BIDYUT NAHA vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Partha Sarathi Sen, J.
W.P.A. 13816 of 2026
Bidyut Naha
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors..
For the petitioner : Mr. Indra Nath Mukherjee
Mr. Indrajit Sen
Ms. Indralina Sen
For the State respondents : Mr. Ms. Indrani Chakraborty, Ld. AGP
Mr. Nilanjan Pal
Ms. Sarda Sha
Heard on : November 16, 2026
Judgment on : : November 16, 2026
Partha Sarathi Sen, J.
1. The subject matter of the instant writ petition is the memo dated
18.9.2025 as issued by the Collector and Deputy Inspector General of
Registration, West Bengal i.e. respondent no. 2 authority, a copy of
which has been annexed at page 50 of the instant writ petition. By
virtue of the impugned memo dated 18.9.2025, the respondent no. 2
authority in exercise of its power under Section 47A(5) and (8) of the
Indian Stamp Act, 1899 (the said Act, in short) enhanced and
determined the valuation of the property as involved in the instant
2
writ petition to the tune of Rs.6,23,75,007/- and thus directed the
present writ petitioner to pay the deficit Stamp duty and the
registration charges to the tune of Rs.26,86,250/- and Rs. 3,83,750/-
respectively within a specified time.
2. The writ petitioner felt aggrieved and thus preferred the instant writ
petition.
3. At the time of hearing Ms. Sen, learned Advocate appearing on behalf
of the writ petitioner duly led by Mr. Mukherjee, learned Advocate at
the very outset draws attention of this Court to pages 40 and 41 of
the instant writ petition being a copy of GRIPS e-Challan as issued by
the registering authority. It is submitted that on careful perusal of
the said e-challan it would reveal that at the time of presentation of
the document in question for registration by the writ petitioner the
registering authority valued the said property to the tune of
Rs.2,40,00,003/- and on the basis of the said assessment the writ
petitioner has duly paid the requisite Stamp duty and registration
charges. It is further submitted by Ms. Sen that thereafter the said
document was registered and subsequently the said registered
document was delivered to the writ petitioner.
4. At the juncture, Ms. Sen took me to page 49 of the instant writ
petition being a copy of the notice under Section 47A(5) of the said
Act. It is submitted by Ms. Sen that, on perusal of the copy of the
3
notice dated 11.9.2025 it would reveal that the respondent no. 2
authority pursuant to the said notice directed the writ petitioner to
appear before him on 18.9.2025 at 3.00 P.M. to which the writ
petitioner duly appeared before the respondent no. 2 authority. It is
further submitted by Ms. Sen that on the said very date i.e. on
18.9.2025 the respondent no. 2 authority without assigning any
reason whatsoever re-determined the market value of the property as
involved in the instant writ petition to the tune of Rs.6,23,75,007/-
and directed the writ petitioner to pay deficit Stamp Duty and
registration charges as aforesaid on the basis of the revised valuation.
It is submitted by Ms. Sen, that on perusal of the impugned notice
dated 18.9.2025 it would reveal that the respondent no.2 authority
has not assigned any reason at all for revaluation of the property in
question thereby increasing the market value of the property.
5. In support of her contention Ms. Sen took me to Rule 5 of the West
Bengal Stamp (Prevention Undervaluation of Instrument) Rules 2001
(the said Rules, in short). It is argued by Ms. Sen that the respondent
no. 2 authority while revising the valuation of the property in question
is duty bound to issue notice in form VIII of the said Rules in terms of
the provision of Rule 5(1) of the said Rules. It is further submitted by
Ms. Sen that while re-determining the market value of the property
the respondent no. 2 has also not complied with the provision of Rule
5(3)(d) of the said Act.
4
6. It is submitted by Ms. Sen that, the order/notice dated 18.9.2025 by
which the respondent no. 2 authority re-determined the market value
of the property is liable to be set aside in as much as the said notice
dated 18.9.2025 was issued without complying the legal formalities
and/or without assigning any reason for its re-determination causing
serious prejudice to the writ petitioner.
