Power Grid Corporation Of India Limited vs Tangedco
- Court
- Supreme Court
2026 INSC 1237
Reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Civil Appeal Nos.14780-14781 of 2025
Power Grid Corporation of India Limited
...Appellant
Versus
Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution Corporation
Limited (TANGEDCO) & Ors.
...Respondents
With
Civil Appeal No.13153 of 2026
J U D G M E N T
K. VINOD CHANDRAN, J.
The controversy in the above appeals is pinned on the
tariff claim raised by the appellant, separately for two LILOs
(Line-In Line-Out/Loop-In Loop-Out) at the two circuits of
Tuticorin JV-Madurai 400kV D/C (Quad) transmission line
(hereinafter ‘Tuticorin JV-Madurai line’) at the Tuticorin Pooling
Station. The first LILO was commissioned on 04.01.2015 and the
Signature Not Verified
second, identically located, commissioned on 08.01.2015. That
Digitally signed by
VISHAL ANAND
Date: 2026.11.18
16:08:17 IST
Reason:
the generating company (Moxie Power Generation Limited,
Page 1 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
formerly known as Coastal Energen Private Limited) produced
electricity, which was transmitted through the lines of Power
Grid Corporation of India Ltd. (PGCIL), the Central
Transmission Utility (CTU); the Inter-State Transmission
License, it’s receipt and consequential supply to consumers by
the distribution licensee for the State of Tamil Nadu (Tamil Nadu
Generation and Distribution Corporation Limited, the
TANGEDCO) are admitted. The generation, transmission,
supply and end use being admitted, the issue revolves around
whether the LILOs were operational, functional and used in the
transmission. The generating company and TANGEDCO
asserts that it was never used; the Commercial Operation Date
(COD) having not been approved under the Central Electricity
Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions of Tariff)
Regulations, 2014 (Tariff Regulations). There could, hence, be
no factoring of the LILOs in the tariff especially since the
upstream transmission lines from the Tuticorin Pooling Station
to the Salem Pooling Station leading up to Madhugiri having not
been installed or commissioned till 01.12.2016. The period for
which the claim is raised is between 04.01.2015 up to
27.10.2016; with respect to the LILOs of the first circuit and
Page 2 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
08.01.2015 to 27.10.2016 insofar as the LILOs in the second
circuit. The date 27.10.2016 is relatable to the date on which the
generating company built its dedicated transmission line (DTL)
directly to the Tuticorin Pooling Station.
Arguments of the Appellant : -
2. Mr.Ramji Srinivasan, learned Senior Counsel appearing
for the PGCIL pointed out that the two LILOs were approved by
the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC) by
order dated 29.07.2016, accepting the COD as proffered by the
PGCIL, which was overturned by the Appellate Tribunal for
Electricity (APTEL) thus denying transmission charges on that
element, for the period during which the LILOs were functional
and put to use for transmission of the power generated by the
generating company to TANGEDCO. There being no DTL
constructed by the generating company, the tariff has to be
determined on a non-PoC (Point Of Connection) basis. The
learned Senior Counsel specifically referred to the minutes of
th th th
the 29 , 30 and 38 Meetings of the Standing Committee which
comprehensively dealt with the Southern Region Transmission
Scheme, finalizing the Tuticorin Pooling Station and associated
th
evacuation lines. Reliance was also placed on the 5 Joint Co-
Page 3 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
ordination Committee Meeting on 22.07.2011. The generating
companies, two at that point, entered into Bulk Power
Transmission Agreements (BPTA), undertaking to construct and
commission their DTLs directly to the Tuticorin Pooling Station,
simultaneous to the COD of their generating units on 24.02.2010
which stood amended on 08.09.2011. The minutes of the
meetings of the Standing Committee along with the Annexures
to the BPTA clearly indicate that the LILOs were a permanent
infrastructure, the use of which commenced even before the
upstream transmission lines, leading to Salem and Madhugiri
were constructed and made operational.
3. The two LILOs were respectively commissioned in full
compliance with the statutory framework but with a delay of
less than nine months; the scheduled date of commission of the
transmission system being 11.04.2014. The COD was approved
by the CERC after verification of the Regional Load Despatch
Centre (RLDC) certificate, issued on successful trial operation
and the Central Electricity Authority (CEA) certificate issued
under Regulation 43 of Central Electricity Authority (Measures
Related to Safety & Electricity Supply) Regulations, 2010 (CEA
th
Regulations) as also approvals obtained in the 30 Standing
Page 4 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
Committee pursuant to Regulation 4(3) of the Tariff Regulations.
The Standing Committee’s decisions have a statutory binding
force under Section 29(4) of the Electricity Act. Neither
TANGEDCO nor the generating companies placed any material
to challenge the factual commissioning of the LILOs as
approved by the CERC. The CERC by its order clearly held that
since the generating company delayed the construction of the
mandatory DTL and utilised PGCIL’s LILO lines they were liable
to bear the transmission charges under Section 10 of the
Electricity Act until regular commissioning of their DTLs.
4. The finding of the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity
(APTEL), that the LILOs had no beneficial use runs contrary to
the admitted fact of utilisation for transmission of electricity,
from the generating company to the distribution licensee. The
delay in the upstream transmission lines from the Tuticorin
Pooling Station to Salem and Madhugiri did not at all affect the
transmission of electricity from the initial date of its generation
i.e. 23.12.2014. It was facilitated initially through the Tuticorin
JV-Madurai line directly and from the commissioning of LILOs
through the Tuticorin Pooling Station, despite the upstream
transmission lines to Salem and Madhugiri having not been
Page 5 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
commissioned. The Tuticorin JV-Madurai line was also a part of
the evacuation plan, which too served as an upstream
transmission line. The seamless transmission of electricity
requires the LILOs to be factored in the tariff, which was rightly
carried out by the CERC, erroneously reversed by the APTEL.
5. The defence taken that the Short-Term Open Access
(STOA) and Medium-Term Open Access (MTOA) charges
absolve the generator from paying capital cost transmission
tariff, proceeds on a fundamental misconception of the tariff
regulatory framework. The transmission tariff as distinguished
from Open Access charges is determined by CERC under
Sections 61 and 62 of the Electricity Act to service capital
expenditure, return on equity, interest on loans, and
depreciation broadly termed as Yearly Transmission Charges
(YTC), while the open access charges are operational charges
computed by the National Load Despatch Centre (NLDC). The
STOA/MTOA would contain a certain portion of YTC for fixed
assets for which tariff had been determined by the CERC; at
which point of time the tariff for LILO assets were yet to be
determined and therefore did not form part of the STOA/MTOA.
