Md. Isa vs The State of Bihar

Court
Patna High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.8890 of 2025
======================================================
Md. Isa Son of Md. Shams-ul Haque, Resident of Village-Tarha, Ward No. 12,
Sugma, PS-Banma Itihari, District-Saharsa, Bihar-852129.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar through Additional Chief Secretary, Panchayati Raj
Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.
rd
2. State Election Commission, Bihar, Patna through the Secretary, 3 Floor,
Sone Bhawan, Veer Chand Patel Path, Patna.
rd
3. The Secretary, State Election Commission, 3 Floor, Sone Bhawan, Veer
Chand Patel Path, Patna.
rd
4. Officer on Special Duty, State Election Commission, 3 Floor, Sone
Bhawan, Veer Chand Patel Path, Patna.
5. The Additional Chief Secretary-cum-Chairman, General Committee (Caste
Scrutiny Committee), General Administration Department, Government of
Bihar at Patna.
6. The District Election Officer (Panchayat) cum District Magistrate, District-
Saharsa, Bihar.
7. Senior Superintendent of Police (Administration), Saharsa.
8. The Additional Superintendent of Police (Administration), Saharsa.
9. Subhash Kumar, son of Shri Priyavarat Sah, Resident of Village-Thadhia,
P.O. Suagma, P.S. Salakhua, District-Saharsa.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner : Mr. Amit Shrivastava, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Ranjeet Choubey, Advocate
Mr. Siddharth Shankar Singh, Advocate
For the State : Mrs. Pushpanjali Sharma, AC to SC-20
For the Resp. No.9 : Mr. S.B.K. Manglam, Advocate
Mr. Awnish Kumar, Advocate
Mr. Vikash Kumar Singh, Advocate
Mr. Kumar Gaurav, Advocate
For the State Election Commission : Mr. Ravi Ranjan, Advocate
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PARTHA SARTHY
C.A.V. JUDGMENT
Date :14-08-2026
Heard Mr. Amit Srivastava, learned Senior counsel

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
2/31
assisted by Mr. Ranjeet Choubey, learned counsel for the
petitioner, Mrs. Pushpanjali Sharma, learned A.C. to S.C.-20 for
the State of Bihar, Mr. Ravi Ranjan, learned counsel for the
State Election Commission and Mr. S.B.K. Manglam, learned
counsel for the respondent no.9.
2. The petitioner has filed the instant application for
the following relief(s):
“i. For issuance of an appropriate writ in the nature of
Certiorari or any other writ of similar nature for
quashing the proceeding of the general committee (caste
Scrutiny Committee) dated 28.03.2025 and further
communicated vide Memo No.6574 dated 11.04.2025
whereby and where under the committee has been
pleased to reject the claim of the petitioner as belonging
to Teli (Muslim) extremely backward class on the
arbitrary and non est grounds and has been further
pleased to forward the said finding to the Respondent
State Election Commission in case no. 56/2023 [Subash
Kumar v. The District Election Officer (Panchayats) cum
District Magistrate, Saharsa and Others] for further
action.
ii. For issuance of a direction, order, writ, including writ
of Mandamus directing the Respondent Authorities and
more particularly Respondent State Election Commission
not to take any action against the petitioner on the basis
of the aforementioned finding of the general committee as
the same has been prepared malafidely without
considering relevant documents as also ignoring the
inquiry report submitted in said proceeding.

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
3/31
iii. For issuance of a direction, order, writ, including writ
of Mandamus directing the respondent authorities to
show cause as to why the report of three membered
committee/inspecting team chaired by the SSP
(Administration), Saharsa was not duly considered by the
General Committee (Caste Scrutiny Committee).
iv. For a declaration that the petitioner belongs to Teli
(Muslim) community based upon unequivocal finding of
the enquiry report submitted in favour of the petitioner.
v. For a declaration that if statute prescribes a particular
act to be done in a particular manner, then it should be
done in that manner alone or not at all and other means
are not only necessarily prohibited but also constitute
illegality.
vi. For issuance of any other appropriate writ/writs,
order/orders, direction/directions for which the writ
petitioner is entitled under the facts and circumstances of
the case.
vii. For issuance of appropriate writ in the nature of
certiorari or any other similar writ of similar nature for
quashing the order dated 25-06-2025 passed in Case no.
56/2023 by Respondent State Election Commission and
further communicated vide memo no. 2876 dated 25-6-
2025 under the signature of Respondent no. 4 on the
ground that said order is also an illegality as same is
based upon illegal and wrong finding of the general
committee of the caste scrutiny committee.
viii. For issuance of an appropriate writ in nature of
mandamus or any other writ of similar nature,
commanding and directing the Respondent State Election
Commission not to proceed ahead in furtherance of order
dated 25-06-2025 passed in case no..”