7. It is further submitted by Ms. Sen that though the writ petitioner has
duly paid the revised Stamp Duty and the registration charges in
terms of the impugned notice dated 18.9.2025 even then the instant
writ petition is maintainable in view of the fact that the writ petitioner
had to make such payment under duress and compulsion in as much
from the wordings of the said impugned notice dated 18.9.2025 it
would reveal that in the event the revised Stamp Duty and
registration charges are not paid with the specified time, it would
carry penal interest.
8. Per contra, Mr. Pal, learned Advocate for the State and led by Ms.
Chakraborty, Ld. AGP in course of his submission places his reliance
upon the statement of facts as prepared by the respondent no. 2
authority. It is argued by Mr. Pal that, the notice dated 18.9.2025
was issued by the respondent no.2 authority in accordance with law
that is in exercise of its power under Section 47(8) of the said Act. It
is submitted that the respondent no. 8 authority re-assessed the
market value of the property considering the proposed use of land as
5
„Pukur‟ and „commercial‟ as per potentiality of the adjacent area
which was duly accepted by the present writ petitioner by paying the
deficit Stamp Duty and the registration charges which categorically
indicates that the present writ petitioner concedes to the re-assessed
valuation as made by the respondent no. 2 authority.
9. In his next fold of submission Mr. Pal draws attention of this Court to
Section 47B of the said Act which deals with the appeal against an
order under Section 47A(5) and (8) of the said Act. It is submitted by
Mr. Pal that the instant writ petition is not maintainable in as much
as no cogent reason has been assigned by the present writ petitioner
for not availing the alternative statutory remedy and despite that the
instant writ petition has been filed.
10. This Court has meticulously perused the entire materials placed before
it. This Court has heard the learned counsel for the contending
parties at length.
11. Since in course of his argument Mr. Pal, learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the respondent/State raises the point of maintainability of
the instant writ petition this Court is at the very outset proposes to
decide the point of maintainability of the instant writ petition. In
doing so this Court proposes to look to Section 47A and 47B of the
said Act which reads as under.
6
“Sec. 47A. Instruments of conveyance, etc. undervalued, how to be
dealt with.-
(1) ……………………
(2) …………………
(3) ………………..
(4) ………………….
(5) On receipt of a reference under sub-section (3), the authority
specified under that sub-section shall, after giving the parties
concerned in respect of the instrument referred to in sub-section (1) a
reasonable opportunity of being heard and after holding an enquiry
in such manner as may be prescribed, determine the market value
of the property which is the subject matter of the instrument and the
proper stamp duty payable thereon, and shall thereafter issue a
notice in the manner prescribed directing the concerned person to
make payment of such deficit amount of stamp duty within such
time as may be prescribed.
(6) …………..
(7) ………….
(8) (a) The authority referred to in sub-section (3) may, on receipt of any
information or otherwise, suo motu within five years from the date of
registration of any instrument, where such instrument was
7
registered on the basis of the market value which was set forth in
the instrument or which was ascertained by the registering officer
referred to in sub-section (1), call for and examine any such
instrument and any other document relating thereto for the purpose
of satisfying himself as to the correctness of the market value of the
property which is the subject-matter of such instrument and which
was set forth in the instrument or which was ascertained under
sub-section (2) and the stamp duty payable thereon.
(b) If, after such examination, the authority referred to in clause (a)
has reasons to believe that the market value of the property which is
the subject-matter of such instrument has not been truly set forth in
the instrument or correctly ascertained under sub-section (2), he
may, after giving the parties concerned in the instrument a
reasonable opportunity of being heard, determine the market value
of the property which is the subject-matter of such instrument and
the amount of stamp duty chargeable thereon in the manner referred
to in sub-section (5), and the difference in the amount of stamp duty,
if any, between the stamp duty so determined by him and the
stamp duty already paid by the concerned person shall be required
to be paid by him in the prescribed manner:
Provided that nothing in this sub-section shall apply to-
8
(a) any instrument referred to in clause (b), clause (c), clause (d),
clause (e) or clause (g) of sub-section (1) registered before the 31st
day of January, 1994, or
(b) any instrument referred to in clause (a), clause (f), clause (h), of
sub-section (1) registered before the coming into force of the Indian
Stamp (West Bengal Amendment) Act, 1998.