The open access charges collected are adjusted against the
Page 6 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
Point of Connection (PoC) base pool, only after commissioning
of the DTL directly from the generating station to the Tuticorin
Pooling Station, after which the asset charges were socialised
into the PoC pool and bilateral billing was stopped on the
generating company. Essentially, the subject recovery from the
generating unit is for the period between the COD of the LILOs
and the commissioning of the DTL. The tariff order in the
disputed period was issued on 29.07.2016, when the YTC of the
subject LILOs were not included in the regional PoC base pool,
and was applicable only till the DTL was commissioned, which
occurred on 27.10.2016.
6. In conclusion, it is submitted that paragraph 72 of the
CERC order actually recorded the contention of TANGEDCO
but erroneously put it forth as the CERC’s opinion clearly
contrary to the spirit of the order of the CERC. In fact, the CERC
had in paragraph 73 specifically raised the question of the
liability with respect to the transmission charges in the context
of upstream/ downstream transmission system not being ready
which was dealt with on a perusal of the minutes of the meetings
of the Standing Committee, eventually ruling in favour of the
PGCIL. The two LILOs having been put to actual commercial use
Page 7 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
by the generating company for supply to TANGEDCO, in
evacuating power, the transmission licensee cannot be denied
recovery of tariff on an erroneous standard of ‘beneficial use’,
unheard of in transmission parlance and an artificial reopening
of COD.
Arguments of the Respondents: -
7. Mr. Sajan Poovayya, learned Senior Counsel appeared for
Moxie Power Generation Limited (formerly Coastal Energen
Private Limited), the generating company. It was asserted on
the basis of Annexure A1, pictorial depiction of the evacuation
arrangement for Long Term Open Access (LTOA) projects in
the Tuticorin area, that the subject LILOs, the use of which is
sought to be included in the tariff, was never put to
use. According to him, the LILO referred to under the Standing
Committee Meetings (SCMs) is the one which connected the
generating station with the Tuticorin JV-Madurai transmission
line through which the energy evacuation was carried out and
drawn by TANGEDCO for the purpose of supply and end use of
consumers. Electricity, it is contented was transmitted
seamlessly; as is wont to happen in the event of zero resistance,
though the Tuticorin JV-Madurai line for onward transmission to
Page 8 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
Trichy, where TANGEDCO received it. The DTL which was to
be constructed by the generating station and the delay in such
construction is immaterial insofar as the upstream infrastructure
for transmission of electricity from the Tuticorin Pooling Station
to the Salem Pooling Station and then to Madhugiri had not
materialised till much later. The generating unit though was
granted LTOA since the upstream connection had not
materialised, a LILO was created in the Tuticorin JV-Madurai
line through which evacuation of power was commenced on
24.10.2014 under STOA and then continued as a MTOA, paying
the applicable charges for transmission of electricity. The DTL
to the Tuticorin Polling Station was commissioned on
27.10.2016, well in advance of PGCIL's upstream Tuticorin-
Salem Pooling Station line, which came into operation only on
13.11.2016. It was still later on 01.12.2016, the LTOA to the
generating unit was operationalised. The PGCIL's LILO had
started operation only after the commissioning of the PGCIL's
upstream transmission system on 13.11.2016.
8. The contention also is that there can be no liability on the
generating company and the subject claim is unsustainable
since the statutory mandate for declaration of COD; where
Page 9 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
there is failure of either of the contracting parties, was not
followed. The LTOA having not been operationalised during the
subject period, when transmission charges were levied on a
STOA/MTOA basis, there could be no further claim set up by
the CTU. The statutory scheme under Regulation 4(3)(ii) and
Regulation 12 (2) of the Tariff Regulation mulcts liability on a
generator only when the COD is declared as per the
Regulations. The directions by the APTEL to get declared the
COD is apt in the facts and circumstances of the case. The
generating unit having commenced evacuation of power before
the PGCIL’s LILOs were operationalised as per the BPTA it
could have continued seamlessly even without the intervention
of the PGCIL LILOs; based solely on the LILO of one circuit in
the Tuticorin JV-Madurai line, at the generating station. The
interim arrangements continued till the upstream transmission
lines were operationalised which was later to the
commissioning of the DTL, thus making irrelevant the delay in
commissioning of the DTL. If the CERC declares, on the remand
made, that the COD of the LILOs is as claimed by PGCIL,
definitely the liability would fall on the generating company.
But otherwise, the end consumers would be unnecessarily
Page 10 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
mulcted with a liability, without actual use of the subject assets,
in the transmission; is the contention.
9. Ms.Vrinda Bhandari, learned Advocate on Record,
appearing on behalf of the TANGEDCO adopted the arguments
of the generating company and stressed upon paragraph 72 of
the CERC’s order which findings were in affirmation of the
contention raised by TANGEDCO. It is also argued that the
subject assets; being the PGCIL’s LILOs were not independent
transmission assets and were an integral part of the composite
transmission arrangement for evacuation of power from the
generating stations at Tuticorin through the Tuticorin Pooling
Station and the associated 765 kV upstream transmission
system. It was urged that APTEL was correct in holding that the
COD does not depend upon the facility being made viable, and
the liability on the generating unit could only arise if it is
capable of serving its purpose; which was not possible till the
upstream transmission system was established and made
operational. Hence, the beneficial use as contemplated by the
APTEL was perfectly in order.
Page 11 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
The Order of the CERC : -
10. The CERC looked at the investment approval dated
12.12.2011 and the modified Revised Cost Estimates (RCE)
dated 23.02.2015. The scope of work was indicated to be the
LILO in both circuits of Tuticorin JV–Madurai line and
establishment of 400kV Pooling Station at Tuticorin, initially
charged at 400kV including 1x80 MVAR bus reactor. The
elements covered in the scope of the project, was first claimed
as a single asset for the purpose of tariff, while the LILOs in the
first circuit and the second circuit of the Tuticorin JV–Madurai
line, was claimed separately under various heads. TANGEDCO
required the cost to be checked prudently and had challenged
the claims under various heads as also assailed the specific
claim with respect to the LILOs on the ground that without
commissioning the other elements of the common transmission
system, the LILOs cannot be practically put to use. The specific
contention of TANGEDCO was that the LILOs upon which the
claim was raised was redundant until the Salem and Madhugiri
Pooling Stations providing upstream connectivity from the
Tuticorin Pooling Station is put under Commercial Operation.
Page 12 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
11. The date of Commercial Operation (COD) was accepted
as 04.01.2015 and 08.01.2015 for the two LILOs termed Asset 1
and Asset 2 respectively. This was also based on the RLDC’s
successful trial operation certificate and the CEA Certificate, as
also the implementation of 1x80 MVAR bus reactor at the
Tuticorin Pooling Station. While the delay occurred was
explained by PGCIL, it was found to be not substantiated with
valid reasons for which liberty was left to the PGCIL to provide
documentary proof at the time of truing-up. The aspect of the
time over-run having not been condoned, it had a bearing in
determination of the amounts to be quantified under the various
heads, wherein the scheduled COD was reckoned rather than
the actual COD.