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
4/31
3. The case of the petitioner in brief is that in the
election held in the year 2021, he was elected on the post of
Mukhiya of Gram Panchayat Raj Sahuria. A complaint was filed
by respondent no.9 before the State Election Commission
(‘SEC’ or ‘the Commission’ in short) praying for disqualifying
the petitioner on the ground that the seat on which the petitioner
had been elected was reserved for Extremely Backward Class
(‘EBC’ in short) while the petitioner who belonged to Sheikh
community had fraudulently obtained a caste certificate of EBC
wrongly showing himself to belong to the caste of Teli
(Muslim).
4. Upon the direction of the Criminal Investigation
Department (Weaker Section), a three member Enquiry
Committee enquired into the caste of the petitioner and
submitted its report dated 31.12.2024 (Annexure-P/3) according
to which it confirmed that the petitioner belonged to Teli
(Muslim) caste.
5. The petitioner received a show cause contained in
letter no.2319 dated 7.2.2025 asking him to respond to the
report dated 31.12.2024. The petitioner submitted his reply on
4.3.2025.
6. Another report dated 28.3.2025 (Annexure-P/5)

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
5/31
contained in memo no.6574 dated 11.4.2025 came to be
submitted by the three member Caste Scrutiny Committee
wherein the claim of the petitioner for reservation in the EBC
category on account of belonging to Teli (Muslim) caste was
rejected.
7. The Commission proceeded with the Case no.56 of
2023 registered on the complaint filed by respondent no.9 and
passed order contained in memo no.2876 dated 25.6.2025 under
the signature of the State Election Commissioner, Bihar holding
that the petitioner was not a permanent resident of the State of
Bihar and thus was not entitled for reservation on the ground of
the illegal caste certificate. Thus his election as a Mukhiya was
not proper and as a result he is removed from the said post. It
was further ordered to recommend action against the concerned
State employee who had issued the incorrect caste certificate to
the petitioner.
8. It is against the Caste Scrutiny Committee
proceeding dated 28.3.2025 contained in memo no.6574 dated
11.4.2025 and the order dated 25.6.2025 passed in Case no.56 of
2023 of the State Election Commission that the petitioner has
filed the instant writ application for the reliefs as stated herein
above.

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
6/31
9. Mr. Amit Srivastava, learned Senior counsel
appearing for the petitioner submitted that it is the Caste
Scrutiny Committee which is the fact finding body. The
Committee in its report dated 31.12.2024 (Annexure-P/3)
having confirmed the caste of the petitioner as Teli (Muslim), in
view of clause 4(kha) of the resolution dated 5.2.2014
(Annexure-P/2) of the General Administration Department,
Government of Bihar, there was no occasion for taking further
steps in the matter. The Committee once again entering into
examining the caste of the petitioner was beyond its jurisdiction
and thus the second report of the Caste Scrutiny Committee
dated 28.3.2025 is not sustainable.
10. Learned Senior counsel for the petitioner further
submitted that even in its second report dated 28.3.2025, the
Caste Scrutiny Committee refused to give benefit to the
petitioner of reservation for the EBC category on the ground of
the petitioner not being a resident of the State of Bihar and thus
not being entitled for benefit of reservation under the Bihar Act
15 of 2003.
11. It was submitted by learned Senior counsel for
the petitioner that taking into consideration the contents of the
second report of the CSC dated 28.3.2025, the State Election

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
7/31
Commission by its order dated 25.6.2025 passed in Case no.56
of 2023 allowed the application filed by the respondent no.9
holding that the petitioner had obtained the benefit on the basis
of an illegal/incorrect caste certificate. It was recommended that
the District Election Officer (Panchayat)-cum-District
Magistrate, Saharsa proceed against the petitioner.
12. It was finally contended by learned Senior
counsel for the petitioner that in view of the facts and
circumstances of the case, the respondents having committed
the illegality in re-examining the caste of the petitioner and the
petitioner having been incorrectly denied the benefit of
belonging to the EBC category on the basis of the provisions
contained in Bihar Act 15 of 2003, the orders impugned are not
sustainable and thus be set aside.
13. Learned Senior counsel appearing for the
petitioner in support of his contention relied upon the judgments
in the case of Kumari Madhuri Patil vs. Addl. Commissioner,
Tribal Development; (1994) 6 SCC 241, Tarlochan Dev
Sharma vs State Of Punjab; AIR 2001 SC 2524, Nazir
Ahmad vs Emperor; AIR 1936 PC 253, Karim Uddin
Barbhuiya vs Aminul Haque Laskar; AIR 2024 SC 2193, Ex-
Recruit Babanna Machched vs. Union of India; AIR 2024

