rightly held that except the suit schedule
properties there are no any other properties of
Maheshwarappa available for partition. Under such
circumstances the contention of the learned counsel for the
appellant is not acceptable. The trial Court taking into
consideration all these aspects has rightly hold that the suit is
perfectly maintainable. Under such circumstances the
defendant No.4 is not a competent person to contest the suit
filed by the plaintiff. The trial Court considering the entire
evidence available on record has rightly hold that the suit
properties are the self acquired properties of Maheshwarappa
and after his death, plaintiff and defendant No.3 being the
daughters and defendant No.1 and 2 being the sons, they
have succeeded to the suit properties and as per Sec.8 of the
Hindu Succession Act, they are entitled for equal share in the
suit properties and accordingly, he has rightly decreed the
suit. Hence, the impugned judgment and decree does not
require interference by this Court. Accordingly, I answer Point
No.1 in the AFFIRMATIVE and Point No.2 in the NEGATIVE.
27. POINT No.3 :- In view of my finding on above
points, I proceed to pass the following:-
ORDER
The appeal is DISMISSED by confirming the
judgment and decree dated 21.04.2010 passed by the
learned I Addl. Senior Civil Judge, Davanagere in O.S.
No.103/2008.
No order as to cost.
- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
Draw decree accordingly.
8. As can be seen from the aforesaid impugned judgment
and decree of the First Appellate Court, the First Appellate Court
also recorded a categorical finding of fact that the suit schedule
properties were joint family properties, in which the original plaintiff
Smt.Nagarathnamma and her brothers defendant Nos.1 and 2,
Sri.Veerabhadrappa and Sri.Veeranna as well as their sister
th
Smt.Vinodamma – defendant No.3 were entitled to 1/4 share each
in the suit schedule properties and consequently confirmed the
judgment and decree of the Trial Court as stated supra and
decreed the suit of the plaintiff by holding that she was entitled to
th
1/4 share in the suit schedule properties, which would be subject
to the decree to be passed in O.S.No.114/2008. It is a matter of
record and an undisputed fact that the aforesaid suit in
O.S.No.114/2008 came to be decreed in favour of the appellant –
defendant No.4 vide judgment and decree dated 02.06.2011
directing the respondent Nos.2 and 3 herein i.e. defendant Nos.1
and 2 to execute a Sale Deed in favour of the appellant –
defendant No.4 in relation to the suit schedule properties with
th
respect to their 1/4 share each in the suit schedule properties. It
- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
is also not in dispute that aggrieved by the said judgment and
decree passed in O.S.No.114/2008, the appellant – defendant No.1
approached this Court in RFA No.1534/2011, which has been
subsequently transferred to the First Appellate Court. So also,
defendant Nos.1 and 2 also challenged the said judgment and
decree passed in O.S.No.114/2008 by filing RFA No.1533/2011,
which has also been transferred to the First Appellate Court.
9. Under these circumstances, having regard to the
undisputed fact that RFA No.1534/2011 and RFA No.1533/2011
were filed by the appellant – defendant No. 4 as well as defendant
Nos.1 and 2, respectively, before this Court, which have been
subsequently transferred to the First Appellate Court and are
pending adjudication, I am of the considered opinion that the rights
of the appellant have been adequately safeguarded by the Trial
Court and the First Appellate Court in the aforesaid suits and
appeal and consequently no question of law, much less substantial
question of law arises for consideration in the present appeal and
the appeal is hereby dismissed at the stage of admission itself. It is
however made clear that dismissal of the present appeal would not
- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63107
RSA No. 1441 of 2016
CNR: KAHC010524972016
come in the way of the parties agitating their respective claims in
RFA No.1534/2011 and RFA No.1533/2011, which have been
subsequently transferred to the First Appellate Court and all rival
contentions between the parties in the aforesaid RFA
No.1534/2011 and RFA No.1533/2011 are kept open to be decided
by the First Appellate Court, in accordance with law.
Sd/-
(S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR)
JUDGE
SV
List No.: 2 Sl No.: 18