12. The CERC eventually considered the question as to who
would bear the transmission charges and found the minutes of
th
the 30 SCM held on 05.05.2010 would be relevant from which
the following was quoted:
“ 5.0 Transmission System Associated with the
Coastal Energen Pvt Ltd (2x660 MW) and IND Barath
Power Ltd (2x660 MW) projects in Tuticorin area of
Tamil Nadu:
Page 13 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
5.1 Chief Engineer, CEA explained that the Tuticorin
Pooling Station-Tutlcorin JV Station (of NLC) 400kV D/C
Quad Line was inter-alla agreed as part of the
transmission system associated with the Coastal
Energen Pvt Ltd (2x600 MW) and IND Barath Power Ltd
(2x660 MW) projects in Tuticorin area of Tamil Nadu.
Later, NLC informed that they could spare only one bay
at their Tuticorin JV station. As such, considering space
constraint and better capacity utilization of the 400kV
quad D/C line, it is now proposed that instead of the
Tuticorin Pooling Station of Tuticorin DV Station 400kV
D/C line, both the circuits of Tuticorin JV-Madurai
400kV Quad D/C line may be LILOed at Tuticorin
Pooling Station.
-----------------------
5.2 After discussions, the above proposed
modifications in the transmission system for the Coastal
Energen Pvt. Ltd (2x600 MW) and IND Barath Power Ltd
(2x660 MW) projects in Tuticorin area of Tamil Nadu
were agreed.”
13. Based on the above as per the RLDC Certificate, the LILO
in one circuit was intended for the use of Coastal Energen, as a
measure of extraction at the Tuticorin JV–Madurai Line, a
temporary line for evacuation of power from the generating
station and again LILO-ed at the Tuticorin Pooling Station on the
Page 14 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
Tuticorin JV-Madurai Line. The LILO by Coastal Energen was
found to be a temporary measure which was liable to be
dismantled, according to the CERC, within six months from the
date of the issue of the order; obviously on commissioning of
the DTL. Reliance was placed on a connected matter and it was
held that the transmission charges for the instant assets, i.e. the
two LILOs termed Asset 1 and Asset 2 were to be borne by
Coastal Energen and Ind-Barath Power till the commercial
operation of the DTL up to the Tuticorin Pooling Station, which
was the obligation of Coastal Energen and Ind-Barath were
occasioned. Ind-Barath never commenced operation.
Pertinently, despite being made a party, the generating
company did not appear before the CERC to raise its
contentions.
The Order of the APTEL: -
14. The APTEL considered the issue of Non-PoC charges of
Rs.15,43,26,909/- for the period between 04.01.2015 to
27.10.2016. APTEL framed five issues and answered them in the
following manner :
(i) The LILO of both circuits of the Tuticorin JV- Madurai
line at Tuticorin Pooling Station was a permanent part
Page 15 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
th
of the transmission plan, as approved in the 30 SCM
and sanctioned by the CERC in Petition No.233 of 2009.
(ii) The decision of the CERC to grant COD of the assets
under consideration is not correct since the correct
procedure was not adopted; namely the procedure
under Regulation 4 (3)(ii) of the Tariff Regulations,
2014.
(iii) The subject assets being not a temporary
arrangement, PGCIL was not liable to bear its cost on
a Non-PoC basis.
(iv) The construct of PoC transmission charges is based on
usage and hence no transmission charges could be
claimed by PGCIL for the assets since no power was
flowing through these LILOs.
(v) The availability of Dedicated Transmission Line (DTL)
of the generating company is irrelevant since
upstream transmission from Tuticorin to Salem and
Madhugiri Pooling Stations was not operationalized,
thus disabling the full power of the generating station
from being evacuated. The COD of the LILO as granted
by the CERC needs to be reviewed.
Page 16 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
Hence while finding the LILO to be a permanent structure of the
evacuation arrangement, it was held that the same were not put
in use. In the review filed by PGCIL the matter was remanded
to the CERC for determination of the COD of the LILOs; which
order is impugned in the other appeal.
Preliminary Analysis: -
15. For better understanding of the controversy, we have to
necessarily look at the pictorial depiction as seen at Annexure
A-1 (extracted hereinbelow, a little later) which clearly
indicates that the LILOs at Tuticorin Pooling Station on the
Tuticorin JV–Madurai Line intercepted the two circuits of the
said line. Hence, on evacuation of power, from Coastal Energen
and Tuticorin JV; the two generating stations, to the Tuticorin
JV–Madurai Line, it had to be necessarily intercepted at the
LILO for the purpose of routing it through the Tuticorin Pooling
Station and send back to the Tuticorin JV–Madurai Line for
onward transmission to Madurai and its eventual receipt by the
distribution licensee, TANGEDCO, at the downstream
transmission lines. We would elaborate on this when we look
at the statutory scheme of transmission of electricity and the
Page 17 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
necessity of a Pooling Station. Suffice it to notice, for the present
that Tuticorin JV is a generating station set up by the Neyveli
Lignite Corporation (NLC) and TANGEDCO as a joint venture
(JV). By the introduction of two other generating stations, as
originally contemplated there were multiple sources; stations,
of electricity generation.
16. The argument of the generating company that electricity
moves through the path of least resistance though indubitable
is fundamentally flawed on the facts herein and does not
support the contention of no beneficial use of the LILOs having
been made. The pictorial depiction clearly indicates that after
evacuation of power through the temporary LILO put up by the
Coastal Energen in the Tuticorin JV–Madurai Line, there is a
diversion through the permanent LILO of the PGCIL, at the
Tuticorin Pooling Station. The free flow of electricity through the
path of least resistance hence supports the plea of PGCIL that
on its interception at the Loop-In/Line-In, the path of least
resistance is the one leading to the Tuticorin Pooling Station and
from there, after stabilization, through the Loop-Out/Line-Out,
back to the Tuticorin JV–Madurai Line. There cannot be two
opinions on this, and the contention raised is rejected. We also
Page 18 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
notice the specific contention taken up by the generating
company, in its appeal before the APTEL, which is as under: -
“…..It is submitted here that the Appellant has
commissioned its first unit on December 23, 2014, and
has been using Tuticorin Pooling Station to evacuate
power under STOA/MTOA since then. Further MTOA of
558 MW has been provided by the Respondent No.2 to
Appellant on the instant transmission assets (LILG) for
supplying power to TANGEDCO for the period from
1.7.2015 to 30.6.2018. The MTOA stands duly
operationalized and it is evident that the subject
transmission system was being used. In view of this, it
could be stated that the instant assets are and will be
used to evacuate power for Southern Region
Beneficiaries, it is therefore submitted before the
Hon'ble Commission that the transmission charges for
the same must be shared by all beneficiaries through
the PoC mechanism.”