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
8/31
SC 921 and Anjani Jha vs. State of Bihar; 2023 (2) PLJR
793.
14. The application is opposed by Mr. Ravi Ranjan,
learned counsel appearing for the State Election Commission. It
was submitted that on a question with respect to the caste of the
petitioner being raised in a complaint filed by the respondent
no.9, the documents not being of unimpeachable character, in
view of the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case
of Kumari Madhuri Patil (supra) the matter was referred to the
State Level Caste Screening Committee which is the apex fact
finding body. A report was submitted confirming the caste of the
petitioner to be Teli (Muslim).
15. It is further submitted by learned counsel for the
State Election Commission that the ancestors of the petitioner
were resident of Jaunpur in the State of Uttar Pradesh. The
petitioner was asked to respond to the same. The petitioner
responded by filing a reply. Another report dated 28.3.2025 was
submitted by the Caste Scrutiny Committee. Taking into
consideration the provisions of Bihar Act 15 of 2003 that a
person who is resident of a place outside the State of Bihar
would not be entitled for reservation, in view of the fact that the
ancestors of the petitioner were resident of Uttar Pradesh, the

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
9/31
benefit taken by the petitioner on account of belonging to Teli
(Muslim) and thus to the category of EBC, the same was denied
to the petitioner. The matter was thereafter considered by the
State Election Commission. By its order dated 25.6.2025, the
State Election Commission was pleased to allow Case no.56 of
2023 filed by the respondent no.9 and holding that the petitioner
not being a original resident of the State, he was not entitled to
reservation here which he had obtained on the basis of an
incorrect caste certificate.
16. Learned counsel for the Commission submitted
that in coming to the findings, the State Election Commission
has relied upon the findings of the Caste Scrutiny Committee,
the admitted stand of the petitioner that his family migrated to
the State of Bihar about 125 years ago and that the documents
produced by the petitioner could not prove that he belonged to
Teli (Muslim) caste.
17. Learned counsel for the Commission in support
of his submissions relied upon the judgment in the case of Mari
Chandrashekhar vs. Seth G.S. Medical College; (1990) 3
SCC 130 and Bindu Devi vs. State of Bihar; 2024 (2) PLJR
103 . It was submitted that there is no merit in the writ
application and the same be dismissed.

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
10/31
18. Mr. S.B.K. Manglam, learned counsel appearing
for the respondent no.9 submitted that the caste of the petitioner
having been called in question on a petition filed by the
respondent no.9, the matter was referred to the Caste Scrutiny
Committee. In its final report dated 28.3.2025, the Committee
came to the conclusion that as per the petitioner’s case itself, his
ancestors had moved from Jaunpur, Uttar Pradesh to the State of
Bihar and, therefore the petitioner was not an original resident
of Bihar. Thus, in view of the provisions contained in Bihar Act
15 of 2003, he was not entitled for the benefit of reservation.
19. Learned counsel appearing for the respondent
no.9 further referring to a copy of the letter no.673 dated
8.3.2011 (Annexure-R9/1) of the General Administration
Department, Government of Bihar submitted that as per clause 9
thereof, the documents mentioned therein are to be considered
evidence for issuance of caste certificate. Further referring to the
provisions contained in section 4 of the Bihar Reservation of
Vacancy in Posts and Services (for Scheduled Caste,
Schedule Tribes and Other Backward Classes) Act, 1991
(‘Act of 1991’ in short), amended by Bihar Act 15 of 2003, it
was submitted that persons resident of outside the State of Bihar
are not entitled for reservation under the said Act and thus the

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
11/31
petitioner not being an original resident of the State of Bihar
cannot claim reservation on the basis of the caste certificate. It
was submitted that the State Election Commission on the basis
of the final report of the Caste Scrutiny Committee rightly held
the petitioner not to be entitled for the benefit of reservation and
thus set aside the election of the petitioner as a Mukhiya on the
seat reserved for the EBC category.
20. Learned counsel for the respondent no.9 in
support of his submission relied upon the judgments in the case
of Manoj Prasad vs State Election Commission (Panchayat);
2023 (4) PLJR 6, Pooja Kumari vs State of Bihar; 2024 (1)
PLJR 391, Khushboo Ara vs State of Bihar; 2023 (3) PLJR
560 affirmed in LPA no.881 of 2023 and Bindu Devi vs State
of Bihar; 2024 (3) BLJ 714.
21. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
the material on record.
22. The relevant facts in brief are that the petitioner
was elected as the Mukhiya of Gram Panchayat Raj Sahuria in
the elections held in the year 2021.
23. A complaint case was filed by the respondent
no.9 before the State Election Commission under section 136(2)
of the Bihar Panchayat Raj Act, 2006 (‘the Panchayat Raj Act’