(9) …………..
(10) Explanation. - ………..
Sec. 47B. Appeal.-(1) Any concerned person aggrieved by an order
passed under sub-section (5) or sub-section (8) of section 47A
determining the market value may, in the prescribed manner, prefer
an appeal to such appellate authority as may be prescribed within
sixty days from the date of receipt of such order or such further
period as may be allowed by the said authority for the cause shown
to his satisfaction.
(2) Subject to such rules or procedure as may be prescribed, the
appellate authority shall dispose of any appeal preferred before him
under sub-section (1) in the prescribed manner.
(3) Where the appellate authority modifies the amount of stamp duty
determined under sub-section (5) or sub-section (8) of section 47A
and the modified amount of such stamp duty is higher than the
stamp duty already paid by the concerned person, he shall pay
9
interest at the rate specified in sub-section (6) of section 47A on the
modified amount of such stamp duty from the month in which he
was liable to pay interest under sub-section (6) up to the month
preceding the month of payment of such modified amount of stamp
duty.”
9. Keeping in mind the aforementioned legislative provisions if I look to
the factual aspects as involved in the instant writ petition, it
appears to this Court that admittedly a notice under Section 47A(5)
of the said Act dated 11.9.2025 was issued by the respondent no.2
authority addressed to the writ petitioner directing the writ
petitioner to appear before him on a particular day and hour. On
careful perusal of the impugned notice dated 18.9.2025 it appears
that the respondent no.2 authority recorded that the writ petitioner
appeared before such authority and participated in the proceeding
as initiated under Section 47A(8) of the said Act. Learned advocate
appearing on behalf of the writ petitioner in course of her
submission also not disputed rather admitted that the writ
petitioner appeared before the respondent no.2 authority. However,
it is the grievance of the writ petitioner that the respondent no.2
authority most unilaterally enhanced the market value of the
property as involved in the instant writ petition without complying
the provision of Rule 5 of the said Rules.
10
10. On perusal of the impugned notice dated 18.9.2025 it appears to
this Court that rightly or wrongly the respondent no.2 authority
exercised its power under Section 47A(5) and (8) of the said Act and
thus increased the market value of the property as involved in the
instant writ petition thereby directing the writ petitioner to pay
deficit stamp duty and the deficit registration charges which have
also been paid by the writ petitioner though according to Ms. Sen,
learned advocate, the same was paid under duress and
compulsion.
11. At this juncture, if I look to the provision of Section 47B of the said
Act it appears to this Court that it is the legislative mandate that in
the event a person is aggrieved by an order under Section 47A(5) or
(8) of the said Act, he shall have to approach the appellate
authority by preferring an appeal within 60 days from the date of
passing of the said order. On careful perusal of the entire pleading
of the instant writ petition this Court finds that the writ petitioner
has not assigned any cogent reason for not preferring the said
appeal under Section 47B of the said Act before the appellate
authority. At this juncture, the moot question arises for
consideration as to whether despite availability of alternative
efficacious statutory remedy, the present writ petition is at all
maintainable in the eye of law or not.
11
12. At this juncture, this Court proposes to look to the reported
decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of U.P. State
Spinning Company Limited –vs.- R.S. Pandey and Anr. ,
reported in (2005) 8 SCC 264 wherein the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
while dealing with the subject of entertainability of a writ petition
despite availability of alternative remedy expressed the following
view :
“ Normally the High Court should not interfere if there is
an adequate efficacious alternative remedy. If somebody
approaches the High court without availing the alternative
remedy provided, the High Court should ensure that he has
made out a strong case or that there exist good grounds to
invoke the extraordinary jurisdiction.