Hence, the use of LILOs was admitted and the contention was
only of sharing, which cannot be raised without commissioning
the DTL.
17. At the risk of repetition, it cannot but be observed that
admittedly the generation commenced on 23.12.2014 upon
which the power was evacuated through the Tuticorin JV-
Page 19 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
Madurai 400/220 kV lines by creating a LILO on one of the
circuits of the said lines which continued seamlessly during the
disputed subject period also. Hence, generation, transmission,
supply and consumption are clearly admitted and there arose
no situation where the generating station held its horses, after
it become operational and ready for generation of power; thus,
creating a liability on the CTU which had the responsibility and
obligation to transmit electricity on its generation. The issue is
only as to whether the two LILOs created as intervention to the
two circuits on the Tuticorin JV-Madurai line was used or not;
which on its commissioning is a foregone conclusion.
18. The PGCIL categorically asserted that the two LILOs were
made operational on 04.01.2015 and 08.01.2015 respectively.
We will deal with the issue of COD a little later; which we have
to merely notice now, as having been found by the CERC to be
on the dates projected. While according to the generating unit,
the Tuticorin Pooling Station could be operated only on the
upstream connection established, the contention of the
appellant is that the power generated and evacuated from the
generating unit had to be first brought to the Pooling Station
through the Line-In (Loop-In) from the Tuticorin JV-Madurai line
Page 20 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
and then pooled out from the Line-Out (Loop-Out) back to the
Tuticorin JV-Madurai line which was a part of the plan
contemplated for evacuation of power from the generating units
in the Tuticorin area, strengthening the Southern Region
Transmission. Hence, the upstream transmission lines from the
Tuticorin Pooling Station to Salem Pooling Station, though
delayed did not cause any hindrance to the power generated
by the generating unit and the same was transmitted to the
purchaser, the distribution licensee, who had supplied it to the
end consumers, de hors the upstream line to Salem not being
established.
19. In fact, the plan comprehensively contemplated the
LILOs as an integral part of the composite transmission
agreement as admitted by TANGEDCO. The situation of the
creation and operation of the LILO of the PGCIL, puts in place
the evacuation arrangement of power in the Tuticorin area. This
makes relevant the delay in establishment of the DTL directly to
the Tuticorin Pooling Station, which was the obligation of the
generating company. The claim raised by the appellant is not
from the date of generation which is 23.12.2014 and does not
extend after the DTL was established by the generating
Page 21 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
company, which was on 27.10.2016. The claim is within the
period of the operation of the LILOs on 04.01.2015 and
08.01.2015 up to 27.10.2016 when the DTL was established and
made operational.
Questions of Law -
20. The questions of law, hence arising from the orders
challenged; one in original and the other in review are the
following: -
I. Whether the transmission licensee, the appellant PGCIL,
is entitled to transmission tariff, including the element of
the two LILOs spanning over 10 kms, bringing in the
power generated to the Tuticorin Polling Station and then
transmitting it further through the Tuticorin JV–Madurai
line especially since the LILOs were a part of the statutory
planning under Section 29(4) of the Electricity Act, 2003
and the BPTA ?
II. Whether the Appellate Tribunal was right in law in its
interpretation of Regulation 4(3)(ii) of the Tariff
Regulations in directing the CERC to consider the COD of
the LILOs when already it has been approved by the
CERC ?
Page 22 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
III. Whether the delay in construction of the DTL would
enable the liability for the period between
04.01.2015/08.01.2015 and 27.10.2016 to be mulcted on
the generating company ?
The Statutory Scheme -
21. While the appellant, PGCIL banks on the delay in
establishing and operationalisation of the DTL by the
generating company, the generating company and the
distribution licensee; TANGEDCO, projects the delay in
establishing and operationalisation of the upstream
transmission lines between Tuticorin and Salem Pooling
Stations to be determinative of the absence of any liability on
the generating company or the distribution licensee. The
upstream transmission lines and the downstream transmission
system referred to in Regulation 4(3)(ii) having not been
defined in the statute, we have to look at the statutory scheme
to better understand the rival contentions of the parties.
22. Generation of Electricity is dealt with in Part III of the
Electricity Act, 2003. A generating company is entitled to
establish, operate and maintain a generating station without
Page 23 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
obtaining a licence under the Act, if it complies with the
technical standards relating to connectivity with the grid
referred to in clause (b) of Section 73. A generating station also
includes a hydro-electric generation and captive generating
station, which has additional requirements to be satisfied under
Sections 8 and 9; which we are not concerned with. Section 10
stipulates the duties of the generating companies, which are; to
establish, operate and maintain generating stations, tie-lines,
sub-stations and dedicated transmission lines (DTL) connected
therewith in accordance with the provisions of the Act, the Rules
and the Regulations. A DTL is defined under clause (16) of
Section 2 as any electric supply-line for point-to-point
transmission required for the purpose of connecting electric
lines or electric plants, also under Section 9 and Section 10, to
any transmission lines or sub-stations or generating stations or
the load centre. The DTL, hence, is the obligation of the
generating station.
23. Part V of the Act deals with the Transmission of Electricity,
which includes both inter-State and intra-State transmission. For
the purpose of inter-State transmission, the Central
Government is empowered to make a region-wise demarcation
Page 24 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
of the Country for the efficient, economical and integrated
transmission and supply of electricity as per Section 25. Section
26 speaks of a National Load Despatch Centre (NLDC) for
optimum scheduling and despatch of electricity between the
Regional Load Despatch Centres (RLDCs); which RLDC’s are
established under Section 27. Insofar as the intra-State
transmission is concerned, the State Commission is empowered
to facilitate and promote transmission, wheeling and inter-State
transmission connection within its territorial jurisdiction under
Section 30 for effective functioning for which a State Load
Despatch Centre (SLDC) is constituted under Section 31. The
functions of the NLDC are as prescribed by the Central
Government under sub-section (2) of Section 26 and that of the
RLDC and SLDC are delineated respectively under Section 28
and Section 32. While the Central Transmission Utility (CTU) as
notified by the Central Government under Section 38
undertakes establishment and facilitation of inter-State
transmission under Section 38, the distribution licensees under
Section 42 are obliged to develop and maintain an efficient, co-
ordinated and economic distribution system in their area of
supply. The State Transmission Utility as notified under Section
Page 25 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
39 has an obligation to undertake transmission of electricity
through the intra-State transmission system.