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
12/31
in short) and the same was registered as Case no.56 of 2023.
24. The case of the respondent no.9/complainant was
that the petitioner is a Sheikh by caste and showing himself to
be a Teli (Muslim) he has fraudulently obtained a caste
certificate of EBC from the Circle Officer, Banma Itihari and
contesting the elections for the post of Mukhiya from Gram
Panchayat Raj Sahuria which was reserved for the members of
EBC, the petitioner had been elected. As such, he be
disqualified from the post of Mukhiya of Gram Panchayat Raj
Sahuria.
25. It may be mentioned here that there is no dispute
with respect to the fact that a caste certificate dated 2.2.2016
was issued by the competent authority certifying the petitioner
to be belonging to Teli (Muslim) caste, and a copy of the same
has been brought on record as annexure to the application.
26. The issue with respect to benefits etc. on account
of an incorrect caste certificate having been obtained by a
person came up for consideration before the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of Kumari Madhuri Patil (supra). The Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that admissions wrongly gained or
appointment wrongly obtained on the basis of false social status
certificate has the affect of depriving of genuine candidates of

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
13/31
the benefit conferred on them by the Constitution. So far as
admissions to educational institutions are concerned, the
applications are generally made by parent as the student may be
a minor and it is the parent or guardian who play fraud claiming
false status certificate. The Hon’ble Court proceeded to hold
that it was necessary that the certificates issued be scrutinised at
the earliest and with utmost expedition and promptitude. It
proceeded to streamline the procedure for issuance of social
status certificate, their scrutiny and their approval. The relevant
part of paragraph no.13 and paragraph no.15 of the judgment in
the case of Kumari Madhuri Patil (supra) is reproduced herein
below:
“13. The admission wrongly gained or
appointment wrongly obtained on the basis of false
social status certificate necessarily has the effect of
depriving the genuine Scheduled Castes or Scheduled
Tribes or OBC candidates as enjoined in the
Constitution of the benefits conferred on them by the
Constitution. The genuine candidates are also denied
admission to educational institutions or appointments
to office or posts under a State for want of social status
certificate. The ineligible or spurious persons who
falsely gained entry resort to dilatory tactics and
create hurdles in completion of the inquiries by the
Scrutiny Committee……………… It is, therefore,
necessary that the certificates issued are scrutinised at
the earliest and with utmost expedition and

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
14/31
promptitude. For that purpose, it is necessary to
streamline the procedure for the issuance of social
status certificates, their scrutiny and their approval,
which may be the following:
1. The application for grant of social
status certificate shall be made to the
Revenue Sub-Divisional Officer ………
……………..
3. Application for verification of the caste
certificate by the Scrutiny Committee shall be filed at
least six months in advance before seeking admission
into educational institution or an appointment to a
post.
……………….
7. In case the report is in favour of the
candidate and found to be genuine and true, no further
action need be taken except where the report or the
particulars given are procured or found to be false or
fraudulently obtained and in the latter event the same
procedure as is envisaged in para 6 be followed.
………………….
11. The order passed by the Committee
shall be final and conclusive only subject to the
proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution.
12. No suit or other proceedings before
any other authority should lie.”
27. At this stage itself, it would be relevant to refer to
the Full Bench judgment of this Court in the case of Rajani
Kumari vs. The State Election Commission through its
Secretary; 2019 (4) PLJR 673 wherein in an answer to

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
15/31
question no.I as to whether the State Election Commission will
have power to consider disqualification of a candidate after
election as such Election Commission is constituted for conduct
of elections, this Court held as follows:
“183. I, therefore, find that the cumulative
impact of the entire discussion in the separate
judgments would take us to answer the reference in the
following terms:-
Question No. I-Whether the State Election
Commission will have power to consider
disqualification of a candidate after election as such
Election Commission is constituted for conduct of
elections?
184. We are in agreement that the State
Election Commission has got power under sub-section
(2) of Section 18 of the Bihar Municipal Act, 2007 and
sub-section (2) of Section 136 of the Bihar Panchayat
Raj Act, 2006 to consider an issue of pre or post-
election disqualification of a candidate subject to a
caution which we have pointed out in our judgments in
respect of a case which is in the nature of a purely
election dispute and then a matter which cannot be
decided without adducement of evidence by a
competent court and authority in accordance with law.
The State Election Commission shall entertain and
consider the 'disqualification' issues on the basis of the
unimpeachable materials placed before him. Whether a
complaint brought before the Commission either suo-
moto or by any other person, the Commission shall at
the first instance enquire whether it is a purely election