There are two well-recognised exceptions to the
doctrine of exhaustion of statutory remedies. First is when
the proceedings are taken before the forum under a
provision of law which is ultra virus, it is open to a party
aggrieved thereby to move the High Court for quashing the
proceedings on the ground that they are incompetent
without a party being obliged to wait until those proceedings
run their full course. Secondly, the doctrine has no
application when the impugned order has been made in
violation of the principles of natural justice. ”
12
13. The same view was reiterated by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in a
later judgment in the case of Radha Krishan Industries –vs.-
State of Himachal Pradesh , reported in (2021)6 SCC 771
wherein the Hon‟ble Supreme Court held thus :
“27. The principles of law which emerge are that:
27.1. The power under Article 226 of the Constitution to
issue writs can be exercised not only for the enforcement of
fundamental rights, but for any other purpose as well.
27.2. The High Court has the discretion not to entertain
a writ petition. One of the restrictions placed on the power of
the High Court is where an effective alternate remedy is
available to the aggrieved person.
27.3. Exceptions to the rule of alternate remedy arise
where:
(a)the writ petition has been filed for the enforcement of
a fundamental right protected by Part III of the Constitution;
(b) there has been a violation of the principles of natural
justice;
(c) the order or proceedings are wholly without
jurisdiction; or (d) the vires of a legislation is challenged.
13
27.4. An alternate remedy by itself does not divest the
High Court of its powers under Article 226 of the
Constitution in an appropriate case though ordinarily, a writ
petition should not be entertained when an efficacious
alternate remedy is provided by law.
27.5. When a right is created by a statute, which itself
prescribes the remedy or procedure for enforcing the right or
liability, resort must be had to that particular statutory
remedy before invoking the discretionary remedy under
Article 226 of the Constitution. This rule of exhaustion of
statutory remedies is a rule of policy, convenience and
discretion.
27.6. In cases where there are disputed questions of
fact, the High Court may decide to decline jurisdiction in a
writ petition. However, if the High Court is objectively of the
view that the nature of the controversy requires the exercise
of its writ jurisdiction, such a view would not readily be
interfered with.
28. These principles have been consistently upheld by
this Court in Chand Ratan v. Durga Prasad reported in
(2003) 5 SCC 399, Babubhai Muljibhai Patel v. Nandlal
Khodidas Barot reported in (1974) 2SCC 706 and Rajasthan
14
SEB v. Union of India reported in (2008) 5 SCC 632 among
other decisions."
14. Keeping in mind the propositions of law as decided by the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court if I look to the factual aspects as involved in the
instant case it appears to this Court that the present writ petitioner
has miserably failed to make out a case for entertaining the instant
writ petition inasmuch as on perusal of the impugned notice dated
18.9.2025 it appears that the present writ petitioner appeared
before the respondent no.2 authority and participated in the
hearing pursuant to the notice dated 11.9.2025 as issued under
Section 47A(5) of the said Act.
15. It further appears to this Court that no case has been made out on
behalf of the writ petitioner that the action taken by the respondent
no.2 authority is otherwise ultra vires rather sufficient materials
have been placed by Mr. Pal, learned Advocate for the State to
substantiate that the respondent no.2 authority acted within its
authority within the meaning of Section 47A(5) and (8) of the said
Act. It thus appears to this Court that the writ petitioner has made
no endeavour to make out a case for entertaining the instant writ
petition despite availability of alternative statutory efficacious
effective remedy.
15
16. In view of such this Court is constrained to hold that the writ
petition is not maintainable.
17. With the aforementioned observation WPA 13816 of 2026 is thus
dismissed.
18. There shall be, however, no order as to costs.
19. However, keeping in mind that the present writ petitioner is
pursuing his remedy before a wrong forum may be under a wrong
legal advice, this Court grants liberty to the writ petitioner to prefer
an appeal before the appropriate appellate authority under Section
47B of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 and in the event such an appeal
is preferred within 30 working days from the date of passing of this
judgement, the said appellate authority shall treat the said appeal
within the period of limitation.
20. Urgent photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
furnished to the parties on usual undertaking.
(Partha Sarathi Sen, J.)