24. It is the CEA constituted under Section 70 which specifies
the technical standards for construction of electrical plants,
electric lines and connectivity to the grid, the compliance of
which, as provided under clause (b) of Section 73, is stipulated
in Section 7, with reference to a generating company setting up
a generating station. The ‘Grid’ is defined under clause (32) of
Section 2, which means “ the high voltage backbone system of
inter-connected transmission lines, sub-stations and generating
plants ” (sic). The transmission lines are defined under clause
(72) of Section 2, which means all high-pressure cables and
overhead lines, not being an essential part of the distribution
system of a licensee, transmitting electricity from a generating
station to another generating station or a substation with an
intervening step-up and step-down transformer, switch-gear
and other works necessary and used for the control of such
cables or overhead lines.
25. Here, we should also have a better understanding of what
a Pooling Station is and the purpose it serves. A Pooling Station
is defined under the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission
Page 26 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
(Indian Electricity Grid Code) Regulations, 2023. The Preamble
of the said Regulation refers to the definition of ‘Grid’ in sub-
section (32) of Section 2 of the Electricity Act, which is extracted
hereinabove, as a backbone system. Keeping in view the
mandate and statutory framework as envisaged in the Act for
stable, reliable and secure grid operation in order to achieve
maximum economy and efficiency of power system, the grid
code is brought in; which apart from the provisions relating to
the role of various statutory bodies and organizations and
functional linkages contains extensive provisions pertaining to
various aspects as delineated thereunder. A Pooling Station is
defined as ‘the ISTS grid sub-station where pooling of generation
of connected individual generating stations is done for interfacing
with the next higher voltage level’ . It has to be specifically
observed that in the subject evacuation arrangement, the
Tuticorin Pooling Station was to aggregate power from three
sources; Tuticorin JV, Coastal Energen and Ind-Barath. The
Pooling Station acts as an intermediary electrical hub collecting
power generated from multiple energy sources and
aggregates it into a single high voltage output for efficient
evacuation to the main transmission grid. This is in tune with
Page 27 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
Section 61 of the Electricity Act 2003, which requires the
generation, transmission, distribution and supply of electricity
to be conducted inter alia on commercial principles,
encouraging competition, efficiency and economical use of the
resources, good performance and optimum investments as also
safeguarding of consumers’ interest, enabling recovery of the
cost of electricity in a reasonable manner (sic. clauses (b) (c)
and (d) of Section 61).
26. From a conspectus of the above statutory scheme, the
Grid encompasses the entire transmission system starting from
the generating company at the point of evacuation of electricity
generated, which moves through the dedicated transmission
lines (DTL), as established by the generating company and gets
transmitted through the transmission lines established by the
CTU, including the LILOs, Pooling Stations etc; which come
within the ambit of “other works” as found in the definition
clause (72) of Section 2, received by the distribution licensee
and supplied to its end consumers through its distribution lines.
The distribution licensee receives the power from the
transmission lines of the CTU and extracts it and through the
distribution system, for supply to the end consumers. The
Page 28 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
transmission, hence can be divided into three stages, (i) the
DTL which extracts power from the generating station and
brings it to the transmission lines of the CTU (ii) the
transmission lines of the CTU, which transmits the power
through the transmission lines to the distribution licensee and
(iii) the distribution system established by the distribution
licensee which extracts power from the transmission lines of the
CTU and supplies it to the end consumers. From this statutory
scheme, the upstream transmission system is the inter-State
transmission system established by the CTU and the
downstream transmission system is that established by the
distribution licensee within the respective States. It is with this
understanding of the statutory scheme that we have to look at
the facts of the case.
Adjudication on the Facts: -
27. On facts, we commence with Annexure A2, the Minutes of
th
the 29 Meeting of the Standing Committee on Power System
Planning in Southern Region (SCPSPSR) held on 27.08.2009.
Under Clause (12) discussions on the Inter State Transmission
Systems (ISTS) with respect to the Long Term Open Assess
(LTOA) Applications made to the CTU for Projects in Southern
Page 29 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
Region, Coastal Energen Pvt. Ltd. and Ind Barath Power Madras
Ltd., in Tuticorin area, Tamil Nadu were considered. Insofar as
the Coastal Energen Pvt. Ltd. and Ind Barath Power Madras Ltd.,
the Transmission Systems contemplated are seen from Clause
12.3.2, which are as under: -
12.3.2 Transmission System for Coastal Energen Pvt Ltd
(2x660 MW) and IND Barath Power Madras Ltd. (4x350 MW)
projects in Tuticorin of Tamil Nadu:
(i) Establishment of 765 kV pooling station in Tuticorin,
Salem and Madhugiri (north of Bangalore) (initially charged
at 400 kV)
(ii) Coastal Energen generation switchyard - Tuticorin
pooling station 400kV D/C Quad / High-capacity line
(iii) Ind-Barath generation switchyard Tuticorin pooling
station 400kV D/c Quad/High-capacity line
(iv) Tuticorin Pooling station - Salem Pooling station 765kV
D/C line initially charged at 400kV
(v) Salem pooling station-Madhugiri pooling station 765kV
S/C initially charged at 400kV.
(vi) Madhugiri - Yelahanka 400 kV Quad D/C line
(vii) Tuticorin pooling station - Tuticorin JV 400 kV D/C
quad line.
28. Pertinently it has to be observed that the LILOs at the
Tuticorin Pooling Station were not contemplated, and the
Common Transmission for Coastal Energen and Ind Barath
Page 30 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
Projects as decided are found under Clause (c) which is again
as below: -
i. Common transmission for Coastal Energen and Ind-
Barath projects
• Establishment of 765 kV pooling station in Tuticorin,
Salem and Madhugiri (near Bangalore) (initially
charged at 400 kV)
• Tuticorin Pooling station - Salem Pooling station 765
kV D/c line initially charged at 400 kV.
• Salem pooling station - Madhugiri pooling station 765
kV S/c initially charged at 400 kV.
• Tuticorin pooling station - Tuticorin JV 400 kV D/c
quad.
The estimated Cost of the evacuation system shall be about
Rs. 2500 Crores.
29. The dedicated transmission system with respect to
Coastal Energen was to commence from the generation station
of Coastal Energen evacuated to the Tuticorin Pooling Station
400 kV D/C quad/high-capacity line. A temporary measure for
drawing startup power as well as to evacuate power till the
commission of dedicated transmission system was
contemplated as hereinbelow:
iv) Further a temporary measure for Coastal Energen
to draw startup power as well as to evacuate power till
Page 31 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
the commissioning of above transmission system, LILO
of one circuit of Tuticorin JV – Madurai 400 kV Quad D/c
line (under construction by POWERGRID) was agreed
which shall be restored matching with the
commissioning of pooling station in the Tuticorin area.