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
16/31
dispute and only when it is found that the dispute
brought before it is not a purely election dispute, the
Commission shall proceed to consider the same on the
basis of unimpeachable materials. Whenever a disputed
question of facts and a contentious issue is brought
before the Commission as a ground and basis to render
a candidate disqualified, the Commission would be
required to relegate the parties to a competent
court/tribunal or a fact finding body competent to
decide such contentious issues after taking evidences
and till such time the Commission shall not take a
decision on such complaint either suo-moto or
otherwise.”
28. On filing of Case no.56 of 2023 by the
respondent no.9, a direction was given by the Criminal
Investigation Department (Weaker Section) to scrutinise the
caste of the petitioner.
29. The three members Caste Scrutiny Committee
constituted on 18.3.2024 issued notice to the petitioner on
7.6.2024 and visited his residence in Panchayat Sahuria, Post
Sugma as also the present residence under Police Station
Banma Itihari. The Committee made enquiries from the
villagers of the petitioner, his neighbours, relatives as also
various public representatives. In course of enquiry, the caste
certificate issued in favour of the petitioner was also given to
the enquiry team and enquiries were made from a number of

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
17/31
persons including Chandra Kishore Mehta (neighbour),
Shambhu Ram (co-villager), Md.Vakil Khan (co-villager), Md.
Masir Alam (relative), Md. Shoaib Alam (relative), Kuresha
Khatoon (relative) and Aklu Bhagat (neighbour). It was stated
by the Committee that the elections for the seat of Mukhiya of
Panchayat Sahuria held in the year 2021 was reserved for the
EBC category, the petitioner who belonged to the said category
contested the election and was elected. Besides the above,
witness Ward Member Smt. Indu Devi as also a member of
Panchayat Samiti namely Sri Kalo Kumar disclosed that they
know the ancestors of the petitioner who are Teli (Muslim).
Further, the caste certificate issued in favour of the petitioner
from the office of the Circle Officer of Banma Itihari was sent
for verification to the said office. A verification report was
made available from the office of the Circle Officer along with
the covering letter stating therein that after getting the
necessary enquiries done by the Revenue Karamchari and
Revenue Officer, the caste certificate had been issued in favour
of the petitioner stating that he belonged to Teli (Muslim) caste.
In view of the aforesaid facts, the Caste Scrutiny Committee
submitted it’s report dated 31.12.2024 signed by all the three
members to the effect that the petitioner belonged to Teli

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
18/31
(Muslim) caste.
30. In view of the categorical finding of the Caste
Scrutiny Committee in its report dated 31.12.2024 finding the
caste certificate issued by the competent authority in favour of
the petitioner to be genuine and that the petitioner belonged to
Teli (Muslim) caste, it is the submission of learned Senior
counsel appearing for the petitioner that the matter should have
concluded.
31. At this stage, it would be relevant to refer to
para 13(vii) of the judgment in the case of Kumari Madhuri
Patil (supra) where the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that in
case the report is in favour of the candidate and found to be
genuine and true, no further action need to be taken.
32. Learned Senior counsel appearing for the
petitioner also refers to clause 4(kha) of the resolution
contained in memo no.1567 dated 5.2.2014 of the General
Administration Department, Government of Bihar which
provides that if the report of the Caste Scrutiny Committee is in
favour of the certificate holder, nothing further is required to be
done.
33. The petitioner was served with a copy of the
enquiry report dated 31.12.2024 along with the letter no.2319

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
19/31
dated 7.2.2025 asking the petitioner to respond to the same.
The petitioner submitted his response (Annexure-P/4) on
4.3.2025 before the Caste Scrutiny Committee (CSC) of the
General Administration Department. The Committee in its
meeting held on 28.3.2025 prepared a report contained in
memo no.6574 dated 11.4.2025 (Annexure-P/5). In its report,
the Committee referring to the provisions of Bihar Act 15 of
2003 that the candidates residing out of the State of Bihar shall
not claim benefits of reservation under the Act and that the
petitioner had not produced any other document except for the
hibbanama in evidence of his having moved from Jaunpur,
Uttar Pradesh and having settled in the State of Bihar, the
Committee came to the conclusion that the petitioner cannot
take benefit of reservation in the State of Bihar on account of
his claim of belonging to Teli (Muslim) ie EBC category.
34. On the report of the Caste Scrutiny Committee
contained in memo no.6574 dated 11.4.2025 being submitted
with the State Election Commission in Case no.56 of 2023, the
Commission passed order contained in memo no.2876 dated
25.6.2025 holding that the petitioner is not an original resident
of the State of Bihar and, therefore, not entitled for the benefit
of reservation on the basis of the illegal caste certificate. Thus