30. This led to the Bulk Power Transmission Agreement
entered into on 24.02.2010 between the appellant on the one
side and Coastal Energen and Ind-Barath Power, on the other
side. The transfer of power from the respective station of
generation to the place of delivery was specified in Annexure
1. The Transmission System required for direct evacuation of
power from the respective generating stations to the pooling
points of the PGCIL was finalized in consultation with the
Central Electricity Authority and indicated at Annexure 2. The
Transmission System to evacuate and dispatch power to
respective beneficiaries from the generation projects was
indicated at Annexure 3 and the applicable transmission
charges were agreed to be shared and borne as decided by the
CERC, which mechanism was indicated at Annexure 4. The
extracts from these annexures of the BPTA are relevant for
consideration.
Page 32 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
31. Annexure 2 of the BPTA refers to the dedicated
transmission line, which was the obligation of Coastal Energen,
which as noticed hereinabove commences from the generation
switch yard to the Tuticorin Pooling Station. The common
transmission system to be developed by PGCIL as per
Annexure 3 of the BPTA, for strengthening the system in
Southern and Eastern Region, has been specified at Serial No.1,
of which that intended for Southern Region alone are extracted
herein below:
a) Establishment of 765 kV Pooling station at Tuticorin and
Salem (initially charged at 400 kV)
b) Tuticorin Pooling station - Salem Pooling Station 765 kV
D/c line (initially charged at 400 kV)
c) Salem Pooling station - Madhugiri Pooling Station 765 kV
S/c line (initially charged at 400 kV)
d) LILO of both circuits of Tuticorin JV - Madurai 400 kV D/c
quad line at Tuticorin Pooling station
e) Establishment of 400/220 kV, 2x500 MVA substation at
Madhugiri (near Bangalore) with 765/400 kV provision in
the same switchyard
f) Madhugiri - Yelahanka 400 kV D/c quad line
g) Associated 400kV bays at Tuticorin Pooling station,
Salem Pooling station, Madhugiri Pooling station and
Tuticorin JV substations.
Page 33 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
32. The BPTA specifically provided for the LILO of both
circuits of Tuticorin JV-Madurai Line at Tuticorin Pooling Station,
which is not the LILO of the generating company created as a
temporary measure for the purpose of evacuation of electricity
from the generating station, before the commissioning of the
dedicated transmission line (DTL). Annexure 3 was replaced on
08.09.2011 and the common transmission system was
contemplated in two parts as Part A and Part B as specified
hereinafter:
1. Transmission System Strengthening in Southern Region
for evacuation of power from Coastal Energen Private
Limited and Ind-Barath Power (Madras) Limited in the
Tuticorin area
Part-A
a) Establishment of 765 kV Pooling station at Tuticorin
(initially charged at 400 KV)
b) LILO of both circuits of Tuticorin JV - Madurai 400 kV D/c
quad line at Tuticorin Pooling station
Part - B
a) Establishment of 765 kV Pooling station at Salem (initially
charged at 400 kV)
b) Tuticorin Pooling station - Salem Pooling Station 765 kV
D/c line (initially charged at 400 kV)
Page 34 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
c) Salem Pooling station - Madhugiri Pooling Station 765 kV
S/c line (initially charged at 400 kV)
d) Salem Pooling Station - Salem 400 kV Quad line
e) Associated 400kV bays at Tuticorin Pooling station,
Salem Pooling station, Madhugiri substation.
th
This was in consonance with the decision of the 30 SCM held
on 05.05.2010, extracted in paragraph 12 of this judgment. Due
to the incapacity of Tuticorin JV to spare more than one bay, the
LILO’s were necessitated.
33. The commissioning schedule of Part A as per Annexure 4,
replaced on 08.09.2011, was July 2014 and that of Part B was
December 2014. The establishment of the 765 kV Pooling
Station at Tuticorin initially charged at 400kV was in time and
the LILO of both circuits of Tuticorin JV-Madurai line at Tuticorin
Pooling Station occurred respectively on 04.01.2015 and
08.01.2015 with a marginal delay. As is evident from the order
of the CERC, the investment approval was on 12.12.2011 and
the scheduled date of Commercial Operation was 11.04.2014.
There was a time over-run of 8 months 23 days with respect to
the first LILO and 8 months and 27 days with respect to the
second LILO, which was considered by the CERC in its order,
Page 35 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
which time over-run in the case of the subject assets was not
condoned, but the PGCIL given liberty to substantiate the
reasons for the delay along with documentary proof at the time
of truing up.
34. The various claims raised were considered and some
declined, which eventually led to the order directing the
generating companies to pay transmission charges for the
instant assets till the dedicated transmission line (DTL) up to the
Tuticorin Pooling Station is constructed and declared as
commercially operational and put to regular use by the
concerned generating station. Fifty percent of the charges of
the LILO was to be included under PoC and the balance 50% of
the transmission charges to be borne by the generating
company, which had not commissioned the dedicated
transmission line. It was categorically found by the CERC that
the LILOs were agreed upon in the SCMs, and an extract was
th
made from the meeting of 38 SR-SCM dated 07.03.2015 in
paragraph 74 of the CERC order. It was also found that the LILO
of Coastal Energen on one circuit of Tuticorin Madurai
transmission line was agreed as an interim arrangement which
was directed to be removed within six months from the date of
Page 36 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
issue of the order of CERC; simultaneous to which the dedicated
transmission line (DTL) was to be made operational.
35. From the above, it is very evident that the LILOs on the two
circuits of the Tuticorin JV-Madurai Line, though not initially
contemplated, was later made part of the transmission system,
which even according to the respondents is an integral part of
the system. The liability now cast on the power generating
company is only by reason of the DTL having not been
constructed, which would have extracted power from the
generating station and transmitted it directly to the Tuticorin
Pooling Station. In the absence of the DTL, power was
evacuated from the generating station through the temporary
LILO on the Tuticorin JV-Madurai Line at the location of the
generating station, which, from 04.01.2015 was taken to the
Tuticorin Pooling Station and further transmitted to the
distribution licensee. The intervening LILOs were, hence,
essential for the purpose of implementation of the system and
was an integral part of the system, which was made
commercially operative on 04.01.2015 and 08.01.2015. After the
establishment of the LILO, there could not have been a direct
transmission of electricity from the LILO of the generating
Page 37 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
company directly to Madurai as is clear from the pictorial
depiction, which we extract hereunder: -
Page 38 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
36. Upstream connection, which was not established as per
the timelines stipulated is the one shown in red commencing
from the Tuticorin Pooling Station to the Salem Pooling Station
and then further to Madhugiri. The delay in such establishment
did not in any manner affect the evacuation arrangement, since
the Tuticorin JV-Madurai line was utilized from the initial
generation of power from Coastal Energen as on 23.12.2014.