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
20/31
his election on the reserved post of Mukhiya is not as per the
Rules. His election was set aside in exercise of powers
conferred under section 135 read with section 136(2) of the
Bihar Panchayat Raj Act, 2006. Recommendation was made to
proceed against the officers and employees who had issued the
incorrect caste certificate in favour of the petitioner.
35. The first point contended by learned Senior
counsel appearing for the petitioner was that on the Caste
Scrutiny Committee coming out with its first report dated
31.12.2024 (Annexure-P/3), in view of the provisions
contained in clause 4 (kha) of the General Administration
Department, Bihar contained in memo no.1567 dated 5.2.2014,
no further steps were required to be taken. It may only be
observed here that from a bare reading of the provisions
contained in clause 4 (kha), it cannot be said that there is an
absolute bar in proceeding further in the matter.
36. The question thus arising is as to whether the
Caste Scrutiny Committee after having submitted its report
dated 31.12.2024, had the power to review the same and come
out with another report on 4.3.2025. In this context, it may be
observed that the first report dated 31.12.2024 was by a
Committee comprising of police personnel ie Additional

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
21/31
Superintendent of Police (Administration), a Police Inspector
and a Police Sub-Inspector constituted on the direction of the
Criminal Investigation Department (CID). A copy of the said
report was provided to the petitioner to which he filed his
response (Annexure-P/4) on 4.3.2025 and thereafter the
respondent Caste Scrutiny Committee in its meeting held on
28.3.2025 came out with the report contained in memo no.6574
dated 11.4.2025 wherein the three members were the
Additional Chief Secretary, General Administration
Department, the Deputy Secretary (Weaker Section and EBC),
Welfare Department and Additional Secretary, General
Administration Department. Thus, the second report contained
in memo dated 11.4.2025 cannot be said to be a review of the
first report dated 31.12.2024.
37. It may be observed here that while in its report
dated 31.12.2024 there was a categorical finding affirming the
caste certificate that the petitioner belonged to Teli (Muslim)
caste, in the subsequent report contained in memo dated
11.4.2025, the Committee observed that the petitioner had not
produced any other document in support of his belonging to the
Teli (Muslim) caste except a hibbanama issued in the year
1900. This report was being prepared by the Committee after

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
22/31
the petitioner was served with a copy of the enquiry report
dated 31.12.2024 and after he had filed his response to the
same. Thus the report dated 31.12.2024 was also before the
Committee. Inspite of these facts, the Committee preparing the
subsequent report dated 11.4.2025 failed to take into
consideration that it was not just the hibbanama but in
preparing the report dated 31.12.2024, the three member
committee had taken into consideration a number of other
factors, for example, (i) enquiries from the villagers,
neighbours, relatives as also public representatives of the
petitioner (ii) caste certificate issued in favour of the petitioner
was verified from the Circle Officer.
38. It would also be relevant to note that in its report
contained in memo dated 11.4.2025, the Caste Scrutiny
Committee did not conclude that the petitioner did not belong
to Teli (Muslim) caste or that he belonged to some other caste.
It only stated that on account of residing out of the State of
Bihar, in view of the provisions contained in Bihar Act 15 of
2003, he was not entitled for benefit of reservation under Bihar
Act 15 of 2003.
39. It may be mentioned here that the Bihar
Reservation of Vacancies in Posts and Services (for Schedule

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
23/31
Castes, Schedule Tribes and Other Backward Classes) Act,
1991 was framed to provide adequate representation of SC, ST
and OBC in posts and services under the State of Bhar.
Schedule I of the said Act gives a list of Extremely Backward
Classes (EBCs).
40. Bihar Act 15 of 2003 ( The Bihar Reservation
of Vacancies in Posts and Services for Scheduled Castes,
Scheduled Tribes and other Backward Classes
(Amendment) Act, 2003 ) brought about amendments in the
Act of 1991. It added a third proviso to section 4(2) of the Act
of 1991 which reads as follows:
“Provided further that the candidates residing out of
the State of Bihar shall not claim for benefits of
reservation under this Act.”
41. So far as the application of the Act of 1991 to
the elections of Mukhiya is concerned, it may be mentioned
that reservation of seats for the post of Mukhiya is governed by
the provisions contained in section 15(5) of Bihar Panchayat
Raj Act, 2006 which provides that seats shall be reserved for
SCs, STs and BCs, but the same shall not exceed 50% of the
total seat of Mukhiya within a Panchayat Samiti. Backward
Classes is defined under section 2(b) of the Bihar Panchayat
Raj Act, 2006 as follows:

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
24/31
“(b) “ Backward Classes ” means and includes the list
of Backward Classes of citizens specified in Annexure 1
of the Bihar Reservation of Vacancies in Posts and
Services (for SC, ST and Other Backward Classes) Act,
1991 (Bihar Act No.3, 1992).”
42. Thus from the facts stated herein above, it is
clearly seen that so far as the Act of 1991 is concerned, the
same does not govern the reservation in the election to the post
of Mukhiya but the said reservation is to be governed by the
provisions contained in section 15(5) of the Panchayat Raj Act.
The connection between the two Acts is to the extent that so far
as the list of Backward Classes within the meaning of
Panchayat Raj Act is concerned, the same has been defined to
mean the castes specified in Annexure 1 of the Act of 1991.
43. The Caste Scrutiny Committee in its report has
held that Act 15 of 2003 provides that a candidate residing
outside the State of Bihar shall not claim benefits of reservation
under this Act. Firstly, the benefit of reservation so far as
election to the post of Mukhiya is concerned, is not claimed
under the Bihar Act 15 of 2003 (Amending Act) or the main
Act of 1991. As stated above, the same is to be governed under
the Panchayat Raj Act. Further the petitioner cannot be said to
be a candidate ‘residing out of the State of Bihar’ for the reason
that even as per the respondent’s case, the ancestors of the

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
25/31
petitioner moved from Jaunpur, Uttar Pradesh to Bihar about
125 years ago and 3-4 generations above the petitioner. The
ancestors of the petitioner residing in the State of Bihar for
more than 100 years, by no stretch of imagination can it be said
that the petitioner is a candidate residing out of the State of
Bihar. Even the third proviso to section 4(2) of the Act of 1991
does not use the word that the benefit of reservation under the
Act will be given to ‘original residents’ only. Thus, in the
opinion of the Court, the Caste Scrutiny Committee in its
report contained in memo dated 11.4.2025 has clearly erred in
applying Bihar Act 15 of 2003 to the facts of the present case.
44. It would also be relevant to point out that while
holding that the petitioner cannot be given benefit of
reservation on account of not being a candidate residing in the
State of Bihar, the Caste Scrutiny Committee which is the Apex
Fact Finding Body has neither cancelled the caste certificate
issued by the competent authority in the State of Bihar in
favour of the petitioner certifying him to be belonging to Teli
(Muslim) nor recommended for it’s cancellation nor has it
given a finding that the petitioner belongs to some other caste.
45. On the report contained in memo dated
11.4.2025 of the Caste Scrutiny Committee having been

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
26/31
submitted to the State Election Commission, the Commission
proceeded to finally dispose of Case no.56 of 2023 by its order
contained in memo no.2876 dated 25.6.2025. A perusal of the
said order would show that the reasons for allowing the said
case filed by respondent no.9 are that the petitioner is not an
original resident of the State of Bihar and, therefore, cannot be
given the benefit of reservation on the basis of the caste
certificate. As such, the election of the petitioner as a Mukhiya
is set aside in exercise of powers under section 135 read with
section 136 (2) of the Panchayat Raj Act and further holding
the Circle Officer, Banma Itihari and the Revenue Karamchari
responsible for issuance of an incorrect caste certificate in
favour of the petitioner, recommendation is made for taking
appropriate action against them.
46. So far as the benefit of reservation not being
given to the petitioner on account of his not being an original
resident of the State of Bihar is concerned, the issue has
already been dealt with in detail herein above. In so far as the
State Election Commission also proceeding on the basis of the
provisions contained in the Act of 1991 (amended by the Bihar
Act 15 of 2003), reservation in the elections of Mukhiya are
not governed by Act of 1991 or the Amending Act but by