Though as argued by the generating company, electricity
moves seamlessly through the transmission lines, upon the
intervention made by the LILOs respectively on 04.01.2015 and
08.01.2015, the power generated from the NTPL, i.e. the
Tuticorin JV, and Coastal Energen evacuated through Tuticorin
JV-Madurai Transmission lines necessarily gets diverted to the
Tuticorin Pooling Station from which it is again evacuated and
transmitted through the Tuticorin JV-Madurai Line to the
distribution licensee. The LILOs being an integral part of the
system, the delay in implementation of the upstream
transmission to Salem does not affect the evacuation
arrangement at all. Hence, when the evacuation arrangement
as contemplated with the two LILOs were put in place on
04.01.2015 and 08.01.2015; which operated as the upstream
Page 39 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
transmission path, the delay in operationalizing the DTL
assumes significance.
37. The DTL in the above depiction is again indicated by the
broken red lines starting from Coastal Energen and ending at
the Tuticorin Pooling Station. The temporary arrangement by
way of a LILO for extraction of power from the generating
station is depicted by the broken blue lines commencing from
the generating station and the LILO at one circuit of the Tuticorin
JV-Madurai Line. The LILOs intersecting the power and
diverting it to the Tuticorin Pooling Station is shown again in two
sets of broken green lines commencing from the Tuticorin JV-
Madurai line and ending in the Tuticorin Pooling Station and
then retransmitted to the Tuticorin JV-Madurai Transmission
Lines. The beneficial use is hence clearly established.
Commercial Operation Date: -
38. Insofar as the COD is concerned, we extract the definition
clause Regulation 3(53) and Section 4 hereunder:
3 (53) ‘ Regular Service ’ means putting into use a
transmission system or element thereof after successful trial
operation and a certificate to that effect has been issued by
the concerned Regional Load Dispatch Centre.
xxx xxx xxx
Page 40 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
4. Date of Commercial Operation: The date of commercial
operation of a generating station or unit or block thereof or
a transmission system or element thereof shall be
determined as under:
(1) Date of commercial operation in case of a generating
unit or block of the thermal generating station shall mean
the date declared by the generating company after
demonstrating the maximum continuous rating (MCR) or
the installed capacity (IC) through a successful trial run after
notice to the beneficiaries, if any, and in case of the
generating station as a whole, the date of commercial
operation of the last generating unit or block of the
generating station:
Provided that
(i) where the beneficiaries have been tied up for
purchasing power from the generating station, the
trial run shall commence after seven days notice by
the generating company to the beneficiaries and
scheduling shall commence from 0000 hrs after
completion of the trial run:
(ii) the generating company shall certify to the effect
that the generating station meets the key
provisions of the technical standards of Central
Electricity Authority (Technical Standards for
Construction of Electrical plants and electric lines)
Regulations, 2010 and Grid Code:
(iii) the certificate shall be signed by CMD/CEO/MD of
the company subsequent to its approval by the
Page 41 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
Board of Directors in the format enclosed at
Appendix VI and a copy of the certificate shall be
submitted to the Member Secretary, (concerned
Regional Power Committee) and concerned RLDC
before declaration of COD:
39. Sub-clause (ii) of clause (3) of Regulation 4 applies only
when a transmission system or an element thereof is prevented
from regular service for reasons not attributable to the
transmission licensee or its supplier or its contractors but is on
account of the delay in commissioning of the concerned
generating stations or in commissioning of the upstream and
downstream transmission system. Hence, when a generating
station has operationalized its power generation and there is a
delay in the operationalization of the transmission lines or vice-
versa when the transmission lines are operationalized and there
is a delay in the generating station being operationalized, then
the defaulting party would be made liable for which an
appropriate application for approval of the date of commercial
operation (COD) is required to be filed before the CERC.
40. In the present case, as has been admitted by both the
generating company and the distribution licensee, there was no
Page 42 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
impediment caused to the transmission of electricity from the
date of commencement of generation at the generating station.
The upstream transmission system insofar as the subject
evacuation arrangement had two alternatives, one the Tuticorin
to Salem Pooling Station and further to Madhugiri and the LILOs
on the Tuticorin JV-Madurai Line at the Tuticorin Pooling Station,
the latter of which stood established, though with some delay.
Despite the delay not being condoned, the liability falls on the
generating company from the date of the COD of the LILOs;
especially for reason of the DTL having not been established.
The definition clause, as extracted hereinabove, clearly
indicates that ‘Regular Service’ means putting into use of the
transmission system or element thereof, after successful trial
operation and a certificate to that effect issued by the
concerned RLDC. This is in consonance with clause (3) of
Regulation 4 which declares the COD to be the date declared
by the transmission licensee from 0000 hours of which an
element of the transmission system is in regular service after
successful trial operation.
41. The CERC in its order has specifically referred to the
claim of the petitioner, the CTU, of commercial operation of
Page 43 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
Asset 1 and Asset 2, both being LILOs at the Tuticorin Pooling
Station, implemented as on 04.01.2015 and 08.01.2015. The
RLDC certificate for charging of the instant assets after the
successful trial run and the CEA certificate under Regulation 43
of the Central Electricity Authority (Measures Related to Safety
and Electricity Supply) Regulations 2010 had been submitted
by the CTU through an affidavit dated 12.05.2016. The CTU also
submitted the implementation of 1x80 MVAR bus reactor in its
Tuticorin Pooling Station for the purpose of voltage control.
th th
Referring to the 29 and 30 Standing Committee Meetings, as
per scheme approved by the Southern Region beneficiaries,
the commercial operation date of Asset 1 and Asset 2 as on
04.01.2015 and 08.01.2015 was accepted. This calls for no-
redetermination under Regulation 4(3)(ii) of the Tariff
Regulations.
The Precedents: -
42. All the parties placed heavy reliance on the decision of
this Court in Power Grid Corporation of India Limited vs.
Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Company Limited and
Page 44 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
1
Ors. (authored by one of us: Justice J.B. Pardiwala) wherein the
first respondent who was the distribution licensee was required
to construct and commission the Inter-State Transmission Line
coinciding with the timeline of completion of works, which were
within the scope of the appellant, the CTU. Therein the time
over-run was attributable to the distribution licensee, who
delayed the commissioning of the downstream intra-State asset
while the CTU obtained approval of the COD under Regulation
of 4(3)(ii) of the transmission lines set up by the CTU. The CERC
not only allowed the CTU to claim compensation for the period
prior to the COD as liquidated damages, interest during
construction and incidental expenses incurred during
construction, but also the transmission charges in case of all the
assets, to be borne by the first respondent, from the COD
determined under Regulation 4(3)(ii) up to one day before
actual charging of the downstream system. The first respondent
argued that there was no regulation to support the said liability.