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
27/31
section 15(5) of the Panchayat Raj Act.
47. With respect to the State Election Commission
coming to the conclusion that an incorrect caste certificate has
been issued by the Circle Officer, Banma Itihari and the
concerned Revenue Karamchari, it may be observed here that
the basis for the Commission to come to the conclusion could
only have been the finding of the Apex Fact Finding Body ie
the Caste Scrutiny Committee. The Committee in its first report
dated 31.12.2024 having come to the categorical finding that
the petitioner belongs to the Teli (Muslim) caste and even in its
second report contained in memo dated 11.4.2025 only
observed that the petitioner had not produced any other
evidence in support of his caste except hibbanama and that the
benefit of reservation under the Act of 1991 (which this Court
has held to be not applicable) cannot be given to the petitioner
on account of his not being a resident of Bihar, in the opinion
of the Court, the State Election Commission clearly committed
an error in applying Act of 1991 in the case of election of the
petitioner as a Mukhiya and recommending action against the
concerned Circle Officer in absence of any supporting finding
to the said effect by the Caste Scrutiny Committee.
48. So far as the judgments relied upon by the

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
28/31
learned counsel for the State Election Commission and learned
counsel for the respondent no.9 are concerned, it may be
observed here that in the case of Bindu Devi vs. State of
Bihar; 2024 (2) PLJR 103 , the petitioner who belonged to a
caste under the Backward Class (BC) category in the State of
Uttar Pradesh came to Bihar by reason of marriage. She was
not given the benefit of reservation under the Panchayat Raj
Act on the ground of belonging to the OBC category in the
State of Uttar Pradesh as under the Act in Bihar reservation is
given only to persons belonging to EBC category. So far as the
fact of the instant case is concerned, the petitioner has not
moved to Bihar on account of his marriage but his ancestors
from 3-4 generations above have been residing in Bihar for the
last 125 years. Further, the Caste Scrutiny Committee has also
not come to the conclusion that the petitioner does not belong
to Teli (Muslim) caste nor has it recommended for cancellation
or cancelled the caste certificate of the petitioner.
49. In the case of Manoj Prasad vs. State
Election Commission; 2023 (4) PLJR 6 , the petitioner therein
had contested the election of Mukhiya on the seat reserved for
EBC declaring himself to be Dangi caste though he belonged to
Koeri (Kushwaha) which came under the OBC category. The

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
29/31
petitioner had described himself in the sale deed of a land
purchased by him in the year 2018 as belonging to Koeri caste.
Dangi was a different caste from Koeri caste which came to be
included under OBC in the year 1995 and in 2015 under EBC.
The Caste Scrutiny Committee came to a finding that the
petitioner does not belong to Dangi caste but to Koeri caste and
thus cannot contest from a seat reserved for EBC category. The
facts of the said case have no application whatsoever to the
instant case and are thus of no assistance to the respondents.
50. In Khushboo Ara vs. State of Bihar; 2023 (3)
PLJR 560 , while the petitioner contested for Mukhiya on a
seat which was reserved for the EBC category, an application
was filed to disqualify her on the ground that she belonged to
the caste of Sheikh which did not come under EBC. The matter
was referred by the Commission to the department including
the Caste Scrutiny Committee which came to the finding that
the petitioner belongs to Sheikh caste and thus disqualified the
petitioner. In the instant case, while in the first report, the three
member Committee found the petitioner to belong to the EBC
category being Teli (Muslim), even in its second report it did
not come to a conclusion that the petitioner does not belong to
Teli (Muslim)/EBC category nor did it recommend for

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
30/31
cancellation of caste certificate issued in favour of the
petitioner. Thus, the instant judgment also is of no assistance to
the respondents.
51. In view of the facts and circumstances of the
case, taking into consideration the report dated 31.12.2024 of
the three member Committee constituted on the directions of
the Criminal Investigation Department (Weaker Section)
finding the petitioner to be belonging to Teli (Muslim) caste on
the basis of the oral and documentary evidence discussed in
detail therein and the contents of the report dated 4.3.2025 of
the Committee, this Court is of the opinion that both the Caste
Scrutiny Committee in its report dated 4.3.2025 as also the
State Election Commission in its order dated 25.6.2025 passed
in Case no.56 of 2023 committed an error in applying Act of
1991 as also Amending Act 15 of 2003 in the case of
reservation to the post of Mukhiya.
52. In view of the facts and circumstances of the
case, the proceedings of the Caste Scrutiny Committee dated
28.3.2025 contained in memo no.6574 dated 11.4.2025 as also
the order contained in memo no.2876 dated 25.6.2025 passed
in Case no.56 of 2023 (Subhash Kumar vs. Md. Isa) by the
State Election Commission, Bihar both being unsustainable are

Patna High Court CWJC No.8890 of 2025 dt.14-08-2026
31/31
hereby set aside.
53. The writ application is allowed.

(Partha Sarthy, J)
Saurabh/-
AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE 09.07.2026
Uploading Date 14.08.2026
Transmission Date