43. Looking at Section 79 and 178 of the Act of 2003, it was
held that the CERC, the statutory authority under the Electricity
Act is enjoined with the tasks of both; regulation as well as
1
(2025) 8 SCC 705
Page 45 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
adjudication on the aspects of generation transmission and
distribution of electricity. However, such functions by
themselves were distinct and separate, since those under
Section 79 were administrative or adjudicatory in nature, while
those under Section 178 were delegated legislative powers. It
was held so under paragraph 42, relying on PTC India Limited
v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission, Thr.
2
Secretary :
“42. What is discernible from the aforesaid exposition of
law is that there is a dichotomy between the power to make
a regulation under Section 178 and the power to regulate or
adjudicate on the various areas enumerated under Section
79(1). A regulation under Section 178 is of general
application to the entirety of a particular subject-matter as
opposed to regulation on a case-to-case basis which may
be done by CERC under Section 79. Therefore, making of a
regulation under Section 178 has the effect of interfering
with and overriding existing contractual relationships
between the regulated entities. On the other hand, the
orders under Section 79 have to be confined to the existing
statutory regulations and do not have the effect of altering
the terms of contract between the specific parties before
CERC.”
2
44. PTC India Limited declared that ‘making of a regulation
under Section 178 is not a precondition to the Central Commission
2
(2010) 4 SCC 603
Page 46 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
taking any steps/measures under Section 179 (1)’ (sic) . While
unequivocally declaring that if there is a regulation under
Section 178 then the measure under Section 79(1) has to be in
conformity with such regulation, it was also held that an order
imposing regulatory fees could be passed even in the absence
of a regulation under Section 178. While the validity of the
delegated legislation under Section 178 has to be tested by way
of judicial review, an unreasonable levy under Section 111,
whether it be; in the absence of a regulation, or on an
interpretation of the regulation enacted under Section 178,
could be challenged before the APTEL by way of an appeal.
45. Reliance was also placed on Energy Watchdog v. Central
3
Electricity Regulatory Commission and Ors. Etc. , which
found Section 79(1) to be the repository of the regulatory
powers of the CERC, which powers should be exercised in
conformity with the guidelines or regulations; if in existence
under Section 178, and even otherwise despite a regulatory
lacuna. The order of the CERC which was impugned in PGCIL
imposing liability of payment of compensation for delay on the
part of the first respondent was upheld despite absence of a
3
(2017) 14 SCC 80
Page 47 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
regulation under Section 178; finding the liability to be
reasonably imposed on the defaulting party. The dictum
squarely applies in the present case, where the generating
company failed to establish and operationalise its DTL within
the time stipulated. In the period between COD of the LILOs
established by the CTU and the establishment of the DTL by the
generating company, the liability cast by the CERC on the
generating company is perfectly in order.
In Denouement of the APTEL Order: -
46. We are definitely of the opinion that the APTEL erred in
finding the usage of LILOs to be absent in the transmission of
power. We have seen that the strengthening of the Southern
Region Transmission System as available from the minutes of
the SCM, which were duly agreed to, in the BPTA, required the
LILO of both circuits of the Tuticorin JV-Madurai Line to be made
at the Tuticorin Pooling Station. The PGCIL thus was obliged to
construct the said LILO, which was also a permanent part of the
transmission plan. However, while accepting the LILO to be a
permanent part of the transmission plan, surprisingly the APTEL
found its use to be not established and the COD having not been
granted in the manner it should have been done; despite clear
Page 48 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
admission of its use by the generating company. We have
already held that the consideration of the COD by the CERC, in
the context of no prevention of regular service, to be perfectly
in order. In fact the COD as projected by the PGCIL was
accepted on the basis of the admitted ‘Regular Service’ as
defined in the Tariff Regulations, on the strength of the
successful trial operation certified by the RLDC.
47. It is pertinent that APTEL noticed the contention of PGCIL
that TANGEDCO has taken mutually destructive pleas of; no
liability to transmission charges despite utilization of the LILOs,
and the plea of the LILOs have been not been put to use at all.
The APTEL also noticed that under Section 29(4) of the
Electricity Act, the decision taken by the Regional Power
Committee of the SCM, in furtherance of grid stability and
coordinated transmission planning has legal sanctity and hence
the approval of the LILO in the 30th SCM participated by all
stakeholders, including TANGEDCO binds all parties. It is
pertinent here, to observe that the generating company never
raised any objection in the SCMs and also did not participate in
the tariff determination before the CERC.
Page 49 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
48. The error committed by the APTEL also in placing heavy
reliance on paragraph 72 of the CERC order, based on which
the concept of ‘beneficial use’ was coined, in the context of
absence of the upstream transmission lines. As we observed,
paragraph 72 of the CERC order cannot be isolated and
considered out of context. Looking at the spirit and tenor of the
CERC order, paragraph 72 cannot be termed as a finding of the
CERC and can only be looked at as the recording of the
contentions of the TANGEDCO, while paragraph 73 to 77 posed
the question of liability of the transmission charges and mulcted
it squarely on the generating company, based also on the
th
minutes of the 30 SCM the extract from which, we also
extracted in paragraph 12 of this judgment. The conclusion of
the APTEL that the pictorial depiction clearly indicates the
temporary arrangement of a LILO made by the generating
company on the Tuticorin JV-Madurai line, which proceeds
directly to Madurai and does not reach the Tuticorin Pooling
Station, factually is incorrect. The LILO’s on the line restricted
such transmission directly to Madurai without being routed
through the Tuticorin Pooling Station.
Page 50 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.
49. The first question of law is answered in the affirmative,
finding the element of the two LILOs, in the Tuticorin JV-
Madurai line at Tuticorin Pooling Station, as includable in the
transmission tariff, as found by the CERC, from 04.01.2015 upto
the establishment of the Dedicated Transmission Line (DTL) on
27.10.2016 as non-PoC. The second question of law is answered
in the negative, finding the interpretation of the APTEL, on the
COD, to be erroneous. The third question of law is again
answered in the affirmative, based also on the decisions of this
Court cited as precedents hereinabove.
50. We, hence, on the above reasoning, set aside the
impugned orders of the APTEL in both the appeals and restore
the order of the CERC.
51. The appeals are allowed.
52. Pending application (s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
……...…….……………………. J.
(J. B. PARDIWALA)
...………….……………………. J.
(K. VINOD CHANDRAN)
NEW DELHI
NOVEMBER 18, 2026.
Page 51 of 51
C.A. No.14780-14781 of 2025 etc.